Fantastic interview with an absolut giant! Subscribed!

@throughconversations

2 жыл бұрын

I appreciate your support, thanks for watching!

@inthso362

2 жыл бұрын

The Wise understand those with a million followers started with zero. I'm pretty sure Noam would never sit with Mr. Beast.

@felya321

2 жыл бұрын

It is like saying all lives matter in response to BLM.I did not realize he is in such a poor state of mind.Comparing Ukraine to Mexico forgetting that Russia just took over 2 chunks of Ukraine!It is like wolf crying for sheep not to joint “Animal defense league)

@Curse44

2 жыл бұрын

@@felya321 The only poor state of mind I see here seems to be yours if you truly fail to understand what he is saying.

@justicar5

Жыл бұрын

@@Curse44 he is saying that Russia is the only nation that counts and Ukraine must bend the knee, remain powerless and friendless, and accept ethnic cleansing and cultural genocide. HE could not be clearer.

I treasure Chomsky so much .. Also saddened that we wont have him forever. He is a small light in a dimming world.

@samantharaymond1844

Жыл бұрын

I am right there with you. I periodically check for news of his passing, I have to brace myself. He will be such a huge loss but sadly, many will not know of him and his incredible contribution to society until he is gone. He is my idol. A bright stunning light in the world, but everyone is out here in designer brand sunglasses. Only light shining in their lives is that from their iPhones or tablets

@fabiengerard8142

18 күн бұрын

🙏🏻🙏🏽🙏

Chomsky will literally sit down with people who have 476 subscribers lol, legend.

@wachowski9525

2 жыл бұрын

dude I was about to say lmao, absolute legend we don't deserve wizard chomsky 🙏

@silafaupaulmeredith7251

2 жыл бұрын

He is one of my all time idols. A living legend on the border of being a prophet.

@Sientodesilusionarte

2 жыл бұрын

Yes! He is a legend but also give credit to the host! He has really great interviews IMO! 💚🙏✨

@smoochie3331

2 жыл бұрын

Would chomsky against the war against nazi?

@anyariv

2 жыл бұрын

That’s hilarious. Literally the first thing I thought when I saw how many subscribers he has. And it’s the second time he’s been in his show! Same questions from everyone now.

Truly the time for wisdom - thank you

Thank you Noam Chomsky for your great insight !

@throughconversations

2 жыл бұрын

Glad it was helpful!

what a legend of a man 🙏🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪

I found it natural that Gandalf the Grey best knows the history and situation in the Middle Earth. Deepest respect.

May God Bless this magnificent being!

Thank you!😊

Really depressing times. I almost can't watch the news anymore it gives me horrible anxiety

@conslin1147

2 жыл бұрын

Yup, the haircuts of the news anchors are traumatic... I feel your pain!

great interview

Thank you for bringing him on. He’s such a light in these stormy times. So wise and sobering.

@throughconversations

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you for watching and for your support!

@fryavanbosh3563

2 жыл бұрын

Song....pete Seeger ....where have all the flowers gone ....! Marlene Dietrich also in german. Voorlopig zullen de investeerders hun geld niet zomaar laten verdampen , de Oekraïne ,EU burgers en ook de Russische burger zullen lijden . De use hebben de Russen lang aan ‘t lijntje gehouden en ook respectloos t.o.v hen geweest. Weet zeker dat de Russen dit nooit hebben gewild maar wanneer je niet aan die WEF en al die andere sekte gekte mee doet, ligt men eruit en er zijn genoeg voorbeelden uit de geschiedenis.

@marcialynne4737

2 жыл бұрын

Wisdom is not one of Chomsky's attributes, he is an impressive linguist and philosopher. Nevertheless, he lacks the training required to correctly analyze the accuracy in climate change research where the NASA predictive models are in constant flux, which renders all conclusions drawn from the research invalid.

@billy6pack887

Жыл бұрын

He's a piece of toast now. All things have their time.

Far out norm I been following you all my mature life .. you looking old my good mentor.. still so sharp.. educational interview 😎

subscribed of course, thank you

Thanks! Another great video from the most respected American person in the world, Noam Chomsky.

@fryavanbosh3563

2 жыл бұрын

When I see him, I always think at Pete Seegers and his songs.

@carlitosgl

2 жыл бұрын

@@fryavanbosh3563 I never heard of him, I am looking him up on Wikipedia. Thanks! (When I see Chomksy, I think of Tom Lehrer).

What will happen without your work 😕 Love ❤ 😍 and blessing

10.minutes and some, the kid says he hasn't witnessed war in his life time and he doesn't mean to say he is in ukrain right now. Yet with his statement clearly dismisses the wars that are on going round tge world, specially in africa.

@pelvicthrustful

2 жыл бұрын

There are wars in Africa? - he says ironically. The 'Global South' was mentioned. -Two seconds. China-apparently of no importance- Three seconds. Interesting thoughts but unfortunately the usual self-obsession and polemic around the U.S.A.

I do not agree with Noam on many issues, but I totally agree with him on this!

Thanks for having Noam on as a guest

He is the greatest minds we have in prest times

Hip Hip for Noam! Hip! Hip!

Thank you Professor , how sad it is hearing youre words of wisdom knowing that these words could make such a change in Human beings , but those in power are NOT willing to make peace. There goal is trying to acheive more power and dividing the People... I will use Any time and opportunety to spread youre words and wisdome to my children, Famely and Friends . What a great Human being you are ❤🌠 I Hope you know the impact you have on me and many , many People. God is really showing off by making a Human being as you ❤. Youre wisdom will never die .

Long live Professor Chomsky! Thanks so much!

@throughconversations

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you for watching!

The 80% of us may think we are the wise ones in the room, but when Finland and Sweden want to do the same thing as Ukraine knowing the potential consequences, that’s something else.

@donovan4222

Жыл бұрын

What do you mean “it’s something else” ? Finland and Sweden wanting something doesn’t mean that thing will prevent war or create good outcomes

@micll3229

Жыл бұрын

I don’t live in Europe, I have no right to pass any judgement ! Albert Einstein - 'Peace cannot be kept by force; it can only be achieved by understanding.'

If USA would be smart they should listen to this wise man, he is a universal treasure.

I subscribed in .5 seconds

Great interview, thanks.

@throughconversations

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks for watching!

Thank you for having Mr. NOAM CHOMSKY. A humanistic Genius..I understood so much about this absurd Rusian Ukranian War..!

@lorenzo6868

2 жыл бұрын

He doesn't say anything concrete, should Ukraine surrender then? Give up land to appease Russia? It's easy to propose peace if you don't say how.

@sharondavid-melly1498

2 жыл бұрын

Well, yeah Russia is absurd. Putin is Evil and he knows it that's why he failed no matter what happens

@vinm300

2 жыл бұрын

Chomsky blames NATO and the US. Forget the Bucha massacre, the West is to blame.

@lorenzo6868

2 жыл бұрын

@@vinm300 What a well constructed argument, so convincing.

@vinm300

2 жыл бұрын

@@lorenzo6868 Thanks. I'm able to be brief because I've been listening to Chomsky for four decades. I've eard him end Saddam and his psychopathic sons. He defends the fascist theocracy of Iran, and the Russian dystopia - no mention of women protesters being beaten and sexually abused by the Russian police. Chomsky reserves his ire for the West.

Brilliant conversation. I learnt a lot from this episode. Thank you very much! Keep these convos coming my man. 👍👏

@sharondavid-melly1498

2 жыл бұрын

And where does that talk lead you while people all over the world are suffering from war, starvation, at the hands of murderous authoritarian dictators? Nowhere. We must fight them.

@bernardofitzpatrick5403

2 жыл бұрын

@@sharondavid-melly1498 💭

A conversation has two participants, Chomsky is great.

He’s really leaning into the “wise old man” style, with that fantastic beard.

Thank you for this gem!

Another brilliant intervention of whom without a doubt is the most important intellectual of these times.

@danal81

2 жыл бұрын

He so is not lol.

@jotaere100

2 жыл бұрын

@@danal81 Can you tell us why “he so is not”? Who is according to you the most important intellectual?

@danal81

2 жыл бұрын

@@jotaere100 His linguistic theory has been increasingly refuted and is considered outdated, his politics are so often plagued with tunnel vision-criticism of the US to the point he ends up whitewashing genocidal dictators. I fail to see what would cause people to label him as “the most important intellectual of our time.”

@edwardmurdoch5070

2 жыл бұрын

I agree. He is a very rare wonderful person; a great intelectual with empathy. We had had only a few like him thru history... Epicurus, Spinoza, Russell and a few more. Most of the rest of the great thinkers stayed loyal with their respective establishment. On another subject matter... aguante Boquita! :)

@jotaere100

2 жыл бұрын

@@danal81 Incorrect. Science works like that, his theories where groundbreaking and started a revolution in linguistics and they should always be questioned therefore advancing the science of linguistics. But that’s not the point. Chomsky is the most cited current intellectual in the arts & humanities for decades on. The top ten are: Shakespeare, Marx, Aristotle, the Bible, Lenin, Plato, Freud, Chomsky, Hegel and Cicero. Reading your erroneous assertions I realize that you don’t have an opinion of your own but repeat what it has been said for decades trying to systematically nullify Chomsky for his truthful anti-establishment critique that annoys the conformity and delusion to which you are subjected.

237th like... I'm about that... Chomsky the geopolitical G.O.A.T.

No words can describe this gentlemen! He is in the league of Einstein!

In his 40-minute interview, not once did Chomsky demand that Russia leave Ukraine! Not once did he condemn Russia for invading its neighbour with the intention of absorbing it into Russia, as it has done already with Crimea and other parts of Ukraine, a surprising omission since he’s always been the first to condemn the US for invading other countries. As for Chomsky’s solution for ending the war, the deliberately vague term of a “settlement” between Russia and Ukraine inevitably translates into Ukraine giving up some of its lands to Russia, in exchange for its safety, just as a victim has a choice when confronted by a thug: your money or your life. It is really the time for Chomsky’s devotees to scrutinise his agenda of promoting Marx’s ideas and his frustration at how Marx’s project has constantly been thwarted by the US and the West generally. Since Chomsky is not open with his agenda, it’s about time someone asked him a few hard questions about his worldview while he’s still with us.

@annov7500

Жыл бұрын

Exactly. For 40 minuts not condems Russia War Terrorist country . Don't get this man. We in Poland so happy to be in NATO...unlike peaceful Ukraine...

@Prosadko22

Жыл бұрын

What would this condemnation achieve? He has already harshly criticized the Russian government in the past, but a condemnation is just that - words. It will not achieve the goal of Russian troops withdrawing from Ukraine because the Kremlin views it's Euro and NATO integration as the same security threat as the US would view Mexico trying to change it's neutral status and integrate with a different military bloc. That is what Chomsky is saying. Whether you agree or not, given the different narratives, the Kremlin is going to fight a war of attrition and it has more manpower to burn in this fire than Ukraine. The US and it's military-industrial complex is just throwing fuel into it. My two cents.

@AristarchusEsti

11 ай бұрын

@@Prosadko22 you are right. This guy has a naïve view on war, in countries like Vietnam or Afghanistan, the us isn’t threatened. That’s the massive difference, Russia sees an exponential threat and responds accordingly. That’s why they aren’t just going to “leave.” The implications of this proxy war are literally edging on a nuclear war; closer than even the Cuban missile crisis, and proponents of “we should just leave” just don’t see that the issue isn’t that simple!

How is it possible to connect with Professor Chomsky, is there a website or email address for him?

Chomsky is the best ASMR artist

Reaction from Germany: Definitely not putting your mind at ease, but probably necessary to counterbalance some of the misrepresentations and to lay open the stupendous logical fallacies of and in our Anglo-American-European position regarding the present war in the Ukraine. The muffled hurra´s of Lockheed Martin and the Exxon-Mobil, to name two, should make us think. How wonderfully organized this 93 years old brain walks through this dense issue.

@alexleibovici4834

2 жыл бұрын

> How wonderfully organized this 93 years old brain walks through this dense issue. No, the issue is crystal clear, dense is the 93 years old brain...

"However, I think it carries a very heavy burden of proof and the burden of proof is always on those who choose violence. Sometimes the burden can be met in my opinion, but its a heavy burden." (cit N. Chomsky)

Straightforward and powerful.

14:00 15:00 Escalation of the western side before the Russian invasion, OSCE Reports 29:00 INF treaty

@vinm300

2 жыл бұрын

Chomsky blames NATO and the US. Forget the Bucha massacre, the West is to blame.

50 years from now the history is going to be written and non of this interview is going to be remembered. It will be erased! No doubt in my mind. The few that will remember this will be ridiculed. That’s how it works. I’m trying to figure out how Noam is able to talk about these issues and still walk this planet. You would think he would be silenced long time ago. Thank you so much for your dialogue.

@jotaere100

2 жыл бұрын

But he was silenced. Chomsky is the first cancelled person in history. The luminaire of his intellect has allowed him to prevail in intellectual circles otherwise we might have never known him. After he became highly controversial because of his sharp criticism against the system as we know it everybody in the media turned against him and was constantly mis-labeled, MIT refused to fire him and he was published by underground prints. But then the internet took care of the rest.

@dudewaldo4

2 жыл бұрын

Silenced by who?

My understanding is that a proposal was made to not extend NATO to the east, along with other proposals, including bringing Russia into NATO, but that was not negotiated into an agreement. Putin cherry picks historical incidents to justify his agenda. Like Trump, you cannot believe a word he says without independent corroboration.

@Prosadko22

Жыл бұрын

The issue is that political leadership outlook in the White House and Kremlin are completely different. The promise not to extend NATO eastward was made by a Foreign Secretary but not in any way signed into existence, it was an informal agreement. Kremlin possibly viewed it as a much stronger commitment than it actually was. When the US presidential administration changed, the new Foreign Secretary had no idea about this agreement, or chose to pretend he didn't, depending how you look at it. Russia becoming part of NATO was simply unfeasible. It would have become too strong of an influence inside of the bloc. Besides, NATO was created to contain and combat the USSR, what would be the point otherwise? No sense to let in the USSR's successor state and throw the whole system out of balance. This whole thing has been horribly mishandled by both sides, sadly, and now ordinary Ukrainians and Russians are paying the price with their lives.

It is a great pleasure to listen to Chomsky. So much wisdom. The world should listen to him.

I want to hear Chomskys voice Im a linguist who studied Chomsky

I am Carrier-Gitksan Indian from Northern British Columbia. I live; I love; I laugh; I cry; I hurt; I am. My people have thrived and we have suffered through Millenia. We have seen the worst scourges of disease and pestilence that near wiped us off the face of the Earth, and we cried as we watched our families waste away and die, or hear their hearts stop beating in the onslaught of burning fever. Too weak to cry and no tears to cry anyway as the fever has taken the last of our body's water. The white man introduced the diseases to our babies and elders and all our people in an effort to wipe us out. They used their guns and cannons to eradicate our people and every memory of us. For what? This land? The Gold underneath? The Buffalo that roam on it's plains? How now I ask you do I stand here and live? Where is this one life going to end and what will it leave behind? What are my responsibilities and obligations to my ancestors and my great Grandchildren? We looked on in curiosity to this new being. The men with the skin without color. We were afraid...puzzled. We knew we had to feed them berries and fish and meat or they would die. We communicated as best we could. We feasted with them and welcomed the strange men. They cherished the things they could not own or eat. The land, the yellow rock. They want to meet all our people but we are as the stars in the sky or the fish in the ocean. Where they ask? Everywhere. It did not go well, for those stars and fish were wiped out in but a few generations through acts of genocide. Our people are a living or dying testament to the hard efficiency of Biological warfare. The deliberate introduction of the pox and other deadly disease proved devastating to my people. Most of us were eradicated, almost all. My son is eight. He was born at 19 ounces, four months early. The white man's incubator kept him alive for the 5 months he was in the Children's Hospital. An oscillator breathed for him for a few days. Longer than any premature child had in that ward and survived. The machine tore his tiny lung and it collapsed. He was like a newborn bird that fell out of its nest. Every morning we went to be with him and hold his head and tiny feet as his lungs needed months to develop. Each morning as we made our way to the NICU we agonized if our baby was still with us. Five months later we took him home. Two weeks later my 12 year daughter was diagnosed with bone cancer, and we had to go back to Vancouver Children's hospital for 11 months. The white man's surgery and medicine did its work and my two youngest children are thriving. I love those doctors, the nurses. Do we love our creator only when things go well? For I tell you when all this happened I felt so abandoned by God. We felt so alone in this Universe. Four years later my Mom had a massive heart attack, and she was flown to Saint Paul's Hospital in Vancouver. My daughter's Doctor's husband was Mom's doctor and did an amazing job as Ma was discharged a mere days later at 76 years old and she is doing well today. I feel great anger at what happened to me and my people through history as I am a survivor of the Residential Schools. I was abused in that school, and taken from home at 5 years of age until I reached 8. I suffered as did all the other kids in that school. For me missing mom and dad and family was the most devastating trauma, even above the physical and sexual abuse at the hands of the supervisors and priests. Where do I begin? for when I see those doctors and nurses, I love and want to forgive. When I think of those Soldiers that fired on my people, I hate. When I see those Priests, the Vatican, the Government that enabled the residential school, I hate. How can I even begin to approach my kids and teach them about where they came from and their people. Land. My family has a trapline over vast swathes of land. Others fight us over the trapline. Ownership. Title. Everything has been considered. In the past animals were snared and trapped to sell their furs to the Hudson's Bay Company. Now mines can be built on it. It can be logged for trees to make lumber. But that's not why 'we' fight over this land, it was inherited and passed down to my Dad. Others are after money, so they fight for its ownership. They start to believe their lies of ownership. Soon all their families and relatives begin to believe in the lies. They become united. The fervour reaches a fever pitch in their unity and common goal. I can say when a people attach themselves to land, the endeavour becomes holy, it becomes noble and "right" in the eyes of God. The backdrop of the value of the land is secondary and only a small part of the war. These people will die for the cause. So it goes with the people of Ukraine and Russia. I identify with Ukraine. I wonder if they feel abandoned by God. I pray for the people of Ukraine, all the time.

@justdynee

2 жыл бұрын

@@anaveta6942 Putin made up a lie on Nazism. Propoganda. Don't pay attention to it. Excuse for war to boost his approval ratings.

great discussion, but the politicians will unfortunately not understand, specifically the USA

@throughconversations

Жыл бұрын

I appreciate your comments! Make sure to stay tuned in because Chomsky is coming back to the show for a third time-episode coming later this month.

Hello, Alex Levy, I greatly appreciate your video and content. May I request permission regarding some of its content? I sent a message to your channel's email address. Thanks in advance for checking.

The interviewer should sometimes attempt to challenge the subject of the interview and not be praising nonstop. That would raise the level of the discourse and make it a lot more useful.

@throughconversations

2 жыл бұрын

I appreciate your feedback, will note for future interviews. Thanks for watching!

wow Noam Chomsky ! thanks for making it available! When did the interview take place?

Fantastic!

@throughconversations

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks for watching!

Hearing Chomsky’s take is always interesting! Too bad for the interviewer. He wasn’t even asking actual questions, just saying words to get Noam talking.

Why would the US be responsible for negotiating a peace deal between Russia and Ukraine? Also if anyone has a copy of this “agreement” where the US and NATO said they wouldn’t accept any new member states into the NATO alliance. Can someone Please produce it or send me a link where i can read it? Finally did the US annex any territory of Iraq as the 51st state of America after the war ended? If not how can you compare the Russian invasion of Ukraine with the war in Iraq?

This man is a legend!! Thank you for this interview!! What a great job!!🔥💚🙏

@sharondavid-melly1498

2 жыл бұрын

This man is too comfortable in his own head. He's way out of reach

Senility is truly a sad state to be in.

@alukuhito

Жыл бұрын

Too bad half the US is senile - the Trump voters.

Really hard to hear, microphone output is so low. Otherwise very interesting

I have a question - if there was an escalation in Donbas from the Ukraine (before invasion), then why Russia was not expected to negotiate and agree to some "ugly" agreement to protect Donbas people? If we follow the NC logic - the subject of aggression just needs to bend low enough to protect people, so why Russia is not expected to just bend, widthdraw to protect people? Why does it apply to Ukraine only?

@sharondavid-melly1498

2 жыл бұрын

Excellent point. Putin needs to be gone. He's distroying Ukraine and he'd distroy the entire West if he could.

@hess6wi

2 жыл бұрын

The escalation of tensions running back years is not a simple case of aggression.

Beautiful heart

@alexleibovici4834

2 жыл бұрын

All heart, no brains...

Given his age, I am surprised by the amount of information his brain still maintains. Mine keeps forgetting everything almost.

20:15 Chomsky roasting

astute as always. Noam's keen and nuanced analysis stands out in today's environment filled with crap analyses such as Mearsheimer, the latest American apologist for Putin's unjust war

Ummm, Hello 💓

I cannot heaar thewords by Chomsky. Why?

Love noam just tells it how it is

Too bad he can’t be interviewed at a local newspaper in our “free world”. They will not let him speak.

Grace… up.

@leebmac

Жыл бұрын

Grace…

He didn't tell Jew to settle with Nazi by then?

Russia is committing war crimes in Ukraine. Ukraine is not committing war crimes in Russia. Just thought I'd point that out.

@charlesmain9938

Жыл бұрын

Ukraine has been committing war crimes in Ukraine against Russian Ukrainians since at least 2014.

I wonder ... if Noam Chomsky were russian or chinese and he would have criticized Russia or China like that ... what would his "life expectancy" have been like !!! It's just a simple question ...

@ubermensch8627

2 жыл бұрын

Im sure he would have gone missing long time ago lol

@henrym5043

2 жыл бұрын

Many elites and fans of the US in China, criticize the government everyday, they have much better life than Noam.

@sharondavid-melly1498

2 жыл бұрын

Absolutely!

@ssamd263

2 жыл бұрын

You mean like Epstein committing suicide while in prison while on suicide watch or how the CIA was planning to assassinate Julian Assange who reported how the U.S. committed war crimes and there are plenty of whistleblowers that have been thrown in jail in fact Obama holds the record for jailing whistleblowers.

@rocksvelte5760

2 жыл бұрын

No, and he said that himself. That at least the US is not a totalitarian society, and that the people actually have the power to make themselves heard and affect change in their government.

You have to put Chomsky on the Left side of the screen I guess! ;-)

@aqk

2 жыл бұрын

You mean just like the NY Times and WaPo? I doubt it.

@sharondavid-melly1498

2 жыл бұрын

Way over

I would like to believe that if we sent Professor Chomsky to Moscow to negotiate with President Putin that a peace deal could be reached...but I think it's much more likely that Putin would simply shout, "This is Sparta!", and kick the Professor into a deep hole.

@patrickpowers3850

2 жыл бұрын

In a 2013 survey in the United States by Public Policy Polling, 4% believed that "'lizard people' control our societies."

good interview, Noam gets some facts wrong, China does have missile capable nuclear submarines and is targeting Australia geopolitically, economically and to some extent now militarily, so Aukus is understandable but not desirable. Also his comments about European civilization is a bit extreme, if one looks through out history of human civilization just about all cultures have used violence and war, as soon as humans become civilized we then become extremely uncivilized. I really wish humans could change.

@kurtwollermann2210

2 жыл бұрын

if we soon dont smarten up then revelations and the tribulation will occur and we stupid humans will be extremely regretful

@philipwoodgate9555

2 жыл бұрын

@@kurtwollermann2210 I agree, but can humans change, built into our DNA perhaps

Did he say that the global south is the more civilized part of the world? 22:40 What does he mean by that?

@charlesmain9938

Жыл бұрын

Sardonic?

If there were to be an end to humanity starting from this conflict then surely it would be a victory for Nihilism.

@kurtwollermann2210

2 жыл бұрын

considering what china has in its arsenal that they dont reveal in popular mechanics nihilism may very well triumph

@pstotto

2 жыл бұрын

@@kurtwollermann2210 Chomsky is partly responsible for this conflict as a Nihilist where the Northern Hemisphere will do anything rather than admit they've been had for 300 years by the desert tribesmen who control their financial markets as well as making prats of them all in the process from Freud onwards to Richard Alpert and beyond.

@pstotto

2 жыл бұрын

@@kurtwollermann2210 What pillock brain gave japan oil and metal after the war and allowed China to develop at all? Why put the world in cars to use the oil the Northern hemisphere needs?????

@pstotto

2 жыл бұрын

Chomsky is convincing in his conversation but it is a broken Plover wing conversation i.e. everyone sent in the wrong direction.

Oh for fuck sakes. Im not down at all

i am first

@wachowski9525

2 жыл бұрын

Chomsky got here before you 👿

@rubengarcia8375

2 жыл бұрын

The Lord God almighty is I AM.... only Him

What an excellent guest ruined by ridiculously low sound levels.

Those who do not learn from history, are condemned to repeat it. So, please carry on being ignorant, oblivious and simply greedy and stupid. We all die in the end.

Chomsky lives in the most armed country in the world. Keep this in mind as he's telling you not to militarize or get nuclear weapons. Chomsky wants countries like Ukraine to be in perpetual danger of hostile states and not do anything to arm themselves. If the world was fair chomsky would be living in fear in Ukraine trapped without water or food.

@ubermensch8627

2 жыл бұрын

Shut up. He is calling out double standards & hypocrisy.

@sharondavid-melly1498

2 жыл бұрын

Excellent point. Ignore the refute to your comment.

@Brandon-ld2dn

2 жыл бұрын

Noam is no friend of democracy, and wastes no opportunity in degrading America. I’d love him to move on to Russia, it’s where he wants to be anyways.

@jotaere100

2 жыл бұрын

You didn’t get it

@ubermensch8627

2 жыл бұрын

@@Brandon-ld2dn why cuz he calls out the almighty American hypocrisy

Another major oversight from Chomsky is the analysis around Mexico. Why is the US-Mexico relationship possible in the way it is now? Because of the symbiotic economic relationship between them. US is beneficial enough to Mexico's economy that Mexico lacks the will to resist the US's influence on them. Mexico is economically beneficial enough to the US that the US is fine with Mexico setting the majority of it's own policies, albeit with the understanding that they cant step too far out of line. Russia has not, and will not, offer Ukraine the same type of beneficial economic relationship. In fact, they've actively moved away from such a partnership over the last two decades. As much as we can point out the influence of NATO and the US in the Maidan uprisings, those movements received large support across the country, and more importantly, the elections that followed cemented the desire for autonomy. Russia had the opportunity to court the new government in Ukraine, and instead, they threw a tantrum- invading Crimea and funding and arming separatists in the East of the country. These actions, do not a symbiotic relationship make.

@olgaakrylova9682

2 жыл бұрын

Re symbiosis read up on gas supply

@chandleraz5018

2 жыл бұрын

What do you mean “they can’t step too far out of line” what things are out of line? Just curious.

@charliechapman7156

2 жыл бұрын

@@olgaakrylova9682 gas supply for whom?

@charliechapman7156

2 жыл бұрын

@@chandleraz5018 for Mexico? Too far out of line would be taking a militarily aggressive posture against the US, inviting a trade war, supporting direct, open enemies of the US, or outright trying to join an anti-US alliance. US responses would likely scale up into invasion much more slowly than Russia, largely because the US has access to much stronger economic tools to enforce its will.

@coursecorrection870

2 жыл бұрын

@@charliechapman7156 Why would Mexico want to?

While Noam grounds his "whataboutisms"in examples of pertinent ethical comparison aimed at providing insight that might provide solutions or proposals for the current crisis, wheras "whataboutisms" are more often regarded in as instances of cancel culture, where the arguments for action responding to a clear breach of conduct in a current case are deemed canceled by citing loosely connected historical examples.

Can anyone tell me. What does Putin get out of this war?

@dimitrigamkrelidze2804

2 жыл бұрын

he expands russian territory... he's nazi...

@valeriep6478

2 жыл бұрын

when Biden and bad "actresse" Zelensky stop playing their bad roles

@jotaere100

2 жыл бұрын

@@valeriep6478 But seriously. What does he get out of this war?

@sashavasilieva3049

2 жыл бұрын

@@jotaere100 As a Russian, I am also asking this question. It led me to the topic of food security, seed export. Ukraine has valuable black soils, it seems that Russia want to control eastern farm lands and ports, which are being used for export. Otherwise, I don't see any logic why under the slogan of saving russians from nazis, we bomb russian-speaking cities.

@jotaere100

2 жыл бұрын

@Jason Hunt No, Putin is bombarding the Donbas without care (his specialty, like Aleppo) killing Ukrainian and Russian speaking Ukrainians alike so he is not stopping any “genocide”. The Russian economy is ruined and of course he envisioned this, so the question stands. What does Putin get out of this war?

Can anyone explain to me why American Imperialism is Bad and Russian Imperialism is Good?

@charlesmain9938

Жыл бұрын

The obvious answer is that imperialism is bad, regardless.

@Vlad_the_Impaler

Жыл бұрын

@@charlesmain9938 So why does Noam Chomsky hates American Imperialism and loves Russian?

@charlesmain9938

Жыл бұрын

@@Vlad_the_Impaler bye, troll

@Vlad_the_Impaler

Жыл бұрын

@@charlesmain9938 Legit question, not a troll.

@alukuhito

Жыл бұрын

@@Vlad_the_Impaler What are you talking about? People let American imperialism go on, but everyone's all anti-Russia these days.

It's like Noam has x-ray vision. He sees through all the bullshit.

I am having issues with the things the professor are saying. I wont make a super long post, but, the short version of it is whataboutism. He says it's a problem, yet it engages in it constantly. If you use a timer to count how much he criticize the US, it's much longer than any other actor, like Russia or China or anything else. And some of the criticism is valid, some I find less valid in light of recent events. I'll just use one small example. Before that, I think a bit of background about myself is in order. I am a Romanian citizen. Prof Chomsky said: the armament industry and the patrol industry are happy they get to do more business. First of all, the way he described it. You would think he rubs elbows with them and sees them rubbing hands and laughing maniacally. Which I doubt that it's true. But even so, why wouldn't they be? Let's take arms first. First of all, arms are used in 3 ways. To attack, to defend and to deter your opponent from attacking you. I suggest we take 2 perspectives into account. I will grant professor Chomsky the premise that the industrial military complex and war hawks like to sell more weapons and the chaos they create because they get to sell even more weapons. Basically leveraging the only use of the weapon, to attack. But, weapons are also used, again, to defend and to dissuade your opponent to attack you. Again, as a Romanian, I didn't think before the invasion, that my country economy can take such a large hit for defence, now I see it as mandatory. Russia cannot be trusted, and there's no other way other than defence. At least I don't see one. Am sure all the diplomats tried, including giving up to Putin's demands, and none of them worked. I guess prof Chomsky likes to ignore that bit, and blame the Americans for not "negotiating". What would the Americans have to negociate about Ukraine? And the very idea is: bleah. And second point. Climate change and the petrol industry. Again, bizarre interpretation of events. So it's ok for Russia to take gas and petrol out of the earth and sell it and contribute to global warming. It just wrong when America gets to do it. Why, coz America grows richer, and Russia poorer? Or should the Europeans just freeze or turn off their economy? Sounds to me like the typical "non-interventionist". Or you know, "neutral" position. That is actually helping Russia by inaction or by straight out fud. Fear uncertainty doubt. America isn't perfect. Not the country. Not the people. Not the leaders. But its leagues ahead of others. They just have to find ways to not elect people like George Bush or Donald Trump. One because of the ilegal wars, the other for obvious reasons. And I could try at least to concede another point here to prof Chomsky about previous past crimes made by previous administrations. Prof Chomsky likes to go back to Nicaragua, and he's right, but they go way back. And they go back even further. It's hard in global politics to play "fair". Or "right". The cold war smeared the entire world. I have no illusion about geo-politics being a nice guy game. But, America and the West wages economical war, cultural war and War war. But it doesn't annex stuff. And it doesn't engage in ethnic cleansing. You won't hear a US official, or a NATO official saying "that is not a country". You don't see journalists and political opponents jailed in the US or the West (although prof Chomsky is actively asking for just that ... like Bush in prison)... which is a slippery slope. I don't know. Anyway... you don't see people put in jail because they have a blank piece of paper. And you don't see as much refugees coming out of the US as we're seeing coming out of Russia. If Russia was such a great place to be and right in every way, why are their own citizens leaving the country?

@charlieandoni3595

2 жыл бұрын

I don’t think you addressed what he said nor understood the discussion.

@axlslak

2 жыл бұрын

@@charlieandoni3595 very helpful. thank you very much. 2 denials and an insult, 0 arguments. At least I tried to explain why and how and how.

@axlslak

2 жыл бұрын

@@travisbiko8990 Fair enough. Norway yes, but I doubt it will be Russia.

@taniakol

2 жыл бұрын

@@axlslak Right. Or China. Specifically Shanghai.

@rocksvelte5760

2 жыл бұрын

You misunderstood what he said about whataboutism. He wasn't saying it was a problem, he was lamenting that when he points out that the US has done the same or worse, that he gets accused of whataboutism in order to shut down any conversation that goes against the party line. I see many comments in here saying that he thinks Russia is a good country or that he would rather be in Russia, but he even said that at least America is not a totalitarian state, so the people can speak up and affect change in their government (unlike in Russia, etc.)

I thought Zelensky offered neutrality, so long as there was some kind of back-up. I can't speak for U.S. motives, and I don't have a background in political science. I do, however, have a background in psychology, and Putin, in my estimation, is a real psychopath. It means you can't negotiate with him in good faith. He will take advantage of any situation and any proposal, and his word is worthless. Therefore, I don't see any negoiations working unless from a position of strength. Basically, the answer is that he's going to have to be deposed from inside, which might happen if the war goes on long enough and the Russian citizenry gets tired enough of their sons coming home in boxes, that the propaganda stops working.

@cheeto8960

2 жыл бұрын

Zelensky offers neutrality but it is being blocked by his government and US government

@wentadi

2 жыл бұрын

Many injected by the safe and effective substance promoted vehemently by old Chom are finishing in those boxes and no harm is done to C1984 propaganda

@susannemeyer7023

2 жыл бұрын

Well, true, it might happen, but it might as well not happen. Sure is that every hour of prolongation of this war will cost lives, wounded civilians, homeless civilians, disowned civilians, traumatized children. Thousands of fates are at stake. Who takes responsibility for these ordinary people? Who really takes about their suffering? All this strategic thinking is seemingly so pure, clean and abstract, but has dire, very dire consequences.

@SamadHayati

2 жыл бұрын

I also have the same question. NC said that the Ukrainian president had offered naturality as a piece deal, but he did not elaborate on why Russia has not responded to his offer. He accused the US of opposing all peace deals but without any references. He also correctly criticized US oil companies to be so happy that they can now produce oil without any problem, but he did not say anything about the Russian oil industry.

The sign of a bad podcast = their closed captions talk about norm Chomsky

After a minute, I see Noam is as crazy as ever.

@sharondavid-melly1498

2 жыл бұрын

Yep

@jotaere100

2 жыл бұрын

You just repeat bs. He didn’t say anything crazy.

Whatever the talk, it is not a democratic war because the UK people were not asked if they wanted Ukraine in NATO.

No answers here !

@Sportliveonline

2 жыл бұрын

just a lot of words

EXPANDED VERSION: I am ashamed to admit that for a long time I used to be Chomsky's admirer until I studied Jung and revisited Nietzsche's writings and most importantly considered my own experiences in life. It was then that I learned to repeatedly question my views (the eternal recurrence of Nietzsche) in my search to find my authentic self. I also learned that empathy was not limited only to sympathy for others' pain but it required putting myself in other people's shoes, even embracing their pathology. It was then that I understood that the paradoxical and the duality of human nature as described by Jung and repeatedly portrayed in Kubrick's films demand our examinations to include power dynamics along with our constantly evolving ideas of ethics and morality in the empathetic process. The operative word here is "dynamic" which is something Chomsky's ideas lack. For Chomsky time stood when he 1st appeared in front of the press cameras and introduced himself as an anti-war activist. That is it. In his mind, he still is the same young dashing intellectual standing in front of cameras. If you have seen one Chomsky presentation/lecture then you can rest assured that you have seen them all. They haven't changed significantly since the 1960s. They are all repetitions of the same theme. So, at least with Chomsky, you know that you will never miss anything. His predictability and repetitions is is unrivalled in terms of monotony. He is the same when it comes to linguistics. Once, he has said something there is no way to change his mind. I could give you an example that was arbitrated by the MIT computer science department simulated the issue and came out against Chomsky but he refused to accept it and he has such clout and idiotic admirers that even MIT people wouldn't say that he was wrong, just the data supports that conclusion. But that would take too long. Therefore, it is a character flaw and has nothing to do with his politics. If you listen carefully he says that as an American dissentient his role is to criticise the U.S. regardless of the issue at hand. Chomsky is as dogmatic as the Catholic Dogma. The passage of time and its consequential changes is absent as consideration in all of his work including his linguistics. He is like the frozen Narcissus (god of vanity) forever captured by his own reflection. He denies change in people, administrations, regimes, the evolvement of ideology and the development of individuals through time. The prime example of this dogmatic approach that is often used by him and his "followers" about the history of Russia, is the phrase "not one-inch expansion of NATO" which is not true even in terms of the way that is phrased. NATO does not expand like some invisible liquid poured out of a vessel or fed into a pipe. Countries apply to join and NATO decides to accept or reject their application. Rejections are less frequent but they do happen as it did in the case of Georgia and Ukraine. Furthermore, he disregards the fact that neither Baker nor Bush nor NATO ever committed such a promise into any written legal agreement that could bind their successors to follow the way he demands us to respect international agreements. He also ignores that the promise was made to Gorbachev as the head of the USSR, soon disbanded by Yeltsin. The promise was not made to Russia and therefore it can legally be argued that the promise was null and void once USSR ceased to exist. Chomsky also omits the narrative of how the USSR was disbanded and Gorbachev was removed by force. But that is another story for another time.

@annov7500

Жыл бұрын

So according to Chomski countries can't apply for NATO membership because Russia is not happy about that??? What a nonsense... If Ukraine jointed NATO Russia didn't invaded...amen

@ExiledGypsy

Жыл бұрын

@@annov7500 They apply for NATO membership because of Russians' backward paranoia. This whole excuse of Russians and some western Geopolitical analysts about the flatness of the terrain to invade Russia is a deliberate excuse to keep the Russian population ignorant and backward so that a bunch of so-called elite can keep denying them cultural growth for their own humongous benefit. Why do you think the Oligarchy is so unbelievably rich? It is on the back of the peasantry who are held back very much like the black in the US. All this crap about Hitler and Napoleon is again a misinterpretation of Russian elite practices of imposing scorched earth not against the enemy but their own for their own sake. It is also again part of deliberate refusal that technology has rendered the old arguments redundant. Otherwise, Belgium would have been invaded by the Dutch several times by now because of the flat terrain of their borders. What a joke. It is a comically stupid argument that the Russians must rule over 100 million souls just to "feel" safe, A big F**k off is the only response to that argument and to Mr. Chomskey.

Professor Chomsky, great analysis. I am a CS student so i know a bit of your contribution to the field and so on. But there is a thing that you did not cosidered in your speech. Jens Stoltenberg said that all options are avaiable, ok, but there is a problem there. First, maybe he was trying to highlight a possible intervetion of NATO forces, instead of a nuclear response as u said. Second, did you ear lavrov's and putin declarations about nuclear attacks? I do, and as european, i found them really interessing, as you might say. So, dear professor Chomsky, why not to bring russia terrorist declarations into your evaluation? Thaaanks

@conslin1147

2 жыл бұрын

Maybe Noam Chomsky should do your course, because being universally recognised genius for 80 years has led him to overlook a couple of bullet points your professor put on his powerpoint.

@emanuele6619

2 жыл бұрын

I miss all your points, maybe because I am dumb, but surely beign recognized as a genius doesn't mean that you have good points in areas in which you are not competent (e.g. race claims by Watson, Enrico Fermi was a fuc**n freak with his family but surely he was a genius, even Einstein said 'God does not play dice' but turned out that maybe he plays them and maybe not just a pair). We can assum that even geniuses say bull***t, for sure

@conslin1147

2 жыл бұрын

@@emanuele6619 I think it´s God who has all the points.. I suppose Chomsky just made his points.

@emanuele6619

2 жыл бұрын

@@conslin1147 u are a bot

@conslin1147

2 жыл бұрын

@@emanuele6619 Well to increase my vulnerability in the shadow of your named geniuses, as you mentioned ´race´ it was while sitting in a lecture given by Chomsky that I fully understood that he thinks on another level. After the lecture someone asked him about studies which indicate that different races seem to exhibit different IQ scores (statistically speaking)... I was curious as to how how would answer this difficult question. He said " Only in a racist world would that matter. Otherwise it´s about as relevant as studying the IQ of people over six feet tall compared with people under six feet tall." With that unprepared ad hoc answer to an uncomfortable question I understood I was in the presence of greatness.

это США тоталитарное государство и пытки в Гуантанамо, и мучения Ассанджа тому пример!

@ritahafliger7170

2 жыл бұрын

Ja, Kriegsverbrecher, Provokatöre! AMERIKA WIR WOLLEN EUCH NICHT!!!!! Russland und Europa schwächen 👎👎

Noam Chomsky, you are today's Bertrand Russell / war protestor! A secular saint. Perhaps if you went outside and sat on a curb, more people might listen to you. Alas, it's April now and the weather is cold in the Northeast. I'd hate to see you catch cold. Try it in a month or two.

I listened to Chomsky and read the comments. I find it difficult to believe how his indoctrinated can't find bias, pessimism and inaccuracies in what he says. It is quite easy to pick many of his statements apart. THINK. There is a reason his beliefs are not mainstream among scholars. He should stick to linguistics.

@charlesmain9938

Жыл бұрын

And "bias, pessimism and inaccuracies" are not "mainstream among scholars"?

I want to ask Noam why he believes Putin feels so threatened by Ukraine becoming a NATO member, even though Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia have been NATO members since 2004. All three of these nations are former Soviet Republics along Russia's western border, and are even closer to Moscow than Ukraine is. As far as I can tell, NATO is not a real legitimate threat to Russian sovereignty. I also would like to add the US population is not the same as it was in 2003. No future US President is dumb enough to start a new war after the obvious failure of the War on Terror. I think pointing fingers at the US wars in Iraq, Vietnam, and Afghanistan is sort of pointless as it likely will not happen anytime soon. It would be political suicide. Now, non democratic countries like Russia and China, where public opinion does not mean a thing to the regime, those are serious threats to global security. They need to be kept on a tight leash and smacked whenever they get out of hand. I do however agree that Julian Assange needs to be released. His treatment is totally despicable and embarrassing.

@valeriep6478

2 жыл бұрын

North American hegemony is the greatest shame of our humanity. Military interventions since the United States of 1945 are an immeasurable disgrace. Believe me in Russia much more freedom than in USA and Europe

@President.GeorgeWashington

2 жыл бұрын

@@valeriep6478 "the greatest shame of our humanity" really? How Melo dramatic. This is just Great Power Politics, and it has been the way the world is run ever since the start of civilization. And no, there is not more freedom in Russian than there is in the USA....

The Aristotle of our times

I usually listen very carefully to Chomsky, something I find truthfull, some not, but this part on Ukraine is a lot of nonsence. Russian army have nuclear weapons, and as weak as they are, they can simply blackmail tre rest of the world and they know it, thats why we have this war, same as war in Iraque , on american part. Thats why we have to support eastern european countries with weapons and troops. Unfortunatelly, Russian side started it. I dont want to live in Putins Gulag.

@theazzi

2 жыл бұрын

Russian's army can undergo a nuclear war that will probably lead to major world destruction, but it's not as strong as to conquer other nations and therefore you living in Putin's gulag.

@ekaterinaekaterina846

2 жыл бұрын

Путинский ГУЛАГ?)))) ну вам лучше лечь под запад и раздвинуть булки))

The problem is looking at the atrocities that are currently happening and then taking the Putin position of focusing on Iraq and Afghanistan. Saturation bombing and chemical bombing in Syria. Has Putin or Russian officials taken steps to be held responsible for the atrocities? It's a very one-sided argument.