Season 6 Episode 10: Debunking Thomas Sowell

Ойын-сауық

Matt McManus joins us to discuss his Jacobin article "Thomas Sowell Is a Cynical Man":
jacobin.com/2024/03/sowell-cy...
This Thursday (3/21), Ben will be speaking at Wayne State University (sponsored by Metro Detroit DSA & Wayne State YDSA) on "Debunking the Many Bad Arguments Made by Israel's Apologists in the West" at 6 PM at Old Main 0103.
Support the Smith College library union:
www.sclwu.org/
Support the Long Beach post union:
actionnetwork.org/petitions/u...
Follow Matt on Twitter: @MattPolProf
Follow Ben on Twitter: @BenBurgis
Follow GTAA on Twitter: @Gtaa_Show
Become a GTAA Patron and receive numerous benefits ranging from patron-exclusive postgames every Monday night to our undying love and gratitude for helping us keep this thing going:
patreon.com/benburgis
Read the weekly philosophy Substack:
benburgis.substack.com
Visit bebenburgis.com

Пікірлер: 75

  • @Garrett1240
    @Garrett12403 ай бұрын

    Shouts to unlearning economics

  • @jakecreighton9039
    @jakecreighton90393 ай бұрын

    Dude I’m loving McManus more and more. His vibe is super confident nerd that doesn’t tolerate the bullshit.

  • @demandbetterworld
    @demandbetterworld3 ай бұрын

    Unlearning economics just had a great video on this! Is this a coincidence? I havent watched yet

  • @Chill_Pills
    @Chill_Pills3 ай бұрын

    I was some form of libertarian/conservative for almost ten years and was initially influenced by Sowell. Glad that you and others are challenging his work because I think he is really popular.

  • @Supersized45
    @Supersized452 ай бұрын

    Signed both petitions! Hope your talk went well

  • @ScottM5.0
    @ScottM5.02 ай бұрын

    “Retirement is stupid!”- Rich kid with a Sharpie beard

  • @MsZeitgeist85
    @MsZeitgeist853 ай бұрын

    The problem with Thomas Sowell's extremely rigid brand of Libertarian Market Fundamentalism is that so many of his premises and conclusions rely on hypotheticals instead of empiricism. Unlearning Economics did a video on his book Basic Economics. His book should be called Basic NeoLiberal Economics. One of the biggest flaws is how in his book Sowell downplays market failures. In his only mention of market failures he only talks about it for 40 words.

  • @anthonyesposito7

    @anthonyesposito7

    3 ай бұрын

    Yea well Neoliberal economics is basically just market fundamentalism at the end of the day.

  • @bermo6066

    @bermo6066

    3 ай бұрын

    ​@@anthonyesposito7 A lot of neo liberals weren't really market fundamentalists or doctrinaire libertarians, they were interested in markets as a way of shaping public behavior. There is a belief in markets for sure but particularly as a technology of social control.

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    Thomas Sowell does NOT favor Jim Crow. He DOES NOT say that Jim Crow is innocent disparity.

  • @davidluckens3479
    @davidluckens34792 ай бұрын

    As Prof Wolff pointed out 45 doesn't appear to understand what tariffs are,let alone how they work

  • @genYprogressive83
    @genYprogressive833 ай бұрын

    Economists like Thomas Sowell need to be forgotten as quickly as possible. His work has little to do with actual economics of having a better society as much as it is preserving an order of the market being our master.

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    Violating property rights means violence against the freedom of people from slavery. Property rights are the rights to the fruits of your labour. They are the fruits of your labour.

  • @thomasd2444
    @thomasd24443 ай бұрын

    54:29 - Well, Bless his heart 56:18 - see description - Support the Smith College library union 57:20 - see description - Support the Long Beach post union 59:20 - See Ben talk @ 6 PM , 21 MAR 2024 , Old Main , Rm 103 , Wayne State U , Detroit , MI , USA , Global North

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    Justice is best understood, by the straightforward concept of, justifying your level , in material construction. That terminology is the fundamental basis point of the level straight balance.

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    If you would bother to read the basis points of microeconomics principles it starts from the individual social consent based. That multiplies the great social progress.

  • @maxshea1829
    @maxshea18293 ай бұрын

    What wondrous love is this? Oh my Sowell, Oh my Sowell.

  • @erikbjorke5851
    @erikbjorke58513 ай бұрын

    Political representation is certain vocations is sometimes self-selecting. There are more liberals in academia because that sort of job appeals to liberals.

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    You are letting your static engraved image of capital, block your mind You do NOT get the basis points of economic social science.

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    Science does NOT care about your feelings. That is a fundamental building block of how you make choices. That is regarding, what is or is NOT, the best use of human capital, physical capital and time and space.

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    You did NOT even discuss the most fundamental concept of dynamic scoring of economic social kinetic, entrepreneur functions.

  • @tom_rob
    @tom_rob3 ай бұрын

    27:45 - Each person who attains to the age of 50 whether having been subsisting well from work-able compensation & or subsisting well from work-unable compensation may begin to receive a pension paid by our Currency-Issuing-Self--Government's Treasury in order to continue subsisting well in old age. It only requires each Voter to know how our money economy operates

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    He was saying that Black USAmerican citizens, do NOT fall behind, when the field is fixed. That is the reason why, Jackie Robinson or Michael Jordan, can climb up higher than the super majority of people

  • @snackweight
    @snackweight3 ай бұрын

    Can we start a gofundme for Norm's tuition?

  • @gangofgreenhorns2672

    @gangofgreenhorns2672

    3 ай бұрын

    I imagine him just rhetorically eviscerating Shapiro while dressed identical to Steve Buscemi's "How do you do fellow kids?" character in 30 Rock.

  • @bgiv2010
    @bgiv20103 ай бұрын

    The beer analogy only works if you think Black people have a long and proud history of poverty, as a cultural industry.

  • @tom_rob
    @tom_rob3 ай бұрын

    44:23 - This Life: Secular Faith and Spiritual Freedom , by Martin Hägglund , MAR 2019

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    Thomas Sowell's defense of employers is NOT separate from your freedom from whether you should or should not pay for my comments, right now

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    Sowell is describing the way individual social consent works. You are manifesting your own slave-master-mind, Analysis.

  • @tom_rob
    @tom_rob3 ай бұрын

    25:20 - I N T R O D U C I N G

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    You guys have NOT said anything that is a basis point of individual social consent.

  • @rabbit_herder_420
    @rabbit_herder_4203 ай бұрын

    Tis the season of Sowell

  • @thomasd2444
    @thomasd24443 ай бұрын

    52:54 - Justice in the Western Tradition of 35 Centuries is That which one does for another.

  • @thomasd2444
    @thomasd24443 ай бұрын

    1:33:56 - Simply, Thomas So-well is missing his soul

  • @spcphd
    @spcphd3 ай бұрын

    I thought this video was about Sowell.

  • @BenBurgisGTAA

    @BenBurgisGTAA

    3 ай бұрын

    It's a whole episode, but the discussion of the Sowell article is the main event. Starts at about 53 minutes and goes to the end of the episode.

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    Thomas Sowell's critique of Donald Trump was clear. Dr. T. Sowell talked about Trump after President Trump served. It was a matter of the brand-name, capital "P", Progressive political policies, that are ill-liberal anti-social policies. That is, I DO NOT speak for Thomas Sowell. It is that Trump was not as ill-liberal and anti-social as capital " P" Progressive policies.

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    You have NOT said anything that shows that you even care about what Thomas Sowell's actual economic social science ideas are.

  • @drewdp515
    @drewdp5153 ай бұрын

    These guys come across like they've never read Bastiat.

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    You have NOT even indicated that you ever give any of your time to Thomas Sowell's actual economic social science literature. Try his Basic Economics, Common Sense.

  • @thomasd2444
    @thomasd24443 ай бұрын

    27:45 - Poor B.S. mistakes the need to work to subsist or else to die of starvation or homeless exposure in a country not yet providing living-well pensions to all. No one needs to work for subsistence after age 50. It is affordable in 2024 & beyond for our Congress to provide & maintain Living-Well-Pensions for each American which ensures an abundant retirement after the period in life of subsistence-working. Living-Well-Pensions which allow each person time in adult life to continue in retirement to take advantage of the opportunities of access to the pleasures of sense as well as the pleasures of play and the aesthetic pleasures and the opportunity to access the goods of the mind through educational facilities just as they ought to have had those opportunities during their term of subsistence-working.

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    Thomas Sowell does NOT say anything that you should keep telling us that he is saying that people should stay happy, with whatever their conditions are. You are standing still That is NOT Thomas Sowell's advice for anybody, to stand still.

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    You need to read F.A. Hayek's "The Fortunes of Liberalism", in the classical sense. I will paraphrase Hayek. He, Frederick Hayek, says that Thomas Sowell's works are, along with James Buchanan, the best successors of Ludwig Von Mises's Economic and Social Science .... You tried to demean Thomas Sowell, by misrepresenting Frederick Hayek, in contrast to Thomas Sowell. However, the several schools of thought, that were influenced by Ludwig Von Mises's Economic and Social Science, include Frederick Hayek and the rival Murray Rothbard. Frederick Hayek is the head of one of the major branches of Classical Liberal Individualist social dynamics, that in great ways, represent Ludwig Von Mises's Economic and Sociological Analysis of Socialism. That is precisely the book that Frederick Hayek, says changed the whole debate of the whole economic social science profession. That was, after The First World War- WW-ONE Prussian German state-ism patterns of Socialist militaristic imperial war on the West. Hayek makes crystal clear, in his Forward to Ludwig Von Mises's Economic and Sociological Analysis of Socialism, that Ludwig Von Mises' social science works, destroyed Socialism. Later, in F.A.Hayek's " Fortunes of Liberalism in The Classical sense, Hayek says that Thomas Sowell and James Buchanan are the best successors of Ludwig Von Mises's Economic and Sociological Analysis of Socialism. So, why don't you guys, take some mushrooms and some Acapulco gold and take a vacation from your ill-liberal anti-social, static scoring, habits Some of the later writing of Timothy Leary on libertarian social choices, might help free your minds. You need to chill out of your hater's mindset.

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    You keep trying to insult Thomas Sowell, in contrast to Frederick Hayek. You just mentioned Ludwig Von Mises. So you should NOT keep stereotyping, what he says.

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    Ben Burgis , you not getting Thomas Sowell's idea, at all. That is because you do NOT get the dynamic Kinetic economic social science principles. Thomas Sowell does NOT say that poor people should just stay resigned to poverty. You need to climb up from your static scoring mindset. You have not shown that you have a clue about wealth creation

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    You guys are NOT describing economic social science based thoughts. You have not said anything, that sounds like you understand what the meaning of " capital" , means. You have a static concept of a status quo. That shows that you are NOT getting the concept of what economic social science calls small " p" , progressive capital formation and progressive capital accumulation.

  • @mattgilbert7347
    @mattgilbert73472 ай бұрын

    Another shoutout to Unlearning Economics.

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    You are NOT getting anything correct. So maybe you should be required by the government, to pay for my time, that I have been wasting, trying to educate you. That is, you are so privileged to have the ability to organize your time and resources, so that you have a video presence.

  • @atwarwithdust
    @atwarwithdust3 ай бұрын

    I'm the 100th like.

  • @jodag3475
    @jodag34753 ай бұрын

    "Nordic countries shows a study that they are "higher trust" societies... and there is no doubt at least some of m this is becaise of their government social programs".... good guess... lol. Let me guess too. They are homogeneous, rich countries that avoid war

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    Again, Sowell does NOT ever say anything that you should interpret that he said, perfection just springs from the earth Again, you are manifesting the static scoring, status quo, standing still frameworks. That is NOT Sowell's thinking You are NOT doing justice, (JUSTICE) to the subject. You need to smoke a joint and drop some acid and read Sowell's social science. Maybe you can read some later Timothy Leary psychedelic psychology. You guys are NOT even describing Thomas Sowell's social science. You need to go back to the basic economics.

  • @jodag3475
    @jodag34753 ай бұрын

    Their score 2/10. Just cuz sowell writes in an elementary style to appeal to all people... doesn't give you the right to use elementary logic to "destroy" the man's life work. He is allowed to believe in a minimal role for government.... and at the same time believe crimes should he punish strictly.

  • @jodag3475

    @jodag3475

    3 ай бұрын

    "Sowell has nothing original to say" ... are you kidding??? The differences statistics he lays out from differences in rivers to differences to middle men through out history. .. he brought a lot to the table

  • @jodag3475

    @jodag3475

    3 ай бұрын

    In the final few minutes... one claims that sowell, despite empirical evidence, claims that free market capitalism is the only solution... then he credits post 1950 American economic boom to the social programs in the USA. What?!?! Capitalism made America the champ... not social justice in post 1950. Yall get 1/10

  • @jodag3475

    @jodag3475

    3 ай бұрын

    These guys claim that Sowell can't even imagine it even a possibility that capitalism could be improved... I say you guys can't even begin to understand sowells world view. His view is less, of what they claim, that the strong thrive and the weak do as they must... sowells view is more... the weak are the most comfortable people in the history of the world.... they have A.C, cell phones, internet, heat, cars, fancy cloths, and food cards... the weak in this country are richer that 99% of the world

  • @charleswofford6296

    @charleswofford6296

    3 ай бұрын

    @@jodag3475Sowell just repeats the same boomer clichés that we've all grown up hearing.

  • @jodag3475

    @jodag3475

    3 ай бұрын

    @charleswofford6296 maybe in the 30 seconds clips... he wrote 16 books or more.... I doubt they are filled with boomer cliches

  • @johnpaulgettelman86
    @johnpaulgettelman8613 күн бұрын

    You do NOT ever get to the basis points of economic social science. You present cliche images of libertarian ideology. You do NOT advance your social science concepts, by your mutual congratulations social media gossip. You are NOT even discussing Thomas Sowell's social science ideas.

  • @jimitaco1303
    @jimitaco13033 ай бұрын

    {Uncle} Thomas Sowell

Келесі