Sebastian Bach Vs Erik Grönwall (Lets Settle This)

Музыка

#Skidrow #Erik Grönwall #sebastianbach

Пікірлер: 178

  • @matthewmaurer1443
    @matthewmaurer14437 ай бұрын

    Thank you for your honest and kindly worded video. There is no bigger fan of SR & Bach than me. (Sorry everyone... it's true!) 😆. I have sang professionally for over 2 decades, so I know what it takes. Here's the nutshell: 1. Age IS a factor 2. NOBODY will ever be able to replicate Bas' emotion and conviction. There's a difference between "conviction" and "hitting the notes". 3. Eric is great! I had a chance to hang out with him 2 months back, and he's a sweetheart of a guy. He has nothing but love and respect for Bach. 4. Without Sebastian singing on those first 4 albums, SR would have probably never made it to the big time, and we, as fans, would have nothing. 5. Without Rachel and Snake writing the majority of the songs back in the day, Bas may not have had a chance to male it big.

  • @sco77
    @sco776 ай бұрын

    Shall we take consideration for age here. Let’s be fair. Bach is 55 Erik is 36. Let’s also consider that Bach has toured extensively for over 35 years. If anything, bring up videos of Sebastian at age 36 and evaluate fairly!

  • @iam5162

    @iam5162

    6 ай бұрын

    or wait till Erik is 56 after 20 more years of touring and compare with Bach of today lol

  • @rocklol2335
    @rocklol23357 ай бұрын

    it would be unfair to compare 50+ years old BACH with 30+ y/o Eric, so to compare Bach then and Eric now- BACH wins (great voice+great hair+80's magic?), however now...Sebastian in live performance sounds out of breath and it is a little bit painful to listen to but his new song is dope, Eric seems like a perfect fit for 2023 Skid Row, but would he be remembered after 30 years as a rock legend like Bach is? I hope so

  • @iam5162

    @iam5162

    6 ай бұрын

    Bach has been a bit rough touring last summer. He's been better in his latest gigs though and lost some weight. We'll see what 2024 brings.

  • @e.p.649

    @e.p.649

    3 ай бұрын

    The only way to compared them is when. Bach has 30 +some and Erik 30 before the narrow bone transplant. I you Americans bother in doing a little research of what he was in Europe... there will be no comparation. Erik is better singer , had more energy and of course he is a gentleman with his former band ,they are FRIENDS , he's not a bigmouth or a clown to talk shit about someone he didn't bother to know who he is. Erik, wish to see you soon all over Erurope&UK like I did before. But as a disable chronic illness sufferer now : HEALTH FIRST. ❤

  • @jonasandersson3684

    @jonasandersson3684

    2 ай бұрын

    Your opinion and description on this matter is spot on. You are so very right in that in order to get a fair assessment these singers needs to be compared at roughly the same age. A young Sebastian is hands down the better frontman in terms of the whole package. In terms of the voice they come pretty close, but I see the young version of Sebastian as slightly better with hiting high notes. At this point in time Erik would probably be doing a better job, but I still would prefer a Skid Row reunion with Sebastian as long as Sebastian sounds better then Vince Neil. 🤣

  • @christinemazur7795
    @christinemazur77956 ай бұрын

    Erik is an AMAZING singer. And I enjoyed watching him from Swedish Idol and all his unbelievable covers with his talented session/studio musicians. It's clear Sebastian's influence on him, and yet Erik's covers also prove he can sing *ANYTHING*. He is also nearly 20 years younger than Sea Bass. Erik's journey to Skid Row frontman reminds me of the movie Rock Star with Mark Wahlberg (believe based on the Judas Priest replacement singer's story?). All of that said, anyone looking at Baz either when he first made those songs famous, or even from when he was in his mid to late 30s (Broadway footage, Gilmore Girls, all the VH1 shows he did, Forever Wild, Super Group, I Married....) must give the man his due. There is no other man put on this earth more destined to be a star than Sebastian. Then. Now. And forever.

  • @FatterTony
    @FatterTony7 ай бұрын

    I love them both but i think it's unfair to compare in this way. when the Audi R8 cane out, it was a supercar, 15 years later, it's slower than some family hatchbacks. I think it would have been more fair to compare prime with prime. However, we all win because Skid Row are back. I saw them last year. Best night of my life I think.

  • @AbbaSlav
    @AbbaSlav5 ай бұрын

    For the comparison to be ethical and correct, both should be the same age, singing the same song. I did it. They are both 22 years old performing "I remember you" and I can say this: Eric is a good singer and a cool guy, but Sebastian is brilliant and unique. Sebastian's voice is 5 octaves and he commands it to perfection. There is passion in him! Unique vibrato. Stage behavior and presence, contact and attitude with the audience. Add in the good looks and we have a perfect formula for a ROCK STAR.

  • @iFoss

    @iFoss

    3 ай бұрын

    He never commanded it to perfection tho. Always had pitch issues especially in his chest voice.

  • @matsinilsson9578

    @matsinilsson9578

    2 ай бұрын

    Geezus ..... your voice comparison is just inaccurate lady... kzread.info/dash/bejne/Y3ynx49yetmbYJM.html

  • @DrRyan81

    @DrRyan81

    Ай бұрын

    @@iFossbruh you don’t understand singing

  • @iFoss

    @iFoss

    Ай бұрын

    @@DrRyan81 Sure bruh, sure

  • @DrRyan81

    @DrRyan81

    Ай бұрын

    @@iFoss Even Erik himself admitted He is no match for Bach and that he only wishes he can do Justice to Bach songs which we all know he didn’t do it anywhere as good as Bach. Sure Erik is a great singer and I love him and his solo stuff and also heat but Bach is an innovator a true master of metal singing

  • @aimeedouglas1584
    @aimeedouglas15845 ай бұрын

    Bach has been touring and singing his ass off for the entirety of Erik’s lifetime. Think about that… Also, its important to note that we wouldn’t be talking about Skid Row in 2024 if it weren’t for Sebastian in the first place.

  • @truemetal478
    @truemetal4787 ай бұрын

    Bach just changed some of the high notes he wasn’t struggling the one who was struggling is Erik. Look at his neck tension and it reveals it all

  • @ryant3600

    @ryant3600

    7 ай бұрын

    Bach never could hit those notes in key live.

  • @MsCruisein

    @MsCruisein

    6 ай бұрын

    You might want to watch their snl performance or their MTV experiences, their early 90s stuff. Of course, it matters that he can hear himself.

  • @niblet112

    @niblet112

    6 ай бұрын

    @@ryant3600yeah I’m not surprised, he ran around the stage like a madman. It wasn’t about hitting notes, it was about entertaining the massive crowds. Completely different time. Completely different audience. There was nothing like skid row back in the day. And the new band today they don’t even come close to that greatness today.

  • @DrRyan81

    @DrRyan81

    6 ай бұрын

    ⁠@@ryant3600you are delusional

  • @AbbaSlav

    @AbbaSlav

    5 ай бұрын

    ​@@ryant3600Man, you've obviously never seen or heard Skid Row with Sebastian Bach live. A huge miss for you. As he runs and sometimes sprints across the huge stages, Sebastian manages to sing absolutely right. I wonder how he has air and strength! Some live performances are better than studio recordings. But that's what happens when you sing with all your heart. Not for money, but for the love of music. Respect! Check out the 1991 Wembley concert. Sorry man, but this is a real rock star. In the full sense of this expression. Unfortunately, Eric at the same age and singing some of the same songs standing still can't even come close to Sebastian's vocal capacity. Documented facts.

  • @IronDave1985
    @IronDave19856 ай бұрын

    Age is a factor, but Bach in his prime was really unmatched in this genre.

  • @e.p.649

    @e.p.649

    3 ай бұрын

    Sure. But he wasn't smart enough to take care of what made him special. Now it's not handsome,is fat as much as he laughs at V Neil, and had lost his special voice. So ...🤡

  • @marthy995

    @marthy995

    2 ай бұрын

    "Unmatced" well yeah nice studiovoice but there ya can turn it around etc. Live we can al hear that he falls in the ditch & its not even even in his "prime". But Eriks always rock solid.

  • @DrRyan81

    @DrRyan81

    Ай бұрын

    @@marthy995you don’t understand singing

  • @marthy995

    @marthy995

    Ай бұрын

    @@DrRyan81 What is it i do not understand? A matter of fact is that Erik has never been so pitchy as Bach. He was not even even in his prime performance. Sure it was stil a cool performance but the notes was not spot on in the final chorus etc.

  • @DrRyan81

    @DrRyan81

    Ай бұрын

    @@marthy995 that’s false dude. Bach has great pitch

  • @yuthgonwild
    @yuthgonwild7 ай бұрын

    I never picked sides when Sebastian and Skid Row parted ways. But I am definitely Team Erik when it comes to fronting Skid Row. I have seen both of them live in the past week. Bas has obviously been working on his vocals, but I am very happy with Erik leading Skid Row and don't want to see anyone else as Skid Row's lead singer. This is Erik's time and he also puts out incredible covers on his KZread channel.

  • @teetomcdo5469

    @teetomcdo5469

    3 ай бұрын

    wow!!!comparing an icon to an idol,a product of devotion from a poser copy cat??? bach has aged man,but still kicks ass,and most of diz replacements tried to copy n pattern their voices on his so how come eric sounded n fronted skidrow better?? BACH IS WAS AND WILL ALWAZE B D STANDARDS OF THESE SONGS NOT THESE CHEAP ASS IDIOTS ON THE RHYTHM SECTION, BUT BACH HIMSELF IS THE STANDARD OF THESE SONGS WETHER U LIKE IT OR NOT

  • @annagretaerlandsson
    @annagretaerlandsson6 ай бұрын

    An important factor: The bandmembers doesn´t like Bach but they are very happy with Eric

  • @Chris-oe9mi
    @Chris-oe9mi4 ай бұрын

    Bach is a legend. Period. You cannot compare him with anybody. He's a showman he's number one, the best vocalist ever.❤❤❤ Sebastian Bach❤❤❤

  • @supernova3586
    @supernova35866 ай бұрын

    Settle what? One dude is copying the other. The end.

  • @niblet112

    @niblet112

    6 ай бұрын

    Exactly ones a metal god, the other is a karaoke singer

  • @aimeedouglas1584

    @aimeedouglas1584

    5 ай бұрын

    Yes! I wish more people could see this. I mean, Erik can sing but he’s no Sebastian Bach.

  • @matshagstrom1869

    @matshagstrom1869

    3 ай бұрын

    Its not copying,Erik is another voice than Seb,and he is doning its own way.

  • @supernova3586

    @supernova3586

    3 ай бұрын

    @@matshagstrom1869Doing what? That's right COPYING Bach. You can't be serious.

  • @pondparadisedesignsinc.rob5313
    @pondparadisedesignsinc.rob53134 ай бұрын

    Sebastian Bach by far is the much better front man than Eric would ever try to be. Sebastian is a natural born lead singer front man never be matched.

  • @sylviegrondin5288
    @sylviegrondin52887 ай бұрын

    I never knew Sebastien,but I know that Erik in SkidRow his fans truly seem to love him and Erik loves to entertain his fans and I just love every song that he sings ❤🤟🤟❤️

  • @niblet112

    @niblet112

    6 ай бұрын

    Different time, and now a completely different band. The time when skid row hit the scene will never be replicated. My generation and the generation before me were spoilt with great bands, and great music. A time long gone.

  • @user-ti5xz1kg8f
    @user-ti5xz1kg8f7 ай бұрын

    Let’s be fair how old is Sebastian and how old is Erik come on you can not compare that shit now, there’s an age gap as you get older things change Sebastian holds his own quite well Sebastian brought them to stardom period he’s the original and that will never change.

  • @RichyKearnsproductions

    @RichyKearnsproductions

    7 ай бұрын

    Look at artists like Phil Lewis from La Guns Matijevic from Steelheart or Carine Pinto from Manigance age plays a part sure but so does diet exercise and maintaining your voice with practice it doesnt have to be this way i love seb but thers things that could be done to improve and it isnt doing it his fans want allways comment that hes better than erik in my comments but now that ive shown the comparisons its not fair 🤷🏼‍♂️

  • @user-ti5xz1kg8f

    @user-ti5xz1kg8f

    7 ай бұрын

    @@RichyKearnsproductions even if they did all what your saying aging is part of life things are different 30-55 even with singing it is what it is Sebastian will always be the #1 in Skidrow. Erik does a good job but he’s no Sebastian. Sebastian has heart he lives and breaths rock n roll that will never change. Sebastian has that energy no matter what those are Sebastian’s songs that’s what people think and hear when they hear those songs it will forever be Sebastian rock n roll never dies but we will all be dead sometime or another and it will be his legacy.

  • @MsCruisein

    @MsCruisein

    6 ай бұрын

    Agree. Guess we'll see when Eric turns 55 and has been singing nightly for 35 years.

  • @MsCruisein

    @MsCruisein

    6 ай бұрын

    Or, look at Baz clips when he was 35. He was on Broadway then. Lots of footage.

  • @niblet112

    @niblet112

    6 ай бұрын

    @@MsCruiseindoesn’t matter you cannot compare 55 year old seb to A young erik. Again Sebastian did world tours playing to millions of crazy fans in huge metal festivals. The 80s-90s were crazy times of party’s living a true rock and roll lifestyle. Erik is in a band now with old men who have been there and done it. They probably tell erik crazy stories about it.

  • @thomascoburn5481
    @thomascoburn54814 ай бұрын

    Erik Gronwall is a worthy Successor to Bach and to Skid Row, but Skid Row isn't Skid Row without Bach.

  • @lusse7183
    @lusse71837 ай бұрын

    I’am team Erik in this, Sebastian is a legend but Erik has the Youth and is the best singer to fill Sebastians shoes, Sebastian was one of Eriks biggest inspirations from young age. Erik is the reason I found Skid Row, after seeing his audition in Swedish idol 🤟🏻🤟🏻

  • @Jesoteric
    @Jesoteric7 ай бұрын

    You cannot be better then the original who you are simply imitating, I’m not saying the guy isn’t a great singer, he is, but he’s filling shoes not wearing his own, that’s just the reality, so the question is redundant

  • @umarae27
    @umarae272 ай бұрын

    No comparison. Enjoyment is very subjective, as it should be. Nuff said.

  • @Pamplemousse82223
    @Pamplemousse822235 ай бұрын

    My wife can't stand Metal or hard rock. I said how about anything from Skid Row. She said not the music, but oh Sebastian Bach I know who that is. Settled.

  • @chriskerr5255
    @chriskerr52556 ай бұрын

    There a very few rock vocals better than on the Slave to the Grind album. To me its easily Sebastian

  • @user-nk8fr3dh7o

    @user-nk8fr3dh7o

    6 ай бұрын

    I share that I don't know anyone, not even Erik, who can sing with that quality and viceral power. nobody!!

  • @johnnykelley3727
    @johnnykelley37274 ай бұрын

    Sebastian Bach is a better frontman and definitely a better singer. For anyone that says Erik is better, go listen to Wasted Time. Hell go listen to the whole album of Slave to the Grind. Sebastian is a fucking VOCAL GOD!!!

  • @Bigrailindad333
    @Bigrailindad3333 ай бұрын

    Bach was the best hair metal singer of all time! Except for Mille from steelheart

  • @fortybay
    @fortybay6 ай бұрын

    Probably would have been better to use video of Bach when he was Eric's age for a more accurate comparison. Bach isn't what he was. I personally like both singers...

  • @mbgmail5911
    @mbgmail59115 ай бұрын

    Sebastian these days sounds like a parody of himself and Erik sounds better live than Sebastian did even in his prime. Sebastian does sound better on the original records.

  • @joet6434
    @joet64346 ай бұрын

    Unfair comparison as Sebastian has a good 20 years or so on his old bands current singer, so is showing signs of that. What you should do is have them both compared at similar ages & i would wager Bach would take it, not taking away from the new singer, but he has youth on his side.

  • @jadej51
    @jadej515 ай бұрын

    cant compare to sebastian bach! he made skid row! go back to skid row when they came out!! he still going on!! compare sebastian bach in his 20s!!

  • @wayneforrest3360
    @wayneforrest33602 ай бұрын

    Yep Eric does a good job of trying to sound like young Sebastian. But if we’re not for SB who would he be singing like?

  • @johnperra3695
    @johnperra36956 ай бұрын

    Well I’m gonna say this if Sebastian’s ego didn’t get in the way he’d probably still be with Skid Row and we wouldn’t be having this conversation I love the old Skid Row but I do like the new album it’s a worthy effort by the band

  • @SplinteredChaos
    @SplinteredChaos6 ай бұрын

    This is a poor comparison. The singers are not being compared in the same point in careers or even environment.

  • @r.c.2669
    @r.c.26696 ай бұрын

    They are both great singers! Skid Row is not Skid Row with out Sebastian. I love Eric with H-E-A-T .

  • @user-kh7mv1pz8f
    @user-kh7mv1pz8f6 ай бұрын

    Time?

  • @thomascoburn5481
    @thomascoburn54814 ай бұрын

    Using Bachs current voice isn't fair to use in this comparison

  • @marthy995

    @marthy995

    Ай бұрын

    No but he was pitchy back in the days also

  • @riri-cq8zp
    @riri-cq8zp5 ай бұрын

    In the vide you said Eric "Sounds like prime Bach"??? This is your comment. So, Eric is just a Copy cat "trying hard" to sound like Bach. LOL

  • @RichyKearnsproductions

    @RichyKearnsproductions

    5 ай бұрын

    Erik sounds like prime bach yeah i said that but i also said he gives us variety look face the facts Sebastian is out of shape and his vocals are shot to bits if he gets himself back into shape and actually practices his vocal lessons he could still actually sound amazing but right now Erik is king people like yourself will bitch and moan all day long about how Sebastian is better but when i actually show you the reality suddenly im not being fair and then a laundry list of excuses pour out you act like i just shot Santa Claus chill out lol

  • @teetomcdo5469
    @teetomcdo54693 ай бұрын

    BACH IS SKIDROW!! SKIDROW WERE INKED IN THE ROCK N ROLL WORLD CUZ OF SEBASTIAN BACH!! 😂VOCALS WERE PATTERNED ON BACHS VOCALS EVEN ERIC DOES SO DEFINITELY BACH !!

  • @user-mx6zv1jl1e
    @user-mx6zv1jl1e5 ай бұрын

    年齢が違うからね。 全盛期のセバスチャンバックのほうが色っぽくてカッコいいよ。

  • @marthy995
    @marthy9954 ай бұрын

    Sebastian in his "prime" was not really close to Eriks spot on live performances when it comes to pitch etc.

  • @authines
    @authines4 ай бұрын

    There’s only one Sebastian Bach!🤘 That’s awesome they got a fill in but he’s not the same! In a Darkened Room are you kidding me 😂. Listen to the original Eric isn’t hitting those notes at all like Bach used to. Age is a factor for sure but even at a young age Eric doesn’t sound close to me sorry.

  • @greatlife9638

    @greatlife9638

    2 ай бұрын

    It is the studio version that you are comparing with Erik's live performance. Bach don't sing those high notes live. Publish a link here so i can listen.

  • @wayneforrest3360
    @wayneforrest33602 ай бұрын

    By the way show me a picture of Eric when he’s 50. Oh that’s right he isn’t there yet. What’s that saying, I’ve been your age you haven’t been mine

  • @RichyKearnsproductions

    @RichyKearnsproductions

    Ай бұрын

    I get that argument but i think its to easy to blame things on age ther is somthing to be said for looking after yourself perfect example look at Lenny Kravitz hes 59 still has a fantastic voice and still looks great bach if he put in the work could sound and look better

  • @monkeyhouse1672
    @monkeyhouse16726 ай бұрын

    Martial arts has nothing to do with being a good singer, vocalist or frontman. Seb had much better material to work with. The Gang is all Here is mediocre, with a modern over-compressed digital production. It won't age well and it sounds awful on vinyl. The first two Skid Row records are the heart and soul of the band. And Seb was a ln integral part of that, with his arrangements, harmonies, lyrical compostiion and performance. This new person is just a journeyman who has joined an ageing legacy band.

  • @RichyKearnsproductions

    @RichyKearnsproductions

    6 ай бұрын

    I would strongly disagree martial arts is a discipline that keeps you fit and healthy both in body and mind being fit and healthy means more energy to run around on the stage and having the breath hit those insane highs and the mental discipline to know when to talk shit and when not to further more that discipline is admirable it shows an audience that he isnt just some lumbering buffoon but a guy that you can beilive in a guy that will to the best of his ability carry the torch as far as he can take it

  • @monkeyhouse1672

    @monkeyhouse1672

    6 ай бұрын

    @@RichyKearnsproductions Yep, doing martial arts really improved Billy Joel, Elton John, Freddie Mercury, Geoff Tate, and all the other front-men of the last few decades to underpin their performance #facepalm 🤦‍♂️

  • @DrRyan81

    @DrRyan81

    6 ай бұрын

    Well said

  • @iam5162

    @iam5162

    6 ай бұрын

    gangs all here is pretty decent but you're right that it won't age well. if it came out in the 80s or 90s, it'd be lost in a pile of generic, flavor of the day ratt, whitesnake, sven gali and slik toxic albums. nevermind the modern production, the songs on it just don't stand out. bach put out 1 track recently and its catchier/beefier than anything on the gangs all here album, as if its a missing track from the slave to the grind era.

  • @DrRyan81

    @DrRyan81

    6 ай бұрын

    @@iam5162 very well said dude

  • @marcrijkhals
    @marcrijkhals7 ай бұрын

    Bach for sure......the best

  • @patrickreeves4650
    @patrickreeves46504 ай бұрын

    teenage me says bach....realistic, adult me says erik is less of an issue, and a better singer. i vote erik. bach is an ass now a days.

  • @MsCruisein
    @MsCruisein6 ай бұрын

    You even say "if you close your eyes, he (erik) sounds like prime Bach." Isnt that weird that you phrased it that way. Who's the better singer, you think?

  • @DrRyan81

    @DrRyan81

    6 ай бұрын

    Erik doesn’t sound like Bach I don’t get it. To me they sound pretty different however erik was influenced by Bach but still Bach always had a much powerful voice

  • @iam5162

    @iam5162

    6 ай бұрын

    if i close my eyes Erik sounds like Rob Halford more than Bach lol.

  • @DrRyan81

    @DrRyan81

    6 ай бұрын

    @@iam5162 how come Rob halford? I don’t hear that at all. He doesn’t sound like anyone of them to me

  • @ukrpgfan4029
    @ukrpgfan40296 ай бұрын

    Bach is Skid Row. End Of.

  • @martist911wasits-not-real4
    @martist911wasits-not-real46 ай бұрын

    SB preached the virtues of the government 💉 and my girlfriend razzed him about it. Blocked her after a status quo rant. She was a fan for a long time and then realized what an establishment DB he really is 😅.

  • @user-vr1hc7df7o
    @user-vr1hc7df7o6 ай бұрын

    50 something vs 30 something EG kills it now if you want to compare 30 year old Bach to 30 year old Gronwall.....But as of now EG is way better

  • @alexmaverick407
    @alexmaverick4073 ай бұрын

    Broder they are not the same age at all. How can bach beat erick being 20 years older

  • @RichyKearnsproductions

    @RichyKearnsproductions

    3 ай бұрын

    Age isnt the reason why he is sucking

  • @AlS-oq8kj
    @AlS-oq8kj6 ай бұрын

    Sebastian is better by far, being fair to Eric he’s a pretty good fit

  • @ryant3600

    @ryant3600

    5 ай бұрын

    What are you listening to? Dillusional..

  • @PACK-ge5gu
    @PACK-ge5gu6 ай бұрын

    😂

  • @dannydavis5245
    @dannydavis52456 ай бұрын

    Sebastian is skidrow and nothing more needs to be said

  • @keithkinkade4265
    @keithkinkade42656 ай бұрын

    There is no comparison. Bach is a LEGEND. The other dude can sing, but he can't toucg the shit Bach did in his prime. Not even close

  • @danielsuske7356
    @danielsuske73563 ай бұрын

    This isn't a fair comparison at all. The new singer is just a kid. You can't compare him to Bach of today and give the kid points because Bach struggles a bit to sing every word late in a show. Compare this kid to the Bach of Skid Row right here: kzread.info/dash/bejne/iWilyJaFdc7Alqw.html That will leave no doubt Bach is a pro and this kid is 2nd rate. You want to compare them? Compare where they played at the same age. Bach was in Stadiums and this kid is a lounge singer.

  • @RichyKearnsproductions

    @RichyKearnsproductions

    3 ай бұрын

    Excuses

  • @RichyKearnsproductions

    @RichyKearnsproductions

    3 ай бұрын

    In the fictional scenario where bach is 21 and erik is still 36 sure bach wins before i made this video bach was king but that wasnt the point i was trying to make i wanted to show everyone the reality before i made this video the argument was bach is better no contest now that ive shown everyone how bad it really is the excuses have rolled out Im being unfair oh his age etc not to ruin my next video but i scene a woman in her 70s who lived the same life style as bach sellout an arena she sang her songs to perfection in her 70s and ther are alot of artists like her that do the same even in our own genre despite ther age bottom line Sebastian is out of shape and become a parody of himself it isnt age

  • @Joe-si2dq
    @Joe-si2dq6 ай бұрын

    Sabastian bach is skid row Eric is like machine gunn Kelly wanna be

  • @Dehumanizer3000
    @Dehumanizer30007 ай бұрын

    Sebastian is way older than Erik its not a fair comparison and comes across as cherry picking, Bach is 55 and has declined from age (with Bach being a high tenor and his reckless life style his voice has declined faster than most.. high tenors tend to burn bright and fast, Robert Plant and Midnight (Crimson Glory) are other examples) you should compare both Erik and Bach when at the same age and at the same point in their career. Bach in the early 2000s is still a far better singer than Erik, you are comparing singing technique and the voice, not how they sing right now. Matijevic from Steelheart is a low Tenor and has worked hard on his voice and after taking a break worked hard to get it back to strength, he also does not have the mileage on his voice that bach has because bach never stopped touring or working. another example of this is Michael kiske, for a long time he quit doing tours and took a break, doing only did session work and some albums. only when he rejoined helloween is he doing heavy touring and more using his voice, and he sounds great! you can tell he does not have the mileage on his voice and he was smart to do that. so if you are gonna compare erik and bach one for one, do it by comparing them at the same age and the same point in their career.

  • @jeremyurbatsch4980
    @jeremyurbatsch49807 ай бұрын

    Bach takes 2nd place here.

  • @niblet112

    @niblet112

    6 ай бұрын

    How can the OG be 2nd. There is no competition. Skid row back in the day were awesome. They will never replicate that time. Sebastian will forever be remembered

  • @DrRyan81

    @DrRyan81

    6 ай бұрын

    @@niblet112In dio’s case I’d argue dio beats Ozzy vocally or in iron maiden id say Bruce is better than di anno technically. But for skid row it’s easily Bach

  • @truemetal478
    @truemetal4787 ай бұрын

    Sebastian still sounds much better. Erik was so forced on the high notes and sounded like a chicken

  • @iFoss

    @iFoss

    3 ай бұрын

    You high? Or just completely ignorant when it comes to vocals?

  • @DownMemoryLaneParis
    @DownMemoryLaneParis7 ай бұрын

    Using Bas bad footage to compare any of Erik perforances is not fair. Also 36 vs 55... not a good start. Erik is a killer singer, but to me he lacks the sex drug & rock n roll attitude Skid row used to represent... Bas is still this mothertrucker he always was and always gonna be.

  • @RichyKearnsproductions

    @RichyKearnsproductions

    7 ай бұрын

    I find this fascinating before this video the attitude was baz is so much better than erik erik could never be better than bach but now that this video is out its oh hes old it isnt fair to compare him to erik lets just ignore the fact that hes let himself go and that he clearly isnt looking after his voice hes still by some mad logic better than erik 😂

  • @DrRyan81

    @DrRyan81

    6 ай бұрын

    @@RichyKearnsproductionshe is still better dude

  • @niblet112

    @niblet112

    6 ай бұрын

    @@RichyKearnsproductionsSebastian sang these songs when he was 19. You cannot compare a lifestyle of the 80-90s of constant world touring and crazy party’s to skid row now. It’s incomparable. Seb metal god. Other guy replicated karaoke singer. The fact that Sebastian can still sing at all is amazing tbh. The things he’s seen and done are incredible. What a life a true metal god!!!!

  • @iam5162

    @iam5162

    6 ай бұрын

    THIS. The charisma / intensity is missing. You can't replace that. As a singer, Erik is 10/10, though.

  • @DrRyan81

    @DrRyan81

    6 ай бұрын

    @@iam5162 Bach’s vocal ability superior though. Like even when they hit the same note Bach has much more power

  • @srhatfield
    @srhatfield7 ай бұрын

    Erik is 20 years younger than Sebastian. Erik is definitely a better singer but age has to account for something here.

  • @niblet112

    @niblet112

    6 ай бұрын

    @@DrRyan81the best of Sebastian was amazing. Was he just 19 when he recorded 18 and life?

  • @niblet112

    @niblet112

    6 ай бұрын

    @@DrRyan81 can’t compare a living legend to a karaoke singer 😂

  • @Floffrickard
    @Floffrickard4 ай бұрын

    This is stupid. Its also about singing the soft tunes

  • @DVTOM
    @DVTOM6 ай бұрын

    you pick the worst performance of bach

  • @RichyKearnsproductions

    @RichyKearnsproductions

    6 ай бұрын

    By all means pick me a better one from 2023 and leave the link here for me to look at

  • @johnnykelley3727

    @johnnykelley3727

    4 ай бұрын

    ​@@RichyKearnsproductionshow about 1 from Sebastian in his mid 30's??? Sebastian is fucking KING so get used to it.

  • @bjorncalmgren6699
    @bjorncalmgren66996 ай бұрын

    Bach is a karaoke Singer and Erik dominate Skid Row as Bach nerver did

  • @shellybean9

    @shellybean9

    5 ай бұрын

    I agree and it's about time somebody said Bach and karaoke in the same sentence, instead of the replies of Erik is karaoke. No he's definitely not.

  • @thekombatrealm6082
    @thekombatrealm60824 ай бұрын

    Erik outdoes Bach any day. Bach's voice sucks nuts now.

  • @lukelang6954
    @lukelang69547 ай бұрын

    Well they are both equally gay

  • @RichyKearnsproductions

    @RichyKearnsproductions

    7 ай бұрын

    🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍🌈

  • @bastardoize
    @bastardoize5 ай бұрын

    You are comparing a guy with someone half his age, that is not fair. Compare them with Bach in his prime and I think things will be very different than what you present here. As a long time Skid Row fan, Erik is the only singer that has brought me back to Skid Row; the dude is legit and brings it to the band. But I'd still rather see them with Bach, just because...it seems right. But I'll be good with Erik; he is better these days than Bach is these days.

  • @ivanveljkovic6242
    @ivanveljkovic62423 ай бұрын

    Sebastian in his prime and Eric who is amazing singer can compare,Sebastian is better,its not in the same level 🙏

  • @DrRyan81

    @DrRyan81

    3 ай бұрын

    Ofc. I’d argue Bach in 2011 was way better than Erik also

  • @RichyKearnsproductions

    @RichyKearnsproductions

    3 ай бұрын

    2011 Bach was him at his best and heres the thing i believe that if Bach bothered his arse to get to a gym and train he could be that good again but at present hes in Vince meal territory and we all know what that ends up like

  • @DrRyan81

    @DrRyan81

    3 ай бұрын

    @@RichyKearnsproductions Sebastian had several primes I’d say one was in the 80’s and early 90’s and the other prime was his singing during 2000-2014 from shows I’ve seen from him. Which that already proves even after a decade that his voice wasn’t at his best he could get it back via a better lifestyle, So I agree with what you say

  • @IanIsrael
    @IanIsrael7 ай бұрын

    Sebastian has really let himself go,he can barely hit the notes now. So glad i watched this video,man.

  • @niblet112

    @niblet112

    6 ай бұрын

    Of course the man has he’s led an absolutely crazy rock and roll life. It’s amazing singers from that era are still alive tbh. He entertained millions touring to massive crowds of crazy fans. The fact he can still sing at all is a testament to how strong his voice is. He’s a living legend

  • @iam5162

    @iam5162

    6 ай бұрын

    His last year's gigs were pretty bad, its true. The recent stuff is much better. I dunno what he did to himself in a year but he did shed the gut a bit and his voice is better. Check Eddie Trunk's recent 40th anniversary gig, Bach kills Sweet Little Sister and Monkey Business there. Much better than those summer gigs

Келесі