people before 50 years wouldn't believe buying a car and getting continuous improvements over the air while you own it, that on its own is crazy!

„I assume human...“ 😂

@filmislife77

3 жыл бұрын

I would hope it was a human

@goodyKoeln

3 жыл бұрын

@@filmislife77 you never know. 😉

@filmislife77

3 жыл бұрын

@@goodyKoeln if it's a ice car I'm 99.9% sure it's a human

@goodyKoeln

3 жыл бұрын

@@filmislife77 you’d be probably right, but you never know. 🤷🏻‍♂️

@whatdrivesyou6798

3 жыл бұрын

Lol, definitely my favorite quote from this one

Keep hitting the accelerator when it's being hesitant or slow and help it creep out into the intersection for left turns. Tell us when you do it so we know.

@jeffbransky7966

3 жыл бұрын

I hope it works that way on left turns when touching the accelerator. On right turns and going straight ahead I think hitting the accelerator means go now. Also, I keep wondering if there is a setting that makes Dirty Tesla’s car stop so far back from the stop signs and lights.

Honestly, your analysis of Tesla's FSD is some of the best on KZread. Keep it up!

2:13 Visualization of the roundabout looks really good!

14:50 “It’s never going to do things 100% perfect, neither am I, neither are you” My legally blind ass who can’t get a valid licenses “this car already drives 1000x better than I ever will”😂

Here in BC you're supposed to move up on green when turning left. So long as your front wheels are past the crosswalk (or stop line if there isn't one) before the light turns red, you count as "in the intersection" and not running the red.

The best real world FSD focused channel on KZread.

8:05 You doing right by moving up to middle. That's the rules lol. The only exception is when there's a traffic jam and you know you will have a trouble leaving the intersection.

@benlac1000

3 жыл бұрын

The rule is one car is allowed to move up. So if the car in front of you is up there trying to make the left you will need to wait back at the line until he completes his turn.

@lellius

3 жыл бұрын

@@benlac1000 As long as there's enough room for you to fully enter the intersection during the green phase then your are allowed to complete the turn after the light changes. It doesn't matter how many vehicles are in ahead as long as you don't enter the intersection after the light turns red.

@kenbob1071

3 жыл бұрын

Yes. In driver's ed they taught us to move into the intersection/box on a green and turn when safe even if the light turns red while you are waiting. If there's a sign that says "Do Not Block the Box," then you can't hang out in the intersection. Also, I agree with benlac 1000 about the one car scenario. Personally if oncoming traffic is busy and more than one lane, I may not pull forward but wait for the green arrow because it can be very difficult to see oncoming traffic in the far lane if the view is blocked by another left-turning vehicle in the closest oncoming lane.

@tjbonzo

3 жыл бұрын

I believe this is the pertinent law (for Michigan): tldr; legal to move into the intersection, cross traffic must yield even if their light is now green. " (a) If the signal exhibits a green indication, vehicular traffic facing the signal may proceed straight through or turn right or left unless a sign at that place prohibits either turn. Vehicular traffic, including vehicles turning right or left, shall yield the right-of-way to other vehicles and to pedestrians and bicyclists lawfully within the intersection or an adjacent crosswalk at the time the signal is exhibited." legislature.mi.gov/doc.aspx?mcl-257-612

@MrValles10

3 жыл бұрын

Here in Belgium, it's prohibited to enter an intersection if you know you'll end up standing still on it.

Psychology LOL! A neural net trained by humans that creeps through stops suddenly goes full-stop after passing a cop... what can we possibly deduce from this?

Glad you are having so much fun! You are making a positive impact for the Tesla FSD Team!

I'm so glad you got the FSD Beta. Its been fun watching you show off the improvements

I am subscribed and LOVE the effort! 4k, video segments, good audio, great camera angle, cam on your face too etc. awesome! love from Germany! Can't wait for FSD in Europe

Very impressive, especially turning left on the roundabout. I would always enter the intersection when waiting for oncoming traffic, not hang back. If you hung back like that here in Australia, cars behind would beep to tell you to move into the intersection.

Outstanding speedups and commentary. Really makes watching this for the FSD key points easy and fast....thank you so much for that. Well you got the snow...you are the first!

I so look forward to each of your videos ... you explain well, we know when the car is in charge and when you are. Just keep the information coming .. thank you very much.

I really appreciate your running narrative. You can see far more than I can on video. Also I appreciate that you have very high expectations for FSD and report "failures." You are doing an excellent job of testing and making FSD better when it gets to general release.

I love your approach to making the videos... fast forward, then regular speed to talk about something interesting. Great camera angles too!

Thank you for taking the time to produce these videos. I’m looking forward to public release.

07:15 When will Telsa fix that sudden wide-lane wobble? Humans know a lane doesn't go from 12 ft to 20 ft, they use the center lines as guides.

I've been sharing your vids with my 89-year-old father who bought TSLA (on my recommendation) and used to work at Ann Arbor Trust (which has since been bought by someone else). He's really enjoying your work, as am I! Can't wait until my 3 can do the same things yours does now! :-)

Tesla: Runs a red light, drives on the wrong side of the road, turns left. DirtyTesla: I'm okay with that.

@nonconsensualopinion

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah, that and the hard brake should have been reported.

Definitely two steps forward, one step back.

@elecktromaestimmy

3 жыл бұрын

that is progress in my book :D

@devindykstra

3 жыл бұрын

@@elecktromaestimmy absolutely! It's amazing!

I like your intro clips. I always find myself having a good chuckle before the video starts

Your vids are so great and your comments/explanations perfect. I also like that you mention previous issues and fixes or if the issues is still there

13:27 i watched that 4 times. we're really getting there!

I really love how you can just comment all the things that the car does live, and then some, also with great energy, keep it up!

General practice is when you're making a left turn, you pull into the intersection- so that when you complete turn you will not be in that quarter of the intersection you should never ever be in. Also, you do not pre-turn your wheels (if you're rear ended you could be pushed into oncoming traffic). When the oncoming traffic clears, and there's no one in the cross walk, you can complete turn into any driving lane. (So on a left you can turn into lanes 1 or 2, or 3 if there's one. On a right turn you are only supposed to turn into the far right driving lane). In Los Angeles my wife was hit by a woman who had no license, driving an unregistered and uninsured car, no driver's training, except her husband who taught her, "When the light turns yellow, that's when you turn." He failed to mention to check that there's no oncoming traffic. You never have a legal right to do anything unsafe. (Despite some of my 8th graders thinking jaywalking was their Constitutional Right - worth dying for! (It's okay because my family will get a lot of money mister.) ) So if someone scoots through on the yellow and you can only complete the turn on red - that's legal. But if you were waiting back behind the line, you can't complete your turn. (If this sounds all legal and true... I have no authority other than drivers' ed and being a nerd, but I'm pretty sure it's accurate.) It's also really great to see how well the Beta is advancing. Again, it's like a teenager learning to drive, Initially, the basics - steering, braking are not that difficult, but all the details are the steep learning curve. Later when they've got some hours, maybe even their license, with each, uh-oh, a young driver not only learns, but learns how to learn.

Subscribed finally! Really enjoy your videos; they are clear, to the point and informative. Love that you also prioritise your viewers' time by speeding up the "boring" segments.

Yes! Thank you!!! I have been watching your channel forever now and I love every single video you put out! I enjoy all your explanations and jokes as well as your excitement!! Again just thank you these are so amazing!

@DirtyTesla

3 жыл бұрын

Hey you're not supposed to watch this one yet! 😂

@chasestrother8318

3 жыл бұрын

@@DirtyTesla oops i watched all the FSD Betas a second time and saw that one out. I just had to😂

TY for your videos and dedication. It's getting closer, yet still a lot of edge case to go, the last few percent could still take a lot of updates.

@DT, the progress of Beta is truly outstanding!!! :-) Keep up the excellent work, plus it is great to see downtown A2.

Glad you have the beta and are getting the videos out quick! So exciting!

This is super cool. I’m watching from Ann Arbor. Please keep making videos here!

I got ya! I always hit thumbs up on your informational and well done videos. I forgot to on this one but now you’ve got mine.

Another great video. Very impressed by your ability to verbalize what’s going on. It’s clear that you’re contributing to training the neural net. Car really drives like a human that’s just learning. Overly timid at times, makes odd decisions, etc. but I’ve been following these fsd beta videos closely and the improvement is noticeable. Thank you!

Thanks for the reviews :) I'm anticipating the public release of FSD - been a long time waiting in my Model S.

While I realize that many suburb dwellers may be unaccustomed to the maneuver,, the proper way to handle a left turn when there's no green arrow is to enter the intersection during the green phase and then complete the turn as soon as the oncoming traffic allows. As long as you fully enter the intersection prior to the light turning red then the you're allowed to complete the left turn after the light changes.

Ann Arbor ->Huron River Drive (lots of bikers and people)->Downtown Dexter (Tight bridge, 2 roundabouts, small town traffic) -> baker Rd -> Jackson Rd (michigan left turns) -> down town A2. Always great videos thank you for making it very informational. This route would be cool to see, scenic drive too!

Great job! You have the best FSD videos. It really needs to creep out into the intersection on green left hand turns. Also, I would be nervous if the wheels turned left while it was stopped in a left turn lane. Driver's ed tells us to keep the wheels straight until we commit to the turn, in case the car gets rear-ended. You don't want to be shoved into the path of ongoing traffic in case of an accident.

Good to see the FSD beta get some snow experience! Keep up the good work. Soon there will be snow on the dirt roads from your house! THAT will be a challenge.

Keep the videos coming man! This is getting a lot better very quickly, and I can't wait to see when it will be a bit less timid at yield signs or intersections in general, looks like you've had to press the gas in some places but the improvements are there.

Looking good! Thanks for training the neural net for us. Still the best tesla autopilot videos out there.

I appreciate your updates about these updates.

Thanks for these videos! It's really interesting to see the progress. As someone who doesn't/can't drive, I'm looking forward to the day when FSD is readily and publicly available to everyone for general transportation.

So happy for you getting into the beta. Who are these people not subbing?! Hah. I watched a video yesterday showing off the Waymo system and it’s really interesting to compare how these two systems handle certain situations. The edge case issues are definitely similar challenges, but I think the Tesla does a better job of not freezing up completely- although it arguably can get away with that since a human is still behind the wheel to intervene if needed. I’m excited for the future of self driving cars everywhere!

You criticized FSD for slowing for the yellow caution light at 6:02, but isn't that what a driver should do since the flashing yellow is signaling to warn of possible danger?

@DirtyTesla

3 жыл бұрын

This is where we get into what you should do vs what people actually do. Maybe slow by a few mph, but the car was going to come close to a stop if I didn't intervene.

Love your videos. I'm a California Tesla owner, but native of Michigan. It's great seeing my old 'stomping grounds' while you're thoroughly testing FSD. Appreciate what you're doing! Subscribed!

@DirtyTesla

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks! I was born in Cali but am now here! D:

@brainiator

3 жыл бұрын

@@DirtyTesla Michigan has GREAT beer though! Is the Blind Pig still around in AA?

@DirtyTesla

3 жыл бұрын

@@brainiator I don't know I don't hang around aa much :)

Subscribed to your channel, great narration, and editing.

I like the presentation and narration in these videos. Keep them coming!

Great videos - and some very informative commenting. Found your channel Today... and immediately subscribed, of course 😉 So involving that I almost feel sympathy for the car when it makes mistakes 😅 Thanks a lot for sharing these peeks into the future. BR, Per (Denmark)

Nice, I can see the improvements. Keep up the good work. Won't be long and you can try it on a road covered in snow. Go Blue!

The way the car adds just a touch of brake to slow for the guy that cut in front of you at 5:10 is super impressive. I had a similar thing happen to me while using AP on City Streets the other day and the car grenaded the brakes even though the car was well out of my way by the time it would have been “close”.

In Driver's Ed class, at Ann Arbor High School in the 1960's, I was advised that you ARE supposed to pull into the intersection on green, when making a left turn. Bonus-- Then you're *obligated* to turn left when the light changes!

I don’t have a Tesla but I love watching these videos. Thank you!

@DirtyTesla

3 жыл бұрын

That's how it starts >:)

Yes the car should enter the intersection when turning at a light. Entering the intersection on a green or yellow light is legal and leaving the intersection on any color light is legal. What is illegal is ENTERING the intersection on a red light. As long as you are IN the intersection, the light color when LEAVING intersection is irrelevant. That’s a mostly standard law for most roadways. There are some intersections you’d literally never be able to turn at if you didn’t enter the intersection before initiating the turn. In some states it’s not clear what the law means, stating things along the lines of “a driver shall not impede the flow of traffic exercised by those with a right-of-way”, without explicitly stating intersection entrance rules. So as long as those with a right-of-way are not impeded, you’re not breaking the law. You’d be entering the intersection on green/yellow while having the right-of-way and exiting the intersection as the oncoming lane lost its right-of-way, thereby leaving the intersection before impeding the new right-of-way. No laws broken. There hasn’t been a successful ticket/traffic citation for entering an intersection on a green light in my state. Ever. Not one. So those kind of maneuvers are where driving judgment comes in. As long as you’re being safe, I’d enter an intersection before the turn is required to minimize my time to make the maneuver across right-of-way traffic.

Thank you for testing this for all of us looking forward to it

And no bright sunshine to cast long shadows on the road as was the case in the last video. In the past, there seemed to be some problem with the system seeing white objects on the road. It would be interesting to see what happens with snow all around and a bright sunny day. Keep up the good work!

Awesome video as usual! I am excited to see the quick improvements to the software. Really hoping to get this soon.

Good job on the videos. I really like your videos on FSD beta.

I always watch the whole thing but thanks for putting in timestamps

@DirtyTesla

3 жыл бұрын

I appreciate that it helps the channel a ton

I'm on 'Team Pull into the Intersection'. I was trained by a driver ed instructor who preached assertive driving, whereby you don't hesitate to take the right of way when it was yours. He also taught to pull into the intersection while waiting to make a left turn to maximize how many cars could get through on a light, with the worst case being that at least you get through.

Another great FSD video. May I suggest... editing a side by side or top and bottom split screen of pre update vs post update fails vs successes. Such as failing the third exit and not failing the third exit with you voice over so we can see the difference. I don’t think anyone is doing before and after videos. If the split screen doesn’t work you can preroll it with a vintage filter. Thanks again.

Great video! So cool to see the progress. I use AP every single time I get into the car (city streets, interstate, everywhere) and it SEEMS to me that FSD Beta is head and shoulders better than existing AP. Meaning that it does a better job and is safer than existing AP even though it still makes mistakes. I"m guessing (HOPING) that we get a wide FSD release before Christmas.

LOL you even have a disclaimer on your verbs! (love the vids)

14:55 I'm already blown away, thank you 😁

Lovely to watch and experience vicariously. Great work!

Well, I don’t know who is not subscribed but I am!😂🤠 Also, keep telling it it’s too slow with the accelerator !!! It’ll improve better 👍 It really feels surreal thinking about where this is leading, well actually it seems it’s already almost here ! What an incredible time right now !!!

No more Pizza Bob's?!? (S. State Street). Ah, the memories, my friend Claudia had just driven back from Detroit, where we saw a movie at the Detroit Arts Institute. We were in my VW, pouring rain, working the wipers with a piece of string. We were starving (that or being stoned the only reason anyone ate at Pizza Bob's - also being young and clueless). We had $5, enough for pizza but no pop (soda wasn't invented until I moved out of Michigan in 1979). They didn't charge us. Somehow this meant something at the time. Sorry, where were we? Oh, yeah your car was driving you around while you were talking about it....isn't that a little weird? Well, it will be if you're still doing it in five years. Cheers.

I was taught to always “get under the light” when turning left.

@Shadefrank

3 жыл бұрын

in my country only one car should move to the crossroad waiting for the left turn. All others should wait behind the line, but they always do stack up behind the first one anyways.

@Sn1per9CZE

3 жыл бұрын

@@Shadefrank This is not necessarily correct, as multiple cars can move into the intersection, but only IF they are not blocking any crosswalks.

@Findalfen

3 жыл бұрын

@@Shadefrank I also how I learned it in France. But as M0dEx mentioned, usually more than one car go to the intersection.

@GreylanderTV

3 жыл бұрын

Yes, the lead car making a left turn should move up to roughly the middle of the intersection and wait for oncoming cars to clear. Legally the second car should hold back until the first car clears, but as a practical matter this is often dumb, as then only one car gets through per light instead of two or three. If you do not move up into the intersection, you can then get stuck without enough time to get through.

@tmeekins42

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah, I always pull into the intersection to wait to turn. Makes it much easier when it turns yellow.

Very cool thanks for the update videos

Awesome to see FSD! I don't know how it is in the States, but here in Europe you are supposed to indicate when exiting the roundabout, so I hope FSD will do that when it eventually gets available here :)

It's looking really smooth. The creep-and-look is excellent. I think I'd be very nervous that it would pull out in front of another car but it seems like it sees traffic and stops better than I do :)

Keep up the good work! Make sure to let us know if/when FSD Beta gets a wider release / there's an actual form to sign up / show interest.

The turn situations are thrilling!

Really interested to see how it handles snow when there is more of it. I live way up north and snow is always the very first thing people bring up when self driving cars are mentioned. Although it's already really cool to see that the falling snow doesn't seem to cause any problems.

Would be interesting to see a Waymo in these weather conditions, not to mention they would need to premap the area first :D

Great drive and breakdown of what’s being experienced. Keep it up 👍

Actually very interesting, definitely not ready, but near, its amazing how well it does .

We've gotten to the point where we arent even sure if a human is driving a car... One year ago, that sentence would make no sense

@adamdeaves2498

3 жыл бұрын

Turing test for cars ?? haha

@ThompYT

3 жыл бұрын

@@adamdeaves2498 totally

@adamrak7560

3 жыл бұрын

It would be hilarious if the FSD commented in voice what it is "thinking". :D (as far as explainable A.I. goes it would be extremely useful too!)

@adamdeaves2498

3 жыл бұрын

@@adamrak7560 it would have to speak at 100x normal speed. I bought my neighbors kid to drive and I would comment on all (Driving) thoughts in my head as I drive, showing him all that you need to think about. And made him do the same. We were talking continuously.

@adamrak7560

3 жыл бұрын

@@adamdeaves2498 I imagined it as saying only the most important stuff, or think it is not too sure of. The rest goes into the log file.

Chris, you are my FIRST channel with notifications turned ON. I look forward to your videos. Hope to connect sometime in person in the D, when all the chaos is over.

@DirtyTesla

3 жыл бұрын

Will announce when the Tesla owners club does a meet!

I took driver's ed from a company based in Ann Arbor (All Star Driver's Ed) in 2006. We were taught to pull out into the intersection, that if the vehicle is passed the solid white line, you can complete your turn, even on red (as long as it's safe to proceed). Unless that law has changed, in the last 14 years, I'm sure it's the proper way to do that, and legal in the state of Michigan.

I stay for that outro tune, I dig it

I live in India where i can't buy a Tesla but still i watch your videos

Thank you!!! Finally caved and hit the subscribe button! 😁

I have a route suggestion: Find a route with severe potholes. Obviously not for the current build... but eventually they will need that feedback too. Be thinking of where you might go for this use case. In Michigan, (like us Northern states, such as Oregon) should be easy to find a good road to test.

Ann Arbor is where I drove to about 6 months ago to get my 2019 Model 3. There was a Mini Coop dealer who was selling it, and it was the only time where I’ve never bargained on price . Can’t wait for FSD to drop.

Really great video and narration! Thanks for testing so many variable scenarios! Love the production too: screen in screen and speeding up for nothing interesting

Thank you! When the light turns green on a left-hand turn waiting for oncoming traffic, I pull into the intersection but don't block it. When the light starts to turn yellow, I pull further into the intersection (effectively blocking it) so the car behind me can legally turn left too. Without pulling into the intersection, I know of many situations where oncoming traffic never opens up to turn. Staying back at the line, the car would never legally be able to make the turn.

I did learn in PA driving school you are supposed to move into the intersection before turning. And that once you move out into the intersection, you are allowed to complete the turn even if the light has turned red.

Nice vids bro, so exciting!

Have been enjoying your videos pre FSD beta testing but from a U.K. point of view it’s interesting to see it in action. I just can’t see FSD working on our roads though, they’re too narrow, cars double park, the roads are full of potholes etc. I’m just not convinced it’s worth the £6k+ they are asking for right now, let alone the increase when we start seeing beta testing. I do see how it’ll work in the US though and think long term it will be a huge benefit/addition to the driving experience. I stand to be corrected though when it does roll out over here, but if it can work on our roads it’ll work anywhere I guess. Keep up the good content and be good to see some other none FED videos too mixed in 👍🏼

I loved you Self Driving Challenges, Ignore me if you want but it would be great if you could do rating for different maneuvers over time so we can see improvement over time. On eg a graph. GREAT JOB!

I've had a MY for almost a month. I did buy the FSD and truly hope I get value out of it sometime. Right now I'm on the homeward bound leg of a 700 mile trip to pick up a 17' travel trailer and when towing you can't use FSD. I can use the cruise control but it is almost useless. When going up I-5 through the mountains in Norther California, there are lots of yellow warning signs, some with flashing yellow lights, on both side of the road and sometimes overhead as well. The autopilot keeps hitting the brakes quite aggressively at times and if you have a Semi truck behind you when that happens... its not pretty. I really hope that when FSD is released, it also makes cruise on autopilot smoother and SAFER as well.

I had to check the driver's manual, in NY it says that "you may pull into the intersection". The Michigan DMV says (page 30) "You are making a left turn at an intersection. When the light is green, you may turn once all oncoming traffic has cleared. If you are still in the intersection when the light turns red, complete your turn as quickly and safely as possible.", which tells me that either way is legal. To me it is better for traffic congestion and more considerate to other people is to pull into an intersection in order to complete a left turn.

You have no idea how jealous thousands of us are! I can't wait for FSD beta! Honestly, my current dream job is to be a full time FSD beta tester.

I love the clear and down to earth way you show how far FSD has gotten every update. Very informative! Thanks, and I keep watching your coming video's.

It’s like Tesla knew you were posting a video the same day

Great testing!

First thanks for your work to inform us. The moving into an intersection before a clear way through is very interesting. On the east coast or west coast you would be crucified if you didn’t go into the intersection and would often never be able to turn left. But the Midwest driver is typically trained to not go into the intersection. The law is to not block the intersection but that is only relevant when the light changes and you don’t move! Also the timid Midwest driver will say if you are in the intersection when the light changes to red you are going through on red. That is not true - you went into intersection on green.