Dude, i just love both 2012's Judas: Tim's voice was anger and pain while Josh was a force of nature suffering for a man. Trully amazing

Oh my god this is so unsatisfying to watch because for every clip I wait for the "GET OUT, THEY'RE WAITING" and it never comes

@alexinitalics188

2 ай бұрын

Yes, we need a compilation of that part next to watch immediately after 😅

Jérôme's Judas has a special place in my heart I don't know why he just shows so much emotion

@RAZZM4T4ZZ

Жыл бұрын

I don't want to see more Jérôme pradon hate

@madamemaximoff9838

Жыл бұрын

@@RAZZM4T4ZZ same! He may have difficulty hitting some high notes but he is amazing at hitting those low notes and his acting 😍 I love him as Judas, he show so much love for Jesus and I honestly love how during the arrest he never looks Jesus in the eye after he kisses him, when the other apostles start waking up and start singing” What’s the buzz tell me what’s a happening” Judas just kind of falls into Jesus’s arms and cry’s because of the guilt and my heartbreaks when the guards pull them away from each other and Jesus reaches out to Judas, they have such great chemistry between each other especially in that scene

@csh43166

Жыл бұрын

I very much enjoy Jerome's performance as Judas! ❤️

My favorites are definitely Carl Anderson, Fred Johanson and Josh Young. Just the right amount of fury, tragedy and excellent vocals without any overacting. Side note: Anderson's maintenance of his voice despite being older is absolutely wonderful. Man had brilliant technique.

@Phasmania

Жыл бұрын

If you haven’t already, watch Carl Anderson’s 2003 Heaven on Their Minds performance, which was just months before he sadly passed from leukemia. It genuinely rivals his original 72 version, dare I say it’s better. I’ve never seen a vocalist stay just as good and maybe get better that many years later

Do you think you could do the climax of Trial Before Pilate? "DOOOOOON'T LET ME STOP YOUR GREAT SELF DESTRUCTIOOOONNN"

@pollypockets508

3 жыл бұрын

What do you mean by that?

@oldmanbillybob8513

3 жыл бұрын

That is not an answer

@victormeyers1860

3 жыл бұрын

@@oldmanbillybob8513 you’re deep in trouble, friend

@oldmanbillybob8513

3 жыл бұрын

@@victormeyers1860 Someone Christ king of the jews

@michaelwilliamybarra2409

3 жыл бұрын

Here's one that may suffice, I think! kzread.info/dash/bejne/i4SCtq6ndM2YgKw.html

I have such a love for Zubin Varla’s interpretation, especially this section. He’s angry, sure, but he still maintains his voice without going too hard-which is a bit too easy to do as Judas/Jesus in this show.

Murray Head (Original Judas) might not be as vocally impressive as others- but his original interpretation of the role and vocal choices influenced everyone to come, especially Carl Anderson. He’s an amazing character actor and we would not have any of these amazing Judas performances as we know the role to be without his tortured approach. ❤️

Ramin Karimloo is one of the most talented singers I know, and you could tell he struggled a little to hit the notes. Just goes to show how hard of a role this is.

@JD-ht7yw

2 жыл бұрын

Sounded rough

@anonymoususer2271

2 жыл бұрын

11:55

@josefcamilleri6934

2 жыл бұрын

@@anonymoususer2271 thanks yes it was recorded studio performance but Ramin is an all rounder ....great performance all of them it s not an easy track ...

@josefcamilleri6934

2 жыл бұрын

@@JD-ht7yw recorded

@Spannie

Жыл бұрын

Not the song for him in my opinion.

Please can you do "everyone I look at you I don't understand... you'd have managed better if you had it planned"? It's my favourite Judas bit and I'd love to see a comparison of each performer's take on it!

4:18 Carl Anderson kinda looks like: "Okay, all this pushing is extremely unnecessary for my taste, but, it's on the revival script, so Imma just push Jesus a lil' bit" lol. Compared to Jerome's version of "The Push" at 3:57, C. Anderson's look kinda tame, but that's because he is an old school judas, and back then it was more of a psychological fight than a flat out AGGRESSION XD.

Interesting to see the changes between "someone HAD to turn you in" and "someone HAS to turn you in", like the former is an admission of guilt as jesus obviously sees it

Zubin Varla is so underrated. In fact, I think the entire 1996 London Revival is severely underrated.

@madisonjones632

2 жыл бұрын

HERE HERE. It’s my favorite overall album and Zubin is the best Judas IMO

@rachels2560

2 жыл бұрын

It's the recording I grew up on, and I adoooore it!

@Phasmania

5 ай бұрын

Still tragic that there are no recordings of him performing live at all

Yes, I will be commenting how much I love Josh Young on all your videos.

@antonellamR2D2

2 жыл бұрын

He's great!

Carl Anderson, Jerome Pradon sing while still managing to take advantage of the hard consonants and high trills to express the fury of the moment. I notice most tend to err more toward trying to sing pretty or playing the emotion so much they don't sing well at all. Also shoutout to Peter Johansen, Tim Minchin, and Ricardo Afonso.

My personal favorites are Zubin Varla, Carl Anderson, Peter Johansson, Josh Young and Tim Minchin 🤩

@CharcoalLord

3 жыл бұрын

As much as I like Tony Vincent’s performance as Judas I prefer him as Simon in film of year 2000

@theDENIMMAN

2 жыл бұрын

Zubin Varla is just so damn good

Carl Anderson…hands down. Thankful I got to see him do it twice live

I live for Tim minchin.

This whole section is no joke my favorite part in the entire score!!! Though Carl Anderson and Brandon Victor Dixon are my favorite Judas’s My personal favorite rendition of this part is Tim Minchin’s. He brings such particularly strong and emotion to it! Some honorable mentions though are Zubin Varla, Tony Vincent, and Josh Young

@amenra13

Жыл бұрын

I agree with what you said, but I also think Timothy Walton @10:14 deserves an honorable mention as well. Cheers for your assessment overall.

Serkan Kaya is an amazing performer, so nice to see him here! I think Josh Young will be forever my favourite Judas, his rendition of Judas Death was phenomenal!

3:22 is pilates from the 2000 movie

Awesome! It was only very recently that I discovered how amazing this show was. I grew up Jewish, so I never learned anything about Judas whatsoever as a kid. (I learned a lot of that stuff later on Wikipedia. Lol). But it was only when they aired the U.K. arena tour here on KZread a few months ago that I finally ‘got’ it. Like, oh, this is what this show is. THIS is why people love it. This musical is incredible. Lol

@legendaryTMNICO

2 жыл бұрын

Let’s go Brandon

@daneschmidt3706

2 жыл бұрын

@@legendaryTMNICO Why is that relevant here?

Tim Minchin's is actually my favorite

Can you do a comparison of 'if you'd had it planned' that is the impressive phrase in this song

Carl Anderson Dying of cancer he is still the amazeballs guy to beat

@masarusenpai1952

2 жыл бұрын

But he didn't get cancer. He had leukemia

The Swedish version sounds like Judas calls him a "simple little shoe" and that's now my favorite thing. 10:05

@alvedonaren

3 жыл бұрын

The actual ine is "simpel liten tjuv" which means "simple little thief".

@cococovers1333

2 жыл бұрын

it is "simpel liten tjuv" which means "simple little thief"

@cococovers1333

2 жыл бұрын

@Pe Anthony Norico it's actually the line "like a common criminal"

3:43 he sounds like a cartoon villain

@Sharpe1502

2 жыл бұрын

He does. I love that version so much. It’s so over the top. 😂

@rachels2560

2 жыл бұрын

Jerome gets pretty screechy by the end, but I adore him and that version. 😂

4.18 in 2003 Carl Anderson 1 year prior to his death in this tour he had a car accident when he was going to perform and doctor diagnosed him with leckumia great singer Rip Great Judas

I love Zubin Varla’s Judas, the 1996 soundtrack is my favorite to listen to!

@milliemaran1039

3 жыл бұрын

For me: the 1996 album and the concept album(brown album)

@TheRabidWolverine

3 жыл бұрын

Carl Anderson is still the best.

@elijahenes3899

3 жыл бұрын

Me too! I wish so much there was footage of him somewhere out there.

@lukebradford

3 жыл бұрын

@@TheRabidWolverine Nah, Carl Anderson is overrated. Definietly amongst the weaker Judases.

@TheRabidWolverine

3 жыл бұрын

@@lukebradford I have to disagree. I really liked how he did this role. However I also do like Corey's in 2016/17 on with Ted Neely. And I really like this one. The vocal range with Brandon Dixon is awesome.✌️😁

Carl Anderson reigns RIP!! That's it that's all!

Drew is unreal in that Amstetten production

I really love that version with Serkan Kaya from the 2008 Vienna concert, because that's Drew Sarich (from the previous clip) playing Jesus, and during the moment right before this he goes up to Judas, puts his hand over his heart, and bends down and kisses his feet. I don't think Serkan knew he was going to do that because his reaction seems really emotional and genuine, and I burst into tears the first time I saw it. Unfortunately the bootleg isn't very good quality, but they released an album of the recording which is quite good.

@suddenlysavannah

2 жыл бұрын

where do i find this bootleg omg

@katieelspeth2299

2 жыл бұрын

@@suddenlysavannah Here you go! kzread.info/dash/bejne/aK6eytqGga6tc6Q.html

@suddenlysavannah

2 жыл бұрын

@@katieelspeth2299 AMAZING thank you

Josh Young will always be my favorite. I was never a big fan of the rock tenor sound commonly used in this show, it just wasn't my thing. So I'm so happy I can still enjoy the music by watching the 2012 revival!

@mewingmanda

2 жыл бұрын

same here!!

@blueturtle3623

4 ай бұрын

Woah... its almost like this might just be a rock show. Which requires actors who sound good singing rock music.

Thank you for this incredible comparison of one of the most impactful passages in this entire masterpiece. Corey Glover's performance on the National Tour in 2007 was INCREDIBLE - (Ted Nelly's last tour) - unfortunately there's precious little footage from any of those shows.

Of all the unknowns shown here, since we are all gushing about the more famous ones, is Timothy Walton at 10:14. His voice is a bit more "proper" (something that lets Josh Young down a bit), but this guy manages to put grit back into it.

@localboys7449

2 жыл бұрын

The phrasing on the dragged out “JA-ADED” is a really good touch

This once again reaffirms my belief that the original Jesus Christ Superstar had a stellar cast and Murray Head

You gotta love Tony Vincent!

I think, if you'll have time for it, you should make a comparison of the end of last supper. "Every time I look at you I don't understand... " until Judas finishes. In my opinion that's the best part of this song and that'd be awesome. 😁

Carl Anderson and Brandon victor are my favorites hands down

@rosier3260

2 жыл бұрын

Yes!!! Mine too!

I'm more interested in the order that they're saying "jaded, faded, faded, jaded, jaded mandarin" in LMAO

I will always like Carl Anderson but that Tim Minchin was pretty great too.

I absolutely love this comparison vids! Could you do one for judas' betrayal?

Id say my favourites are definitely Zubin Varla, Carl Anderson (Specifically in the 2000 video), Tony Vincent, Peter Johansson, Brandon Victor Dixon, and Tim Minchin! They're absolute rockstars!

@lillywerk4642

2 жыл бұрын

They’re superstars!

Hey! Do you happen to have the full bootleg of the 2019 National Tour? I have quite a few bootlegs I'm willing to trade for it!

3:05 I was like omg is that Michael Lee playing Simon?

Tim Walton brought a whole new life to the role

@localboys7449

2 жыл бұрын

Agreed! The vocalisations are beautiful

Love Tim Minchin and Peter Johansson!!

I’ve watched a lot of different versions and I must say David Jakobs is my favorite! He’s just so underrated, and he hits the night note like it’s nothing

OMG i have no idea which I prefer! I love all...but Carl Anderson emotion is on point... He sounds angry and sad

Tim minchin ❤️ mi favorito

Would you be able to tell me where you got the recording of the 2014 Bonn version? I´ve been looking for it, because I´m really in love with that cast:) Thanks in advance.

Shout out to Jon Stevens of the Australian cast - fabulous power! ❤

Top Ten Anime Betrayals 1:20

I need to know where you got all of these clips from! Like links please because I want to watch all of these!

I love the vocalisations timothy Walton does

I apologize, but do you have full bremerhaven video? (maybe you're willing to trade? ;))

Tim Minchin is amazing!

hey man, do you have the full barbican 2019 performance???

Jerome Pradon and Fred Johanson as judas hit different

I'm biased and Aussie Jon Stevens for me

From me: Carl Anderson. No more. ❤ 😊

3:43 and 8:17 PAL UK high pitch audio

Josh Young ❤️❤️❤️

carl anderson is amazing

anyone knows where I can find the Essen Germany 2000 production starring Fred Johanson as Judas???? HE'S AMAZING I want to hear his take on heaven on their minds?!!!

Most people: intense drama. Tim Minchin's Judas: pokes Jesus like an annoying 9-year-old brother.

Is Doug Thoms real? He looks like a background character is an animated medieval movie

Please. I’ve been looking for the Japanese version for so long.

*Tony Vincent, Josh Young, Carl Anderson; and Tim Minchin reign supreme*

@masarusenpai1952

3 жыл бұрын

Don't forget Murray Head

@somebodystoppls

3 жыл бұрын

Carl Anderson and Peter Johansson too!

@cosmicjosie

3 жыл бұрын

notgordonramsay thank u for reminding me 😌

@jerimiahdaniel1251

3 жыл бұрын

notgordonramsay Fred not peter

@CharcoalLord

3 жыл бұрын

*Josh Young and Tim Minchin supremacy* (Tony Vincent and Carl Anderson are also amazing)

Do you have more footage of Fred Johnson as Judas??

Carl Anderson

Saw this production, but Josh's understudy proformed at my show, he did great, but i still feel i missed out by not seeing Josh.

Zubin Varla is an excellent Judas, he has a similar sound to Jerome Pradon but with much more vocal talent. I like Jerome’s performance and vocals on occasion but I feel he’s a bit too villainous at many points.

Ok, so is it “mandolin” or “mandarin”?? Because I’m clearly hearing both throughout the video

9:50 Peter Johansson is the best hands down

@Villan.00

Жыл бұрын

I adore this man

ok but what is a jaded/faded mandarin? I never understood that line haha

Jon Stevens and Brandon Victor Dixon killed it.

It would appear that. One of the hardest parts is Jesus, just standing and taking it. Teddy Neeley is always my fave. However, I didn’t think he is the best actor, but John Legend handled this non-singing part the best.

that tyrone huntley sounds pretty good

This turned me into a Carl Anderson fan

Get out! They're waiting! GET OOOOOOOOUUUUUUUUUUUUTTTTTTTTTTT!!!!!!

They cut out the 2018 version

How do you get your hands on the live version??

@Sharpe1502

3 жыл бұрын

Which one? The one with Tim Minchin is gonna be on KZread this weekend.

@clamfear97

3 жыл бұрын

@@Sharpe1502 I meant the one with John Legend, but I also want to see the one you're talking about. Where is that gonna be?

@Jojo-su2vm

3 жыл бұрын

@@clamfear97 IDK if you found it because they already had it on KZread but there are some Tim Minchin clips posted by „The Show must go on“

@clamfear97

3 жыл бұрын

@@Jojo-su2vm I saw it when it up! Now I want to see the John Legend, Sara Bareilles version

@Sharpe1502

2 жыл бұрын

@@clamfear97 I think I saw it on daily motion.

none comes even close to Carl...

Josh Young

2000s was very violent!

@RachelLittle2010

Жыл бұрын

I saw Tyrone live and he was so good. I'm not a fan of when the Judas becomes violent. Its weird.

Drew Sarich does a great job and is an amazing Judas, but Carl Anderson is the only performer whose vocals are so powerful he can just channel the raw emotions of the scene and let the performance follow without his voice sounding strained and thin on those difficult high notes.

What's a jaded mandarin?

@sinajakelic

3 жыл бұрын

a tired ruler

@cringemeister04

2 жыл бұрын

yo mama

@pollypockets508

9 ай бұрын

@@cringemeister04 Google thinks you're speaking Spanish

@pollypockets508

9 ай бұрын

@@sinajakelic Thank you!

@sinajakelic

9 ай бұрын

@@pollypockets508 my pleasure :) (it took 2 years, but still a pleasure haha)

Jesus Christ, someone help Frank out. Who left him unsupervised on stage?

Carl Anderson is the Best

Josh Young supremacy.

Brandon Victor Dixon. No debate.

@pollypockets508

3 жыл бұрын

Yes, debate. He's great. But your opinion doesn't automatically mean there's no debate.

9:13 I don't know why, but that german version really looked like a version of the Passion Of Christ, only played on a stereotypical anime japanese school. So interesting...

9:57 Rasputin!

PERIOD JAPAN

German productions don't play! 😍😍😍

Carl Anderson was the best Judas IMO.

I know Jerome pardon played judes in the movie but they should have got tony Vincent to play the role and I know he played Simon in the film but he should played it in the film

Carl Anderson ans Tim Machin of curse !

Carl when he was almost 60 (30 years after he did the original movie) was the best by far in 2003!

@lukebradford

3 жыл бұрын

No, that's easily one of the weaker versions. 90% of the other versions are better.

Carl Anderson is the one and only Judas.