Reminds me of my former math teacher. She's a very very competent teacher and loves teaching; even a bad student like me managed to get 'okay' rank despite getting F continuously the previous year. Yet there's one problem… because she's very competent she got assigned more task not related to teaching like going to courses etc. so much that we only saw her two days in a week. She make up for her absence by teaching her classes for half a day session during weekends which she also didn't force any students to attend because the fault is with her and not her students.

@rosidahariff2365

23 күн бұрын

Her dedication is a thorn in her colleagues & superiors.

@jiaxin4116

23 күн бұрын

the fault is not in her. its in the body that assigned her more work

@louong93

17 күн бұрын

You must be a Singaporean is it ? Or Vietnamese is it ? Malaysian teachers are terrible especially those that teaching Chinese school. If you fail Chinese you are automatically no hope. But they forget Malaysia national language is malay.

The problem isn't that we DONT WANT stem subjects , it's that the SCHOOLS limit only to a few classes for stem . Alot of my friends wanted to enter science stream but got placed in commerce stream instead due to overdemand

@izzdakwat0.591

8 күн бұрын

Some schools care more about their school ranking than their student's passion

@ryantang1460

8 күн бұрын

@@izzdakwat0.591so true like the pengetua of my school wants to keep the title of “number 1 school of the region” so badly that he made so much dumb decisions that does not benefit us at all

In a country that favors BUMIPUTRA in Education slots.. not surprising

@Armz69

24 күн бұрын

Definitely one of the main factor

@dlareg7201

23 күн бұрын

And the whole country goes towards more “religious “ while people are moving forward with science technologies, they cant even do anything on blasting loudspeaker annoying students and schools for hours on so called religious reasons while Vietnam people are studying hours

@ngpl83

23 күн бұрын

Ain't this fixed under Anwar?

@XxxX-ek6fx

23 күн бұрын

​@@ngpl83The existence of the quota for bumis is written in the constitution. What Anwar did was guaranteed a spot for the nons getting 10As in matriculation. The quota still exist, it's in the constitution and I don't think it's going away anytime soon.

@MrOverseachinese

23 күн бұрын

We see the non bumis thriving under this unfair system. When i told my aussie counterpart and my sri lankan colleague about our quota system, they were shocked. Aboslutely SHOCKED. They said to me this is most Racist think they heard in 2024 and they asked me whether Malaysia practices arphatheid. I was so speechless hahaha.

Education policies in Malaysia is a political tool/football used to create the idea of helping the underprivileged but In reality is used to keep the elites in power.

@user-uw1br3cr8d

23 күн бұрын

If education is neglected, the Nation will eventually fail and lose the competitive edge against other neighboring countries.

@theallseeingeye9388

23 күн бұрын

Bang on

@fazwanalif

23 күн бұрын

Absolutelyyyyy

@eddieemri2907

18 күн бұрын

​@@user-uw1br3cr8dif anwar not change yb fadhlina, she s*ck as menteri pendidikan

@PassionPno

16 күн бұрын

Education has always been political. Read up the history of the modern schooling system.

Me as a teacher 1. Inadequate training is half the problem. Malaysia is too slow in providing properly trained teachers. They resolve to open vacancies to non education major graduates and only provide little training to them. KPLI, DPLI, interim, mystep. Still we dont have enough teachers 2. The clashing between old school/ dinosaurs with the new teachers. Education is a dynamic system. As generation changes so does the way we teach. The old cant cope, the new properlt trained ones are pressured to the demand of the dinosaur that resting in the higher up. Dont forget the little napoleon that " bawa kepala sendiri" Miss match of understanding and views within educators that makes it hard for us to move together. 3. Training is always provided to the teachers but they just " bagai melepas batuk di tangga" put everything shove it down to our throat then expect us to implement them without proper facilities, equipment, budget etc. 4. Under appreciate, lack of reward system. Yes they are some but of it are superficial. Some based on seniority, some purely based on the wow factor instead of effectiveness and viability. 5. Lack of authority, teachers really cant do anything nowadays. Everybody seems to be above us. Even the students. They can do whatever they want we cant do anything. The system listen more to parents instead of the teachers. Nobody is listening, nobody is really looking. Only ousiders condemning teachers here and there Reality is everything looks find and dandy on paper. The system said they did that and this and macam2 program here and there But under here eveything is a shithole and nobody is truly give a damn.

@MrMoneyTV

22 күн бұрын

Thanks for shedding light on this matter as a teacher. Understand it can really feel helpless especially if ur a teacher who is trying to make changes and do the best! Keep it up! Don’t give up on our students. 🥲

@alexlim4508

16 күн бұрын

Alternatively, you can choose to become a private tutor instead 😂 more rewarding and satisfying 🎉 for you can decide on the system and the kind of students you want too 😅 all the best

@leehongchoo8798

4 күн бұрын

As a parent I really feel your challenges. I respect and salute those passionate and responsible teachers. Thank you for caring for our children. God bless you.

Coming from an intense Chinese primary school and onward to a National secondary school, the drop in quality of teachers is pretty evident. But I enjoyed the more relaxed atmosphere in secondary. From the get go, I knew that everything was about the As. The number of As means access to scholarships, both private and government. It didn't matter if you were competent, or whether you could think critically, I spend most of my energy just memorising and vomiting. I also negotiated with my parents, as long as my grades were fine, I can skip tuition. At the end of it all, I did well but felt incredibly stupid! I'm just glad that my school was very active in its co-curricular scene. I think those clubs taught me more about life than anything I could learn in class. There weren't a lot of teacher supervision, and we needed to get things done on our own. We organised lots of camping trips, and made plans to go Petroscience etc. I'm not sure how schools can mimic this kind of active initiative amongst students; all I know is if your teachers are swarmed with admin work, the responsibility lies on the students to make things happen.

@MrMoneyTV

23 күн бұрын

This is a good one. I did learn a lot more from co-curriculum too, leadership and dealing with people. In fact I recall I had some friends who have no idea what the subject was all about and could barely apply the knowledge yet scoring As simply because they memorize the answers. Critical thinking ability = low However recently I saw the syllabus in primary schools. I have to say it does encourage high level thinking skills and critical thinking. But I’m just unsure if the teachers are ready to teach and our preschools are able to prep the students to adapt for primary schools. This will lead to a huge problem, in this young generation

@user-tl9wv6wu9h

23 күн бұрын

⁠@@MrMoneyTVrep for para 3: Syllabuses are too pack & many topics to catchup before final academic semester. I agree with aspects of HOTS/KBAT but it must balanced with lesser topics (in a subject), so teachers have optimum period to track & do reinforcement for weak students before continuing next topic. If you read KSSM/SR syllabus, there’s no mention about provided period to recap & enrichment (like our curriculums were designed for robots without taking account on children cognitive development nature - perhaps only ‘guru-guru cemerlang di bandar’ were chosen to get involved in designing curriculum along side with pakar than ‘guru biasa di luar bandar’).

@avint247

23 күн бұрын

Very well and truly spoken. One more thing and it's often overlook is the role of parents in child education. I can see that your parents are very well involved in your education. Not to belittle bumis, but their parents lack the mentaliti of Chinese counterparts. Not to say that they are not education aware but they dont encourage or supportive enough about their child education.

@rachelwan90

23 күн бұрын

@@MrMoneyTV Critical thinking might also equate to subjective answers that might be difficult for teachers to assess and grade. If you were graded more on social skills, like leadership, empathy, cooperation, initiative, wouldn't it be better? Trouble is, how do you even grade these sort of stuff? I think the gov can start by firing those non-performing teachers. 'Firing' might sound super mean but I have teachers who taught English that can't even speak the language properly. It is very unfair to those teachers who have Masters and are very competent in conducting lessons.

@rachelwan90

23 күн бұрын

@@avint247 My parents didn't really check on how we were doing academically. When you have a top performing elder sister, you already have .... that pressure XD. Even if I did well in school, nobody cared T.T

Vietnam is a confucianist country. Their emphasis on education is similar to all confucianist cultures.

@BillyMandalay

17 күн бұрын

Meritocracy. 👍

@BillyMandalay

17 күн бұрын

Meritocracy.

In the developed countries, teachers often come from top academic background. Compare that to Malaysia where top students pursue other options, working overseas and not coming back

@anthonychai5425

24 күн бұрын

When the pay is peanut, we can't really blame those talents.

@MrOklah123

23 күн бұрын

@@anthonychai5425 it depends, in sg their Moe provides bond for those who wants to study overseas top universities; you can then decide whether to serve in their education system or not after the bond ends. There are no such opportunities in Malaysia.

@anthonychai5425

23 күн бұрын

@@MrOklah123 Malaysia JPA and MARA do provide scholarships for Malaysian students to study abroad. These students were then requested to come back and serve the government in various positions (medical professionals, policy makers, researchers, lecturers etc), but definitely not some primary or secondary school teachers. However, many will just leave Malaysia for a better career prospect (good salary, more conducive work environment) after their contract ends.

@user-hr3nq4uk6d

23 күн бұрын

can't even blame them when the pay is like dogshit

@zulamy3472

20 күн бұрын

​@@MrOklah123lmao we do have it here. The programmes have been for decades.

I was in Sekolah Kebangsaan from 1986-1996, and I can tell everyone reading that I barely learned anything in those 11 years. Out of the dozens of teachers I had met in the six schools i went to in Melaka, Selangor, and Penang, only 3 ever had my respect and considered actual educators instead of being useless government servants just there for a paycheque. I had a teacher assigned to teach English and she couldn't speak English fercryingoutloud! Alhamdullilah my parents took it upon themselves to give my siblings and I homeschooling as it was very evident early on school could not be depended upon.

Peter I understand your concerns over our education system. While I agree our education system need serious reforms, I think you need to get some of your facts corrected. I think you misunderstood cascade-oriented professional development. As a former Malaysian teacher trainee I particular took offence to how loosely you use the term “teacher training”. What the paper and yourself were referring to is Professional Development not teacher training. That is a wholly a separate matter. Malaysia still invest a lot in teacher training but these institutions have suffered from underinvestment as well as not attracting the best talent for the industry. If you were born in the mid eighties you are a product of a curriculum based on KBKK (CCTS) everyone wanted to go “science stream” art stream classes was stigmatised. The boom in interest in STEM which you described in Vietnam happened in Malaysia between 1995 and weaned circa 2010. I would have felt more receptive to this video if you spoke about the failure of Malaysia Education Blueprint 2013-2025 rather than comparing us to Vietnam. The Blueprint was the brainchild of JIBBY administration was loosely based on the Australian Education system particularly NSW system. Admittedly it was a great document to read but at the end of it how much of the Blueprint was realised. Oddly enough Peter, it speaks about giving autonomy to schools, lessening teacher workload even highlights the importance of early childhood education. While your intentions are noble Peter, I just find this video very “opposition”. In the end of the day like pencen and oil subsidies, education is also very high up in our expenditure. As you have pointed out in terms of universal education I can admittedly say we have done a decent job. Also its pertinent to note that there are many many many excellent teachers out there but access to schools with very good teachers still remains "exclusive". I do agree that things need to change. Our education system has suffered neglect over 10 years while the world changed and shifted their education focus we were resting on our laurels. What I fear is I don’t expect any wholesale changes soon.

@sonnymak6707

21 күн бұрын

Right on my friend. These kind video is to pander to a set of doomsday Malaysian with very bias views more to sentiments than any sort of empirical facts. Dont expect better from him becuase these type of videos sells views. If the title is success of Msian education ... No one would click .

@olderchin1558

20 күн бұрын

I spend most of my life as a quality control manager for Malaysian education, being an Engineering manager hiring hundreds of engineers for 5 different companies. I can vouch for Peter's accuracy on quality if our STEM graduate. My wife, me and children have the missing teacher phenomenon. This isn't new, I am in my 60s. Between maternal leave and professional development, we don't see much of these teachers. And if they around, reading and transcribing from text books isn't exactly teaching. Today, I noticed a new phenomenon, self study and student teaching students. A lot of graduates are going to end up inadequately trained.

@vimalrajkr

20 күн бұрын

The education problem is a multifaceted problem. It requires constructive dialogue. 16 mins cannot highlight the issues of system that serves the whole country. This system, has to serve children across various different terrains and most importantly diverse socioeconomic background. I did not say the overall talent development in our schools is good. SOME schools do a phenomenal job. I went to the same school for 12 years. A government school in Kedah a little over 100 years old. The alumni of my alma mater include a Petronas CEO, two speakers of the Dewan Rakyat, the guy who brought you MyBurgerlab was a classmate of mine. My school produced the OG SPM superstar in 2001. If you recall a certain Ong Jin Hock who came from a humble hawker background. These are just a few to name. Im not saying they owe the school for their success. As a alumnus I know the school has some excellent teachers. We had decent facilities. Parents of most children were very involved. However, Ive also had the experience to sit on the other side of the table as a TEACHER in classrooms across three secondary schools in Kuala Lumpur. MGSKL and VV both partially funded by the government and the other SMK Bangsar. These are schools which basically break-even in their daily operations and they also serve the most vulnerable population in Kuala Lumpur. The educational quality and schooling experience I had during my school life was nowhere near the same. Just compare the education quality in SMK BANGSAR AND SMK BUKIT BANDARAYA. These schools are just 2km apart. That was almost two decades ago. Has anything changed? The current public school system needs a revamp. The centralised model we have post independence was to improve literacy and increase participation. IT did that job well but it came at at expense. Additionally after Pak Lah, look at what JIBBY and MOO did. (Blueprint). They basically broke an already ailing system. The higher education part of the Blueprint saw massive rebranding, where institutions which were originally accredited to produce diplomas became new degree factories. This may be one reason why you are seeing more undercooked grads. To expect the government alone to provide high quality education is fallacy. At the same time having done extensive work on effects of neoliberalism in education in the antipodes, privatising education will just exacerbate inequality. This is where I think SJK/SMJK C provides a model to emulate. Public-private partnership. I don't want to dwell on ideal solutions as I've mention before it needs political will which will never come.

Vietnamese here. Believe me. Education in Malaysia is wayyyyy better than Vn. Score doesn’t tell you the full story. I lived in MY for few yrs and know lots of vnese having kids studying in Malaysia

@lightscameraaction1423

24 күн бұрын

R u studying in local or international schools? Bcs there is a huge difference in education between the two.

@TrungNguyen-xk5rx

24 күн бұрын

@@lightscameraaction1423 I studied locally until high school then went overseas for Uni. But I see over time there r more ppl sending kids to international schools and overseas which proves that local education system is failing, there r technically no more trust The things that Peter mentioned is true on paper. But practically it is the opposite

@kennykhoo1689

23 күн бұрын

​@@TrungNguyen-xk5rxvery contradicting 😂

@TuyenNguyen-vf5yg

23 күн бұрын

Là 1 sinh viên đã ra trường tại ĐH Bách Khoa Hà Nội , tôi trả lời cho bạn rằng 1 là bạn không đủ trình độ vào các trường đại học công lập nổi tiếng 2 là bạn có điều kiện để học tại nước ngoài và tư thục . phần lớn học sinh Việt Nam đều học tại trường công lập, các học sinh đại diện Việt Nam đi thi quốc tế cũng học trường công lập . Bạn đừng có ăn tí cá biển rồi chê mùi cá ao

@jerryle379

23 күн бұрын

​@@TrungNguyen-xk5rxto be fair those that go to Malay for uni or america but unknown uni are quite shit student in Vietnam , the smart one all go to well know uni in Japan - china - korea , Singapore or america - British , few of my friend from high school are quite stupid do they patent send them to unknown college - uni in the state for study , all it need to get in was 🤑

Another thing is manipulation, some educators in an attempt to protect school reputation, leak questions or provide model essays for kids to score an A. It was only a year ago a mother spoke to teacher for his kids only scored 10 marks for BM. In the coming uasa, he scored and A ....Half year after uasa, the kid told me he failed the BM test again. I really feel so sorry for our generations.

Very good research, more of these..

fully agree with all the purposed idea. Hope the PM can see your video and implement it.

Thanks for making the video content like this as I also in a miserable stage to make a choice in between national secondary vs igcSe. Too much doubt not only on the U-turn factor; another concern also I was informed that some schools tends to only focus on good grades student. The average and ordinary grades students tend to get neglected which it shouldn't be like that.

@audreygiamlayhoon

23 күн бұрын

The choice is clear. Leave the National System

We suffer in IQ test ranking as well, because conventionally our education does not emphasise reading proficiency, critical thinking and problem solving; it's all memorization practice and speed answering that take us to straight A's. When the government tries to explore what we lack of, they actually pile up the material instead of rehauling the teaching system as a whole. What you have is materials push to earlier timeline. (i.e: Science chapter in standard 6 has now belonged to standard 4, or form 5 's chemistry is now form 4). In addition to abolishment of UPSR and Covid Study deficiency, teachers give up. There is no longer a reliable standard as goal post, There is a bureaucratic check list, teachers are actually more administrators than teachers. Also, double coexisting language medium does not help teachers at all. I think teachers are underpaid for what they need to perform, the student: administration: 1 teacher ratio is brutal, and the education standard fluctuates for no good reason. Culturally, does A mean I manage to remember to solve math problems 100 time correctly, or I'm being really clever at solving how far a potato bazooka can shoot a potato? That is the question ministers, teachers and parents need to solve.

@MrMoneyTV

24 күн бұрын

Agreed. Teachers in Malaysia do need, 1) to be appreciate with better incentive, 2) given the right training and support 3) respected

@brendongunn9477

23 күн бұрын

Wow, wasn't expecting a reply of this calibre but here we are. To add on to your comment, I remember back in the 90s where my teachers used to teach us how to think critically i.e. 1+1=2 Why and How ? What is the number 1 and 2 ? Small things like that which made my class topped the school's test result when we didnt really memorize much at all (save for sejarah and geography because those are really just based on memory). However I still think its important to train our memory regularly since modern day tasks require you to multitask and forgetting just makes you appear less competent in the job market. Agree on teachers needing to be appreciated monetarily. Upon graduation our teachers literally told us to not be teachers because the pay is literal dog poop.

@dasgerbil5189

20 күн бұрын

Hah. This is an irony actually. IQ test for students not done among blind / random schools. It favours candidates from urban / international school. If the IQ test result was bad, comparatively it tells that the most glorified Jenis school + urban school + international school has problems. The most pure and intelligent, and rajin school has problems compared to other country. Still going blame kampung school eh? In actually, I would say kampung school was bad. You read this ah Peter

@brendongunn9477

20 күн бұрын

@@dasgerbil5189 Bro dont embarrass yourself la. Your answer proved his point right. 1) Are you implying that there is a large number of blind and deaf or even disabled people who have problems doing IQ tests in Malaysia ? Does this mean we have a national health issue ? 2) Jenis, urban and international schools dont even make up the majority (seriously wtf are you on about) with kebangsaan school still being the majority. 3) Where in the world did our comments imply and/or impose blame on kampung schools ?? In fact if anything, it also involves those schools in point 2) You literally made yourself an example of our failing education system. Thanks anyways.

@MS113MS

10 күн бұрын

I agreed. I have a sister who was a teacher. She complained this problem many many times before. Teachers have been forced to become more of an administrators more and less as a teachers.

great work peter👍masterpiece

Good information. 👍

Great Content 👏

Sadly , not losing....it is lost. If Malaysia continues insists on using certain language, which does not help in the global requirements....coupled with their lack off global competition in studies both within the country (based it on pure merit, regardless of race) and regional & international ranking.....when these Uni students are shielded from competition, they do not know real market needs or culture. Don't pay lip service, it need complete overhaul.

Great video and good points. Hope the education really improves in the coming years!

@foreveryoung999

21 күн бұрын

Fairy tale

Spot on. Private preschool fees in Malaysia is ridiculously expensive,even that goin to year one, there still a lot of catch up to do especially in Chinese primary schools. My opinion is that teachers must be focused on teaching & training, english must be emphasize in all subjects especially secondary school and like you mentioned,leave politics away from education unless Malaysia still wants to be behind Vietnam and soon more more countries.....all the brains in parliament pls wake up la

@vister6757

23 күн бұрын

actually the teachers in the private institutions also have a lot of administrative works but the pedagogy is quite different from public schools. The other major problem with public school for the subject of English is that there are not enough of qualified ones and trained English teachers.

Malaysian education system is not about excellence or meritocracy, its always about (1) racial quotas and (2)making it simpler so that more students get more A's so that ministers can pat themselves on the back. If your priority is racial quotas, the teachers can only teach as fast as the slowest student can comprehend. A class is not A class anymore. It's A,B,C class.

@user-uw1br3cr8d

23 күн бұрын

Getting more A's is one thing. What about quality? A parent said that getting 9as is as easy as eating chocolate. Hope it's not true ?

@lowkatherine

23 күн бұрын

Bring back exam results in marks not ABC grades.... Dare or not to see the difference?

@user-uw1br3cr8d

23 күн бұрын

@@lowkatherine Has the Govt. the political will to make changes to improve the lowering standards of education?.

@lowkatherine

23 күн бұрын

@@user-uw1br3cr8d government dare not face the truth

@tharungowrappan4042

23 күн бұрын

Midin cow create kbat questions kemahiran berfikir tanpa otak😁😀😁😝😁😝😁😝😁😝

Actually it’s not just government policy but also due to Vietnamese culture, which emphasis children education. This is similar to other east asia countries. Vietnam is culturally east asia , although geographically south east asia. If you visit vietnam, you will see alot of culture practice similar to southern china. It’s part of sinosphere. The most common identity among countries in sinosphere is all of them use chopstick when taking food.

@ELGtheMAN

23 күн бұрын

Yup, if you look into Vietnam's culture and history, then you will not be surprised by Vietnam's rise as one of the major global economic power. They are just next door to China and they had many same culture and almost the same work ethnic of the Chinese. FYI Vietnam was ruled by ancient China on and off for about a thousand years, hence the culture and some practises remained until today. Another 2 facts here that we should really take note is that they defeated mighty ancient China from being annexed and finally able to be independent which led them being a sovereign kingdom and eventually a nation. And secondly the fact that all of us know which was just decades ago, they defeated mighty America in the Vietnam war despite having weapons and technology far more inferior! So these 2 facts are proofs that Vietnamese people are indeed really determined people.

@sonnymak6707

21 күн бұрын

What a load of racist rant bull.

When it comes to Malaysia, there is no need to compare. A country that discriminates on race and is not based on meritocracy is doom to fail.

@YaFazka

23 күн бұрын

learn history bro, if you are citizen then respect the constitution if you are not, then what the hell you commenting here

@delsol1967

23 күн бұрын

@@YaFazka you need to learn the constitution yourself. Useless to argue with dumb dumb like you

@delsol1967

23 күн бұрын

@@YaFazka people like you show why Malaysia is so backward.

@gruzit2622

23 күн бұрын

The immigrants ancestors did not bark during independence. Blame your ancestors

@adrianwang2724

23 күн бұрын

@@YaFazka , why the Malaysian genius went to other countries to contribute latest research, ideas, technologies, and Malaysia way back behind, thanks on your such mentality.

I prefer my child Learn to learn instead of learn to score. Singapore realized this mistake and the govt now stop emphasizing academic result (albeit too late) and strongly encourage to look beyond. If you learn to score, it is hard to think out of box. MOE said they will do this, implement that but never say HOW in details hence it is all merely lip service but without any concrete plan. Increment on STEM intake means many student realized the importantly of it but that also doesn't mean they will do well if teacher quality did not improve. I always said this, our syllabus is not that bad but it is our teacher that need better training. That teacher competency report say it all.

@audreygiamlayhoon

21 күн бұрын

@frankchong5585 A "good syllabus" can be copied from any "good country ". Malaysia ranks 55 in PISA rankings. Singapore ranks number 1. Malaysia can copy from any 54 countries above it. It is not that Malaysian teachers are bad. It is not that Malaysian students are bad. It is not that Malaysian parents are bad It is not that Malaysian syllabii are bad. It is that the Malaysian Education System is bad.

@NewmaticKe

11 күн бұрын

Compare to Singapore is futile. That the student is learning to learn but cannot be measured is nonsense

@beetledune9264

6 күн бұрын

Sg student look like computer programme,nerdy.ranking yes,but outside than academic,like robot.

@audreygiamlayhoon

6 күн бұрын

@@beetledune9264 Quite wrong, The rankings place Singaporean 15 year olds as the best in creative thinking , with out of the box solutions. not robots. And, nerds rule.

As a VNmese, i strongly agree that we must send kids to Pre school for their knowledge preparation before Primary school. I come fr HCM city, childrens at 4 -5 years old already know how to read, write and do simple mathematics. It was shocked me as well when my hubby told me that Malaysia primary school starts at 7 years old (VN is 6 years old). Is it too late for a kid to start studying at 7 😅

@user-uw1br3cr8d

23 күн бұрын

Parents here send their kids to kindergartens between 5 and 6 years old. However, not many parents can afford this luxury. Therefore, a better way is to start primary education at 6 years old. Did our educationists and political leaders think of this?

@lowkatherine

23 күн бұрын

Preschool has many differing syllabus, private school fees charge accordingly to quality... So some started Std 1 well, some struggling... All in parents choice in cause and effecta

Nowadays most of the Malays send their children to religious schools and our government schools standards are also deteriorating day after day, education is the most factor to build the nation but yet many Malays are not bother about their children education, what they matter most is their religious beliefs and their mother language and not the knowledge or skills of living after they left the schools. Moreover many of the teachers are lazy to teach in the classroom, they will tell the students to go for tuitions instead and some teachers are teaching in the tuition centres which they earn more income than their salaries in government schools 😊😊😊

After Vietnam ended the war with the United States, there was a border conflict with China that did not end until 1989, in 1995 the embargo was lifted by the United States and Western countries, and in 1999 it attracted investment. foreign investors, only entered the market economy in 2001, and joined the WTO in 2007 through many negotiations with the efforts of the Minister of Trade... In the early 2000s, Vietnamese people had to go to work in Malaysia because life is still hungry and deprived... Looking back, Vietnam has less than 25 years to freely develop its economy.

I never knew we have problems with pre school education here in malaysia because as far as i can remember, i could already read and write in english, read the quran and do math problems (with exams) even b4 standard 1. When i was in high school, i was the invigilator for students taking the entry exam for standard 1 in my school and the questions were quite similar to what i had learned during my pre school years. However, i'm not a product sk/smk. I went to islamic school (sekolah agama) since pre school until spm. P.s when i started working, i was surprised that some of my colleagues cant swim bcs we were taught that in pre school too

By the way Peter, becoming high income nation doesn't always relate to high education. Since Vietnam did better (in education) than Msia in many years, why Vietnam is not high income nation yet? I don't think it is right to always tag high education = high income

@NhatVinhLe-lm5jh

21 күн бұрын

Hãy tìm hiểu lịch sử chiến tranh của Việt nam bạn nhé . Việt nam mới hết chiến tranh với Trung quốc và cambodia năm 1990 và phải đến năm 1995 mới được Mỹ bỏ cấm vận . Vietnam hiện nay đang xếp thứ 7 trong bảng tổng sắp huy chương vàng các cuộc thi olympic toán quốc tế , với tổng cộng 69 huy chương vàng . Trong khi không có nước nào khác ở Đông nam á có mặt trong top 30 .

@anhlam7131

21 күн бұрын

Vietnam only had less than 25 years to develop after the US embargo was lifted which prevented trade and aid after the Vietnam war. The economy really developed in late 2000's.

@phambinhan17

23 минут бұрын

Higher education does lead to better income. Although the economy is dependent on many other factors such as natural resources, politics,...

Chinese schools are still of high quality which is why there are more than 60,000 non Chinese studying there. These schools are the only option for parents to send their kids to if they cannot afford private education.

@jespertan7689

22 күн бұрын

Fr but we have smjk Chinese school which is free tho

@louong93

21 күн бұрын

Chinese school people can't speak proper English and bahasa melayu.

The last time I checked, Vietnam doesn’t use English as a medium of instruction for science and math

yeah speaking about kbat.. one flaw it has is that there isnt really much space for students to express their ideas. not sure if its just my school but the skema jawapan is a bit too strict. physics: there's this type of question where you need to provide improvements to be made to a design based on a few aspects. okay cool, thats what i do a lot with my projects. but why do you have a strict scheme? if the suggestion of the student is opposite of the scheme, look at the reasoning. if it makes sense then why not consider this answer? (sorry im just venting coz my exam papers just got distributed today and i am not happy with it XD)

@muhammadyaseer9673

16 күн бұрын

Your teacher suck mine is a bit funny she start marking with strict skema then after she distribute the paper to the student then students can ask the teacher why the fuck is this wrong and then teacher see and gave marks. Some of my classmates have to show proof from the internet. A lot of my classmates went up a grade like c to b or b to a

I have been a good private teacher before the pandemic. Now I want to rejoin the teaching line. I live in the KL area

LOVE your content 🙌 ❤ Just to chip in, I think government could implement this preschool thingy from primary school itself. I would say it's quite cost effective rather than subsidizing all of private preschool institution. Another way, set a ceiling price or strict policy, make it affordable to those from lower income family. ❤

@MrMoneyTV

24 күн бұрын

Thank you! Yes I’m very convinced that our government should investment more resource into pre-school! I think it will really help especially the B40s.

@seanchen9265

24 күн бұрын

Preschool did exist ; Check Borneo...kpm provides preschool here. Each preschool kid will go to their own Sk School. Semenanjung well, too many private preschools so ya.

@mr.sl33py94

24 күн бұрын

@@seanchen9265 Yep² it exist however not widely used, like my primary school, they have it as well. But if you zoom out look at big scale, we still lack behind in policies and implementation.

Any links to the research papers mentioned in the video? Just for further reading.

Malaysia will one day become a Estopia country. Status already below African's country. K-Country in Kampung style, K-PM, K-Ruling, K-Economy, everything still K Style...

Keep the people dumb > easy to manipulate > easy to get votes > stay in power forever > pocket becomes deeper and deeper

@BillyMandalay

17 күн бұрын

What parties want is not what parents want.

THANKS

Good job Mr Money! If only policy makers have a listen to your vids.

Pls teach all science, math and even IT subjects in english. This is not about neglecting the Malay language, this is about efficiency.

@cliffarroyo9554

23 күн бұрын

How is teaching in English more efficient? Surely teaching in the local language is better (unless the plan is to help people emigrate).

@tengfs

22 күн бұрын

Well, Vietnamese public schools do not teach science and math in English

@StanChess768

22 күн бұрын

​@@cliffarroyo9554because English is international language and therefore learning it early can help a lot in uni and real world

@cliffarroyo9554

21 күн бұрын

@@StanChess768 No need to make it the language of instructing other classes (again, unless your goal is to encourage people to leave the country).

@Jack-wm5ih

21 күн бұрын

@@cliffarroyo9554 Your question shows your lack of understanding of the current science, IT and math fields related jobs.

One of my close friend is a teacher. He needs to teach IT subject but the training he receives is very minimal, how to teach properly like that? And the thing about their work is they not only need to teach, they also need to do so many admin works and "babysit" the students. If we want to increase our education quality, the teachers should not be burdened with so many tasks so that they can focus on teaching and producing good quality students

I, myself was a student in rural area schools, during my primary and secondary school time. To be frank, based on my experience, almost all of the teachers during my school days seem to be more interested in teaching me how to score in exams, rather that raises my curiosity in the subjects. I knew that it was not their fault. The school simply doesn't have resources to make learning interesting. As a result, most of my ex classmates were not even interested in what the teachers were teaching. Ironically, most of my ex classmates (I would say almost half), can't even get a full B or above results despite being in the top class. If the students are not motivated to learn on their own or smart enough, it is really difficult to get a good result if the students only rely on what is being taught in school. It was also difficult to attend tuition class as all those tuition centers were in the urban area. To make things worse, the ministry has a high tendency to send teachers with disciplinary problems to teach in rural areas. So, those in the rural areas will always be lagging behind. Fortunately, Malaysia has the matriculation system, so those from rural areas still have chances to study in university. But that is just an act to increase the quantity, not the quality of the students. I'm just afraid that there will be a time where the government cannot support the system anymore. What will happened then?

How to beat vietnam where we afraid meritocracy in matriculation system even we left behind Africans nations

All pre-school teachers in Singapore has a Diploma or Degree whereas most teachers in primary and secondary schools in Singapore has a Degree and Masters. This makes them No.1 in the world.

i would like to offer a different angle. Parents also play an important part in this decline. Now the "snowflake generation" kids cannot be taught, reprimanded or disciplined. If the kids were scolded by school teachers, they will go back to complain and guess what.. the next day the parents will come full swing with threats to sue the teachers... so after a few rounds of these.. the teachers will lose their interest in teaching students. In the mind of teachers, why do they need to stick out their necks to make sure the kids are successful .... teachers just need to go to class, talk and give out homework and thats it.... they will be paid their salary. no need to do extra and make sure the kids learn. My friend who is a teacher told me so... parents threated him with the law suit... so he learnt to let the students rot..... so parents cannot PUSH the blame solely to the government.... LOOK IN THE MIRROR!

@raid1010

23 күн бұрын

100%. In the end we have these useless youngsters who contribute ntg to society and only cause troubles. Granted, some of them do pass the stage and be a better and more matured person, but how much would actually reach that stage...?

@yongkheankhoon6710

21 күн бұрын

@@audreygiamlayhoon kzread.info/dash/bejne/pZ2e3NSfqsmWopc.html

when Malaysia introduced KPLI.. where university student graduate with degree not related to education or teaching course, applied to became a teacher... some of them dont have the spirit or determined to teach and just motivated by salary as govt servant..

It is easy to talk and condemn without really reaching out and talk to all parties involved in the matter to get a clearer picture to understand the situation. There is nothing wrong with your personal assumption but do realize that people will receive and interpret it differently. It is as a person condemn you base on your outside appearance without knowing about you better.. It is wiser to rather change the topic to how we together as Malaysian can help to elevate our education system

Mr money, Excellent research , kudos to your effort

@quangduong535

21 күн бұрын

​@@audreygiamlayhoon. There's nothing out of date, beautiful lady

@quangduong535

21 күн бұрын

​@@audreygiamlayhoon. There's nothing out of date, beautiful lady

300 thousands graduates in E-Hailing where are billions FDI claim by government?

It has always been too little too late to improve the education system for a long time. Has the Govt. the political will to overhaul the system so that our students can excel in the job market. This is the cry of most parents.

well,.. malaysia only want to lower the grading system to accommodate weak students,.. i heard nowadays 60 of 100 can get A liao,.. F below 30,.. some more want to abolish SRJK when their performance is better than SRK,...and majority prefer agama school and agama course than STEM,..

Malaysia education system from dumb to less dumb.

I think it’s disparity between regions. Kuala Lumpur and klang valley would probably be better than for example Kedah

The old days...how many Chinese Ministers and Deputy Ministers we have?? And there was never a single racial riot. People were so united. But now our unity is questionable.

@huzaijack4282

23 күн бұрын

Because when they are the opposition, they are the one who use racial riot to create problems but when in power still useless as ever.

Finally a video that focus on other country other than singapore.

I'm Vietnamese and I'm really glad that our neighbour cares about us. But you know, I have had no idea about the education ranking or PISA until I found your video. And I don't think Vietnamese education is that good. 1. The education system hasn't changed for decades. 2. Teachers in Vietnam (except for English teachers) are paid really really low. Like $200-$300 USD per month. That's rough for them. 3. We're not allowed to be creative, even doing an essay, we have to do all the things that be taught from the teacher. 4. There's no places for other fields but STEM. 5. We have to study a lot, like... a lot. Even summer, we just have a 1 month break and head back to study to prepare for the next year 6. The National Exam to get the ticket to universities is everything. If you failed, you'd be dishonored by your family. So that's so much pressure for 17 year-old kids.

Energy cost is one of the biggest household expenses. also heavily subsidized by the government.

You didn't mention the uneven quality of schools and teacher's across Malaysia. Some schools in Selangor and KL are par with develoepd countries but in rural areas the resources are much nore lacking.

Seems like everything abt MY is regressing and failing, maybe apart from tourism

We hv QUOTA system... what do u expect? Excellence?.. perlahan2 tunggu la

It reminds me that my school old days, teacher ask me to help her do adminstration job such as write all the name list in class attendance, etc. Helping teacher feeling so proud last time, but now thinking back, i slaving for teacher. 😢

Percentage is not the true information, as Andrew Lang said statistics is used for support rather than illumination. So is percentage - 1 out of 1 = 100%. I would like to know if it is the 50% from rural schools. Or it is 50% from schools in the city. Or it is 50% of truly interested students and who are able to cope with pure or applied sciences and Additional Mathematics. The next question would be have the government prepared adequate jobs for these would-be graduates?

Not just Malaysia but is veary close to Singapore in johor even Kelantan close to Thailand too

I am grateful to have been born in the 1970s. By the time I was in secondary school, most (not all) of my teachers were very dedicated and competent. My STPM teachers were among the best!

very good video , i like the research put into it with the references and stuff. Personally, i read 1 summary and 1 book, poor economics and lean startup, the logic presented in both suggested to me ways for a country that is "falling behind" to catch up. Firstly from the book lean startup, we should form a build, measure, learn loop and roll out trials in small batches for education practices, measure student retention in class(the amount of truancy), average grades obtained, how many students sign up for extra courses on their own, how many actually attend those courses, how many would refer others to their education institute, these are the "registration rate, activation, retention, referral and revenue" of a company which can translate to that of a country in different form. I strongly believe that running a country takes similar executive skillset to running a company. Secondly, from the book poor economics, it is said that by just enforcing the idea of how good school is to parents, they would push for their child education and causes them to be more likely to remain in school, this is the biggest factor. Second factor would be de-worming the child, which implies that having good health is important for studying better too. However, all these are just tidbits i learned from books, it may or may not be viable in the education sector.

About the teacher assessment, i think NAZIR might be it, you can google bout it

Are your university degrees recognised?

one thing I agree with you is any government jabatans in malaysia tend to force their staff doing programs outside of their working scopes…teachers is the example also police…dont know so much about other jabatan..in some rural area if the jobs isnt that busy they’ll tend to do big programs in order to entertain their state boss or even hq boss..another thing is also most jabatans doesnt do anythings with their problematic staff

I still remeber when i was in form 5, the english teacher was absence for first half year

Even in the 60s when I started teaching at national schools, without a doubt for some reasons, Mathematics wasn't a desired subject, hence many of us were forced to handle the upper forms despite of the fact we just started our teaching career. Of course, the head said, you all had good mathematics results including additional mathematics, The gap was so obvious, in fact the students in my class , as the class teacher-in-charge, often complained that their Maths teacher always concluded that the answers given at the back of the book were wrong!! In fact I was told by a recent teacher that he was quiet sure that the current students reading a maths degree might not be able to pass the questions in Further Mathematics and Applied Mathematics that were used in Form 6 of the 60s. Indeed, we were tola by the Head of our school to test those Indonesian DR. teachers on their quality by asking them to solve the problems in the Further Mathematics and Applied Mathematics, all of them could not solve them!

The education system in Malaysia is race and religion-based. When an Indian student with exceptional results will end up in lower-income jobs like hospital attendant, while a mediocre Malay will end up as a doctor. Because of the education apartheid system in place, the poor, especially if the Indian student is from a poor family, cannot afford to avoid this predicament and get pushed to the corner. In contrast, a wealthy Chinese boy can overcome the hindrance by going to a private university to pursue MBBS, which he deserved. This education apartheid in the long run will create a situation where the best person would not get the chance, but the wrong person is in the wrong place. This is why education meritocracy is very, very important in a country. An apartheid system with race-based quotas and special privileges exploited by rich Malays will create a big problem called brain drain. Brain drain is a major setback for Malaysia, and Malaysia is in such a predicament with lower salary, lower income, worse ringgit value, still a developing country while neighboring countries adopt better education systems and are doing much better than Malaysia. Using apartheid systems as a tool for political reasons is a curse for the nation.

@beetledune9264

6 күн бұрын

Well said!

I think everyone deep down knows why this happened

Hit 200k today. I'm really grateful for all the knowledge and nuggets you had thrown my way over the last months. Started with 14k in March 2024

@Chrisholding-wq3ho

24 күн бұрын

Wow that's huge, how do you make that much monthly? I'm 37 and have been looking for ways to be successful, please how??

@Sarahmaxwell336

24 күн бұрын

Yeah, since meeting expert Brisa, I now agree that with an expert managing your portfolio, the rate of profit high, with less risk.❤❤

@Aaron-122

24 күн бұрын

I will advise you stop trading on your own if you keep losing. And i don't trade on my own anymore, I always required help and assistance

@Downey32

24 күн бұрын

Venturing into crypto as a newbie was very difficult due to lack of experience which resulted in loosing funds..... But Brisa Richardson, restored hope shes a good woman

@GaryMaria.

24 күн бұрын

She's a licensed broker here in the states.

school whereby we learn to social and communicate...others we can learn via internet such as udemy, youtube, edx, khan acedemic etc

Malaysia should adopt the Singapore education system to ensure advancement.

Im lecturer in one of the local public universities, now all IPTS requirements to hire new lecturers that must have Phd’s, all IPTS now are in red flags with no students on certain programs.

In my company the top guys in sales and operation say their school marks are not good. They succeeded because they are good with people, that why they can manage people. So who needs good students like me who are introvert and now are below them, and does all the detail work and follow their instructions because they have more authority due to their people skills. What's the point of good education?

yes , malaysia should compare with other south east countries than to singapore , totally different leaue

ONE OF GREAT TEACHERS USE TO SAY... ..MANY MAY BE ABLE TO TEACH BUT NOT ALL CAN EDUCATE...

The moment Malaysia is taking Vietnam as a role model in education instead of countries like Singapore or China or Korea..😂

@MrMoneyTV

24 күн бұрын

Don’t worry. Even US and other countries are looking at Vietnam to see what they can learn, Vietnam is quite power.

@user-uw1br3cr8d

23 күн бұрын

Why compare with Vietnam as against other role models in Asia?

@ELGtheMAN

23 күн бұрын

If you look into Vietnam's culture and history, then you will not be surprised by Vietnam's rise as one of the major global economic power. They are just next door to China and they had many same culture and almost the same work ethnic of the Chinese. FYI Vietnam was ruled by ancient China on and off for about a thousand years, hence the culture and some practises remained until today. Another 2 facts here that we should really take note is that they defeated mighty ancient China from being annexed and finally able to be independent which led them being a sovereign kingdom and eventually a nation. And secondly the fact that all of us know which was just decades ago, they defeated mighty America in the Vietnam war despite having weapons and technology far more inferior! So these 2 facts are proofs that Vietnamese people are indeed really determined people.

@ELGtheMAN

23 күн бұрын

​@@MrMoneyTVIf you look into Vietnam's culture and history, then you will not be surprised by Vietnam's rise as one of the major global economic power. They are just next door to China and they had many same culture and almost the same work ethnic of the Chinese. FYI Vietnam was ruled by ancient China on and off for about a thousand years, hence the culture and some practises remained until today. Another 2 facts here that we should really take note is that they defeated mighty ancient China from being annexed and finally able to be independent which led them being a sovereign kingdom and eventually a nation. And secondly the fact that all of us know which was just decades ago, they defeated mighty America in the Vietnam war despite having weapons and technology far more inferior! So these 2 facts are proofs that Vietnamese people are indeed really determined people.

@audreygiamlayhoon

23 күн бұрын

@@MrMoneyTV Power..."ful"

In Malaysia, Education ministers are more expert in education than a veteran seasoned professional teachers...btw... x pandai BM, apa guna... 😌

This is something that people already expected will happen from a few decades ago. An education with lack of critical and creative thinking will not cultivate a talent

Even our ministry not well educated so why should the teacher be more educated?

Too many useless subjects. Please compare to Singapore. They focus on important subjects. Teachers incompetence because they are too busy doing unrelevent things ordered by the government. Plus too many racial stuff in the school.

Malaysia doesn’t emphasise in English & Chinese studies. 1. English language an advance language in Sciences, Medicines, etc. 2. Chinese a language of vita economically values nowadays. Malaysia educations handicap themselves by emphasising in Malay and Religious studies resulting in backsliding, ‘missing the boat’ & brain drain.

@izzdakwat0.591

8 күн бұрын

You can always choose to send your children to schools that offer DLP (teaching STEM in English), what Malaysia needed to do is improve the quality of English education. Teaching sciences in English to less-proficient students is going to make it worse.

probably what should even come before education is attitude. Put down ego, pick up kiasu.

Our education in Singapore is still the best . I am grateful that me and now my children can have the opportunity and platform to thrive amongst the leading education system in the world. I hope Malaysia can follow suit as soon as the sleeping ministers wakes up and invest more in education.

Masy'Allah Allahuakbar Permudahkan urusan kami semuanya aamiin ❤🎉🎉❤ Exclusive maintain 💯 😊😊😊bawa 4 biji teluk x 3 sen x 365 = 4,380 sen menabu

Lesson: Don't be katak bawah tempurung. Open up and embrace. Do not be afraid of your own shadow.... Mistakes will happen and just learn from it and re-tune. But continuing as is will be disastrous. We are in the globalised era - tempurung also cannot find already!

Education in Malaysia is based on the needs of Chinese, Indians and of course Malays. The Government is in a Dilemma. Susah Mei. Lets go Digital, Smart Learning and go meritocracy. No need for Poor Teachers to deliver education and let the Internet do the same. The tuition industry is booming

You can bring a horse to the river to drink ,you can't drink for the horse. It's all up to the students and parents in the process of learning. For example when it comes to English Language some students can't be bothered because if you fail ir won't hurt your SPM certificate but if you fail your BM or sejarah it will be difficult ,same goes for mathematics as some students drop them.

it’s about the education system. It is not about the quota thing. It’s very sensitive topic and please respect the Bumi’s. If you’re truly Malaysian, respect our Perlembagaan.

@BillyMandalay

17 күн бұрын

Staying stupid is perlembagaan ?

I’m a kl-lite born in the 80’s. I noticed my friends with kids would only send their kids to international/private schools and if they can’t afford, to srjkc, which as you may know is also not cheap. They cite the perceived poor level of education in srk/smk now and worry about bullying due to low number of non bumi enrolments. I myself am childless, but I often wonder, if money is a problem, should parents really spend top dollar to send their kids to good schools and then suffer later when they can no longer afford the payments and revert back to the public school system? Or should they instead send their kids to to public school first and start saving for their kid’s tertiary education, which I believe is more important? Maybe I come from a time where primary and secondary education is ok, but I didn’t feel like I learned a lot nor applied anything during primary and secondary in my adult life. How many of you remember sejarah and add maths? Everything I learned during college and uni on the other hand was thoroughly useful and applied to me. What are people’s thoughts on this?

Thank god, I thought it was just a "me" kind of problem. Sometimes I feel as if I'm being overwhelmed with school and homework that I can't even enjoy my time at home. I know some teachers are also being overwhelmed with work, but PLEASE don't use the excuse: "If you're tired, then I am more tired than you" Yeah , we know that, but that is not going to help us learn and feel curious about subjects that we actually love. And one more thing, School start times. The current system is asking for problems. In primary, you feel sleepy and the teacher will yell at you In secondary, your parent can still send you to school. However, the moment you get your car or motorcycle license, you're dancing with death.A sleepy student controlling any vehicle in the morning when other people are going to work is about to cause a few accidents. In tertiary education, if the school time is long and the homework is longer, you can say goodbye to a few years of your lifespan. Yes, I know the argument. "If the school time change to later time, I cannot send my child to school on time. Otherwise, I will be late for work" If that is the case, then our public transportation should also be investigated in order to assist our population. We should consider having later start times and shorter school times so that our younger generations can enjoy the last few years of being young. If the quality of teachers were to improve, then later start times, shorter school times and less homework wouldn't be a problem.

Vietnam has a dominant ethinic group which is the Kinh people so its easy to teach/converse because they all speak vietnamese. Malaysia on the other hand have many branch of ethnicity/language so i can see why its hard for malaysia to compete against vietnam, but vietnam’s education isnt perfect because most public school (usually the lower end ones) only let students study theories and not put them in practice, another problem is corruption where u can pay to buy degree/grades

@angkhoanguyen6114

4 күн бұрын

Are you live in Vietnam or not? Your patterns of comment proved otherwise.

There are good international pre-schools that is not super expensive. If you average out the price, it costs less than 1500 per month. Where u get a proper campus, swimming pool, good library, good classes, a class with fewer than 20 students, proper teaching and qualified teachers, very good facilities, STEM learning where studenthave cooking, science, computer, experiment class, and good system. As compared to those corner lot converted pre-school that charging RM1000-1200 per month, I would say those international-preschool worth every single cents.

You can do this why malaysia loses in ... For many episodes.... And it is very important..... Hopefully some change

When meritocracy is sacrificed for afterlife aspirations...