संवाद # 95: How old are Hindus, Hindustan, India's cultural & political unity | Dr Meenakshi Jain

#ancientindia #hindustan #hindu
MeenakshiJain is a historian interested in cultural and religious developments in ancient and medieval India. Her recent publications include Vasudeva Krishna and Mathura (2021); Flight of Deities and Rebirth of Temples (2019); The Battle for Rama: Case of the Temple at Ayodhya (2017); Sati: Evangelicals, Baptist Missionaries, and the Changing Colonial Discourse (2016); and Rama and Ayodhya (2013).
In 2020, she was awarded the Padma Shri by the Government of India.
Her latest book 'The Hindus of Hindustan: A Civilisational Journey' is now out. You can order your copy here: www.amazon.in/HINDUS-HINDUSTA...
0:00 Meenakshi Jain’s most important book
2:47 How old are Hindus and Hindustan
4:37 How our sacred geography expanded
6:41 Indians had solid consciousness of India by 500 BC
9:43 How the institution of Tirth united India culturally
13:42 Chanakya & antiquity of India’s political unity
17:29 The consciousness of Cholas
18:57 Common men & women patronised Dharma
25:12 Did Brahmins impose Sanatan Dharma on masses?
26:52 Mathura as melting pot of Dharmik panths
29:52 The unity of Sacred dharmik symbols
32:30 Reality of Dharma Shastras
36:02 Aryavarta - Meaning & its expansion
39:25 Manu & how Indians viewed foreigners
42:47 Interesting history of Maga & Kamboj Brahmins
44:15 Did we induct foreign warrior groups into our social system
47:18 Why Gurjar kings used 'Pratihara' title
49:01 How earlier invaders became Hindu
54:35 Why Hindus became wary of foreigners - Islamic invasions
58:18 Brave Hindu resistance against Islamic invaders
1:06:06 Why no big temple in Chandni Chowk
1:09:51 Why Raja Maan Singh feared building a temple
1:11:47 Mughal oppression of farmers
1:15:36 Akbar promoted Persian, not Hindi
1:18:01 How Urdu was born
1:21:34 Real reason why Akbar hired Hindu officials
1:24:49 Mughal mindset always preferred foreigners

Пікірлер: 1 500

  • @prateeksaini8553
    @prateeksaini8553 Жыл бұрын

    Meenakshi mam is our real history guru there should be more people like her

  • @narinderpalsingh4369

    @narinderpalsingh4369

    6 ай бұрын

    😂😂😂😂

  • @Sankalp0302

    @Sankalp0302

    5 ай бұрын

    ❤😊

  • @nickpop23

    @nickpop23

    5 ай бұрын

    कमेंट्स मी ब्राम्हणो को गाली देनेवालो, ब्राम्हण सबका बाप है! सभी हिंदू ब्राम्हण ऋषी से हि पैदा हुए है! जो ब्राम्हण को ना माने वो शूद्र, देशद्रोही है

  • @mukherjiradhika85
    @mukherjiradhika85 Жыл бұрын

    हृदय गद गद हो गया, नेत्र सजल हो गए। शत शत नमन 🙏 आपकी शुद्ध हिंदी ने भी मन मोह लिया। 🙏🚩🕉

  • @monkeymindat
    @monkeymindat9 ай бұрын

    This quote hurts "Hindus became atom of dust" Thanks madam for this revealing truth 🙏🏾

  • @ObjectiveFairminded

    @ObjectiveFairminded

    5 ай бұрын

    Most Hindus are still sleeping.

  • @gopalkrishnamenaria895
    @gopalkrishnamenaria895 Жыл бұрын

    आदरणीय मिनाक्शी जी भारत को विश्व गुरू बनाने में आपका बडा़़ योगदान रहेगा । पहली बार ऐसी ठोस एतिहासिक जानकारिया दी । एसे ही पुरे भारत का इतिहास लिखना व पढाना अनीवार्य करना चाहिए। आप दोनो को साधुवाद ।

  • @ArchanaSingh-fb1fq

    @ArchanaSingh-fb1fq

    5 ай бұрын

    Sahmat hu

  • @Dhruv_Dogra
    @Dhruv_Dogra Жыл бұрын

    Meenakshi Jain ji is immortal now Her honesty and her books have made her that

  • @mahendrasinhchauhan3951

    @mahendrasinhchauhan3951

    5 ай бұрын

    She is misinform about some facts.

  • @drsanjaykumar3448

    @drsanjaykumar3448

    5 ай бұрын

    Romila Thapar and Irfan Habib are only scientific historian and Minakshi and her historical creeds have nothing to do with history. They are just part of bhagva brigade

  • @mahendrasinhchauhan3951

    @mahendrasinhchauhan3951

    5 ай бұрын

    She is not historian she is tweesting fake history.

  • @drsanjaykumar3448

    @drsanjaykumar3448

    5 ай бұрын

    @@mahendrasinhchauhan3951 agree

  • @madhusmritabaruahbarbora7493

    @madhusmritabaruahbarbora7493

    Ай бұрын

    Yes she is real historian. She provide authentic document for almost everything whatever he say.

  • @sharadchandakacherla8268
    @sharadchandakacherla8268 Жыл бұрын

    When Meenakshi ji tells Arihant to wait and continues on a topic 😅. She’s done such service to the our civilisation 🫡 respect. Evidence of the kshaatra spirit that survives in us.

  • @akkkkk813

    @akkkkk813

    Жыл бұрын

    😂😂

  • @srinivasansubramaniam3629

    @srinivasansubramaniam3629

    Жыл бұрын

    Absolutely Professorial command, to not disturb the train of thoughts, to an eager and excited student's question. I am sure a mature person like Arihant definitely respects that. The same thing happened when she first mentioned Sun Temple (Multan) 🙂

  • @wisecritic7197
    @wisecritic719710 ай бұрын

    Dr.Jain is a gem 💎 and contributing to uncover the history of Bharat !

  • @tanmayyadav978
    @tanmayyadav978 Жыл бұрын

    To call her Ma’am is far less than what she is. She is undoubtedly a Goddess, incarnated amongst us humans to spread knowledge as it is. It is people like her who will be the heaviest factors in the rise of India again. There’s no point in wishing for her health because her legacy is beyond the constraints of time now. She is a blessing herself.

  • @anujmishra4871
    @anujmishra4871 Жыл бұрын

    Meenakshi mam have sweet grandmother vibes

  • @Vaad

    @Vaad

    Жыл бұрын

    One of the most wonderful human beings you will meet.

  • @anujmishra4871

    @anujmishra4871

    Жыл бұрын

    @@Vaad aap bhi bahot accha kaam kar rahe hai arihant ji

  • @ReligioCritic

    @ReligioCritic

    Жыл бұрын

    True, my grandmother died before my birth, I wish I had a grandmother like Meenakshi ma'am who would tell me all the historical stories of Hindu culture and Hindu resistance.

  • @deepakpalsana4240

    @deepakpalsana4240

    Жыл бұрын

    @@Vaad I got an opportunity to meet her in Jaipur Dialogues Annual Summit and could take selfie with her ask questions on Ayodhya and Ram Janmbhoomi Movement, she also adviced me to go through her text 'Flight of deities' . It was a wonderful meeting. She is one of the best personality I have interacted ever.

  • @bellacchu

    @bellacchu

    Жыл бұрын

    Yet like a good Ajji, she is a fierce tigress.

  • @VijayKumar-eh4rf
    @VijayKumar-eh4rf Жыл бұрын

    I'm from South, Cholas were staunch Shaivites so they showing respect to Ganga is not a surprise and then they had conquered till Ganga and that is why the title " GangaiKonda Chola" meaning the Chola who won Ganga.(lands of Ganga plains).

  • @zephyr2600

    @zephyr2600

    Жыл бұрын

    After that the temple gangaikonda cholapuram temple was built.

  • @yashu05
    @yashu0511 ай бұрын

    Dr. Jain's voice is a brave one which challenges colonial narratives. The podcast is an eye opener. How little we have been taught about our past ! How foreigners like Kushans, Satvahanas integrated & assimilated nto our culture . Save for one particular religion hell bent on destroying everything we had. High time our history books are filled with the likes of Ms Jain & our children grow up learning the correct version.

  • @udaisingh8436
    @udaisingh8436 Жыл бұрын

    Every guest that have appeared on vaad platform are gems but for me Arihant is top of them for giving us such a nice channel which is not only indic values but his way of expression is the best.

  • @kamus2478
    @kamus2478 Жыл бұрын

    प्रोफेसर मीनाक्षी जैन जी को प्रणाम तथा अरिहंत जी को साधुवाद 🙏 Looking forward to reading this book.

  • @atulsaxena990
    @atulsaxena990 Жыл бұрын

    विद्वान दादी नानी की अनुभुति हो रही है मीनाक्षी मैम को देख सुनकर ...बहुत तार्किक ज्ञान है मीनाक्षीजी को🌺💗🌷🙏

  • @pankajkumar-gc5sm

    @pankajkumar-gc5sm

    Жыл бұрын

    Manuwaadi hai ये😂

  • @amarnathgupta3253
    @amarnathgupta3253 Жыл бұрын

    I salute you as you have exposed the reality of Hindus which is peacefull religion who accepted all sects (Matta) and respected them It is felt that this was a wrong practis Be one and be Hindus Jai Hindu Rashtra

  • @thegamersgaming600
    @thegamersgaming600 Жыл бұрын

    दोस्तों समस्या मुसलमान नही है समस्या कि जड आसमानी किताब है और सबसे बड़ी समस्या ऐसे वामपंथी उग्रवाद जो इस विचार को अनैतिक समर्थन करते हैं🙏💕🙏💕

  • @DeepakSingh-ej4oi

    @DeepakSingh-ej4oi

    Жыл бұрын

    वास्तव में आप जैसा बुद्धिमान इस धरती पर वर्तमान तक जन्मा ही नहीं क्यूंकि जब ईश्वर बुद्धि वितरण कर रहे थे सबसे आगे आप जैसे महा मूर्ख चूतिया को देख तरस खाकर सारी बुद्धि आप को दे दी शेष आत्माओं के लिए हाथ का गर्द झाड़ दिए वह डस्ट सारी आत्माओं को मिला इसीलिए आप जैसा चूतिया विद्वान सब को बुद्धिहीन समझते है

  • @thegamersgaming600

    @thegamersgaming600

    Жыл бұрын

    @@DeepakSingh-ej4oi में बुद्धि से युक्त तो नहीं पर कुरान और इस्लाम को समझा है और फिर बोलता हूँ, समस्या मुसलमान नही है समस्या कि जड आसमानी किताब है और सबसे बड़ी समस्या ऐसे वामपंथी गद्दार है जो इस विचार को अनैतिक समर्थन करते हैं | सभी मुसलमान यही समझते हैं कुरान आसमानी किताब है | क्या आप भी यही मानते हैं? और अगर मानते हैं तो आप भी वामपंथी गद्दार है❓❓❓❓❓

  • @muhammadalishamim2632

    @muhammadalishamim2632

    Жыл бұрын

    Bharat ko barbaad krne wala drm Hindu drm aur uske atanki blatkaari drm ghranth hai jo koi iswar ka likha hua nhi manuwadi hram khoro ka Man ghranth hai Muslim ke 57 desh Quran ke kanun se chl rha hai tumhare atanki repist drm ke ghratho ke anusaar ek desh to churo ek muhlla bhi nhi chl rha khi bhi isliye andh bhgkti repist drm se bahar nekl kr dekho dusre ko fatlu ke gayn mut pelo saalo gwaro Ke wansj

  • @thegamersgaming600

    @thegamersgaming600

    Жыл бұрын

    @@muhammadalishamim2632 दोस्तों उलटा चोर कोतवाल को डाटे, आप ये बताओ भारत का विभाजन इस्लाम के आधार पर हुआ या नहीं? कश्मीर नरसंहार हिन्दू ने किया? गोधरा कांड हिन्दू ने कराया? और सबसे बड़ी बात अफगानिस्तान में आखिरी गुरुद्वारा में बम्ब लगाकर उड़ा दिया? दोस्तों 143 आतकंवादी सगठन बनाकर कोई ये बोले तो इसको आप क्या मानोगे? सबसे बड़ी बात कुरान 8/41 में अल्लाह लूट के माल से 20% हिस्सा लेता है❓❓❓

  • @aliflaila905

    @aliflaila905

    Жыл бұрын

    सुभान ओम ! माशा ओम! ऐसा लगता है आपको ज्ञान है । आपका नाम ही ज्ञान से भरा है।

  • @manansanghvi
    @manansanghvi Жыл бұрын

    I had tears in my eyes for my forefathers. Thank you Ma'am for this realization and awakening

  • @HelloThere-dk3me

    @HelloThere-dk3me

    Жыл бұрын

    'Vishal Mangalwadi & john anderson .....views on a english youtube channles are ;; INdia is devided & backword becaiuse of hindus !! comments were thankyou for telling us ...link kzread.info/dash/bejne/aIqtrK5wlK_Hd5M.html&lc=UgyG8yhfO-v4_g-Bn514AaABAg

  • @ripaday8695

    @ripaday8695

    Жыл бұрын

    Same and along with tears I have anger against those peaceful invaders. 😢😠

  • @rahuldeovatsa

    @rahuldeovatsa

    Жыл бұрын

    बस कर पगले रुलायेगा कया?

  • @Dalia-De

    @Dalia-De

    Жыл бұрын

    Same happened with me , thanks alot meenakhsi ma'am

  • @MrinalM.

    @MrinalM.

    Жыл бұрын

    Same🤔😱🤨😭🤬

  • @AbhishekPatel-tg3cd
    @AbhishekPatel-tg3cd Жыл бұрын

    इतिहास एक ऐसा विषय है जहाँ आप जिस नज़रिए से जाएंगे आपको वो मिल जाएगा. साबित करने के लिए तथ्य भी मौजूद हैं. सब कुछ अच्छा-अच्छा नहीं हो सकता और सब कुछ बुरा भी नहीं हो सकता. मेरा मानना है कि आज तक जो भी इतिहासकार या लेखक हुए हैं या जो होंगे वो पूरी तरह तटस्थ नहीं रह सकते. क्योंकि उन पर कोई ना कोई विचार हावी जरूर होता है. उस विचार की ख़ोज और उसे जानने की चाहत(विचार पर सहमति या असहमति) आपके विचार के तथ्यों की तरफ़ आकर्षित कर ही लेती है. इसलिए किसी इतिहासकार के लेखनी को सार्वभौमिक सत्य नहीं माना जा सकता. लेखिका महोदया जी के साथ भी यही संकट है.

  • @amolakkoka

    @amolakkoka

    Жыл бұрын

    Sahi pakade hain

  • @mohammadharunkhan3740

    @mohammadharunkhan3740

    Жыл бұрын

    एकदम ईमानदार विश्लेषण।

  • @vidyasagar1583

    @vidyasagar1583

    5 ай бұрын

    Right. विशेष धर्म और वर्ग के प्रति आकर्षित नजर आती है. साक्ष्य से अधिक कहानियां ज्यादा है l

  • @uday8008

    @uday8008

    5 ай бұрын

    जो सत्य है वो अपराजित है साक्ष्य यही है की यह देश काश्मीर से कन्या कुमारी हिन्दू कुश से बर्मा तक एक ही सभ्यता का ग्वाह है

  • @r_p_134

    @r_p_134

    4 ай бұрын

    Discovery of india is not completed till today.

  • @OnkarShrma
    @OnkarShrma Жыл бұрын

    This book must be add to #UPSC and judiciary syllabus. Our Beauracracy need to know the real history of India.

  • @myvlogs638

    @myvlogs638

    Жыл бұрын

    पहले ncert में डाल दे फिर upsc में डालेंगे

  • @lata633

    @lata633

    Жыл бұрын

    Aur apne sickular log mastishk hi khol le aur apne logon ke virodh na jayen!! Sapne toh ham dekh hi sakthe hain. Asal mein yeh 15-20 saal mein haavi ho jayenge. Apne bhai bandhu aaram se so rahen hain.

  • @nav9005

    @nav9005

    Жыл бұрын

    No need to add fake hinditva narrative books

  • @snehasemwal7362

    @snehasemwal7362

    Жыл бұрын

    @@lata633 chalo kuch log to jaag rahe hain.. Bus apne dharam k liye usee tarah kattar rahiye jaise muslims apne dharam k liye hain.. Humare bhai to so rahe hain aur kayar ho chuke hain, ab hum Hindu ladkiyo ko fir bharat ka Sanatan dharam apni takat se bachana hoga, jaise maa durga ne Sanatan ko bachaya tha..

  • @venkateshamurthy2568

    @venkateshamurthy2568

    11 ай бұрын

    Yes, yes judiciary should know Bharateeya history & culture.

  • @samyak128
    @samyak128 Жыл бұрын

    Meenakshi ji is one of the scholars whose shoulders we are all resting on. Not to mention that they sacrificed success in their professional lives (due to organized persecution) and paid the price for the truth. My pranam to her and others like her

  • @HelloThere-dk3me

    @HelloThere-dk3me

    Жыл бұрын

    'Vishal Mangalwadi & john anderson .....views on a english youtube channles are ;; INdia is devided & backword becaiuse of hindus !! comments were thankyou for telling us ...link kzread.info/dash/bejne/aIqtrK5wlK_Hd5M.html&lc=UgyG8yhfO-v4_g-Bn514AaABAg

  • @hunnysingh7547

    @hunnysingh7547

    Жыл бұрын

    U believe in Buddhism

  • @paldhakariya1947

    @paldhakariya1947

    Жыл бұрын

    Itni bdi sabyeta ka sabut kha he madam Likh to kbi bhi skte he

  • @chitrasingh9234

    @chitrasingh9234

    Жыл бұрын

    ​@@paldhakariya1947first you need to be archaeologist

  • @footjn532

    @footjn532

    Жыл бұрын

    ​@@paldhakariya1947 Arre Meena bhai Reservation Enjoy karo...Garv se kaho Hindu hu...

  • @ReligioCritic
    @ReligioCritic Жыл бұрын

    I wish people like her and Vikram Sampath write history syllabus for NCERT.

  • @veerendrapratapsingh8719

    @veerendrapratapsingh8719

    Жыл бұрын

    So that history can be fked forever,British at least Rajputs ko Scythian maante the,inhone to 8th century tak laa Diya aur uper se pratiharas ko gujjar bana diya ,kuch din RSS ki building se thode instructions ke baad naa sidhe 15th century tak le aaye ..

  • @sanjaybhatt60

    @sanjaybhatt60

    Жыл бұрын

    ​@@veerendrapratapsingh8719 unke pas proofs hain bhai, vo apni marji se nahi bol rahin kuch bhi, aap b book likh ke khandan karo inka,

  • @ReligioCritic

    @ReligioCritic

    Жыл бұрын

    ​@@veerendrapratapsingh8719 Issi liye maine kahan hai ki Vikram Sampath jaise aur historians ko bhi include kro... aur main toh kehta hoon Virendra Singh Rathore ko bhi, sbko include kro nayi history panel mei...Meenakshi ji ki main har baat se agree nhi krta....Mere hisaab se Rajput word Rajputra se bana hai jo ki Ramayan aur Mahabharat mei bhi hai...Rajput Vedic Kshatriya hain magar ye bhi sach hai ki baad mei aaye kuch logon ko jaise ki Shveta Huns ko bhi Rajput status mil gya...Aur rahi baat pratiharas ki, toh uspe mera ye kehna hai ki uss time Rajput ek class tha caste nhi, issi liye aur bhi bht log iss class ka hissa ban jaate thhe...Ma'am bhi yhi keh rhi hain ki Gujjar bhi Rajput hi hain, yaani ki Pratiharas Gujjar thhe toh wo automatically Rajput bhi ho gye na? Aur bhai rahi baat RSS ki toh wo toh waise bhi apne schools mein padhate hain ki Prithviraj Chauhan kabhi haare hi nhi aur galat history padhate hain...Agar RSS kuch kregi bhi toh wo Rajputs ke favor mei hi kregi...

  • @veerendrapratapsingh8719

    @veerendrapratapsingh8719

    Жыл бұрын

    @@ReligioCritic arre Bhai har jagah politically correct hone ke liye aisi historical blunders nhi karni chahiye,hoons as per Manu were fallen Kshatriyas,but unke baad me Rajput ya kisi anya caste me absorption ka source nhi milte(jitne hoon surname aaaj dikh bhi jayenge toh wo gujjar hote hai aur unka asli clan name dusra hota hai),infact unka decline Aulikaras ke samay ho jata hai,many Rajput clans originate from ancient clans ye bhi sach hai but bahut si hai jo main hone ke saath sath ancient hai jinki history pre hunic era hai(ex-Bhatti,and Yadu of mathura),bhai gujjar ek pastoralist caste hai,they nothing to do with rajputs,wo ek alag caste/tribe hai,Gurjara pratihara ek Dynasty thi caste nhi,Gurjara ek state/country than western India jisme different caste exist karti thi(Gurjara Brahmans(Nagar),vaishya,sunar,suthar,kshatriya),Pratihars were among the prominent kshatriya clan of gurjara country (others were Chavda,Solanki,Guhilot and Badgujar), pastoralist Gujjars were among the pastoralist caste(others were Banjara and Ahirs) of Gurjara country, Gurjara was said to 100ds of millions of cows in the 3-4th century,Gujjar pastoralist were among pastoral community,not Kshatriyas....

  • @ReligioCritic

    @ReligioCritic

    Жыл бұрын

    @@veerendrapratapsingh8719 I am not trying to be politically correct or anything, here is a small 6min video by Abhijit Chavda about the Chavda Dynasty, he mentions that Chavda Dynasty had Shveta Hunnic descent. kzread.info/dash/bejne/ZqZ4xpOKYtHWYLA.html

  • @vicky7100
    @vicky7100 Жыл бұрын

    Meenakshi mam held the Nationalist fort when the left ecosystem was dominant in india … Its really coming of age that she’s getting her due as a great Historian.

  • @SmallusDicckus
    @SmallusDicckus Жыл бұрын

    I love how our Arihant bhai gets all fan boy in front of Dr Meenakshi Jain, and she replies like our school teacher, Let me finish up my point first. Arihant you are a gem in indian podcast i love your patience and your questions, and Dr Meenakshi Jain is an ocean of knowledge. Love and respect to both of you🙏

  • @HelloThere-dk3me

    @HelloThere-dk3me

    Жыл бұрын

    'Vishal Mangalwadi & john anderson .....views on a english youtube channles are ;; INdia is devided & backword becaiuse of hindus !! comments were thankyou for telling us ...link kzread.info/dash/bejne/aIqtrK5wlK_Hd5M.html&lc=UgyG8yhfO-v4_g-Bn514AaABAg

  • @rajivranjankumar3316

    @rajivranjankumar3316

    Жыл бұрын

    Jai bharat n Jai shree Ram

  • @kpdwivedi1672
    @kpdwivedi1672 Жыл бұрын

    We need many people like Ms meenakshi jain to carry on the work she has undertaken. I appreciate her efforts in this respect.

  • @ayushimishra1912

    @ayushimishra1912

    5 ай бұрын

    True

  • @swapnavarkhedi
    @swapnavarkhedi Жыл бұрын

    Minakshiji ke liye shata shata pranaam 🙏🏻. Hope many people read her books to get the right info and leatn right history. She is the treasure trove of Indian history

  • @Dr2689

    @Dr2689

    Жыл бұрын

    Yes correct

  • @kanahyatiwari1315

    @kanahyatiwari1315

    5 ай бұрын

    Aap bramhakumaris join kariy fir mount abu jaiye. Shanti sukh paiye.

  • @pinakpanibhattacharjee87
    @pinakpanibhattacharjee87 Жыл бұрын

    Hindu dharm mein wapas ana Bangladeshi hinduo mein bhi bahut logo ne kiya tha. Those hindus had to read and recite quran for the fear of muslims after being forcefully converted to islam. Even do namaz at mosques. And this incidents of families have also been published in newspaper. After bangladesh was freed from pathan and pakhtuns, those hindus came back to hinduism discarding islam. And being an east bengali this stories we heard from our ancestors.

  • @shivamgurjar9391
    @shivamgurjar93916 ай бұрын

    I am a proud Gurjar and I knew about this pratihar meaning even before i watched this episode but i was not 100% sure about it. Thank you for providing this information. Jai hind 🇮🇳

  • @harpreetkasana9863
    @harpreetkasana9863 Жыл бұрын

    I m a gujjar Kasana Gotra from northern Punjab. It’s fascinating that our Kul Purohit still writes us Kushan or khushaney in Sanskrit. Even today Gujjar population resides in a kushan kingdom map. Our Kul Purohit still worships our Sati Mata. Raja Jaipal Khatana hindushahi was from Khatana gotra of Gujjars

  • @missionaryavart113

    @missionaryavart113

    Жыл бұрын

    you are hindu my brother

  • @surendergupta7123

    @surendergupta7123

    Жыл бұрын

    When we go much deeper in history, we would find that all the communities of Sanatan Dharma are very much related to each other even the converted people too that were forced to took up Abhrahmic faith.🧐

  • @jujharsingh5461

    @jujharsingh5461

    10 ай бұрын

    Raja jaipal wasn't gujjar or khatana of any kind lol

  • @Bhakti_spirit108

    @Bhakti_spirit108

    10 ай бұрын

    ❤❤ gurjar brother ❤❤

  • @Traveler55188

    @Traveler55188

    10 ай бұрын

    @@jujharsingh5461 exactly and Gujjars were mostly nomadic herders.

  • @akshatsolanki33
    @akshatsolanki33 Жыл бұрын

    Ma'am👣, neither my own ppl nor this government recognize or adhere to any of your contribution you made in these decades , your books gonna give strong argument support to the young one's 💫

  • @HelloThere-dk3me

    @HelloThere-dk3me

    Жыл бұрын

    'Vishal Mangalwadi & john anderson .....views on a english youtube channles are ;; INdia is devided & backword becaiuse of hindus !! comments were thankyou for telling us ...link kzread.info/dash/bejne/aIqtrK5wlK_Hd5M.html&lc=UgyG8yhfO-v4_g-Bn514AaABAg

  • @anoopirs
    @anoopirs Жыл бұрын

    आप दोनों की चर्चा अद्भुत है। इतिहास की सही समझ सभी तक पहुँचाने हेतु आप सभी का सादर आभार..💐🙏

  • @iXpress
    @iXpress Жыл бұрын

    Thanks to scholars like Dr Meenakshi Jain who's work are redefining Indian history with high standard of research & fact based perspective. Great work in service of Bharat Mata 🚩

  • @aliflaila905
    @aliflaila905 Жыл бұрын

    ये तो सच है कि जन्मागत ब्रहामणों ने कर्म करनें की स्वतंत्रता को समाप्त कर जन्मागत बना कर एक बंद और जकडन वाले समाज को बनाया

  • @krmusic3523

    @krmusic3523

    5 ай бұрын

    ये ब्राह्मणों ने बनाया तो बाकी वर्ण के लोग कमजोर थे क्या? जो विरोध न कर सके। सबका अपना अपना स्वार्थ था।

  • @NikVilluri
    @NikVilluri Жыл бұрын

    Thank you for all you do Arihant and team

  • @bhuwaneshwarprasad6424
    @bhuwaneshwarprasad6424 Жыл бұрын

    Thanks Meenskshi Mam, you are champion of Indian culture and civilisation.

  • @sunilhardas5273
    @sunilhardas5273 Жыл бұрын

    भारतको समझना सनातन धर्म संस्क्रुति को समझना इसके लिये देशभ्रमण पठन चिंतन मनन और विद्वानोंसे संवाद आवश्यक. धर्मग्रंथोंमें भूगोल व खगोल दोनो का ज्ञान मिलेगा. इतने बडे विषयको लेने के लिये आपका अभिनंदन!

  • @lata633
    @lata633 Жыл бұрын

    Meenakshi ji’s point of 60% tax going to army resonates even today in Baakasthan. It is their majhab’s teaching. Everything she mentions from her extensive study of historical books and references rings absolutely true, like this 60% of Hindu tax payers money being used to oppress them. It just transformed to oppress their own firkas as no Hindus are left to abuse in majority of Pak.

  • @azwraith9973
    @azwraith9973 Жыл бұрын

    The Mughal Oppression of Farmers and the Mansabdari System is so reminiscent of the Political System of Modern Day Pakistan. 1. Power consolidated among few elites. 2. Hierarchy among elites is: military followed by judiciary/clergy and finally civil bureaucracy. 3. Population subjected to backbreaking extortion through taxes or bribes. 4. Elites having massive land holdings with their own private army and private jails. 5. Extravagant lifestyle and spending of elites during times of stress(e.g.:Shahabuddin/Shah Jahan was building the Taj Mahal during one of the worst famines in India. The Pakistani Elites are also throwing off wealth in marriage ceremonies, imported cars and foreign coffee brands during this time of extreme economic stress) What do you guys think? So many similarities and remarkably similar consequences. A detailed study should be conducted on this. This will help us understand the Mughal Rule and it's impact better.

  • @purabi123

    @purabi123

    Жыл бұрын

    Today's Ms are the Bad Hs. They committed the worst of crimes in humanity and blamed it on Brahmins. Ms are trying to preach adharm as the word of God.

  • @DiatomAlgae
    @DiatomAlgae Жыл бұрын

    🙏Dr Meenakshi ji & Arihant. Thank you. Excellent podcast. I hope TV shows will be made based on this book.

  • @dandsamladi3332
    @dandsamladi33328 ай бұрын

    मीनाक्षी जी को उनके लेखन के लिए हिंदुत्ववादियोंने बडा सम्मान करना चाहिए।

  • @nitovatorsnitj
    @nitovatorsnitj Жыл бұрын

    Lets hope that there are student historians under the likes of Meenakshi Jain ji, to take her legacy forward.

  • @SanatanRevival
    @SanatanRevival Жыл бұрын

    Eternally grateful for Meenakshi Ji 🙏 Arihant, you're creating - EVERGREEN CONTENT. Thank you to you too 🙏

  • @ckc4747
    @ckc4747 Жыл бұрын

    I have listened to all of recent Dr Jain's videos since I a video of her explanation of the Ayodhya judgement so many years ago. She continues to amaze me. Respect to this noble rishi. Thanks for brining Dr Jain back to your show Arihant. Your enthusiasm in this conversation shows! :)

  • @user-up2rw1dp2p
    @user-up2rw1dp2p5 ай бұрын

    सब धर्मों में पूजारी ,बाबा और मौलाना वर्ग समाज और नेताओं पर हावी रहता है तथा विभिन्न समाजिक वर्गों में बांट के रखते हैं ताकि उनकी दुकानें चलती रहें। धर्म, सम्प्रदाय, जातियां न मिल सकें, यही संस्थापकों, आचार्यों, बाबाओं,मठाधीशों, महंतों तथा वक्ताओं का ध्येय रहा।

  • @niihaanraajput4350
    @niihaanraajput4350 Жыл бұрын

    Wonderful narration of our history 🙏

  • @shubhamkumar6689
    @shubhamkumar6689 Жыл бұрын

    We are still fighting the same evil forces which our ancestors fought for centuries.

  • @NativeVsColonial

    @NativeVsColonial

    Жыл бұрын

    And we will keep fighting this war for upcoming centuries too, if we don't learn from them and move our defensive mentality to offensive. We have to fight wars in their territory before they come and poke us in our territory.

  • @shubhamkumar6689

    @shubhamkumar6689

    Жыл бұрын

    @@NativeVsColonial we have a new problem too, these evil forces have sympathisers from our own community and they're doing psychological warfare.

  • @shubhamkumar6689

    @shubhamkumar6689

    Жыл бұрын

    @Stardust Meant To Shine True, centuries old struggle and still we have many people who are confused about the real threats. This reminds me of ex-kgb Yuri bezmenov's video about subversion of population.

  • @ameya7723

    @ameya7723

    Жыл бұрын

    AMBEDKAR is the name of that evil force

  • @shubhamkumar6689

    @shubhamkumar6689

    Жыл бұрын

    @@ameya7723 No, I'm talking about invaders.

  • @sdmamansood9687
    @sdmamansood9687 Жыл бұрын

    Lot of Pranams to Meenakshi ji! Thanks a lot for bringing her on the podcast again!

  • @sanjeevkaushik4272
    @sanjeevkaushik427210 ай бұрын

    Excellent knowledge imparted through this episode.

  • @ritakhanna5432
    @ritakhanna5432 Жыл бұрын

    Eye opening discussions..Thanks Vaad.

  • @asitbaranchatterjee2098
    @asitbaranchatterjee2098 Жыл бұрын

    It is really very informative. I was looking such type of book,very soon I am going to purchase this. Thank you very much..🙏

  • @vijayakolpe7837
    @vijayakolpe78379 ай бұрын

    This intervew is unveiling most of the cobwebs entangled in our Ancient History . Very scholarly writing and profound knowledge of Our hidden Historical facts and truths are open for wider perspectives .....Where can i get this book ? plz provide details.

  • @ausgang9495
    @ausgang9495 Жыл бұрын

    Meenakshi Jain is a national treasure.

  • @Decoloniality_Bharat
    @Decoloniality_Bharat8 ай бұрын

    Please read this type of Historians 1) Vikram sampath 2) R.C. Majumdar 3) Minakshi Jain 4) Sanjeev sanyal 5) J.sai.deepak

  • @anoopamsingh3135
    @anoopamsingh3135 Жыл бұрын

    वस्तुतः धर्म सनातन है..धारण करने योग्य सद्गुण और सदाचरण ही धर्म है.

  • @pankajkumar-gc5sm

    @pankajkumar-gc5sm

    Жыл бұрын

    Jai mulniwasi😃

  • @siddharthavhad6893
    @siddharthavhad6893 Жыл бұрын

    Listening Dr Jain is like drinking amrut. Absolute bliss!

  • @nabangshusinha1519
    @nabangshusinha1519 Жыл бұрын

    I can literally listen to Dr. Jain for hours.

  • @jasodhasharma
    @jasodhasharma Жыл бұрын

    Amazing talk. Thank you for sharing it.

  • @kalidashgupta4455
    @kalidashgupta4455 Жыл бұрын

    Beautiful podcast with one of my favorite intellectual meenakshi Jaina ji

  • @adityash1041
    @adityash1041 Жыл бұрын

    Modi government must work in tandem with actual historians like Meenakshi Ma'am and Vikram Sampath to reinvigorate Indian pride and consciousness at the pan-India level. Old, colonized NCERT books need replacement and the clock is ticking fast.

  • @DynomRitOfficial
    @DynomRitOfficial9 ай бұрын

    Thankyou for the knowledge Dr Meenakshi Mam ❤⭐

  • @gopalkrishnamukerjea4319
    @gopalkrishnamukerjea43195 ай бұрын

    Dr. Minakshi Jain has done deep research, unbiased and true academic!

  • @leaderofmass
    @leaderofmass Жыл бұрын

    meenakshi mam is treasure of India❤ mam charan sparsh❤

  • @shikha505
    @shikha505 Жыл бұрын

    Once again bang on episode with Meenakshi Jain ji.. 🥰👏👏👏👏👏

  • @Iamkumarmihir
    @Iamkumarmihir5 ай бұрын

    Meenakshi mam you are genius, thank you for sharing truthful history about our nation, also thanks Vaad for this wonderful podcast 🙏🚩❤🙏

  • @veenasharma2304
    @veenasharma2304 Жыл бұрын

    बहुत बढ़िया। अच्छा लगा मीनाक्षी जैन मैम आपको यहां सुन कर।

  • @jigsaw2281
    @jigsaw2281 Жыл бұрын

    Kitni knowledge mili h dhanyawad

  • @thewittiewolf
    @thewittiewolf Жыл бұрын

    Meenakshi ma'am you are a true inspiration.

  • @vasudevanpayyurli318
    @vasudevanpayyurli318 Жыл бұрын

    Great attempt Meenakshi Mam. Your hardwork will remembered by all Indians. Will buy Your books to know more about our past history. Keep going All the best

  • @subodhsriwastva2341
    @subodhsriwastva234110 ай бұрын

    Great discussion 👍

  • @sandeepnath1744
    @sandeepnath1744 Жыл бұрын

    Very important discussion with lots of authentic information of our history…. Thanks a lot for enriching us 🙏

  • @dontwannabefound
    @dontwannabefound Жыл бұрын

    I know there’s a very Hindi-language centric view that sees anything in English as the devil. But there are a lot of Indian diaspora across the world that would benefit from what is being said here. These are people who don’t have the ability to learn Hindi, sons and daughters of migrants now settled abroad. Just saying there’s a huge opportunity to expand your reach as audience by simply making the clips with English subs Humble request 🙏🏽

  • @kumar3321
    @kumar33216 ай бұрын

    I have read Meenakshi Jain’s books, these are fantastics.👌❤️👍

  • @omjidwivedi4184
    @omjidwivedi4184 Жыл бұрын

    Bahut bahut dhanyawad is talk liye yeh aap hamare liye kiya .. sach esa aaj tak maine kabhi nahi suna

  • @anandshukla1730
    @anandshukla1730 Жыл бұрын

    While listening this discussion I was figuring out Google map that what we were and what we remained... Seriously its very painful 😣 we lost a lot😓

  • @hariomshukla1242
    @hariomshukla1242 Жыл бұрын

    Thank you meenakshi ji for your great work towards our culture and history🙏.....more power to you!

  • @vishvapradhan8476
    @vishvapradhan8476 Жыл бұрын

    Thank you for the discussion it was great discussion love to read the book

  • @globalpromo3212
    @globalpromo32124 ай бұрын

    Great coverage in your story👏

  • @bhagwandasjangde-yi3lc
    @bhagwandasjangde-yi3lc Жыл бұрын

    मेडम झूंठ बोल रही है कि संस्कृत भाषा ईसा से पूर्व की है।गलत रुप से जानकारी गपोड़ी रही है।

  • @Shyamkumar-bw9kw
    @Shyamkumar-bw9kw Жыл бұрын

    ज्ञान का तेज से दीप्त है मीनाक्षी अम्मा का मुखमंडल

  • @ArchanaSingh-fb1fq
    @ArchanaSingh-fb1fq5 ай бұрын

    Professor minaxchi jaenji aapko hriday se dhanyavaad mn ke uthal puthal hote sawalo ka barhi aatmiyta se mila 🙏🌺

  • @sv8362
    @sv83625 ай бұрын

    She is a genius ! It's so engrossing to hear her everytime !

  • @Dr2689
    @Dr2689 Жыл бұрын

    70 साल तक सच छुपाने वाले कोण है,,,, असली इतिहास कभी सामने नहीं आने दिया.. ना वीर विहीन थी भारत माँ ना वीरांगना विहीन.. बस.. धर्म कमजोर हुआ भेदभाव हुआ, कुछ अहंकारी आए और ये कमजोर हुआ

  • @pankajkumar-gc5sm

    @pankajkumar-gc5sm

    Жыл бұрын

    2000 साल तक manuwadiyon ne chhupaaya

  • @captainblackbody6350

    @captainblackbody6350

    10 ай бұрын

    Chankiye nhi peda kr bhae 😢 . .

  • @sudhakarwadiwa3426

    @sudhakarwadiwa3426

    9 ай бұрын

    70साल तक छुपाने की बात बचकना है. सभी लायब्ररी किताबोसे भरी पडी है, और किताबे छपने पर कभी बॅन नही रहा उस समय कोई फॅसिस्ट सरकार भी न ही थी.

  • @omsingh8625
    @omsingh8625 Жыл бұрын

    आपके काम को सभी ने सराहा है जो अनिर्वचानिय है।काश भारतीय जन इसका आत्मसात्।कर पाती सारे मतभेदों को भुलाकर। आपको शत शत नमन है।

  • @gpatekar
    @gpatekar5 ай бұрын

    What a great collection of knowledge is this!!🙏🏻🇮🇳

  • @nutanshelat
    @nutanshelat5 ай бұрын

    Very nice description of all ages of Hindustan

  • @vedashriram39
    @vedashriram39 Жыл бұрын

    Arihant you are just amazing. You have such an in depth knowledge. That's the reason such deeply impressionable people join you in your podcast. Love it. Tq young achiever. Meenakshi Ma'am is the light in the darkness that surrounds us. We can look back at our history with pride.

  • @Vaad

    @Vaad

    Жыл бұрын

    Thank you ma'am for such kind words. You are right. Meenakshi ma’am is a true rock star.

  • @male.3437

    @male.3437

    Жыл бұрын

    @@Vaad kya sir dar gye kya, खलिस्तानी nahi hu, marathi sikh hu aur sanatani se pyar karta hu..... Lord hunumanji ka bhakt hu..... Aap achha karya kar rhe he...

  • @vedashriram39

    @vedashriram39

    Жыл бұрын

    @@Vaad I am a woman. ☺

  • @Dr2689

    @Dr2689

    Жыл бұрын

    ​@@vedashriram39 yes he used ma'am for you as women

  • @iloveindia2846
    @iloveindia2846 Жыл бұрын

    I am shocked by this discussion and disgusted by these leftist who have given us a black & imaginary history

  • @bobinpune

    @bobinpune

    Жыл бұрын

    History is history. It's not left or right! If we lost a fight, there's no meaning in denying we lost. We need to analyze why we lost and improve. Today BJP RSS are using religion and history as a political tool for vote bank. They are bashing today's Muslims and calling them anti national. This is sheer opportunism for vote bank politics.

  • @kadambaritripathi3995
    @kadambaritripathi39959 ай бұрын

    Bahut accha likha h ma'am ne, hmare pass to time ni hota book padhne ko but es channel k madhyam se suna krte h. Thnks

  • @shailjaverma6663
    @shailjaverma6663 Жыл бұрын

    बहुत अच्छा प्रयास 🙏👌👌🇮🇳🕉️

  • @prasaddurga3450
    @prasaddurga3450 Жыл бұрын

    Thank you for such a informative interview. Every Indian should read this book

  • @Pushpkamat
    @Pushpkamat Жыл бұрын

    Awesome episode..Thank you a lot for this..each one of us should know our correct history

  • @AdityaSingh-wj2rx
    @AdityaSingh-wj2rx11 ай бұрын

    Truly inspiring ma'am

  • @manishbindal2839
    @manishbindal28397 ай бұрын

    Excellent work she is doing. सादर नमन

  • @avinash7335
    @avinash7335 Жыл бұрын

    Hello Arihant Bhai, one factual correction needed here, Raja Maan Singh appointment as a Governor of Rohtas is not situated in India rather it’s situated in Pakistan now and it is known as Rohtas Fort.

  • @kapa5970
    @kapa5970 Жыл бұрын

    Madam you are missing the most vital point, Main reason of defeat of Hindus was that Hindus were used to Dharmyuddh whereas Muslims fought Adharmyuddh, no morality, rapes, killing of all ages including infants, dhokha, lies, putting cows in front of own armies etc

  • @sugatabose3691
    @sugatabose36915 ай бұрын

    Koshish = Pracheshta Sadiyo = yugo Zaroori = avashyak Political = rajnaitik Soch = chintan Welcome = abhivaadan Bilkul = avashya Fundamental = mool Cultural unity = sanskritik ekta Sabooth = pramaan

  • @Madhura1818
    @Madhura1818 Жыл бұрын

    One thing I have always noticed among Indians that many of them are full of pride that their ancestors were not Indians and they belong to somewhere else. Being an Indian native is a kind of "gaali".

  • @jyotivyas9286
    @jyotivyas9286 Жыл бұрын

    Thank you Meenakshi Mam..👌💐😊😢😊Thank you Vaad....

  • @mohag24
    @mohag24 Жыл бұрын

    I was so waiting for this talk wd Meenakshi ji....

  • @williamdixon1512
    @williamdixon1512 Жыл бұрын

    Despite many flaws still the idea of unity in diversity is appreciable.

  • @LNJHA
    @LNJHA7 ай бұрын

    Very good Sambad.Informative&Educative. Thanks.

Келесі