Does Dr. Adekoya make some good points? Full episode out Monday. Hit like and share!

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

No ,it sounds like a pseudo-intellectual way of justifying colonialism via exceptionalism, Andrew, as do the writings of his that I have posted above for you. I'd love for you to debate the point with me , but seeming as you lost your temper with me after you stating that you support and believe in collective punishment for Palestinian women and children non combatants live on feed in front of quite a few people, I doubt I'm going to get much of a response other than a flip one. You can't reasonably accuse others of ignorance just for disagreeing with you. But as a great man once said, Andrew :"Whatever gets you through the night".

@morticiag

7 ай бұрын

@@denemessina8601 Speaking of colonialism, tell me 1 nation in the entire Middle East that Hasn't been Colo'nised by Islam ?

@morticiag

7 ай бұрын

@@denemessina8601 But Hamas launched the first Atta'ck on innocent men, women and children in Israel, some of whom were tourists to Israel ? Did you forget about that? Did you go out on the streets to celebrate this fact together with the Muslims and pro Pale'stinians? Do you honestly BELIEVE that Israel would sit back and let them go after that? Israel WARNED the Pale'stinians WHERE they would be bo'mbing... So WHY didn't their own Ar'my, Hamas, let them evacuate? Any ideas?

@morticiag

7 ай бұрын

@@denemessina8601 Are you Italian origin, Mr Messina ? You do realise that it was your fellow Romans of the ancient times that Colo'nised Israel first, before the current Je'ws and before the Muslims did ...? What about Roman colonialism and expansionism ? All the Je'ws have wanted is to get their homeland, Israel, back. . They have NOT tried to con'quer any other territories, have they?

@Grace.allovertheplace

7 ай бұрын

Hi Andrew, I just must say how incredibly important your voice is! And I’d appreciate to see you and Vlad Vexler making an interview together perhaps a shared livestream? Can I go/text him my suggestion? Would you be interested? Take care of yourself and your precious fiancé and your precious whole family! ❤

Qatar is one of the largest funders of Hamas and we tolerate them because they have wealth.

I never understood how the Holocaust happened. I now see how that happened. Scary times. We have weak people in the West that are repeating the mistakes of the past.

@charleswhite758

7 ай бұрын

Please stop bringing up the Holocaust. This has nothing to do with the Holocaust. Using the Holocaust like some trump card to silence debate will not work.

@franklin519

7 ай бұрын

@@charleswhite758 Quit bringing up genocide, there is no genocide going on.

@garycannon2887

7 ай бұрын

@@charleswhite758Israel been bringing up holocaust and nazis from the beginning

@menid2691

7 ай бұрын

​@@garycannon2887yes, we should be focused on the present and the now, like the Palestinians who certainly don't start every conversation with "75 years ago... So now I'm allowed to burn babies"

@garycannon2887

7 ай бұрын

⁠​⁠@@menid2691is there evidence of Hamas burning anyone The wider context is usually brought up when oct 7 is used as an excuse for ongoing actions of Israel

Does it even matter what side you’re on ? Innocent people are dying ! Everywhere! That’s the debate to be had across the board and the one thing we all can agree on.

@Timothy1976

7 ай бұрын

Agreed

@menid2691

7 ай бұрын

So what should be done?

@deedee7780

7 ай бұрын

Well clearly this guy is taking a side, just look at the title of this video. He has done nothing but spread zionist propaganda since October 7th attacks. It's really sickening.

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

Andrew doesnt agree with you. He publicly stated in the live feed for this content that he supports collective punishment of women and child non-combatants. As does the Israeli government. The people of Israel I have no problem with, but Bibi et al need removing. Andrew should withdraw his support for the israeli govt in the matter of this genocide in progress. Which, by the way, he denies is genocide. In fact he actually accused me of lying about a genocide that wasn't happening in Gaza right now.

@menid2691

7 ай бұрын

@@denemessina8601 there is no collective punishment because civilians aren't being hurt. They are all safe in the many km of underground tunnels while the only people above ground are terrorists. The Palestinians had over two weeks to prepare for the ground invasion of the north so there's no way Hamas left anyone to get hurt in that area right?

Thank you so much Andrew. I guess you have lost viewers but not all of them. You have got the real empaths, the ones that would never never bully a fellow university student because of who they descend from, their surname ‘ their religion. Much love from a Protestant christian female fan!!!

@charleswhite758

7 ай бұрын

When you are fighting a battle you don't want the "the real empaths" on your side. They are the ones who refuse to fire a gun. You want the nut-jobs and crazies fighting for you🤣

@charleswhite758

7 ай бұрын

How do you think Palestinians are treated in universities in Israel? ..... Oh, wait, Palestinians aren't even allowed to attend universities in Israel. Nor are they allowed to own property. How do you think a blond haired Christian is treated in universities in Israel? Or is it just Westerners who are the nasty ones in this world? Do you know anything about this long dispute?

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

Nobody Bullied Andrew, though his cronies made a failed attempts at bullying and silencing others. The issue is NOT descent, surname, nor religion. The problem is Andrew is spreading misinfo as is Remi. Misinfo, I might add, first proffered in the U.K by our horrific home secretary, whose husband is a prominent Zionist and has business interests in Israel. You do realise how it looks when Zionists say stuff that isn't true but to believe in it is to the profit of Israel, yes?

@MusiciansWithVision

7 ай бұрын

You see yourself as a real empath, then; sadly your empathy does not extend to those of a different faith, a different culture, who don't look, think, speak, dress or act the way you and your Protestant Christian brothers and sisters do!

@NotInMYName_AntiZionistJew

7 ай бұрын

@@MusiciansWithVision​​⁠ ⁠ I’m confused. I don’t understand how you reached that conclusion. Commenter said absolutely nothing about the horrors occurring in Gaza, only about antisemitism on campus. Why can’t you be both against antisemitism and also want an end to suffering for the Gazans? I don’t see the problem here.

these are students in our universities , the future of the country and they dont even take the time to understand a situation before engaging in hate speech , thats a worry

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

As a gen x, personally I'm proud of generation Z. They see through lies like the one you're trying to peddle and are not afraid to stand up for what they believe in, even as you lot patronise them and look down on them because they won't tolerate your doublespeak 1984 gas-lighting nonsense. How dare you judge them, when you support genocide and the suppression of free speech?

@shadowwhowalk

7 ай бұрын

What is the hate speech?

Thank you, Dr Adekoya, and Andrew.

The people who stand with you in bad times are the ones you can trust as yours

Underdogs can be evil, just because they are backward and dumb, it does not mean they are good and virtuous.

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

Yes but the problem is, it isn't nice to invade someones land , steal their house, steal all their stuff, beat them, make them second class citizens and generally oppress them. it's not relevant who the oppressed are anymore in this case, because you have committed an evil act in the name of wanting what they have. Exceptionalism is merely self-justification for being a bit of a douche-bag.

Another great interview! In times like these, it is most important to hear rational, well-informed, balanced and nuanced arguments. Andrew, keep up the great work! ❤️ from Germany

@MusiciansWithVision

7 ай бұрын

The Jewish and Christian perspective would call it rational, well-informed, balanced and nuanced arguments, the Islamic perspective would not!!!

@longfield0023

6 ай бұрын

@@MusiciansWithVision Sorry, I work with people who follow the islam faith and you can not speak for every one of them. Are you the gatekeeper for Islam? What is the "Islamic Perspective?" There is not one perspective in any faith.

@MusiciansWithVision

6 ай бұрын

@@longfield0023 What exactly are your disagreeing with, and why do you assume I do not have strong connections with Muslims??? To make such an audacious assumption you are exposing your own ignorance on the matter, so let's not project your own failings onto me!

@MusiciansWithVision

6 ай бұрын

Just because YOU believe he delivers rational, well-informed, balanced and nuanced arguments, doesn't prove anything; the very fact that you have come to this conclusion suggests you are not qualified to make such an evaluation! I have experienced the childish, self-absorbed, side to Andrew Gold, which will remain hidden to you as long as you continue to suck up, criticise him in the slightest way and he will expose himself--how someone handles criticism is the real test of someone's character, their sincerity, their integrity, their conviction, their principles, their authenticity, and that is where the likes of Andrew Gold come up well short of the mark!

@nightingalesingon

6 ай бұрын

@@MusiciansWithVision it seems you are making this way too personal without giving any concrete examples. It's not about Andrew Gold or me -- as an academic I am fully capable of (and I moreover enjoy) handling controversy, disagreement and criticism. I am trained in looking at a multitude of sources of information and handle arguments carefully. Throughout my life I have found that rationality, moderation and an intersubjective approach weighing pros and cons proves to be a good and plausible starting point. That's how academic discourse functions. As far as I can tell from AG's content, i have no doubts @AndrewGold1 can handle controversial arguments and well-founded criticism like a pro. As to your point, I find it a rather weak and childish position to accuse or criticise someone without making any effort to come up with concrete information or arguments.

Kyyyaaarrrr !!!! One need not be a LEFTIST, nor a MUSLIM, to support the ppl of GAZA. Any human w/ a HEART will almost certainly be calling for an IMMEDIATE CEASEFIRE, & INQUIRY. #INSIDEJOB #BIBIKNEW

@valeriehynd3064

7 ай бұрын

How could they possibly not have been in on it....definitely inside job 😢

Great interview, thank you.

Why are the palestines not welcome in other arabian countries ?

@redfox4929

7 ай бұрын

There are 2 types of Muslim's, Shia and Sunni. They are at odds with each other. I found it confusing.

@khylerin70

7 ай бұрын

@@redfox4929 if they can't get along with themselves how on earth is anyone else going to. Careful though, you may be labelled as something you aren't just for questioning anything by some commentators here as I have been. Mainstream Jewish people are not unlike you or I really, it's the Zionists that are the issue and it's curious that Andrew has zeroed in on one toxic cult called Scientology yet there's just the sound of crickets where the Zionism cult subject is concerned 🤔🤔🙄

@eddieobrien1411

3 ай бұрын

Because they cause trouble.Look into Palestinian refugees in neighbouring countries,including Lebanon,Syria and Jordon,Egypt…the list is long!

There are many Jews who oppose the brutal oppresion of the Palestinian people by the Israeli goverment. These are the Jews who follow the true teachings of the Torah and of God Almighty. The people who commited the 7th October of attacks are not true Muslims because it is forbidden to murder civilians even in times of war according to Islam. If everyone followed the true teachings of God and acted with absolute justice instead of their own vested interests, conflicts like this could never happen. We are all linked together by humanity. Humanity should prevail. Justice should prevail. May we live to see world peace.

@AndrewGold1

7 ай бұрын

i think you're very reasonable zara, fair points. the only thing is - if you're israel prime minister, and your role is to protect israelis at all costs - what do you do? i don't think it's simple.

@mariastejereanu

7 ай бұрын

True! But what to do when the other party does not follow the teachings?

@Live4truth369

7 ай бұрын

Thank you, I hate the term Islamic extremists. It’s not fair and will bring more hate and division. Why do we say Islamic extremists? If someone were to say Jewish extremists or Christian’s extremists it’s a problem. And we act like there is no Zionist extremists, why then? Islam is not what made them what they are. War is.

@kavithakrishnanshow

7 ай бұрын

Well the Quran clearly says kills those who doesn’t believe in allah

@khylerin70

7 ай бұрын

100%, an incredibly insightful comment.

When is someone going to muster the courage to inform Greta that she's the product of a multi-generational, rich, Swedish family. She was never "robbed" of her charmed childhood!

@toldyouso5588

7 ай бұрын

Certainly not the UN who will invite her to the general assembly to say again to Israel this time "how dare you."

@DorothyNylund

7 ай бұрын

Greta is her generation's epitome of the axiom that "charism does NOT equal charctor"

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

And Bibi his.@@DorothyNylund

@JoJoGranum

7 ай бұрын

Greta would have been one of those no nuke protesters in my generation. For the record I have no issue with nuclear power if it’s used responsibly and not for weapons. In Ontario, Canada it may be our cleanest energy source as solar and wind are unreliable for the needs of the province.

@NotInMYName_AntiZionistJew

7 ай бұрын

How is being autistic leading a “charmed life” in any aspect? Neurodivergents face constant discrimination in our neurotypical society.

These misguided students are Turkeys voting for Christmas

Thank you Andrew. 🇲🇽 ❤️ 🇮🇱

Thank you for stimulating my braincells, gentlemen. 🎉

There shouldn’t be a higher standard… they are human beings and they are held accountable at the same level.

Great piece Andrew and very sorry to miss you at the Battle of Ideas. What a great weekend.

@AndrewGold1

7 ай бұрын

ah you were there! fantastic! i got six more interviews coming out - longer ones - from that weekend. i was hidden away in a room at the event recording them all weekend!

@rebeccaharris7650

7 ай бұрын

@AndrewGold1 great! Can't wait to see them. I was only there for the Saturday but managed to get to hear most of my favourite people as well as some great discussions. Keep up the great work, especially in such hard times.

4:27 is he talking about Greta? Because she comes from a wealthy family. She is a millionaire. She is not middle class.

I think most of them know and understand exactly what they're saying. They are more comfortable expressing it now due to the current global acceptance and rise in antisemitism.

@ltahoe9257

7 ай бұрын

What's baffling to me, is how people keep insisting that speaking against Israel is being antisemitic. It's not. I cannot in good conscious support a country dropping white phosphorus on schools

@deedee7780

7 ай бұрын

There's actually a rise in Islamophobia. This channel is doing the same.

@garycannon2887

7 ай бұрын

If you referring to from river to sea those trying to make it antisemitism just purposely lie to try smear protests. While there is rise in hate against Jews and Muslims when Israel in news, the rise in support for Palestinians is due to more people being exposed directly to Israel’s representatives and what they are open about doing, along with Palestinian voices starting to be heard with social media allowing them to be humanised

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

Yes it indeed is. I don't know if you saw the live feed but Andrew publicly gave his seal of approval to the collective punishment of Gazan women and children . i kid you not. @@deedee7780

@ladidaohoh3168

7 ай бұрын

@@deedee7780that’s insane!!!! There are 10’s of thousands of supporters of Palestinians on the streets in every nation. Although none of the virtuous Countries in the Middle East are taking in any refugees. So what you saying, that is absolute garbage and you know it.

Thank you 🙏

Might it not be as simple as people not wanting to see other people (half of them children) being slaughtered in what seems a disproportionate and indiscriminate manner ? If we all care about the horrific events of Oct 7th, why be blind to subsequent crimes. It is NOT antisemitic to hold the Israeli government to account for actions of retribution, which even a fool knows cannot possibly achieve peace in the region. Just a thought.

@krarosie

6 ай бұрын

YES THANK YOU 🙌🙌

they understand what they are saying , if they have even a tiny amount of interest in the situation then surely they know what the chants mean

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

Yes they do. However our home secretary is pushing disinfo that is extremely dangerous. Y'know the one that wants immigrants to die and that homelessness is a "lifestyle choice". Andrew and his bunch have been parroting the same lie as her re-Palestine. Do you know who her husband is?

@shadowwhowalk

7 ай бұрын

Which chants do you find problematic?

Andrew, I hope you don't mind if I suggest that you put some biographical detail about your guests in the programme notes.

@AndrewGold1

7 ай бұрын

Ah yes, good point - the full episode is out Monday and I'll have a bit more about him! :)

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

I can provide some, if you like. He's quite interesting. be seeing you. ;)@@AndrewGold1

@kcc-karenschroniccorner9432

7 ай бұрын

@@AndrewGold1 thanks! I was about to ask if there was a longer version. Can not wait!!!

I really think you are missing the point by focusing on individual protesters. Of course there is wrong on both sides. But Israel as a sovereign nation state (not a terrorist organisation like Hamas) has a responsibility to abide by the Geneva convention and basic human rights standards and STOP bombing civilians and seek a new path to free hostages and restore some peace. Israel alone has this power. The people of Palestine do not.

Andrew, although I don't agree with your analysis of the Israeli-Palestine conflict and the current situation in the Middle East, I do not intend to unsuscribe to your channel because I appreciate the content you create and your balanced approach. It cannot be denied that antisemitism is real and that there are fanatics on the other side who exploit the current situation to spew their personal hatred of Jewish people. Yet, being critical of the state of Israel or the Israeli government's actions doesn't mean being antisemitic or being pro Hamas. This kind of reductionism is not only ridiculous, but also just a convenient tool to silence dissent. From a purely human perspective, most decent people were horrified by the atrocities of October 7th just as we are by the carnage that's taking place in Gaza right now. Having said that, it would be good to hear on your channel other voices from the Jewish community itself (e.g. Gabor Maté, Hungarian-Canadian physician and Holocaust survivor, Ilan Pappe, Norman Finkelstein, both historians, etc.) to get a different perspective and a more balanced view of what's going on.

The LGBT + amaze me by saying that they stand with Palestine. Do they not realize that if they went to the Middle East, any country except Israel , they wouldn't stay alive 24 hrs. This shows ignorance on their part. Before the attack by Hamas I was already amazed by statements made by college students on some American campuses concerning history. I learned more history in the 5th grade at ten yrs old than they can answer questions to. My father might been a coal miner but he was a self educated man, especially history. He really believed if people didn't get taught history it might repeat itself. I'm ashamed of the ignorance that some young Americans are showing. I do believe in free speech. Free speech doesn't cover threatening anyone. The majority of Americans don't think like these people shouting in the streets. We have to speak up and not remain silent like people have done in the past. I support Israel. I listened to what the Hamas leader said. He said basically the same as what a doctor from Pakistan told me over 20 yrs ago. I guess I would be told that I believed in Islamophobia if I said it here on KZread. What he told me was very graphic about what would happen to the Jews and Infidels someday. If anyone looked up the Hamas leader's speech this last week they'll see what I mean. Hamas doesn't like the pawns in the streets anymore than does he does Jews. He will do what he wants to no matter what Biden and his administration does or says.

@andalltheangelssay212

7 ай бұрын

It doesn’t show ignorance on their part, they are quite aware of this, don’t you realise that they are protesting for human rights because it is against international law and a war crime to use collective punishment on a civilian population, and they are protesting for a cease fire as 9000 Palestinians have been killed, including 4000 children? They are also protesting for Palestinians in the West Bank ( and Hamas are not involved in the West Bank) 300 of who have been killed by Israeli military this year, many of them children, this is where the river to the sea chant comes in, from the West Bank to Gaza is what it means, they are not using it in an anti- Semitic way x

@JoJoGranum

7 ай бұрын

I’m LGBTQ and I have real issues with those who are standing for an organization that would kill them if they practice their lifestyle. It’s .. very.. well paradoxical is the best word that can come out of my aging brain .

@andalltheangelssay212

7 ай бұрын

@@JoJoGranum the protesters are not standing for an organisation, they are supporting a civilian population who have war crimes committed against them, their rights to food water and electricity taken away, ordered to leave their homes and go south and were bombed on the way. 10, 000 now killed including between 3 and 4 thousand children. Israel are bombing schools, hospitals , refugee camps, ambulances. Is that self defence? 500 killed in a bomb strike to get to one man, a convoy of ambulances full of injured Palestinians bombed because the israeli military thought (wrongly) that they had seen someone who worked for Hamas get in one of them. And they are also in solidarity with the civilians of the West Bank where 300 have been killed by the Israeli military this year. Hamas are nothing to do with the West Bank so what’s Israel’s excuse there?

@shadowwhowalk

7 ай бұрын

Do you like Palestinian LGBT+ so much you are willing to stand with them? If so, do they support Palestinian liberation? Yes or no? The majority of Americans support ceasefire. Do you support it? If you like history so much, look up apartheid South Africa.

@JoJoGranum

7 ай бұрын

@@shadowwhowalk if you mean me, I would support Palestinian LGBTQ (as in LGBTQ who are Palestinian ) because most are being persecuted or in hiding long before this started. And I know about South Africa. I was a teen in the 80s. What I do think is Israel has a right to defend themselves.

I’m on neither side, both are problematic

This was a subpar "debate" with two people falling over each other in agreement

They should raise the age for voting eligibility to age 30. If students today are so ideologically brainwashed - and most of them extend their years of study to 5 years - they would only have sufficient real-world experience by age 30. Anything younger & we're placing our future in the sticky fists of intellectual toddlers.

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

How very totalitarian of you. Do now you want to treat Zoomers like you treat Palestians? How would you feel if I told you that your age group were not allowed to vote.? I don't believe that you can come out with that and think that's ok. What is wrong with you? I'm nearly 50 and of course my mindset is different from, mills, zoomers, boomers and all the rest of it. BUT I would not take away their right to vote because they don't agree with me. Who decided that you are the opinion police? Why do you get to decide? You can pretend all you like that they dont have any knowledge on the subject. Most of the people who's voice you'd like to take away are actually pretty clued up and disgusted with your awful behaviour. You're a fascist, supporting an evil, atavistic, violent regime and you'd like to remove the vote of anyone who disagrees with you. It's pathetic , evil and a clear sign of immaturity. As Andrew found out last night, decent people will call you out on your hatred of democracy. Israel are not going to get away with this for much longer and neither are it's sycophants. It's not your world, it's the young's world and you all know that they'll trash your paradigm in a few years . Good for them. Your ugly mindset will cause ww3 if allowed to rampage unchecked.

Andrew, I would love to see an in-depth look at the hypocrisy and woke craziness going on at Harvard right now. For example, contrasting all the ways that they have earned their dead-last rating from the FIRE Faculty Network with their abrupt “about face” in front of Congress; attempting to redefine plagiarism and peddling alternate terms like “duplicative language” and “insufficient citation”; and their attempts to kill the plagiarism story early through legal threats and bullying. This story deserves a full airing.

Nigeria is a wealthy country. It has oil amongst other things. The poverty would be much less if there was a fairer distribution of wealth.

Such an interesting and enlightening conversation. Andrew, you're doing amazing work! PS: please note that (presumably without your knowledge) someone, posturing under your name, is replying to viewers' comments by promoting financial investment schemes. Seems to be some external interference in your channel??

Fantastic informative interview 👏

Greta is playing many ppl are protecting her because she is noisy and doing puppets work

@khylerin70

7 ай бұрын

100%👍👍. That and the poor misguided bugger is revelling in the attention upon her. It's patently obvious too, but the bleeding hearts will continue to enable her 😖

@NotInMYName_AntiZionistJew

7 ай бұрын

She is autistic and that puppet was utilized to express the emotions she is unable to express. You can disagree with her stances without mocking her for being autistic. 😢

😢interesting. He makes sense.

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

No he just conveniently justifies Colonialism via exceptionalism. Not big and not clever. I wonder what Mandela would have said to him?

Who gets to decide which countries are developed enough to stop using fossil fuels?? And what about poor people who live in developed countries? Don't they deserve cheaper fuel and a chance to get out of poverty? Applying social justice has nothing to do with justice. The free market is the Best tool to lift people out of poverty

Just so you know, here in Sweden where Greta is from, the liberals are considered to be the right, not the left. That’s because we don’t have any conservative parties, only communist, socialist, and liberal parties. Therefore, the liberal parties are the right-most parties here. The liberal parties of Sweden (so, the Swedish right) are the ones questioning Greta’s tactics and the cult around her, while she is worshipped by the Swedish left (ie the socialists and the communists).

This guy's great. Does he have a channel?

Being Pro Palestinians, it does not mean being Pro - Hamas . You should listen also to the Palestinians' voices who feel occupied and humiliated and without a future, and those are the reasons why they do support Hamas. Understanding would help a lot in this situation, and by the way the word apartheid was used by the ONU. There are also so many ONU's resolutions fog the illegal settlers, and also ONU's reports about how the occupation did not allow the Palestinians to produce their own water and electricity. I am truly not racist and always felt bad for the pogroms and the Holocaust but in this situation Israel is overreacting against the poor Palestinian population and I'm sorry that you are ignoring their suffering, their victims and their deaths.

@krarosie

6 ай бұрын

YES 🙌

Suggestions for guest speakers: Noa Tishby, Simon Schama, Yoseph Haddad, Gad Saad, Douglas Murray, Mijal Bitton 1,176 posts See new posts

"Forward, I pray, since we have come so far, And be it moon, or sun, or what you please. And if you please to call it a rush-candle, Henceforth I vow it shall be so for me." William Shakespeare - The Taming Of The Shrew

The problem to start with is the idea that the underdog is always right. They don't.

I’ve been watching you for a while and it feels like there is no side that is good or innocent.

@msbramble176

7 ай бұрын

One is certainly more powerful and definitely the colonising force. No doubt about that.

I don’t subscribe to the climate change caused by humans theory but I do agree that the pollution caused by manufacturing needs to be addressed. The earth has created its own episodes of huge climate change.

Palestine has the UK SUPPORTERS

🕊️🙏🕯️ perhaps y t is deleting them. They seem to be deleting some of my comments.

Why do the Palestinians remind me so much of the Nazis?

@luchseterna

22 күн бұрын

Because they do nazi salutation and read Hitler's Mein Kampf in UNRWA schools. They also have "Hitler jugend" groups. I am not kidding. They are obsessed with annihilating jews.

Religions. Blech! Yes, I've said it.

@Timothy1976

7 ай бұрын

They would only find another reason

@khylerin70

7 ай бұрын

100%👍👍...100% !!!. Wake up to yourselves, there's much better, cheaper and harmless fiction to entertain you. People need to wake the f**k up to themselves about all this adherence to omnipotent invisible boogie men . Wake the f**k up for f**ks sake 😝😝😄😆😅😅

@TimeIdle

7 ай бұрын

@@Timothy1976 Yes but they won't likely be able to be so radically righteous. In the name of God. Both sides. Gimme a break!

But the level of corruption in developing countries, including those in Africa, is far in excess of what it is in the West. So when you are sitting down with those African governments, the people you are talking to only want to line their own pockets. They also control the judiciary, so there is no opposition to them. His equating of African and Western countries is a false equivalence.

It's called Israel 🇮🇱

There is a reason why people are against Israel and it has nothing to do with antisemitism. You clearly don’t exist in a vacuum. You have chosen to remain silent on the obvious, and that speaks volumes.

@luchseterna

22 күн бұрын

There is a reason to be against islamists. Israel is a modern, democratic country with 2 millions of arabs living there, who for the most part don't play the victim card like the indoctrinated Gazans. Let jews have their tiny land whom they built with their own hands. They are certainly not colonisers, nor white supremacists. So much nonsense propaganda.

Nailed it. They side with the underdog. (Hammas/Palestine) They side with whatever they think is most controversial (LGBTQ+).Edit: You can be who you want but most of the drama is unnecessary. It's all so that they can create and latch on to drama. This is what narcissists do. They can't live without drama. If they were balanced they would also speak out against what happened in the first place in Israel. But they categorically won't. Because that would dilute their drama. They are just attention seekers, that either got spoiled as children or didn't get any real belief in themselves, leading to an unbalanced view of the world. They need to skew the world to fit with their needs. Not look at the world independently. There are less and less independent thinkers. Less and less able to give a balanced view or observation. Children no longer become adults. They just stay children. And that is also what happens with narcissists.

It would be too easy to go right-wing looking and this but I refuse. I refuse even if I’m hated.

Because a group may be behind culturally, morally , educationally or civilizationally/organizationally does it then give others the right to do what has been done to them? Further, this goes all the way back to “who” God loves best… it’s a painful assertion that spawned two other religions in reply. The Creator of Us All loves all of us and equally the same. Both sides feeling God is on their side and against the other, makes this an existential battle for the love of God. Incredibly sad. I was raised to only see one side of this, and it was the Israeli Jewish side… I strongly felt Jewish people need to have a homeland, especially after what happened in WW2. But we weren’t taught what had to be done to the others who lived there to make it happen… all these years. And yes, Palestinians may be behind the Jewish civilization in many ways but does this give the right to do what has been done to them the last 75 years? (example women’s rights, gay rights, etc etc and antisemitism too-but this purge project never would have been done without outgroup anti Muslim beliefs on the Jewish side as well…going back to the beliefs about the favored and unfavored tribes of God in the Torah/Old Testament.) & Does history of horrendous abuse then give a right to abuse? Do we have a right to steal from so-called (through speech or insinuatio) “barbarians”? Consider interviewing/debating Gabor Mate about this 🌀💙🌀

The Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters all over the world.

Is 7000 children enough yet?

There is a big field of dissonance in this issue. I think that one thing is the strong feeling of self righteousness based in a feeling of fighting for the existence among Israeli and/or jewish people. That is something that is not well communicated to the world. Probably it also won't be accepted as an explanation for what the state Israel has done to the Palestinian population (and its doing in this moment). The state Israel doesn’t come across as a state defending the existence of its people, but as a perpetrator. I have since I was a very yong perceived the Israeli state and jewish people as if they inside of themselves are stuck in a petrified state of PTSD filled with the acute feeling of needing to defend themselves - perceiving the reality totally different from others and also in that emotional condition lacking adequate empathy for others. The big painful trauma from outside is that Israeli and/or jewish people don't seem to understand that the acts of the state Israel seems like a repetition of what has been done to jewish people throughout history. This in a small scale counting the people, but in a big way looking at the cruelty in the actual actions. You have to be blind not to think about ghettos when seeing how the Palestinians are living. And the different inhumane violent actions that has been done to the people in their "ghettos", which leads to constant fear of when something will happen again, in their own home areas and in their individual homes. This is done bluntly and openly in front of the eyes of the world. Only someone who's stuck in a culturally nurtured trauma response can be surprised by the lack of sympathy from others. I honestly think that UN didn't do the jewish people any favour creating Israel. It prevented the jewish people from fully see what was done to them and to reach a full acceptance of its consequences and then try to individually and collectively try to go on with life in a sustainable way. No denial but also no state of perpetuating the trauma. Trauma is a wound that might never heal, but it needs another kind of care than keeping the wound open. I do think that UN should facilitate unity for all people who don't have a state that binds them together. And the world should find ways to support healing, sympathy and recognition. But to create the state was a mistake made wothout understanding the consequences. An attempt to provideba quick fix, but instead they gave the jewish people a physical place to project the trauma responding fear of being erased. A very well grounded and horrible fear. I do understand that you all have done your best to deal with, heal from, and live with. I do understand that, because I'm a woman in patrarchy. And because I'm a woman I constantly live with that people like me are dehumanised, erased etc. And we have no other place to escape to. As long as we live in patriarchy, we have to live with never knowing when we come across sexism in attitudes or violence. Like when you, Andrew, sit on in KZread videos and discuss with other men how much you have to care about if a man actually is quilty of rape or not, when I as a woman know that this was not just an attack on an individual but an attack he wouldn't have done to a man, and would've done to other women - hence an attack on womem. For you as a man not to see that it is just as much about you and that you should take responsibility to realte to it being aware and emphatic man in patrarchy, is in my eyes sexist. Just as well as I as someone not jewish or arabic has to relate to the situation with the awareness of antisemitism in the world. Although this doesn't mean that you and I come to the the same conclusions in specific situations. What I have written now is the essence of conclusions after decades of living with this conflict in my heart, trying to communicate with many different ppl living in it. My view is in constant review, but this is what still seems true to me. The world doesn't hold the Israli state to a higher standard. It holds it to a humane standard and the world reacts to inhumane acts conducted bluntly and openly. There are many unjust things happening in the world and they need to be exposed, but Israeli actions are made openly and the world can't not react against them.

@BodilWandt

7 ай бұрын

And; even if most people see Hamas as a terrorist group, most poeple also understand clearly that the Palestinian people since long are submitted to constant violence, including threat of violence. Most people can see.that they are in a chronic but ongoing acute need to defend themselves. So the reaction to Hamas first recent attack this time was horror and empathy for Israeli civilians. And even if most people know that Palestine is in the need of liberation, they reacted against Hamas choice of methods. But when Israel is reacting with thousand times heavier violence with injuries and terror to an uncountable amount of civilians, Irael confirms the need for Palestine's liberation. To stand up for the Palestinian people's need for liberation is not antisemitism and its not alignment with extremists. It is a humane. You getting stuck in trying to understand why many people don't sympathise win the Israeli state's way towards Palestine and its people, can seem to be out of proportion, and I think it is, but I do think that you do that from this trauma driven state of righteousness being filled with what has been (and is) done to jewish people and not capable of having an adequate empathy for others. It wasn't the Holocaust wasn't the Palestinian's doing, but they have paid the price ever since. The whole world needs to rise above this and seek healing from both the Holocaust and the Israel-Palestine "conflict".

@luchseterna

22 күн бұрын

Woke pseudo psychologic feminist leftist bla bla. Israel MUST defend itself as it has been constantly attacked by arabs. Thank God the intelligence, allies and technology it has maintained its independence. Certainly not because of these leftist woke protestors who think Palestinians are innocent nice people. Indoctrination in Gaza has been pushed by HAMAS and UNRWA and we all are guilty of having been blind about their violence and antisemitism. Iranians who fled the islamist Iran are all pro Israel, because they KNOW. Palestinians living in Israel speak against HAMAS, but leftist media ignores these voices. "Son of HAMAS" and many more talk about the horrible violence in Gaza. These people are not civilised. Don't compare Israel to those. Israel is defending its population and country and trying to destroy the enemy and in the end perhaps free the hostages. HAMAS is using civilians as a human shield, there are plenty of interviews where IDF is trying to get people evacuated but they refuse. HAMAS is a death cult.

Protesting to stop the killing of civilians is not the same as being anti-Israel. Also, protests to support Palestine are banned in some European countries? What else do you want? People to stay silent to they don't bother Israel while it commits war crimes.

@user-bb5cz2qw3t

7 ай бұрын

If you are so tone-deaf that you do not get why Germany banned such "peaceful" protests where Israeli flags were burned and crowds were chanting gas the Jews, then you should really open a history book!

@marinalachtarnik1906

7 ай бұрын

1. Protest is much easier than find an alternative solution. I bet you don’t have any alternative solution that will promise safety to Israeli citizens. 2. When protesting uses slogans that call to destroy Israel- it IS anti-Israeli. It IS antisemitism. No need to wash words because it IS. 3. When Jews afraid to get out of their homes, go to school or collages it DOES mean there is antisemitism.

You really should use the cable clips provided with the mic stands! 😉

@AndrewGold1

7 ай бұрын

now i'm going to obsess about that!

@thekeysman6760

7 ай бұрын

@@AndrewGold1 No, that'll be me! 😂

The problem is absolutely about a bad race: HUMANS

@user-yc9vx3nz5z

6 ай бұрын

Nope. This is such a white person thing to say.

Andrew, just a suggestion but I think it would be a very good thing if you could interview Max Blumenthal. He's a journalist, and he is an American Jewish man. You and Max may have different views but I think it would be great a great interview. I understand why you may be bias , and most of the people who you have interviewed all have the same views that you have. It would be great to see a different view of the Israel and Palestine' .

@AndrewGold1

7 ай бұрын

Could be good, I wouldn't say no to that kind of discussion. The guy who went on Piers Morgan was really good too...wouldn't know how to get hold of though.

@user-yc9vx3nz5z

6 ай бұрын

@@AndrewGold1 Max Blumenthal loves to side with extremists and imperialists while presenting himself as an anti-imperialist. His show Grayzone is always defending China and extremist groups.

Andy McDonald got suspended from the Labour Party for saying this “ we won’t rest until we have justice, until all the people, Israeli’s and Palestinians, between the river and the sea can live in peaceful liberty “ what he was actually suspended for was the between the river and the sea bit. It is not being used in an anti-Semitic way in the protests, the phrase from the river to the sea is being used to mean literally from the West Bank to Gaza. In this way the protesters are also supporting people in the West Bank who have nothing to do with Hamas, yet approximately 300 civilians in the West Bank, many of them children have been killed by the Israeli military this year.

@donpietruk1517

7 ай бұрын

I still think it comes across as anti-semitic because of how Hamas intends it. If the protestors want to make it clear they aren't being anti-semitic they need to come up with something different. I understand expressing support for the Palestinian people but that chant would have chilling implications to me if I were Jewish.

@andalltheangelssay212

7 ай бұрын

@@donpietruk1517 you’ve got a point in that the protesters could come up with a different chant to show that they are protesting about the 4000 children killed by Israelis in the last few weeks and the collective punishment and deaths of civilians, then they could distance themselves from any connection with anti semitism connotation and the media would then be unable to label them as anti semites or chanting hate speak. But if they are chanting it in an innocent way (and in London last weekend many Jewish people joined the half a million protesting and chanted with them and held up signs saying not in our name) they probably feel that they should be able to chant it without being labelled in any way.

@andalltheangelssay212

7 ай бұрын

@@donpietruk1517 I get your point but don’t you think it is awful that labour suspended someone for saying “until all the people, Israelis and Palestinians, between the river and the sea can live in peace and liberty”? He was calling for peace and liberty for both Israelis and Palestinians.

@donpietruk1517

7 ай бұрын

@@andalltheangelssay212 I would agree given how the statement was qualified that the suspension is harsh. With the added verbage it doesn't come across as anti-semitic to me and seems to express support for democracy and liberty.

@deedee7780

7 ай бұрын

Clearly, this channel is pushing misinformation and zionist propaganda and hiis audience is too ill-informed to realize it. Thanks for your intelligent comment!!

Surrounded by How many muslim countries!?

Free Palestine.

@urgadurga

7 ай бұрын

You forgot to complete the sentence. You mean "Free Palestine from Hamas" right?

@margaretthatcher6828

7 ай бұрын

@@urgadurga Correct.

@hypatiaalex

7 ай бұрын

@@urgadurga free palestine and the world from the zionist/terrorist state israel

@mathildestoltz4260

7 ай бұрын

What is palestine?

Its not anti israel. Its anti excessive violence. Nobody expected Israel to not respond. Its like a mate who was mugged and caught the thief and was excessively beating them. Any friend eould step in and say, comenon mate.

@AndrewGold1

7 ай бұрын

The friend might step in and say 'hang on, you might wanna give those 200 hostages back' to the first guy though, too?

@Egos_Altar

7 ай бұрын

@@AndrewGold1 another great reason to not flatten place? They can find nazi war criminals living in Argentina for years, they can find their hostages. They are doing what they want to do. I understand that, I really do. Are they on mission creep? 100% come on Andrew. Oct 7th was truly awful, shocking and inexcusable. So is this IMO.

@MrFeezy91

7 ай бұрын

@@AndrewGold1 How many Palestinians including 100's of children does Israel hold without charge. It's very interesting how everything seemed to have started on 7th October. How about the dozens of children killed by settlers and IDF in the West Bank this year before 7th October? You might truly be genuine and try to be fair and balanced, I hope you bring some one who knows the history and what's happening.

@luchseterna

22 күн бұрын

​@MrFeezy91 You are certainly not balanced. The teenagers in Israeli prisons are there for terrorist acts. You get into jail in any country for stabbing. Listen to "son of HAMAS" who was imprisoned as a teenager and experienced the horrible violence of HAMAS already as a child. Islamist indoctrination don't make innocent civilians, but shahids.

The moment you start censoring criticism is the moment you've lost, remember that, Andrew! And it will do you no good because I always take screenshots immediately after posting comments, fully aware that criticism that hits the bullseye doesn't do your cause any favours, it might well get a few, though not most, thinking, and those seeds of doubt can actually spread over time. Deleting criticism is the worst thing anyone can do, a bit like disposing of incriminating evidence; doing so makes the accused look all the more guilty! I leave it out there, and you can bet I receive a lot more criticism than you do, when you're in the minority it comes with the territory! If I were to delete such criticism, it would make me look intellectually weak, incapable of defending my views, but I am confident I can always defend them because I don't deal in contradiction, hypocrisy, double-standards, bias, my views are consistent across issues--as long as that is the case one remains on solid ground! Your reaction, resorting to questioning the intelligence of your critics instead of continuing with the debate, is due to the fact that your arguments are built on shifting sand, you are not equipped to defend them, unnoticeable to the kind of subscribers you attract, but to anyone who considers issues at a deeper level, considers background, history, context--those of us you dismiss as trolls--your reasoning on issues caves in on itself!

@squanchysquanch1840

7 ай бұрын

Look at you, still waffling on. Lol I’m not even a regular viewer of Andrew, I watch maybe 25% of his content, yet you label anyone who disagrees with your self aggrandizing drivel as some Andrew fanboy. Making sweeping conclusions about people you don’t even know, and engaging in bad faith rhetoric. You just can’t help yourself. It’s no wonder why reasonable folks wouldn’t want to engage with you in conversation, you’re absolutely full of yourself and see anyone who disagrees with you as below your clearly sky high level of intellect. Lmfao I’ve never run into a more intolerably tiresome person in KZread comments, and I’ve done my fair share of browsing comment sections 🤣

@melissaelliott325

4 ай бұрын

Thank you for saying this -I have had comments that were very fair but not in agreement to the views he states be deleted as well. I do like his show for the most part and watched lots of his content but this video and others really turned me off.

@MusiciansWithVision

4 ай бұрын

​@@melissaelliott325 For me it confirmed suspicions I was already forming; certain things he said, every now and again he would reveal the fact that he is more biased than he lets on. And regarding the Israel?Gaza issue, he tried his best to minimise his Zionist perspective, but Zionism is such an all consuming ideology he couldn't keep it up, and when I confronted him directly he did eventually respond. I was actually quite surprised that he resorted to extremely childish personal abuse, no attempt to undermine my criticisms, which can only be interpreted one way, he was stumped by how accurate my criticisms were. he's intelligent enough to know I, for one, could see past the facade, that I detected the underlying bias, the self-serving motives, the sense of entitlement, his belief that he has all the right answers, but anyone who presents himself as having absolute infallible insight into just about every issue under the sun is driven by a massive ego not compassion for his fellow man! He does believe in free speech, his own, and those who hang on his every word, but he feels contempt towards those who dare to exercise free speech that undermines his perspective. Most of these platforms are about ego, even those that seem to say the right things; subscribers to these channel are just an audience and nothing more, their role to fawn, to suck up, to feed a narcissistic ego!

LGBTQ+AA must stand with Palastein. Free Palatine, let their LGBTQ community have their Voice.

@TheBeautifulWindsofAragon

7 ай бұрын

You would not survive one day under Hamas ruling.

@squanchysquanch1840

7 ай бұрын

@@TheBeautifulWindsofAragon it’s gotta be satire, lol. Or they are implying that Palestinians should be freed from Hamas

@corneliadumitru6568

7 ай бұрын

Of course, they have their "voice". It is equal with "chickens for KFC", but go ahead! No, far better, they should go to Gaza - the southtern part, or at the border in Egypt and show support. It would be interesting how long the community lasts there. Interesting!

@lorna7338

7 ай бұрын

This is a dark theory but it could be the trans community themselves were the ones who's idea it was to hold a pride party so near the border with hamaz HQ. The objective was human trafficking women all along.

So why doesn’t he go back there and try to make things better? That’s where he’s from after all. So he can stay in the west and live the good life but still self-righteously ‘identify’ with Nigeria? And critique the West while he’s at it? Give me a break, Buddy.

Yetanyahoo created the hamas😂

@menid2691

7 ай бұрын

Iran did. Hamas are their lap dogs, even inferior to Hezbollah which the Iranians prefer because Hamas are Sunni and the Iranians are not

@mathildestoltz4260

7 ай бұрын

Not true. Where are your proofs?

@eyeswideopen7777

7 ай бұрын

@@mathildestoltz4260 do it your self lazy 🦥

@luchseterna

22 күн бұрын

No, HAMAS was created in Egypt. Just another islamist terrorist group, like Hisbollah.

Whenever I hear arguments above carbon dioxide I am always reminded that it makes up no more than 0.04% of the Earth's atmosphere.

Are you sure about that? Aren't there bigger fish to attack?

@morticiag

7 ай бұрын

You don't get bigger fish than Islam my dear. Israel is the ONLY Non-Muslim country in the entire Middle East and North Africa region... They are like a tiny island SURROUNDED by a Sea of Sharks.

@morticiag

7 ай бұрын

Remind me again WHO atta'cked first and Targeted innocent, unar'med civilians who were enjoying their holiday ? Who hun'ted down and killled innocent people, many were families ? Who ra'ped the women and children, paraded the German tourist na'ked in the streets and then be'hea'ded her ? Who Be'hea'ded 80 Je'wish babies? Who is Still holding many Israelis and tourists hostage, many of whom are women , babies and children ? Who went out onto the streets the next day to celebrate 🥳🥳 their so called "Victory" ? And the day after that, who is Now crying "VICTIM!!". because Israel DARED to Re'taliate?? Israel actually gives them WARNINGS where it will send it's bo'mb's (to des'troy their ars'ena'ls). They deliberately use their own people as human shields to gain your Sympathy and support.... Why are you Supporting such M'on'grels??

@morticiag

7 ай бұрын

Why don't you tell me how many Muslim dominant countries exist in the World? 50? And how many Je'wish countries exist in the world? 1?

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

And? This proves what exactly? @@morticiag

@morticiag

7 ай бұрын

@@denemessina8601 Which one of the many questions I posed are you answering to ?

Rele sad bro context and critical thinking .....😊 Go ahead and sit in your Tower bro I'll be down here with the rest of the unwashed masses you can be special❤ I understand it's so clear🙄

Andrew…honestly… I listened to you both talk. After you agreed that Israel was bigger and stronger….you said “when you look at the map Israel is this tiny little country” surrounded by great big Arab states. That has nothing to do with the incredible power imbalance between Israel and Gaza. It is this circular logic that reveals Zionism as a cult. You sounded like two Scientologists speaking cult language. You have to take a look at Zionism as a cult. Please. Thanks

@deedee7780

7 ай бұрын

This guy is a propagandist just like the rest of the "mainstream media" he likes to call out. I am very disappointed to see he is nothing but a hypocrite and a wolf in sheep's clothing. Thanks for calling him out!!

@khylerin70

7 ай бұрын

101%. Absolutely 101%.

@mathildestoltz4260

7 ай бұрын

100 % wrong

@khylerin70

7 ай бұрын

@@mathildestoltz4260 yeah, righto. Aren't we lucky we have the right to discuss each other's views without the undeniable consequence we'd be certainly executed for it by hamas et al for doing so. I don't know what your beliefs are or where you reside but I've never been more glad to have no religious beliefs and to live in Australia 👍🥳. The whole middle east has become a faulty self cleaning oven 😖😝

@mathildestoltz4260

7 ай бұрын

@@khylerin70 and because of that you believe in nazipropaganda?

From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free!!!

@TheBeautifulWindsofAragon

7 ай бұрын

And pray, what do you think that means?

@menid2691

7 ай бұрын

From whom? Who gets to stay? Do Palestinian Jews get to stay? What about the Druze? What about the Baha'i? Should the Arabs that moved in the 19th century from countries like Syria and Lebanon be kicked out? Are we doing this in other countries too? Should Canada be freed of non indigenous? What about South America from the Spanish? Should I go on?

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

@carinacosta-correa8355 Erm... it means what it says. It is the cry of hope and pain from the oppressed. Where does it say "exterminate all Jews"? I mean, maybe I'm missing a Stanza or 2, but given where it starts, " exterminate all Jews" would pretty much wreck the rhyming scheme and is tonally incongruous. On a more serious note, you wont even let them write poetry about being invaded by a hostile colonial force that ravage your rights and steal everything you own and having lived under an iron fist for decades? That's pretty mean-spirited...@@TheBeautifulWindsofAragon

@deedee7780

7 ай бұрын

@@menid2691 That phrase calls for sovereignty and not having to live in an open air prison. There are indigenous jews, christians along with muslims that consider themselves Palestinian. Please stop drinking the Kool-Aid.

@TheBeautifulWindsofAragon

7 ай бұрын

@@denemessina8601 Poetry? You sincerely do not know what Hamas is about? Their Charter? Hamas does not want a two state solution, but to create an Islamist state. Naive people in Europe don't seem to get that they're not very different from ISIS.

In every conflict between Hamas (not the whole of Palestine) and Israel, the more civil victims come from Gaza. It has always been like this. And is blooshed. Dont come with rigtheous commentary about nations politics when children are being killed without mercy, even those who were in the supposed safe zone.

@TheBeautifulWindsofAragon

7 ай бұрын

It is always the Palestinian leadership that has gone against a two state solution, sometimes in the eleventh hour and terrorism comes from the Palestinian side.

@urgadurga

7 ай бұрын

Yes. One side has a modern military and air force, the other is so ill-equipped they hide underground, don't distinguish themselves from civilians, and hide among and under civilians to offset their technological inferiority. Even most other terrorist groups like Hezbollah are way better equipped and trained compared to Hamas. In WW2, the Germans suffered a disproportionate amount of casualties compared to the Brits and Americans. Does that mean they were the better side? Does the firebombing of Dresden and Tokyo, the atom bombings of Nagasaki and Hiroshima make Imperial Japan and Nazi Germany the poor innocent victims in the war? Or is it a reality that war is brutal and disgusting and should be avoided. Germany and Imperial Japan provoked those wars. Hamas provoked this one. They could've avoided the bloodshed if they weren't so aggressive. Andrew repeatedly says he mourns the loss of innocent Palestinian life. Those lives wouldn't be lost if Hamas weren't hiding with or under them. Those lives wouldn't be lost if Hamas would allow them to follow the IDF's REPEATED, CONSTANT orders to evacuate. Those lives wouldn't be lost if Hamas didn't break a ceasefire and commit a heinous terrorist attack. Those lives wouldn't be lost if the Palestinian Authority or Hamas would agree to Israel's multiple deals to give them a sovereign state and negotiate peace, something Israel has attempted numerous times in the past 20 years alone, which has been rejected outright. Every. Single. Time. You're mad about Palestinian deaths? So am I, so is Andrew, so is every other Jew. You should be mad at Hamas for sacrificing their own people and being unwilling to negotiate peace and land for the entirety of their existence, and all the Palestinian authorities before them who've enabled and encouraged this senseless bloodshed.

@corneliadumitru6568

7 ай бұрын

Well, I ask, based on a personal known example. I had a friend who married a Palestinian and went to Gaza, in or around 2018. Didn't she know where she was going? Next: the population in Gaza voted Hamas in 2007. After that they agreed to be ruled by them, and even to die for them. Point: would you agree that I build tunnels under your house, and use them for shooting, say, innocent bypassers? I don't think so. This is why I believe there are no innocent civilians in Gaza. Mind you, I began with "I had a friend". On 8 October she phoned me, screeching with happiness about what Hamas has done, and thereafter she phoned several others while whining that "oh, they now are bombed, she needs to get out" and we should show solidarity with their "cause". Interesting. I believe in Gaza are terrorist, terrorists in training, and children brought up to become terrorists in training. I heard lots of stories before October 7 from her for several years, this year, and I continue to refuse her calls. She is just as perfidous as all of them.

@menid2691

7 ай бұрын

You're punishing Israel for protecting its citizens and rewarding Hamas for putting theirs at risk. Israel invests a lot of money on protecting its citizens and Hamas doesn't. Would you feel better if Israel turned off its Iron Dome? Israel would have many more casualties that way because all of the Hamas rockets target civilian populations as opposed to IDF airstrikes that target terrorists. Think of it this way, Hamas has so many tunnels that it could easily place all the civilians there and they could be safe for years. When asked why they don't do that, Hamas said that it's the UN and Israel's job to protect the civilians, not theirs

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

Hmmmm.... easy to say this stuff, but the last time Palestine tried to peacefully protest, you shot them. So, erm, what would you do in their circumstances?@@TheBeautifulWindsofAragon

Some of your subscribers are attacking Greta Thunberg over her mental health issues, as though that disqualifies her from engaging in protest, but I say anyone who has mental health issues yet doesn't allow them to stop her from going out there and taking on the world, that's something awe-inspiring not something to be contemptuously ridiculed! And you are all expecting those who struggle with such millstones to be perfect in word, thought and action, so what say you, with your intact mental capacities, are your thoughts, words and actions always without fault???

@khylerin70

7 ай бұрын

Even when they are misinformed, manipulated and inflammatory?. What, everyone gets a platform regardless of actual awareness?. Get real, little wonder the world's a shemozzle. Stand by your comment when an unqualified speaker engenders enough bleeding heart support to affect, really affect you, yours, your thing's and your world. I don't care who or what, unqualified attention seekers with obvious limitations of reasoning or actual qualified ability must be kept out of influencing serious geopolitical matters. End of section.

@AndrewGold1

7 ай бұрын

well it's their free speech.

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

Yeah absolutely. After all, Bibi is a psychopath and it seems everybody here laps up his insane ravings with gusto, he's made it to quite a high position, despite having a non-functional anterior insular cortex. So why isn't it fine for Greta , who's divergence is not a dangerous one that makes her into a sadist.? What's sauce for the goose, as they say.......

@janeslater8004

7 ай бұрын

Autism is not a mental health condition its a learning and social understanding communication disability .

@MusiciansWithVision

7 ай бұрын

@@AndrewGold1 So you are now defending their right to MOCK those with Mental Health Issue? In fact, not just defending it, but encouraging it! And you actually see yourself as serving a more valid purpose than Great Thunberg, bet you wish you received even a fraction of the attention she receives, so what exactly is it you are achieving, other than catering to, reinforcing, the bigoted views of those who lack the analytical skills to think things through! You're not exactly reaching an audience of intellectuals are you, Andrew, your audience is susceptible, easily impressed, happiest when bleating in unison, even sycophantic; do you admire that in your subscribers, are those the sort of qualities you set out to encourage, is that the sort of admiration you respect? Wouldn't you feel were achieving more if it were those who examine issues on a far deeper level who being drawn to your output? Consider the following Trump has, is it impressive or does it speak volumes about the widespread ignorance of well over one third of the American population? Well, that's pretty much how I view your dismissive attitude towards your critics, how I view the mindset of those who come to your defence, discounting every single point I present! Those who come to your defence do not have any of the credentials one would hope for in a defence witness!

You're header is a tad misleading, also are you conflating Hamas with Palestine? Most Palestinians are civilians. Of course Slogans aren't complicated, slogans are slogans, their not bloody essays.

Look whos deleting comments.

@AndrewGold1

7 ай бұрын

Certainly not me. Never delete them, it's my policy. They delete automatically for whatever crazy reason. I certainly don't have the time to go through deleting them, as my channel gets 100s per hour. I happened to see this one though and set the record straight.

@Tomtaylor7337

7 ай бұрын

KZread actually deletes comments, its not the KZreadrs , its KZread themselves, they even unsubscribe you from certain channels ....

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

Hey when you get a chance @@AndrewGold1 I'd like a chat about this. In private if you prefer.

@Rick_Cleland

7 ай бұрын

@@Tomtaylor7337 *_KZread / Google_* arbitrarily either deletes comments after about ten seconds or you have to sort by "Newest first" to see some of them.

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

It's alright my dudes, i've got the whole feed, i'll set up a burner d.m for anyone who wants it. It's quite revealing.@@Rick_Cleland

Remi said this: "According to this ideology, oppressed groups are the weaker, poorer groups who have little or no power because they have been deprived of this by the Oppressors. Oppressed groups are fundamentally noble while Oppressor groups are fundamentally not so. " He then argues that this is not always the case, and not in Israel. I wonder if he could give me an example of a case where an illegally invading colonial force with vastly superior weaponry, the backing of the U.S and operating an apartheid regime were the good guys, the natives were the bad guys and this arrangement was actually for the good of both the oppressor and the oppressed. Can he actually tell us when invading a country and stealing everything that belongs to it's citizens, including their freedom and human rights is a morally positive act?

@morticiag

7 ай бұрын

Answer me a riddle, please? Remind me again WHO atta'cked first and Targeted innocent, unar'med civilians who were enjoying their holiday ? Who hun'ted down and killled innocent people, many were families ? Who ra'ped the women and children, paraded the German tourist na'ked in the streets and then be'hea'ded her ? Who Be'hea'ded 80 Je'wish babies? Who is Still holding many Israelis and tourists hostage, many of whom are women , babies and children ? Who went out onto the streets the next day to celebrate 🥳🥳 their so called "Victory" ? And the day after that, who is Now crying "VICTIM!!". because Israel DARED to Re'taliate?? Israel actually gives them WARNINGS where it will send it's bo'mb's (to des'troy their ars'ena'ls). They deliberately use their own people as human shields to gain your Sympathy and support.... Why are you Supporting such M'on'grels??

@morticiag

7 ай бұрын

Was there a country in the USA before the Europeans went to America ? Tell me, what was this country called that the Europeans stole America from? Which of the many Warring tribes ran this country? What did it's flag look like? What did it's constitution look like? Did it have a national anthem ? Edit: I misread your OP and thought the quote was comparing Israel and the USA. This is why I'm asking you about USA ... anyway, Israel was Colo'nised by the current Muslims living there .... don't Forget.

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

Welll then.. Are you so daft that you think I approve of any of the actions you just described? The U.S are easilly as bad as Israel ,as are the UK....I dont like colonialism, genocide and ethnic cleansing .Dont you understand?@@morticiag You've just reinforced my point. Maybe you're just too amoral to realise how you soun: Like you think 2 wrongs make a right. Tells me all I need to know about you. That might be acceptable to you and Yahweh, but it's not to anyone who isn't a sociopath. You might wanna write that down, to save you future embarrassment.

@TheBeautifulWindsofAragon

7 ай бұрын

Can we stop the invading narrative? Israel exists for soon to be 70 years on a piece of land smaller than Wales. There were always a Jewish population there, even if they were the minority.Yes, things happened when Israel became a state that were not fair and should be corrected, but what other people inherit refugee status and what do you say about other people throughout history that have been forced to move?

@morticiag

7 ай бұрын

@@TheBeautifulWindsofAragon Israel was Israel before Jesus was born. The Je'ws lost it to the gentiles and they wanted it back. It is their Home. Palestinians are ARABS and Egyptians and Assyrians who came from neighbouring countries. Is it Fair that the entire Middle East is Colonised by Islam but the only One place that isn't ruled by Islam is continually haras'sed and a'ssa'ulted?

Maybe so.. But Israel's cumulative actions and policies over the years has lost them any friends they ever had in the Middle East.. And now most of the world.

@brucewu3781

7 ай бұрын

They never had any friends in the Middle East. Israel has been under attack since it was formally returned to the Jewish People 75 years ago.

@TheBeautifulWindsofAragon

7 ай бұрын

That's the intention of Hamas. Forcing Israel to retaliate in such a way that people look just at that and not why they did what they did. Hamas does not want a two state solution. They want to wipe Israel off the map and in that struggle 10000 dead people on their side is a price they are more than willing to pay.

@manofwar2354

7 ай бұрын

There is no friend to them in middle east ,people hate them because they are land thives

@menid2691

7 ай бұрын

Actions like what? Signing 6 peace deals and giving up land for peace?

@nokandu5684

7 ай бұрын

@@menid2691 giving up land that they stole.. We did the same for Native Americans and you don't see them complaining. What a nice person you are..

Take a look at the live feed folks, where Andrew tells us that he believes in collective punishment. Shame you wouldnt debate and just tried to shut us down instead. You and your cronies come off as very disingenuous and tried every diversion and troll tactic instead of engagment. Jojo even accused me of misgendering them, because I refered to them as she, as i'm on a chromebook and cant see their tiny pic ... But saying "she" once to someone with no stated pronoun was to them deliberate misgendering. Only it wasnt, and you should be ashamed Jojo. As should you Andrew. Dont you think people cant see through that kind of behaviour? It's the behaviour of those who cannot morally justify their position

@toldyouso5588

7 ай бұрын

If these gazans want to live they can flee south. The IDF will not chase them down like the ham-asites did to their victims on Oct. 7.. By staying these gazan fools are stubbornly invoking their free right to die, like in Canada today.

Actually, I do know what FREEDOM OF SPEECH means, it means freedom of YOUR speech, freedom of speech for all those who agree with YOUR point of view, those who stroke your brow, Andrew Gold, so you were mistaken when you suggested I'm ignorant in that department! And disagreeing with you doesn't automatically make someone a troll, doesn't automatically make someone ignorant, naive, smug, superior; how on Earth did an intelligent guy like yourself (that's right, I don't doubt your intelligence even though you question mine) arrive at such an absurd conclusion, have you picked that cop out reaction up from those who don't know any better?

@seelenvogelxx6650

7 ай бұрын

It seems like you desperately need help with your vision. It is blurred to the point of incomprehension….. Freedom of speech clearly does NOT include hate speech and discrimination….. Not sure what universe you are living in…. certainly not mine thank god…..

@Monkey114

7 ай бұрын

Trump does hate speech everyday?

@MusiciansWithVision

7 ай бұрын

@@seelenvogelxx6650 There you go, equating freedom of speech, alternative viewpoints, with hate speech; another cop out response!!!

@Rick_Cleland

7 ай бұрын

@@Monkey114 _Huh...??_

@squanchysquanch1840

7 ай бұрын

@@MusiciansWithVision looks like Andrew really triggered you mate lol. I’d say he seems to be spot on with recognizing your ignorance

Lol. Ru going to gaslight us into thinking we are anti semites again? Palestinians are semites too. Israel could be any ethnic state and textbook genocide definition would remain the same

@franklin519

7 ай бұрын

Israel just wants to exist. The Arabs create all this hate and carnage. Islam is a religion of ☠️💀

@denemessina8601

7 ай бұрын

It never works though does it?Especially when Jews who don't support the Zionist agenda are also labelled as an antisemite by these semi-useful idiots. Never mind, Andrew spoke up eventually and told everybody on stream that he supports collective punishment and that killing non-combatant women and kids is ok as long as they're Palestinians. Very brave to utterly stand by your man like that. Even in warcime. Even in evil. That's true love, T.T. These people are too evil to be conscious of how awful what they are saying is.

@menid2691

7 ай бұрын

Jews are Palestinian too

@Tucker_Tries

7 ай бұрын

​@@denemessina8601are you saying Andrew is my man? I'm so confused lol. To be clear this is a strong condemnation of Andrews rhetoric

@Tucker_Tries

7 ай бұрын

​@@franklin519ok now let's hear you substantiate those words, I'm ready to back mine