i am so impressed that she knows several informates about Uzbekistan

I came looking for copper and I found Gold. Your content is truly a treasure trove of information. Can't wait for your next video!

Intervyu menga yoqdi. Mazmun, mavzu, samimiyat. Rang va dekoratsiyaga alohida qoyil. Alohida tor mavzuda chuqurroq gaplashilsa biron mavzu bo'yicha yaxshi va foydali bilim bo'lardi, menimcha. Turli sohalardan oz oz gaplashish ham yomon emas. P.S. telegramdagi kanal nomi ham Hoshimov Iqtisodiyoti ga aylantirilsa brend kengroq yoyilardi va yangi muxlislar uni osonroq topardi, menimcha. Hammasi IMXO. P.S.S. Videoga "wow"!

"Показуха" хаетимзга жудаям емон урнашиб олган деб уйлайман. Чулдаги показуха колледжлар билан показуха туйларимиз бир бири билан боглик.

Right person, right topic and right time for the interview. I really liked how she is sincere on this topic and her findings.

@HoshimovIqtisodiyoti

4 жыл бұрын

thank you!

Prof Murtazashvili is amazing! Her insights on Afghanistan are just wonderful and it is shame for us that we don't know our neighbour Afghan people so well.

Yana boshqa olimlar bilan ham suhbatlarni kutib qolamiz! Bu ilmiy rivojlanishimiz uchun muhim. Charchamang!

Davlatni rivojlantirishda institutsional va sotsial faktorlarning o'rni haqida chiroyli suhbat bo'libdi. O'ylaymanki bizdagi rasmiylar ko'rib, hulosa chiqarishsa, barchaga foydali bo'lar edi....

Prof. Murtazashvili knows a lot about Central Asia. Very productive conversation. Thanks...

It is amazing if around 2 broad-minded people discuss punctual cases. Good job. Keep it up man

wow, mind changing interview! thanks a lot. "sometimes not doing anything helps more than doing something".

Bitter truths about the fact that we are not well known yet by any people. She described the real situation in a very good way and manner. Good luck with the future projects

Shunaqa ko'rsatuvlarimizni soni oshayotganidan juda ham xursandman! Keyingi sonlar hali bundanda qiziqarli bo'lishiga umid qilaman. Davom eting, to'xtamang! ✊

It’s astonishing to witness how knowledgeable she is and how well she knows about the political situation in Uzbekistan 👍🏻

Genuinely enjoyed this. Professor Murtazashvilli is an amazing interviewee. Honest and on point. Thank you, Bekhzod.

@bekhzodkhoshimov6416

4 жыл бұрын

Barno Nazar, thanks!

An amazing interview on political economy and Central Asia in English, we are gonna looking forward to more interviews like this.

Behzod Khashimov Thank You for useful channel and for inviting her! It’s interesting conversation) actually I follow up her posts on FB))

Fantastic talk. We are in need of more!

Indeed demographic factors can tremendously impact consumer spending and overall economy. As you've mentioned, the money spent on wedding party may measure one's success level in Central Asian countries, and it's not all about party itself, it is about what people's attitude towards his consumption and etc. Another hilarious part of the interview, American scholars have more understanding about Afghanistan than Uzbek scholars, even though we are the neighbors))

Thanks a lot Mr Begzod, I was amused and it was even fun to see her uzbek-imitating mimics. she has in fact so much to learn I think. Keep going bro!

wow i gained a lot of specific and excellent information here. I am bad at math to study in economics but i guess i should continue my bachelor's in politics. Thank you Mr.Hoshimov!

Aссалому алекум. Беҳзод ака, сиздака ёш ва Aмерикада дарс берадиган инсонлани кўплаб топиш мумкин ва биламанки сиз улани кўпини танисиз. Mисол учун, Ботир ака Қобиловдака ўқитувчилар. Лекин улани кўпчилиги "камерадан" қочишади. Ула билан ҳам шунақа Ўзбекистон иқтисодиёти, Ўзбекистонда ҳозирги бовотган ишла каби темалада гаплашсела зўр иш бўларди.

I really enjoyed the discussion, got some new views on many topics by both speakers. Look forward to watching next interviews) Respect!

Really enjoyed watching this! Thank you very much for the work you doing. Keep up the great work! P.S. The way she shushed you here 45:23 was hilarious :)

meaningful interview. time well-spent. questions are very interesting and she is very kind

Behzod aka ingliz tilida ancha ifodali so'zlar ekan. O'zbek tilidan ko'ra ingliz tilida ko'proq lavlahalr tayyorlang.

Zo'r , Iqtisodiyot vazirligidan vazir yoki o'rinbosaridan ham intervyu oling.Ular YAIM ni o'sish suratlarini qanday yechimlar bilan ko'tarmoqchi shu qiziq

Actually, I agree with Prof. Murtazashvili that Denau is the most underrated place in Uzbekistan.

Appreciate you.👍 Keep making this kind of interviews.

Гап нима хакталигини тушунмадиму ну Класс,..

Wow, honestly enjoyed a lot watching this! Incredible topics, good reasoning (if not best), great people! I loved the topics about reforms, opinions about building better government. Public Management? from now on this is in my list of possible grad school fields..!

Juda foydali suhbat chiqibti. Rahmat.

thanks man, keep it up

super

Thanks Begzod

Katta rahmat ko'rib mazza qildim. Iloji bolsa shuni uzbekcha hich bolmasa transcript bilan youtubega joylasez ko'proq insonlar ko'rishi uchun. Bu suhbat to'liqligicha tushunilsa, juda ko'p muammolarga javob topiladi, ayniqsa lavozimdagilar.

Bunisi umuman boshqacha bŏlibdi, tabriklayman Bekzod! Our government should hire Prof. Murtazashvili as consultant and should ACTUALLY act upon her recommendations.

Today Uzbek weddings are not just a way of showing how they are successful. But it's the way to hide their real financial status from each others or mahalla. This is my definition

@_bigbro

4 жыл бұрын

wedding is the tradition. Uzbek always lived in as a large family - they always said - our Country is the just one BIG mahalla(village). This is the main reason - you have to invite all of your relatives, all of neighbors, co-workers.. etc.. if you miss anybody - then it will be a real problem due high role of interpersonal traditions. Also, wedding - is the best place for YOUTH to find their partners as there not much places where you can do it.

@QALAMPIRTV

4 жыл бұрын

Isaac Kleiner And that is wrong, all goes wrong due to lack of doing big wedding party! Almost every uzbek says I have to play big one because I have been in their weddings, if you don’t play or play small wedding party, you are addicted and related on what people say and think about you! Thus I am totally agree with my_opposition!

@ulugbekabdukhamidov4533

4 жыл бұрын

@@QALAMPIRTV I agree with what you say. But on top of that, I believe that we, as individuals of the society, need to learn to be less prone to conventional wisdom. Surely we are social animals and surrounding people have a huge say in our mindset but, at the end of the day, we are the ones to enjoy our life. To illustrate my point, the establishment of the recent law concerning the restrictions on the number of guests in wedding ceremonies seems a bit absurd to me as it resembles some features of communism. Should I not buy an expensive car if I can afford it?

Well done! Let tyrants everywhere tremble!!!

Really interesting interview. However, I am still waiting for talk with Yuliy Yusupov. Is it going to be uploaded or not?

@HoshimovIqtisodiyoti

4 жыл бұрын

next week hopefully.

professor Jennifer Murtazashvili, I want to attend your classes. "measuring outputs vs measuring outcomes"

Murtazashilli 😀, o'zimizdan ekanmi deyman ota-bobolari. Yaxshi suhbat bo'libdi. Raxmat!

👍

Aka tarjimasiyam busin uzbda tagida

Noob noob: Gaaaaaad daaaamn Hoshimov: This guy gets it

Aksent zòr gap yò . L.n tushunmadim

@islom_urolov

4 жыл бұрын

Toxir Raximov subtitrlar bor

Yuliy Yusupov bilan suhbat bulmadimi ?

Tarjimasini kutib qolamiz. Hech bo'lmaganda subtitrda

@islom_urolov

4 жыл бұрын

uzbek uzbekistana subtitrlar qo’yilgan

Жуда зор , факат subtitles етмади

@bekhzodkhoshimov6416

4 жыл бұрын

Улугбек Азимов hozir bo’ladi. Ozgina qoldi.

@mirzayevmaxmud3239

4 жыл бұрын

@@bekhzodkhoshimov6416 20-minutdan keyin subtitr ko'rinmayapti

Хошимов узбек 🇺🇿 тилида булсин рахмат олдиндан

@HoshimovIqtisodiyoti

4 жыл бұрын

Tarjimasi qo'yildi. Subtitrlarni yoqib ko'rsangiz bo'ladi.

20 daqiqadan keyin caption yo'qoldi. Introdagi musiqa interview ga mos bo'lmabdi.

Here government officials are accountable for the centre (hokims, principals), not for the people. hmmm)

Ока таржимаси йокми тушинмадим сиздан илтимос таржима килинг.

@HoshimovIqtisodiyoti

4 жыл бұрын

Ertalabgacha tarjimasi qo'yiladi.

@Madaduz_SPBGo

4 жыл бұрын

Hoshimov Iqtisodiyoti Ассаламу аллейкум таржимасини коймадиз таржимасиям болганда жуда котта хиссаизни кошган болардиз фойдали малумот нуктасидан кайси Тилда болишидан каттий Назар Рахмат бу хамманиям колидан келмайди

@HoshimovIqtisodiyoti

4 жыл бұрын

@@Madaduz_SPBGo Tarjimasi bor, subtitrlarni yoqing, ko'rasiz.

Ózbek tilida ovur ukam intervyuni English da olishinga ancha bor ekan ukam

@DFSK_NAVOI

3 жыл бұрын

Yaxshiku aka shunga gapini tushuntirolyapdiku. Hammagayam shu kerak

subtitrli bo'lganda qanday yaxshi bo'lardiya...

@bekhzodkhoshimov6416

4 жыл бұрын

Subtitrlar qo'yildi, ko'rsangiz bo'ladi.

Salom uzbek tilida berishni iloji bormi.

@HoshimovIqtisodiyoti

4 жыл бұрын

O'zbekcha subtitrlarni yoqib ko'rsangiz bo'ladi.

Eventually i found a person who is speaking level is nearly perfect among Uzbekistan.

Узбекча субтитр булсин инглиз тилини жа унака зор тушинадиганларгаям фойдали булади илтимос

ХОШИМОВ узбек тилида субтитрларни кутодим , озгинагина доирадаги чет тилини биладиган узбеклар учун булиб колибдику. Узбек тилида субтитрлар булгандаям оддий одамам Бир нарса килиб тушуниб оларди сухбат мазмунини, курган одамларни Сал бусаям сиёсий савиясини оширишга ёрдам берган болардиз, субтитрли ёки таржимали вариант ни кутиб коламиз

@islom_urolov

4 жыл бұрын

Белгоре tarjimalar qo’yilibdi uje

@user-ct6ov4zy6s

4 жыл бұрын

Лайк👍 бу шуни иктисодчиларимизам куришдимикин а? Куришларини маслахат берган болардим

@user-ct6ov4zy6s

4 жыл бұрын

Ислом уролов сизгаям Рахмат , сухбатни куриб мазза килдим, хазил килиб айтганда шу опадан пархама килиб купайтириш керак, тугриси нимагадир иктисодчиларимиздан кура шуларни фикри яхширокка ухшаб туюлади

37 дақиқадан бошлаб субтитр йўқку

@islom_urolov

4 жыл бұрын

Собитхон Собиров qo’yilgan

Ват абоут транслейшн?)

@HoshimovIqtisodiyoti

4 жыл бұрын

it is translated to Uzbek

@bekzodjuraev7283

4 жыл бұрын

@@HoshimovIqtisodiyoti where?

@islom_urolov

4 жыл бұрын

Bekzod Juraev subtitrlarni yoqishiz kerak. Captions degan joyidan

why do you always wear red color socks?

@HoshimovIqtisodiyoti

4 жыл бұрын

it is just a coincidence. Don't read too much into that.