Leftists and Nationalists in Pakistan (Urdu)

Музыка

Can leftists and nationalists unite in Pakistan? A skeptical view.

Пікірлер: 74

  • @mrsporty9669
    @mrsporty96693 жыл бұрын

    معلومات کا شکریہ, آپ سے بہت کچھ سیکھا ہے جاری رکھیں

  • @jamessheffield4173
    @jamessheffield41733 жыл бұрын

    I find your You Tube videos very informative; but unfortunately, I only understand English. Need more of your videos for your English audience. Thanks.

  • @user-dw6ow2ol5p

    @user-dw6ow2ol5p

    Ай бұрын

    He have a second channel dr taimur rehman english

  • @jamessheffield4173

    @jamessheffield4173

    Ай бұрын

    @@user-dw6ow2ol5p Thanks. Blessings.

  • @azeemsarfarazlexicon101
    @azeemsarfarazlexicon1013 жыл бұрын

    Thanks for the share sir 😍

  • @rkkakar6531
    @rkkakar65313 жыл бұрын

    Thanks for the share Sr.

  • @filmyzila4477
    @filmyzila44773 жыл бұрын

    Sir Ap Ke 1 1 Bath Sahi hain......Love from Balochistan. Or Allah Pak hamay en bath par amal krnay ke tofeeq dy.... Duniya kaha sy kaha poch chuke hain...or hm abi tak yahe par pansy hua hain....

  • @samiullahkhan2391
    @samiullahkhan23913 жыл бұрын

    I think its still possible. For example Young doctors associations need some sort of partial amalgamation. Same can be done with paramedic associations, teacher unions, farmer unions, industry unions. But to achieve this leaders of these associations will have to work together towards this goal.

  • @muhammadjavaid2615
    @muhammadjavaid26155 ай бұрын

    Excellent video..Javaid from USA

  • @mishkatulhuda2064
    @mishkatulhuda20643 жыл бұрын

    Its of great help Sir.I should be most grateful if you would kindly make a video on the genesis of Pakistan's political system.

  • @naveedahmad8687
    @naveedahmad86873 жыл бұрын

    دل ناامید تو نہیں ناکام ہی تو ہے لمبی ہے غم کی شام مگر شام ہی تو ہے

  • @umarjack9564
    @umarjack95643 жыл бұрын

    Exactly Boss You're right 💞

  • @IrfanAli0068
    @IrfanAli00683 жыл бұрын

    You are great sir g

  • @farhanqazi
    @farhanqazi3 жыл бұрын

    hope for the best...

  • @abdulhaleemkhan2581
    @abdulhaleemkhan25813 жыл бұрын

    Very well said

  • @MHW-ey5do
    @MHW-ey5do3 жыл бұрын

    Salam Sir how can I contact you..? l want to learn about communism, please help me.

  • @FouzSiddiqui
    @FouzSiddiqui3 жыл бұрын

    A new type of "Samaj", truly... (y)

  • @shoaibazad685
    @shoaibazad6853 жыл бұрын

    Good sir👌👏

  • @learnphilosophywithazharal5100
    @learnphilosophywithazharal51002 жыл бұрын

    I endorsed it sir

  • @HassanAli-jv6qv
    @HassanAli-jv6qv3 жыл бұрын

    Sir g ہم پر تمہاری چاہ کا الزام ہی تو ہے دشنام تو نہیں ہے یہ اکرام ہی تو ہے کرتے ہیں جس پہ طعن کوئی جرم تو نہیں شوق فضول و الفت ناکام ہی تو ہے دل مدعی کے حرف ملامت سے شاد ہے اے جان جاں یہ حرف ترا نام ہی تو ہے دل ناامید تو نہیں ناکام ہی تو ہے لمبی ہے غم کی شام مگر شام ہی تو ہے دست فلک میں گردش تقدیر تو نہیں دست فلک میں گردش ایام ہی تو ہے آخر تو ایک روز کرے گی نظر وفا وہ یار خوش خصال سر بام ہی تو ہے بھیگی ہے رات فیضؔ غزل ابتدا کرو وقت سرود درد کا ہنگام ہی تو ہے

  • @KhalidGujjar173635
    @KhalidGujjar1736353 жыл бұрын

    Very nice sir gg

  • @ashrafalam6075
    @ashrafalam60753 жыл бұрын

    End result of these questions/ conflicts is inevitable. Result is written on board and Very Clearly Shining but someone has the ability to see/ read it.

  • @zakirullahkhattak3411
    @zakirullahkhattak34113 жыл бұрын

    Please make video on existentialism philosophy in urdu

  • @SAA-kr3zs
    @SAA-kr3zs3 жыл бұрын

    Sir have a video on george orwel

  • @gullarzo5667
    @gullarzo56673 жыл бұрын

    Sir what is meant by leftist???? Urdu mai smjha day

  • @muhammedawan4414
    @muhammedawan44143 жыл бұрын

    Golden words delivered by Professor

  • @DiscoverThal520
    @DiscoverThal5203 жыл бұрын

    Ap city mn apne campain na chlain villeges mn bhe jayn zyada population villages mn rhte ha

  • @FouzSiddiqui
    @FouzSiddiqui3 жыл бұрын

    Last lines, were beautiful...

  • @theenlightenededge1
    @theenlightenededge13 жыл бұрын

    I'm huge fan of you sir , want to meet you live sir

  • @tariqwazir7407
    @tariqwazir74074 ай бұрын

    Sir what you thought about PTM Pashtoon tahafuz movement...

  • @jeremiahjoseph2413
    @jeremiahjoseph24133 жыл бұрын

    Sir Ayn Rand ki tashree karein please

  • @muhammadbilalmunir4673
    @muhammadbilalmunir46733 жыл бұрын

    Level

  • @ak-nb3qv
    @ak-nb3qv3 жыл бұрын

    i download it ok sir

  • @abumusabawan1191
    @abumusabawan11913 жыл бұрын

    کیا لیفٹ کا دور گزر نہیں چکا ؟

  • @AbaseenPodcast
    @AbaseenPodcast3 жыл бұрын

    Sir, some people are now saying Bangla Desh did the right thing and if nationalist separate from Pakistan they will not be worse off (if not better off) ... How can people come out of Nationalist/Religious identities in next two generations? It seems extremely difficult if not impossible.

  • @CCCP_Again
    @CCCP_Again3 жыл бұрын

    leftism and secularism is a lost cause in Pakistan sadly!

  • @neelamkhalil4120
    @neelamkhalil41203 жыл бұрын

    Solipsism video please

  • @zahoorgabole6727
    @zahoorgabole67273 жыл бұрын

    I am a 3rd year student in Mehran university of engineering and technology. I am not a nationalists, but I know about their movements, their struggles. I read the books of nationalists and leftists. Sir, I don't know about other provinces, but in Sindh leftists and nationalists were against feudalism and they did not belong to the feudal class(Though some leaders(nationalists) were elite, but their behavior was people-friendly, were against feudal ie: GM Syed . They(Sindhi nationalists) never called themselves Wadera/Sardar/Khan). Yes, you are right. Nationalists have a hostile narrative against Punjabi intellect and Punjabi leftists . One of the reasons is, according to the nationalists perspective: Punjabi leftists are like liberals(who pretend to be sympathetic with oppresed people). They have become narrow, rightly said. What to do to overcome this tension or misunderstanding? I think, Leftists are not well introduced with lower class as compare to nationalists .So, You have to be pronationalist(As acc to me, demands of nationalists are fair. You should support them). You should endorse their demand that Pakistan should be the very federation what the nations were promised for, as per resolution of 1940. The federation should have only 3 things ie: foriegn affairs, currency and Army. provinces should be independent states and they should have their own identity. I think, such moves from you can melt the hearts of lower class(as lower class supports nationalism and is affiliated to it).

  • @mabukhari4519
    @mabukhari45193 жыл бұрын

    being a national volunteer i am also too disappointed.....💔

  • @meerhammalbaloch5202
    @meerhammalbaloch52023 жыл бұрын

    Agr ek lakh loogh nai nikaal skthe to punjab k leftist ne kiya work kiya apne arseh me....

  • @samiullahkhan2391
    @samiullahkhan23913 жыл бұрын

    Red Maulana : Bashani

  • @rahmatkakar9257
    @rahmatkakar92573 жыл бұрын

    What about PDM, though, nationalist parties supported it.

  • @shaistamominstudio242
    @shaistamominstudio2423 жыл бұрын

    اس ملک میں بہت دکھ کے ساتھ تسلیم کرنا پڑے گا کہ قومیت کے نام پر لوگوں کو اکھٹا کرنا آسان ہے۔ سوشلزم کے نام پر تو بالکل نہیں۔ اور علیحدگی پسندی یقیناً بہت بڑھ گئی ہے لیکن کیا علیحدہ ہو جانا کوئی حل ثابت ہوگا۔ خون کی ہولی کھیلی جائے گی اور بالفرض کوئی قومیت علیحدہ ہونے میں کامیاب بھی ہوتی ہے تو اس کی طاقت ور قوتیں قوم پر حاوی ہو جائیں گی۔ مظلوم تو مظلوم ہی رہے گا۔ وسیع تر مفاد تو اسی میں ہے کہ ہم سوشلزم کے نام پر اکھٹا ہوں۔

  • @HamzaAli-ee1oh

    @HamzaAli-ee1oh

    3 жыл бұрын

    بلکل آپ سے متفق ہوں۔ ہوگا بھی یہی ہندوستان تقسیم ہو کر پاکستان بن گیا مگر حکمران تو پھر وہی مخصوص طبقہ ہے۔ اور سرمایہ داری میں ہر جگہ یہی کچھ ہے۔

  • @shaistamominstudio242

    @shaistamominstudio242

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@HamzaAli-ee1oh durust

  • @atiph66
    @atiph663 жыл бұрын

    Jani struggling to find your video in support for Farmer’s movement in India. Hai bhi ya nahi ??

  • @yusrarana3814
    @yusrarana38143 жыл бұрын

    Sir,it is too much idealist goal to gather all the labour class of globe... I was basically idealism that led to 2nd world war. So,be Realist lest there should be a 3rd world war. Just focus on our state,Pakistan.. Then,the momentum of successful socialism in Pakistan would shake hands across the borders of our state.

  • @samiullahkhan2391
    @samiullahkhan23913 жыл бұрын

    East Pakistan script

  • @shairshaor1256
    @shairshaor12562 жыл бұрын

    Despite all these facts; you are not clear on the national question. From the independence of nations like Poland, Gorgians, Tito as a great supporter and leader of national during the Second World War. These all are the facts behind this question. Until we are not clear on the national question; we cannot be successful in uniting the working class, and the peasants of Pakistan’s four nations.

  • @naveedahmad8687
    @naveedahmad86873 жыл бұрын

    Sir don't you think it's a limitation of leftiests that they talk only about labourers? Why don't u talk about the collective will of all sections of society? And plz convey the message of unity. Our ancestors had got this piece of land by sacrificing a lot. I fear due to our mistakes one day everything might end in smoke. This counry wasn't created to be torn into pieces.

  • @Taimur_Laal

    @Taimur_Laal

    3 жыл бұрын

    Because we believe emancipation of the working class (which is the majority of society) is the emancipation of humanity itself.

  • @yusrarana3814

    @yusrarana3814

    3 жыл бұрын

    I think so, Privileges should be given to the poor including working as well as non working class (employment and education especially). Socialists should amend their policies. There should not be complete removal of Capitalism. Socialism should secure its place in the existing system. If it is basically a party of the working and poor class,being Muslim socialists, why not we start aid programming from funds. Why not we start aid from Zakat funds.

  • @naveedahmad8687

    @naveedahmad8687

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@yusrarana3814 socialists were viewed as a threat because of some of their extreme policies. I don't think so that every rich one is an evil man.The focus and struggle should be to not wholly change the system but to remove the major obstacles in the path of progress of common people.

  • @braveheart8318

    @braveheart8318

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@naveedahmad8687 nationalist and socialist are both enemies of this country. The first group wants to break up Pakistan and form their little kingdoms. The second group believe in a failed ideology and want to violently take over the resources of the country in the name of emancipation of laborers and poor people. There is no doubt that this current rotten post colonial exploitative system need to be changed but not with the ones mentioned above. Our country need a new dynamic system with secular democracy, rule of law, basic human rights, division of provinces into manageable sizes, acceptance of diversity of culture, language and religion, equal opportunity, private property/ businesses, an efficient and fair taxation system and national social welfare programs for the masses i.e. education, health, housing etc.

  • @maliktemoor2701

    @maliktemoor2701

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@Taimur_Laal sir plz answer my as a Punjabi's why we Punjabi's don't gave to jasrath khokkar first Punjabi to rule the greator punjab In comprisen we love lodhis and Suris who only ruled up bihr and lahore plz reply it me

  • @alifarhanmirza7246
    @alifarhanmirza72463 жыл бұрын

    جدوجہد تیز ہو

  • @funnyhomemadefilms4145
    @funnyhomemadefilms41453 жыл бұрын

    Sir are you losing hope?

  • @Taimur_Laal

    @Taimur_Laal

    3 жыл бұрын

    Not at all.

  • @funnyhomemadefilms4145

    @funnyhomemadefilms4145

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@Taimur_Laal When I talk about the armed struggle in order to bring the communist revolution with my fellow comrades they criticise me by saying that it cannot be successful in the society like ours. What are your thoughts on this comrade Taimur?

  • @Taimur_Laal

    @Taimur_Laal

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@funnyhomemadefilms4145 what reasons do they offer?

  • @funnyhomemadefilms4145

    @funnyhomemadefilms4145

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@Taimur_Laal the one thing they say is that, at present the CPI is weak and does not have widespread support of the working people. They argue that, rather than armed struggle we should instead focus on increasing the party membership by working on the field. The other problem which they always talk about is the growing right-wing populism and ultra-nationalism which has weakened the working class and how it has erased any mild thought of their emancipation.

  • @Taimur_Laal

    @Taimur_Laal

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@kinggedro9040 My god, sometimes I just marvel at how people only hear what they want to hear. I have argued that unity between nationalists and communists is difficult. And you are saying I am supporting terrorism. It is like someone saying "it is day time outside" and you are saying "how can you say it is night time, shame on you". Matlab, baat ko samjho to sahi.

  • @muhammadshaharyar6700
    @muhammadshaharyar67003 жыл бұрын

    Islamic Socialism is need of the hour

  • @sleepyjoe7518

    @sleepyjoe7518

    3 жыл бұрын

    Islam is anti-socialism.

  • @itsmee6663

    @itsmee6663

    3 жыл бұрын

    Har chiz me islam dondna he lasi bi islami pety ho

  • @meerhammalbaloch5202
    @meerhammalbaloch52023 жыл бұрын

    علیحدگی کی وجہ 70 سال کے تجربات ہیں...جن میں پنجاب کے لیفٹیسٹ کی حقیقت بھی سمجھ آگئی ہیں..

Келесі