The comment sections in these videos, are proof enough that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict will be hard to solve.

@ahyaok100

7 жыл бұрын

what you just say about my mom?

@pebblepod30

3 жыл бұрын

12:20 That is very nice, but as the Palestinian interviews showed on this channel, most Palestinians interviewed do not even support the existence of Israel, they seek its destruction & believe in Palestinian exceptionalism**. But if that changed, it would work. **Because all lands in the whole world were conquered at some point. Should Muslims give Istanbul back to the Christians, or so much other lands? Of course not, because everyone else (other than Palestinians who maintain this belief) move on & sacrifice resentment & control for peace.

@pebblepod30

3 жыл бұрын

Basically, look at the Palestinian interviews on this channel. Almost all of them are saying "any chance we get. we will seek the destruction of Israel". It isn't like other cultures who were not taught Exceptionalism & entitlement to the same degree. Like I said, would you demand Muslims to give Constantipole back, or so much more? Of course not. Most lands have been conquered at some point, including by Muslims.

@lampoyo

3 жыл бұрын

Yes, and here we still are, five years later 😷

@pebblepod30

3 жыл бұрын

@@lampoyo You seem to have written a few comments to me, and either there is a bug or you deleted them. Just clarifying: Look, as I think I said, I may have bad data, but that channel is one that appears pretty balanced. I note that most of the responses assumed what I said - it wasn't often said explicitly. As for bias - I grew up with pro-palestinian media - it was the exact opposite for me. I am not pro-Palestinian OR pro-Israel, and I feel that people who take sides (instead of attempting an ethically consistent & practical position) are enabling the conflict to go on forever.

The first guy made some very good points, I liked him.

@malvolio01

8 жыл бұрын

+Sandertie1 When he said the Palestinians live in the past, he hit the nail in the head. Jews remember the past, Palestinians live in it, and that difference makes all the difference. Until Palestinians are willing to move forward, nothing will happen.

@shamanking19042000

8 жыл бұрын

+Sean L. most are

@malvolio01

8 жыл бұрын

Tuber... I wish that were true. But that hasn't been my experience. And according to most polls, the majority of Palestinians still want a state that includes the land that's now Israel. They need to understand that compromise involves both parties making sacrifices.

@shamanking19042000

8 жыл бұрын

Sean L. Well guess what it is true. There has been some statistics showing it to be true .

@shaharbaladi8694

8 жыл бұрын

+Rezk Mohammed you hate us but your govement didnt support your lovely palestinian. really stupid are you...

The bloke at 5:46 hit the nail on the head. The problem is always, at heart, education.

@boyjames888

7 жыл бұрын

The matter is that there are different types of education and that few have fully completed one type of it and even fewer have it all. But it'd be good if us all uneducated masses would shut the fuck up to avoid mass conflicts and let the few wise guys who remain do a peaceful thinking, if ever possible. It is still improbable in a democratic world of course, anyways

@seriousbees

3 жыл бұрын

He's got some ok opinions but its funny how he took it so personally when the guy accused him of being a part of the problem for living in an illegal settlement. You can be a little moral philosopher all you want until the issues start touching you personally. Then its "me me me"

@mortenrobinson

3 жыл бұрын

That's why I support a one-state solution. At least a temporary one-state solution. All palestinian and israeli children ought to be going to the same schools together, schools with both palestinian and israeli teachers. They shouldn't be educated/brainwashed separately, they should be educated together. That's the solution to the conflict, to breed a generation of palestinian and israeli children who grow up together, get to play together, get to know each other and just don't get taught to hate one another.

@trollnerd

3 жыл бұрын

The hilarious irony of this conflict is you'd think that two people who were both kicked out of their homeland and just want to return to where they came from could empathize with eachother and find a way to live together. I think the Israelis are there to be honest. The animosity is mostly coming from the Palestinian side.

@mortenrobinson

3 жыл бұрын

@@trollnerd you can hardly say that the Israelis have been kicked out of their homeland. The modern day Israelis stole that land from the arabs. That's just a fact! Some jewish folk were exiled more than 2000 years ago by the romans, but a lot of things happen in 2000 years, especially to a people that is constantly migrating. Modern day Israelis are not exclusively descended from the jews who were exiled from Israel, they are descended from various different peoples. There is a reason why jews from Africa are black, why jews from central and northern Europe are white, why jews from Asia range from indian traits to epicanthal folds and so on. Any israeli looking back 2000 years would find that only a small percentage of their ancestors were jews exiled by the romans. They would even find that they are in fact ALSO descended from the romans who invaded the region back then. Israelis are not native to that region today! The palestinians are. And the palestinian exile didn't happen more than 2000 years ago, it happened like yesterday and is in fact still ongoing. Btw, all non-african peoples have a history in that region. The ancestors of all non-african peoples migrated out of Africa at some point in time, and they ALL came through the holy land because that is the only way out of Africa. They came through that region way way before there were any jews and anything called judaism.

From a philosophical point of view, no solution is a solution... I love that!

@EnigmaHood

10 жыл бұрын

***** Sure

@fenotipobombay

10 жыл бұрын

that's why philosofy has never solved nothing.

@EnigmaHood

10 жыл бұрын

fenotipobombay That's why I love it! :D

@TheChutzpahGirl

9 жыл бұрын

***** Times change ... watch the next couple of years

@TheChutzpahGirl

9 жыл бұрын

zaxx19 Israel can only ever exist as a military state, and no military state lasts for ever. You will be forced to abandon the entire West Bank.

I just came from Corey's vid where Palestinians answer the question. The difference is notable. Many there advocated mass deportation of Israelis. While here people seem genuinely vexed and searching for a solution. Israelis also offered up criticisms of themselves which I didn't hear from the Palestinians.

@tzvitaylor3168

3 жыл бұрын

There's actually a second Palestinian video where they do submit more cooperative solutions. Peace to all

@odaenathus7825

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, the thief wants the owner to compromise.

@BROLY__

2 жыл бұрын

@@odaenathus7825 they fought for it keep crying as river.

@r7ahtesham885

2 жыл бұрын

@@BROLY__ Fought against women and children? Keep crying

@BROLY__

2 жыл бұрын

@@r7ahtesham885 they got kill bcoz there men's were hiding behind them.

I love these videos. I'm an Emirati Muslim from Dubai and all I want is peace..

@selenamarino5203

10 жыл бұрын

Preach. :)

@abdishakurxabeeb9110

8 жыл бұрын

+Selena Marino shut up what peace you are talking about ???????????????Emirates and Palestine are the same!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! you have no idea what you are talking about !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! they are suffering 1948 until now shup up

@anzhelamagdalene6472

6 жыл бұрын

Abdishakur Xabeeb people whom love peace will get happiness immortally.

@cecil123

6 жыл бұрын

+Abdishakur Xabeeb Yes, suffering under Islamic colonial apartheid occupation. Free the middle east from Islam for world peace.

@scumbagmgtowmonk4251

5 жыл бұрын

you mean from israel the real cancer you just dont have enough guts to say it cause you're afraid fucking coward.

These are really informative videos, it's nice to see what the citizens think. Thank you for you work

Quoting the guy at @05:49, so true. "18 year olds talking nonsense based on cliches they've been hearing from their elders"... Education is the solution to all such problems of hatred in the world, not just between these 2 nations. Very good answer by that guy.

@somegirl4631

6 жыл бұрын

English Rain I live in Israel and my teachers always thought me that everyone is equal. 😏

@somegirl4631

6 жыл бұрын

SH. T well I'm an Israeli and if you're a palastain athaist you must be an Israeli Arab (from Israel borders) or from Judea and Samaria. the palastains in the Gaza strip are simply much more radical than you my friend. till today I mate only one gazan that didn't wish death to all my family simply because I'm Jewish. it's a sad true.

@somegirl4631

6 жыл бұрын

SH. T it's same for both sides. ahaelan ☺

@Starry_Night_Sky7455

6 жыл бұрын

Same thought.

@theisraelig5162

5 жыл бұрын

This guy is the furthest away from "educated" if anything all he's doing is talking nonsense based on cliches he's heard from his elders... Saying the settlements are a cancer in the conflict is retarded, "Palestine" doesn't allow Jews in so the only way in is through settlements, just think about Hebron, An original Jewish city with Jewish ancient graves, thinking that would be under Arab anti semitic rule is naive, Just because the UN made declarations (that the Arabs declined anyways) doesn't mean the UN made any sense when it came down to it, the fact is the "palestinians" are the only ones stopping the peace agreement from occurring, An agreement can come any day when they decide they respect Jews living on the same land as they do.

As an Israeli that shares the most common opinion in this country,let me tell you this. The old guy,who's a hero by the way,the young guy with the beer,and the guy talking last are the opinion of this nation as a whole. That's the truth. Love us,hate us,we don't care.

@philipkozely3768

10 ай бұрын

Didn't the Nazis say and acted the same ?

@1995yuda

10 ай бұрын

@@philipkozely3768 Is there enough oxygen reaching that small brain of yours at any given moment?

@captain2ahab

7 ай бұрын

"Love us, hate us, we don't care" Is the motto of every criminal bastard

first guy = legend

@soyboy3833

5 жыл бұрын

He's probably the only realistic person I've heard in probably 20 of these gay videos. A very reasonable and clearly good man. This channel... Why interview people who barely want to talk or even know what they're talking about. Get good, Son.

@daviddorante3283

5 жыл бұрын

#israelcompromise

@jaredcurtis481

5 жыл бұрын

1q1q1q981 no cause he says the Palestinians rejected the partition of Palestine but the Jews still moved in. It’s illegal occupation and you expect the Palestinians to go peacefully, would you be happy if you got kicked out of your home? Think about it.

@andrerothweiler9191

5 жыл бұрын

I was pro Palestine but now I am not. Look Syria, Lybia, Iraq.... Palestinians will never stop, even if you will give them 99% of Israel they will always want more and more. Palestinians live better in Israel and have more freedom than other Arabs in Arabic countries. The only solution is to annex West Bank (which is horrible) and deport all Palestinians who are against state of Israel.

@bruhnolol3867

4 жыл бұрын

@@jaredcurtis481 Imagine your'e a 10 years old boy and some people took your house would you still complain about it when you will be 80 years old ? or would you move on?

what an awesome work here!! thanks for taking the time to record these testimonys

This was really one of my favorite of Corey's videos you have made. People actually understood the question and answered it thoughtfully.

@ElectronicHouseFlash

Жыл бұрын

Jews are really intelligent People, especially the first one. Corey is doing a very great job in this. I hope one day all the jewish and palestinian extremists will get just thrown out of entire Earth.

@captain2ahab

7 ай бұрын

@@ElectronicHouseFlash No, they are as intelligent and as stupid as everyone else.

I really respect the guy who clearly said “this is wrong we need to withdraw from all the occupied territory” he’s so in peace with him self which is clear in his answer!

@manishas9411

3 жыл бұрын

I didn't understand what he was saying. He wanted Israelis to withdraw from all of the land, so where would the Jews go? I wish he was asked a follow-up question of where would the Jews go if that was done... It was a really bold statement.

@thetruth9494

3 жыл бұрын

@@manishas9411 No what he said is that Israel should retreat from the occupied territories.

@chadchadson3894

3 жыл бұрын

He said withdraw from the land and 'see how things go' as if the neighbours who hate israel more than anything would not still want further concessions until Israel no longer exists. He is a naive leftist tree hugger.

@thetruth9494

3 жыл бұрын

@@chadchadson3894 Exactly what Israel has been doing since it was awarded land. It was not content with what it was given but expanded more and more. Because that is the actual aim of the Zionists - to take full control over what it erroneously considers its land. Just like it did in the Old Testsment - stealing lsnd from its rightful occupiers and exterminating them using God as an excuse.

@chadchadson3894

3 жыл бұрын

@@thetruth9494 The israelis agreed to the UN proposal in 1948 but it was rejected by the arabs who declared war. So its actually the arabs who are the uncompromising ones not israelis.

The irony of Phil Collins "Paradise" playing in the background as Yoav talks about how things are not paradise is not lost on me

Some good thoughtful replies. Thank you Corey for your efforts.

These videos are really interesting, thanks for making them!

respect to the drunk white kid, who wants to educate both sides and stop the hate

@CantStopTheBox

9 жыл бұрын

luay Guevara It's easy to talk about peace when you're the one in power with the advantage. The kid is living in a settlement illegally taken from its Palestinian owners and is talking about how everyone needs to be educated and peaceful. Take that into a different scenario. You have a house, someone comes in, forces you to leave and then starts telling you to be peaceful when you're trying to take back your rightful property. Then the media paints him as the good guy for trying to be peaceful and resolve the situation (which ends in him keeping YOUR house and YOUR land while you get nothing) and they paint you as a terrorist and a fanatic for wanting your rightful property back. Both sides of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict are wrong. They both commit horrors, and it's a very hard subject to civilly discuss, but I find it very hard to agree with someone saying he is right and other people are wrong while living in an illegally-appropriated settlement.

@somegirl4631

6 жыл бұрын

Pat Micucci not exactly. before 1800 report show no one was in Israel, but with the first alia of jews came also the "great Arabs immegretion" from the surrounding areas (from 1800 to 1948) and the palastains nation were invented by yasser Arafat in 1967.

@joannaszulc1496

5 жыл бұрын

he's not white, he's jewish

@jigajiga3886

5 жыл бұрын

the Jewish

@dodongdan1848

5 жыл бұрын

@@CantStopTheBox there always be a two state solution you know. It is still on the table. The arabs started the 6 day war and lost, and now are crying about the consequences. You hit a hornet's nest, you get stung, and you complain?

Massive respect to Yoav!

very nice video. very educational , and a positive work

If you watch also the Palestinian answers to this same question, you understand why so many Israelis have given up on hope for peace in their lifetime. The Palestinians want Israel to be wiped from the map. I always was in favor of the 2 states for 2 peoples solution as well as return to the '67 borders, but how can you make it work when the other side wants us to 'go back to Europe and the US'? The irony of it is that a lot of good-hearted people hate or condemn Israel because of its 'apartheid and genocidal' policies without understanding that the other side would wipe us out if they could.

@lucabriatore7891

2 ай бұрын

I defend the existance of Israel, but Israeli should start to realize what a tragedy was the foundation of Israel in 1948. It's like the Celts going back to France and establish a Celt state in half of it. Or the Etruscans going back to northern Italy, the Greeks going back to southern Italy, or the american natives asking for half of the States....

The first guy had the most realistic view about the conflict.

Yoav ( at 5:53 ) and Uri ( at 11:59) . These guys were the best. We need people like them who keep aside hate and think of a solution . Life is too short to hate each other people. Much love from an Indian muslim

@captain2ahab

7 ай бұрын

Yoav is a settler, LOL !

I liked the guy who spoke of education and the guy who wanted to pull out of occupied territories as a first step.

@gili41

2 жыл бұрын

the guy who wanted to pull out of occupied territories as a first step is stupid and dont understand that this is the first step to loose all of israel, thx god the rest of the jewish are not stupid like him

Its interesting how the views of Israeli's in this video and Palestinians in the other video are in complete contrast. One party wants war and the other opts for peace...

I think they live in settlements because they are government-subsidized and thus there are financial benefits to the residents. If I lived there, I would feel like I was living in a military outpost.

The dude @11:55 shows compassion. If you start by showing love, you begin the process of peace

@pebblepod30

3 жыл бұрын

12:20 That is very nice, but as the Palestinian interviews showed on this channel, most Palestinians interviewed do not even support the existence of Israel, they seek its destruction & believe in Palestinian exceptionalism**. But if that changed, it would work. **Because all lands in the whole world were conquered at some point. Should Muslims give Istanbul back to the Christians, or so much other lands? Of course not, because everyone else (other than Palestinians who maintain this belief) move on & sacrifice resentment & control for peace.

@pebblepod30

3 жыл бұрын

Basically, look at the Palestinian interviews on this channel. Almost all of them are saying "any chance we get, we will seek the destruction of Israel". It isn't like other cultures who were not taught Exceptionalism & entitlement to the same degree. But the Jews here are not seeking the destruction of Palestinians, they only want peace, and would even give up some land if it helped (which it probably wouldn't, & be taken back). Like I said, would you demand Muslims to give Constantipole back, or so much more? Of course not. Most lands have been conquered at some point, including by Muslims.

@pebblepod30

3 жыл бұрын

@Cat Cat Your right - I stand corrected: Palestinians & Zionists BOTH feel they are unique Exceptions - Zionists in the past, palestinians today. But would you also admit the same mistake as well? Do you still believe in Palestinian Expceptionalism? Or support perpetual war for the next generation on that basis?

@hishamadnan689

3 жыл бұрын

@@pebblepod30 Could you explain why Israel became a country? Why cannot Jewish people live under Palestinian government like the ones that were there before 1948?

@pebblepod30

3 жыл бұрын

@@hishamadnan689 We both know & probably agree that Zionists came & stole Israel & it was unjustifiable. But it is also true what I said PICK ONE: Unending war or negotiate peace where everyone can live together & forgive the people in the past who created the problem, and those that continued it.

The starting point of a true discussion must be the neutralization of every sympathy, antipathy and prejudice.

The first guy summarized everything that needs to be said in short about the conflict

The second to last person give an accurate assessment, militarily no nation in ME can fight Israel or Threaten it. Issue of right of return of Palestinians can be solved with compensation for their houses.

The first man seems a good person, but the irony of an Israeli complaining about Palestine ignoring UN resolutions is a bit much for me.

@uriyah8479

2 жыл бұрын

they literally waged war on us because they didn't like the UN resolution... nothing Israel has done can even be compared to this

2:53 "So we have a problem that Palestinians always want to return to the past" The basis of Zionism and foundation of Israel is returning to the past. how could you expect Palestinians to forget and forgive what you did to them 30 years ago, which continued up till now, while you didn't forget what some people 2000 years ago did not to you, to your very far ancestors?

@promix3

4 жыл бұрын

mot hakimi there’s no palestinins, its arabs

@derherrdirektor9686

4 жыл бұрын

@@promix3 For gods sake, ethnicities define themselves. You could say, there are no Germans, Netherlandish, Dutch, English, French, Danish and so forth, they're all Germanic or all "Arian" and you'd be as good a person as Hitler. Zionism created Palestinians like the Third Reich created Austrians.

@dorazati4905

4 жыл бұрын

@@derherrdirektor9686 The ancient israel included some parts of jordan, west bank and gaza. we (jews) are ready to give up on west bank, gaza and jorden parts. so the palestinian should take the west bank and gaza and give up the rest. thats the solution, its not fair and it will hurt but this is the most realistic solution.

@avishaybm6222

4 жыл бұрын

@@derherrdirektor9686 you do know Austria exist centurys before germany was even a thing the nazis didn't invent them

@johntheos

3 жыл бұрын

Only 20 likes for the only honest comment on this thread. THAT's sad.

So basically their proposal is in most cases 2 state solution where every Palestinian must have a helicopter if he wants to travel longer than 10 kilometers??? Yes, we can all agree that Israelis are just mentioning 2 state solution because they know that it is impossible because of the settlements. That is just a cover story to keep the expansion going. If they really want 2 states they would give some proposal that is not totally unacceptable, and where Palestinians would live like a human beings. That can only happen if there is no walls and checkpoints on Palestinian side. There are currently roads in the West Bank where (if you are Palestinian) you travel about 25 km for 5-6 hours.

@dogbert52

2 жыл бұрын

Perhaps the solution would be to do to the palarabs what they plan to do to je ws.

May Allah bestow peace on both sides. May there be only love love and love on both sides.

The problem isn't Geographical, this is why even if Israel will give Jedua and Sameria to the Arabs like it did in Gaza it will make peace. Because they have no desire to live in peace with Israel (like the Egyptian wanted Peace) . At the end, the Palestinians has many opportunities to have a state and they declined all of them. Because the Palestinian Nerative was invented for one reason only...to have a human weapons to destroy Israel... And when you don't respect one existence... Its all dommes

@ef2718

2 жыл бұрын

Read your first sentence again. *doomed (Not dommes)

Thank You Yoav.

Isn't it so sad that while the guy from 5:45 is explaining, "Another Day In Paradise" by Phil Collins is playing on the background?

The Palestinians people as a culture, historically always have been occupied. Even their given name "Palestinian" was given by occupations that changed over history. But that name was given to both local Arabs and Jewish who always co-existed on that land. The only difference that happened in 1948 is that there was enough migration of Jewish people from around the world that brought and invested enough resources to build a government and a nation. Many Arabs chose to stay and now considered Israeli Arabs. Many chose to go to war and still call themselves Palestinians. I think today's Palestinians lack the education and knowledge of their own history. Many Israelis do to, they are taught to love their country but not respect the Palestinian right to coexist as well. While Palestinians today are taught that this land is their's only and does not belong to Jewish people as well. But at the core of their majority they don't have the capacity to build a civilized nation and a government, they never had at no point in history. Education is the key and the very first step for both sides to begin to acknowledge and respect each other enough to start a practical and a realistic conversation. How we go about it in a a way that ensures the safety and cooperation of all the people that's a whole another conversation.

Sadly there is no human solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The Palestinians would like to go back to the pre-1948 borders, meaning they get every inch of modern-day Israel and want the "colonizing Jews" to leave and go back to the lands from where they came from. That's never going to happen! Israel on multiple occasions agreed to give up the West Bank, Gaza, and East Jerusalem but it's never enough for them. Therefore, only Messiah will bring peace.

@edwinlucianofrias1643

3 жыл бұрын

Won’t the Messiah be human?

I agree education and enlightenment is the most important to solve this conflict and taking down political interests on both side, politics is always the cause of conflicts and nothing else, education mostly compensate wrong political interests and attitudes.

I hope Yuav is doing well :))) He sounds very educated and genuinely cares about a solution that'd be helpful for both sides

The Israeli Jews seem to wish for peace and to coexist with the Palestinian Arabs much much more than the vice versa.

@ef2718

2 жыл бұрын

Huge disparity between these cultures.

@philipkozely3768

9 ай бұрын

​@@ef2718huge disparity in truth

First, thank you so much for this and other videos! We should spread them far and wide. Exactly as a few commenters have said, I especially like, the man, ironically living in a settlement, talking wisely about educating children for wisdom and not hate, and the final interviewee, suggesting that Israel withdraw from the occupied territories. But all of the interviews are fascinating and you can learn so much from this. Unlike the news we have been getting, you, Corey, are sharing what people really think.... this is great work. Thank you so much.

That's the hardest question I've ever heard.

No religions, no problem. That’s the best solution

7:40 very clever gentleman.

"I fought in 3 Wars but I want Peace..." this basically resumes everything

@captain2ahab

7 ай бұрын

The winner always wants peace. The loser wants his land back

@markusk9080

6 ай бұрын

@@captain2ahab Losers don't get anything, losers don't deserve anything, especially if they are as primitive, vile and backward as Palestinians and Arabs. Deal with it and submit to the superior culture or be prepared to continue living like the losers you are.

Yoav, the first Israeli that I agree with! Education is the key.

Can you ask these questions in Hamas controlled territories?

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert: _If there is no two-state solution Israel will end up in a South Africa-like situation_ And then Olmert said, _if Israel ends up in a South Africa-like situation, that will be the end of Israel_

@josephsvennson5694

5 жыл бұрын

Meaning?

@Dk-ns3ge

4 жыл бұрын

Joseph Svennson Israel will become an apartheid state and that will be the end

@matthummel8306

3 жыл бұрын

@@Dk-ns3ge with the jewish nation state law which imply jews superiority have been passed so israel is already an apartheid state.

@Dk-ns3ge

3 жыл бұрын

@@matthummel8306 Not really considering all Israeli citizens, regardless of ethnicity and religion are protected by law against discrimination, and enjoy all the same rights. There’s more protection of rights and equality than Islamic republics.

@matthummel8306

3 жыл бұрын

@@Dk-ns3ge do you even know about jewish nation state law that have been passed in 2018?

Peace on earth love on earth coming soon dont believe me just watch

@cmtiger

10 жыл бұрын

Say that to Putin

@scriptaman2888

10 жыл бұрын

CmTiger ahahahahah :( nice pun, sad truth

@anzhelamagdalene6472

6 жыл бұрын

MBCustoms1 you believe that will happen

Religion really is a breath of fresh air. Solution, we could tell them the truth about their crazy little pocketbooks.

Cont....If the people are too head strong to come to an agreement then a 3rd party needs to step in and take matters in their own hands. I truly believe this.

@Sippy309

8 жыл бұрын

Truly the rest of the world is sick of this!

@Sippy309

8 жыл бұрын

+Ariesticnig You say the rest of the world should stop paying attention?! Are you kidding me?!! Look at the crisis in Europe. Your damn right I would trust a foreigner to act as mediator! At this point what difference could it possibly make?! What more damage could they do than that which has already been done. There needs to be a mediator, a go-between. Someone who could possibly neutralize the situation. Maybe you should ask yourself how long this crisis has been going on. Europe will close its borders if this keeps going on. They have had enough, and Refugees can go further east with their fellow brethren.

@Sippy309

8 жыл бұрын

+Ariesticnig Time will certainly tell

I say this as a relative of a ex IRA man,in response to the man at the beginning saying Israels do not lynch did the Irgun not lynch British soldiers Clifford Martin and Mervyn Paice in their war for independence. I mean to lynch kill is one thing but denying it is another and i would doubt this man forgot this piece history with ease

@ethanfarber8201

8 жыл бұрын

+Cormac Finn What he is saying about the Ramallah "lynching" is actually much more sanitized than how he knows it happened. What happened in Ramallah was not actually a lynching, and he is underplaying it because the reality is so horrible it defies imagination. What actually happened in Ramallah was the crowd literally tore apart the bodies of two Israelis, disemboweled them and chewed on and ate their internal organs. You can Google pictures of it, if you have a strong stomach.

@cormacfinn6430

8 жыл бұрын

Yeah i Just found it, pretty gruesome and terrible. But still what the Palestinians to the Israelis does not take away from what they did to the Brits. Keep in mind i don't "pick sides" in the the conflict i only hope to see the truth and put things in perspective.

@ethanfarber8201

8 жыл бұрын

Cormac Finn Not comparable. The British had no right to be in Israel in the first place. Every British target was military, and the Jews were never sadistic for its own sake. The Jews and Arabs both lay claim to the same piece of land, both have some kind of connection to the region, but the British had no business there at all, and the Jews had every right to remove them.

@danielfriedman3007

8 жыл бұрын

+Cormac Finn An underground group hanged them. It was not sanctioned in any way by representatives of the future state of Israel. And in response, the British troops killed 5 Jews in Tel Aviv and injured others. There were also riots in British cities against Jewish communities. Obviously I don't agree with Ethan's attempt at justifying it, but it is a far stretch to compare that hanging to the lynching of these Israelis. The PA didn't just allow it to occur, but actively encouraged it.

@cormacfinn6430

8 жыл бұрын

Oh yeah i'm hip what happen in Ramallah and when the Irgun lynched the soldiers are not the same. Ramallah was a angry mob spured on by the authorities. What the Irgun did was an act of terror to weaken the British soldiers moral it was strategic and organized. Much different. Im not trying to necessarily say the Irgun were evil or any thing i'm just trying to put the old man comments in context. There was no official Israeli state at that time it came about because the Irguns fight for independence don't forget this.

If someone come to your home and occupy 70% of it's area by force and ask you to make peace... what would you do?

@bilalbataineh8367

3 жыл бұрын

he should give the half of it :D

@LordNoob-e

3 жыл бұрын

@@bilalbataineh8367 you are an idiot

@jessecohen4517

3 жыл бұрын

Except if they gave it back, Israel would be destroyed. Would you commit suicide to appease your enemies?

@Plobq

2 жыл бұрын

@@jessecohen4517 Occupies land, kills Palestinians and steals their homes and dignity. Wonders why they would be destroyed LOL take some accountability!

@jessecohen4517

2 жыл бұрын

@@Plobq Arabs were attacking jews in british palestine before the state was founded. Get you timeline right pal

This was exactly 10 years ago 👏🏼

Dude who starts talking at 5:46, with the her in his hand-you are fucking cool! Post here if you are in Tel Aviv, I'll buy you a Goldstar.

I wish more Israelis thought like Yoav and Uri.

@gil6875

5 жыл бұрын

Lol me too, and im from israel

@barilish

4 жыл бұрын

Most israelis think that...

@5:47 shit i've never wanted to shake a Israeli's hand more than at that point in the video. I wish there was more level headed people like him (on both sides). @12:05 this man too. this man for president!.. Every Israeli and every Palestinian has the God given right for peace.

@godxstreaks411

5 жыл бұрын

I can tell that a lot of the people in israel think like that, but the goverment dont think like that.

@uriyah8479

2 жыл бұрын

actually, the third peace negotiations, between olmert and abu-mazen was just like he said (the Galilee was conquered from Syria in yom kipur war so other than that) but the palestinians refused, so...

Guy at 5:41 is hella smart. Enjoyed his conversation.

The first guy literally predicted the current conflict. Damn sir

@WUB0105

5 ай бұрын

yes, he got in all the points. Also the comparison to Syria, and the one mill refugees. And I believe half a million dead (syrians).

12:12 That guy has a point!!!!

@hagitaleinikov8643

3 жыл бұрын

How? We withdrew from Gaza and they started shooting rockets !! SMH

I could tell that the first man was from Poland, because i am as well and i could hear the accent :D Shalom!

@SalemPhiladelphia

6 жыл бұрын

Chris S. Go back to your country

@bakedpotatoes5545

3 жыл бұрын

@@SalemPhiladelphia we dont have a country

@SalemPhiladelphia

3 жыл бұрын

@@bakedpotatoes5545 He is from Poland. Go back there.

The statements of the guy at 5:44 sound true. Maybe a wrong education is a huge part of the problem. But therefore I don´t understand, how he can live in the settlements of the West Bank. Thank you Corey Gil-Shuster.

@MrFazeFaze

9 жыл бұрын

Maybe it's because he lives in the settlements that helped him make that claim. would him not living in the settlements help? His accommodation would just be occupied by another israeli. If you want to solve a problem, you have to deal with the core reasons for the problem rather than the symptoms.

@1995yuda

9 жыл бұрын

+Leonard Dietrich I share his opinion and I lived there too. He already answered that question:he said he's taking advantage of the situation,as did I. Living there is financially easy. He understand that settlements are not the cause and therefore it dosen't matter if we live there or not. I agree with the last person too,by the way.

MASSIVE respect to yoav

These comments by the Israelis are so much more perceptive & realistic than all the Palestinian answers except two. I also totally forgot how Jews have been in Palestine for many hundreds of years, and also accepted the UN plan in 1948, and Palestinians started the war, not them. On top of that, all lands on earth were conquered at some point, yet everyone else moved on except Palestinians.

@pebblepod30

3 жыл бұрын

@Cat Cat I already responded to you, see you in the other section. Yes, I made a mistake here -Zionists believed in their exceptionalism in the past, Palestinians believe in their Exceptionalism today, and are taught to by their elders. I see both as errors. Do you then also acknowledge they are both Exceptionalism, both entitled positions? My position is that it doesn't matter what dead people did, it matters to create something good today. if someone is born in country X, then they belong there. I don't support the idea of a person having racial or religious guilt or resentment or entitlement based on what other people did of the group. Esp if they are long dead. Do you support that?

@pebblepod30

3 жыл бұрын

@Cat Cat But if people support gaining land (Palestinian or Israeli) by using violence, then they don't have much grounds to complain when they get rocket attacks. Do you get my point about the silliness of conflicting ancestoral land claims? All land on earth has been conquested many times. Would u demand Turkey give back Istanbul? Or honour ancestoral land claims? It guarantees perperual conflict.

@pebblepod30

3 жыл бұрын

@Cat Cat Btw Jews - just one correction - Jews also have an unbroken indigenous connection to the land (not that i support any ancestoral land claims anywhere).

@pebblepod30

3 жыл бұрын

@Cat Cat Being more or less powerful doesn't automatically make something right or wrong. Palestinians alao oppress the Jews, they are just limited in their power.

@pebblepod30

3 жыл бұрын

@Cat Cat And Isn't it right to oppress & restrict people until they give up destroying others (that is what jail is for)? What is an alternative? Likewise, if i stood for destroying others, it would be right for the Authority to OPPRESS ME UNTIL I STOPPED. Im not in hypocrisy - same rules for everyone. But when Israel does more land grabs, yes I agree that is unjustifiable and means perpetual war too.

11:55 "give it a shot" Theres still hope...

@Gabi-hv2xc

3 жыл бұрын

That was a stupid reply.."Give it a shot" pls do not take a chance on my life. I do not take shots I only go on "For sure"

@G00dwILLHuNt1n9

3 жыл бұрын

@@Gabi-hv2xc Ha! Dna of a coward

@Gabi-hv2xc

3 жыл бұрын

@@G00dwILLHuNt1n9 DNA of a suicidle in the name of ....I love life more than death..do u?

@G00dwILLHuNt1n9

3 жыл бұрын

@@Gabi-hv2xc You love killing children in the name of flag and in your delusional state of mind think you have some sort of a moral high ground. Yeah that's about correct

@Gabi-hv2xc

3 жыл бұрын

Still a stupid reply

The last dude knows what he's talking about !

The question must be: Shall you leave the land? as it was before the 48? if yes why? if not why?

8:40 what a lad

@omarabouhassan6673

9 жыл бұрын

ofek zelig Very balanced view on his part, I respect that.

@MobHeataEnt

9 жыл бұрын

ofek zelig He lives in the West Bank settlement. There are more settlements being built. Soon, they wouldn't have to worry about a solution because Palestinians will all be wiped out.

@principal_optimism

9 жыл бұрын

Vital Mark Egypt? Jordan? They all came from trans-Jordan anyway.

@principal_optimism

9 жыл бұрын

Bilal Kh It's not about genetic ancestry. I have never understood what genetics mean. My own mother went through a phase when she read all of our family tree and did some research. Turns out we are both descended from Prince John, the brother of Richard the Lionheart. Great. Nice story bro. But it really means nothing to me today. Even my grandparents. Idk. They're dead, they're gone. Spiritual ancestry however does mean something. To be in the land of the founders of your religion. Those whose stories and lives are told of in your book. That to me means more than any blood relation. Israel, alike Mecca, is a religious city. Israel is a land for Jews, not Israelis. If I was the prime minister I'd probably reject an applicant who was descended from King David himself if he was a Buddhist. I mean. There would be other implications in the decision, but he'd rank lower than someone who'd just converted to Judaism and whose ancestry was all contained within Japan.

@kjhgd1357

9 жыл бұрын

+ofek zelig I can't believe your reasoning man. Jews, who are European by majority, deserve to go live in the place they like the most. What about the humans who are already living their? Ppsshht I dunno let them go anywhere else!

How ignorant it is that the man (3:02) saying that the palestinians always talk about the past and are referring to the 1948 war. The jews are actually the once talking about the past by referring 3000years the land was promised to them.

Wish there was a link to the equivalent Palestinian question vids.

@WUB0105

5 ай бұрын

Palestinians: What is your solution to the conflict?, Palestinians: What is your solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict? + corey gil-shuster

5:50 that guy is like my brother, he lives in a settlement too yet he is against the settlements.

Would an Israeli accept a U.N. resolution that gives the best land to Palestinians?

@malvolio01

8 жыл бұрын

+hamnose I take it you haven't been to Israel. When you get a few miles away from the coastal plain, with the exception of the mtns, it's pretty much ALL desert. And the most barren area (the Negev) is in Israel, not in the territories.

@hamnose

8 жыл бұрын

+Sean L. No I have never been to Israel. But a map of the original state of Israel shows that Jews were given the better land. Looking at the question another way. Bad land or good land, would an Israeli, or would you accept a U.N. resolution that throws you out of your home? Another question: Why should a Palestinian Christian (over 40% of those displaced by the resolution were Christians) or a Muslim have to give up their home when it was mostly Germans, Poles and Croats who murdered the Jewish people?

@malvolio01

8 жыл бұрын

+hamnose Most Jews living in Israel today (about 60%) have no connection to Europe. They, or their families, were kicked out of Arab countries. Where would you suggest they go??

@hamnose

8 жыл бұрын

+Sean L. That's tragic but that isn't what I asked. Answer the fucking question: Would you accept a U.N. resolution that throws you out of your home?

@malvolio01

8 жыл бұрын

+hamnose Who was thrown out of their homes again??

The first guy is funny that the arabs started the war, i guess he never heard of plan dalet. He says he wants it to be like Europe and the middle east is barbaric. Go back to Europe if you Ashkenazi are like europeans. In 67 isreal struck first. For there to be peace isreal has to look at its actions critically and come from a different approach.

@nadavstein4471

3 жыл бұрын

I realise that I’m writing these three years too late, but I think you know why European Jews fled from Europe, because let’s just say the throughout history it never went well for as

@r7ahtesham885

2 жыл бұрын

@@nadavstein4471 Everyone knows why, but the real question is why did they pull a Nazi and kick out Palestinians instead of living alongside them? People say that Palestinians rejected them staying there, but they don't understand that the reason is because zionists wouldn't live alongside them. Just by themselves

@nadavstein4471

2 жыл бұрын

@@r7ahtesham885 honestly, I can’t tell you. I mean, there definitely was Palestinian violent resistance to the creation of Israel but i don’t think that justifies kicking innocents out of their homes, by the way I’m sure you know that many never left and later got Israeli citizenships. Now we can only hope for peace to stop the bloodshed

@r7ahtesham885

2 жыл бұрын

@@nadavstein4471 That's very reasonable and nice of you to say that. The problem wasn't israelis coming to Palestine, but the problem was the government creating an apartheid state. Just a normal state would have OK. But we both can agree. It's still an apartheid.... Thank you for saying something that makes sense and is true... Hopefully there's peace ✌️

The translation is not 100% accurate. There were many words and phrases that were mistranslated.

By the number of UN laws israel has violated it's baffling that an israeli would make it as a reference since even the legality of its statehood has been disputed by it. It's such a complicated subject that realistically "conversations" doesn't solve and after diving a lot in this subject, i simply believe there is no solution where both would be satisfied even if peace is established permanently the grudges and hatred will not disappear for a few generations and the damage will never be restored and they are in fact now the new jews, injustice wise.

@ezerma1

8 ай бұрын

It is very interesting to hear such an accusations while Israel is surrounded by dictatorships like Syria, Egypt, Jordan etc. Most of western countries were astablished after kicking natives and eliminate them de facto. Israel offered the Palasinians a real chance to astablish a state but unfortunatly, the Palastinians inv3sted only in tunnels and rockets.. The us army and nato wiped out entire vilages upon their people, that happend in Iraq also. Not to mention Russia in Ukraine. The double standard and the hypocrisy from your words screams out to the heavens.

the first guy criticising Palestinians not sticking to the 1967 border? Israel doesn't even stick to the 1967 border itself, Israel has pushed far beyond the 1967 border. I don't believe one country can keep occupying more of other countries' land just because it won the war. For example, China fought against Vietnam and India before, and Chinese army went deep into Vietnamese and Indian border, but China drew back! I just can't understand why Israelis think they have the right to keep taking more land.

@bardockobama5495

7 жыл бұрын

Because the arabs attacked them first, so they took some lands, and that's normal, in almost all wars, the one who wins takes some Land

@barrenmicro4024

7 жыл бұрын

yea we live in a jungle

@ahyaok100

7 жыл бұрын

the difference is because the terrain would leave israel too vulnerable for attack. they would be fired on from the mountains. it would be stupid for them to back to the 67 boarder. its the arabs fault then and its the arab fault now. they don't want peace. no more giving anything.

@ahyaok100

7 жыл бұрын

i don't think you really know the situation. a lot of people don't you have to realize that anytime a jew buys land in the "palestinian" territory it is considered illegal by the "palestinians" even though they have no established authority for them to do it. its just a common practice for them. at the same time, non-jews are allowed to own property in israel and its protected by law.

@barrenmicro4024

7 жыл бұрын

ahyaok100 is that suppose to mean that jews bought every inch they live on ? and so this country is bought? if only settlements in the west bank and gaza tell me how jews claimed ownership of the rest of the lands out side the green line?

Uri for President !

when a muslim says he want peace i ask him only one question do you want sharia laws if his answer is yes then he doesn't want peace.

Does he know his Torah ?

the second last guy spoke the most truth! ' withdraw from all the occupied territories, its not ours' its as simple as that.

what they did to (2) soldiers does not really account for the thousands who have been crushed and destroyed from modern Israeli weapons killing children and everything leaving behind shattered lands and people filled with sadness and hatred.

@malvolio01

8 жыл бұрын

+Mohamed Alajmi And I suppose the Palestinians themselves aren't to blame for any of that?? When will they begin to take some responsibility of their own? Why do you insist on treating them like children??

@samjack643

8 жыл бұрын

+Sean L. Israel attacked first.

@malvolio01

8 жыл бұрын

+Sam Jack When?

@bluewizo

8 жыл бұрын

?

@TheMrCalindo

8 жыл бұрын

the weakness and ignorance in our muslim countries is the reason why israel steel exists , once we build the nation again and become united and independant in our political decision israel will disappear

8:09 ...he lives their for own personal reason and not supporting the idea of settlement...this proves that they are getting money for living there...

@tFighterPilot

6 жыл бұрын

Maybe he studies in Ariel university.

@mon76ph

3 жыл бұрын

Maybe his parents move there and he didnt have the means yet to move out from there... The good thing is he acknowledged the fact that the settlements are illegal...

Two people suggested the beginnings of a possible just solution: Uri: kzread.info/dash/bejne/lm2Vs6OLlZCspMo.html/ Rotem: kzread.info/dash/bejne/lm2Vs6OLlZCspMo.html Also, I really respect the frankness and honesty of: Yoav: kzread.info/dash/bejne/lm2Vs6OLlZCspMo.html Yoav, a lovely thoughtful guy, while he didn't offer a solution to the conflict, he did offer a vital pre-requisite to ease the path to a just solution - The need for unbiased education on both sides. While he called the settlements a "cancer", he did not recognise that some of the hate from the Palestinian side is due to this cancer that the Israeli state has bred so it is not only education that is needed on both sides bit also action in recognition that there is a cause and effect with everything and in order to modify the effect, education dictates that we rectify the cause. Peace is the child of justice and there can be no lasting peace if it is not based on absolute justice.

I'm with the side who is more educated, civil, assimilates well with others(not trying to steal another countries identities and cultural beliefs away) and makes greater contributions to society. This is no longer a question of who had first rights to the lands. As far as I'm concerned you should not have the right to govern it if you can't prove yourself otherwise. Leave it to people that are more qualified. I'm sorry but thats just my opinion.

@eatgreenpoop

8 жыл бұрын

So Israel?

@samerawad8092

6 жыл бұрын

no need to be sorry ... this is life !! but forget all the bullshit about qulification ...one word equalls all of that =POWER

‘They started the war not us’ I think you’ll find the moment you started illegally occupying their land and kicking them out their own homes, that pretty much started the war.

@zivguymoore974

3 жыл бұрын

There was no "illegal occupation". Jews are historically and religiously connected to the land of Israel and Jerusalem as its capital. No one goes to Saudi Arabia telling Muslims they do not belong In Mecca and Medina, so same goes for Jerusalem to the Jews. You may read it in the bible, the holy book which was stolen and converted by Islam and Christianity and laid the foundations to the current day civilization. Read "Haj Amin Al Huseini" on Wikipedia for more information. Good luck.

@trs7534

3 жыл бұрын

@Cat Cat But if the native people in America wants their land back, can you call it occupation?, I don't think so, all countries in America respect native people now and agree with their rights to exsist in the land.

@edencohen7097

3 жыл бұрын

@Melchior Magni But the Muslims in Saudi Arabia were never forced out of their land like Jews were at the Babylonian Exile. Also, many Jews lived in Israel for centuries before the establishment of Israel.

@CanadianMonarchist

2 жыл бұрын

The Arabs started the war in 1948.

@Plobq

2 жыл бұрын

@@zivguymoore974 nice try mossad, however you seem to forget Israel doesn't have borders, it's an occupational military border. HA! What a joke of a country, can't even pay for iron dome missiles without American tax dollars! Hahaha

Golan hights has nothing to do with it!

12:07 There's a lot of people living in those areas that would not want to leave Israel though. I hate to make this comparison because they are incredibly different but the same problem exists in Northern Ireland, Even if England gave Eire the northern counties there are scores of people that want to stay with UK and not be part of the republic. Its too complicated . One thing may work and that's to mix the schools and let the hate become diluted through generations until no one cares anymore. But that might solve a kind of surface peace sure but it doesn't solve ownership of the region. That's why its even more difficult regarding Israel because of both sides claim plus logistical difficulties.

"We don't kill children" really?

@ethanfarber8201

8 жыл бұрын

+Abdulla Ali Name Yes... really... killing children who are carrying knives or bombs because you are not man enough to commit murder yourself does not count...

@Metrotion

6 жыл бұрын

Ethan Farber what about the UN schools full of children that were blown up? The several UN hospitals? the many videos showing the IOF using palestinian children as human shields?

@redbenada798

5 жыл бұрын

@@Metrotion no. That was Hamas. Hamas uses human sheilds and fires missiles on top of schools and hospitals, but when Isreal fires back, Hamas calls genocide. There's more to it

@almostafa4725

5 жыл бұрын

@@ethanfarber8201 And your apparently man enough to kill those children...oh wait.

@BGaMs

5 жыл бұрын

Yes really wow the brain wash is real

"where were you born?" "Poland" I heard enough

@thevillageyid

4 жыл бұрын

You heard enough? And people wonder why this conflict is so heated. You won't even listen.

@Zoitality

3 жыл бұрын

Arafat was born in Egypt, what's your point?

@CanadianMonarchist

2 жыл бұрын

Is that you Nigel Farage?

That second guy though, he doesn't realize that one of the biggest things both groups have in common is there culture, clearly hasn't been around enough Arabs.

"Children with no real opinions who repeat cliches they are told"

Uri, Kfar Truman, stay off the pot man

A quote from David Ben Gurion: "Why should the Arabs make peace? If I were an Arab leader I would never make terms with Israel. That is natural: we have taken their country." This man was a visionary but did not quite realize that decolonization of Israel will happen sooner or later, it's just a question of time. That's why many Israeli intellectuals have already started to leave the country ...

@XtreemMetalManRedToTheBone

7 жыл бұрын

why should Jews agree to not have their own country.

Some good points.If the hardliners are marginal then there is a chance.

Have only one state, call it whatever you want, and give all people in it equal rights.

@jessecohen4517

3 жыл бұрын

It will start a civil war

@killuazoldyck7216

3 жыл бұрын

@@jessecohen4517 no, with the right methods this should be the best solution. end both states and build a new one, one that isnt bond on a religion biut one which is neutral to all 3 abrahmic religion. have a neutral court and a parlament which represent the people correctly. If we manage to let no one interfere in, looking art USA, UK, Russia etc., then a civil war shouldnt be a big of a problem.

@jessecohen4517

3 жыл бұрын

@@killuazoldyck7216 you can make it as neutral as you want. It'a not going to solve the fundemental problem.

@slik_

2 жыл бұрын

Yugoslavia 1993 the sequel

Israelis: Normal people Palestinians: Middle Ages people

@DarkerThanBlack88

9 жыл бұрын

***** screw the Quran it's trash I wipe my ass with it

@thefreeworldproject8742

9 жыл бұрын

Jon Price: It is so amusing when you Zionists and pro-Zionists run out of your lies and use insults instead :D Will if you like to wipe your Zionist ass with the quran …I will sell more Quran to you. Would you like an order of 100 copies of the Quran for just $1000. If you order soon, I will give you a gift of 5 copies for free ;) i hope you don't mind buying Quran from a Muslim ;) if you don't mind shipping will be free :D

@DarkerThanBlack88

9 жыл бұрын

uhhhh im an american bro a pure blooded christian come at me bro

@thefreeworldproject8742

9 жыл бұрын

*****: And did anyone talk to you :) I replied and sadly dignified with my reply the idiotic comments insulting a religious book and holy people etc made by 2 Zionist or pro-Zionists. I never said I was offended. There is no need to proof anything to you. + I didn’t accuse Sombr with anything. I simply read his insults and I reply to it ;) that’s all. thank you for your advice :D

@sombrnegr1386

9 жыл бұрын

***** And did I ask for YOUR input?? No, so you're a HYPOCRITE to say that Grigori was wrong to reply (typical product of Islamist school systems, as *hypocrisy* is the mainstay of Islamosupremacist history classes). But here's a little secret: This is a public forum; nobody needs to ask Your Highness's permission to reply and point out what an illogical argument you just made.

The old man had my attention until he said we don't kill children. Then I stopped watching the video. Edit: I rewatched the video and skipped the old man sequence, I was interested by what said the man who live in the settlement.

@dogbert52

4 жыл бұрын

How many jewish christian and hindus did the religion of peace slaughter this week?

@shengloongtan229

3 жыл бұрын

@@dogbert52 if you're still curious, Israel killed 70 children from Palestine this year.

there's an easy salutation for the conflict but its hard to apply coz of politics ONE STATE SALUTATION

hmm. We have any way for both Israel and Palestine live under the united country?