10 years ago, if you had told me this was a Bring Me the Horizon song, I would have laughed so hard I'd have to re-straighten my hair.

@MusicShed

3 жыл бұрын

It woulda re straightened all by itself!

@aka_tinalouise

3 жыл бұрын

This comment made me laugh so hard 🤣😂🤣

@bravomikefox5449

3 жыл бұрын

They’ve come an impossible distance from the start, but this is an evolution, not a regression. Embrace ollies talent.

@massgrave8x

3 жыл бұрын

@@bravomikefox5449 In no way was my comment intended as a diss, just poking fun at the 2008-2010 metalcore/deathcore scene

@creatively_unavail

3 жыл бұрын

@@massgrave8x They changed so much from when they first came out. I mean his screaming made 0 sense it was so hard to even understand when they were life and now, wow. My favorite band. The lyrics have gotten so much deeper.

Fun fact, when he sang "you know I can't breathe on my own" she sung "you know you can't breathe on your own" to symbolize we need nature but it doesn't need us

@emmaburgess1705

3 жыл бұрын

The song is quite literally Earth and Humans. Amy's voice is supposed to be Earth and Oli's is supposed to be the role of the Human. It's an awesome song!!

@archangelsailo6925

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah.. this song is deep and dark.. and all of it could come true if we didn't change..

I love the abrupt ending. She's still singing but fading out. He's singing but screaming that fades out. Her at peace with an end she couldn't change. Him in anguish over a future they could have made. Then....... Nothing. It's such a beautiful way to end that song.

Amy Lee has a hauntingly, resonating, captivating voice

@MusicShed

3 жыл бұрын

Yes she does

@phantom_angel

3 жыл бұрын

@@MusicShed 🥰

@Taxman5scotty

3 жыл бұрын

Shes an all around beautiful human

Wait people are getting mad because he pauses the music? If you wanna listen to music, then go and listen to music. He reacts to it, and I love his comments! It's better than half of the "reaction" videos when they watch it and say "that was great" and move their head like they're insane for 3 to 4 minutes... You are doing a great job. I watch mostly the BMTH reaction videos, but only because I'm obsessed with BMTH for years XD

@amitthapa1801

3 жыл бұрын

Actually you are right because reaction means to react every rhythm of it .

@bekahnavarro

3 жыл бұрын

Exactly. I think some people just want to see someone rocking out the corner of the screen while the video plays. That's just stealing content.

So if you want to hear just an insane amount of emotion from BMTH, I highly reccomend Hospital for Souls and The Snakes Start to Sing. Loved your reaction to this track.

@ameliaredick3015

3 жыл бұрын

Yes! Agree

@gamingassassin5898

3 жыл бұрын

Also it never ends

@linkin_p4rk435

3 жыл бұрын

And deathbeds... :)

@alexpalacios1151

3 жыл бұрын

Or dont go

@kenn0th3

3 жыл бұрын

Oh no live at rah. Its „Poppy“ and great

Its just mind blowing to watch you listen to a new song and just instantly play it back on the keyboard. This is coming from a musician that plays drums and self taught drum kit player. I can do this to an extent but it just makes my brain want to explode every time.

@eduardog8782

3 жыл бұрын

Same same, I'm nowhere near a pro musician but I know what I'm mostly doing and playing back to a new song really gives me a headache lol major props!

@Eleanor8965

3 жыл бұрын

@@eduardog8782 I’d love to see him expand down the road and do videos on music theory or some sort of educational series on music. That man has some things in him that need to be shared. Lol

@orginizegeneral

3 жыл бұрын

I know man he ridiculously talented

@Cityz3nn

3 жыл бұрын

@@Eleanor8965 well to be fair, he has perfect pitch which you can't learn ahah But yeah you can work on this to an extent, it must be awesome to be able to play instantly something you heard

@b-radg916

3 жыл бұрын

This is the first time I’ve seen this guy, but 7:15 blew my mind!

The story of this song is so haunting as the song is sang from the perspectives of Mother Earth and Mankind and the harmful relationship they have with each other! Amy and Oli honestly complimented each other vocally so mesmerisingly as they both experimented with new vocal styles and it honestly in my opinion created a masterpiece! Excellent reaction as always David thank you! 🙏🏼

@josefranciscogasparini9082

3 жыл бұрын

Bullet Club 4444 Life

@AKprime051

3 жыл бұрын

Oh fuck I love that.

@BoundlessOwl

3 жыл бұрын

i get its between mother earth and mankind, but honestly it sums up my past relationship quite well, and it hits deep

@bcog9519

3 жыл бұрын

@@BoundlessOwl yeah I get that, the lyrics have that feeling about them 100% and I think that’s where the greatness of the song really comes through as it could be applicable to any situation in which someone you love is gone.

Apparently the end of this song is a lead-in to their next planned EP/album. We'll see if that's true, but if so, they're freakin brilliant.

@modeeeeee

3 жыл бұрын

😱😱😱

@AKprime051

3 жыл бұрын

Would not surprise me, this project is a two-parter and these guys are known to pull slick shit like that.

@pearcey86

3 жыл бұрын

No way..... Sick!

@omegazx7236

3 жыл бұрын

@@AKprime051 it's a four-parter actually 😂

@madisonlindy

3 жыл бұрын

Yes. I need this!

Music Shed is just like that cozy and warm hug in a winter night, with hot chocolate and a firepit. I feel really comfortable and welcomed to be here watching and learning every second about new stuff and music. Eveytime it releases a new video, I send it to my friends so we can feel this vibe all together. Merry Xmas and happy new year, stay safe and healthy, David! ♥

@coljay-ir6os

3 жыл бұрын

YESSSSS

"Why did I never get into Evanescence".... I don't know, but you've been sleeping on them. There are are so many good songs to check out if you're interested. I'd recommend songs like My Immortal, Hello, Lithium, and Good Enough if you want softer, more piano-based songs and songs like My Tourniquet, Everybody's Fool, or Call Me When You're Sober if you wanna go beyond that. Or newer stuff like Use My Voice. Amy Lee also has an awesome duet with Lzzy Hale called Break In, and an amazing duet with her ex, Shaun Morgan (from Seether) called Broken... which was actually originally just a Seether song.

@jesusmanriquez3827

3 жыл бұрын

I think he also should hear the earlier stuff from their EPs, like Lies, Exodus, Understanding, Even in death, Solitude, etc

@levischorpioen

3 жыл бұрын

@@jesusmanriquez3827 I'd love to hear someone analyse their pre-Fallen stuff!

@The.Opal.Lioness

3 жыл бұрын

EVERYONE sleeps on Amy Lee

@stevenluoma1268

3 жыл бұрын

My guess would be that Amy Lee is pretty fantastic and the rest of the band is somewhat bland.

@madelineblaze5072

2 жыл бұрын

Broooo literally anything from ‘Fallen’ or ‘The Open Door’ is a masterpiece

Amy Lee DOES NOT GET ENOUGH RECOGNITION FOR HOW FUCKING BEAUTIFUL HER VOICE HAS ALWAYS BEEN.

@Diamondsrfvr

3 жыл бұрын

@Amber Fuller.....THIS!!

@florf2469

2 жыл бұрын

🙌🙌🙌

@thunderbuns6811

Жыл бұрын

does not get enough recognition? she's widely regarded as one of the best singers ever. so much so that quite a lot of people think she's had opera training, it's become a pretty common myth.

Pronunciation is so important. It's especially noticeable in music with screaming vocals. People can more easily listen to harsh vocals if they can understand what you are saying

David, you remind me a lot of my favorite professor I had in college. He taught English, and was one of the only people to ever reach out to me and tell me how well I could write (I was even offered a job in our Writing Center by him). It meant a lot to me, and actually inspired me to step out of my comfort zone and start writing lyrics for my songs, as opposed to just the instruments. The thing you have in common with him, from what I've seen of your videos, is your level of understanding and comprehension for the thing you love the most, and your ability to instantly throw yourself into it. It's a totally different kind of analysis from what I see on a lot of other channels. I don't mean this to be a dig at anyone else, because I do enjoy a lot of other reaction channels, but the way you listen to a song and are so capable of diving in and feeling the emotion in them is inspiring. It's more than just grabbing a clever lyric, or an impressive high note, you dive into the nuance of every song and I applaud that. This is a true musician's reaction, and from one musician to another I deeply appreciate these. Keep making the awesome videos, and absolutely do a cover of this song!

@MusicShed

3 жыл бұрын

Ty Mr MG

@maehelsinki6464

3 жыл бұрын

Agreed

@Paul_Ward

3 жыл бұрын

I couldn't agree more, I love his analysis in his reactions

Dude Amy Lee is an absolute angel singing...Also Amy Lee is playing the piano as well. You really got to get into Evanescence and her solo stuff

As they are both incredibly gifted musicians, I’m curious as to who will catch David’s eye more between Amy and Oli.

@Dancing_Psycho

3 жыл бұрын

Ear ;)

10:15 - this is why music is life. This is why it touches a part of us that nothing else can. It can move us to feel things we don't feel any other way. I would be dead without music. I am nothing without it. Thank you for showing that to the world.

@madisonlindy

3 жыл бұрын

The ending of this song is so awesome. How this beautiful melody meshes with the screams in the back. How dope would it be if it’s a transition into the first song on the next ep.... epic

@carlosm9111

3 жыл бұрын

@@madisonlindy LOVE IT

Amy Lee has always been my favorite artist. I need to see her in concert and I haven’t yet. Evanescence is my favorite band as you could guess. Haha. Amy Lee is amazing. Oh yeah another newer good song by her is “Use My Voice”

Amy Lee easily one of the best female vocalists today. Just amazing power and control!

On the contrary, I enjoy the fact he pauses the video because he always gives his opinion and interesting bit of music knowledge which is what I watch reaction videos for, I want to know what someone else thinks of the song instead of just watching them listen to it and ending the video.

@thatguynar

3 жыл бұрын

Lol same. I don't watch reaction videos just see people nodding their heads and saying "cool" every now and then.

You have no idea how beautiful it was the melody you created on piano.. it literally made me cry.. I had to replay that part so many times, it really touched me..you need to make a cover out of that song, and also, thank you! 🥺

Amy Lee is an actual angel and nothing will convince me otherwise. She blesses us and we do not deserve it.

i love this song but didn't know the meaning behind the lyrics, well now i love even more, everything just wow make sense, at the end Amy says "you can't" and Oliver as humankind "i can't" in unison...fucking awesome

Seriously one of those songs you dont want to end.

not dry.. PURE. for over 20 years, I have been captivated by the hauntingly angelic voice of our 21st Century Goddess of Rock.. Amy effing Lee.. you just get drawn in by the voice.. time seems to not matter anymore.. I have a few.. older songs you can react to.. 1) Either version of Where Will You Go.. (and even though the lyrics are the same, the musical composition really does turn one song into two.. 2) Anywhere 3) this one is a must.. Exodus... its pure Amy, her voice and a piano

Evanescence has been releasing ton of new music this year, you totally need to check out their latest singles "Wasted On You" relased during quarentine in April, "The Game is Over" released in July (both music videos recorded by the band themselves using their phones bc of the lockdown) and "Use My Voice" released back in September, the 3 music videos are great and very different one from another lyrically, sonically and visually. They are great songs to react, specially now that you liked Amy Lee in this song.

Man I'd love for you to listen to some stuff from Sempiternal. Shadow Moses. And the Snakes Start to sing. Hospital for Souls. House of Wolves. That's gotta be my favorite album by them.

Why people get mad for him pausing the video, go listen the music before the react and then go back here, cuz this man is really feeling this music, and that for me its PRICELESS , and that make the difference between all reactors, soo if u people dont get that, go watch other reactors

This song gives me the full body goosebumps. It's so haunting and beautiful.

You've earned another sub, bud. Not just because of your intro piano piece explaining pauses. Not simply for your awesome music space. Not only cause of musical choice to react to or really good opinions/comments. Nope, it is more than that. It is for the fact you played the song by ear beautifully. Especially that bridge part. I subscribed for more reactions like that. That was amazing.

Amy's strong but captivating voice compliments Oliver's voice so well, oh my god what a song

Beside official Evanescence songs its worth listening to "solo" songs. For example Speak to me from the movie Voice from the stone. Such a great song.

Amy Lee and the Japanese Wagakki Band have been collaborating. The Wagakki Band mixes traditional Japanese and Western instruments. They have a powerful female vocalist (Yuko Suzuhana) who sings in a traditional style called shigin. They have performed the Evanescence song "Bring me to Life" with Amy. And they have done an original song together "Sakura RIsing".

You should definitely do some evanescence reactions Lithium My heart is broken My immortal Going under

What separates your reactions from others is the amount of insight that you share within each pause. Keep it up!

I have a suggestion by Bring Me The Horizon that I'm not sure you've heard yet (I'm new). I would recommend listening to Don't Go by BMTH as it's also a really good slow song from their There is a Hell album. They collaborated with a musician called Lights for this song and it's a heart wrencher. Have a lovely Monday.

Got chills, love your expiration of bliss at the end of the song!

I can't get enough of this song!! 💜💜💜 Wonderful reaction as always!

This is gorgeous!!!! Thank you for your reaction and insight.

I’m so happy you’re listening to this EP/album, it’s really one of the best to come out this year and I can’t wait to hear you cover some of these songs!

Omg I just cried right at the part were you started to played the raw version only with the piano! Thanks for this amazing video

I just loved your reaction! 👏

Another great react! Always look forward to your videos.

got like halfway through this video, being my first vid of yours, and subscribing. appreciate an actual music person who's animated doing reacts!

The reaction you had to this really reminded me of the first time I listened to this song. It absolutely blew me away, and I am so happy whenever I see another person become absolutely captivated by just how masterfully this song was crafted. I feel so blessed to have listened to it.

That was gorgeous man, thank you (Your playing and reaction. I already knew the song was great)

Loved your version, i added it as an intro in a personal mp3 i have of that song, and it also works as an outro. great job!

This is the first video I’ve ever seen by you, and watching you play the piano while listening to them made me really happy. You’re a really talented musician and your insight on how they sing and the different techniques done was so fascinating to listen to! :)

I am so content ans happy. Thank you David!! I love this song and feel like you help me understand it even better. This was a beautiful turn for BMTH!! Your video was much anticipated and much loved!!

My friend, if you like this you absolutely need to check out BMTH - Drown (Live Vevo Performance). It will blow your socks off!

@tymcgraw8502

3 жыл бұрын

Bump

@kinjalbiswas6574

3 жыл бұрын

I +1 this , Oli just blew it out of the park there

I love you videos!! Very different from other reaction channels!!

I was going to listen to this in the background of doing my homework but then I saw the fun facts on the side and your facial expressions and now I can't look away,, earned a new subscriber!!

It truly is a beautiful, mesmerising song that embeds itself into my head for hours at a time. I love the thoughtful approach you have to all your videos.

@MusicShed

3 жыл бұрын

Good word, embeds

I love watching your reactions, they're so pure and passionate. You really know your stuff. Have a great day too, and happy new year!

You are the music teacher everyone wish they had. Great work and I love your reaction videos.

Your piano was so beautiful. Chills!!!

A reaction channel that really gets into the music and gives us awesome break down so glad I found this channel and thanks for awesome reaction 🤘🏻

For you to be able to play so much of the song just from one listen is pretty amazing. I liked your lecture on annunciating the consonants. I get that lecture from our choral director all the time.

Man, this reaction was one of the best I've seen to this song. Putting this in my favorites playlist so I can come back over and over. No one I know loves the style of music that I do and this makes me feel like I have a friend who "gets it".

Hey I love when you pause to breakdown the music and I love it, you do you. I'm not here to listen to the song if I wanted that I'd listen on spotify but I want to hear your knowledge on the music. Love the channel keep at it man!

I've been waiting for this!

I just knew you would like this. Your comments and insights are helping me articulate and understand my feelings towards music. Singing around the beat made the song feel organic. I also got grief, sadness, regret and acceptance (of the inevitable). Music does not just entertain, it stirs emotions.

You are the literal definition of feeling the music

Amy lee’s voice is Angelic, my favourite performance of hers is a toss up between “Lithium” and “Sally’s song”

That playing you did around 8:00 almost made me cry. You have such a great ear and amazing talent. This is an amazing song as well.

I'm really glad that this got a reaction, and I'm really upset with KZread for not notifying me about this video! Glad I searched for it though, an excellent video as I expected. Thank you

I love your piano breaks in the pauses. You, my friend, ARE REALLY VERY TALENTED!

This song gives me actual chills every time. Also, I love how much you pause! Talk to me David!!

Just discovered you. You’re so funny for that pause. I love your videos. 💗 great job! I love how you break down the sound. I learn so much from you. Thank you for these videos, subscribed !

Oh man I’ve been waiting for this one 😫 was not disappointed. Another one by bmth that I think you’d enjoy is follow you. It’s a bit older but man is it a powerful song

Thankyou for doing this! I love your reactions, you break down the music and I learn something every time! Much better ‘oh shit guys! That was awesome’ keep up the good work!

This was so much fun! I love this EP and am loving watching you slowly hear the whole thing. You should listen to That’s The Spirit next I think you would have a lot of fun with that. Doomed, Happy Song, or Follow You are some songs off that album I would love to see you react to. Awesome stuff!

I love the fact you actually researched for the video.♥️

Its always a pleasure to hear you teacher! 👌🤘

I just heard this song very recently, so it's awesome that you're reacting to it!! :)

See some people do make it hard with pausing in their reactions but thats only because alot of times they dont have alot to add. But you add alot and its fantastic and you have earned this and every subscription you get my man. Also I adore the fun facts you pop on the screen! Stay awesome and I am definitely going to keep up with your stuff!

Miss Amy Lee is just from outer space! What a good, well driven and on point collaboration between two amazing artists. Deep meaning behind the lyrics, good and breath taking atmosphere! You should check out her recent work: such as #YeahRight or their live cover of “Glory Box” from Portishead! That k on le showed her skills as a pianist, besides singer

I have no problem with your pauses. You really know what's going on and can point out every detail. Great Job

Always as amazing teacher!

First time watching one of Music Shed's videos. Love the attitude and REAL personality. There're a lot of great KZreadrs, but not all of them are raw.

These reactions are bringing me so much joy!

@MusicShed

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah! Joy is good!!!

Really enjoying watching you react to songs! please do more BMTH

You are amazingly talented, a joy to watch

woowww first time on that channel lol ! the way you started to improvise with the song at like 3/4 of the video soo fucking nice ! you have a new follower ! 👍

bro you made me think my youtube broke with that pause joke 😂

This song just reaches in your gut and takes your breath. Amy wrote and performed a song speak to me for a movie. So epic live and a ton of piano

I've been following you since I saw this reaction because I’m a big fan of Amy Lee and Evanescence and I think you’re a very competent musician I love how you rearranged the melody of this song, you’re a very good pianist man!

People can be mad with you and your style but for me if not my favorite the one of my favorite reactors on youtube. You always make me feel the music through my body. Analizing music like i never had before. And its not analyzing structure exactly but analyzing passion, and the extreme thought and care that we are recieving through this music. Thanks Music Shed! Keep it, you are amazing!

This is beautiful ❤️ thank you sir, love from India

Listening to this song gives me a bit of Chiodos - Those Who Slay Together, Stay Together vibes. I'd like to see a reaction to that.

I just found your channel, & have been singing since the late 80s. The tips you’re going over, the comments your making, are the same that I grew up learning at the hands of a battle-axe of a woman who wouldn’t let me get away with being lazy. Also, I’ve found the sheet music for this song, online. I had to take it into a different key, for my own voice restrictions, but it at least let me see the notes.

This is a music teacher i would love to have. Im glad i found this channel

New to the channel, really like your style! Keep up the good work!

Okay wow! You've earned a new subscriber! I live your reactions, so respectful bit good tips and learning. To me as it should be! You shouldn't apologize about pausing the video, you are here to react! That means talking and well reacting to things not a listen along! But your voice is so soft and so lovely to listen to! I felt so at ease. Well now I'm excited to watch your other videos!

Great breakdown as always.

I love the flow of his reaction videos. They are around the average times of 13 ~ 17 minutes, but they just sail by so quickly and are very enjoyable.

My favorite band since the first album, and now with Amy it's another lvl that you feel goosebumps omg! ♡♡♡

Got goosebumps while you were playing Butterflies. Thats music, ladies and gentlemen. It appeals directly to the soul.

The main reason I love your videos is because of the pausing and giving your opinion that’s what makes it a reaction lol

Man you have such genuine reactions! The ending of the song where it suddenly drops off and you can't move ahaha I was howling I had the same reaction! Love how you learn the song pretty much on the spot too! Keep doing BMTH and some Falling in Reverse