'It's bad': Van Jones reacts to SCOTUS ruling on presidential immunity
CNN political commentators Van Jones and Scott Jennings weigh in on the Supreme Court's ruling that Donald Trump may claim immunity from criminal prosecution for some of the actions he took in the waning days of his presidency in a decision that will likely further delay a trial on the federal election subversion charges pending against him. #CNN #News
Want to stay up to date on the day’s top stories? Sign up for CNN’s 5 Things newsletter, and we’ll give you the 5 biggest stories you need to know, videos people are watching, and more!
Sign up here: www.cnn.com/newsletters/5-thi...
Пікірлер: 10 000
You know what, Scott, I think I'll take a pass on your reassurances that Congress can always step in and throw out a criminal president. What we have witnessed with our own eyes is that Congress becomes part of the problem, and constantly finds ways to ignore, marginalize, dismiss, participate in, and/or otherwise capitulate to outrageous behavior on the part of the POTUS.
@gsmith2520
Күн бұрын
Impeachment process is partisan. A majority party of Congress will determine the impeachment results. The minority party of Congress will effectively have no bearing on results of impeachment.
@markfenaughty8301
Күн бұрын
And impeachment is not the same as criminal liability.
@1247.cccccc
Күн бұрын
@@markfenaughty8301 How so?
@lilblackduc7312
Күн бұрын
Lol, sucka...
@anonomous7817
Күн бұрын
I agree with you 100%.🖐️
Scott does not understand that a judge is supposed to do his job without being partisan. People cannot vote these idiots out
@iamdev42
Күн бұрын
I think Scott understands full well what he is saying, but is just acting in bad faith.
@bo2.4u6
Күн бұрын
"WASH WASH".
@kimocoloma4123
Күн бұрын
Democrats must not only accept but respect the outcome/verdict of the highest court of the land. Follow and abide the rules of the law, you are not above the law. The U.S. Court of Justice main function is to interpret the law.
@neonthai
Күн бұрын
So its just by chance that 6 repulican judges vote the same and 3 democrats vote the same they are all just puppets put there by presidents.. Its decisions is just made by who dies at what time so the sitting president can put his own people in so basiclly the supreme court is a lottery of who of them dies when
@Occupied_South
Күн бұрын
Just because the decision didn't agree with you doesn't mean it was partisan.
To hear this people speak about bipartisan is beyond infuriating. What a bunch of hypocrites.
@cidquakenbush302
19 сағат бұрын
Exactly! A 2 tiered system and a weaponized FBI/DOJ
Sorry, enlighten me Scott - when has a president ever needed this protection?
@gorkyd7912
22 сағат бұрын
Democrat president Andrew Johnson needed this protection when he was clashing with Congress over reconstruction of the South. Republicans in Congress labeled him a traitor.
@jasondamrau9943
2 сағат бұрын
Obama when he murdered US citizens in Yemen in drone strikes. The GOP could have easily had hom jailed for that in Trumps time in office but we didn't weaponize the DOJ like the Democrats did
@pilarpalabunda4805
Сағат бұрын
@@kvkv7423 When a sitting president goes after a former president/ political opponent the way they do in 3rd world banana republics.
But Scott Jennings, what if there are corrupt people in Congress and the Senate🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
@janislentz5649
Күн бұрын
That is exactly the case in front of us-corrupt Republicans who FAILED to impeach and remove Donald Trump!
@martinrayner6466
Күн бұрын
And what if the courts become corrupt. That's a silly circular argument, as many are beginning to suspect. At least the senate is open for scrutiny.
@BassRck50-xv8iz
Күн бұрын
Because, there ARE!
@yaboi_LGK
Күн бұрын
@@martinrayner6466 Considering SCOTUS is the only one with the capability to determine if they are corrupt, I don't have much faith in them either.
@gregs42768
Күн бұрын
Then you voted in the wrong people
Congress has already proven what a joke impeachment is. It's always one side vs. the other.
@KaribeCuebas
Күн бұрын
Exactly! Impeachment process is a waste of time and money. The way I see it it’s like me committing a crime and the prosecution allowing my family members as the jury. What the chances of my family convicting me? NONE! So, in Congress whoever is in the majority will convict the other side or protect the members of their side without true evaluation. 🤷🏽♀
@quanbrooklynkid7776
Күн бұрын
@@KaribeCuebasdamn
@greg11786
Күн бұрын
The 2 hoax impeachments by piglosi? Yeah. She should be behind bars for jan 6th.
@ericargo9157
Күн бұрын
Yep, impeachment has zero consequences to the impeached. It's just a shitshow created by Congress to achieve...nothing. And, that nothing is paid by Joe and Jane tax payer that hired (elected) those buffoons in the first place. The United States has and never will be perfect but in 2024 it's just gotten ridiculous and pretty embarrassing.
@metalmagicrestoration3823
Күн бұрын
@@KaribeCuebasYou have already committed a crime. You murdered your now dead baby. I say throw you in jail, throw away the key and take away all your rights! People like you that support abortion need to be locked up forever! Karma always wins! God wins… You lose!
The impeachment process goes away with this ruling because now he is inmune.
Van said it and moved passed it too quickly. The whole point of the founders was to “constrain” the office of the President. The three branches work to constrain one another. It wasn’t meant to be the job of voters to constrain the President.
@frederickgriffith7004
Күн бұрын
Exactly.Do people realize how much damage can be done between election cycles.And then because of so much misinformation out there the voting electorate is not as informed as it should be.We delegate that responsibility as voters to the three branches of govt to maintain checks on one another.Sad to say.The only thing left with any integrity is our military.Once that goes,and it will,we are done
@CarterM54
Күн бұрын
It's the job of the voters to constrain their representatives. Of course, when the system was changed to the "universal franchise" - meaning illiterate morons who can't get a job flipping burgers have just as much say in our governance as responsible, intelligent, and educated citizens, what can be expected other than the mess we have today?
@loladaise6432
19 сағат бұрын
No. The Founders wanted to restrain the government. The whole purpose of the government is to protect our inaliable rights. It was meant to be small. The Executive branch is supposed to see that the laws are carried out. Legislative branch crates the laws and Judicial sees that pre existing laws are interpreted correctly as per the Constitution. Judicial is the weakest of the 3 branches.
@amerispunk
15 сағат бұрын
@@loladaise6432 The founders, after fighting a king, did want to avoid having (another) king, above all other aims. Restraining the government includes restraining the president, does it not? Is it OK to have a renegade president who goes overboard with a revenge tour against (perceived) enemies? What president is promising such a tour? There is no reliable way to say which branch is the strongest, but surely a lifetime appointment is at least supposed to convey some independence which is more important for those who hold the final review of a president's actions.
@ThePianoMan1953
11 сағат бұрын
@@loladaise6432 Very nice! Thanks! A small government is something the left will never understand. 🥹
What is absolutely asinine about Scott Jenning's position is if the ultimate check of power is with the voters, then the voters did reject Trump, and what he did next is what got us here in the first place.
@paularroyo3450
Күн бұрын
Scott has orange all over his face
@Acidfox86
Күн бұрын
Then you can reject him again. Doesn't mean he can't be on the ballot. Just vote for who you want, you shouldn't be bothered by someone you don't plan on voting for.
@peggyivey5828
Күн бұрын
There was so much cheating it was pitiful
@MercuryCold
Күн бұрын
@@Acidfox86, criminal actions should be prosecuted, obviously a popularity contest would have nothing to do with the issue.
@billtmarchi4320
Күн бұрын
If no immunity then biden Obama Clinton's can all face dozens of charges. They all commited worse crimes than Trump. Educate yourself.
At 7:45, Jennings is asked if he's OK with the President committing crimes not in an official capacity..shouldn't his answer have been "NO"? America is circling the drain
@quanbrooklynkid7776
Күн бұрын
Yup
@KaiCross
Күн бұрын
Paying off someone’s silence isn’t a crime. It wasn’t campaign funds. The judge’s family in the case actually funded Biden… I thought that was a conflict of interest… Trying to indict your political opponent is election interference also… there’s a major reason Trump will be the 2024 President elect…
@janislentz5649
Күн бұрын
Shut UP, Jennings! It is NOT ok for a president to violate any law outside his official duties! It is a crime that demands prosecution!
@debgrant8776
Күн бұрын
This is why I don't watch them anymore either MTN is the way to go!
@johnnygrant363
Күн бұрын
Wow!!!! Gotta watch out for him. SMH
So many citizens don't have any clue what the implications of this are and its scary.
*So under this new ruling, does this mean, current President Biden can choose not to concede, be the last President, & appoint his successor, rather than another election, & we can say good bye to Trump forever!!!*
@pilarpalabunda4805
58 минут бұрын
@@sandyleewhite it doesn’t mean that at all you nut.
It doesn’t matter if a lower court makes a ruling because the matter can be pushed back up to the SC, giving them complete control!!!!
@robertpierce6444
2 күн бұрын
😂😂😂
@jinxterpinxter
2 күн бұрын
It will go back and forth for years.
@DonKeecock
2 күн бұрын
we got this on lock. We gonna MAGA again.
@Chulitatr
2 күн бұрын
Exactly. It's disgusting. Project 2025 has just began and the SCOTUS Republican justices gave them the keys to overthrow the government and finish the coup.
@user-xb6qw1mi5q
2 күн бұрын
@@DonKeecocklmfao no you’re not tool.
The corruption in politics today is endemic. America is in an existential crisis. It really is.
@largerthanlightmedia8162
Күн бұрын
This is an ACTUAL crisis
@eds7343
Күн бұрын
Clear out all the George soros backed Liberal Communists since the democrat party is all communists.
@phillipalder9045
Күн бұрын
167 Biden LLCs that produced nothing and provided ZERO services -absolutely, we have a crisis.
@treeofliberty5611
Күн бұрын
@@JonnM you do know your local mayor has immunity of offical acts as well, even the dog catcher has immunity for offical acts... why? Or how did you people get so brainwashed and dumb?
@user-po3ev7is5w
Күн бұрын
@@largerthanlightmedia8162 Aw, widdle commie upset. Obamao had immunity from prosecution over the illegal war he started against Libya
Anderson Cooper, when will you quit putting Scott Jennings on air? A clear Frump apologist! Not watching anytime he is on!
@gorkyd7912
22 сағат бұрын
Snow flakes can now not bear to listen to even a potentially opposing view point. The ideological purity test is that the words are insufficiently false.
@alberttrinidad1750
20 сағат бұрын
Until he stops being fair balanced with two opposing view. It's called fair democracy
@beckyheinz7337
20 сағат бұрын
😢I lost all respect for CNN and the NYT after the debate debacle. I unsubscribed from both. This Country is heading down a path unlike anything I've seen in my 63 years. Billionaires control everything that can be bought including SCOTUS.
@paulduffy697
19 сағат бұрын
So you don’t like hearing different views?
@gorkyd7912
19 сағат бұрын
@@beckyheinz7337 Watching TV makes people very depressed about the country.
Interestingly, we have had 46 presidents in our history and only one has requested complete immunity as a former president. Since the Constitution has always provided for presidential accountability, you might have asked your guest why this was so important at this time that there is only one (ex)president facing criminal charges at the moment.
Congress was the one who said "let the criminal justice system take care of this" FFS America is BROKEN.
@deborahpitcher7723
Күн бұрын
Vote blue and we can overcome this
@deborahpitcher7723
Күн бұрын
Vote blue we can’t overcome this. It’s only powerful of Trump if he’s president and he’s not.
@ericskelton8368
Күн бұрын
Don’t forget “Let the voters decide.” But that’s the whole point. MAGAs don’t even respect elections. It’s lying on a Soviet scale what the GOP does.
@BogartFK
Күн бұрын
Liberal tears
@BrianBrayMedia
Күн бұрын
@@BogartFK Every American should be crying.
Scott Jennings is so good at gas-lighting he probably doesn't require any domestic source of electricity. Or is he just auditioning for a spot on Newsmax or OAS?
@PUFFYADDERSONSFakeNewsAN-qv4ku
Күн бұрын
he's a WEASEL!
@billtmarchi4320
Күн бұрын
He tells the truth. Unlike Jones and ahole licker cooper
@bcwest619
Күн бұрын
100%, I really wish they'd get rid of him. The left-leaning commentators actually have some nuance and ability to call actions from people "on their side" wrong when they are wrong. Scott Jennings is just a right wing lackey that has absolutely no ability to actually think about anything beyond "right good, left bad." I don't watch CNN much anymore, and Jennings is the biggest example of why.
@user-yb8vr2ip2t
Күн бұрын
Jennings knows damn well this Supreme Court HATES Congress. Roberts told the Senate to F OFF when they wanted him to come in and speak about all the bribes the Right Wing Justices are taking.
@Anthony-ox4pt
Күн бұрын
It’s suppose to be opinions from both sides of the isle. Sounds like you just want to hear from one side. Is that real journalism?
I read this comments by Trumpers and I've decided a couple of things. 1. I understand why America is falling apart. 2. I don't argue with crazy, so I'm not arguing with Trumpers. I didn't realize how common simple minded people are in America.
@paulridenour1086
18 сағат бұрын
It's "these"
@TKaePetras
14 сағат бұрын
@@paulridenour1086 Get over it.
@serahrinaa
6 сағат бұрын
Relax .. it’s TRUMP 2024. 😅
@BigHunt206
2 сағат бұрын
Evidently there were 80 million simple minded morons that voted for Biden. 😂
What an example for the world to “follow” sheesh the world has gone to shit
Didn't McConnell say after the Senate refused to impeach Trump that the legal system should be the remedy? And now there is no legal remedy.
@ritaostrum2433
Күн бұрын
Exactly!
@endhate6505
Күн бұрын
Guttless Moscow Mitch! A vote to impeach. Could have saved us from all this shit.à
@daviddestefanis2989
Күн бұрын
The legal system was there in 2020, 2021, and 2022. Democrats dragged the Jan. 6th protestors into court during that time. The reason they didn't bring it until August of 2023 is because that was when it became clear that Trump would run again. They kept it in their pocket as a political tool, and it backfired. That's what happened.
@whatshaploing8256
Күн бұрын
Congress was the remedy set in place by the Constitution. It isn't the role of common courts to sue the president for their perceived slights/crimes, etc. and to do so over and over in order to bankrupt, silence or jail him is ridiculous.
@strikercwl
Күн бұрын
Mitch was also the sole reason Trump was able to stack the court, that is not a coincidence.
If the Supreme Court is corrupt, and Congress is corrupt, and the President is corrupt, who can the people turn to for justice?
@MikeAinsworth
Күн бұрын
Yourself. Second Amendment.
@kelbatt7729
Күн бұрын
@@MikeAinsworth looks like the people are going to have to do something
@phoebemulube4451
Күн бұрын
♥️🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@dr.g3860
Күн бұрын
Superman.
@user-rx7hn9li5c
Күн бұрын
Smith and Wesson
If SCOTUS ruled that presidents has immunity in core work, they didn’t need to make a ruling. 250 years and all presidents had this as understood. By ruling that he has immunity EXCEPT in cases not associated with his job, it makes every case end up in SC to see if it’s job related. Lawyers want to throw out the Stormy case because you know, that was his official duty😂
Supreme Court hurt itself? As if they care about constitution
Impeachment is not justice. Being kicked out is not prosecution
@kansashoneybadger7899
Күн бұрын
O.K.l let's take this one step at a time. Impeachment was solely intended to remove an official from office. Period. Impeachment is distinct from and has nothing to do with either a civil lawsuit or a criminal prosecution. The Supremes "granted" Trump (and all following Presidents) nothing more than what virtually every public official in the U.S. already enjoys: governors, mayors, etc. You are apparently unaware that the Presidency was the sole public position for which this was not clearly established. Trust me the Badger has practiced law for more than 40 years.
@mysticx0
Күн бұрын
impeachment has nothing AT ALL to do with being kicked out of anything LOL
@vinista256
Күн бұрын
@@mysticx0 well, OK-impeachment AND conviction … is that better? 😯
@stvnkbrown
Күн бұрын
But it's a start.
@stvnkbrown
Күн бұрын
@@vinista256 Much.
Mitch McConnell is responsible for all the mess we're in right now. Let's not forget that.
@marykaybrewster
Күн бұрын
Don’t forget Harlan Crow
@jwhatheduck
Күн бұрын
He wanted the Supreme Court majority. He would not have gotten it if trump was held accountable
@MsNextgeneration12
Күн бұрын
Biden is going to be responsible for democrats loosing in November. 🤣🤣🤣
@nhungngo6103
Күн бұрын
@@MsNextgeneration12 I still vote for 💙💙💙💙
@Ohreallybro95
Күн бұрын
Boo hoo
I this presidential immunity thing really needed? I mean, after over 200 years of US history, how many times has a president needed immunity from prosecution in order to do his official job?
@gorkyd7912
22 сағат бұрын
This has been the standard for 200 years. You can find SCOTUS cases upholding presidential immunity going back 150+ years. Just because liberals are completely and absolutely ignorant of basic history doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
@milehighyt2097
12 сағат бұрын
Never… until the left lost its mind and was willing to do anything and everything to alienate half the country, relentlessly targeting and attempting to destroy their political rival / threat to power
@jasondamrau9943
2 сағат бұрын
Only when Democrats decided to weaponize their Gestapo DOJ. I guarantee you wouldn't feel this way if a Republican lead DOJ decided to arrest Obama for the murder of US citizens in drone strikes in Yemen, or if after Biden was outed in November they arrested him as an accessory to the murder of Laken Rylie for completely opening the border
Jennings talking about how the voters can reign in a President when this was about the attempt to manipulate and delegitimize an election is pretty rich.
@jaobidan2358
Күн бұрын
To be fair, Biden's "questionable" victory has only increased in doubt as his Presidency marched on. I didn't think much about "the big lie" having any credence early on...But as I watched Joe more and more? I began to have my doubts the majority of the people put him in the WH. You can't blame others for feeling that way.
@howlinwind
Күн бұрын
@@jaobidan2358 You can't blame others for being an idiot. How many times have I asked you what connections Biden has with China, while Trump has over 100 fast tracked trademarks to do business there? Run away like you always do and take your stupid user name with you.
@paulmoss7940
Күн бұрын
the election was not fair. Way too much smoke for no fire.
@joparkcat
Күн бұрын
LOL CNN should give trump and his traitor group more air time, like a debate. keep normalizing trump!! 🤣😂😅
@renenowicki
Күн бұрын
Fake electors tried to rob me of my vote.
All they had to do was answer the question before them regarding THE PARTICULAR CASE IN FRONT OF THEM! Not the ENTIRE PRESIDENCY!!!!!!!! World is watching 😢
@WillBrightback
Күн бұрын
Wow. What a m o r o n you are😂
@suedavis3525
Күн бұрын
And we are disgusted.
@naby214
Күн бұрын
Clearly you have no idea what you’re talking about. 😂 The job of SCOTUS is to uphold the constitution and they did just that. It’s really that simple.
@libbycollins9349
Күн бұрын
Absolutely. Cases involving the constitution are to be narrowly decided.
@WillBrightback
Күн бұрын
@@libbycollins9349 I know you are joking. Good one
2 problems with the 'just impeach him if he breaks the law' argument... We're so divided that no matter what the actions, there will NEVER be a conviction... And even if that weren't the case, what if it's in final week of final term? Won't go through in time and no recourse in courts after this ruling
@hannahpumpkins4359
Күн бұрын
There won't be any 'final term' for a POTUS - they can now stay in office forever.
@benalexandra
Күн бұрын
@@hannahpumpkins4359 well, for an unethical (aka Republican) president
@gorkyd7912
21 сағат бұрын
It's almost like there are checks and balances against one side railroading the other side for stupid crap like "property values."
I will have more faith in the public's choice when companies like Fox have laws that regulate the lies and misinformation they can spread. VOTE BLUE 🔵🟦🔷💙🙏
I cannot think of any law a President would need to break in order to perform their duties!
@robertmatthews2009
Күн бұрын
Obama ordered the assassination of a US citizen without a trial or any due process based on his belief the man was a danger to the US. That is the definition of murder, but this Supreme Court ruling gives him immunity.
@Saneka999_
Күн бұрын
Murder in war? Obama killing Osama bin laden? Also him killing women and children with drone strikes?
@rotaryenginepete
Күн бұрын
think harder 🤣
@chectasy1731
Күн бұрын
President Obama killing an American and a wedding party in a drone strike. President Biden killing a family going for water he thought was terrists.
@carlocalingasan998
Күн бұрын
Obama killed 4 American citizens. Bush tortured. Bill Clinton lied under oath.
Here is a rule of thumb that should be plastered in all schools and the supreme court. No Man is Above The Law !!
@snjg1035
Күн бұрын
But obviously that is NOT the case.
@dirkdiggler9056
Күн бұрын
Exept if your name is biden..or clinton..or bush..pelosi..ect. then you can lie and sell the country down the river and insider trade to your hearts content.
@philanimasuku4256
Күн бұрын
So why Bush and Obama not in prison for war crimes?
@motorwhisperer
Күн бұрын
You must be talking about biden. ONLY POTUS can unilaterally determine classified document disposition, NOT a VP or Senator. Biden got a pass for violating the law. Trump got charged for following it.
@ssherrierable
Күн бұрын
Said no cop ever 😂
Mr. Van Jones, how could it possibly go down as you quoted, “bad politically for the Supreme Court”, when the Supreme Court is not a political group?
@BlazingShackles
16 сағат бұрын
Van Jones is a moron.
SCOTUS is asking Congress to do its job and we’re asking SCOTUS to do theirs. This isn’t it.
@howdareyou41
Күн бұрын
6-3 GOP SCOTUS is doing exactly what they were placed there for
@gorkyd7912
22 сағат бұрын
SCOTUS doesn't write the laws.
Only kings and dictators are free to ignore the law. In a democracy, no individual should be immune to the law.
@patriot4usa
2 күн бұрын
Joe Biden committed multiple felonies by having classified docs but Robert Hur said he didn't recommend an indictment because Biden is old and forgetful and too old for a trial. Huh? But he can be in the White House? And the Biden admin just admitted in federal court to altering the transcripts to make Biden look less incompetent. And now they won't release the tapes so they are hiding something very damaging about Biden. Go Trump and FJB and his banana republic regime.
@DonKeecock
Күн бұрын
Hillary got away with it, but it's only a problem now?
@anyroad5455
Күн бұрын
If the penalty of breaking a law is a fine, it’s only illegal for the poor.
@misterfunnybones
Күн бұрын
June 1215 Magna Carta. Review your history.
@giovanniramos5499
Күн бұрын
but the MAGA idiots only see this as a win for them instead of a loss for ALL.
What is the oath of office for? ...TO DEFEND THE CONSTITUTION. I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I take this obligation freely, without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion
@mr.kilroy6818
Күн бұрын
Yeah' we need protection from those Evil Ass Democrats !
@janislentz5649
Күн бұрын
Trump himself is the DOMESTIC enemy of our Constitution! Proceed with the Georgia case, The Florida case and the DC insurrection case!!!
@rufiorufioo
Күн бұрын
Yeah that all does not matter to these ring wing wackos anymore. They want a dictatorship. They want us like Russia. They are against democracy. This is why you never hear MAGA talk about democracy ever.
@carriegoebel7541
Күн бұрын
That is exactly why he needs to be charged with treason immediately!
@kansashoneybadger7899
Күн бұрын
Spare me the drama. The Supremes "granted" Trump (and all following Presidents) nothing more than what virtually every public official in the U.S. already enjoys: governors, mayors, legislators, and so on. You are apparently unaware that the Presidency was the sole public position for which this was not clearly established. Trust me the Badger has practiced law for more than 40 years.
Van may be feeling the pain. This is what that looks like. Jones will cry for attention in time. For all to see.
"If we don't have faith in the voters and the people they send, then I am not sure what we're fighting about today." YEAH CAUSE TRUMP HAS LOADS OF FAITH IN THE VOTERS AND WHO THEY ELECT. What a load of BS.
How can a broken, gridlock Congress punish a president who has half the congress in his pocket...
@xU7fr1cx
Күн бұрын
but I thought "bidens really with it" campaign had him as the "top tier winner" 🙄
@OCFilmFan
Күн бұрын
Trump doesn’t have half the country. His zombie supporters want voters to think they do, but voter intimidation wouldn’t be necessary if they did.
@richardnielsen4999
Күн бұрын
One-third of the country, my friend. I am part of the other third. And then we have the 1/3 that could vote, but apparently could care less. They will be the loudest whiners, but they will be salved by their "cultural superiority" on the wasteland of MAGA.
@margomargao2004
Күн бұрын
Trust in God. everything shld be fine for president joe biden. Blessings🙏
@bobjames5264
Күн бұрын
And half the CONGRESS in his pocket…
"If the President does it, it's not a crime." How does this ruling affect Congress's ability to impeach a president for "high crimes and misdemeanors?"
@forfun6273
Күн бұрын
If the president commits a crime that isn’t in his official capacity then they can still impeach him. They can pretty much impeach him for anything if they have the votes. Police officers have qualified immunity. It’s their duty to enforce the law. The president is the head of the executive branch which’s duty is to enforce the law. So why tf would a random police officer have immunity but not the president? The president dictates policy to the atf, fbi, cia,NSA, and all the other agencies. If he orders one of those agencies to do something thinking it’s going to save American lives but he ends up being wrong then he shouldn’t go to jail. If he had the potential to go to jail then you would compromise the ability of the federal government to enforce the law and protect Americans. Obviously there’s a line that can be crossed between acting in an official capacity and being a tyrant or abusing your power. In that case house impeaches senate finds guilty and removes. Once that happens then he’s fair game for criminal prosecution by the appropriate courts.
@lebohangmohapi8605
Күн бұрын
Your initial sentence is wrong.
@jiggahenry9471
Күн бұрын
IF? God help those who don’t have money or power to buy favor.
@thebeezkneez7559
Күн бұрын
Yes, the first sentence is wrong because the only things he'll have immunity to is official acts and unofficial acts have no immunity. If you read through the case most of the stuff is not official in the same way Nixon and the wiretapping was not official while Reagan and the Iran contra was.
@Tasmanaut
Күн бұрын
it actually makes impeachment and removal pointless. That power only makes sense if the president has the absolute immunity that Trump argued for. This ruling actually limits the immunity of a president but makes impeachment pointless, as I stated.
But congress wont take action, they are such a mess. What happens when one party controls all levers?
@gorkyd7912
22 сағат бұрын
I don't know but it looks like they prosecute their opponents and toss them in jail. Hypocrites.
@dericnentrup5627
18 сағат бұрын
California
Van Jones really raised some very important points there. Kudos to him.
@paulduffy697
19 сағат бұрын
😂🤣😅
No previous President has had to worry about having immunity in the 245 years our country has existed.
@davej1425
Күн бұрын
erm, Nixon?
@pilarpalabunda4805
Күн бұрын
No previous president was part of a witch hunt the way Trump is .
@christineschueneman4147
Күн бұрын
Because none of those past presidents where not autocratic criminals
@AltariqAbraham
Күн бұрын
@@davej1425That was an act of congress. That is always on the table.
@Einoidmilvada
Күн бұрын
Because no president ever had his opponent going after him.
Having Scott’s voice on CNN normalised dangerous far right ideas. That hire was strategic and CNN is shifting the discourse to where you don’t want it to be
@Kreeyolo827
Күн бұрын
💯% AGREE!
@reddzrzrrider1086
Күн бұрын
🤦🏽♂️Scott is definitely not far right… Just because he told you the truth and you don’t agree with his statement… You must like getting pacified… Your statement definitely defines you as a very misinformed person
@user-tn3qf1gg1j
Күн бұрын
He is far right in The Magat camp ,I've watched him for 8 years sniveling and groveling for their Orange Menace, he just the official propagandaist for him .
@denakochevar4333
Күн бұрын
The debate was a disaster partly because CNN did not require trump to answer their questions, he diverted all of them and lied all the time. I’m sick of hearing how Biden is old, so what! We are safe with him and he will not be a dictator!
So what Trump has been going through the last 8 years is nothing to them but if he gets back into office there is all this fear all of a sudden. Hmmmmm
Scott is for the executive branch! WE need to put them in their place. This is a huge step backwards for our country!
IT DOESN’T MATTER IF A LOWER COURT MAKES A RULING BECAUSE THE MATTER CAN BE PUSHED BACK UP TO THE SC, GIVING THEM COMPLETE CONTROL!!!! 🙂😄😀
@l.dennisfarmer4810
Күн бұрын
Mr Trump could,and, should be in jail after next week. The is no reason for Mr Trump to get treated any different to any one else! This Supreme Court is Mr Trump court.
@andrettski8686
Күн бұрын
Trump derangement syndrome, Kathy Griffin had it too.
@robertmatthews2009
Күн бұрын
Yes, that's how the Constitution works.
If Scott Jennings had been living in Germany in 1932 he would have commented "I'm okay with it", when Adolf became chancellor.
@northernbohemianrealist1412
Күн бұрын
We are in Germany, 1932. Remember President Hindenburg last week? Funny hair, violent followers, minority rule, but most important, an apathetic public. Cabaret.
@BassRck50-xv8iz
Күн бұрын
"As a guard at Auschwitz-Birkenau!"
@kellymcquay2626
Күн бұрын
Hitler=Democrats!!!
@toodleloo2253
Күн бұрын
SO TRUE!!!- And like we're supposed to wait for Trump to grow a Conscience!!-??!.. In reality, Trump admits that he studied Hitler's speech-making tactics, & reads Hitler's Mein Kampf Manifesto for Inspiration-?!!... This is SO insane!!-☠☢
@kellymcquay2626
Күн бұрын
@@toodleloo2253 No PEOPLE LIKE YOU ARE INSANE!!
This is being overblown, maybe because this announcement was pumped up by the media. Now they have to make it seem so serious, it’s still up to the judiciary
More immunity should come more scrutiny of who gets the power. If there is any chance someone will abuse that power, no votes.
WHY waste time asking a non-lawyer like Scott Jennings for his opinion on a legal matter? Wtf CNN??
@ashfox7498
Күн бұрын
You literally don't even need to be a lawyer, there's no reality in which a president should be above the law and no legal precedent to proclaim this. An 8th grader with a C in social studies could tell you this is wrong and unconstitutional.
@glennknauer2696
Күн бұрын
You watch CNN and believe them? Time to grow up hon.
@bobjoe3810
Күн бұрын
Because they are reaching
@mommabearmaryann8106
Күн бұрын
The only qualification needed is to be a democrat.
@jameswhipple48
Күн бұрын
Yes, God forbid someone have a different opinion and allow viewers to hear 2 sides.
The Founders were working on the pretense that representatives were going to be loyal to the Constitution and its processes. With the number of traitors in the government that we have and had, it's not a good prognosis.
@seewulf2385
Күн бұрын
Their master's voice..and payola.. Read G Washington re. foreign entanglements and pol.parties..
@justacoginthefkery
Күн бұрын
Exactly. The system has become corrupted into everything that the founders were trying to avoid. Even the 2 party system was meant to prevent the power play nonsense. Now everything is centered around grown adults playing "king of the sandcastle" & "I know you are but what am I? Na-nuh-na-nuh boo boo!"
@murrayflewelling1258
Күн бұрын
It's go time for seal team six President Biden !!..........................no greater example of threat to country could even be imagined that would have made it this far , while some rule of law still exists
@zefdin101
Күн бұрын
/\ Secret Service… please investigate/\
@TheDerlick
Күн бұрын
The founding fathers were operating under the assumption that leaders will be virtuous. I'd be surprised if 2% of politicians are virtuous.
Terryfiying. This fake ex thug needs to be in jail looong time ago!!!
@TKaePetras
13 сағат бұрын
I would say, this thug needs to be in prison for his crimes. He is a convicted felon on multiple counts. Why should he be granted immunity?
When the Supreme Court has the ultimate say on anything - the talking points about a fail safe in congress doesn’t mean a thing.
Scott says the people can stop the president by not voting for him, but what happens after he is voted in. You have to wait 4 years to vote him out of office. A lot of criminal actions can happen in 4 years and the people have no say
@BassRck50-xv8iz
Күн бұрын
Been there!
@dustinbarlow1623
Күн бұрын
If He is voted in, it means more people than you wanted him as president!
@howlinwind
Күн бұрын
@@dustinbarlow1623 No it doesn't,. Trump lost the popular vote twice. The one time he was elected it was by the electoral college, not the people.
@Reaper-cm4jr
Күн бұрын
@@howlinwind And Biden lost in THREE primaries before being "Elected". So your point is?
@joesmith4443
Күн бұрын
@@howlinwindTyranny by Minority & a MAGA judicial system with activist judges that can “veto” any new law they don’t like 💯 even IF you win elections with Popular Sovereignty.
The same court has said biden cant forgive student loans and then turns around and says trump can do whatever he wants ?
@drowningpooralice5505
2 күн бұрын
That's not what happened.
@DonKeecock
2 күн бұрын
You take a short bus to school, don't you?
@thetoastedhippies1997
Күн бұрын
Biden can do whatever he wants to. Since he is President he can do all kinds of official acts. This could backfire on Donald and his minions.
@millionairedee6136
Күн бұрын
That part...
@seanmccartney5177
Күн бұрын
Uh "Constitution"
Surprised surprised Van Jones didn't say it was a white lash. It wouldn't be the first time that he used that phrase.
America is about to vote for their new monarcy. It's funny how this was never needed until Trump came to office. The Trump royal family is about to be seated and Americans deserve what they are about to get.
America - for the love of God!?!? What the Actual £&@! are you doing? You WILL lose your democracy if you don’t get out and vote Blue up and down the Ballot in November. This is sad, this is scary, this is unbelievable. Get out and vote, Get your friends, families, acquaintances, community to use their votes. And use them wisely.
@ThePianoMan1953
15 сағат бұрын
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@serahrinaa
6 сағат бұрын
Relax . It’s Trump 2024.
5:22 impeachment is not a criminal trial, and the people also dont charge criminality.... so no
@matthewstump7563
Күн бұрын
Once they are impeached and removed they are stripped of their immunity and the DOJ can prosecute them.
This interview is NOT informing people. It only helps create more uncertainty.
You need 2/3 to convict in Congress. Should we suddenly belive that if there is more criminal activity, they suddenly will grow a spine and convict? That's ridiculous.
So why hasn’t this been an issue for past administrations? He’s doing a favor for FUTURE presidents? President have NEVER required immunity before; that should scream volumes… smh
@eriv
2 күн бұрын
Obama would have went to prison for his seat sale in Chicago with/along blagovich if it wasn’t for this same thing
@drowningpooralice5505
2 күн бұрын
Dude, this has been this way for 243 years. That's why it hasn't been an issue. This isn't a Trump thing this was the Democrats getting too big for their britches.
@Maia-j7j
Күн бұрын
Biden will require immunity, so he should be grateful for today's ruling.
@notastone4832
Күн бұрын
obama drone strikes on american civilians? people said he had immunity
@czgibson3086
Күн бұрын
There's a precedent for civil immunity but not criminal immunty. Nixon v. Fitzgerald (1982): The Supreme Court held that the President is entitled to absolute immunity from civil damages liability for acts within the "outer perimeter" of his official responsibilities. This means the President cannot be sued for damages for official acts taken while in office.
And this is why I don’t watch CNN anymore because Scott Jennings should not be on this segment or any segment in my opinion. He’s not even a lawyer!!!!!!
@JimCastleberry
Күн бұрын
I know, you want your CNN propaganda pure and undiluted. You want to be comfortable in ignorance and divorced from reason or thinking. You can always scream at the sky!
@bart4543
Күн бұрын
But ur watching this video lol
@crazzygamer2866
Күн бұрын
So like what, you just want everyone in the room to agree with each other and offer no dissenting viewpoints? The lack of curiosity and intellectualism in liberals is astounding
@MindfulAttraction2.0
Күн бұрын
Okay so you just want everyone to agree LOL
@Doc_Holiday
Күн бұрын
Awwwww 😂🤣😂🤣
This is a clear ruling that was already implemented. look at what presidents have done, and only one prosecuted. Good grief. Why is it that so many cannot understand a scotus ruling, and the limits on the president. The media and president is not helping when they through murkiness on this ruling.
Politics here finally destroyed this country. Sad.
@haruhisuzumiya6650
Күн бұрын
And will end up destroying other countries
"The Constitution gave Congress a way to reign in any president, it's called impeachment." Sure, assuming that the president--having full immunity from prosecution--doesn't kill or imprison the rivals trying to impeach him, or doesn't just ignore the impeachment altogether.
@yemarb1
Күн бұрын
Right. And the Dems knew they could not do that so they lied. They are liars.
@peggyivey5828
Күн бұрын
The House votes to impeach but the Senate decides if there is reason to act, like remove them from.office. The dumocrats impeached Trump after he was president the idiots! 😅
@hatchet3755
Күн бұрын
what if Biden does it first?
@riverpirate1022
Күн бұрын
You people are SOOOOOOO dumb. That would be illegal and outside of official acts, he would not be allowed to do it, unless he gets the police and military on his side, which makes it a coup at that point.
What''s to stop a President, acting in his official capacity, from declaring martial law and suspending an election?
@IndelibleHD
Күн бұрын
You've got to be joking
@ashfox7498
Күн бұрын
At this point nothing more than the generals telling him to piss off
@JohnDebasa
Күн бұрын
checks and balances and the population who wouldnt stand for it...if trump was gonna do that, why not do that in his first 4 years?
@Josh-fz9rh
Күн бұрын
Uhhhh the constitution? Which contains 2A
@MrDucksBill
Күн бұрын
The senate can strip the president of power. It's in the constitution
Voters will decide whether they are 'comfortable with Donald Trump'...🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
They referred to the "Wisdom of the Founders" You mean the people who didn't know where the sun went at night?
I have no faith in our politicians or our Supreme Court anymore.
@Reaper-cm4jr
Күн бұрын
Well when an Administration turns loose the power of the Legal System to Jail their Political Opponents that is pretty good evidence that something is F**KED UP!!!!!!
@Inconvenient_NPC
Күн бұрын
Why? Just because you don't want Trump to be President? Grow up. The Supreme Court is perfectly competent.
@johnmshaw49
Күн бұрын
Never did
@johnmshaw49
Күн бұрын
@@Inconvenient_NPCcompetent at what? Being idiots?
@Inconvenient_NPC
Күн бұрын
@@johnmshaw49 - You are basically repeating what Heller6395 said. Trump didn't do anything wrong. Why the hell would you vote for Biden? Look at the state of America. Doesn't it concern you?
It is difficult to believe that Ivy league educated judges cannot make the distinction between a Charlatan and political integrity!
@lilblackduc7312
Күн бұрын
ok cupcake
@user-zd2uv3ss9z
Күн бұрын
They CAN, but they CHOOSE not to!
@ChuckWortman
Күн бұрын
They can and they do. They hide behind their pedigree to advance their political beliefs
@mosesaguirre2392
Күн бұрын
@@ChuckWortman Of course.
When the political party you're affiliated w/ doesn't vote to CONVICT... impeachment is WORTHLESS... and this guy KNOWS it.
The constitution does not work without checks & balances between the 3 branches of gov. Now the executive branch is immune to the judicial branch?
This is a big efffffin delay they wasted our time and kicking it to the lower courts and giving them nothing to work with it useless, I'm disgusted by the majority - thank you justices Sotomayor
@paulmoss7940
Күн бұрын
She is way too far left. Doesn't even know what a woman is.
@1247.cccccc
Күн бұрын
If you paid any attention to the Chevron decision from Friday your comment would be embarrassing to you. How does it feel to be an ignorant naif that trusts CNN?
This country is on the WRONG path. Period.
@glennmerlini2895
Күн бұрын
right dementia joe has got to go
@johnyager1205
Күн бұрын
That’s why we need the SCOTUS to help put it back on the right path.
@nedhill1242
Күн бұрын
It has been for generations because of Democrats. Go read the constitution. It never ever gave this much power to the president or Congress or the federal bureaucracy. America is in fact a fascist country. Thanks primarily to the Democrats and the media with help from establishment Republicans.
@anthonyb.7360
Күн бұрын
Exactly why we need Trump to get us back on track! :D
@stevemcelfresh85
Күн бұрын
Thanks to democrats.
The supreme court knew the truth. God bless America and God bless President Trump 🇺🇸
The jury in this case is not twelve peers, it is the voters and the verdict will come on November 5th.
The Supreme Court taking away women’s rights while simultaneously giving trump unequal rights, seems about right! Right in all senses of the word, as in total bias. We are in serious trouble as a nation.
@recentlyretired
Күн бұрын
As far as I know the Abortion Rights issue went back to the States! Did you not know that ? And in this day and age it took away men’s rights as from what I’m hearing Pregnant people is the new term not Pregnant Women 😂
@Monika-mh2je
Күн бұрын
Before Trump we respected the law the justices,there was a higher ground,but when Trump "touches" something is start to rotten. 😡 look at the congress ,he divided the country, they attacked the Capitol....
@AutismusPrime69
Күн бұрын
No one has the right to kill a baby.
@emerymyers7748
Күн бұрын
@@AutismusPrime69 it’s none of your business what a woman decides is best for her body with her doctor. You don’t have a say over another woman’s body. Manage your ejaculate if you don’t want a kid, or please, abstain!!!
@jm_1214
Күн бұрын
@rethey don't want to know that. It goes against their agendacentlyretired
What about the LAW to rein in a president? Why leave it up to congress? They are so divided among party lines, they can’t get anything done for the American people. It is the official duty of the president to uphold the law, not commit crimes. This is undemocratic and un-American.
@marcusjewelry
22 сағат бұрын
government /parties/agencies have been incorporated. Which means they are in business for the PROFITS. Individuals in a corporation are not held responsible for actions of the corporation.
@charlesvorones3612
18 сағат бұрын
Scott MAGA Jennings knows that Congress will never stop Trump. It's a MAGA majority in the House now! Even if the Dems win the House in Nov., you need 67 senators to vote Trump out of office. When would the Dems ever have 67 senators? With so many rural and western states? Never.
@pawthecowboycorgi
16 сағат бұрын
Reign iN BIDEN FFS
if you cant beat a criminal says alot about ur candidacy lol
How long did it take for Rome to maintain its Republican State before it turned into an Empire? I'm seeing parallels here viewed from the lens of the story of the United States. Damn!! Seeing it happening in modern times and in my life-time is surreal! It pains me as a person living in a democratic way of life here in South East Asia see this situation happening in the United States..
@StudioFocus-hh7dx
Күн бұрын
More like how Hitler took over germany
Scott Jennings “official” opinion is as good as a baseball fan offering political advice.
@bkh8528
Күн бұрын
@jk22222sd Or some random “would be know it all” making some opinions on the internet about baseball and politics………… 😉
@terrycollins9744
Күн бұрын
Trump 2024!! MAGA baby!!
@k16e
Күн бұрын
A really terrible idea for CNN, this Scott Jennings fella
@bkh8528
17 сағат бұрын
@k16e Yea probably better for CNN to just put a bunch of “yes men” on instead……….. ohhhhh that’s right, it’s what CNN usually does……… Well at least CNN has turned on Joe………. those democrats sure like to “eat their own”, huh?… 😉 The mental gymnastics democrats and jumping through hoops they do is astounding hilarious to watch………. Good stuff.
@k16e
17 сағат бұрын
@@bkh8528 Guess we'll never know. But who does does.
How can the supreme court hurt itself Van? They answer to nobody and have lifetime appointment.
@brentkuehne435
Күн бұрын
Yep, kind of like our permanent bureaucratic state. 😮
@iafarm2304
Күн бұрын
Supreme Court "Justices" can also be IMPEACHED & REMOVED from Office.
@bkh8528
Күн бұрын
@David.Lee78 Spoken like a true Ghostbear clan member………. 😉
@bkh8528
Күн бұрын
@David.Lee78 Ohhh and let the internet know when you actually figured out what it means…………. 🤨 Children of the Bear, hearken to my words: Be always vigilant. Learn for yourselves that which your forebears imparted So easily and freely; Demand of yourselves The foresight of Jorgensson And the courage of Tseng; Through them, we are strong. To them a debt is owed, Repaid through loyalty undying and Character unflinching. -the Oath of Acceptance, Clan Ghost Bear
@bkh8528
Күн бұрын
@David.Lee78 Or do you just like the pretty colors of your Clan Ghost Bear avatar??? Cope harder next time, Loremaster ………….. 🥱
CNN lost credibility during presidential debates! It’s a shame that the rest of the commentators that are honest need to to find honest work. Jake Tapper has to live with that.
The government would have to get rid of qualified immunity to get Trump😂. How badly do you want him behind bars😂
STOP GASLIGHTING, SCOTT!
@MsNextgeneration12
Күн бұрын
Biden is out in November. Thanks to the voters
@MajorAnthonyNelson
Күн бұрын
dems hate democracy. they hate the voters
@user-bh1fo2wg1g
Күн бұрын
@@MsNextgeneration12You want King Trump ?
@yakivpopavich
Күн бұрын
@@user-bh1fo2wg1g Yup.
@redstarchrille
Күн бұрын
@@MsNextgeneration12 Biden can now stay in power forever becuse no laws applyes to him.
Enough already with the gaslighting, Scott!
@shaft5
Күн бұрын
#Trump2024 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
@joakos1122
Күн бұрын
what are you talking about can you give an example
@user-un1eg6by4d
Күн бұрын
The gas lighting was don’t by Van Jones
how can anyone claim US jurisdiction is impartial after this ruling ALONG PARTY LINES? and where does this lead to?
We should have faith in the supreme court but thats not happening. Arrest on the homeless because millions have no place to live and some have jobs.
It makes me sick to my stomach that 6 people are ruling America
@stevenfenley9359
Күн бұрын
Amazing comment... we certainly know who ISN'T running the country...
@user-eq6pi2kx1q
Күн бұрын
Haha 2 bad so sad MAGA 2024
@PassdeDutchie
Күн бұрын
Sex People...
@Mikael.formermilitary
Күн бұрын
6 appointed judges are interpreting the law. You should be happy. Biden and Obama have immunity.
@carljackson2233
Күн бұрын
Take an Alka-Seltzer.
Yeah. Who want's to drag a US President into a courtroom each time they attempt a fucking coup.
@Ninja_Skillz
Күн бұрын
What a coup lol He went to the courts. Lost. And then left office in January.
@harryape9059
Күн бұрын
@@Ninja_Skillz ain't for lack of trying
@user-oc8sr3ml9m
Күн бұрын
And or did some gun running to cartels. Like obama.
@Ninja_Skillz
Күн бұрын
@@harryape9059 It’s ok man. I can tell there’s no convincing you of the truth. You’re way too far gone. Just keep listening to the people who have been lying to your face telling you Biden is totally fine lol I’m sure that will continue to work out well for ya.
@ohsnapitsbilly3200
Күн бұрын
There was no 'attempted coup". Nancy Pelosi is responsible for what happened on J6. She even admitted it on video. Blame her!
If none of you wanted this to happen, you should have never pushed it that far
Scott the Court has been highjacked. What crimes does the President need to be immune from?
Justice delayed is Justice denied
@stoggy4839
Күн бұрын
Agreed Biden should be arrested for refusing to secure the border. He should be charged as an accessory to all the crimes the illegals have committed.
@naby214
Күн бұрын
Lol how original. 😆🙄
@PIANOPLAYJAZZ
Күн бұрын
@@naby214 and yet, still appropriate
@martinrayner6466
Күн бұрын
@@naby214 Yet very true, and worth repeating for the uneducated.
@Reaper-cm4jr
Күн бұрын
Many of us feel that way about DOJ waiting SEVEN YEARS to indict Hunter Biden all while letting the Statute of Limitations expire on the most serious charges.
Fear is all these bozos have
@glennmerlini2895
Күн бұрын
I love it,they will have more in november
@richardmesser1091
Күн бұрын
When did the trailer park get internet
@lisadeak5723
Күн бұрын
Republicans AND Democrats ARE Americans. Love thy neighbors.
Yes, "they gave us impeachment." Then the Vongress punted when McConnell said let the criminal courts decide. It's a GOP shell game, and we're sick and tired of this sham!
I can sum-up CNN in one word, "gaslighting"
What about America, not having a king? So a president is equivalent to a king for four years smh...
@jamesjahnke5721
Күн бұрын
Don't say that to Biden he would be totally confused
@kansashoneybadger7899
Күн бұрын
Spare me the drama. The Supremes "granted" Trump (and all following Presidents) nothing more than what virtually every public official in the U.S. already enjoys. You are apparently unaware that the Presidency was the sole public position for which this was not clearly established. Trust me the Badger had practiced law for more than 40 years.
@lilblackduc7312
Күн бұрын
The last really good monarch America had was President Nixon.
@juliehughes2265
Күн бұрын
No Kings have absolute power nowadays . They are constitutional figure heads . But what America is creating is the bed for a modern day Tyrant .
@BladeRunner-2211
Күн бұрын
They don't have a king, Trump can't be in power for his entire lifetime, do keep up.