Rolling Thunder Revue Explained by Dylan and Ginsberg / Live Footage of "Knockin' on Heaven's Door"
Музыка
This is a video I edited together using footage from "Rolling Thunder Revue: A Bob Dylan Story by Martin Scorsese," a Netflix documentary. If you haven't seen it yet, do yourself a favor and WATCH IT. These clips were taken from the end of the film.
Ginsberg's abstract monologue gave me chills the first time I watched it. It made me sad knowing that this benediction was the close of something so beautiful, a tour that will never be replicated again. But it was also an uplifting reminder about what we can learn from the Rolling Thunder Revue:
“You, who saw it all, or who saw flashes and fragments, take from us some example, try and get yourselves together, clean up your act, find your community, pick up on some kind of redemption of your own consciousness, become mindful of your own friends, your own work, your own proper meditation, your own art, your own beauty, go out and make it for your own Eternity”
-Allen Ginsberg, 1976
Пікірлер: 110
That message from Ginsberg at the end really sums up what I believe all artists/humans strive for; to be true to oneself and one's art for eternity. A lovely sentiment to live by.
@henryulric
Жыл бұрын
Ginsberg did hit strong with that message. Love him.
I get chills every time I hear "mama wipe the blood off of my face.."
So cool to see Dylan and McGuinn letting their freak flags fly.
I was hanging out in Vermont in a small town, singing and playing some music in a small bar. Some young teenage girls were there as well who said they saw a poster in the laundromat saying Bob Dylan was going to be giving a concert in a few days. I looked at my boyfriend; he looked at me. We were overjoyed for a second, but then said, "Nah. Can't be." Right.
My favorite part is at 1:35 when Scarlett walks into the picture, looking beautiful, and puts a faint smile on, and starts nodding her head to the music and you know she is saying "yeah, I am on stage with Dylan and this is great music we are making." Best performances are always when the musicians are enjoying themselves.
What remains of that tour, Bob is not nothing .....as u said......what remains is some fantastic versions of timeless songs that u wrote that have touched the hearts and souls of many and many more to still to come.....
I've just seen the rolling thunder revue film....very interesting....I wish i would have been there...but not even born yet.... If time travellin would be possible, I would go to Bob Dylan concerts 1966 in Newcastle, Royal Albert Hall and Paris, also I would see the Rolling Thunder Revue... So actually I can only dream about it.....
It’s completely appropriate for Ol’ Baby Blue Eyes to say of Rolling Thunder that nothing remains... just ashes. He always knew when to strike a match 🔥and start anew
@dickslayer111
4 жыл бұрын
Geoff Strum nicely put. Neil would tell us lessons in life maybe are only castles burning. Bob would remind us that sometimes those fires need to be placed. As if we’re the Fahrenheit 451 firemen in our own lives. Go start anew...
@ferociousgumby
3 жыл бұрын
You mean, those eyes that are bluer than robins' eggs?
Yeah, it was a long time ago, but the night of the concert I thought I would never again see so much talent on one stage at the same time. Thanks to my neighbor Bill R. who phoned me up and said simply, Dylan tonight at the gardens, when can you leave ?
Bob is totally hypnotic, his eyes are burning. Roger is under Bob’s spell. He looks frantic. Rolling Thunder will be my first stop, when project Time Traveling is ready for regular people, not only scientists. 🕊🙏🌎💕💜
@marynelson3067
3 жыл бұрын
@Britt Beck I was at “Hard Rain”’ May 23, 1976 Fort Collins, Colorado about three feet from the stage ❤️🔥❤️
@charliern
Жыл бұрын
Idk, I think it's mutual. They're both hypnotised by the performance. It's a 2 way connection
This is beautifully and lovingly put together. Wow. Thank you.
I love that tour and every single thing about it . Incredible incredible and very powerful thank you for sharing BOB
Lovely clip. You keep making my weekends better! I love that part where Dylan pauses to admire Roger McGuinn seemingly mesmerized by his finger picking. Fantastic
Thank you for this...the blessing from Mr. Ginsberg was wonderful.
Its so funny. This was literally just a tour and we give it so much importance.
You are the gift that keeps delivering... haha but really you give us a lot of fantastic stuff, thanks mate 👊
Thanks for this Swingin!❤️
I fell in love with Alan Ginsberg and how can nothing exist when it still moves me so?
Another gem... I can't thank you enough!
@not2tees
4 жыл бұрын
Yes, appreciation for Swingin' Pig does arrive for me, too, after repeated benefitting and shaking my head at these amazing videos. Subscribed today.
wow - hard ti believe i was fortunate enough that I was at the 4th show 11/2/75 in Lowell MA - Sooo remember the Scarlett violin dominating the set -
proud to have witnessed these times and nice to see it on screen now those where wild days belive me but i love it better now doing the weeds mending a fuse having a glass of wine🤪or two
Thank you as always you are the best
This was such a great documentary
Well expressed by that bald, bespectacled man. He has a way with words. Should be a writer or a poet or something.
@gerrycurran8966
3 жыл бұрын
Nice one. Ha Ha.
the ashes comment broke my heart, but thank goodness Ginsberg patched it up for me.
First time Dylan does crazy eyes
It was a cool week in Plymouth when he was getting ready to start the tour
I loved that tour
Allen was our true voice, our fire source, the VOICE OF AMERICA, our Love God, the Poet Laureate Emeritus of all our time. We can all bow down. What a whirlwind, a vortex that tour was/is still. With Ginsberg/Dylan we certainly got another Pound/Eliot.
This one gets me every time...
I never saw any of this tour, but read all the coverage in the Village Voice as it was happening, and later the Larry Sloman (?) book about it. It was a quite thick paperback, but about all I remember was a story about him asking Dylan in the "Sad Eyed Lady of the Lowlands" lyric, when he wrote "my warehouse eyes my Arabian drums" ... did Dylan mean "eyes" as a noun or a verb. I don't think Dylan answered; I don't think he even had an answer. I guess I always imagined probably an eye roll was his answer.
@ferociousgumby
3 жыл бұрын
What has always galled me is how everyone wonders, slack-jawed, "WHO did he write Sad Eyed Lady of the Lowlands for? Who was it really about, anyway? Guess it must have been Joanie, huh?" TAKE THE WORD *_LOWLANDS._* REMOVE THE "LA" FROM THE CENTRE OF IT. Put a pencil over the LA and cover it up. OK, WHAT DOES IT SPELL?????
This whole documentary is on Netflix for those interested!
Hard to know who’s madder - Bob or Roger. ! Saw Roger once in a converted church in Glasgow. Pretty good gig. Dylan has the most beautiful eyes.
Good clip.. Remember it well
PEEAAAKKKIIINNNGGGG!!!!! My boys are peaking.
Bob ...as ya"ll know.... Always had and always will have ....a way with words .....sooooooooo cool ....
Face paints look brilliant! I bet inspired by Bowie and glam!
I was 15 and saw the Night of the Hurricane--Astrodome.
I believe this about Rolling Thunder - that Bob who had been married with children, living a settled down home life - wanted to re-visit his past - because as a family man he was not living the life like the gypsy performing musician he had in his youth - so once again friends, folks from his past were back in his life again, traveling the country, often Bob driving the bus -briefly rekindling a romance with Joan perhaps. It would be as if you could go back in time and re-visit your past. Bottom line: there are some really fine performances preserved on film.
That beautiful new verse McGuinn sings, does anyone know if he or Dylan wrote it?
Bob Dylan dedicated the song 'Desolation Row' to Allen Ginsberg while playing a concert in Canada in 1997 , who had died the night before . Ginsberg for Dylan is more than a friend , a poet or a philosofer . '' I first met Bob at a party at the Eight Street Book Shop , and he invited me to go on tour with him . I ended up not going , but , boy , if I'd know then what I know now , I'd have gone like a flash . He'd probably have put me on stage with him .'' Allen Ginsberg ( when met a Dylan in New York , early 1960's)
4 жыл бұрын
I've met and talked with both Dylan and Ginsburg. Both were very nice. Ginsburg even told me a Dylan story. Lovely memories. Allen is dead. People on the left now are a bore. Against all they used to be for. Dylan totally distanced from the left and its obsessions. Still just an artist. Was the "voice" of something else. Thank God!
@SteveH4es
4 жыл бұрын
John Desmond can you expand of him leaving the left?
@blackcrow7049
4 жыл бұрын
@ Thanks for the answer . Already now I' ve seen it after 4 months (thanks KZread) . For me Ginsberg and Dylan are big names , It's not easy talking about only with journalists references or even their own works , because many Times , the person and the artist are living together but in differents worlds . I love both worlds , trying not to judge one or another . It was a pleasure knows your real history about that Meeting with Bob and Allen . Regards.
@GD-me2lv
4 жыл бұрын
John Desmond I never categorized Dylan as left or right. Such limited thinking demeans his literature. I never thought he identified with the left. I think he has always identified with the reality of the human condition. Period.
@lillynietz17
3 жыл бұрын
Yeah, there was A reason Bob sang That song ,That night.....That song was absolutely inspired by the Poetry of Allen Ginsberg! This has been affirmed by Dylan himself....They were quite close...and if you've watched the great documentary "Don't Look Back"...Allen appears with Bob on his first tour of London '64...Footage of a movie directed by BOB.. (Renaldo & Clara circa '77)...show Bob & Allen visiting Jack Kerouac's grave in Lowell Mass....He would show up in Bob's place in the village and literally record music with him, that has been released commercially... Listen....you might SEE!... Read a little bit of Ginsberg and....................
Those crazy McGuinn eyes!!!!!
Is that Jackie Earle Haley (Kelly from Bad News Bears) as one of the tour assistants? Sure looks like him at .37 seconds and .45 seconds. Great stuff.
@mikelabomusic7782
4 жыл бұрын
Not JEH.
Ashes... not true. It rings and rings and rings, my children are a part of it and we’re making it a part of our own eternity.
👍😊❤️
Every time I see Ginsberg my skin crawls.
@Rilez616
4 жыл бұрын
What did he do
@Rilez616
4 жыл бұрын
@Joe Lleyton oh right wtf
Please can some one write the lyric of this veresion of knocking on heavens door?
@peterwalker8316
3 жыл бұрын
Yeah it's really interesting - the new lyrics fit the Rolling thunder theme. Plus eternity. Here we go: Mama wipe the blood from my face, I can't see through it any more.... Mama I can can't hear the thunder roll, Echoing down from God's distant shore, Can't hear it comin for my soul, I feel I'm knocking on heavens door.
@peterwalker8316
3 жыл бұрын
Yeah it's really interesting - the new lyrics fit the Rolling thunder theme. Plus eternity. Here we go: Mama wipe the blood from my face, I can't see through it any more.... Mama I can can't hear the thunder roll, Echoing down from God's distant shore, Can't hear it comin for my soul, I feel I'm knocking on heavens door.
@valentinocaruso9282
3 жыл бұрын
@@peterwalker8316 I want to know the third line of the first part
@lebenz29
Жыл бұрын
@@valentinocaruso9282 “I need someone to talk to in a new hiding place, feel like I’m looking at heaven’s door.” However, on the other video posted with the fan audio, it’s slightly shorter (and indecipherable), something like “I need to relate and a new hiding place.”
thank you i didnt know. maybe i forgot. :)
Time is the real enemy
Ashes are as sacred as jewels
Think bob and Roger, are on the devil's dandruff 😎
Ashes
👏👏👏👏🇧🇷🇧🇷👍
Ginsberg is truly nuts - does he ever talk sense?
@lillynietz17
3 жыл бұрын
Really?....READ A BOOK!
Was that Mick Ronson at 0:40?
@LoosedSage-yi5pl
4 жыл бұрын
Yep
I’m 65 and I’m a musician too but Never understood this mans talent! Different frequency garbage!
Has he got a winter wedding bouquet stuck in his hat?
The ass live was n my heart ❤️
I wouldn't take the "ash comment" that seriously, Bob also said, it's been so long since he wasn't even born at that time. I think he's more interested in the present and the future
@kennethbarber438
2 жыл бұрын
you never know how the past will turn out
It doesn’t matter in the present does it plus as per usual it was selfishly taken credit for by the big name when the real im put musically came from a guys who is dead leaving that dead mans family without his heart felt work being rewarded.
It’s not ashes to me..
1:12 i remember this striking me how they made their eyes so wide and scary so i tried it with people i knew as a social experiment.. people thought i was scary or crazy or scared it was really funny and interesting for me but i do not recommend it!!
@MaryLou222
3 жыл бұрын
Did you do it in like regular conversations with people?
@claymationwaves
3 жыл бұрын
@@MaryLou222 i went too deep and now i am done, i do not recommend trying to turn life into a social experiment.. i started when i was 12 and now i am 31 i live normally among you now..
@simon-ym1iw
Жыл бұрын
this is the funniest shit ive red
Not for me . Good memories with friends here and lost to time
Ја креирам во Скопје,Македонија..Нешто ме натера да не влезам на концертот на Дилан..веб на пола километар во Гази Баба...и не го ни памтам дождот после концертот .... Ме потсети на него пријател..што цела вечер се сеќавам дека ме тражеше и не се сеќавам дал ме најде
Lieber Bobby, bei Ginsburg ist es vielleicht ganz einfach so, dass ich wegrennen würde, weil mir sein Gesicht so unangenehm ist.
Darin ist etwas gierig-geiles, das mich absolut abstößt. Nichts wie weg...!
Mcguinn is a weird guy
Drug abuse alcohol abuse deep reading interest the darkest books on the occult which led Dylan to search for Christianity.. he hated this time period because it was one extreme to the other which I think he finds a marring and painful time in his career and life, who wouldnt
@SwinginPig
4 жыл бұрын
douglas jardine Hard to say. IMO, if he really didn’t like it, he wouldn’t have looked back at it at all in this movie. He had some wild stories to tell (not all true, but entertaining regardless).
@claymationwaves
4 жыл бұрын
Yah he was fucked up after his divorce and it affected his decisions for a while.. then the American Christian boom.. either way we are all just humbly into guitar religion now....
@shanehunter4274
4 жыл бұрын
@@SwinginPig What is wrong with you? Why do you deny the truth just so it fits your unreality? You don't know how Dylan felt...then or now.And why do you keep taking my replies out of the video chats?
@SwinginPig
4 жыл бұрын
Shane Hunter huh? I never remove comments. They might be flagged by KZread, then they go to my spam which I don’t check. What are you saying, exactly?
@shanehunter4274
4 жыл бұрын
@@SwinginPig sorry, I thought that because this is your sight you were removing my comments. My comment was removed three times in one of the videos and their was no cursing or saying anything mean to anyone.......sorry again...my bad.
It actually was a bad tour. His management wanted Dylan to play stadiums. The tour lost tons of revenue and was slowly becoming a burden. They played mostly on the east coast then as they were traveling around the tour was hemorrhaging and was losing steam. Small clubs weren't even selling out as most Dylan fans had moved on from him and his style of music. Early Dylan is phenomenal it was new and exciting between 63 and 66 Dylan was at his very best singing and writing but once he left in 66 and abandoned his fans because his ego was hurt when they turned their backs on him when he went Electric and rightfully so as his electric sound was God awful and his harmonica sound was just terrible and his lack of experience fronting a back up band really showed. After going electric he should of taken the rest of 65 off and concentrated on fronting a band making sure his sound he wanted was perfected but his management wanted $$$ so they pushed him out to do concerts with Dylan changing some of his best songs ( only a few years old) to electric and sounding poorly and already with a mob mentality fan base that hated that he went electric. If only he waited out the rest of 65 and worked on his new sound and gave his fan base some time to settle down things could have been better for all. Playing acoustic for the 1st half and then electric the 2nd was insane. If he had been given more time and he played a full electric set things might have been different
@dude6894
2 жыл бұрын
"If only he waited out the rest of 65 ..." he might still be packing venues today, 56 years later. What a mistep.
Did you hear that, "Swingin Pig"? Did you hear what Allen said? Pretty sure you didn't. I'll paraphrase: MAKE YOUR OWN ART AND FOCUS ON THAT. Leave Bob and all these clips and snippets to Bob and the people involved. Go make something of your own. Bob released what he wanted people to see. Making entire channels to his throwaway content is disrespectful and intrusive and invasive and just generally shitty.
@anjeniuous
3 жыл бұрын
Shut the fuck up