Wendy is truly the base of RV songs. Her harmonies and backing vocals are the base for sooo many of the songs. Our versatile main vocalist!

people should realize that being good singer doesn't always base on who can hit the highest note. it how they use their vocal range rightfully and red velvet has it. they are called one of the best groups with good vocals. even we know Irene and Yeri is quite weaker vocalist than Wendy, Seulgi and Joy. Red Velvet also has the best harmonies in the Kpop industry ~

@jaehyunjjhyunoh

Жыл бұрын

FACT

@mel_zzz_

Жыл бұрын

I think that's the reason why Sment have beautiful harmonies...the same happens with SNSD. 3 have a strong range and the others are weaker but I think that's a beautiful balance, not everyone should be good in everything. For a reason they are a group and not soloists. Members help each other because the company choose the perfect combination, with a soloist...this person must have something ( In kpop industry that's the standard ) to be an all-rounded artist.

@migu8328

Жыл бұрын

I AGREE Extreme obsessive fans keeps comparing x idol is better than y because x can reach high notes. And its kinda dumb

@luqmanmohiuddin4006

Жыл бұрын

Have u heard of mamamoo's harmonies tho xd. I feel like u don't know who mamamoo is

@krm101

Жыл бұрын

@@luqmanmohiuddin4006 I know mamamoo.. but don't mention them here cause this is about Red Velvet and we don't need to compare them here.. i also know mamamoo is top tier in terms of vocals. only fools will deny it.

What is amazing about these artists.. especially Red Velvet is their stability in their vocals even while they are dancing on stage. The recent concerts of theirs in the Philippines and in London, the fancam footage shows the live vocals coming thru while performing on stage. Because of their real talent, they have the confidence to really energetically interact with the audience.

irene and yeri's voices are so good especially when in comes to harmonization, when all their voices comes together to harmonize its so complete... an eargasm

I love how honest you guys are with reviewing and actually talking about their different skill levels, cause other reactors just be saying how everything is amazing and they don't actually talk about the obvious struggles and what not. Just makes you appreciate more the hardwork that was put into this song😄

Thank you 💛 it is always beautiful when professionals praise Seulgi's vocals since kpoppies love to try to diss her vocals about being nasally which is the the diss they think it is... She deserves her vocal praise for the amazing vocals she has 💛💛💛

@deeharper1364

Жыл бұрын

Her being nasally is not a diss, it's a fact. Just don't mind it because BP's you-know-who is even more nasal.

The way you react to seulgi was how i reacted the first time i saw the vid 😂 i was so impressed by her

Wendy can sing the alphabet and I'll still be mesmerized listening to her. First one or two seconds of Seulgi singing and I'm weeping on the inside

Now yall understand why some member have more line then others. Is for not ruin their vocal cord. Every red velvet song is hard to sing. Irene and Yeri is actually amazing here. Most kpop artist really struggle when they sing red velvet song. But still is hard for Irene and Yeri too. So thats why mostly Irene and Yeri got less line then others.

As for Red Velvet tho or just sm artists in general, their company already have multiple recording studio so they can really take their time in the studio until they are satisfied 💗

they really loved seulgi hehehe

@cklambo

Жыл бұрын

Who doesn't

@deeharper1364

Жыл бұрын

@@cklambo I mean she's their bias ofc they will praise her. I just hope they don't pull other down just to praise her.

if you wanna see more wendy you can watch her solo "like water" which also has a recording behind

Wendy recording her part after dj-ing youngstreet(her radio program)

If you want pure Seulgi runs and low notes you should listen to kingdom come by Red Velvet.

the reason why Wendy sings better on the second day is that she had a rest unlike her schedule on the first recording which she reconded 4 hours for her radio show 🥺 2 hours for live radio and the other is pre recorded one

I love how they are fangirling over seulgi

You must react wendy solo album recording, when this rain stops and like water😚😚

I love how honest this review was

RED VELVET WILL FOREVER BE THE CONCEPT QUEENS.❤️🧡💙💚💜

Red velvet has a recording behind video like this one but for Queendom. You might want to check it out too :)

You mention having already watched Queendom's recording booth but I'd love to see your reaction to that anyway! Loved this vid

Ah I really hope RBB had a recording behind too, because the ending part there is very very difficult the one where Wendy ended the song. where she hit a certain note and it changes to another one. That shows why she is the main vocal of red velvet. and also Wendy does the layer on all of their songs I'm just sad it didn't showed as much in here. Also Wendy's opening in All I want for Christmas had trended because she hit like 12 notes in 2 seconds, just shows how amazing she is. I hope you can see those. Also Seulgi said in Bestfriend Recording Behind that Wendy is her vocal mentor since they debut, and that says a lot. I hope you can react to Like Water Recording Behind and Best Friend too. New subscriber to your channel. I Love You Both! Nice analyzation ☺

I love how both of you are trying to find the right English word to use. You are both so funny, I love both of yall ☺. Hope you can react to Like Water Recording Behind. love how you analyze and examine their technique and vocals. ❤

Just say this is a Seulgi praise video and go

THANK YOU so much for reacting to RV recording behind. I've been hoping more professionals/vocal teachers do it so I could understand their vocals and appreciate it more (even the imperfections) as a fan. Thanks for pointing out how much effort they put in recording a song, their hard work, techniques, talent and professionalism. Hope you will do more reactions to RV vocals. Btw, both your english are good. Please don't worry about it. I enjoyed it very much and subscribed! Cheers :)

the original key of the song is extremely high, and so naturally it would not fit everyone's vocal range, but i personally think they did an excellent job. also the parts that you pointed out as more 'struggling' were for back vocals in which they needed to sing even higher, which is very understandable. indeed wendy and seulgi have the most developed voices, but irene and yeri's voices are definitely my favorite when it comes to harmonizing/lower register.

Seulgi is definitely the best singer for runs and low notes in Red Velvet. And, I love how they said that Seulgi did all the most difficult parts of the song. Ace!

@deemasalang4147

Жыл бұрын

not all the most difficult part was done by seulgi. you can tell that wendy's part is difficult too because she struggles in them 😅 considering she is the main vocal. but she still did an amazing job. they all did

@deeharper1364

Жыл бұрын

Pls do not post misinformation here. The most difficult parts of the song is done by Wendy. It really makes you seems like a troll when you steal credit from other singers to prop seulgi up. Stop setting seulgi up.

@keserutimea

Жыл бұрын

How can you say Seulgi gets the hardest parts when Wendy is the one who sings the intro and that insane bridge in the end????? Wendy is the best vocalist in RV...be about low notes or high notes she owns all of them.

@hlnolvrgo_c

Жыл бұрын

oh god the wendy stans in these replies are really annoying lol for some, seulgi's parts were harder. for some, wendy's was harder. it depends on how high or low your voice can go, how to control it, etc. you could say some technically wise wendy has the hardest part but there are always subjective ways voices work. anyway. stfu.

@deeharper1364

Жыл бұрын

@@hlnolvrgo_c seulgi stans are annoying af. They are responding to op who is clearly defaming wendy while propping seulgi up. Reveluvs all knew it's wendy who does the difficult runs in Red Velvet even in this song. Ace! Anyway STFU. You are an annoying hag. They can reply whatever they want. You are not the expert. Again. STFU. You want to prop seulgi up, sure go ahead but trying to bring other singers down to boost seulgi's fake credential? BIG NO. You guys can't even boast without bringing other singers in so STFU.

You got it backwards. They sung it in the lowered key first and then decided to go with the original key which was a half step higher.

I love this video so much. You guys are very entertaining. Thank you for the honest reaction. ❤️

I really enjoy watching it because I also learned a lot from you two

This is one of the reason why I love RV so much... i know and how big their effort to produce a music for us all. I honestly don't recall many music artist showed us the detailed vocal process in the making. I respect and love them so much.

it's really refreshing to see detailed comments on red velvet's vocals from people who have had vocal training. very relatable that you both loved seulgi, her voice is literally honey that melts you

finally found a reaction channel that has the same accent, phase and speed as me when speaking in english + humor

Thats why wendy is the main vocalist and irene is the main rapper

Love the vid and need more your reactions for Red Velvet..!

The sarcasm in this video made me crack up so much, you guys are so funny 😭 Also I love how you guys explained everything in so much details, I just found you guys but not gonna lie I love your interactions so much

I like u both omg, like the explaination sis?? Wooow . A true singer ✨

Woah I didn't expect this to be a fun 46 mins video 😅🥰

4:28 "When you're in a recording session or a recording place you have to pay money for the time...." -> Fortunately, majority of major Kpop corporations have their own recording studio inside their building along with producers and sound engineers. So they are relatively flexible with recording time while less worrying with the money for recording because it's their own place.

Thank you for your amazing positive reaction..💖💛💙💚💜

I really like this channel. Their first video i watched and i loved it already. Also i love your accent 💙

@Lalala-ym9ro

Жыл бұрын

And these two are entertaining as well i see lol i literally lmfao with you both 🤣

you should watch the recording behinds for wendys solo "like water" :)

Thank you for the reaction :) I personally think that RV sings quite differently in Feel My Rhythm, and you can see that they are more focused on making 'pretty' and 'ethereal' sound matching the vibes of the song, which explains the slight uncomfortable singing in some parts (also the fact that female idol songs are almost always placed above comfortable range). I do really like that they are still very passionate in delivering other sounds of Red Velvet through Feel My Rhythm even in their eighth year. Also, Red Velvet members have great low notes and personally, a notable example would be the whole Monster ep.

SEULGI's VOCAL VERSATILITY is WAY TOO BRILLIANT and BEYOND HEAVEN to the point that this two amazing music composers/ producers with vocal training GONE INSANE. SEULGI IS THE CORE VOICE OF RV. 🐻💯

this is the best reaction i was seen

The nasal tone is a cultural level preference. It is deeply routed in "classical" Japanese and Korean singing. It is probably also common in most of the other oriental styles, but I do not have enough background in those styles to say for sure. Growing up in Canada, it took me a long time to get accustomed to it. To this day I would not say that I particularly "like" it. I don't "mind" it. The reason that you like Wendy's voice tone is because she was raised mainly in Canada (actually not very far from me), so she sings mainly in a "western" vocal style. She could walk on a Broadway stage and people would not know that she was a K-pop star.

Love the honest reactions and the funny moments 😂

great analysis👍please react to wendy like water album recording next😁

i know ur bias hehe 💛 rv is a very brave group to show a recording process. not all kpop groups have the balls to show it to fans. rv knows they nailed it and one of the best group with amazing discography. just wendy is on another level 🔥🧎‍♀️

I like how they're honesst. I hope they stay that way. They can go hard with the opinions actually

WENDY 🔥💙🔥💙🔥

Please react to Like Water Recording Behind.

Wowwww red velvet❤️❤️

OOOOOOOOOOO LETS GOOOOOOO

Can u react to Red Velvet - Wildside? I think u guys will be very shock with their vocal

People will say passagio in English! I mean... not in English obviously, but will still use that term - or they will say someone is singing across their break. It is cool to hear you noticing the way Wendy changes her tone and placement throughout various parts - because she's really doing that to blend with the other members depending on which part it is or if it's a part that features her more as a soloist in front of the group. (Aside from the changes due to where it is in her range etc.) So they said at that part where she did it with more air, that that was "hers" - her featured chorus area. I love the commentary as well noting the weaknesses of Yeri and Irene as well as their strengths - it's only natural that every member of the group doesn't have the same abilities, which is how they complement each other. Watching Seulgi layer is soooooo gorgeous. She's like an entire orchestra all of her own. To me Seulgi is very nasal but not in the FRONT - it's like, deep and dark. It's so beautiful. And yes! Seulgi is recording harmonic lines that are not at all predictable, like a proper thick middle harmony. Seulgi has a gorgeous lower register. Joy definitely has the most air, and has also struggled most with vocal stamina and injury so it's exactly as you said. But yes. Wendy works so hard. She is so incredible.

36:40 This is me everytime I hear WENDY SINGS 😆

Seulgi is my Bias

You just have to watch Taeyeon behind video of her recordings too! Thats on its own different level!

Please do the Red Velvet's Queendom uncut recording and NCT Dream Hello Future uncut recording.

y'all better react to RBB, Dumb Dumb n One of these nights but ASAP!!

please react to red velvet again 😭

Would love to see your reaction to nct’s gimme gimme recording too 😭🫶🏻

I hope you can react " Into the new world" ballad version of SNSD and Taeyeon TOP 12 Emotional Singing (Concert Edition). I think you will like it.

more red velvet pls

can you guys react to Taeyeon? She also have recording behind (ex: SIREN)

@anq252

Жыл бұрын

Up!

Joy is my bias

Holaa. Me sorprendió que hablaseis español al principio jajajajajja. Simplemente quería recomendar a algunos cantantes después de ver el vídeo. Aunque todavía no sé muy bien cuál es vuestro estilo. Jongho y los vocalistas de ateez me parecen unos de los mejores cantantes de los grupos de kpop más jóvenes. Xiaojun de nct, wayv es otro cantante genial. Creo que los dos tienen entrevistas con lee mujin en las que cantan, si podéis estaría genial que los escucharais

It's hard to be an angel.

🎶🎵

hope youll react to other sm artist recording vid too ^^

I recommended you BTOB Behind recording

Please react to nmixx kill this love and o.o live, and also their jypn qualifying and jypn cover live. Your gonna love it for sure and some reactors who watched it said that they are literally one of the best vocals of 4th gen era. 🔥

I need to guys to react to Seulgi’s Dead Man Runnin recording!

I mean the song is pretty high so its normal to be nasal sometimes

YALL have to check out seulgis solo debut 28 reasons

It would be nice if you guys reacted to Dreamcatcher's Scream in K-pop

Wish you guys can react to Taeyeon, I like all her songs 🥺

If you are music composers, pls react to IU. She is the #1 Kpop idol in Korea. You will love her as she also composes her own songs

you should react to *nct dream teddy beat uncut recording*

React Wildside Red velvet please 😊

You should react to nct 127- magic carpet ride recording there’s a whole section where doyoung does all of the backing vocals and harmonies and it’s so goodd

@user-rv6bz9iy2o

Жыл бұрын

Finally found this comment

@jaehyunjjhyunoh

Жыл бұрын

up

@nnnn9627

Жыл бұрын

YES PLEASE

@nnnn9627

Жыл бұрын

I would recommend the song "Sticker" tho it's the hardest Nct song according to the members

@fleurdons3787

Жыл бұрын

@@nnnn9627 yeah but it doesn’t really show off their harmonizing skills like mcr or even favorite i recommended it specifically cause they praised seulgi and wendy’s harmonies a lot here :)

I don't think Wendy's able to open her mouth as wide since her injury as well. I believe she fractured her jaw when she fell in December 2019.

Please do NCT RECORDINGS! They are from the same label of red velvet and are younger group. Please check out their pre recordings they have several :)

To be fair, that's Joy's concentration face hahaha she always looks like that 😅

안녕하세요...😁☺️😊

Creí que al principio hablaban español por decir tres, dos, uno JAJAJA

23:33 💗

Por favor, reaccionen a Dreamcatcher 💙💙

wow... a great reaction I hope you react to STAYC recording behind too. Like and subscribe

i think you guys kinda forgot that most of the things they sing are in Korean, and that's a pretty nasal language, so that may be one of the reasons of why it's kind of "included" in their tones, good reaction and reviews btw uwu

@deeharper1364

Жыл бұрын

No korean isn't a nasal language!! Where the hell did you come to that conclusion. Stop massacre korean

@whatismoisty7004

Жыл бұрын

@@deeharper1364i mean, of course the vowels not. But the sounds that come from ㅁ,ㄴ definitely are. you need to internalize the process of nasalization for you to pronounce those the right way if want to reach a native level of Korean.

@deeharper1364

Жыл бұрын

@@whatismoisty7004 Then how come most korean singers doesn't sound nasal when they are singing korean songs?

Please reaction to girls generation villain

These women have been singing professionally for 8 years now. Studying nonstop years before their debut until now. I think they have a pretty good idea what's gonna hurt their vocal chords, their limits, what actually sounded good or wrong. Plus, this video shows a lot. They're in the booth exploring whatever alleys that could potentially work for the track, which of course is supervised by the engineers, vocal coaches, etc. They all study before the recording (not just Seulgi). They record multiple songs a year. They've worked with various people that actually have released stuff. They for sure know more about this craft more THAN WE DO. Anyway, you guys just sounded pedantic rather than informative.

@mel_zzz_

Жыл бұрын

And you just sound emotional rather than logical...and that's worse.

@aqsah14

Жыл бұрын

And at the end of the day, they’re still right lmao

7:15 mixed voice

Please reaction recording behind the scene NCT Dream so many video, and you can also explain about the vocal or music, i hope u accept :)

You should also react to all nct group recording album, tje really amazing vocal and differ tone voice, nct and red velvet are in the same company sm entertainment the king of vocals

you should react to nct

Where r u guys?

Petition to react to more Red Velvet songs including the b-sides

plss Reaction RV Birthday Recording hiuhiu