Thanks for your sharing the difference is so clear

Can you hook up more than one scanner to the same computer for increased quality?

Thanks for the comparisons! Any plans to post some outdoor tests to demo how the D435 fairs against ambient IR interference?

@conradf4105

6 жыл бұрын

yup kzread.info/dash/bejne/maZs2seKgdnVdrA.html

Thanks for your video, and I give up the idea to buy Intel D435. I am doing indoor wall scanning, and the depth accuracy is the most important issue. Any suggestions for the camera? I am thinking about using BlasterX senz3d.

@user-pc2fd5wg6w

5 жыл бұрын

Kinect is dead :( Kinect Azure is 399$ for July 2019

@RusticRaver

5 жыл бұрын

@@user-pc2fd5wg6w good news!

Have anyone tried realsense d series with faceshift studio?

In Kinetic, the depths are measured. While in RS, the depths are calculated. That makes the result different.

@AtulMishra-rm8sd

3 жыл бұрын

Can you please explain in brief

good morning friends can you please tell me which is the best configuration to buy a laptop to work with kinect v2? Thank you !

Wow, massive difference between TOF and stereo. TOF wins hands-down indoors. It will be interesting to see how the Realsense Lidar camera L515 compares, maybe it will be as good as the TOF based tech.

@conradf4105

4 жыл бұрын

yeah iam curious too

The Realsense is so inaccurate I don't see any application for it over the kinnect?

@artispeedy

5 жыл бұрын

it works outdoors

@wuliwuli241

5 жыл бұрын

@@artispeedy it works out door because it based on stereo vision and ir dot projector, but kinect v2 only based on laser. All 3D cameras which based on stereo vision work outdoors.

@wuliwuli241

5 жыл бұрын

tof camera is not so good when the work distance is not so far.

@Matt1Up

4 жыл бұрын

Look up software called Dot 3D and see if you still feel that way 😉

Does this video imply that Kinetic is better than Realsense camera?

@conradf4105

6 жыл бұрын

for this thesis you will have to compare both cameras under all conditions. The realsense can deliver the images at a higher frame rate and more resolution. Remember: This is just a short comparison of one indoor scene.

@khalilammour4245

6 жыл бұрын

Yea, that's true, I just wanted some opinions from your personal experience with both, as I would like to purchase one of them, What do you suggest?

@aydynbekshubladze4733

6 жыл бұрын

Khalil Ammour assalamu aleykum. I had personal experience with both cameras. Intel definitely has the higher framerate, FOV, and resolution but its point cloud is nowhere as precise as what Kinect offers. For my particular algorithm setup, Intel camera's data was simply too imprecise. The only reason i switched to the new camera was because of its other good features and also because kinect has to be powered by an outlet cable. If u are planning on getting intel camera, make very thorough research before doing so

@conradf4105

6 жыл бұрын

as far as i know the kinect v2 is discontinued

@khalilammour4245

6 жыл бұрын

Thank you Shubladze, I appreciate your feedback !

i have a kinect v2, with what software can i do these kind of video experiments?

@conradf4105

5 жыл бұрын

to view the point cloud of the Kinect v2 you can use the Kinect2.0 SDK on a Windows PC. For my Kinect v2 point cloud i wrote code that transfers the depth information to a Linux system running ROS. The Kinect v2 point cloud in this video is shown in RViz, a viewer for ROS messages.

@cheesyquaver

5 жыл бұрын

Brekel's suite of tools are perfect for Kinect2 workflows FYI

what is with the incredibly disturbing context of this video?

@conradf4105

5 жыл бұрын

Observation of nurses at a care bed :)

Hi, ConradF! I'm a developer/dentist and I'm planning to develop a tool where I can use a depth cam to get an accurate position of dental implants using scanbodies... Can you do me a huge favor??? I'd REAAAALLY appreciate if you could generate a point cloud of your mouth opened... I know it's an embarrassing thing to ask for, but it is my everyday life to look inside people mouths... Tks in advance!!!

@sechevere

4 жыл бұрын

Adriano: the "focal distance" would not give you the detail you need. The sensor requires the subject to be at least 2ft away / 60cm, with very little detail for what you need

The problem is not the camera, its the user. The real sense is still a developers tool, and its not plug and play. you can see how unstable the point cloud is. Yes the kinect is mature product, and you plug it in and just turn on with software. This video only proves that you are not skilled enough to perform a proper comparison.

@conradf4105

5 жыл бұрын

i really want to use the realsense! Please share your advanced knowledge how to set the parameters right. This was already the best i could get out of it with the supplied Real Sense Viewer...

@IfyStatement

5 жыл бұрын

@@conradf4105 these are for developers. They have updates all the time. First thing I recommend is updating the device firmware with realsence tools. Second I would make sure you always download the SDK and build it from source. Also a PC with devoted USB 3.1 is important. Point One has way more bandwidth. Then you need to buy a cable that is USB C 10gb bandwidth. I found only one cable locally that could perform this, and cost double Price. Good luck.

@conradf4105

5 жыл бұрын

Do you have any prove that the mentioned changes would improve the quality of the data? I would like to know that before i start to invest time here. As for this video, i used the latest firmware at this time. Nevertheless i dont use usb 3.1. because the specification of intel tells me i should use USB 3.0 Type - C. Building from source could be an option tho

@bullrunhunter6489

5 жыл бұрын

Conrad he is correct we just started playing with dev products ourselves and it is nothing to sneeze at. I am well versed in mechanical engineering aspects of my business yet when it comes to c or c plus, python, or various other dev platforms your world becomes vastly difficult if you don't know what you're doing. Fortunately I have a business associate with a bachelors in coding among ten years of additional experience. You can learn on your own and most forums will accept and help you. Be humble and you will maybe even get someone to start the coding for you.

@conradf4105

5 жыл бұрын

Iam familiar with c++ and other programming languages because I got an M Sc in Computer Science :D. I still dont understand what beeing able to write code has to do with the performance of the real sense. The viewer that is provided with the realsense promisses to be able to change every parameter of the camera. We used it here. At the time this video was made (upload date), it was not possible for us to get Kinect v2 like data out of the camera. This is all the video is showing. Maybe i will upload a short comparison again with the latest firmware.