New Law That Would Mandate Congressional Districts Be Based Only On U.S. Citizens Debated In Rules

The Rules Committee debates the Equal Representation Act, which would mandate a question about citizenship be included in the Census, and make Congressional districts be based on U.S. citizen numbers only.
Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:
account.forbes.com/membership...
Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: / forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: / forbes
More From Forbes: forbes.com

Пікірлер: 401

  • @4bnfree
    @4bnfree26 күн бұрын

    The main question to me is why should people who broke the law and are here illegally be awarded government representation?

  • @donethatbefore100

    @donethatbefore100

    22 күн бұрын

    And if they'll break the law getting into the country, are we to believe they'll follow all other laws? Ha! Not even funny.

  • @carolschmidt7880

    @carolschmidt7880

    22 күн бұрын

    Raskin what r u saying??? YOU are responsible for this mess and I want to keep my Country. I love my Country and your a blight on our Country. 😢

  • @deborahjoyvalentine6180

    @deborahjoyvalentine6180

    21 күн бұрын

    😮😮Or USA Government aid🗽 STOP aiding Illegals❗ 📣Aid USA Citizens to live ABOVE Poverty level‼

  • @chermainemadison2729

    @chermainemadison2729

    20 күн бұрын

    It’s called Biden Obama BS

  • @VanMan83

    @VanMan83

    20 күн бұрын

    It's more insidious and sneaky than that. It involves basing Congressional representation and Electoral College votes on Gross state population per the census WHICH INCLUDES ILLEGAL MIGRANTS. So they are being brought in to distort the electoral system even if they aren't individually allowed to submit a ballot. It still affects Electoral College and Congressional representation.

  • @rickalexander2801
    @rickalexander280126 күн бұрын

    Not at all surprised by Raskin. He's for anything that stacks the deck against fair play.

  • @ColonelSandersXVI

    @ColonelSandersXVI

    20 күн бұрын

    Are you (((noticing)))?

  • @opinion4246

    @opinion4246

    20 күн бұрын

    I think he's wanting to be discovered.

  • @gailmarie4039

    @gailmarie4039

    19 күн бұрын

    He’s despicable.

  • @Hugh_Junet
    @Hugh_Junet26 күн бұрын

    Sounds completely logical. And for that reason it won’t happen.

  • @Genesis-007
    @Genesis-00726 күн бұрын

    We don't need a consensus, what we need is voter I.d

  • @goosecouple

    @goosecouple

    26 күн бұрын

    "Remember, China happy to make voter ids for the border trespassers. Place your orders now."

  • @316bonnie1

    @316bonnie1

    21 күн бұрын

    Exactly! ONLY Joseph and Mary complied

  • @mikemurphy7304

    @mikemurphy7304

    21 күн бұрын

    Mexico has voter id!!!?

  • @Genesis-007

    @Genesis-007

    21 күн бұрын

    @@mikemurphy7304 are we talking about Mexico?

  • @CivilizedWarrior

    @CivilizedWarrior

    19 күн бұрын

    What we need is politicians who aren’t willing to destroy our entire nation for personal gain. It’s just unfathomable to me, what they are willing to do, and how far they are willing to go to maintain their lifestyles, their wealth, and their power.

  • @johndawson8544
    @johndawson854426 күн бұрын

    How is this even a debate. Not a citizen. No f'n vote.. jeez

  • @WalkiTalki

    @WalkiTalki

    26 күн бұрын

    I would agree but I don't understand how a Samoli named Omar and a Palestinian, from Nicaragua named Tlaib or an Indian named Jayapal are Congressmen so I guess it is needed.

  • @michellem-s1108

    @michellem-s1108

    26 күн бұрын

    lol - the census tells us about the population, and tells us about the number of people in a congressional district. Slaves in the South were counted as 3/5 to fluff the numbers of residents in the state during that period, even as those people were not allowed to vote. Apportionment has to do with Congressional representation NOT with who is allowed to VOTE!

  • @heent7972

    @heent7972

    26 күн бұрын

    THE problem is that the population for apportionment (how many Representatives each state gets in Congress) currently counts ALL PEOPLE, INCLUDING ILLEGALS. THAT is why DEMONcRATS have been importing them for decades, but especially over the last 3+ years, because their policies are NOT popular with people that pay attention.

  • @mitchadams2815

    @mitchadams2815

    26 күн бұрын

    Exactly!! If you come to this country,you must become a naturalized citizen to vote! That means you swear the you will honor the constitution and follow the laws of it! You will defend our country with your life,from all enemies foreign and domestic!! As you will honor the USA flag!! Protect the flag and Constitution,even against A Rogue Government!! This BS of dragging the impeachment of FJB and allowing him and his administration to continue to destroy America!! Specially when there's so much evidence on his corruption!! The SUPREME COURT OR SOMEONE SHOULD SETTLE WHAT THE CONSTITUTION MEANS AND STOP THIS AMENDMENT BULLSHIT!! We're paying these idiots to take care of this country and it citizen's period!! upreme Court

  • @richardhessert7862

    @richardhessert7862

    26 күн бұрын

    ​@@WalkiTalkiIf you listened to Jamie he said have to be nationalized for seven years before you can run for Congress, what ever that means

  • @shaneomac823
    @shaneomac82326 күн бұрын

    This is America! Wake up!

  • @H3llo_Kidd3n

    @H3llo_Kidd3n

    23 күн бұрын

    Is it really! America is starting to disappear both in the senate and congress, just look at Talib and Omar!

  • @10beachbum22
    @10beachbum2226 күн бұрын

    It will never pass because it would be a fair and level playing field.

  • @keithmartin3914
    @keithmartin391426 күн бұрын

    The point is illegal should not be counted

  • @DAVIDMAINORD

    @DAVIDMAINORD

    19 күн бұрын

    Do you understand?

  • @IAmWithinEverything
    @IAmWithinEverything26 күн бұрын

    It better be American citizens ONLY

  • @HandmadeCreations

    @HandmadeCreations

    19 күн бұрын

    And not illegals!

  • @napoleonsmith7793
    @napoleonsmith779326 күн бұрын

    5 minutes and done. Only usa citizens please

  • @legaleeblonde4310
    @legaleeblonde431026 күн бұрын

    Can you imagine this ever being a discussion at any point in time before JB took the WH? This is nuts! 😂😂

  • @DidiArte

    @DidiArte

    20 күн бұрын

    Took is right. did NOT win!

  • @bevfarnquist92
    @bevfarnquist9226 күн бұрын

    No voting no citizen , if you're not a citizen , you don't bolt

  • @jarodstorm6372
    @jarodstorm637224 күн бұрын

    Only citizens should vote.

  • @deviouskris3012

    @deviouskris3012

    19 күн бұрын

    It doesn’t give non-citizens the right to vote. It is about the census. Which includes counting residents, which doesn’t only apply to citizens.

  • @artisticendeavors5076
    @artisticendeavors507626 күн бұрын

    Yet another flawless example of why there needs to be term limits and a spending cap on each person in all political elections. It would end most issues, which is why it probably won't happen. Otherwise, it would have been done already.

  • @user-fh4nw6ct9y
    @user-fh4nw6ct9y26 күн бұрын

    Wow this was an intense episode of the Twilight Zone!!

  • @jenniferwilson7150
    @jenniferwilson715026 күн бұрын

    Did I hear that right did raskin call founding fathers radical Republican

  • @travispratt6327

    @travispratt6327

    26 күн бұрын

    They can’t seem to get their story straight on their whole party switch myth thing.

  • @deviouskris3012

    @deviouskris3012

    19 күн бұрын

    @@travispratt6327you may have missed basic history. But being a republican, meant in favour of a republic and not being subject to the monarchy of England. So you are really failing when you conflate the two. But this is why Raskin is a constitutional scholar and you aren’t.

  • @DAVIDMAINORD

    @DAVIDMAINORD

    19 күн бұрын

    That can't be they had a spine

  • @RayBecker
    @RayBecker26 күн бұрын

    The requirement for President is NATURAL BORN CITIZEN. The Founding Fathers cited DeVattel in their letters. Natural Born Citizen is defined as a person born on US soil, to Citizen Parents. That's Parents with an S. Plural as in more than one Parent. John McCain was not a Natural Born Citizen; he was born in a civilian hospital in Panama. In fact, Hillary and Obama sponsored a Senate Resolution giving NBC to McCain. Statutes and Senate Resolutions can never make anybody a Natural Born Citizen. Obama was not qualified either. His father was Kenyan and in 1961, Kenya was under the British Crown. We don't need his birth certificate. According to British Law, children born of a British Subject automatically take British Citizenship. So, Obama technically had dual allegiance and to Britain; was that not what the Founding Fathers were trying to prevent? The 14th Amendment removed State's Rights. It made all persons born the US, subject to the jurisdiction thereof. What that has done is to put teeth into the DC Act of 1871 when the US Incorporated. You can't always discern what the Founding Fathers intended just from a document that was meant to be short and easily read by any person. To learn what the Framers intended, you must read their letters, The Federalist Papers and Anti-Federalist Papers. OMG...am I telling people they have to read? If you don't, you will be lost. God said "My people shall perish due to lack of knowledge"

  • @jenniferwilson7150
    @jenniferwilson715026 күн бұрын

    Raskin and her rehearsed that straight up

  • @brandi7580
    @brandi758026 күн бұрын

    Democrats won't let this pass. Most of you already know this. ❤️🙏🇺🇸

  • @mimi-ur8pc

    @mimi-ur8pc

    26 күн бұрын

    And the RINOs helped pass HR 6090, which used the Pro-Palestinian protests to pas legislation that classifies the Christian bible criminal hate speech. Nice way to thank the Evangelical Christian base that is Israel's greatest defender. How about declaring the word "Goyim" hate speech.

  • @michaelschiff4837

    @michaelschiff4837

    26 күн бұрын

    With all due respect, shouldn't only eligible voters count towards districting? Doesn't make sense to count non-eligible folks into something that necessitates the voting eligibility. I'm sure you're far too partisan to genuinely consider what I'm saying here but I felt compelled nonetheless in hopes that someone else will realize how bs this all is.

  • @brandi7580

    @brandi7580

    25 күн бұрын

    @@michaelschiff4837 Yes, absolutely. Although democrats are trying hard to give them the right to vote. Many of us realize the bs that is going on. I think the real problem here, is people not knowing what to do and when some of us do come together to do something we become targets. We have to come together. Talk to family, talk to neighbors, talk to friends. This isn't going to end until we find our balls and rise up, together. ❤️🙏🇺🇸

  • @wvglitter7761

    @wvglitter7761

    19 күн бұрын

    ​@@michaelschiff4837pump the brakes there friend, we're on the same side here. You and the OP are agreeing.

  • @arlenelovell3187

    @arlenelovell3187

    17 күн бұрын

    ​@michaelschiff4837 we have always counted people in the versus that are not citizens. This is not new. This has been going on since the constitution was ratified.

  • @Radiation_Day
    @Radiation_Day26 күн бұрын

    they're not saying don't count them. they're saying only legal voters should be counted for how many representatives each state has. not the same thing

  • @carolynklestinec8589

    @carolynklestinec8589

    26 күн бұрын

    The constitution does not legally say " voters" . That is the crux . It says " persons " because as it was stated women and children could not vote . States were young and fairly empty so in order to be represented they had to count as many bodies as possible. Thats why they also stated that there would be no less that 1 per state .

  • @bgorg1

    @bgorg1

    25 күн бұрын

    The discussion should be about all people in a geographical area or just citizens. Citizens differs from voters. Should non-citizen residents be counted for apportionment of Congress or funds?

  • @raymonsmith1046

    @raymonsmith1046

    22 күн бұрын

    That the citizens and illegals should be counted But Democrats want to assign electors vote by number and get them more reps in Congress they don't care how Many are here Democrats want the power and if they get to vote too there happy Hopefully there won't be many left after November if we're LUCKY

  • @deborahjoyvalentine6180

    @deborahjoyvalentine6180

    21 күн бұрын

    📣Ah but you speak Common Sense of common Legal Voter‼📣🗽🇺🇸✌😊

  • @Radiation_Day

    @Radiation_Day

    16 күн бұрын

    @@carolynklestinec8589 constitution is not mentioning those counted for how many electoral votes a state has either. perfectly constitutional to not count non citizens in that regard.

  • @legaleeblonde4310
    @legaleeblonde431026 күн бұрын

    They just want what they're already doing to be out in the open and legal.

  • @ItsyBitsyDreamstead
    @ItsyBitsyDreamstead26 күн бұрын

    This better become law!!!!

  • @mimi-ur8pc

    @mimi-ur8pc

    26 күн бұрын

    It won't unless people light up the phones and let their representatives know how they feel; otherwise they assume we are asleep. And if that does not work, sue and take it all the way to the SCOTUS.

  • @skygreen133
    @skygreen13326 күн бұрын

    Jamie Raskin making the argument that illegal immigrants should be apportioned in the census....sounds real American....

  • @mimi-ur8pc

    @mimi-ur8pc

    26 күн бұрын

    The democrat party is 100% global communists.

  • @joe-el7iw

    @joe-el7iw

    26 күн бұрын

    demographics. pun intended.

  • @GenXamerica

    @GenXamerica

    26 күн бұрын

    Raskin is far from being for Americans

  • @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    20 күн бұрын

    Everyone gets counted! Be a patriot and support the Constitution!⚖️🇺🇸

  • @DAVIDMAINORD

    @DAVIDMAINORD

    19 күн бұрын

    Communist

  • @MrClifftonChandler
    @MrClifftonChandler21 күн бұрын

    Outrageous this isnt already a law or an existing interpretation. Its common sense.

  • @WearyTraveler_
    @WearyTraveler_26 күн бұрын

    Chances of this passing is slim to none unfortunately

  • @sambahoza7488
    @sambahoza748826 күн бұрын

    Hahhaa why is Raskin a bit quiet here sound so good to be true to allow undocumented people in USA can he take in one family in his house 😅

  • @WalkiTalki

    @WalkiTalki

    26 күн бұрын

    WEF pays him to keep the border open not house terrorists.

  • @sambahoza7488

    @sambahoza7488

    26 күн бұрын

    @@WalkiTalkiI would think he will championed them in his house just saying

  • @christinedowd1820

    @christinedowd1820

    21 күн бұрын

    Do as I say, not as I do.

  • @jenniferwilson7150
    @jenniferwilson715026 күн бұрын

    Another way to give them tax payer money too

  • @bgorg1

    @bgorg1

    25 күн бұрын

    Yes, exactly- if they count in the census then they count towards financial apportionment

  • @jenniferwilson7150

    @jenniferwilson7150

    25 күн бұрын

    @@bgorg1 yes and makes government bigger

  • @roybeach3397
    @roybeach339726 күн бұрын

    NONE AMERICANS DO NOT. VOTE, NO AMERICANS GET TO VOTE,

  • @arlenelovell3187

    @arlenelovell3187

    17 күн бұрын

    Voting requirements are clear. You must be a citizen to vote but the census count is a completely separate discussion. The constitution is pretty clear on who is counted in the census, "the whole numbers of persons" should be counted. It dies not use the word citizen

  • @thom196121
    @thom19612126 күн бұрын

    This is bull shit this is a power grab

  • @ivdg46e

    @ivdg46e

    26 күн бұрын

    A power grab is an understatement it's conquest.

  • @deviouskris3012

    @deviouskris3012

    19 күн бұрын

    Following the constitution is now a bad thing? Ouch. You really hate the US and founding fathers.

  • @randallawson2300
    @randallawson230022 күн бұрын

    Never did our forefathers ever think that we would have a president that would open the borders and Let it bleed out like a person dying

  • @deviouskris3012

    @deviouskris3012

    19 күн бұрын

    You obviously missed the 1886 republicans policy platform. Which was open borders, pro union and better wages for women.

  • @opinion4246
    @opinion424626 күн бұрын

    I never liked raskin.

  • @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    20 күн бұрын

    Why? Because he schools everyone on the Constitution and its history? Very patriotic of you.🙄

  • @mitzilangpitman4491
    @mitzilangpitman449126 күн бұрын

    Desperate times demand desperate measures. Change it. Take care of those who pay for you to be there Ratskin

  • @TannisHenriksen
    @TannisHenriksen26 күн бұрын

    The one w the long dark hair shouldn't even be in a seat..

  • @triciarobey4439

    @triciarobey4439

    24 күн бұрын

    I agree. He’s in my State and wish we could get him out. He’s such an embarrassment 🤦‍♀️

  • @earllannum9613
    @earllannum961326 күн бұрын

    This census is entirely different from any other.

  • @user-pm2eq5dj7m
    @user-pm2eq5dj7m23 күн бұрын

    It is illegal for anyone other than a citizen to vote in a federal election but it is also illegal to ask about citizenship

  • @robbcotton2081
    @robbcotton208120 күн бұрын

    Why are we wasting our tax dollars on debates about people who are in our country illegally.

  • @user-pm2eq5dj7m
    @user-pm2eq5dj7m23 күн бұрын

    If they are illegal qhy are they here and why is our government who is supposed to be for cotizens protecting illegals

  • @peggyjohnson9223
    @peggyjohnson922323 күн бұрын

    THE FIRST QUESTION ASKED ON ANY GOVERNMENTAL DOCUMENT IS : ARE YOU A US CITIZEN ?, WRONG IS NOT RIGHT, RIGHT IS NOT WRONG. GO BACK TO GRADE SCHOOL AND LEARN IT "AGAIN"

  • @suzankephart8461
    @suzankephart846126 күн бұрын

    How many people have become citizens in the last 3 1/2 years? I called my SS office about 2 years ago and they told me they were closed, the only people they were seeing now were foreigners to sign up for SS cards. Maybe this is why the SS office was having problems with cutomer service. They have been so, so busy.

  • @cottonp20
    @cottonp2026 күн бұрын

    That would make TOO MUCH SENSE for CONGRESS TO Ever PASS, and BIDUMB would NEVER SIGN IT!

  • @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    20 күн бұрын

    It would never pass the Senate, you mean. That's not how anything works. 😂 You should read the Constitution before speaking. Good day.

  • @CivilizedWarrior

    @CivilizedWarrior

    19 күн бұрын

    @@lbthingsstuffmore9513 what are you talking about? First of all, the senate is part of Congress, since “Congress” encompasses both the senate and the house. And second of all, the President has to sign any proposed senate or house bill, in order for it to become law. Otherwise, if he does not sign it, the bill needs to go back through both the senate AND the house, AND get a 2/3 majority vote in BOTH houses in order for it to pass and become law. So I don’t know why you’re saying that’s not how it works. In actuality, that is EXACTLY how it works. Op said nothing wrong. It would seem it’s YOU who doesn’t understand how it works.

  • @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    19 күн бұрын

    @CivilizedWarrior, it's against the Constitution! Period! Go read the 3/5 Clause of the Constitution. Go read the SCOUTS' opinions. If Congress wants to amend it, fine, but this is not new. This hearing is in response to voting. There is NO illegal voting problem. Statistically, Republican voters cheat at the polls, and Republicons in Congress hate making voting more accessible because their ideas suck and they can't win on policy, so they cheat by gerrymandering. Not enough voters vote anyway, so illegal voting is not a thing. Stop being gaslighted and use a 5-second Google search. You don't have to take my word for it; look it up. Lastly, since you have to register to vote with an SS# and I vote by mail in my state, where or to whom would I show my ID when I cast my ballot? The mailman? Be a patriot and stop listening to propaganda. Be well.🖖🇺🇸

  • @user-om3cm3td7p
    @user-om3cm3td7p26 күн бұрын

    Lets have hearings regarding the deliberate open border to invite and fund the mass illegal people for the sole purpose of voting. And lady from Pennsylvania is asking about who uses the roads and bridges, but its the tax payers (citizens) that made those possible....

  • @abbottshaull9831
    @abbottshaull983126 күн бұрын

    Well being you have be a Citizen to vote, this is only makes sense. Immigrates and migrants who are trying obtain Naturalize Citizenship population shouldn't be included as they don't have the Right to Vote in our elections. If they were counted towards the making of Congressional Districts, would mean either Party can work to have non-Citizens population increase in order to have certain Districts made that would favor their Parties, that won't be reflective of the Voters of these Districts.

  • @ken2tou

    @ken2tou

    20 күн бұрын

    Precisely. It ain’t right.

  • @DonaldGodwin-vb5kx
    @DonaldGodwin-vb5kx20 күн бұрын

    The legislation we need is Term Limits for Congress & Senate.

  • @thamirlyousif
    @thamirlyousif26 күн бұрын

    this man does know ,have not even a close idea the number of population on this earth,and he is a congress man...what a waste

  • @user-pm2eq5dj7m
    @user-pm2eq5dj7m23 күн бұрын

    Illegal means that a law was broken we have no problem with legal immigration but here in the usa when a law is broken its not ok. If i a citizen break the law i have consiquences

  • @WalkiTalki
    @WalkiTalki26 күн бұрын

    Woh, am I the only one that didn't think this was already how it was done?

  • @petehebert6462
    @petehebert646221 күн бұрын

    There you go guys. I was getting worried about you Representatives not representing our best interests. We Thank you.

  • @takenserious4554
    @takenserious455421 күн бұрын

    I'll be god damned if more of our policy is going to go toward the interest of criminals.

  • @bevfarnquist92
    @bevfarnquist9226 күн бұрын

    They're not for our us.The people they're supposed to be working for at all

  • @lilpinksliplee7310
    @lilpinksliplee731019 күн бұрын

    ASK US!!!! NO RIGHT TO VOTE??? NO RIGHT TO REPRESENTATION.

  • @wilmaeulberg4323
    @wilmaeulberg432326 күн бұрын

    Citizens should only be considered.

  • @mimi-ur8pc

    @mimi-ur8pc

    26 күн бұрын

    I hope that everyone who voices their opinion here, also calls their representative and let's them know how they feel.

  • @nickgiaq9614
    @nickgiaq961421 күн бұрын

    There is no legitimate reason for anyone to be against this this is common sense and should be enforced nationwide immediately

  • @bowlady270
    @bowlady27021 күн бұрын

    Jamie Raskin really needs to read the 2nd half of 14th Amendment, where it DOES say that "if the right to vote at any (federal) election be denied to any man being 21 years of age, AND A UNITED STATES CITIZEN, except for reasons of participation in rebellion or other crime, then the basis of representation SHALL BE REDUCED in proportion to those men." So yes, apportionment & federal representation does apply only to US CITIZENS. This is not an extreme right position, it is a Constitutional position.

  • @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    20 күн бұрын

    You should read it!😂😂

  • @benjaminloggins2754
    @benjaminloggins275426 күн бұрын

    The problem with the Democrats argument is they are conveniently ignoring what comes after their incomplete quoting of section 2 of the 14th Amendment. They need to read the whole section and not just the part that supports their disingenuous argument. They are right about one thing. The 14th Amendment is very clear. Every person should be counted for apportionment, but it's very clear that apportionment is to be reduced by subtracting from the count any individual that is disqualified from being allowed to vote.

  • @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    20 күн бұрын

    You mean the Republicons. 😂. Not everyone who lives in the country can vote. That's not the same thing as counting the population.

  • @benjaminloggins2754

    @benjaminloggins2754

    19 күн бұрын

    @@lbthingsstuffmore9513 It's not about voting. It's about allocation of representation. If someone is in this country illegally, they have no right to be represented in Congress. Their mere presence also should not be allowed to effect our presidential elections. The bill being presented doesn't effect apportionment of government funds, only the apportionment of congressional seats and electoral college votes. The 14th Amendment clearly gives Congress this authority (you just have to read the whole thing)

  • @CivilizedWarrior

    @CivilizedWarrior

    19 күн бұрын

    I nearly died when he said “If you want to follow the constitution, in its original meaning, you have to do it all of the time, not just when the text favors your policy outcome.” Really? I wonder if he feels the same way about the 2nd amendment? Actually I don’t, I know for a fact that he does not, because it wouldn’t favor his policy outcome. This whole thing is quite clearly an ill-disguised and desperate attempt for democrats to obtain more electoral college votes in blue states, where most illegals reside in sanctuary states and cities. Cheaters til the very end. You gotta give them credit where it’s due, at least they are consistent!

  • @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    19 күн бұрын

    @benjaminloggins2754, what are you watching? Because this hearing is about adding a citizenship question to the census. It is about apportionment and funds. That's how representation works.😅 There are plenty of people here legally who can't vote. That's why you count everyone! It's plain as day in the Constitution. Btw, women couldn't vote until 1919, so your point is silly. You count everyone!

  • @benjaminloggins2754

    @benjaminloggins2754

    19 күн бұрын

    @@lbthingsstuffmore9513 never said not to count everyone. The bill they are discussing doesn't say not to count everyone. Democrats are the only ones saying that this bill says not to count everyone. This bill says that everyone should be counted, and that federal funding and services should be apportioned according to total count. The only change is the citizenship question and that congressional seat and electoral votes be apportioned according to population of legal CITIZENS not just voters. Non-citizens, legal or not, have no right to have a say in our government or how the government is ran. The 14th Amendment clearly gives Congress the authority. Just read the entire section 2, not just the first part, like ol Can't-tell-the-truth Raskin.

  • @Dr.Cosmar
    @Dr.Cosmar22 күн бұрын

    Censure Ratskin.

  • @dorothyfogerson6741
    @dorothyfogerson674126 күн бұрын

    I lived 5 years in a mobile home park an all that time I never got a letter to prove where I was born nor if I was legal nor how many people lived there, I don't believed that any residents got to report either. And there were mobile homes with 3 or 4 families living in each home that didn't spoke English, some had up to 5 families in one home, squeeze like sardines. The never counted how many persons live in the whole mobile park.

  • @nancynelms6455

    @nancynelms6455

    26 күн бұрын

    Disney World Warehouse I told him I had two jobs and they said where do you work and what are you doing I said what what does that have to do with the senses go away I'm here I did you stupid thing I'm not answering that question it's none of their business

  • @shulahamilton9025
    @shulahamilton902523 күн бұрын

    We need voter ID. Do you realize that Vivek and Tump are the only TWO candidates that are wealthy on their own. They don't need Burisma, Insider Trading

  • @ScottGraham-fy3pr
    @ScottGraham-fy3pr22 күн бұрын

    Everyone who is born in the United States is given a birth certificate and a social security number. Between that information taxes paid to the IRS it's fair to say the number of people living in the United States is already accounted for. If you do not have an ID on your person in public in most states it is illegal. Got to have it to drive a car. Got to have social security card in order to pay taxes. All of the information is already there. Anybody who's not in that list is not an American citizen. Therefore they should not be making decisions for American citizens.

  • @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    20 күн бұрын

    You know, you pay taxes when you shop. Did they say, "ID, please?" Oh, no? You show your ID when you register to vote. Many states vote by mail. How does your theory work?

  • @JasRaymond1
    @JasRaymond121 күн бұрын

    How is this even a debate ? If they are not citizens why should they be counted ?

  • @jammahamma3058
    @jammahamma305825 күн бұрын

    Having a citizenship question on the census would not deter anybody from declaring whether they are US citizen or not citizenship questions are on applications for assistance. They are up on applications for jobs. What if the citizenship question has never been on the censorship how in the world would you possibly know that it was a true people from non-citizens from stating whether they are citizen or not how would you know if it’s never been a question on the censorship that it would deter people, you have no way of knowing that if it’s never been try tried

  • @leslieborgia5590
    @leslieborgia559020 күн бұрын

    If you are not an American citizen, you do not have the American right to vote that is ours an hours alone

  • @jjgregory4844
    @jjgregory484422 күн бұрын

    Person but NOT ILLEGAL PERSON

  • @fireman3067
    @fireman306726 күн бұрын

    Has the line not been drawn in the sand yet ??

  • @ken2tou
    @ken2tou20 күн бұрын

    There should be no debate. Citizens only.

  • @petsr4mj
    @petsr4mj19 күн бұрын

    This is common sense. Non citizens should not be counted because taxpayers should not be paying their expenses

  • @md3280
    @md328020 күн бұрын

    Hell yeah American citizens first and always !

  • @6spdkeg
    @6spdkeg21 күн бұрын

    Crazy why they even need to debate this. Anyone that votes for none citizens to vote should be removed from office. Voter ID should be required. You need two forms of ID to get a job at most places. Why should you need any less to vote for the most powerful position in the world!

  • @user-pm2eq5dj7m
    @user-pm2eq5dj7m23 күн бұрын

    Raskin is a slime ball

  • @scottpittsinger1654
    @scottpittsinger165422 күн бұрын

    IT IS EVERY, AMERICAN I.E, REGISTERED.LEGAL CITIZENS DUTY, TO VOTE LETS NOT DEVIANT IT!

  • @scottpittsinger1654
    @scottpittsinger165422 күн бұрын

    THIS IS VOTER RIGHT TO VOTE. AS A CITIZEN.. A LEGAL, REGISTERED CITICIN

  • @bigshrek3926
    @bigshrek392626 күн бұрын

    We deserve everything we are about to get and even more!!!! The Men and Women with our interest in mind are outnumbered or have RINO's in their midst. It's coming Guy's and Gal's so hang on!!!

  • @stevenjernaginii7748
    @stevenjernaginii774823 күн бұрын

    Following the u, s, constitution is the u. S constitution, it's not for anyone else in the world

  • @jjgregory4844
    @jjgregory484422 күн бұрын

    How the hell is the discrimination of the Native Americans, referred to as “untaxed Indians” still being allowed to happen? I suppose they are labelled “untaxed” intentionally, to deny and prohibit their representation. That is disgraceful!!

  • @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    @lbthingsstuffmore9513

    20 күн бұрын

    Read a history book. Native Americans were not "citizens" until 1923. Funny how racism works.

  • @kathleenrudnick2973
    @kathleenrudnick297321 күн бұрын

    The count of people ( not for the votes ) but for financial assistance for each State when urgent need arise- how much are these unknown people going to freely move around in our country?? You’ll never have count correctly… Crazy that this ever happened all these people and no passport or ID !

  • @leslieaharden6183
    @leslieaharden618321 күн бұрын

    We need accountable districting - by citizens, not by how many illegal people occupy a city or live here. Illegal people are creating burdens on healthcare system and infrastructure that taxpayers fun. Agree that inquiring about citizenship should be the uses-as that is more important than their sexual presence or some of the existing questions. Apportionment should not be politically manipulated. It's BS to consider that unconstitutional.

  • @josephcontreras3988
    @josephcontreras398814 күн бұрын

    This is a no-brainer I don't even need to watch the debate only citizen should count.

  • @earllannum9613
    @earllannum961326 күн бұрын

    Don’t!!

  • @jamesgalbraith1742
    @jamesgalbraith174226 күн бұрын

    The last thing this country needs is some more stupid rules

  • @lesliecruz6112
    @lesliecruz611220 күн бұрын

    These millions of people carefully placed in specific locations sounds like were going to be attacked soon 🥺

  • @LyzStarwalker
    @LyzStarwalker26 күн бұрын

    Way to go!

  • @rogerscottcathey
    @rogerscottcathey20 күн бұрын

    We need accurate data on who are here that are not citizens, absolutely.

  • @mitzilangpitman4491
    @mitzilangpitman449126 күн бұрын

    Yes...

  • @user-ft5jm3mh8b
    @user-ft5jm3mh8b21 күн бұрын

    New Mexico has 35% non-citizens? Wow.

  • @vanessadelledonne8567
    @vanessadelledonne856726 күн бұрын

    Hell yeah

  • @johndymond4596
    @johndymond459619 күн бұрын

    Title 18 needs to be scrutinized

  • @Smokerise4969
    @Smokerise496920 күн бұрын

    If they are receiving funds they damn well better answer if they are here illegally or if they don't NOMONEY NO HOME NO NOTHING IS TO BE GIVIN TO THEM AT ALL!

  • @scottpittsinger1654
    @scottpittsinger165422 күн бұрын

    IT'S OUR NOT TOTALL TRUE CITIZENS

  • @keithmartin3914
    @keithmartin391426 күн бұрын

    That means you better take it off job applications and state forms that question that’s exactly what they want. They want that question of every form. Why do you ask On government papers birth certificates drivers license but we can’t ask here that’s stupid.

  • @scottpittsinger1654
    @scottpittsinger165422 күн бұрын

    WHY1 BORDERS BEEN BREECHED

  • @deborahjoyvalentine6180
    @deborahjoyvalentine618021 күн бұрын

    🗽Of, By and For We The American Legal Citizens🗽 Let us VOTE on this topic‼📣 They KNOW the Landslide they face 🇺🇸US🇺🇸 so Global Cabal, OBiden and Olygarchy slither and speak forked tongue AVOIDING our Vote‼📣🇺🇸🗽

  • @PamelaSimpson-cu9mg
    @PamelaSimpson-cu9mg26 күн бұрын

    2020 can't that a lock down! You obviously didn't care. Or, you wouldn't of put a burden on US citizens for a vote that discriminated are Wotld.

  • @JerryWilson-je5pg
    @JerryWilson-je5pg19 күн бұрын

    We don't mind counting the residents of this country. The legal ones we know what you guys are doing and you know we know what you're doing. And yet this guy will stand up regurgitate. The same vomit over and over again. Bring in somebody else

  • @WhydoIsuddenlyhaveahandle
    @WhydoIsuddenlyhaveahandle19 күн бұрын

    Wait this isn't the law now? What in the actual eff? Non citizens are determining US congressional seats? What the fuck good are the courts if this is allowed to be a thing?

  • @PromethiaSHADOW
    @PromethiaSHADOW20 күн бұрын

    How would you even manage that?

  • @kanoamerikano2830
    @kanoamerikano283019 күн бұрын

    Identifying a population of a certain state viz a viz citizen, illegal aliens, green card holder, Legal resident MUST be made known.

  • @user-ft5jm3mh8b
    @user-ft5jm3mh8b21 күн бұрын

    "Excluding Indians not taxed". Implies other groups "not taxed", including "illegal immigrants" flooding into our country should be excluded as well. Those who come in through valid ports of entry should be treated as existing laws or regulations demand/allow.

  • @chermainemadison2729
    @chermainemadison272920 күн бұрын

    THEM DECIDING NOT TO SIGN CENCUS IS NOT A REASON TO NOT ASK !!!..IT IS YOUR JOB TO ASK THE QUESTION AND MAKE IT CLEAR IT WILL NOT AFFECT THEIR GREEN CARD OR THEIR SITUATION BY INCLUDING THAT INFO IN THE CENSUS SO THEY CAN READ IT .. HOWEVER NOT A CITZEN YOU ARE NOT TO BE COUNTED!!!

  • @DaveSmith-pm2yq
    @DaveSmith-pm2yq14 күн бұрын

    Raskin is wrong The reason why it didn't say based on citizens was so slaves would be counted as "percentage" of person. (a despicable thing but not the point here.) A slave wasn't a citizen. Get it? He doesn't.

  • @jenniferwilson7150
    @jenniferwilson715026 күн бұрын

    What exactly do you really need the census for anyway? It just seems like a power grab

  • @carolynklestinec8589

    @carolynklestinec8589

    26 күн бұрын

    No it is so states get funding for programs, schools, roads and bridges ( supposedly what a lie) . And for the # of house seats and senators .

  • @jenniferwilson7150

    @jenniferwilson7150

    26 күн бұрын

    @@carolynklestinec8589 yes supposedly

  • @boatman352
    @boatman35221 күн бұрын

    It should have already been this way. The United States Constitution does not apply to non citizens

Келесі