I really liked that Pr. J.Robinson was sincere about the criticism and limitations to his book. Unlike some academics, Professor James Robinson didn't push his argument as the only valid source of the truth. He acknowledged that the economic development in developing countries is a complicated process that requires a deep knowledge of the context and it is foolish to act blindly according to some hand ready-made textbook. Also, I am very pleased with how Begzod and his team are trying to generate useful content to Uzbek media. Such interviews help us to listen to other opinions, widen our horizon of knowledge and go beyond the mainstream Uzbek mass media and biased newsmaking. Keep up the good work, Begzod

@jeffreyonyx6860

3 жыл бұрын

you prolly dont care but if you guys are stoned like me atm you can stream pretty much all the latest series on instaflixxer. I've been streaming with my brother for the last few days xD

@lanedrake6778

3 жыл бұрын

@Jeffrey Onyx Yea, I have been watching on Instaflixxer for since november myself =)

It came to me as a huge surprise and, I should confess, a very pleasant one that an Uzbek scholar sat down to interview the co-author of what is regarded as the most well received scholarly piece of literature of our generation. Kudos for all the hard work you did! Nonetheless, I have some little friendly remarks concerning both the content of the interview and your peculiar manner of conducting it. Let's start with technicalities; as a person who is well familiar with Professor Robinson, I had no problems with diving into the conversation, whereas the general audience who were not clued in might have been alienated by such an abrupt start of the interview. What also seemed awkward is how oddly inimical your starting position was. I will ascribe that to the fact of you not being an interviewer by training, but you definitely should learn how to make your guest get used to their assigned role first. So if you had taken some more time talking on neutral topics, such as presenting Robinson to your audience, both aforementioned issues could have been avoided. What also put me off is how poorly timed your injections were. It spurs me to think that you say things just for the sake of coming across as a sufficiently educated interlocutor and not to bring something of a true value to the conversation. When it comes to the content, you did a decent job of laying out the critiques of the guest's scholarly perspectives by shedding an important light on the egregious parochialism of the institutional argument. Yet still, I was hoping that you would address the book's prediction of the upcoming economic collapse of China attributable to the lack of inclusive political institutions. It seems to me, Robinson himself has changed his outlook on China's future and now referring to meritocracy as the source of the Chinese economic miracle. Also, no justice was done to the issue of limitations incurred on the intellectual enterprise by the left-dominated higher education in the West. I actually have some solid reservations about your adherence to such ideological blindness, too. In fact, anyone being refined by an American educational system is prone to have that, so I'm not putting the blame on you but rather your educational background. Anyway, best of luck on your further scientific and journalistic endeavours!

@HoshimovIqtisodiyoti

4 жыл бұрын

Dear Shakhzod Yuldoshboyev, I made a promise to mail a signed copy of the book to the author of the best comment. Please email me (my email is in channel's description) your address so that I can mail you the book. Yours, Behzod

@user-et4qm2wr4c

2 ай бұрын

Indeed, insightful comments, crafted by educated individuals and steeped in conservative critique, often carry a weighty resonance that can outshine interviews.

Яхши сухбат булибди. Ажемоглу хамда Робинсоннинг илмий ишлари мени эмпирикал резерчга (айникса эндогенностьга) кизиктирган. Уларни фикрига кушиламан, куп иктисодчилар айнан кандайдир реформ ёки иктисодий муаммоларнинг ечимлари хакида гапиришади, вахоланки уша муаммонинг кандай келиб чикиши буйича кам тадкикот олиб боришади. Критикага келадиган булсак, мен ушбу сухбатдан нима учун Ажемоглу ва Робинсоннинг илмий ишлари ва китобида кайд этилган факторлар (settler mortality and historical origins) нега Хитой ва Хиндистон кейсига унча тугри келмаслиги хакида фикрлар кутгандим. Адашмасам Why nations fail китоби хам айнан шунинг учун критикага учраган. Сухбат учун рахмат, Ajemoglu-Robinson ни Узбекистонда кутиб коламиз))

I had the privilege to watch this interview live and enjoyed it so much. You are probably at home and watching this interview is probably the best thing you can do today. The interview touched on a wide range of issues so it is like reading several articles on interesting topics!

Bu safargi suhbatdan ham ko’p narsa oldim. Rahmat!

Actually an interview was quite fascinating... What really impressed me a lot the fact that James Robinson has such an huge experience on third-world countries... He worked in Africa and he knows an real economic climate both in terms of economical theories and real-life experience.... Your questions were really diverse and it really created a scenario like you had to fight in different fronts... (Is Friedman overrated ? Yes ) Unfortunately , Ama not satisfied... * It is really complicated to know answers to the creation of good institutions with statistics, economic theories.. we have to look at the background and cultural and moral behaviour of society... And to my mind it would be better to made an interview with Yuliy Yusupov after this one cuz you asked alot about Institutions in that talk .... And the statement that free trade has a list of advantages was absolutely true but in Uzbekistan especially in car industry we are doing all to restrict free trade .... Paul Krugman's theory or Friedman's speeches about free trade should be taken into consideration.... in an effort to fight against monopoly... And the idea of meritocracy that's what we need in our everyday life...(both social and economic institutions) I really appreciate that he said maybe we have a "latent potential" .. I do believe in this statement... We've gotta learn live without "excuses"... Lee Kuan Yee said let us recognise that Singaporean are a champion grumbler .... Maybe now we became also like this ... Time to think and change the value system.. Just Keep it up . Mr Hoshimov... good luck...

Just an awesome interview with incredible professor. I actually didn`t read much about him but quite a lot about professor Achemoglu. I read just small part of the book, however I have eagerness to start from the scratch. As for interview, I liked the professor`s reaction to the questions first. The question about economists and antropologists was something new for me. In addition, it was very useful to compare the higher education in the UK and in the USA, which is my own favourite topic nowadays. Now I am awared of very important points of this matter. Professor`s answer to the question about Consulting seemed strange, as most economists are doing so nowadays. He is disagreeing with the mainstream, but with well explained reason. One more thing is that his opinion about the people who want to change something. Yes there are lots of them. I liked especially last part - short answer session, however we have different opinions about professor Friedman. Mr.Hoshimov good luck to you and the project.

A great discussion. This book - Why Nations Fail? (around 500 pages)- is on my reading lists. Dr. Robinson has probably given a great doctoral dissertation topic to Behzod: "Why is Uzbekistan poor and/or why is Uzbekistan making slow economic progress?" Look forward to future interviews by Behzod.

Before watching the interview I expected more discussions about equality in growth, the importance of property laws and some other key issues in the book. However, I liked the professor's opinion on free trade: not many people see the benefits of free trade in a way that economists actually do. In case of Uzbekistan, general knowledge of free and open trade is pretty low, including its benefits, such as free movement of capital and labour, attraction of more foreign investment, comparative advantage in production and so on. So maybe it's probably helpful to raise public awareness of benefits of free trade massively by all instruments, which may result in decrease in attempts towards monopoly, and even push the government to seek for beneficial free trade agreements with other countries

Very useful and meaningful interview. I liked that Prof. James Robizon mentioned Confucius's word about "promote the worthy and talented" which can be very important phrase in developing countries such as Uzbekistan

That's good to have some useful and informative content for Uzbeks.

Яхши сухбатлардан бири булади деб уйлайман, Бекзод Сизга омад укам!

Juda foydali suhbat bo'libdi, ishlaringizga rivoj tilaymiz!

Great book by James Robinson - Why Nations Fail! I have an idea, which may have already tickled your minds, as well. The idea lies in teaching this book in our high schools or at least at Universities, to make students and people realize the truth about why nations fail whilst how others succeed..! This might somehow bring transparency for our country. Cause I think, most people have almost no clue about the problems and "tricky" situations happening in Uzbekistan. Anyway, Great talk! Good Luck Hoshimov Bro!)

Bu kitobda biz va uzbekiston uchun kerakli fikrlar g’oyalar borligiga ishonaman kitobni uqilganda videodagindan kora ko’pro malumot olaman degan umiddaman ishingizga omad aka alloh bardavom qilsin

Shunchaki gap yoq👍. Zo'r

Assalom aleykum. O'ziga xos va avvalgilariga o'xshamagan intervyu bo'lganligiga ishonaman:)))

Thank you so much for such an excellent interview. Really helpful, informative. We have So much interest

Love this interview 🙌👏. Big thanks to organizers. It felt like I finished reading "Why Nations Fail" by the end of interview. 😀

Like this true conversation!

1. 1:00 Nega ba'zi mamlakatlar tanazzulga uchraydilar? 2. 13:06 “Nega ba'zi mamlakatlar tanazzulga uchraydilar?” kitobi haqidagi Robinson oʻrinli deb biladigan tanqidlar. 3. 19:01 Oʻzbekistonning rivojlangan davlat boʻlishiga zaruriy shartlar bor, ammo rivojlangan davlat emasligi haqida. 4. 26:41 Robinson maqolalariga gʻoyalarini sigʻdira olmaganligi tufayli “Nega ba'zi mamlakatlar tanazzulga uchraydilar?” kitobi yozilib qolgani haqida. 5. 30:46 Nega oxirgi paytda iqtisodchi olimlar omma uchun koʻp kitob yozishayotganliklari haqida. 6. 34:07 Robinson nega AQShda Phd qilishga qaror qilgani haqida. 7. 38:25 Britaniya oliy taʼlimi AQSh oliy taʼlimidan ortda qolib ketdimi? 8. 41:05 Britaniyada katta boʻlish qandaydir tarzda fikrlashingizda ustunlik berdimi? 9. 44:00 Hammualif Ajemoglu bilan qanday tanishgani haqida? 10. 48:57 Ajemoglu bilan birga kitob yozayotganda vazifalar qanday taqsimlanadi? 11. 49:30 Richar Wrangham va uning olov oʻylab topilgani inson miyyasi kattayishiga olib kelganligi toʻgʻrisidagi kitobi haqida. 12. 50:54 Phd talabalariga tarix, falsafa kabi fanlar oʻrniga mikro-makroiqtisodiyot yoki ekonometrika darslari oʻtilishi yaxshimi? 13. 54:24 Robinson nega chet el hukumatlariga iqtisodiy maslahatlar berishni yoqtirmasligi haqida. 14. 1:01:24 Iqtisod darsliklari yetarli darajada realistik emasligi haqidagi tanqidlar toʻgʻrisida. 15. 1:04:55 Insoniyat tarixidagi eng tinch zamonga yuz tutayotganimiz sababi nimada deb oʻylaysiz? 16. 1:13:05 Hammualiflikdagi soʻnggi maqolalaridan biri “Demokratiya taraqqiyotga sabab boʻladimi?” haqida. 17. 1:17:20 Blits Eng yaxshi izoh qidirilayaptimi haliyam?)

@bekhzodkhoshimov6416

4 жыл бұрын

Diydor Berdiklichev qidirilyapti.

Zo'r suxbat bo'libdi. Guriyevni ham kutib qolamiz shu yerda

Ака кутйабман омад сизга хавас киламан

Tashqi maslahatchilarga oid savol juda ham dolzarb savol bo'ldi deb o'ylayman.

assalomu alaykum, bu interview juda yaxshi chiqqan, qolgan interviewlaringiz kabi... ularda siz har doim bizni ko`zimiz tushmaydigan, nazardan qochadigan, etibor bermaydigan mavzular bo`yicha dolzarb fikrlarni bizga yetkazishga harakat qilasiz, bu ishlar albatta etirofga loyiq, albatta biz sizning bundanda yaxshi natijalarni qo`lga kiritishingizni kutib qolamiz...

Assalom aleykum. Siyosatshunoslikdan iqtisodga juda qiziq va meni ancha oʻylantirdi. Toʻgʻrisi oʻzim uchun kashf qildim SSSR qulashi haqdagi fikrlariga 100% qoʻshilaman. va yana iqtisodiyotni oʻrganishda antropologiya falsafa tarix kabi gumanitar fanlarning oʻrni umuman buni komplex olib qaraganda barcha tadqiqoqlarda va izlanishlarda Asosiy hisoblayman . Ajoyib fikrlar misolllar shunchaki superb!!!

Assalomu alaykum! Olib borayotga dasturlaringiz benihoya tahsinga loyiq! Noyob desam adashmayman! Sizdan iltimos qilib so'rardimki shunaqa boshqa tilda o'tkazilgan intervyularizni ovozli tarjiimasiniyam chiqarsangiz ko'pchilik hamyutlarimiz sizdan minnatdor bo'lishardi! Subtitrga qarab tushunib olish qiyin. Mustahkam sog'lik va ishlarizda rivoj tilab qolaman! Rahmat..!

Very informative and useful talk to understand the aspects of making a good institution. Indeed, a high literacy level and good infrastructure can be an explanation of making good institutions, since society will demand it. However, from my perspective, one of the main factors of building a good institution could be a good cabinet of ministers, because it directly impacts on policy-making and further government strategies. Even though the population is literate and will demand a good institution but if the cabinet ministers will not use its resources efficiently, it will definitely fail. It can be seen in North and South Korea's case, Mexico and the US and even Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan case. Uzbekistan had the highest literacy level in Central Asia and it had good infrastructure compared to other central Asian countries, however, at present Uzbekistan is not the country with highest GDP in Central Asia as predicted 30 years ago.

@azizaabubakirova8026

4 жыл бұрын

I completely agree. At least we need some support and freedom from the government to empower our people voluntarily.

@azizaabubakirova8026

4 жыл бұрын

I completely agree. At least we need some support and freedom from the government to empower our people voluntarily.

@saidbekkamilov7967

Жыл бұрын

Assalom alekum Elmirod aka yaxshimisiz

Outstanding work! You are doing great 👍🏻 But, I hoped that there will be more questions about Uzbekistan, especially about current development strategies.

Assalomu alaykum. Juda yaxshi interview bo'libdi. In my opinion: "Why nations fail". All of the reasons and causes are related to each other. 1. Literacy 2. Political 3. Economic. For example, Well- educated people can change the political, economic of the country to a better way. 2. O'zbek tiliga tezroq tarjima qilish kerak bu kitobni. Hamma qismni. Ps: bu kitobdagi O'zbek bollarni dalada paxta terib yurganni ko'rib ..... Siz ham shu betni ko'rganmisiz?

Tarjimali Dublyaj orqali namoyish etilgan ko'rsatuvlarning tomoshabinlari ham ancha ko'proq bo'ladi.

Assalomualaykum Bekzodaka. Bu safar ham kutganimizdek sifatli, ommabop, qiziqarli ko'rsatuv tayyorlabsiz. Ushbu ko'rsatuvga so'nggi vaqtlarda taklif etilayotgan mehmonlar asosan ingliz zabon bo'lganliklari sababli, uni omma (oddiy xalq) ko'rib tushunishda biroz qiyinchiliklarga duch kelmoqda. SUBTITL orqali qilingan tarjima esa o'ta noqulay. Sababi tomoshabin ushbu yozuvlarni o'qib, tushunib ketishga ulgurmaydi (ya'ni suhbatdosh tez gapiradi va shunga muvofiq yozuvlar ham tez tez aylanadi). Ushbu muammoni bartaraf etish uchun tarjimali dublyajdan foydalanish maqsadga muvofiq bo'lardi.

Super

A very informative discussion of development, modernization theories with one of my favorite economists of modern times. Behzod aka, I, almost in every intervew, see an eager interest of you in why Uzbekistan, despite having all the “basic” aspects of development like infrastructure, almost 100% schooling and etc., hasn’t been able to make the growth it could have. The same was asked from Professor Murtazashvili; I personally think the answer lays in the education of populace in what it takes for a sustained growth to happen. Plus, the open “at-times” countering to James Robinson’s ideas made the discussion even more on fire 🔥 I would like to end with a little question for you: Have some of your views of the views from Why Nations Fail changed after the talk with the co-author?

Ushbu ko'rsatuvning barcha 7 ta sonlarini obunachilar tomonidan necha marta ko'rilganini tahlil qilsangiz, unda til bilan bog'liq umumiylikni ko'rishingiz mumkin. Ya'ni o'zbek va rus tillarida bo'lgan suhbatlar obunachilar tomonidan ingliz tilida bo'lgan suhbatlarga nisbatan o'rtacha 1,6 marta ko'proq ko'rilgan. Ya'ni bu yerda tarjimali SUBTITLning borligi ham tomoshabinlarni yetarli darajada qiziqtira olmagan.

Бехзод илтимос , интервю ни узбекча ё русча версиясини хам чикаринг

Ассалому алайкум Беҳзодбек! Кутмоқдамиз.

@hamidazmetov4633

4 жыл бұрын

Zohidjon Tadjibayev nimani?

Kechaginda shu kitobni kitob do’konida korgandim bu semesterni tugatib albatta birinchi uqiydigan kitobim shu boladi deb memo qilib qoydim

That's right culture does not play any role in Development. Read a book" Culture Matters" you would see how ideas over Korea has changed after Korea has achieved development.

💪💪👏👏👏👏

Assalomu aleykum, Xar bir noto'g'ri qo'yilgan qadam uchun ikkita orqaga qadam va yana oldinga borish kerakligini xisobga olib, men janob Robinsonga savol berish imkoniyatiga ega bo'lganimda, uning iqtisodiy taqqoslama taxlilga qiziqishidan kelib chiqib o'tgan davrdagi yurtimiz iqtisodiy traektoriyasining qanchalik to'g'ri va noto'g'riligini, noto'g'ri qarorlarning badali va bizdek boshlang'ich nuqtadan boshlagan davlatlarning eng yomoni va eng yaxshisi (iqtisodiy ko'rsatkichlar) to'g'risida so'ragan bo'lar edim.

Manda subtitr chiqmayapti nima qilish kk

I was irritated by the poor internet connection. Alas...

Odamlar fikriga qiziqish bildirish natijasida seni fikring shu darajada sayqallanadiki o`zingni qilgan ishindan qoniqish hosil qilolmaysan garchi u sen kutgandan ham ziyoda bo`lib chiqqan bo`lsa ham.

51:18 ))

To'grisi videodi ko'rmadim lekin shu why nations fail kitobi haqida o'tgan yili yozgandiz shundan beri qiziqaman topolmadim . Komment yoqmasaham agar shu kitobdi inglizcha variantini jo'natb bersez pulini to'lab berardim . Oldindan rahmat

@mirzo_makhmood5040

4 жыл бұрын

Googlega yozing turiptiyu Pdf varianti 10 talab

Где титры😂

va yana shuni aytishim mumkinki, sizni bu harakatlaringizni tasir doirasi, yetarli darajada yanada kengroq bo`lishini istardim, yaniki doimiy ravijda chiqayotgan videolar, tv orqali kengroq xalq etiborida bo`lishi, xalqning o`zi undan xulosa chiqarishi kerak deb o`ylayman. telegram, youtube va boshqalar sizni bu harakatlaringizni to`laqonli natijasiga olib borolmaydi deb qo`rqaman. to`g`ri hozirda axborot erkinligi kuchaygan, hozir hamma har xil ijtimoiy tarmoqlar orqali informatsiya olishi mumkin, lekin ko`plab bekorchi, arzimas, kelajagimizdagi faoliyatimiz uchun manfaatli bo`lmagan ma`lumotlarga yon atrofimiz to`la, kim qayda, qanaqa, kim bilan... show-shu bari bemaniliklar..... lekin asli har bir inson, jamiyatda qanday ishlar bo`layotganini, asl demokratiya qandayligini, haqiqiy demikratiya jamiyatida insinlar o`zlarini qanday xis qilishlarini, bunday jamiyatda iqtisodiy bilimlar qanchalik muhimligini bildirish, kimlardir jamiyatda iqtisodiy noto`g`ri qarorlar qabul qilganida, unga qarshi reaksiya bildirish uchun aholidagi iqtisodiy bilimlarni oshirish lozim, va albatta bu masalalarda siz va sizni sohangizdagi insonlar uchun masuliyat bor... men nazarimda sizni bu harakatlaringiz eng kerakligi, zaruriyligi bilan ajralib turadi... bu HOSHIMOV IQTISODIYOTI dasturi doirasida ko`plab mavzular muhokama qilinmoqda, natijasida esa biz kuzatuvchilarni fikrlashimiz, jamiyatdagi o`zgarishlarga bo`lgan fikr va qarashlarimiz ijobiy tomonlama rivojlanib bormoqda.... va bu jarayon butun xalq orasida yuz berishi uchun sizning harakatlaringiz yanada keng qamrovli bo`lishi kerak deb o`ylayman... iqtisodimiz bilamizki xavas qilarli emas, kimlar uchundir hayot yaxshidir ammo ko`plar hayotinini yaxshi tomonga o`zgarishini kutib yashamoqda... "ko`p sohalarda rivijlanish bor, bizni davlat iqtisodi yaxshi, reytinglari yaxshi, mana bizdanda battarlari bor, shu boriga shukur qilaylik" deydigan odamlar oramizda ko`p uchraydi. o`ylamaydiki hozir axvoli o`rtacha, yoki yomonroqdir, ammo kelajakda nima bo`ladi, balki bundanda yomon ahvolga tushar, balki iqtisodimiz rivojlanmay qolar, turli xil tashqi tasirlar, ichki tasirlar doirasida rivojlangan davlat bo`lishimizni balki pensiya yoshida kutib olarmiz, vaqti nomalum... shuning uchun hozir, yangicha emas kerakli dunyo qarashga ega bo`laylik, kerakli bilimni o`rganaylik, kerakli ma`lumotlar bilan boyiylik, shunchaki ma`lumotlarlardan chegaralanaylik, va bunday vaziyatni yaratishda siyosiy maydonda, yetarlicha kuch bo`lmasa, nur sochyotgangan yulduz topilmasa, faqat prezident topshirig`i bilan yurib, shaxsiy fikriga ega bo`lmaganlar, jamiyatda o`zgarish qilishga, odamlar fikrini, hayot tarzini, g`oyalarni o`zgartirishga qurbi yetmaganlar o`rniga, balki, maydonni iqtisodchilarga berish kerakdir, iqtisodiy manfaatlar bo`yicha biron tashkilot kerakdir... davlat chiqargan qonun kim uchun xizmat qilmoqda, kimni manfaati ko`proq bo`lyapti, kim ko`p zarar ko`rmoqda... zarar ko`rganlar uchun, aybdorlarga qanday choralar ko`riladi...

Kutmoqdamiz Behzod aka

@hamidazmetov4633

4 жыл бұрын

Nazar Yoqubov nimani?

Subtiteri yo'qmi

@bekhzodkhoshimov6416

4 жыл бұрын

Bor O’zbekcha

Behzod is much more fluent in English than in Uzbek😁o

Prof. : monopolies block people's opportunities, monopolies block people's incentives. Me: shuni o'zi yetadi nmaga Uzb rivojlanmayotganligiga

Assalomu alaykum Behzod aka charmasdan yuribsizmi ishlaringiz sogligingiz oila azolaringiz yaxshimi aka ishlaringiz qadrli va ajayib men bir fikringizga qushilaman yani qachondir aytgandingiz boylarning yoki boy mamlakatlarning sifatlari uxshash deb men uz dunyo qarashim bilan fikrimni bayon qilmoqchiman aytsylik xar kuni kechki payt bir piyola spirtli ichimlik ichib yursangiz bir yildan sung bunga urganib qolasiz u pdatni tark etish uchun balki besh yil balki undan kup vaqt ketadi balki umuman tashlay olmassiz bu odatni harakatlaringizni olqishlayman lekin ularni yuzlangan qiblalariga burib quydik bas hech kim uzgartirolmas degan hikmatni unutmang yaqinlaringiz va uzingizni asrang aka ollox yor bulsin sog buling qilayotgan xizmatlaringizdan oloh rozi bulsin

Bizikilar ham juda kóp narsa órgansa bóladi bundan

Behzod aka inglizchada yaxshiroq gapirarkansiz o'zbekchadan ko'ra 😂

Молга ухшаган таржима килмисанми ахмок