Line-by-Line Mixing a Musical - Dialogue Crunching 42nd Street, 2018

Ойын-сауық

Ever wondered what's going on behind the sound desk at the back of the stalls? Here's a view of me mixing a particularly dialogue-heavy scene from the musical 42nd St in the West End (Theatre Royal Drury Lane, 2018).
I was asked to explain this technique in the comments after posting a previous video, so here's my best shot at it:
Line-by-line mixing is a technique used in Theatre Sound to achieve the 'cleanest' audio possible; the aim being to aid the audience to hear every word being spoken or sung, and therefore to understand the story being told.
The idea is that a microphone is only ever live while it is being used. If you were to instead have multiple microphones live onstage, the words said by one person will go into each of those other microphones at slightly different times, creating muddy, unclear dialogue. You'd also pick up other actors breathing, coughing, sniffing, etc., all taking away from the 'focus' of the scene. You could say by only having one mic live we are able to control the attention of the audience and aid the intelligibility of the production.
In my eyes, although working in sound for theatre is a 'technical' position, we often feel as though we are performing with the actors and musicians. We're constantly adapting and adjusting to the performers in every show in order to coherently gel everything together, with the aim of aiding transference between stage and audience. As such when we operate we feel we are performing too - our instrument being the sound desk!
Please feel free to post any questions and I'll do my best to answer.
(I'm uploading this video purely for educational/demonstrative purposes - I do not own rights to the music, production, musicians or performers in any way).

Пікірлер: 53

  • @jimorozco2283
    @jimorozco22839 ай бұрын

    Amazing how clean. No phasing that I can hear. I hope there’s more than one mix engineer that knows this show.

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    9 ай бұрын

    Absolutely, a long running musical (in the UK) tends to have 3 people in the sound team who will rotate mixing, or 2 at a minimum!

  • @shannonpeng
    @shannonpeng3 жыл бұрын

    I'm in awe, I can't imagine the amount of concentration and dexterity this takes :O

  • @Darthcat1204

    @Darthcat1204

    Жыл бұрын

    Hello! I’m my high schools audio mixer for all theater productions! It takes lots of practice and memory, at times in shows I can sometimes grab a mint between lines. If given the chance i would always recommend doing mixing as it is so much fun watching every production seeing the actors and practically memorizing every line!

  • @user-hn2wc3fy7y
    @user-hn2wc3fy7y Жыл бұрын

    Amazing. I don’t think I could do this at home with recordings let alone live. Experience, practice, and familiarity are on total display here.

  • @cyricaidoetuk1257
    @cyricaidoetuk12573 жыл бұрын

    That's crazy. Please do more, I can't wait to see it. Thanks...

  • @staticnationbeats
    @staticnationbeats2 жыл бұрын

    seamless. so impressive.

  • @Gauseltown
    @Gauseltown2 жыл бұрын

    Thank you for the great video @Curtis Chadwick. There's a lot going on here, no easy task. Super job.

  • @buzzroadguy
    @buzzroadguy3 жыл бұрын

    Very cool!

  • @benignomoreno7646
    @benignomoreno7646 Жыл бұрын

    Cool video!! thanks! I'll use it to explain to many friends how's to mix a musical hehe.

  • @joshkaposh07
    @joshkaposh073 жыл бұрын

    Riding them faders!!!!!

  • @parkerlabonte9463
    @parkerlabonte9463 Жыл бұрын

    I friggen love line by line mixing it’s like playing guitar hero

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    Жыл бұрын

    😂

  • @paulfisher1665
    @paulfisher16652 жыл бұрын

    Curtis, I'm a part time sound designer for a US high school program and, if you are still looking at comments, I'd like to ask some questions. Background: we have a CL-5 desk and a QLab set-up. Our production week is basically a two day tech (dominated by those never sufficiently cursed light people .. hold ... hold ... hold ...), a sitz probe, two dresses and then into 5 shows and done. Generally we are running with 20 to 25 mics plus orchestra (for musical) and QLab effects (and underscoring for drama).I can't imagine doing line by line in that setting. However, showing this would be an excellent way to show the students why they need to focus on learning to hear. My questions: I'm assuming you have whatever the Venue version of scenes might be mapping the DCAs as necessary. Are you, as A1, recalling those or are they fired by QLab? How long does it take to learn the moves? Do you practice with a multi-channel recording or is it all in rehearsal and preview? How are you handling the orchestra mix if that needs tweaking? Do designers set much in the way of compression/limiting or would that remove your flexibility? Are your hands the compressor? DO you also tweak monitor mixes if necessary or is that never necessary? This is an awesome vid. The kids minds will be blown as they have *no* idea (set it and forget it, right?) Thanks.

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    2 жыл бұрын

    Hey Paul! Thanks so much for reaching out. It's lovely to hear you'll be able to show this to your students, I really hope it helps! To try and answer your questions: Yes indeed. I, while mixing, am firing desk scenes to change the DCA assignments. It's imperative the operator cues this as they want to be driving the desk, not vice versa! Although, just to confuse things, on this particular show everything (including the desk) was controlled via QLab. I was therefore technically firing QLab cues in this video, which in turn, fired desk scenes over MIDI. With learning, both scenarios you've described are viable. If you are opening a new show, you will learn/create the mix on the fly and usually only get a couple of dress rehearsals to try it out before opening to a live audience (still it's expected not to drop any lines of course!) On the other hand, if you're going into a existing show and learning the mix, you'll use a multitrack recording of the show which comes into the the desk and gives you the opportunity to practise as if the show's happening in front of you. You'll then add sections you've learnt into the live show bit-by-bit. In this situation it really depends on a number of factors how long it will take to learn, but generally, probably a minimum of two weeks. The orchestra mix we do indeed tweak on the fly while mixing. Designers tend to set the 'base' which we then aim to recreate every show, which means we're often kept busy adjusting (especially when dep musicians are on). Some shows will require being more hands on with the band than others, say if you manually need to 'highlight' certain instruments in certain sections, but in my experience this sort of thing is often pre-programmed by designers where possible allowing the operators to focus on the vocals. Different Designers will have different opinions on compression etc. but in my experience it will often be a little of both - any major and consistent issues will be handled on the input channels and pre-set by designers and we then do a little live pre-empting and reacting while mixing. Monitor mixes - once a show is set up - usually run in the background or are handled by a separate monitor desk. As an operator you'd rarely ever make monitor changes while mixing the show. Hope this has answered your questions but if not please feel free to reach out again I'd be happy to help! Thanks, Curtis

  • @erikmartin2
    @erikmartin24 жыл бұрын

    I'm blown a way. I just learned today that line-by-line mixing is a thing. I do mixing for community theater, but I think honestly we don't have enough time with the rented mics for us to get enough practice in to do this. It makes total sense though for sound quality.

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    4 жыл бұрын

    Absolutely, in that kind of scenario you'd rarely go for this approach - it can take weeks to get the mix right alone, by which point in most community settings you'd be onto the next show! You're also placing so much trust in the actors to stick to the lines too, dare I say it would often be too much reliance to put onto the performers who haven't had the luxury of months of practice.

  • @BAdams138

    @BAdams138

    4 ай бұрын

    @@CurtisChadwick Does ab-libbing throw you guys "off" on the board? I used to do little acting, now it is church livestreaming with a separate board.

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    4 ай бұрын

    @@BAdams138 Hey Bruce, yes absolutely! Thankfully in west end musicals it doesn’t really happen (unless staged), it would be impossible to operate this way otherwise!!

  • @TJF97
    @TJF973 жыл бұрын

    hi please do more videos

  • @TheThecrazyone
    @TheThecrazyone3 ай бұрын

    This is amazing to watch! Thank you for sharing this. Just wondering, how long does it typically take you guys to learn how to mix a show like this? I was an A3 (radio mic b plot) swing on a commercial musical once, and it seemed like it took our full-time A3 about a two weeks of intense mix training, and another full month to be fully comfortable mixing our show (I believe it's currently one of the harder musicals to mix! But also I can't name it...). I haven't worked for that audio company since that gig unfortunately (I was too busy with my regular sound/lighting gigs that pay the bills). But my main bread and butter is doing contemporary plays that my regular employer produces. Those shows only usually only run for 2-3 weeks. Longest was 4 weeks, usually only ever having a week long production week. Thus, I've never managed to nail down a proper line-by-line mix, and neither have alot of the other audio technicians I have worked with here. I've only resorted to line-by-line in scenes where comb filtering/phasing is an issue. I'm never sure if it's just me or it's the situation (we don't usually get much pre-production time and only a week long production week)! Hahah.

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    2 ай бұрын

    Glad you enjoyed and sorry for the slow response! I would say an experienced musical operator can learn to take over an existing mix in about 2 weeks - this is by using a multitrack to practice during the day times when the theatre is empty then slowly implementing sections into the live show each evening. But you’re totally correct in that then it can take a lot of time to get “comfortable” beyond that point. My last musical I was mixing for 2 years and it would still challenge me every night! It sounds like you’re approaching these shorter run productions in exactly the right way - keep doing what you’re doing!! All the best, Curtis

  • @TheThecrazyone

    @TheThecrazyone

    Ай бұрын

    @@CurtisChadwick no worries Curtis! Also sorry for the slow reply too. That’s interesting! What do you mean by slowly implementing sections? Sorry if that was a silly question. And thank you again for the reassurance and taking your time to share your experience and thoughts!

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    Ай бұрын

    No worries at all! So by sections I essentially mean you may spend the whole day practising a 20 minute chunk of the show - perfecting the ‘finger choreography’ until you feel confident enough to put it into the live show that evening. You then aim to add on another section the following show and so on until you reach the end.

  • @TheThecrazyone

    @TheThecrazyone

    Ай бұрын

    @@CurtisChadwick ah that’s interesting! Makes sense why it takes about two weeks. So basically they’ll practice a line by line mix for a section and put it in that night. But for parts they haven’t practiced they might “cheat” abit and not do a proper lin-by-line or even just have the mics live (within reason)? Thanks again!

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    Ай бұрын

    No so you’ll have an experienced operator with you while you are implementing the new sections - they’re there to jump in if it goes wrong and also to note you for improvements - and as soon as you get up to where you’ve learnt to they’ll take over, allowing you to watch the next section you’re going to learn the following day

  • @JohnWEntertain
    @JohnWEntertain10 ай бұрын

    Would love to see how you program the ensemble mics. Are you recalling snapshots/scenes to mute and unmute ensemble mics to group them together on a per scene and possibly multiple points in a single scene? I use an SQ console which allows you to put single channels and subgroups right next to each other, even allow you to duplicate faders to work the board left to right. Are you using Theatre Mix?

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    10 ай бұрын

    Hi John. Yes you're spot on - we use desk snapshots to change who's programmed into our ensemble Control Groups/DCAs (which themselves may be split into male/female, or bass/tenor/alto/soprano, or group 1/2, etc etc) so we're only making live those that are singing when we put those faders in. There could be 5, 10, 15 snapshots in one song so there's often lots of cues!

  • @omaarpoiriez
    @omaarpoiriez4 жыл бұрын

    How on earth do you manage to find the right fader in time :) Would love to see a setup video if that's possible, how you make your notes etc.

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    4 жыл бұрын

    Omaar Poiriez Great idea, I’ll add that to the list of future projects! If you have any specific questions in the mean time just let me know.

  • @omaarpoiriez

    @omaarpoiriez

    4 жыл бұрын

    @@CurtisChadwick Thanks! Would be interested in how you have the console setup and how you make your notes. How everything's connected is quite similar to a concert setup I imagine except with more wireless mics :)

  • @katelynhaire2271
    @katelynhaire22712 жыл бұрын

    Hi! I know I'm a little late in finding this video but I'm wondering how you got into the live sound industry, specifically theatre mixing. I'm currently in my last year of high school and it's been my dream to mix live shows professionally ever since I first touched a fader. Due to Covid-19 and the lack of demand in New Zealand where I currently live I am planning to complete a bachelor of commercial music, majoring in music technology (their language for sound engineering) so that I can do other work in live sound to gain experience and connections that will hopefully lead me overseas where there is more demand for theatre mixers. Thank you for making this, videos like this are the only motivation I have to finish high school (besides coffee). I look forward to hearing from you!

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    2 жыл бұрын

    Hey Katelyn! Thanks for the comment. So I’ll preface this by saying there are many ways you can get into it and there really is no right or wrong way! I work with people all the time who have come into it from all different angles and backgrounds. Personally I, like you, came in via university/drama school. I studied a three year “Theatre Sound” course at the the Royal Central School of Speech and Drama in London. The greatest ‘pro’ to this route in my eyes were the contacts and connections I made whilst there, which made things easier when transitioning into professional work. That’s not to say it was without it’s cons! I think the best thing you can do is just to put yourself out there really! Write letters, send emails, meet as many people as you can and learn everything you can from each of them. Fingers are crossed for you, stick with it and I’m sure you’ll get to where you want to be!! If I can help with anything just let me know and I’ll be sure to do my best. Hope this helps in some way! Best wishes, Curtis.

  • @lucilaria

    @lucilaria

    2 жыл бұрын

    O yo, another nz teen into sound engineering, im also looking to go into production tech when i finish school at the end of the year

  • @katelynhaire2271

    @katelynhaire2271

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@lucilaria Come to Massey for Commercial Music! It’s been amazing here, very glad I came. Amazing facilities and faculty!

  • @SoundSpeeding

    @SoundSpeeding

    Жыл бұрын

    Hey, another kiwi! Great to meet you. How are your studies going?

  • @panduwics
    @panduwics4 жыл бұрын

    Do you guys also run with plugins besides those faders?

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    4 жыл бұрын

    There are various plug-ins running in the background throughout the show, but most are pre-programmed by the Sound Designer so we as an operators can generally stay focused on the lines!

  • @pwoblem
    @pwoblem3 жыл бұрын

    I'm mind blown, this is really hard work. Isnt there a auto gate function on these kind of mixers?

  • @griffin8062

    @griffin8062

    3 жыл бұрын

    The end result of line mixing sounds much better than leaving mics live. Actors talking at each other can cause interference and phase issues because of the time delay between the audio reaching each of the mics. A gate would not fix this, as the gate would still open.

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    3 жыл бұрын

    An auto-gate wouldn’t really give us the flexibility we’re looking for with this kind of mixing. There may be times where performers are making noise we don’t want to be amplified which would otherwise detract from the scene’s focus. It can also be super important to choose volumes “creatively”... Picking a random example, if a character is shouting from offstage as they’re supposed to be in another room, you’d probably want to mix them quieter to help with imaging.

  • @josephsamala2210
    @josephsamala22103 жыл бұрын

    Cheers from the US and a fellow Theater A1. I was previously on Jersey Boys and Kinky Boots. Are you throwing to -10 for dialogue, and then -5 to 0db for actual numbers? Also how is it on the S6L, living on the SD7T over here. Stay safe and healthy!

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    3 жыл бұрын

    Hey Joseph, lovely to hear from you! Hope things are a little further along heading back to normality out there.. I haven’t touched a fader since March!! Yes, generally. This show was -10 for dialogue and -6 for songs as a general base, but we had to be quite flexible show-by-show. There were lots of external factors on this one, mainly audience size actually! Loved the S6L. As silly as it sounds my favourite thing as an operator was the feel of the faders. It’s something else! Also a huge fan on the SD7T, although obviously a very different way of working. Pros and cons to each of course! Best wishes, Curtis

  • @yeguanting7629
    @yeguanting76293 жыл бұрын

    Hi, What SPL will be normal for musicals? :)

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    3 жыл бұрын

    Hey! It can be totally different dependent on the show as it’s often a creative decision made by the Sound Designer, Director, Musical Director, etc. Some shows are very quiet compared to say a generic music concert (‘naturalistic’) whereas some may even be louder. The only uniform rule is that all audience members should be able to hear every single word spoken by the performers throughout.

  • @stephenhamilton9286
    @stephenhamilton92863 жыл бұрын

    Are you controlling the orchestra through the desk too?

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    3 жыл бұрын

    Stephen Hamilton Yes absolutely. The Sound Designer sets a base mix for each song when setting up the show. As an operator our main job is to maintain that mix, so show-by-show we make general tweaks (say if a dep musician is on and plays a little louder, we would rebalance) as well as pulling and pushing instruments to highlight sections (like boosting the trumpet for a solo etc.) Through songs and underscore we have the orchestra on a grouped fader in our VCAs (the far right fader in this video), so we’re constantly balancing music against vocals.

  • @samkphx
    @samkphx2 жыл бұрын

    Do you also run SFX through Qlab? If not who handles that?

  • @CurtisChadwick

    @CurtisChadwick

    2 жыл бұрын

    Hi Sam, yes we do. On this show QLab also fired desk cues via midi. The majority of musicals do the opposite and have the desk firing QLab.

  • @ReactionShot
    @ReactionShot Жыл бұрын

    Beautiful. I'm dying to fire my sound guy. wish I can find someone half as good as you.

  • @MrThor3232
    @MrThor32323 жыл бұрын

    This might be easier to use the mute buttons

  • @josephsamala2210

    @josephsamala2210

    3 жыл бұрын

    That wont account for dynamics that are built into the show, orchestra, and individual dialogue.

Келесі