I’m going with the eternal edition. I will support any manga printed on glossy paper. We need more editions that have better contrast for the black and white. Plus I love seeing how big the drawings are. It makes me feel like I’m holding an original manuscript or something.

I’m just waiting for them to re release the art books. Can we start a movement to get this back in print. Like an email chain/petition? Lol something?

@chocopancakez

2 жыл бұрын

I would love to have the artbooks ahhhh

@sailorfan86

2 жыл бұрын

I am dying to re-own all of the artbooks. But make it a whole book. Hard bound. Never owned the Artbook ideas. And I want that one too. We don’t need the reprints of the Manga.

@MissCroft09

2 жыл бұрын

Yes please. I need the last Artbook, but they´re super expensive D:

@danielwillingham4618

4 ай бұрын

Sailor Moon is one of my favorite Anime & Manga my Favorite Sailor Moon Character is Sailor Moon

@philip1718

3 ай бұрын

They just released a new artbook!

We need a full release of the manga in colour! To see the story we all love in full colour would be a no-brainer full purchase!!!

I'm definitely going to buy the NTC version! Because I consider myself a sailor moon manga purist I collect all the manga that comes out in the states, and I'm glad that they're making the minor changes from the perfect editions for the NTC version. The 2011 translation was just so unnatural to me, so I'm majorly looking forward to collecting all of them!

Lots of great information in this video, and it is great to see all three editions all together!

Thank-you for this amazing guide & comparison! 💖

Hi I'm from germany and we have a hard cover version from the eternal edition. 😍 Thank you for your videos!

Can't wait to watch! Sailor moon Physical media related video like dvd, bluray or Manga reviews, I'm such a sucker for it 😅

I am tempted to buy these new sailor moon manga because of the translation but I saw it in stores and The aesthetics of the cover and spine do not bring me any joy. Since I already have the large eternal editions I may just go with the older small manga before they go out of stock. Great video as always. Thank you!

YASSS!!! Great vid! Thanks Ochi

As always ochi you slay reviews! 💗💗💗

@brendakrcywicki3800

Жыл бұрын

🌟yes

Hi, I'm from Canada. Great review. I decided to check out your video after watching Sailor Tortilla's review of the 3 english versions of the manga. I bought my copy of NTC volume 1 from Indigo last year. I have already purchased volumes 2 and 3 and I'll be ordering volume 4 in a couple weeks. 😊

Awesome recap!!! Awesome video Ochi!!

Tysm for making videos for us and thank you for all the get better wishes 💖

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

Aww you're so welcome. I wish you a speedy recovery!

I'm surprised😯 that they're releasing another new sailor moon manga but it's smaller than the bigger eternal edition.💁‍♀️🌙📘 I can see that it's similar to the 2014 ones, although it only has one color page.🤨 For me, I like the 2018 SM eternal mangas more because it has some colored pages and shiny too.🥰💖🌙 I got the whole set from Barnes & Nobles.📗 Hopefully they'll make an all color version of them one day.🤞🎨 I also like that picture of a deer in a wolf's head.😀🦌🐺 Thanks for sharing with us and see you later.😉✌🌙

Call me crazy but I wish the Eternal Editions were hardback.

@QueenWaspGo

2 жыл бұрын

With a dust jacket.

Yay i can't wait 🤗

Amazing review!!!

I originally passed on the EE because I wasn’t sure if I wanted the larger books and the higher price, so I ran to B&N last night and picked up Vol 1 of the NTC 😁 I’m so excited! I have all of the 2011 editions and the English TokyoPop/Mixx editions, so I’m excited for the more accurate translation with this edition! Honestly still torn if I eventually want to pick up EE too for the beautiful covers and all the color pages 😅

Thus was a great review! I didnt realize the NTC will have 10 issues vs the 12 from the 2011 version, not a problem just assumed would be the same. It is kind of sad the NTC has less color pages than the 2011, you would think it would have more for what comes off as a special edition overall. I passed on the 2011 and didnt love the size or price of the EE (at least not for a full collection) but do plan to get the full NTC collection now. Maybe at least the 1st EE for the color pages 😁

If the entire color book collection ever exists, they deserve to be hardcover!!! 🌙💕

Thanks for the review, I got the 2011 collection, and after seeing this video, I will totally get the NEW NTC collection.🤩

The moment I heard they were gonne stop printing the earlier versions I ordered the last 6 volumes I still needed! Waiting for those to arrive rn. :)

Thank u for the super review 💕I'm new to manga awareness of such yes my daughter is manga fan but I personally never read go figure lol so this really peeks my interest 😆now a new hobby starts

@ochibawolf

Жыл бұрын

I'm glad you enjoyed this review Brenda!

Cant wait! I already have the version ur talking about in the title. It’s basically the same lol

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

Did you notice that Moon stick/wand difference?

It is exciting to see yet another Sailor Moon translation on the market and I do get why they're re-realeasing the small sized mangas. My questions is, tho, does "Right Stuff" ship internationally or just in Canada and the USA?

I missed the premiere since I was at work, but I've been looking forward to this video since I saw you announce it on your Instagram! I'm very happy that the established conventions will be used for lore terms. That was what made me pass on the Eternal Edition prints. I'll be picking up the Naoko Takeuchi Collection prints when I can for sure! ♥ Thanks so much for the review, Ochi.

I'm collecting all three editions. The 2011 reminds me of the Tokyopop version I had as a teenager in the early 2000s. I have most of the 2011 collection right now. I'm just missing issues 3,4, and 5 which I will be getting shortly. So far my preference is the Eternal version based on the size and color pages.

Thanks Ochi! I’d love to get an exclusive poster version from US but I don’t think it’s available here in UK. Also cnt wait to get a copy of our SM Polish hard cover ee manga which should be released in 2023! Have a good one 😘

So funny! I was researching which version of the manga to get and read the site and followed the link to the video and it’s you!! Haha I have the eternal version of sailor v and I read about half of it and gave up as I read manga in bed and it’s way too heavy and I found it a little too childish for me. But as you know from Instagram, I am watching the viz 90’s version of moon and loving it’s so I want to read the manga and excited to see that there’s a hand held version for easy reading

I love sailor moon sm, I’ve watched it sense I was honestly out of the womb, watching them on the vhs tapes ( still in amazing condition surprisingly) and when I got older I got the change to expand my watching of sailor moon w tv stuff. I’m such a fan, if I didn’t get raised watching sailor moon I really wouldn’t be me today I tell you that! I sorta feels like the anime is for me in a way but ik the fame has raised w the manga and shows. It’s amazing but 😖 maybe I’m a little gatekeeper idk it just feels weird to see it grown to be so popular when it sets in a extremely important spot in my soul and everyday life. But I’m only 17 lmfao so all I know the older I get the more obsessed I will be😂, I’ve rewatched it countless times. Man idk I’m feelin a wayyyy, what I’m saying it’s really cool to see a lady like you as passionate of sailor moon like me, though it spooks me

Really enjoyed the video, now I know how to buy & where to buy!!

@ochibawolf

Жыл бұрын

I am so glad this video helped!!

I will be definitely picking up this release cause I personally prefer single volume manga to omnibus manga.

i am so glade i waited on buying the eternal editions was going to start buying them soon but now i know about this new collection edition i will definitely grab these reader travel friendly versions

super helpful!!!!! buying and reading for the first time hehe

@ochibawolf

Жыл бұрын

So glad it was helpful! I'm excited for you!

I’m really glad I preordered the first volume.

I like the idea of the NTC because it's smaller and cheaper but those iridescent covers of the EE have me in a chokehold... expensive but pretty... I think I will try and collect the EE even though I only have vol.1 currently I just can't not complete the collection

@KaytNicol3

2 жыл бұрын

UPDATE: I saw the NTC in a Waterstones today and I just had to buy it! Looks like I'll be collecting both versions, focusing on the NTC since its cheaper and then once I have all/most of them I'll turn my attention back to the EE collection

It’s a shame I can’t really use right stuff since im not in America they are so much more expensive because of postage to Australia for some reason buying from them off of ebay it’s a little cheaper, so booktopia is definitely more affordable for me even though they don’t take as much care in their shipping but it’s doubly expensive for more to buy from right stuff but for one jojo volume buying from them on ebay is probably my best bet

I like sailor moon as a kid back then and I got a sailor moon manga for Christmas and i’m getting a sailor moon manga for my 19th birthday on August i’m a fan of sailor moon

I love the art of the 2011 covers bought got all the eternal editions and now you're making me want those 2011 lmaoooo

Spectacular!

@ochibawolf

Жыл бұрын

Thank you!!

I have volume 1 of the EE and it is hard for me to physically read. So I did buy volumes 1 & 2 of the NTCs! So excited!

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

totally get that! I love the NTCs!

This is a good set to get. See, I have arthritis in my hands and holding heavy books hurts my hands. But this release is very light.

The only volume I’m missing from 2011 is Short Stories 1…..it’s so expensive 😭

Thank you for clarifying how many color pages are in the NTC! I already have all the EE editions so I don’t need to quadruple dip now!

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

my pleasure! And if these follow the bunko's exactly how they are in japan, no color pages after vol 1 & 2! D:

@TsukasaElkKite

2 жыл бұрын

@@ochibawolf Oh no!

This is my very first manga, since we finally got a store that sells mangas in my country, and I had to start with my all time fav Sailor Moon NTC!

I got excited for a second because I thought it was new stories but they should make new stories in new manga’s because I have all old manga’s. as well as all the Sailor Moon DVDs

I’m collecting the naoko Takeuchi editions. I prefer the size and the cover art. This is actually my first time collecting them and actually enjoying it since I had the 2011 edition back when I was in middle school but I couldn’t get into them since the English literally gave me head aches. But the naoko Takeuchi edition made me really appreciate sailor moon. After I finished volume 2, I couldn’t help but think “damn, sailor moon really is a super hero.”

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

I love that you said this! I too agree the 2011 translations were a bit rough. I really love the updated translations in the NTC!

@Laprincesadequincenare

Жыл бұрын

@@ochibawolf sorry for replying 6 months late 😅 but I remember back i was 7th grade who have trouble read and write and needs special help. I was reading Sailor Moon 2011 ver as my diary read every day, I have some trouble reading the works that English translation doesn't good well and little rough well to read the series. I asked for help with my parents or my reading teacher and they said that English translation doesn't make sense. But I know the story, been learning lot from Sailor moon characters and I love their art 😍 but sadly they won't selling them anymore because of new one. I love this old cute front cover and back too. I got new translation for my 11 year old niece and I love new translation to make lots sense now!

I first borrowed the 2011 from my local library a few years back and there were some very prominent grammatical errors that drove me crazy which is why I never collected them. I was on the fence with the Eternal editions just because of how big they were and the price point. I’m really excited for the NTC collection and I’ve preordered the first one! I’m really hoping they fixed those spelling errors. I am bummed about the less colored pages than the 2011, but overall with the price and size I’m really happy! Mine is set to come on Friday so here’s to hoping I Love this version enough to want to collect the rest. I’m assuming they’re also going to do Sailor V too?

I miss on the premiere of this video but I preordered this Volume on amazon! i cant wait for it to come today Update : it came in good shape.

As someone who owned the original Mixx version - and who now works in manga publishing - the EE's size and glossy paper disappointed me. I'll miss the color inserts for sure and the nice pink end pages of the EE but thanks to your informative review, I'll continue my collection with the NTC!

I initally had my NTC order on amazon, but after watching this video I have cancelled it. Picked up every EE book, I am giddy with excitement as i've never read the manga!

@ochibawolf

6 ай бұрын

I'm glad my video helped you come to a decision! enjoy~

My wish for next Sailor Moon manga for 35 or 40 anniversary is a full color, same book cover as Eternal Edition but little small and still shiny glitter! Ya A manga with full book no black and white!

Okay update, I reread the first volume of sailor v and having watched some 90’s sailor moon, I now get the vibe and enjoyed it

All coloured Sailor Moon manga would be insane! PS: I also got vol.1-3 of the NTCs. 😁

You planning on get the new viz bluray release of season 1? If so can we get a comparison to the original blurays? If there are differences

I love the eternal edition manga most

As much as I love Sailor Moon I prefer the anime itself over the Manga versions.

See you soon 😘

Thanks for the review, it's great that new stuff is coming out. But tbh I think this one is pretty unnecessary and a downgrade in every way (except the translation) compared to the 2011 manga. I have to note that I only know the German version though. People over here also critisized the translation of the 2011 one, but not that much I think - I never had a problem with it. Why is the version with the least features called Naoko Takeuchi collection? I don't really think it deserves that name tbh. The Eternal Edition is definitely the best one. Sure, it's expensive, but for a cheaper version I would always prefer the 2011 version. Still, it's exiting that new stuff comes out, and hopefully it will bring new attention to the franchise.^^

I found mine at an antique shop and i thought it was like 20 years old or something😭

I'm currently collecting the NTC version and accidentally got the eternal version cuz I thought they were the same release in a different size XDDD no wonder the spines didn't match up

Do all the of the 2011 versions contain coloured pages in the beginning? I’m stuck between purchasing the EE and NTC. But for a full collection my wallet would prefer the NTCs lol

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah there's a spot in this video where I show you the color pages in the 2011 and also you can watch this video I made a while back kzread.info/dash/bejne/ZpqGqspmedSrgbA.html

I have been a SM manga collector since the Tokyopop days, in both English and Japanese languages and this is the first edition I have decided not to buy. Previously every new release brought something new to the table, but this version is literally identical to the EE except smaller, on lower quality paper and with fewer color pages.

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

Did you like the minor changes like the Moon stick?

@alexandermackay9636

2 жыл бұрын

@@ochibawolf between Eternal and NTC? I don't feel like those changes are enough to justify the extra expense, for people who don't want to shell out the big bucks for EE this does seem like a solid option though.

Oh god. I am so torn. Can't afford the eternal edition. But the Naoko one is cheaper and such. But I would miss the color pages..... I don't know what I should do. I heard EE is hard to read? And you said its a bit heavy. Is it awkward to read? Like if you're sitting on couch or something and so forth?

No I just missed your live stream!

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

always next time! Maybe you can join in on the stream tomorrow?

@serenasilvercrest3154

2 жыл бұрын

@@ochibawolf I hope so I was so happy to watch your video live only to have missed it, I only got to see the last 2 mins of it. But now that I have seen the whole video it's great very helpful:)

I’m planning to get the ntc version but i have questions. Why will there be 10 and not 12? Will they be making vol 9 & 10 jumbo sizes to complete the story? Will there be code V release too? What about the short stories? Thank you in advance

did they change the name of the silver crystal?

Do we know how long before each volume will release?

Is there a full color version officially released. I see alot of colored scans online but never found where to buy it.

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

Did you miss the part in the video where I answer this question? It's towards the end :)

@stuntdoll

2 жыл бұрын

Not yet. If Japan makes a physical copy, USA may follow. It might take years. :(

Wow!! I'm surprised at the size difference between the English version and the Japanese version of the NTC's!! Mine are sooooo tiny!!

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah! the USA loves to go much larger on manga than JP haha

@SailorVdizzle

2 жыл бұрын

@@ochibawolf Haha!! You are definitely right!! 😂😂

@Laprincesadequincenare

2 жыл бұрын

@@ochibawolf that bc Japanese people are tiny 😅

Already have the first 9 vols of the 2011 releases. is it worth getting these new editions or should i just get the last 3 vols of the editions i already have?

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

I prefer the EE or NTC

My husband spotted this manga at Target. We got it 20% off 🥰

I saw that they have a German and French hardcover for the eternal edition. Do you know if they will make one in English? I know a little bit of French, but I wish they had an English for the price I would pay lol.

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

If you watched this entire video, towards the end, I explain our USA releases are following Japan's. So if Japan gets a hardcover we most likely will, if they continue to follow the trend.

@miscellaneouscell

2 жыл бұрын

@@ochibawolf Yes I did watch the entire video. I just realized that the eternal hardcover French and German versions are published by PIKA and not Kodansha.

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

@@miscellaneouscell yeah we're following the Japanese releases it appears. So until they get one, then we might get one :)

Hello!!! I have a question I didn't know they were son many version I'm new to manga, I got today vol #1 2022 sailor moon but 2 days ago I got vol#2 2011 version thinking it was the same. What do you recommend

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

Definitely the 2022. The 2011's translation is pretty bad in some spots.

@keroppi84

2 жыл бұрын

@@ochibawolf thank you!

First a shout out to the original Tokyo Pop English manga, still hoping to get those one day for a reasonable price 😢 and secondly... Oh wow, they actually fixed some stuff from the translation in the eternal editions. More reason to get them as collector, regardless how small the change is lol 😮😂 Well I wanted the Barnes and nobles exclusive version but after seeing people's posts about it, I'm not missing out much lol the poster is super tiny and not worth taking it out of the book. That color page is in the Japanese bunko edition too, so I'm glad they brought that over since that color page wasn't on the perfect/eternal edition, so it's safe to say that the volume 2 color page will be there too. One surprising thing about this new version, is the size, like you said almost the same as the 2011 edition. I thought its would be the same size as the bunko edition from Japan. I have volume 1 & 2 and they tiny lol. Fantastic video, I'm such a nerd for those kind of videos lol by the way... Loved the low key shade to a certain website 😜

@alexandermackay9636

2 жыл бұрын

If you do start collecting the tokyopop editions be very careful in your selection. Tokyopop used very cheap glue to bind their books and pages came loose all the time. As a child I often had to ask my mother, who was a working librarian, to take my books into work and have the pages reset and glued.

@CucasNerdyCorner

2 жыл бұрын

@@alexandermackay9636 thanks for the tip, but I highly doubt I'll ever unless I'm extremely lucky buy them for super cheap. Even if I did get them, I'll never read lol it's for collection purposes 😅

I hope to get the ntc editions, the eternal editions are way too big for my taste, and I have three of the 2011's but I'd like to switch to the ntc's for the better translations

Also, will Sailor V and the Short Stories get a release in this edition?

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

They should, yes :)

@Laprincesadequincenare

2 жыл бұрын

@@ochibawolf i wish :p Sailor moon Short Stories are only one i don't read yet :

Is there a Japanese version of the NTC for Sailor V?

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

There is a Takeuchi Naoko Bunko of Sailor V so I bet we'll see those come here too (Kodansha hasn't announced those yet though)

Hi! Is it normal for the volume 3 to be without that first colored page???

@ochibawolf

11 ай бұрын

Yup no colored first page in volume 3. We’re learning about these as they release. 4 is coming out next month!

I hate that I have to get the new ones 🤣

I prefer Moon Wand so I'll stick with the Eternal Editions. I also wish the artwork of the cover of the new edition was centred better.

We need original manga Sailor Moon with all colors page

Thats a lot of sailor moon

✨⭐✨💞💖💞💖💞💖💞✨⭐✨

There are actually 4 releases in America anyway. The original release was a cut version which called Usagi, Bunny.

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

this video only covers the IN PRINT releases :)

@SakuraandSesshomaru

2 жыл бұрын

@@ochibawolf Just because it’s out of print doesn’t mean it never existed.

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

​@@SakuraandSesshomaru I never said it didn't exist. I am just offering some clarification this video only covers in print releases :)

I'm totally done buying any book on amazon.

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

what happened?

I talked to some of the people who worked on the localization of this release, and it sounds like Moon Wand > Moon Stick wasn't the only termonology that was changed. I imagine we'll have things like the "Malefic Black Crystal" again too. Also wasn't the All Color Edition just supposed to be the first arc?

Hello, I have a question: Are the NTC editions the same size as regular manga, or slightly smaller? Thank you for your help in advance. 🌙 😊 🌙

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

Hi! Not sure what regular manga means but I gave the size in the video

@stuntdoll

2 жыл бұрын

The NTC edition is 7.07 x 0.68 x 9.99 inches. The 2011 edition is 5 x 0.64 x 7.5 inches. The Eternal edition is the biggest at 7.11 x 0.7 x 10 inches.

Number of volumes released for the NTC

The way the translations keep getting more and more literal (eg. changing “wand” to “stick”) REALLY takes me out of it. Manga shouldn’t just be translated, it should be interpreted.

@ochibawolf

2 жыл бұрын

Moon stick is the actual name of the item though. It's all over the proplica, collectibles, etc.