Is JJ McCarthy a TOP-TEN player in the 2024 NFL Draft? | Michigan Quarterback Scouting Report & Film

Спорт

Michigan's JJ McCarthy has been one of the hottest risers on big boards for the 2024 NFL Draft, but is he really that good? Should he be in the same conversation as other quarterbacks like Drake Maye, or is he just a mediocre talent?
Today, we're going to be doing a deep dive into McCarthy as a prospect and analyzing his tape to determine what his outlook looks like!
BIG shoutout to NFL Draft Buzz for making this video possible! Check out nfldraftbuzz.com for the best NFL Draft content on the internet!
As always, thanks for tuning in, and remember to like, subscribe, and check out the other videos on the if you like content like this!

Пікірлер: 50

  • @joeymerlan
    @joeymerlan4 ай бұрын

    By the time Combine is Over, he will be a top 10-15 Pick. Theres a huge market for QBs right now because next years is Weak

  • @nicolastomas8436
    @nicolastomas84364 ай бұрын

    He’s underrated

  • @FallBallSports

    @FallBallSports

    4 ай бұрын

    In what way?

  • @MyIcepick
    @MyIcepick4 ай бұрын

    You criticize his progressions and pre-snap read? At least he did those things. He played in pro-style offense where he had to do those things. Most of the top QB's didn't. He is far better prepared for the NFL than most, in that regard.

  • @rickl2633
    @rickl26334 ай бұрын

    JJ McCarthy is an elite signal caller. NFL teams draft on potential. This kid has all of the tools to be great at the next level. I would draft him over Nix, Penix, and Daniels. Those guys were not as accomplished as McCarthy at his age. I love McCarthy's upside in the right situation. I hope my Raiders draft him in the first round.

  • @bradkiss8576
    @bradkiss85764 ай бұрын

    His pocket awareness is very good

  • @MrJwdalle
    @MrJwdalle2 ай бұрын

    nailed that draft slot....SKOL!!! 😁😁😁

  • @johnmanes8195
    @johnmanes81954 ай бұрын

    In the negatives you said he frequently has poor ball placement and can make bad decisions sometimes and yet he had one of the highest completion percentages and lowest interception ratios of any college QB this past season so your comments seem a bit unfounded.

  • @ASBDYTheAwesome
    @ASBDYTheAwesome4 ай бұрын

    I hope he can do a complete 180 just like how the other quarterback from michigan did

  • @James-tw3hy
    @James-tw3hy4 ай бұрын

    JJ McCarthy's draft stock rising is a product of the current QB demand. People are VERY down on next year's QB class and with Russel Wilson and Fields looking like the best vets to trade for (i think Kirk resigns) teams without a franchise QB are stuck in a difficult situation with really only 4 options (listed below): 1). Trade the farm to get into the top 3 to get one of the good prospects. (results in getting - hopefully - a franchise QB, but now you gave up all your other assets) 2). Trade for a declining Russel Wilson or a middling Justin Fields. (which really doesn't move the needle) 3). Overdraft a prospect like JJ, Nix, or Penix out of desperation for a QB because there aren't any in next year's class. (probably results in a blown top 10-15 pick) 4). Ignore all three of those options, stick with a garbage QB until the 2026 class which destroys any team building as most players on rookie contracts will be up by 2026. (staff is getting fired) Teams electing for option 3 is what is causing JJ's stock to rise

  • @randybekis.3745
    @randybekis.37454 ай бұрын

    I really want QB JJ McCarthy join in Our Denver Broncos PLEASE sure Amen 🙏🤠👍.

  • @jasonpeterson8
    @jasonpeterson84 ай бұрын

    Man the people that are hating on this kid DON’T KNOW FOOTBALL….. You don’t…. You’re regurgitating what the Negative Nancy’s are saying….. You didn’t watch, Michigan football, you are obviously CLUELESS ON who coached him up…. Damn, stop the hate. Because he definitely better than, Drake Maye…… If anyone is overrated it’s Maye… #GoBlue✊🏾💛💙

  • @obarbeito
    @obarbeito4 ай бұрын

    His negatives are normal for a 20 year old. That can be taken care of with coaching. He's probably gonna have the best or 2nd best career of this class of qb's. He has the tools, he comes from an nfl style offense. I rather take him over Drake or Jayden, Drake is not a leader(he wasn't even a captain the whole season) and Jayden just had his 1st great year after 4 or 5 yrs and in a backyard style offense where the only thing they did was pass it to great open wide receivers..

  • @dboii9741
    @dboii97414 ай бұрын

    His film looks so promising he got some arm talent but I need to see him against NFL level talent

  • @mr.rationale8808

    @mr.rationale8808

    4 ай бұрын

    Out of all the top QB's in this class, he's played against the most Top 25 defenses. What's the next excuse?

  • @elginjames3516
    @elginjames35164 ай бұрын

    Jj is a able to be an amazing talent in the NFL, he has the speed and the arm potential. I see his potential being a slightly worse Josh Allen

  • @FallBallSports

    @FallBallSports

    4 ай бұрын

    Well another thing I didn't touch on in the video is that McCarthy is just over 200 pounds. He weight 35 less pounds than Josh Allen, durability will also be a concern for him

  • @matthewmatt5285

    @matthewmatt5285

    4 ай бұрын

    @@FallBallSports He's strill not a MAN yett,.He will be 225 lbs in 2 yrs and VERY DURABLE,. And he's much more nimble with tons more speed and dexterity than Allen,.. And ALLEN couldn't hit the broad side of a Barn when he came out,. But that is Teachable just like McCarthy,. You leep thinking he ISN'T 2 yrs younger than the other Top qbs in this Draft,. HUGE MISTAKE~

  • @bretttaylor3787
    @bretttaylor3787Ай бұрын

    "He wasn't asked to do much for Michigan" lol that's why he led the nation on 3rd and long passing. I didn't notice that this channel was called Fail Ball Sports.

  • @TreeJ18
    @TreeJ184 ай бұрын

    Hes QB3, everything you said about JJ in this video could be copy and pasted to a Bo Nix prospect other than age, maye had a down year compared to last year and Daniels only popped this year and have their quirks too JJ is a 1st-2nd rounder and teams like Minnesota could absolutely get the best out of him compared to a daniels in NE with no help

  • @FallBallSports

    @FallBallSports

    4 ай бұрын

    I don't think him having similarities to Bo Nix is a point in his favor😂

  • @matthewmatt5285
    @matthewmatt52854 ай бұрын

    Yess~He just turned 21,.The guy is going to be a STAR,.. He hasn't even begun to fill into his Frame,.. Yeah,..He has a lot to learn but he has the perfect frame on Mind and Body to DO IT,.. Another clown wanna be draft expert that can't see "IT" when it's slapping him in the Face.

  • @baecotte

    @baecotte

    4 ай бұрын

    Bro I see you everywhere under JJ videos hahahah

  • @matthewmatt5285

    @matthewmatt5285

    4 ай бұрын

    @@baecotte Heck yeah,.I KNOW talent when I see it hammy : )

  • @Zeffpenguin

    @Zeffpenguin

    4 ай бұрын

    @@matthewmatt5285 Will keep this comment in mind when he is the biggest bust of the QB class :)

  • @BestQBEver
    @BestQBEver4 ай бұрын

    He Also Only STARTED 2 seasons

  • @SayLesNyC
    @SayLesNyC4 ай бұрын

    If I have to convince myself on why a guy is good or not then he is problem not that good. Plain and simple.

  • @mr.rationale8808

    @mr.rationale8808

    4 ай бұрын

    Or maybe you think too hard. The data shows that the production is there. Not hard to look up

  • @GavinEstes16
    @GavinEstes164 ай бұрын

    JJ Mcarthy is so overrated, it’s so annoying that so many draft guys are trying to prove something that’s not even true, JJ Mcarthy got carried by his defense and the run game, the situation JJ Mcarthy is in is the exact same as Brock Purdy in San Francisco.

  • @Curlyfries-zz2dj

    @Curlyfries-zz2dj

    4 ай бұрын

    THANK YOU FOR SAYING THIS. He is really overrated and not even round 1 draft pick. His team carried him not the other way around.

  • @jodyfoster9278

    @jodyfoster9278

    4 ай бұрын

    Go back and watch the 2022 Ohio State game. I know you'll likely point out that Edwards ran for 216 so he carried McCarthy but 160 of those yards came on two plays in the 4th quarter when Michigan was in control.

  • @mthom0861

    @mthom0861

    4 ай бұрын

    agreed. he was never a key to their team. Threw once for over 150 yards in his last 6 games.

  • @jasonpeterson8

    @jasonpeterson8

    4 ай бұрын

    Can’t wait for him to prove you all wrong. For you to say he’s overrated, you don’t have a clue about football. If he wasn’t a top tier QB, he would have NEVER been at, UofM….. If Jim Harbaugh vouches for this. I’m damn sure gonna believe him over you clueless clowns…. He didn’t have to throw like that because we had one of the most dominating rushing attacks… DUH…..! Oh yeah, we won a National Championship…. #GoBlue✊🏾💛💙

  • @stevesalisbury3657

    @stevesalisbury3657

    4 ай бұрын

    Your just dumb

  • @theunexpertspod
    @theunexpertspod4 ай бұрын

    1. Drake 2. Caleb 3. Daniels 4. Penix 5. JJ 6. Rattler

  • @Kyle-bi7df

    @Kyle-bi7df

    4 ай бұрын

    Bo Nix is the 4 buddy😂😂

  • @Jrm-xs9qi

    @Jrm-xs9qi

    4 ай бұрын

    Penix is 🤮

  • @johnmanes8195

    @johnmanes8195

    4 ай бұрын

    i guess you did not watch Penix in the Naty. The guy is terrible under pressure and will probably be injured within a few games in the NFL where he is going to see a lot more pressure than he saw most of last season until the Michigan game.

  • @ryanallen1202

    @ryanallen1202

    4 ай бұрын

    Dudes like Samuel LJackson as Mr. Glass. Could be good but most likely a perennial all pro for the Injured Reserve squad😂

  • @edharris6452
    @edharris64524 ай бұрын

    I can't for the life of me see how anyone can have JJ going in the first round. He's a 3rd round QB. Now don't get me wrong, he could become a Russell Wilson and surprise us all, but the accuracy, arm talent, processing and decision making aren't presently there. He is quite mobile though, but he doesn't have the stature of an Allen, so no round 1 grade for me.

  • @JF--

    @JF--

    4 ай бұрын

    JJ is an accurate passer at 72.3% comp rate this year and 64% the previous...that's one of the few stats that translates to the NFL. Arm talent wise he is not "Elite" but name the top 15 guys in the league and ask yourself "how many guys that are successful in the NFL have "Elite" arm talent?" The answer is not many. There's a reason why NFL teams (contrary to media takes and youtubers) are very impressed with his tape. Drew Lock had ELITE arm talent and how'd that work for Denver? His main issue is sample size. JJ will be a top 10 pick.

  • @stevesalisbury3657
    @stevesalisbury36574 ай бұрын

    All you dummys hating on kid becuase he beat your teams. Like binch of jealous grown men hating on 20 yr old lol pathetic

  • @mthom0861
    @mthom08614 ай бұрын

    come on; so overrated. he threw for 150 yards in his last 6 games ONCE. This was against better teams. He was never a key player in their offense. A gm drafting him so high should not be a GM.

  • @musicdreamerish

    @musicdreamerish

    4 ай бұрын

    Ridiculous. Harbaugh would have ran the EXACT same offense no matter what qb he would have had. It's dumb to claim that Michigan wanted to run some big passing offense but couldn't because they didn't have the QB. NO, Harbaugh runs his same offense NO MATTER WHAT, as the gunslinger for the Chargers will find out. No way he gets past the Viks at 8, and now that the combine is over one on CBS says number 3 to the Pattriots. But the same guy says the Rick Speilman really likes JJ, so he won't go past them, and the Giants are talking to him as well at the combine and they draft 6th I think. By the way, JJ threw the ball 61 mph at the combine, fastest other than that rocket arm guy, Milton from Tennessee. He is a champion, great athlete, great leader. Including his high school days, JJ is 65-5. The few GM\s that pass on him may regret it soon.

  • @jasonpeterson8

    @jasonpeterson8

    4 ай бұрын

    @@musicdreamerish, tell them… They just wanna talk about him because he didn’t have to throw that much, so they just blindly assume that he can’t. They’ll learn… #GoBlue✊🏾💛💙

  • @calebdeatrich5389
    @calebdeatrich53894 ай бұрын

    Definitely overrated. Doesn't belong in top-ten conversations

  • @matthewmatt5285

    @matthewmatt5285

    4 ай бұрын

    SOME PEOPLE CAN'T SEE THE fUTURE~

  • @jasonpeterson8

    @jasonpeterson8

    4 ай бұрын

    How is he overrated? Please explain this to me, because you’re just saying something to say something, or else you would display proof…. Oh! That’s right!!! You have no proof….🧐 #GoBlue✊🏾💛💙😫

  • @matthewmatt5285

    @matthewmatt5285

    4 ай бұрын

    @@jasonpeterson8 He's obviously underrated and people are FINALLY starting to wake up to what we already KNEW~

  • @stevesalisbury3657

    @stevesalisbury3657

    4 ай бұрын

    Lol cope

Келесі