Is THIS the end of Apple? | Genius Bar
Ғылым және технология
🗑️ DeleteMe! Secure your privacy now at joindeleteme.com/geniusbar and use code GENIUSBAR at checkout
💌 Stamps! Get a 4-week trial, free postage, and a digital scale at www.stamps.com/genius. Thanks to Stamps.com for sponsoring the show.
Jon Prosser and Sam Kohl dive into the massive United States DOJ vs Apple lawsuit that claims the iPhone has a monopoly in America. Then they touch on Sam's most recent drama and close out with an interesting turn of events in the leaking world...
Follow Genius Bar
Genius Bar on Twitter/X: / geniusbarpod
Sam on KZread: / iupdate
Jon on KZread: / frontpagetech
Sam on Twitter/X: / iupdate
Jon on Twitter/X: / jon_prosser
Пікірлер: 314
0:00 - Apple vs USA 14:00 - DOJ starting case 15:45 - Apple vs IMessage 24:25 - Apple vs Super apps 29:10 - Sponsor - DeleteMe 31:12 - Apple vs Cloud Streaming 38:15 - Apple vs SmartWatches 43:05 - Haters emerge 50:00 - Apple vs the App Store 57:00 - Apple vs 90’s Microsoft 1:06:51 - Sponsor - stamps 1:08:36 - Apples Market 1:10:36 - Apple vs opinions 1:11:30 - Sam the misleader 1:29:00 - Sam’s birthday tow 1:40:30 - Sam’s TikTok conclusion 1:46:20 - Fishy Mark 1:51:20 - Outro
I don’t understand why Sam doesn’t just hedge his bets and say up front “Reports are coming in that possibly Apple is going to redesign the iOS 18 UI and take elements from VisionOS”. Then he can go into detail on how cool that might look.
@DemonSlayer-vh8uy
3 ай бұрын
see none of them have any news in detail. they subscribe to mark gurman and relay whatever gurman says and gurman is wrong like 70-80% of the time. neither have they(team genius bar) diversified and only stuck to apple products. they have no choice but to build enough hype to garner viewership. but you cannot play the long term game with this. u may get views in short term, but once people realise you are lying all the time, they stop taking you seriously like we stopped taking maxtech seriously.
@LoganT
3 ай бұрын
@@DemonSlayer-vh8uy You do know there are dozens probably hundreds of podcasts where all they do is talk about Apple and Apple rumors, right? You don’t watch these podcasts to learn with 100% certainty what Apple’s plans for the future are. You watch to see a discussion about what Apple might have planned. I truly don’t know why people get so angry when people get Apple rumors wrong. The only reason you would be mad is if you made some bad investments because of the rumors, but hey that’s on you isn’t it?
@DemonSlayer-vh8uy
3 ай бұрын
@@LoganT what investment are you talking about?...the reason we get angry for is because they claim that they are absolutely sure that an ipad will show up and nothing comes out....where does that confidence come from when you have no clue and you know its a rumour....and you are giving him ideas to hedge and all....this is not stock market...hedging will not help him
Sam, in your TikTok you literally say “we just got a first look at iOS 18”. Did you actually see iOS 18 running on a device?
@DemonSlayer-vh8uy
3 ай бұрын
No he did not...another ipad scam from him...
See the Problem with Apple 1. AirPods only being able to receive update from apple device..... 2. Vision Pro coming with a leans cover for the outside glass and not the inside glass lens which is the most important part to protect. 3. Apple was so quick to implement the USB C port on their laptops but it took YEARS for them to bring it to IPhone......if they actually wanted to cut down on E-waste like the said they did they would have made the switch with the IPHONE X not the IPHONE 15...... 4. Apple taking away the power brick and KEEPING the PRICE THE SAME..... 5. Apple's ANTI reparability Practices not making parts available to repair laptops when stuff Breaks. (They forbid their supplier from selling replacement parts to 3rd parties......) 6. Butterfly Keyboard issues yet they kept the design knowing it was flawed. These are just anti-consumer practices
@yellowdrangon
3 ай бұрын
I have love for apple, they brought ports and a decent keyboard back to the Mac Book but damn do they make some wild claims that just stink of BS sometimes
He tried to warn us. Jon tried to warn us lol.
@FrontPageTech
3 ай бұрын
He really did.
@captainastro5270
3 ай бұрын
Bro had to switch accounts for this one 😭
@bazik4
3 ай бұрын
He did. I clearly remember that episode.
"FUCK YOURSELF SIR" Godamn I love this podcast lmao
Re: TikTok - Jern is right - he didn't just state it as fact, he literally said "we just got our first look at" the new iOS. It's flat out deceptive. Clickbait sucks in general, but this crosses the line to flat out deceptive. Clickbait is the headline says something untrue, but the video corrects it. In this case, the video says basically the same thing as what he's calling "the hook." Did you look at the new OS? Did you see it? No. Live your life so you don't have to mince words and differentiate misleading vs lying - it's like starting a sentence with "I'm not racist, but..." yeah, maybe just don't say the rest of the sentence.
I genuinely look forward to this podcast weekly. I’m a 40 year OLD guy and I’m probably not the target audience BUT the format even gets us older folks. Well done and keep up the good work. I know it probably gets exhausting at times but there’s a lot that appreciate it!
@Chad_KBH
3 ай бұрын
I’m 44. 🙋🏻♂️ this is definitely of the funniest tech podcasts ever.
@EVPaddy
3 ай бұрын
I’m 51. 😅
I’d argue that the government is a monopoly 😂
This is the best podcast of all time
@AppleTrack
3 ай бұрын
Thanks for watching, for real ❤
@FrontPageTech
3 ай бұрын
❤
Jon’s rant at 45:00 is GOLD! Saying what we’re all thinking!1!!
Blue bubbles is such an American thing. No one outside really uses messages that much. WhatsApp and Weibo are far more ubiquitous outside the USA
It’s so wild… green bubbles just indicate non iMessage texts. There can be green bubbles between two iPhones if they are communicating via sms
@Gabri3lRocha
3 ай бұрын
There pulling this shit out their ass
@marcsequence
3 ай бұрын
Actually, very interesting that you pointed that out. Seems like they want all bubbles to be green or all bubbles to be blue… I’m pretty sure that’s how you spell racist. But you didn’t hear it from me.
@Gabri3lRocha
3 ай бұрын
@@marcsequence bro now I don’t get shocked at all the cnn propaganda that comes out now but your comment takes the cake. Bro really said that blue bubbles are racist!!!! 😂😂😂😂😂 ain’t no way bruh. You might be joking if so I’m sorry haha
@marcsequence
3 ай бұрын
No everything I say all the time is is mostly a joke lol satire if you will, but isn’t that what they want they won’t know iMessage i.e. eliminate varied colors of bubbles and making the point that pointing that out boiling it down to that is ridiculous@@Gabri3lRocha
@marcsequence
3 ай бұрын
@@Gabri3lRocha maybe if I commented twice I can’t see if my previous reply went through… Let’s say they get their way. They either want to a eliminate iMessage taking on blue bubbles with them or be force up to open it all up and so iMessage/blue bubbles are the only bubbles everywhere? In which case they lose their meaning because Apple can’t enter to end encrypt them or all that good stuff also yeah most of what I say is a joker satire, but I got you to laugh lol I hope the ridiculousness of it is apparent is what I meant
Sam is The Apple Circle of Tiktok lol
I'm the store manager of a Cricket Wireless store and about 90% of my clientele come from Central and South America (I'm in Montana btw) and they are always wanting iPhones but they usually go with our cheapest options But that means that iPhones are the most asked for phones in my store even if they settle for something else in the end
1:15:43 Conversations like this and especially Sam’s responses here are proof that he’s not listening to communicate, but he’s listening to defend himself. Jon’s not yelling; Seems he’s finally getting used to Sam being like this after almost four years of hosting a podcast with him. Edit: 1:19:33 Oh wow, accountability. Nice 💯 Kudos, Sam
So if the DOJ did this to Apple, they should do the same for all other manufacturers 😡
@EVPaddy
3 ай бұрын
What other manufacturer is a controlling bully like Apple?
They should add a function in iOS18 to customize your conversation bubble colors, so people can finally shut up 😂😂😂
The U.S. DOJ be like, "American company Apple, no MONOPOLY MESSAGING. Chinese company MONOPOLY, do it!"
Jon is embodying all the rants I have been having in my discord. 😂
Man im gonna be on the toilet for a while for this one
I couldn’t watch the whole press conference. I got just as mad as Jon.
@marcsequence
3 ай бұрын
Because of how out of touch the people who are in charge of everything are of everything? Because same.
My 12 year old daughter has a Fitbit - but the app won’t integrate into Apple fitness - why don’t the doj come down on them?
Mandating USB-C is insane! I never agreed with Apple complying to adding. Jon is spot on!
The DOJ needs to hear Jon’s rant
The people at the DOJ need to watch this! And also whoever the judge is on the case…
Man, I am so ready to watch this tomorrow!!
Bumper cases need to make a comeback
Also I wonder how many people at the conference were using Apple products
Mark took Pei/Nothing to church. 1000% correct when you said it’s all about software, HW is just the vehicle 👏👏👏
Sam being unprepared is the perfect showcase of a child doing grownup stuff.
@jameslovelesstj
3 ай бұрын
Totally agree, he wants one thing, views! And he doesn’t care how he gets them! Tell a load of lies about what people are definitely getting so he can be a big TikTok star! Dude grow up and be a better person!
@sanderhoogeland9161
3 ай бұрын
A bit unnecessarily rude, but OK.
@sllick
3 ай бұрын
@@jameslovelesstjalso money
I really hope that Apple has a warning screen for those people that use side loading. I hope that it says that if you sideload and it causes a security problem, your warranty is null and void…. on your own.
@Jaraizer
3 ай бұрын
That would be illegal. You can currently side load right now, and people do it every day. Its combersome and you have to renew the license every 7 days, but it won't remove your warranty. Thatd be insane
@markstelzl1245
3 ай бұрын
They do have that. And that’s why they are under fire. Apple are complying with the EU but under duress. Making it almost impossible to side load cause they are being threatened of warranty loss.
@Gabri3lRocha
3 ай бұрын
I just got my mom and iPhone because she always had issues with androids starting to slow down and having weird malware. If this actually ever comes to the US well then me switching her to Apple just becomes useless
@Phoun
3 ай бұрын
You do know they allow "side loading" on the Mac right? Such a dumb thing to try and fearmonger
@Gabri3lRocha
3 ай бұрын
@@Phoun people who use pcs and Mac’s tend to be more tech savvy and careful whereas most people nowadays get by with just a phone as their sole computer. My mom for example especially elderly
Jon Has ASCENDED!! 💥🔥🎤😆
Sam caught Jon with a never ending story there. 😂
1:14:48 I agree with Jon, Sam. Your TikTok was misleading. Average users will see that and assume it's fact, when in reality it's just rumors atp. Gotta do better.
@cb33
3 ай бұрын
What are the stakes in this situation? If Sam says something will happen and then it doesn't happen, who does it affect and in what way?
App store analogy: Can you go into wallmart and put out a table and sell your product within their store? No. So why does apple HAVE to let you host your app without their cut / stipulations
@Gabri3lRocha
3 ай бұрын
They might as well say Walmart has a manoply on retail stores because of their good deals
facts are fellas and ladies. i speak for a iphone user since day one. i am a user mainly because of the closed system. i pay for security, the ease of use, and functionality. this case is making it seem like the justice system doesn't want a company to have such a high user base. but they do because of the exact reasons i mentioned above. come on america. why try to break a beautiful ecosystem 🤔🤔😭😭😭
Jon for President! Prosser 2024! 🚽🧻
It’s almost over I just wanted to let you guys know to have a great week ahead ❤😊
Feel like they did usbc prior to the date so people wouldn’t wait for that iPhone model and would skip iPhone 15
I’ve loved apple for several years, but I feel the support that they used to offer in. Their stores is not what it used to be. They are overstaffed and too busy and act like you’re just another one of their issues they have to deal with. I appreciate that their products last a long time. but I’m in no rush to go out and buy another anytime soon. They seem to be heavily focused on generating subscription, revenue, and raising their prices on them every year. I would rather spend my money, going to an amusement park or on a cruise versus buying the same recycled stuff every year.
Thank you John and Sam you guys finally said some real facts about this that the rest of the media has not. Especially about beeper hacking iMessage and storing messages on a server
Jon is on 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Screw the DOJ
@selw0nk
3 ай бұрын
Nah they are cooking.
@brianpatrickreddington1750
3 ай бұрын
I love Apple
I looooove Jon's malding at 45:00-46:00 mark. But yeah I understand so much.
I luv the way that you think of others Sam. Like when you mentioned about so many people that just don’t have the dollars to pay to get their car out. You’re a beautiful soul. Xx.
50:17 why did it have to take this long to get this statement?!? Like it’s so obvious that Apple is very anti-competitive. The walled garden is a huge thing. In big and small ways. But the DOJ is not Congress, they are way more tech savvy and can prove their case than the Congress or the FTC. The old vs younger people argument is flawed here.
Where Jern is talking about making Apple and android the same so it’s easier to switch between at the 12 minute mark if they aren’t talking about industry standards, I agree with Jern. If they ARE talking industry standards then that’s something the industry itself would come up with and it’s not the government’s job to force it on the industry.
i believe part of the DoJ complaint was that they only agreed to support a limited 2019 spec of RCS that could easily be broken soon anyway due to being out of date, and not continual support of updated RCS protocols
Jon you seriously should be one of the big wigs at Apple…You nail absolutely everything. Thank you 🙏 so so much for being a voice. Xx.
Nothing copied the iPhone 11 design and added lights, now they’re blaming Apple for not succeeding huh
Yes, you can buy pretty much any phone you want. The problem is carriers like AT&T will not let phones like xiaomi, poco, oppo, etc work on their network even though they are unlocked phones.
the problem with blocking streaming apps was that they have their own service to stream games to the iphone .......they stopped blocking them because it is painfully obvious it's anticompetitive
"That's stuff" 😂 6:10 just say yes or no bro.
The new book title: 10 years 10 billion could even be a movie or a comely...
Yes thank you! Excellent episode!! ❤
Let’s not forget about the iPod. Even though this Justice Department complaint doesn’t mention iPod and , I would like to add that I don’t personally agree with a single point they are trying to make, I would like to point out how Apple locked people in to the iPod and Mac by keeping customers music purchases from being used on non Apple devices. And that this customer with iTunes purchases helped sell early iPhones. So I guess I am saying that Apple is capable of doing something like what they are being accused of but they are not currently being accused of anything nearly as obviously underhanded. In my view.
I am 55, and remember when the government was accusing Microsoft of being a monopoly that didn't go well for Microsoft. As a result Microsoft bailed Apple out of Bankruptcy as a weird turn of events maybe to say see we helped a competitor out
Maybe, I 'm just saying, the "government" "asks" something from Apple to do and they refuse. What???
remember the DoJ arent lawmakers. they may or may not have overstepped here, but the EU changes came from a deliberative lawmaking body. For bad or good, the EU changes were legislation that passed a legislative body. Our Congress hasnt passed anything and probably wont, but theres a chance if the alternative app stores in Europe turn out to be awesome for consumers. Probably not though. We just have a DoJ trying to interpret the broadly written Sherman Act for arguable business practices Apple does that could be considered anticompetitive conduct. Our law is broadly written so it is quite political how the DoJ enforces it. The specific points you can debate, but a very huge change to the App store such as forcing alternative app stores, should come from a legislature.
Great episode 💯💯💯
Spectrum cable is a damn monopoly
I've got a solution to tackle the entire issue: Let's put an end to poorly made Android apps! They're a major reason why I've grown to dislike Android; the excessive ads are just too much. Plus, most Android watches are just downright unattractive!
You handled the tow really well Sam! You don’t lie, everything you said happened just as you said, I’m the witness! Sorry this happened to you!
Sam, don’t live in LA. That’s one of thousands of reasons people are leaving in droves. You’re going to lose the court case, I hate to say!
I’m just going to speak on the text messaging part. I think apple should bring RCS to iMessage. I do think that its very anti competitive when you gate keep other companies from being able to innovate. It’s not about “just get better lol” because Google HAS a better option for android users to be able to communicate with iPhone users but APPLE doesn’t want to let them. APPLE is being the aggressor here. In my opinion, android has ALWAYS played nicely with Apple but Apple doesn’t like to play nicely with android. So I hate when people say that android companies are “bullying” apple when it’s the complete opposite. Like, if that wasn’t the case then you iPhone users wouldn’t have the screens you’re using now or the widgets you like to use. All this is doing is finally getting apple to make communication easier for both types of users, that’s it.
@respect386
3 ай бұрын
💯 it’s ridiculous they just haven’t brought RCS to iMessage.
@evancrazyerror
3 ай бұрын
Apple has no incentive to bring RCS to iPhone, in this case, Apple is 100% using their market dominance to stifle innovation (forcing the common standard to be SMS through lack of cooperation) and in doing so is harming consumer experience. But instead of complaining about it and wrapping it in courts for a decade, why not do the *actual* way to get companies to follow suit with new protocol? By passing regulations? Do you see how quickly Apple announced support for RCS once China said they were replacing SMS texting with RCS nationwide? After iMessage came out and became a success, Google tried and failed to push out MULTIPLE standards for internet messaging on Android (anyone remember Google Duo? Hangouts? Meet? Neither do I). Their best attempt, RCS, was still not pushed hard enough to carriers and regulating bodies. Instead of putting in the work of making this the universal standard so Apple had to comply, they went on a 5 year media ad blitz complaining that Apple wouldn’t “get the message”. Sorry Google, but you need RCS more than Apple does, so why are you acting like you don’t truly care about it?
Agreeing with what was already iterated. This suit is really ironic and hypocritical considering if we looked at this in the perspective of governments and countries, Apple is really simply doing what our own government is already doing. This would be like the rest of the world saying, “America, you’re too secure. You don’t allow enough foreign individuals or entities to take over the White House or have more say in our policies. You really need to let a majority in congress to be made up of different countries so they too have an opportunity to vote on policy and bills.” Apple is merely mirroring our own government! A nation that is proud of its security is somehow condemning the same thing that’s being done on a smaller and less consequential scale?
I think there are more pressing issues the DOJ needs to address before they attack Apple like this.
But some of the points are legit. If iPhone is that "good" then it should stand alone and sales should not be affected, right? People will still choose it. Further, how does having encrypted RCS, being able to send normal quality videos, etc. not benefit all? Both sides of the messages. Apple is all about privacy so how about your privacy when you message an Android person over SMS? No one is saying change iMessage at all or open it up; but default to RCS, not SMS. SMS should be a 3rd option of last resort. Yes some of the arguments are bad but there are some valid ones that are just dumb. The same with sideloading; any Mac can do it so it should be an option everywhere (not just Europe). Default it to being off, sure, and riddle it with disclaimers. Their own computers do it already so there's really no good argument on a phone. Those 2 areas are just both really losing anti-competition arguments for Apple. And no, the data does not show that people dont want "open computing." iPhone is about 23% of sales in the world (Harmony 4% and Android 74%); looking at the US data only is not a valid argument.
Bill Gates was one of the reasons why Steve Jobs made the personal computer. IBM could also be considered a monopoly now or at one point. Another point to show that it is everyone vs Apple Right after i typed this, Sam mentioned Microsoft on how Apple was born lol
It doesn't make it an Android, it makes it a Mac. I feel like everyone forgets that MacOS is extremely open, more open than Windows. If I can do whatever I want with my MacBook Pro, why shouldn't I be able to do the same with my iPhone?
@c.rosenfeld
3 ай бұрын
Have you ever even used Windows before?
@velohench
3 ай бұрын
@@c.rosenfeld Have you?
@c.rosenfeld
3 ай бұрын
@@velohench Yes, but have you?
@velohench
3 ай бұрын
@@c.rosenfeldYep, until 2018 I had barely touched MacOS. Mostly used Windows and a few Linux distros. Currently, I have a Windows desktop, MacBook Pro, and an old Surface running Ubuntu.
The point is you’re a news source, whether you want to be a reputable source or not is what is at stake SAM 1:26:00
So you enjoy worse superapps, no interoperability, you love that Apple killed countless cloud streaming projects, you love letting Apple take 0.15% on all offline Apple Payments and 30% off all online payments, and you also happy with smartwatch bundling/exclusivity. 👍
Time to get max tech back on!
Tik tok suggestion, Keep the first line hook the exact same, Fast cut, start the remainder of the video with “according to the latest leak/rumor/source Apple is planning to …” Fully discloses it’s not a fact but resharing information that can be credible, but leaves the out for the “this may not happen” without going into super deep detail. Keep up the great work guys. Favorite listen in tech.
Don’t know how it’s working in the US but in Europe most people use WhatsApp to communicate between iOS and Android users without any troubles.
the DoJ would say . "yes... super apps never got a chance to start up and get off the ground and no innovators/entrepeneurs investing in such when theres no market for it..." it is a bit of a cultural choice but theres room for more than 1 super app. I am not missing em too much, but we also dont know what we're missing since that type of app never got a chance.
Greatest podcast ever guys it’s to the point ❤😊
The closed Apple experience is why I hate Apple even though I use all the Apple products. I only use Apple because I like the Apple Watch and air pods. Their walled system has gotten rid of consumer choice.
I'm surprised they didn't mention the silicone case for the iphone 15 pro is anti-competitive because it doesn't fit a samsung galaxy
Did you take pictures Sam of the incidents so that you have proof of what happened
U2 are so far up apples a**. I think if it benefits messaging between Apple and android then it’s a win for everybody so who the f**** cares if it’s illegal or not. Now when it comes to side loading no one really cares about that because people really care about the security of Apple and I think side load makes it less secure so I think the governments overstepped there. But if it benefits Apple to android experience then I’d rather they just do it. Btw I’m an apple user and I’m sick of having to constantly have bad interactions with android users just because they prefer a certain phone. It’s kind of ridiculous. If anything the bullying that comes from this is a direct result of apples unwillingness to make the experience more secure for both android and apple users and now that china is forcing them to do it I commend china for doing so because it’s really gotten out of hand. All the other stuff I’m pretty sure I don’t care about.
9:24pm EST publish time? Do my eyes deceive me? 👀
3:04 💯 why u can’t give government an inch because they will try to take a mile
Some good points. But!! Apple need to stop charging so much for memory upgrades on their devices their greed will be their undoing.
This pod shouldn’t have been made because Sam didn’t permission to show his face till he had iPad news 😂
We just got our first look 😂😂😂
The US and the EU needs te stop these nonsense! And we need to be very vocal about it. I’m not sure what we can do, but chatgtp gave some options, and I’m pretty sure some people smarte then me can figure this one out.
@selw0nk
3 ай бұрын
It's not nonsense it's true.
@marcsequence
3 ай бұрын
When they were going over the actual lawsuit filing, I was thinking in my head who wrote this ChinaGPT?
Yall should have a conversation with LMG to educate them
1:19:01 💯 Jon Speaking Facts Sam, tech people know it’s all rumors but the rest don’t, they think when a tech reporter says something it’s facts, not just your thoughts on rumors
the lawsuit is not saying the iphone is a monopoly so much as these specific points/practices hold back some innovation and prevent new businesses from starting up etc.
I do think that I would like to have the option of switch Apple Store, cloud service and by opening this would not hurt Apple because the experience would be much better. Even without it is not a monopoly by definition
11:04 With that logic, car manufacturers are anti competitive towards motorcycle makers. After you learn to drive a car, you are stuck in the car ecosystem and if you want to switch you are obligated to re-learn your method of transportation. lol Good joke USA
Dude, that’s why LA was the number one county people left in 2023. You get what you vote for bro.
@selw0nk
3 ай бұрын
Okay Maga person.
@Jdevil21
3 ай бұрын
@@selw0nk lol sorry bro it’s true. They all left to go to Florida and Texas.
@selw0nk
3 ай бұрын
@@Jdevil21 Two of the worst States.
1:01:04 Sam in a nutshell Sam: “I take this very seriously” also Sam: 1:16:19 “I could do a better job of throwing a maybe at the end of the video”. Sam, it’s not that hard, just start your video with the disclaimer. Plenty of TT creators fit this in videos that are shorter than yours 1:24:23 whataboutism
🍎 If Apple wins this case, then other companies will follow Apple
Android fan here. I want RCS to be enabled on iOS like yesterday 🙃 the other stuff the government wrote up is very much weak sauce
@Gabri3lRocha
3 ай бұрын
As an Apple im happy about this as well just it wasn’t forced and bullied to do this like the EU otherwise I wouldn’t care for it but will make it much more convenient for family group chats
No it’s not. I love their technology and their products ❤️
Boys blackberry did it before apple with their BBM platform.
Sorry about your tow on your birthday, Sam! Is that a Los Angeles thing?