I love Liam - he's a brilliant frontman and hilarious - but my god can you imagine having to put up with him 24/7?! It's incredible Noel lasted so long.

@edvinparmeza1298

2 жыл бұрын

It's true, he has abused with the band's patience and tolerance for almost 20 years. Noel himself said that "If I didn't decide to leave the band back in 2009 after the last show, I was going to leave it later anyway", all the frustration he had with Liam was accumulated during the years, and the break-up would happen sooner or later. What has surprised me, though, is that Noel was the one who was abused physically by their father when they were kids, and he turned that pain into strength and became a better person while growing up, while Liam was the opposite, he wasn't touched by their father, but he grew up to become an abuser similar to him.

@Matthew-ve7uv

2 жыл бұрын

Whoa whoa whoa, abuser? You mean physically? Jesus Christ, that's a big claim. I mean, he got into fights with grown lads, but by abuser like his Dad, you mean he hit women and children? That's just a straight-up fucking slander -- his kids seem to love him, and he cheated on his wife but never abused her. If they aren't claiming abuse, who the fuck are you to make it up? Jesus

@TimeFlies1995

2 жыл бұрын

@@edvinparmeza1298 Noel has a cruel and ruthless side as well though, he used people then abandoned them when he no longer had a use for them.

@edvinparmeza1298

2 жыл бұрын

@@TimeFlies1995 I heard the story about him stealing songs from The Real People, and not giving them credit on the songs

@dondanko2509

2 жыл бұрын

@Louis Cypher he’s conservative? I like Noel even more Now. Thanks for sharing.

This conversation got released AS A SINGLE and people actually bought it, that's just awesome man haha.

During his time living in London, my brother met both the Gallagher brothers a number of times. He liked them. Lived round the corner from Liam. One thing I got from my brothers experience with Liam, and from what he personally confided, is that he was surrounded by lots of hangers on and ended up getting in to crazy situations with them. Without sounding too infantilising I suppose you could call it peer pressure? One of these hangers on knicked my brothers pint, Liam found out about it and spent the rest of the night buying him drinks. He has a good heart underneath the silly bravado.

@T0FFII

2 жыл бұрын

@Louis Cypher What about when Liam smashed the sound engineer's guitar up during the Be Here Now recordings? And Noel replaced it with one of his own cause Liam wouldn't buy him a new one.

@y007p3

2 жыл бұрын

@@T0FFII as much as I like the positive stories about Liam, he does seem to be a bit like a kid with some kind of unruly hyper activity disorder 😄

@nervesinapattern7261

2 жыл бұрын

Hoping he ditched them all

@modernchampionmusic81

2 жыл бұрын

@Louis Cypher well that ain't what I heard ..maybe he just looked after his own and was a bit more streetwise than his brother. From what I heard Noel would back up his friends in a fight at football matches and Liam would be nowhere to be seen..Two sides

@GT380man

Жыл бұрын

@@T0FFII That’s true. I saw Noel revisiting Rockfield & Nick Grime, young sound engineer way back, has the guitar Noel had given Nick. Used on that album, Noel said “Did I give you thst? Fuck off! One day, that’ll be worth tens of pounds”.

Im sure it wasnt funny at the time but the way this has me howling with laughter years later. Noels being serious, Liam keeps interrupting loudly then Noel screams SHUT UP more times than you can count. You can feel the brotherly love.

@mywhychromosome

2 жыл бұрын

"I'm gonna have to say this part, are you gonna SHUT UP?!" *Deranged cackling*

If anyone asks you why Oasis broke up just show them this and then say imagine that for 20 odd years

@lawsaudiovault1942

2 жыл бұрын

@Louis Cypher Noel was a bit off the wall too at times back in the day. I think he gets the "boring" label a bit because he had to take charge and he is a bit of a whip cracker. But Noel played along with this sometimes because management, well mainly Alan McGee encouraged it haha.

@jamesmcdonald2244

2 жыл бұрын

They’re both right and they’re both wrong at the same time. The magic lies in the middle.

@MatteoPrezioso

2 жыл бұрын

You're so right. It's a miracle they lasted this long.

@lawsaudiovault1942

2 жыл бұрын

@Louis Cypher I think the bravado "come on let's 'ave it then" shite was all for the camera. It went too far and he was lucky he didn't get a good hiding. I loved his voice and stage presence, just not a fan of the coke rambling down the microphone every two minutes trying to look hard with a tambourine. Apart from that, he's great lol

@lawsaudiovault1942

2 жыл бұрын

@Louis Cypher it's up there with egg shaker (maker) and hand claps. Or what are those Spanish clacker things. That could have been interesting lol

One brother was gifted with the signature voice and was like a class clown with ADHD while the other brother was more serious, but at times was very authoritarian and like a dictator. No wonder they didn't get on easy. Liam was just having the crack at it, enjoying the rapid fame and wild ride of being in a band. Noel had already been in the music scene and carried himself like a businessman and songwriter, but at the same time when they signed that record deal, he got the biggest boost of an ego and that was it. It says a lot listening to what Tony McCarroll had to say about his time in the band. Listening to how he played drums and how he recently played Don't Look Back In Anger, it was clear as glass that Noel just didn't like him. Democracy in Oasis came down to Liam and Noel and the rest of the guys just followed. Liam is a dog and Noel is a cat. Both can be very loyal and loving, but a dog off his leash can tear shit up. A cat is easy to piss off and when you do piss one off, you'll be the first to get those claws to your face. The relationship between them is probably the most intriguing relationship outside of John and Paul in the Beatles. Despite the ups and downs and what inevitably came crashing down in 2009 with Oasis dismantling itself, they did incredible things together and became one of the most amazing bands in the history of all of music. Even though they don't get on now, I'm sure they both can agree deep down that they have love for one another.

@mywhychromosome

2 жыл бұрын

Great comment, although I will say, as much as I personally love Mccarroll's almost Velvet Underground-esque drumming, there are several, much more measured, 'professional' types around the band (producers, managers, engineers, etc) who have testified to the difficulties they experienced with him as a player. There's so many particular pressures on a drummer, things that aren't acceptable for them to do that would be okay for most other instruments in the band, and Tony did most of them, apparently (inability to maintain consistent tempo throughout a take, recreation of the same fills at various points in the performance, etc). It was essentially a studio issue, so if they'd wanted to be very diplomatic, they could've gotten a session drummer for recordings and kept Tony on as live member, but...we all know that wasn't going to happen, lol

@nickjohnson710

2 жыл бұрын

The secret not to piss off a cat, my cat nino is a absolute dude!!! One of the most intelligent individuals I've meet......when he's out on the mean streets of reality, he is a absolute boss ......king nino 👑 ( that is him on my profile picture * met) wasn't the quote about the dog and cat from noel??? ........but great explanation

@mywhychromosome

2 жыл бұрын

@@nickjohnson710 Yeah, Noel makes the cat/dog comparison in "Supersonic", OP spun it a different way though

Just a reminder that this charted on the UK charts at number 52

This is the dynamic, to this day. Liam is thinking about being some image of rock n roll, and Noel just wants to get on with it.

@rockstopsthetraffic

2 жыл бұрын

@Rob Wood In this one particular case, people tend to agree that the publicity was better than that gig. But as Hargreaves has said, that gig had Sony execs at it, it was important. It's entirely possible that their antics wouldn't have gotten noticed, and they wouldn't have gotten another chance anytime soon. It was a massive (albeit probably unintentional) gamble by Liam behind Noel's back. Also, as was said, Liam's later antics would indeed be taken as obnoxious and disrespectful to fans, causing their decline in popularity to be as quick as their rise (and definitely contributed to them never taking off in America).

@desertrose1226

2 жыл бұрын

@P JL Liam just thinks he’s Sid Vicious 😆

@silverwave2238

2 жыл бұрын

@@desertrose1226 I think Liam would spoil his pants if he met a real punk pyscho like GG alin or Sid !

@deadstar1641

2 жыл бұрын

@@silverwave2238 Sid was a fanny. He shit himself when Freddy mercury confronted him ffs.

@404TVfr

Жыл бұрын

​@@silverwave2238 bruh

They'll make up again when they are in their late 70's .... in a care home, dipping custard creams into their luke warm tea. Saying to each other ...... "we were mad fer it back in the day ar kid"

Liam wants to be seen a wild man of rock and roll, but Noel is intelligent enough to know that it is a band's music that is most important, not the stale 'live fast, die young' bullshit.

Liam's solution was a short term solution (if there's a solution at all for him) while Noel's solution was a long term solution. Noel got this one.

I'm old enough to remember when politicians used to speak ill of the Gallagher brothers for being poor role models. Now politicians emulate Liam and Noel.

@rockstopsthetraffic

2 жыл бұрын

So many facets to this, too. To some extent, politicians always just had a veneer of high-class acceptability while being little better... But in some ways it's true, the Gallaghers put up their own trashy facade to get attention, and the race to the bottom for attention has reached politics long ago.

@debonaire_nerd

2 жыл бұрын

@@rockstopsthetraffic Ironic, isn't it? The Gallaghers upheld their celebrity profile with their timeless music and exaggerated manufactured antics. While politicians show their true colours when they think they have the public in the palm of their hands.

@pureevilhotsauce6490

Жыл бұрын

Don't insult Liam and Noel like that!

Imagine being the journalist who tried to conduct this interview and going back to Melody Maker or Q or whatever and having to transcribe 20 odd minutes of incoherent yelling by two angry Mancunians.

Priceless interview, fav bits were Noel telling Liam to f-off when he said Rolling Stones were great cos they got arrested and Liam claiming to know John Lennon. 😂

@davidjames579

2 жыл бұрын

I thought Liam was the reincarnation of John Lennon?

@bderrick4944

Жыл бұрын

Liam’s inner younger brother really shining through during that John Lennon part

liam is being pretty reasonable here like i get his point of view, but i get noel too. they're just both too egotistical to admit that they both have a point.

What a classic Gallagher conversation. Noel tries to say gig should come first but got distracted/stammered. Liam thinks he's told off for rock n roll style. Miscommunication through and through.

I just hear a couple of brothers who love each other. Noel: SHUT UP! BULLSHIT!

As usual, Noel's the saner, smarter brother. Sure wish they'd get back together though

Got a headache after listening to that 😂

@desertrose1226

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah it reminds me of Jeremy Kyle where all the dickheads are shouting over each other 😆

I've got a little brother and this is actually what 70% of our arguments are like: 12:52

Really enjoying this single

Sitcom-worthy.

Great listening to this in 2022. Liam seems chilled now and appears more successful with his solo career. How times change.

The ironic thing is they were both right and it made them successful. End of

5:24 - 5:31 “…AND IT CHARTED! That’s how big they were!” @Tom In The Shadows

i love them cos they're not perfect. liams lairy & erratic & noels stuck up at times n thinks he knows it all but they're just normal people, its annoying when ppl take everything they say so seriously just cos there famous as if we're not all like either one of them sometimes. luv them!!!!

Kudos to the subtitle! I apreciated the effort

I love this channel! Thank you for the great effort.

Love the way they talk😂😂

Imagine being Harris sitting there watching this, having to hide the biggest smile on your face as you think about how big this interview is gonna be

08:45 to 08:50. Wrong Keith, boys! It wasn’t The Rolling Stones’ Keith Richards who had a penchant for throwing tv’s out of hotel windows. It was The Who’s Keith Moon. Other than that, I can barely understand a word of it; they rarely finish their sentences, shout over each other and drift onto different points whilst one of them hasn’t even realised and still thinks that they are arguing about the previous point, then calling each other a c**t or a d******d, thinking that that wins the argument! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

I remember buying this from jumbo rec when i was 13 .My dad got me to get a refund as he said it had to much swearing and drug talking.I wasnt happy as i wanted it part of my collection But i still rec it on tape! And loved playing it to my cousins ect who didnt like oasis .

Had this on CD back in the day. Anyway still keeping the music dream alive. Done three more awesome tunes if you want to check them out. "Do or die", " Bells and Whistles", "Lacerations" And if you could care extra"Real to Real". For an amateur shitkicker writing and recording songs at home I'm probably one of the few people who is writing honest great music that you're probably gonna hear. Love the channel. Can't wait to hear some of your new tunes James.

"You want to be Keith Richards!" - Liam repeatedly to Noel 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Hopefully you do an Oasis iceberg someday

To be honest this doesn't feel like an angry argument, it's just a discussion. I think the media made it worse than it sounds

@fomofud9479

2 жыл бұрын

Ha ha, is that how you discuss things with people 🤣🤣🤣

@MrWolf-xk8sl

2 жыл бұрын

@@fomofud9479 with some friends yeah haha but right after we're just as good friends as we were before starting the discussion

@fomofud9479

2 жыл бұрын

@@MrWolf-xk8sl 👍👍

@indiekiddrugpatrol3117

Жыл бұрын

​@@fomofud9479 this is a pretty civil conversation by northern English standards

@itaintmebabe2467

14 күн бұрын

@indiekiddrugpatrol3117 - omg. When me and mine are taking like this it's trouble.

The John Lennon part was crazy 😂😂😂😂

Very educational for anyone studying this accent

3:27 "I will do that. You - you have bought me a couch!" LOL

This is why there's always been a line of friction between the two and sums up their relationship from that point to now. I do believe deep down they love each other and there's respect. But there was always this clash two of maybe a slight personal differences. Fine Margin but one that somewhere down the line split OASIS up.

And in the end, it wasn't a Rickenbacker, but a Gibson right "up his fucking nose".

This is the funniest argument I"ve ever heard. LOL

Tbh it's nice to see a health conversation 😂😂😂

I have this on CD .. hilarious it was released that way lol

Imo Noel Gallagher gave his brother the world. Without those original songs Liam never be famous. NG will go down as prolific songwriter when it’s over.

They will NEVER get back together. Both stubborn to a fault.

Thanks!

I understand that it comes with the territory that if you're that type of band perhaps things like that do happen. However, I would agree with Noel that all Liam claims to do is show off how "hard" he is acting up, which I don't fucking like at all.

I could never be in a band with this lot!

When you hear this and know all the back story of the conflict between N and L it really is amazing they stayed together as long as they did and created so many master pieces.. it took it's toll on Noel though and it all came to a head on that Paris day in 2009.

That last line though...

Do you have a dream? Liam yeah I take over the band. Part of the master plan.

Funny how different they both are to one another despite sharing the same childhood the same surroundings..

@yourdoulabrandie1853

Жыл бұрын

Liam never got the beatings though.

….and people thought Ray and Dave Davies were bad! Their fights were never bootlegged onto a single!

Iv still got this on cd from the time lol

As I sit & listen I kind of understand Liam’s point of view. The ferry incident ‘happened’ it wasn’t planned and the band doesn’t purposely decide let’s get into trouble. Things happen. Then Noel writes a song ‘cigarettes & alcohol’ w/ the white line reference. Well that’s things that usually lead to ‘incidents’. That’s where Liam says Noel is contradicting himself & Liam is right.

@spartanguitarist6579

Жыл бұрын

yup, noel said "that's just part of life" immediately contradicting himself.

Hi James, it's nice I am back to seeing the notifications to your lastest video here.. One of your old videos was showing up on KZread main page, then I noticed I was unsubcribed.. I have been subbed for the last 8 months now.. Seems KZread is still dropping subscribers..

L: “Rock and roll’s about being yourself” N: “No it’s not, it’s about music” Well they’re both right, but I get Liam’s point here. It’s about MORE than the just music, as Noel would have it. Whilst Liam was a fucking handful he was always honest and it’s annoying how Noel just yells SHUT UP every time his younger brother tries to articulate his point

@samfromme4235

2 жыл бұрын

articulate his point are you joking he’s literally interrupting his older brother, if there’s one thing u do it’s respect ur older brother i wouldn’t dream over interrupting mine, it’s callled respect and liam has fuckign none of it that’s why he called his niece

@desertrose1226

2 жыл бұрын

@@samfromme4235 Liam’s grown up a little.. not too much but a bit. They are still dicks though they need to start talking again.

@richardharrold9736

3 күн бұрын

@@samfromme4235 speaking here as the older of two brothers, respect has to be earned, it's not just some fucking automatic privilege conferred by an accident of timing. My little brother is *way* smarter and more mature and responsible than I'll ever be.

The swearing omg! I mean, I swear.. every day near enough but this lot! Liam says fuck every 2 seconds lol 😆

Could u possibly tab dont look back in anger live from knebworth

Is theree video of this interview?

nuts how this was released on cd! (got it somewhere) its like 3am at a wedding do (dual bollox from everyone!) forgotten about 6 hrs later and still on the internet. this is just brothers pissed up under the mental vacumn of being on a rollercoaster ride!

@davidjames579

2 жыл бұрын

For an interview the audio quality's terrible. All that hiss.

@404TVfr

Жыл бұрын

@@davidjames579 bruh, it's a 90s cassette recording, so the audio is likely to get a bit scuffed. It wasn't quality that mattered, it was purely so the voices could be audible. If this was a planned release (which I don't recall, it was decided after the fact), it might've sounded better.

@davidjames579

Жыл бұрын

@@404TVfr 80's and 90's Broadcast interviews never sounded this bad.

@richardharrold9736

3 күн бұрын

@@davidjames579 broadcast, as in recorded in a studio, is a lot different to just some fucking cassette tape in a dingy, smoky dressing room somewhere.

@davidjames579

2 күн бұрын

@@richardharrold9736 no I'm including interviews where the journo will go to them. It's not always recorded in perfect acoustics TV studio. But the sound is always much better than this.

i wonder what he said that was censored at 7:50

I am on the side of Noel in this one!!

@desertrose1226

2 жыл бұрын

I like Noel better when younger I think but Liam seems ok now whereas Noel is a bit up his own arse.

@gomezthechimp1116

2 жыл бұрын

@@desertrose1226 Liam seems to be enjoying life right now, whereas Noel still seems bitter about the whole thing.

JAMES I MUST KNOW why was 7:50 censored ????? im so curious...

@Laura-kg9le

5 ай бұрын

I have a feeling a word was uttered that shouldn't ever be....

@quackk_kk

2 ай бұрын

I've been wondering that for awhile. Liam must've said something so bad they had to remove it, even worse than when he said summat about the "japs". year old comment but still hold true

Can you do a bit about the Munich Incident in 2002? 😊

'You know what I mean?"

11:13 what the fuck did Liam just said????!😂😂😂😂

If theres an audio, maybe theres a video, that be great 🍻

Liam's defiance era 👌

I’m in the minority who think they will reunite someday 🤞

@rockstopsthetraffic

2 жыл бұрын

I would rather see them just be civil with each other without some reunion, but there's probably even less of a chance of that happening, than them being paid off to stand on a stage together for an hour. But that won't happen either, because both of them are well enough off on their own, especially Noel, who's the one who needs to be convinced. I think there's a better chance of Dik Evans rejoining U2 and them calling themselves The Hype again for a night, than there is of Noel rejoining Oasis.

@cody95

2 жыл бұрын

@@rockstopsthetraffic we'll see!

@Arkantos117

2 жыл бұрын

At the very least it would be nice to see them do a charity gig together at some point, maybe including Bonehead they could do a cancer one.

@cody95

2 жыл бұрын

@@Arkantos117 when I say “reunite”, I definitely mean like a one-off performance at a major festival or something. Or another knebworth. Thinking they’d make new music or do a world tour is definitely a little too far fetched haha

Do you have any other music videos James with other artists. I like oasis but I tire of them a wee bit after a while. Any other rock n roll videos ?

@desertrose1226

2 жыл бұрын

I think it’s because Oasis were wild and considered more interesting than some of the other bands. I wish he’d do Happy Mondays though!

5:21 so funny

Hillarious

Didn't a newspaper gave this interview away on a CD?

@Punkadelic2112

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah is called Oas*s Wibbling RIvalry.

in this interview you can see that Liam was the rockstar of the band , Noel was just a musician

I had this cd lol

Can you do a video on guigsy being a murder suspect when he was in school. Yes I’m serious this actually happened lol.

@1dorz

2 жыл бұрын

Really? I need to hear about this lol. A video about Guigs leaving the band temporarily in 95 would be good too. C'mon James, make it happen!

@kenny75photography2

2 жыл бұрын

Wasn't Guigsy wanted for arsony by the police also? Dodgy guy that man lol.

@theessay2530

2 жыл бұрын

@@kenny75photography2 guigsy is just a psychopath

@Arkantos117

2 жыл бұрын

Wasn't he also the one who got the fake money on their first trip abroad? He must've known some dodgy lads.

@theessay2530

2 жыл бұрын

@@Arkantos117 that’s not that bad tbh just a chancer move lol

I wouldn't go anywhere near that Mong Liam again if I was Noel..brother or no brother.. its about time he grew up...

Love

have u considered finding the source of the line, “‘Cause you said the brains I had went to my head”? noel said it was from an autobiographical memoir tape recording John Lennon made on the day he died. it seems this would have been uncovered by now and placed on youtube if it’s legit. have u heard this tape?

@elizabethb4634

2 жыл бұрын

i mean that’s a good story, but maybe melissa said to him, “your brains have gone to your head” on noel’s lost weekend - i really think melissa was a huge influence on that album

@aidanhickey9845

2 жыл бұрын

kzread.info/dash/bejne/eoWV2M6gdbbQaNo.html This is it, about 5 minutes in. He doesn't exactly say the line, as he's quoting somebody else but it's probably the one Noel heard.

@JamesHargreavesGuitar

2 жыл бұрын

Hi Elizabeth, thanks so much for your support, and apologies for the slow response Yes, it is the link that Aiden Hickey has posted below (kzread.info/dash/bejne/eoWV2M6gdbbQaNo.html) around 5 minutes in I think you might be right about Melissa saying something similar to Noel - check out my latest vid for more on that - kzread.info/dash/bejne/do6jqNGdm7vbhrA.html

Fuck me! No wonder Noel walked. Liam was like a bird incessantly pecking at your head.

@mralex2492

2 жыл бұрын

They were both to a certain degree.

@michellefigueroa8705

2 жыл бұрын

Noel literally started it. He even admitted to riling Liam up on purpose to get this sort of reaction. 💀

@aldanacereto

2 жыл бұрын

@@michellefigueroa8705 Read the book Paolo Hewitt wrote about the be here now tour. Liam was unbearable. He was always trying to rile Noel's up.

……that’s what I’m about

The wise and the foolish are oil and water

I turned it even further down, to 50% (this one's for the pot-heads)

Liam won this argument. How's doing drugs to the point of almost dying just a regular "part of life", but getting into some trouble here and there like getting thrown of a ferry is not? It's contradictory. Besides when he says "difference is I don't get caught", well then the actual point of the argument is lost as well, since he does the same shit, the issue then would be about the fact that Liam and the rest of the guys got busted, and nothing else. I honestly think Noel was a little drunk on this interview and Liam was more lucid.

It's fascinating Noel shuts his brother down all throughout the interview

Reminds me of Iron Maiden’s Mission From ‘Array 😂

When both people are shouting, nobody is listening. The cornerstone of any relationship. They both know what each other are on about, but neither will admit the other is also right. Noel more than Liam, but both have their own valid point. Also, the band was destroyed because of this kind of attitude from Liam, not Noel's. Although they were mediocre after 1997 anyway. Too much money and coke and whatever.

@desertrose1226

2 жыл бұрын

Liam had a nice-ish voice here as a young lad.. round about early mid 2000s though it changed and became really gritty sounding and pretty nasty tbh..

@davidjames579

2 жыл бұрын

@@desertrose1226 He sounds quite posh at times.

The Kray bros cover was a gas cover..Noelo is Reggie

I'd rather have a segment on what Guigsy's been up to since Oasis.

Harris must have had the time of his life

Liam though he was the voice but he was the downfall of what would have could have been the best band in the world.

Liam never fucking changed and thats why we love him end of!

Listening to this theres parts where i laugh but the end is just sad. I think Liam was hella smarter than anyone ever gave him credit for, especially when he says, "youre contradicting yourself now, youve had too many g&t's" ...I kind of think Noel enjoyed putting Liam down at times because i think there was some jealousy from him, and not just in this recording, but in other interviews, its a bit disturbing to watch because its toxic. Not that touring with Liam would be an easy thing. Bottom line...there probably wont be a reunion lol

I’m Japanese!

Liam is such a legend

You've had too many fucking gins, right. 😁

How can someone disagree with Noel

Rock Star ego beefs are hilarious. I had to see Oasis live once; absolutely boring, don’t like their songs, but their squabbles are hilarious.