That "off note" makes it sound so much better

Pancham Da is composer of Millennium and his guitarist Bhanu Gupta and Bhupinder Singh made many songs memorable under the guidance of Pancham Da.

RD Burman sir was the greatest of all time ❤️

The reason a seemingly wrong key worked for #RDBurman in Chingari Koi Bhadke is because it becomes a metaphor for the wrong notes that the lyrics of the song suggest in the life of the protagonist played by Rajesh Khanna in Amar Prem. This is the magic of how music can subliminally reflect the theme of the song

@kdn5109

Жыл бұрын

Also called accidental notes used purposefully

Pancham was a musically genius.

In the movie Sholay the song Mehbooba Mehbooba the sound in the begining of the song and also in the middle of the song " Fuu Fuu " is not an instrument but he blewed the empty bottle and the sound of that blowing the empty bottle was used this is also an experiment R.D.Burman made .

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Also on "Ruk Jaana O Jaana"

R.D. Burman was a musical genius. Any words are insufficient to praise him. We miss you Pancham Da...

@ks20595

11 ай бұрын

Exactly

॥ॐ॥ सर बहोत सुन्दर जानकारी दि आप ने धन्यवाद ,, मै खुद एक गिटार प्लेयर और सिंगर हु, एफ# माइनर कोर्ड और राग भैरवी का अद्भुत संगम और किशोर दा जादुई आवाज पंचम दा का कभी ना भूलने वाला संगीत क्या कहे कोई शब्द ही नही क्या कहे 👌👌👌👌

Panchamda's Magical Music is out of such creativity. Based on the Story Situation, as you said rightly discordant relationship of the Hero and Heroine, Panchamda must have been so happy to use the discordant sound to reconcile with each other. Bhanu Gupta Saab's accidentally playing such off stroke, created Wonders for this unique Song to remember at all times. As you said perfectly, the moment one listens to this discordant sound, could start murmuring Chingari along with Kishore Kumar. Thanks for this valuable treat Sir 🙏🙏🙏🙏

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Thank you sir!

@kalyanbhattacharya6787

Жыл бұрын

Excellent analysis.

Genious of Pancham Da is being talked about everywhere in the world...

@kamaltiwari4996

Ай бұрын

But unfortunately he is talked about everywhere in the world only after he left the world...he was given a shabby treatment when he was alive & creating exceptional music ...feel so sad for him...

There were and are so many brilliant composers in the Bollywood music industry. But still, in my personal opinion, Pancham has been the greatest. And it's so much shameful that this absolute genius didn’t have any National Award. Not only he, the another greatest Kishore Kumar had the same fate. Shame! Shame!!

@SB-dp6kh

Жыл бұрын

who cares for national awards ? for us fans , they are Gods and alwsys be Gods..

@saradaprasadsinha2326

Жыл бұрын

@@SB-dp6kh Absolutely right, my dear friend! Yes, 'God' is the only suitable word for them. 👍👍👍👍

@rajkumarcauttuck8907

11 ай бұрын

Till now no one has reached to that level to be capable of offering a national award to the God of music Pancham ji. I mean it GOD OF MUSIC. Who can give to God? GOD gives to us. U hv to be a parent to give to the child. Same thing applies to Kishore Kumar ji.

@dr.haripandey

11 ай бұрын

We have fans have given them award of immortality and god humans will never understand them because they are heavenly bodies

True music is never limited to notes and forms but to the heart and soul. Pls listen with heart and not the mind 🙏🎵

@udaysawant5822

Жыл бұрын

Yes Right O P Nayyar Saheb not studied music but he was great Bharat Ratna Bhimsen Joshi Saheb listen songs of Kishore Kumar

That subtle reason sounds sensible.... Pancham da was truly a genius one...making melody out of dischorded sound is just out of this world.... Many many salutations to pancham da...👍👌🎊🎉🎤🎶

@ManojAgrawal

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Abhishek!

Bhaiya, you are great to pass on the information to many of ours admirers of Panchamda. He had been my Hero and God from the days of Teesri Manzil. Keep well. 🙏

@ManojAgrawal

Жыл бұрын

Thank you so much 🙂

Genius that_ R D was.Musical notes were ready within his mind we have heard.You have confirmed that,thanks,

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Sunil

Wow... loved the video and the rational explanation 👌

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Thank you, Renu ji!

Fantastic information and interpretation.

Yes you're right sir. Being a guitar player myself, I used to think it was a wrong note when I heard the song. But this small mistake made the whole song with a mysterious melody and result is a super hit

Always Always immortal with legendary composer panchamda with great navratna musicians created magic tracks 🎼🎶🎵✨🪄👌👍♥️❤️💯🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿

@kalyanbhattacharya6787

Жыл бұрын

Exactly said. Really, the musicians of Panchamda are navaratna like Basu Chakraborty, Monohari Singh, Maruti Rao Kir, Vanu Gupta, Bhupinder Singh, Homi mullah, Chandrakant, Debichand, Ranjit Gajmer(kancha) etc. etc. The almighty God created Panchamda and our musical God Panchamda created these navaratna musicians. Let's salute Panchamda 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

Sir your voice is heart touching♥️. Please upload regularly

@ManojAgrawal

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you so much Piyush! Please do visit my other channel kzread.info

All time hit song

Superb Thoughts. Jio Burmanda ❤

Bohot badhiya description ❤️... kyaa baat hai

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Sudhakar 🙂

zabrdast info wah thank u so much for such a grea thing

Complete musician ❤️❤️❤️

Excellent

Yes it is subtle and you are also a genius to feel and express it so beautifully 🎵❤️🌿

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Oh, thank you so much! You are being so kind 🙂

Apka presentation bahot genuine aur full of simplicity hai.. I love it.. also where you gave great comparison of rafi and Kishor

@manoj_agr

5 ай бұрын

Thanks 😊

Really like your second explanation ... you are a true music lover.

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Thank you Justine! Good to see you on this channel too 🙂

Yes pancham da is great after chingari koi bhadke,this chords use in manzil apni jagah& andheri raton mein song prelude

Fantastic explanation Sir..

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Joy!

Came here after seen Mix with Vasu dev Video ... And you've explained it so nicely ❤

@ManojAgrawal

10 ай бұрын

Thanks Vasu 🙂

Too good

@ManojAgrawal

Жыл бұрын

Thanks 🙂

Awesome

Yes, I do appreciate your conjecture.

Bahutkhub!

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Thanks

Brilliant analysis

I don’t think Panchamda kept the chord because of the discordant relationship between the main actors in Amar Prem but I like the way you have put it together. The real reason is the fact that Panchamda always created something different and this particular note fitted perfectly with his personality

@Brajgamer

11 ай бұрын

His argument was not "why did Pancham do this?" His argument was "Why does it sound good?

कुछ ही बेहतरीन गानों में से एक है ये गाना ।।

बहोत बढ़िया तरीके से आपने ये जानकारी दी है. शुक्रिया.

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Dhanyawaad

Keep uploading more videos sir You deserve more and more subscribers

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Thank you Vinod!

Good explanation

Ultimately explained..

@ManojAgrawal

10 ай бұрын

Thanks 😊

best of all rd barman

Good sir

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Rohit!

Mast channel💐💐💐💜🙏, more videos 🙏 please

@ManojAgrawal

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks! 🙂

👍 I found the reasoning 👌 Yes that off note goes very well with the meaning of the song. What's mistake bu Bhanu da 😊 🙏

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Thank you

👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

❤️

Sir jee... Video Aur Bara hona chahiye tha... Bahut achcha laga aapka Guitar Bajana..FULL SONG KA VIDEO BANAYE

@ManojAgrawal

Жыл бұрын

Thank you! I will try to record the full song

Bahot khub ali janab .

minor chord ka ek extension minit flat 6 baj gaya, jo komal dha or b6 is gane ki raag bhairavi ka part hai..diatonic se thora bahar..not out of scale or accidental note..

🙏🙏

Bahut sundar

Genius panchamda

👍

Thanks to all one only boss

🙏❤️🙏

No one can even near to him he simply was a legend

Only one to take risk the boss ❤

Thank you so much.... Sir.. You presenting my great grandpa legendary guruji... S this melodies tune composed tune... My guruji when he was alive remembering this melodies relates... Music sittings storys behind how was make this fabulous song many times more than 1000 of.... My great Guruji remarkable worked with Pancham Uncle... He and pancham was big thinker of every song tune composing both was superb Ginious... In fact in Bollywood 🎶 Industrys.. 1 st time starts first rytham patterns arranges and then tune making.. That was one and only magical Rahuldev Burman and Bhanu Da. Every music sittings. With MANOHARI uncle, Amrutrao uncle, homie uncle, maruti uncle, devichand uncle, santosh singh uncle, Manya uncle and kancha uncle was core sitting team behind every song success... Let me introduce am adorable student great legendary musician late Bhanu Gupta uncle ji.. 😍 pancham Uncle original 🎶 team personally knows me.

@ManojAgrawal

Жыл бұрын

Thank you so much Sanjay and so wonderful to hear from you.

@pushkarraj1088

Жыл бұрын

You r very lucky you knew about this great team

@sanjaymurlidharpathak2104

Жыл бұрын

@@ManojAgrawal Sir Ji am so Muchhhhhhhhhh proud saying "after Bhanu Uncle and 2 years ago my lovely papa passed away 😢 😢 my all legendary masters musicians uncles helping me always they all take caring me, Sir am right hand Desable musician, but my legendary uncles always motivating me, not only socially but echonomicaly every one adoring loves me lotsss. Yes yes yes of course am from my great great Pancham Uncle music family belonging.... In other words pancham Uncle to chale gaye Parr Hummari bahott badi 🎶 familys abbb bhi hain. 😍

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

@@sanjaymurlidharpathak2104 sorry to hear that but good luck to you

@sanjaymurlidharpathak2104

Жыл бұрын

@@manoj_agr Respected sir ji thank you very much but don't worry about my ✋ DESABILITY, whenever I playing on my guitar feel my bhanu uncle holding ✋ and saying "Sanju beta you should play am with, just call your pancham Uncle name and me and Pancham will be front of you and after that miracleyy i can play like normal guitar players, i have my legendary guruji golden days guitar and plectrum wich not only bhanu uncle played but pancham chacha ji also many times played in music siting room. Everyone says "tu tere guruji Jaisa hii rytham patterns bajata hain, jo mere Guruji bajate the guitar and Harmonica mein bhi Wohi bajata Hun, isase badi jivan mein baat Kya ho sakati hain, pancham Uncle ke sare dost mujhe apane bhatije ki tarahh pyyar karate hain!!!!

Beautiful I know it You can do anything

This is a flemenco guitar style chord..and was known to such rich musicians at that time....

@manoj_agr

11 ай бұрын

Maybe, but I have taken this incident from his biography that I have uploaded in a Google doc. Here it is docs.google.com/document/u/0/d/19NDawoIqE7eyNorwOqyItVjoi_ei9YVHPlFmNfag0SQ/mobilebasic?pli=1

@ajaymsheth

6 ай бұрын

Can you cite any example of this flemenco style cord anywhere to support your claim?

10/10

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Thanks 🙂

You have an old world Aakhasvani voice. May God Bless you and keep you healthy always. ❤️❤️👍👍👏👏🙏🙏 The Bhairavi can never be better expressed harmonically then this an F#minor with G(flat 2) both available in the same chord. The tired index finger of BhanuDa going to a bar less index finger arrangement with the G string missed probably deliberate due to his tired fingers and he was exploring some random sounds and a daring Pancham calling Pack up for lack of inspiration and then he hears this sound. And you have an immortal song. This is Pancham the great, who is ready to pay to the studio even without recording a song out of it. We all reach to some rare and unique sounds in our guitar journey and we don’t know what to do of it. A pancham knew the sound and its utility. The 80s was unkind to him but Maa Saraswati was kind to him and blessed him profusely. Long live Pancham Da the genius. Take care Saheb. Subscribed. 🙏🙏🙏🙏

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Thank you so much for your feedback and for your encouraging words, Sir!

@drkhandal

Жыл бұрын

@@manoj_agr ❤️❤️🙏🙏

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

@@drkhandal please do checkout my other channel kzread.info

Aap ko bhi wo song sunanaa chahiye saheb

Excellent analysis. But Sir, 1 million is 10Lakh

@ManojAgrawal

11 ай бұрын

It's just a manner of saying which is different in different languages. Thanks for the comment, though 🙂

Aur video upload karo sir

@ManojAgrawal

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you Shashi! Soon

Wah manoj bhai Pawan jha ji told u are his friend 👍

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Thank you sir! Yes, Pavan is a dear friend.

@spectrovision7466

Жыл бұрын

@@manoj_agr aur kuchh baat nehin ho sakta ? X boltaa hai Y ko , " tum Z kaa dost ho " . Azeeb da'asta hai ye ...

INDIAN GOVT HAS NEVER RECOGNIZED HON PANCHAMDA. NO NATIONAL AWARD SHAMEFUL 🙏🌼🌺😠😪

क्या हम कुछ नये गाने बना सकते है.

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

आपका मतलब समझा नही

Was it played by Bhanu da?? No, Not that, played by Bhupinder Singh

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

As clarified by @PanchaMtantra - Decoding R.D.Burman in one of the comments, mistake was by Bhanu da but played my Bhupi ji in the final recording.

it's a normal suspension cord.

@manoj_agr

11 ай бұрын

Sir, this incident is taken from RD Burman's biography, the link to which is included in the description. Here it is again docs.google.com/document/u/0/d/19NDawoIqE7eyNorwOqyItVjoi_ei9YVHPlFmNfag0SQ/mobilebasic?pli=1

Sangeet feeel se hoti hai ager jo dil me Ghusss gaya to bas wo sound ghuss gaya.... Niyam kanun sb barbad h... Kitabi bhasa bas dikawa h .. Sangeet Ki atma ko smjho... Book ko nai..🙏🙌🏾

With due respect Sir, 1 Million is Ten Lakhs... Btw, nice presentation...

@ManojAgrawal

Жыл бұрын

10 lakh rupees are not equal to 1 million dollars anyway because of the currency conversion. It's just how we say in different languages. "In a manner of speaking" 🙂

@GoodSamaritanGoodSamaritan

Жыл бұрын

@@ManojAgrawal did I at all mention currency once Sir? Please go through my comment again...

It is not at all a distorted sound it is just another chord

@manoj_agr

2 ай бұрын

This incident has been taken from Pancham da's biography and link to the page is in the video description. Here is the link again docs.google.com/document/d/19NDawoIqE7eyNorwOqyItVjoi_ei9YVHPlFmNfag0SQ/edit?usp=sharing

Panchamda is panchamda

Banaya bhanu da ne tha..bajaya bhupendra singh ne bajaya tha

@manoj_agr

11 ай бұрын

Thanks. This has been clarified in comments, as well.

Whats the source of your story ? … do we know …

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

This is based on several accounts and from RD Burman's biography. There is a link to a Google doc in the description. Please do check it out.

Dont know who is correct....this man or the other(s) who gives credit for this chord to the Late Bhupinder Ji

@ManojAgrawal

11 ай бұрын

During rehearsal, the wrong chord was played by Bhanu da, but it was played by Bhupinder ji during the actual recording of the song.

Sir 1 million is equals to 10 lakhs not 1 lakh

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Sir, 1 million 'dollar' is not equal to 10 lakh 'rupees'. I clarified in the video "in a manner of speaking". No one can calculate the actual value so its just colloquial 🙂

@spectrovision7466

Жыл бұрын

But you told one lakh . Your title says one million . You cannot tell both in one occasion . B'coz both cost different . If colloquial , let's take it as one million risk not one lakh ...

@ManojAgrawal

Жыл бұрын

@@spectrovision7466 English colloquial mein one million dollar aur hindi colloquial mein lakh rupee. Dono alag alag hain. Phir bhi aapka dhanyawaad ki aapne video dekha aur comment Kiya

Not Bhanu Da It's Bhupendra Singh Bhuppi

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Not sure but I did read it in RD Burman's official biography. You can google 'Bhanu Gupta + Chingari Koi Bhadke'. Here is one of the results www.thehindu.com/entertainment/music/the-making-of-rd-burmans-genius/article27059316.ece

@deepakyadavdys9825

Жыл бұрын

@@manoj_agr en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhupinder_Singh_(musician)

@deepakyadavdys9825

Жыл бұрын

Or may be part of Bass guitar both

@rakeshkumar-kl3tb

Жыл бұрын

Bhanu Da played this Song ..

@PadalkarP

Жыл бұрын

Bhanuda played Guitar.

galat bja rhe ho ji

Mr Manoj this song was composed in F#m and the note G which was added becomes F#b9 this are all made up stories by you all people sorry to say, it was played by Bhupiji, Panchamda was A Genius his harmony sense was Great he knew wht he was doing I have worked with Panchamda and we know the Genius pls don't post all this fake stories.

@manoj_agr

5 ай бұрын

Sir, I have taken this incident from Pancham da's biography by Aniruddha Bhattacharjee and Balaji Vittal. I have included the link of Google doc in the description. Please do take a look, and if you still think it is fake, please reach out to the authors and publishers.

Aisa apko lagta hai. Magar Aisa hi hua tha ye aap kaise kah sakte hain? Apki mangadhant baten hain. Panchamda and his musicians were all much smarter than you think. Plsease stop spreading false information.

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Sir, this incident is taken from National Award winning R.D. Burman's biography and I have uploaded the relevant page to a google doc. Kindly read and if you still have issues with it please reach out to the authors Anirudha Bhattacharjee & Balaji Vittal docs.google.com/document/d/19NDawoIqE7eyNorwOqyItVjoi_ei9YVHPlFmNfag0SQ/edit?usp=sharing

Aisi koi kahani nhi thi , kuch bhi mt boliye pls ,

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

RD Burman ki biography padhiye. Apna email dijiye apko us page ki copy bhejta hoon jisme yeh kissa darj hai.

@jairafisahabkkrocks3731

Жыл бұрын

@@manoj_agr ji pdh ke hi bta rha hu pyare uncle ji

Ye daa daa kya ho rahe ho ? Kishor Kumar bolo .

This Guitar had been played by Bhupi ji Bhanu da never played lead guitar parts. He used to play always rhythm on guitar. This is a fake story

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

www.thehindu.com/entertainment/music/the-making-of-rd-burmans-genius/article27059316.ece

This story is a bullshit and has been doing rounds. Adding the note G not in the conventional F# minor scale but in the composition is an accidental note. They are deliberately added. Such notes are often used in songs. RD Burman has done such experiments in many songs - Hamein Tumse Pyar Kitana, Kya yahi Pyar hai to name a few. This happens because the basic compositions of RD Burman were often from Indian ragas that never fitted in conventional major or minor progressions.

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

Aap Bhanu Gupta ji ko pakadiye www.thehindu.com/entertainment/music/the-making-of-rd-burmans-genius/article27059316.ece

@SantanuProductions

Жыл бұрын

@@manoj_agr Boss, I am a musician and a filmmaker, I personally know many musicians. Including Bupinder ji. I had asked long ago Bhupi ji if something like this had happened. He simply laughed and said the same logic. Also you yourself are a musician. Tell me how otherwise without accidentals would you use standard notes and chords in ragas that have varjit notes?

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

@@SantanuProductions Bhanu da himself has narrated this incident several times in his interviews and I have read it in RD Burman's biography by Aniruddha Bhattacharjee and Balaji Vittal. Incidental notes are played in passing but this one is being played as a chord. Years ago I sang this song on stage and the guitarist struggled to get this sound. We didn't know then that it was just F#m without the bar finger. This sound could only have been discovered by accident. Anyways, who can know for sure now that most of those people are no more, sadly. Thanks for commenting though. See you around.

Wrong information sir Pls don’t do that unless n until you know the fact…Bhanu da also said wrong thing If you want the fact pls DM me

@manoj_agr

Жыл бұрын

This is from RD Burman's national award winning biography. I have included a link of the google doc with the copy of the relevant page in the video description. Please reach out to the authors of the book in case you have issues with this story.

@ssrvmusic

Жыл бұрын

@@manoj_agr SURE...But Info is wrong

Mujhe ek baat samjh me nahi aati..ki..sangeet ka kya koi fix pattern kese ho sakta hai...sngeet to har kisi ka uski khud ki tarah hoga..iska koi fix pattern nahi ho sakta

@ManojAgrawal

Жыл бұрын

Interesting topic to discuss over a beer. 🙂

मईनरकोर्ड में 2nd फ्लेट यूज़ किया हे आप 9th भी बोल सकते हो ये कोर्ड "कोई हसीना जब रुथजाति हे तो शोले फ़िल्म और एकरुतु आये एकरुतु जाये,गौवतं गोविन्दा फ़िल्म यूज़ हुवा हे ये एक बड़ी अछि अरेंजमेंट हे और जो म्यूजिक थियोरी जानते हे वहीँ ये खूबसूरती कैसे बनाई इसका फॉर्म्युला जनते हे #F Sharp Mainor+2nd Flat स ग,कोमल रे कोमल प 🙏

@ManojAgrawal

Жыл бұрын

I think for the 9th chord you will have to add G# or शुध्द रे whereas we are using कोमल रे so this is not really a 9th. Thanks for the insight though. 👍