3 years of study = 3 minutes learned from this video !... nice !

@kashty024

3 жыл бұрын

i liked this comment when i was in my first year of university. i’m now back here writing the same shit for my final project in my last year! 🤦🏼‍♂️🤣

@TF-hl4bh

4 ай бұрын

@@kashty024is it hard?! Because I am gonna write bc work about this topic

Girl thanks a lot! I needed to understand the concept of index/indexical for a class about transcultural communication. Very insightful!

Life saver for every art history course and art lectures I have had at cal poly

That's really a great video getting me to understand semiotics!! I'm really fascinated by the Structuralists vs Post-structuralists, and have just read Barthes's the Death of The Author, which is closely related to the concept of semiotics~!

Wowww finally i understand.. thank you! it is so helpful for me doing my thesis

Oh my goodness this saved my ass. I'm doing a Packaging project that's due in 3 hours. This literally cleared up my confusion. Thank You!!

Well done, simply and perfect definition! :)

This was fantastic! I remember a similar thing about icons in Scott McCloud's Understanding Comics. Fascinating stuff!

@littlearttalks

9 жыл бұрын

***** Cool! I'll have to check that out :D

This series is very helpful. Thank you!

Thank you so much. this video is awesome. It helps to understand semiotics. love ya :D

this helped me a lot for anthropology, thanks!

This subject is so deep and pervasive in our every step of life that you can easily get lost in it forever. Not to mention the doors it opens...

this was so helpful, thank you so much!

this was super helpful, thank you!!!!

Your video helps a lot thank you so much! I needed this theory of signs for my thesis and now I am completely understand the concept thanks to your video :) Thank you and thank you!

@littlearttalks

7 жыл бұрын

So glad this helps you! Thanks for watching :)

@rahatmohammad3134

7 жыл бұрын

Atikah Amalia i am also working on semiotics and structuralism,,, if you can help me in this,it would be great,,

Excellent video! Thank you! :)

Well that was a great reminder. Thank you :).

Very well explained. Thanks!

Hey there, great video! What’s the painting called that you are using as an example?

great video, you have a new suscriber!!

Please do more videos about it, including symptoms and signals!

@littlearttalks

7 жыл бұрын

That's a great idea! :)

This is so helpful!

Thank you very much . It helps alot .

hi Karin, i would like to quote you on my assignment on semiotics, however, i do not have much details except for your name and the link. please help..assignment due on the 21st

This was useful thank you👍

I am confused between index and icon as both meaninng is same ?? Can anyone tell me ?? What is arbitary meaning ??

thanks madam, u explained very well..

Very clear , thanks

this was fantastic

does humain language include indexical iconic or symbolic signs ? justify your answer.

Great explanation

can you do a video on french phonetioques ??

Quite interesting!!!

im honestly even more confused like whattt im honestly going to fail my exam lmaoo

Thank you!

But what does 'Play' sound like or look like?

I'm now ready for my midterm lol. Thank you for explaining it so well!

the video when im alone: 0:30 the video when my mom walks in: 3:08

Thank you! :)

Play means moving forward. Forward means right. The Play button is an arrow facing right. Get it?

She sounds like she's about to cry. Hehe.. It was a great video. Very educational.... Thanks...

@alex-gs5kr

3 жыл бұрын

don't be mean

@khadijaelkhalfi462

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah! Hhhhh

It's good to understand

If a picture depicts a family, is it iconically a bunch of people and indexically the idea of family or home?

What does arbitrary mean??

Excellent

Awe her voice is so cute🐛🐞

Thank you Mam....

Please can you Write the definitions of icon, symbol and index with examples in replying me in the comment.

What's more of an index? A photograph or a hologram?

At 00:36 you say that "The Process from the signifier to the signified is called signification" But on your drawings signification is placed on the right side, at the arrow down. The arrow down means signified to signification. I just wanted to ask what is the right meaning of signification. Signified to signifier or signifier to signified? Thank you so much :)

THIS IS Good

Not true. The play button denotes play-forward movement by facing the same direction the we read & write.

Somebody get Plato on the phone! Nice job!

@littlearttalks

9 жыл бұрын

Concrete Turtle Thanks :)

You should consider using examples that can be shown in a public school. I'm not sure I'm allowed to show this in my high school art class due to the nude painting. I know, it's art and personally, I have zero issues with it...but some communities are conservative and as such might object. Just my thoughts.

En español tenemos una idea en la cual tendemos a diferenciar signo("sign")de símbolos("Symbols"), En ambos casos representa ideas, pero intuitivamente me entiendo más con el significado que le dan los ingleses.

Nice introduction! It is pronounced CS "purse" not Pierce by the way!

does Tom know that you are using his video?

Indexicality and ostension in philosophy of language is to me a problematic area since, since ostension cannot rest on the physical act of pointing. The notion in semiotics of an indexical sign also seems like a weak point in the whole theory since the photo could look just like you (given the distance, clarity, etc.) and yet have been taken of someone else, so that it would in fact be indiscernible from a photo that was actually taken of you. The one may have the correct causal history, but that is the only thing suggesting it as a representation of you. Replies are welcomed.

Is an image with words symbolic?

@InsistentlyInterdisciplinary

Жыл бұрын

Yeah! It certainly can be. An image is iconic, according to Peirce (a semiotician/philosopher) and the words would be symbolic. If you are interested in the topic, there is also fascinating work done on words called ideophones.

The "Object" is about what sign refers ....it is not a concept or signified .....even signified is closely related to " Interpretant

Had to watch on 0.75 speed + 10x of rewinding every part to get smth into my bubu brain xd

This was a lot of fun. But the "play" button is not arbitrary but rather indexical. The right pointing arrow indicates the direction a tape would play in a recording studio tape deck of an old Boom Box playing cassettes. A button pointing in the opposite direction, to the left meant rewinding the tape, the tape would spin in the other direction. The addition of multiple arrows (fast forward or fast rewind) indicate the speed in that direction would be increased. In the digital age, folks like You Tube have adapted the right-arrow play button for digital uses and so it may seem arbitrary, but for anyone who used or still use tape decks of any kind, it's most def an indexical sign. But like I said, I enjoyed this a lot and will be sharing it with a colleague and some students (I'm a PhD student at University of Chicago).

@OgreBurden

6 жыл бұрын

Your argument works also for the words of a language, they are symbolic but they are not arbitrary : they all have an etymology. Maybe a better definition for the symbol will be a conventional relationship rather than an arbitrary relationship between the representamen and the meaning.

@Sraye

5 жыл бұрын

The "play" button is arbitrary. At some point in history, some guy in an office decided a triangle pointing right or left would mean play or rewind while he was designing the first boom box, cassette player, etc. There is nothing inherent about a triangle that suggests the direction of the tape moving. In some "alternate timeline", someone could have chosen to associate play with an arrow shape, or a heart shape with the pointed end showing direction, or maybe even a thumbs up in the direction of play. There are many possibilities. Good luck with your PhD, I am also doing one.

@adamhendrickson512

5 жыл бұрын

sakeos23 Woaw... I actually didn't know that... Thanks...

@Keemin

5 жыл бұрын

and thus the Media Aesthetics course was born. jk I know it existed long before this but it's funny that I looked this video up to remind myself of something i learned in class and I found someone from U of C

gooooooood

omg your voice 1:57

In 2019 if you say the word 'trees' you're most likely talking about weed.

i'm not listening i am just looking at you talking cuz ur beautiful

whoever is in charge of the production of videos on this channel: use a de-esser PLEASE! All those s-es are like nails on a chalkboard.

Every thing was nice bt the picture at 3:21 it made me addicted to this video 😂😂😂

anyone else here from school 👀