Is Bill Veeck a Liar? The 1943 Sale of the Phillies.

Спорт

Bill Veeck claimed that he was ready to purchase the Phillies in 1943, and field a team made up entirely of African-American players from the negro leagues. SABR published an article in 1998 that essentially called Veeck a liar. Well, who is right? Did Bill Veeck have such a plan ready to put in place until Commissioner Kennesaw Mountain Landis intervened and put a stop to it?
#MLB #baseball #civilrights #desegregation #Phillies #PhilliesHistory
Come join the Philadelphia Baseball History community through Patreon. Get a behind the scenes look at the video making process. From concept to script to editing, you can have a say in the final product, and receive credit in the video.
/ philabaseballhistory
Check out our merch store! We have t-shirts, pins, stickers, mugs, phone cases and masks available, all with our Philadelphia baseball designs:
www.philadelphiabaseballhisto...
Join the discussion of topics about the history of baseball in Philadelphia by visiting our blog:
PhiladelphiaBaseballHistory.bl...
Bill Kovatch, the founder and main contributor to Philadelphia Baseball History is a trained attorney who is currently unable to practice because of health problems. If you would like to help by contributing towards Bill’s expenses, please make a donation, however small, to the Special Needs Trust set up for his benefit.
You can donate through Buy Me A Coffee at:
buymeacoff.ee/PhilBaseBallHis
You can also use PayPal to donate using this URL:
PayPal.me/KovatchSNT
Or this email address: KovatchSNT@gmail.com
Your non-tax deductible donations will go to help pay Bill’s expenses.
We also have a Facebook group:
/ philadelphiabaseballhi...
And a Twitter account: @PhilBaseBallHis.
linktr.ee/PhilaBaseballHistory
Find all of our links here:
linktr.ee/philabaseballhistory
****************************************
References
Dickson, Paul, Bill Veeck: Baseball’s Greatest Maverick (Walker Books 2012).
Gerlach, Larry, Jordan, David Jordan and Rossi, John, “A Baseball Myth Exploded: Bill Veeck and the 1943 Sale of the Phillies,” The National Pastime (1998). sabr.org/research/article/a-b...
Kaiser, David, “A Troubling Myth About Jackie Robinson Endures,” Time (April 15, 2016). time.com/4294175/jackie-robin...
Tygiel, Jules, “Revisiting Bill Veeck and the 1943 Phillies,” Baseball Research Journal, 109 (2006). research.sabr.org/journals/fil...
Veeck, Bill and Linn Ed, Veeck as in Wreck: The Autobiography of Bill Veeck (University of Chicago Press 1962).
Warrington, Robert D. and Macht, Norman, “The Veracity of Veeck,” Baseball Research Journal (Fall 2013). sabr.org/journal/article/the-...
****************************************
All photographs are either in the public domain, or have been used for the purpose of commentary, education and research, and as such are protected pursuant to the Fair Use Doctrine.
Video clips of baseball games are the property of Major League Baseball, and are used for the purpose of commentary, education and research, and as such are protected pursuant to the Fair Use Doctrine.
Music:
“Cute,” “Jazzy Frenchy” by Bensound.com. Used with permission.
“Across the Room” by Letterbox.
“Modern Situtations” by Unicorn Heads.
“Reasons to Smile,” “Keep Dreaming” by Topher Mohr and Alex Elena.
“Willie’s Island Moped” by the Whole Other.
Used consistently with KZread’s Terms & Conditions.
Thank you for watching, and please consider subscribing to this channel.
©️2021 Who’s The More Foolish Multi-Media Productions LLC

Пікірлер: 16

  • @PhiladelphiaBaseballHistory
    @PhiladelphiaBaseballHistory3 жыл бұрын

    Learn more about Connie Mack Stadium, also known as Shibe Park, the former home of the Phillies and Athletics, by clicking here: kzread.info/dash/bejne/pXWarMl-ZKu3dNo.html

  • @big8dog887
    @big8dog887 Жыл бұрын

    Not only did Veeck sign Larry Doby as baseball's second black player (and first in the AL), he also hired Dobe as baseball's second black manager. The significance of this was that Frank Robinson, baseball's first black manager, was hired as a player-manager, Doby was the first black man hired exclusively to manage.

  • @jameselfers9539
    @jameselfers953910 ай бұрын

    Bill Veck's father, Bill Veck, Sr. wrote under under the byline "Bill Bailey" The song "Won't You Come Home Bill Bailey" was written when Veck, Sr. jumped from one newspaper to another on behalf of the original newspaper.

  • @notvalidcharacters
    @notvalidcharacters Жыл бұрын

    Showmanship and exaggeration are two different things; one does not imply the other. And the absence of a story in the Tribune about a deal that never took place, is also not proof of a negative. Meanwhile as noted Veeck's bringing in Larry Doby in Cleveland to break the AL colour line demonstrates his interest in integrating the Game, but if Veeck is working at the time with the Indians... why would he be talking about a failed deal with the Phillies, a deal in the past in another league? This counterargument just isn't well thought out. The Landis statement about being OK with blacks in baseball was part of a spin cycle after Leo Durocher had been quoted (with others) saying that he (Durocher) would like to play black players if Landis would only permit it. Landis then called Durocher on his carpet, after which Durocher announced he had been misquoted. The fact that Landis had to summon Durocher to the office before Durocher decided he had been misquoted, speaks loudly. It was after THAT that Landis made the statement, which pretty much smells like damage control. Durocher went on later to lay down the law on the Brooklyn bench to players thinking about resisting Jackie Robinson's presence on the team. And the sequence of events remains that the breaking of that colour line didn't happen until after Landis had died. Basically here, absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. The fact (if true) that Veeck is the ultimate source of all stories, does not mean that therefore it's not true; it simply means it isn't corroborated.

  • @danholm4952

    @danholm4952

    Жыл бұрын

    Bill Veeck was never the problem... its was jim crow wt owners

  • @kduquett
    @kduquett Жыл бұрын

    Nice video. I have a request, what about taking this story on step further and actually mocking up a 1943 Phillies team with Negro league players. What would that look like? I assume they would dominate the National league.

  • @russphilly

    @russphilly

    9 ай бұрын

    no shit

  • @TheBatugan77
    @TheBatugan772 жыл бұрын

    I loved Bill Veeck. But when he subsequently bought MLB teams, he could've stocked them with black players... or at least tried. He did not.

  • @notvalidcharacters

    @notvalidcharacters

    Жыл бұрын

    Actually he did. Larry Doby, as mentioned above, broke the AL colour line. Satchel Paige shortly thereafter. I believe he brought in Minnie Miñoso as well.

  • @Ozmodiar6
    @Ozmodiar6 Жыл бұрын

    SABR did a good job debunking this. Really, it kinda ruins Veeck As In Wreck for me. How much of the rest of the book is BS? I mean, I guess that's how Veeck became what he was, through hustling and smooth talking and promoting himself.

  • @russphilly
    @russphilly9 ай бұрын

    ..you'd make a helluva Double Talker

  • @russphilly
    @russphilly9 ай бұрын

    why dont you make a 2nd part to this...holy Crap!...talk another 5 hours on this.., what did you say in this 19 minutes or so ? !!!!!

  • @daniellinehan63
    @daniellinehan6311 ай бұрын

    Phillie rooters #2 whiners in MLB behind Boston

  • @danocatster
    @danocatster3 жыл бұрын

    Thanks for helping clear up the slanders against Landis.

  • @danholm4952
    @danholm4952 Жыл бұрын

    Well if he did? Maybe the loser phillies would of won! What a horrible sports town....

Келесі