It's kind of unfair to pair Mariah and Celine in the same team. Together, they could destroy any of new gen singers in the music industry.

Celine Dion is the vocal beast!! Ain't no one doing it like her

Celine has the best access to my soul. Her voice is heavenly.

CELINE ALL THE WAY.....# P.E.R.F.E.C.T.I.O.N. Legendary and ICONIC Timeless GLOBAL SUPREME Singer of all Times in Music History!!! HER VOICE IS STILL IN 2022 THE BEST OF THE.......... UNIVERSE

@ramonpadilha9987

Жыл бұрын

Mariah and Celine are the best. Although Christina is one of my favorites along with them.

My favorite sound is Mariah's voice, so her tone is the most pleasant to my ear in every note. I also love the fact that she wrote and produced her own songs. She's a genius songwriter and singer. In my opinion, she's the very best!

@lillm6874

Жыл бұрын

I absolutely agree 👍 With Christina Aguilera it’s too much imo

Celine Dion is the best female singer in the world

@Marco-el2he

Жыл бұрын

How many times are you going to repeat that. You seem kinda threatened

@xrey83

Жыл бұрын

@@Marco-el2he Probably because Celine is underrated.

@NoName-pu1er

Жыл бұрын

@@xrey83 true but Whitney and Aretha were better

@xrey83

Жыл бұрын

@@NoName-pu1er not sure about that. Celine has some vocal skills and versatility - a lot of it is manipulating her tone and texture plus the fast and complex melismas

@NoName-pu1er

Жыл бұрын

@@xrey83 same goes for Mariah Aretha and Whitney they all did the same thing just differently but I gotta say I do have huge respect for Celine for being able to go toe to toe with them she is one of the best singers to this day

Celine Dion is perfection. She can sing in these days. ❤

@sanchezmcfollins

11 ай бұрын

Not anymore

Mariah and Celine tying each other and winning of course. They're both legendary vocalists, only to be rivaled by Whitney. Ariana and Christina are incredible vocalists as well but you just can't compare.

Celine and mariah obviously but for me celine!

Ofc Celine, by miles ✨✨✨

Ariana sounds "empty" to you maybe because of the fact that all her examples were here singing Pop/dancey music. And the others were singing more "emotional" and very power-y soul songs.

@secrets.295

Жыл бұрын

I have heard her ballad songs. She has enough power to be considered a good singer. I would give her an A. She just isn't A++. The likes of Celine, Mariah their vocal quality is just too superb. The power, the resonance. When they belt they sound heavy. When Arianna belt, sounds good but I need extra. Christina's technique is horrible, but at least her vocal quality is just superb. You can hear the heaviness in her voice. Also I feel like she would have been superb if she utilizes the softness of her voice the way that Diana Ross or Olivia Newton John did. But she choose to sing like Celine Dion or Mariah Carey when she just isn't on that level.

@matthewgabrielleesguerra4598

Жыл бұрын

@@secrets.295 She don't "choose" to sing like Mariah and Celine. There's a reason why she's one of the biggest POPstars. Just cus she sings ballad doesn't mean she's trynna be like Mariah. That's why she focuses on pop because she's aware that's where she shines and that's her music would sell.

@porquest

8 ай бұрын

perfect way to put it

Mariah, the perfect voice ..

MARIAH IS NOT ONLY THE VOICE, BUT THE ARTIST OF OUR GENERATION!!! SHE IS A LEGEND, EXTREMELY SMART AND TALENTED… A TRULY GENIUS!!! THE MUSIC INDUSTRY CAN BE SEPARATED BY: BEFORE AND AFTER MARIAH CAREY ❤️❤️❤️

@BlueSkyMYD

Жыл бұрын

Extremely smart? Not taking care of her voice doing alcohol and smoking and not having a correct diet to take care of her voice its not extremely Smart at all! LMAO

Mariah and Celine 💕💕🦋🦋

Love all, but Christina is my fav.

Mariah wins for me but celine is iconic as well

MARIAH. PERIODT. 🌹

For me: 1. Mariah Wonderfull 2. Celine Perfection 3. Christina Vocal beast 4. Ariana Modern Great singer

Celine's upper belts (above Eb5 improved a lot after 2005). Her vocal prime is 2011~2014

Mariah's voice is so versatile and I prefer it over the other ones..

LMAOOO ill never understand the original vid bc it comapres fancams to televised performances and sustained notes to non-sustained notes

Celine celine… no other like it ❤

Ariana's clips are so old. And 80% of her vocals in this video were from the Vevo Presents Live in 2016. She was not vocally good that day compared to what she has produced on tour. Like the flat D5 and E6 in everyday and Into You compared to the perfectly D5 and E6 in Paris Le Trianon 💀. That's like me using Mariah's all i want for christmas is you live at Rockfeller in 2014 when she has 10 billion other AIWFCIS with good vocals. Everyone has their ups and down performances, and they just happend to use Ariana's bad performance, because it's televised with millions of views 💀Although i'm not saying that she's better than Mariah and Celine (she's better than Christina) because i know she isn't, she has a whole side of her voice that is in the shadows to the public.

@romanmalik7738

Жыл бұрын

agreeee her tours have so much better vocals she improved massively since

@fashionblank

Жыл бұрын

I did think the person who made it possibly wanted to give each person the same "audio quality", and that is just an optimist in me speaking :D but as I see everyone saying that Ariana's best vocals are from 2019, that goes to the creator's credit as they made the video in 2016, so I'll give them the benefit of the doubt :D

You don’t have to worry about giving even all the points to Celine lol , I mean… come on guys she’s THE BEST 🔥

Celine The Queen!

I am a teacher singer and probably you not and I have to say that Celine Dion is a gift from God. Is insane to compare Celine with Aguilera and with Ariana ( please not ). Mariah in her way but the technic of Celine, her 3 lungs and more can not compare with other singer.

Celine sounded legendary,honestly Christina Aguilera and Ariana Grande has better clips and better notes, the clips chosen for them were not their best,anyway I feel like Christina Aguilera has her many technique and flaws but on her good days she can give all those legendary singer a run for their money..

You def need to react to Ariana’s more recent vocals

@jimmyalexander7282

Жыл бұрын

yeah, i feel like many of ariana's clips there were unfair

That was so entertaining... I am still laughing... Thank you! And in case of hesitation always pick Celine :)

I liked whitney Houston she was a great artist. Celine is a great artist.

Celine has the best tone and healthiest vocals

More of this vocal battle!!!

just finished the vid. loved the reaction. although these were the worst clips from each singers, especially for Ariana. Hope you check more of her live stuff especially from 2019!!! That was vocally her prime so far!!!

@TikTok-qw8cz

Жыл бұрын

Exactly.... I think the one who did this video must be anti Ariana.....

Ariana has improved a lot

Mariah >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the other girls

2/3 of the vocal Trinity against good singers. It's obvious who would win

Celine Dion

it's about the range or power....its about the timbre and the richness of the voice

I love Christina Aguilera and Celine Dion

Christina y Celine ♥

They all have better clips but this was good

For me Christina Aguilera So Soulful just like Celine Dion said on interview..

I think for the All By Myself climax. Celine always sings it in a closed vowel like AnyMOOOOOOOUUUUUUUUUUUUU which is really hard compared to an open vowel like AnyMAAAAAAAAAAAAAA at the end of the song. Other singers who cover this version always go to the open vowel because if they do the Celine way I think it will be difficult for them

All those claiming that Ariana has better vocals. All of them has better vocals. Mariah and Celine does have better vocals too. Her best vocals from hero, make it happen, one sweet day etc. are not in this clips! Its just a matter of acceptance. Ariana is not as powerfull as Mariah or Celine and that is a fact. Her tone is more heady and thats why it sounds muted and nasal most of the time. Its sounds like a child singing! Christina is not as technical as Mariah nor Celine. The two rivals in this Clip are Celine and Mariah and my Favorite is MARIAH!

@briannaaudain928

Жыл бұрын

It still doesn’t change the fact that her clips here are bad same others and she’s not muted either but to each their own I guess lol

Celine is a vocal beast so was Mariah (before).

I like all these ladies. All different kinds of voices. Why do I have to pick one? I don’t wear the same thing everyday. Why limit myself to one singer?

@fashionblank

Жыл бұрын

Precisely that. Music is there to enjoy. You can listen to a countless number of singers :)

That's why I don't like comparison videos because it depends on whose fan are making it. They can be biased by putting a great performances from their idols. Most fanbase who really loves to make comparison videos are mostly the Mariah Carey fans honestly. And I don't know why it needs to do it, it just causing chaos to the different fans that they were comparing to. But yeah! I'm just saying my opinions with comparison videos it's mostly biased. They can say that they're not but it's obvious because fans know which performance to be compare with is the best.

Christina Aguilera has all the elements....and shes perfectly beautiful, sexy and a good dancer too!!!

Celine Dion is the best

Definitely should react to her sweetener tour vocals

He didn’t do the second half of the video which has some great notes in it 😭

I do hope you also react to The Voice, Ms. Whitney Houston!

Well for one the clips for Ariana are horrible and this video was in 2016

Celine is the most powerful voice of all😮

Xtina wins

08:37 sounds painful? Every vocal coach who has done a reaction to that All By Myself performance has credited her high vowel placement and neutral larynx. 😂

@angelxemotions9102

Жыл бұрын

Still not resonant tho

@ph6883

Жыл бұрын

@@angelxemotions9102 …… it’s literally resonant.

@angelxemotions9102

Жыл бұрын

@@ph6883 no its not.. it was raspy, yk u cant be both raspy and thin and resonant at the same time right? Search up the definition for resonance, that specific top note wasnt resonant

@koisyneee

Жыл бұрын

He said "To me"

@ph6883

Жыл бұрын

@@angelxemotions9102 sis watch vocal coaches reactions to that video. I’m not going to argue with some rat from yt when real coaches have literally proved you wrong. Have fun. And yeah you can be resonant while still having some some rasp to your voice. If you want this to be a pissing contest i can measure her frequencies, they’ll be neutral.

THE SONG BIRD SUPREME #MARIAHCAREY

For the 1st E5 I'll give it to Ariana Grande and the second E5 will be for Christina Aguilera. I think it sounded great 👍🏼

I feel exactly the same as you.

I think the first c5 is just a prefferencr between mariah and celine

All great vocalist. Ariana vocalists of THIS generation. These clips showed 10% of her vocals all from before 2017

@Marco-el2he

Жыл бұрын

Her power hasn’t increased tho..

@alexiaofficial1

Жыл бұрын

@@Marco-el2he yes,they did increase

@Jacobmsan

Жыл бұрын

@@Marco-el2he LMAO it has?? Her vocals get better every year. I suggest watching her best live vocals 2019-2022 or even her vevo live performances from 2020

@sythe5350

Жыл бұрын

@@Marco-el2he It literally has, and the fact that you tried to discredit that is disgusting and humiliating and once again, proves you know nothing about her.

YES! Mariah and Celine together could destroy any of the new gen singers in the music industry!

The videos that were shown for Xtina wasn’t the greatest. I’m sure there’s a lot more epic performances Xtina has showcased.

Ariana Grande can sing but her voice is a bit light compared to Mariah, Celine and Christina which has more thicker vocals and has more depth and power.

You want to know but at the end you do not say who wins. Sorry, but this battle is not the good sample. And I want to say that you where scare to say who wins. You know what, this kind of comparative nobody can say anything. I go out. This is stupid.

They’re all great but Mariah is the greatest of all time !!! She can do it ALL

@lenstgelais7376

Жыл бұрын

Well in my book there’s at least 3 singers in front of her very easily there’s Celine withney and Aretha because all of them have a monstrous powerful voice not Mariah she never was renowned for that but have other qualities but Celine after a 40 years career she still sound exactly the same certainly not Mariah that simply cannot sing her few big songs anymore

@angelxemotions9102

Жыл бұрын

@@lenstgelais7376 first off ik ur a hater bcuz ur saying “her few big songs”, yk damn well she has the most big songs out of everyone in this list, she legit has 19 #1s, anyways as for the greatest of all time, nobody has ever come close to the agility of mariah, and when it comes to singing and being a vocalist, having skill outranks having a big voice, yes big plwerful voices automatically give u an advantage but the thing is if u think mariah has “not a powerful voice”, youve clearly not heard her voice when she hits notes ranging from E5-F#5 which is where she explodes into blasts of resonance. Listen to “hero” live at tokyo dome, “vanishing” live 1993 (tremendous blasts of resonance), and literally any performance of “vision of love” in her prime like live at tokyo dome. Whereas yes aretha has huge power in high notes but she doesnt have the resonance, mariah easily takes over whitney in high belts, the thing whitney takes is midbelts. Now when it comes to agility nobody is like mariah listen to “vanishing” live at SNL 1990, she legit transitions from chest to WHISTLE REGISTER, listen to “forever” live at tokyo dome/msg, and “vision of love” live at msg.

@katylamb2714

Жыл бұрын

@@angelxemotions9102 PREACH

@lenstgelais7376

Жыл бұрын

@@angelxemotions9102 I’ll make it quick as I said she simply doesn’t have the skills now to sing her hits….that needs a big vocal range that’s what I ment everybody knows that i saw her live probably more than you do i saw her 3 times live saw withney once Aretha once saw Celine 23 times and I’m telling live she comes fourth in my book on the contrary of what you have said i love her…..but I know also that she simply cannot perform live on a regular base’s she simply doesn’t the voice that she add before I’m objective enough to know that sorry but it’s her reality today if you want to put your head in the sand that’s your prerogative 🤷‍♂️

@angelxemotions9102

Жыл бұрын

@@lenstgelais7376 nobody is fucking talking about her voice rn, and she does still have a voice, stop diminishing her to nothing. Have u heard some of the performances from past years like 2013-2016??? ESPECIALLY 2020, her quarantine vocals are incredible, she legit sung part of the chorus of “we belong together” in whistle register entirely. She doesnt have to prove shit, on top of that what she lacks is warming up and needs to rehearse more, but rlly she just gets rlly mervous on stage now bcuz of ppl like u who say she dont have a voice. Anyways im taking about peoples prime here, mariah is legit 52 with nodules, ik damn well ur not willing to talk about whitneys voice in her last years, cuz we can take it there. Now yk damn well were talking abt peoples prime anyways tho, or at least when they were young enough to be at their best vocally, and mariah beats celine in high belts, agility, breath control (at least in her prime she did), arguably low notes, and on top of that she has a whole nother register celine doesnt have, whistle register, and ON TOP of that shes the best in that register of all time. Celine only has midbelts and headvoice on mariah, arguably low notes, thats it.

These talented women are mixing the notew vs. xtina who is singing full chest voice.. she wins

17:58 you are judging the performance rather than the note and earlier in the video you said that's what we are here not to do ;)

we all know christina and ariana have better clips

the mariah clips were not good but love your analysis

At first point u gave to celine, i already know u are celine fan so no wonder celine won this battle in your videos

@itssteven4184

Жыл бұрын

I mean she deserves it

mariah ❤❤❤

I think you have to consider if the the note is phrased or not. We love Celine but her songs are written so she can sustain those notes, Mariah’s gospel and rnb style leaves little room for sustained belts. She also has nodules and hates belting all the time 🤷🏻‍♂️

I love the 4 ladies but my Ultimate Fav, vocal quality, Technique and tone is Mariah carey followed by Celine> Ariana> Christina.❤❤

Its a matter of preference my darling. Never compare one great artist to another great artist since they are both super good and super talented but different in tone , power, vibrato , technique etc. These singers are good . The oldies are the greatest, Celine, Whitney and Mariah. They are super singers and divas who made these young singers aim for the best! Enough comparing and just enjoy listening to that artist you want most . There are some days that I prefer Celine more than Mariah, there are somedays Mariah over Celine and Whitney etc. so stop comparing since people all over the world can agree that a cake is delicious but to have them all the time or everyday of your life from morning till evening will make you hate something delicious. Know what Im tryin to say? We all need varieties of things, music, food, places etc. so never compare because everything have different functions and uses.

Whoever made this comparison shaded tf out of Ariana, her clips were like 2 seconds each when all the others had half their performances showcased 😑

Los videos de ariana son demaciado antiguos , ella actualmente está en su vocal prime creo y merece aparecer dignamente en estas batallas vocales ya que ella al ser de nuestra generacion siempre muestra respeto y admiracion eterna a las grandes divas , basta de dejar en menos a otras artistas.

The Ariana clips were all bad and she has way better clips than what we see.

Naa Celín canta netamente con la nariz y si comparo x registro vocal va María Cristina y ariana

Mariah is a genius singer please don't compare her with those performers, ewww No

Celine DION FOR ME. multiple languages, multiple albums in multiple languages global superstar Ari, christina, mariah dont have a global appeal as dion does. and she won eurovision

@user-cx9vx1wo9g

Жыл бұрын

Mariah เป็นนักร้องเสียงดี เป็นนักเเต่งเพลง เเละproducer เเละนักบริหาร เเละเก่งๆหลายด้าน

Celine dion only

At their level, it’s just a matter of preference. Personally, Christina’s voice touches my soul

Mariah Carey ‼️

Now if Whitney was here then most of the points would be on her

Ariana is a little muted because her mix is very heady out of stylistic choice which lacks that full chesty resonance. However, I hate these mobile phone concert recordings compared to old 90s televised performances where the resonance is enhanced so much more… also her clips sucks and but that excuse only applies to Celine obviously. It’s the instant “no!” For Ariana as she breathes and then quickly backing it up with its lovely but! for me 💀

@briannaaudain928

Жыл бұрын

I disagree with the muted part

Yes Céline 😫😫

Mariahs voice is from Heaven....and unlike the rest she has written 18 out of her 19 Hot100 number 1’s.

I think Celine does Long notes that’s why this videos selections are so wrong.

Mariah is better than them all!

Same here. Ariana. So flat and she is not in Leage like Celine …..

@briannaaudain928

Жыл бұрын

These are old and not her best clips whatsoever

Mariah by faaaaaar!

Can you get past the e5 already

Mariah and celine >>>>

Those clip from ariana are sus

@romanmalik7738

Жыл бұрын

ikrrr

@matthewgabrielleesguerra4598

Жыл бұрын

literally the worst clips😭 the editor did Ariana so dirty

@wahyudeni8461

Жыл бұрын

And Mariah also tbh they pick the worts quality performance 🤡

@NoName-pu1er

Жыл бұрын

Thats because the uploader is a Celine Stan

@matthewgabrielleesguerra4598

Жыл бұрын

@@NoName-pu1er that makes sense

Celine win

Céline won every single point. Some of them were given to Mariah to be kind.

I never like comparatives. But Ariana have not to be in this one, and Christina the same. The singers if you want to compare is not the way. Every one in her way. But if you do it, I know the winner. But please do not do this anymore.

These clips set Ariana up bad the person who made this vid clearly don’t like her !

Do not think you are unfair. Christina always sing the same. Ariana Grande have to be out. Mariah is great but when you compare have to be with the same song