"Or maybe I'll go in and delete that scene from Return Of The Jedi and release a super special edition. Would you like that smartass?" ROFL.

@DEU9002

8 жыл бұрын

But yodas green laser sword

1:59 CONGRATULATIONS you are the first Stormtrooper to ever hit his target!

@squid12825

4 жыл бұрын

Second at 3:33

But the little green laser sword

@lennyfais5040

7 жыл бұрын

Ben Attwood Underrated comment...

@dcb99filmz

5 жыл бұрын

Zero's little green laser sword is better

@obiwankenobi9141

5 жыл бұрын

But the little greenLaser sword is amazing.

@bullymaguire5687

3 жыл бұрын

ahh yap green sword...

@Dino23968

3 жыл бұрын

“That is some robotic bull#%$& nonsense.” How is it considered “robotic” to be a Jedi?

9:19 "How could somebody so stupid get a position in government!" I know that's crazy right, thankfully that would only happen in fantasy and not realty am I right?

@clarityreunited

7 жыл бұрын

dodopoopinpoop *COOOOOOOOUUUUGH* DONALD TRUMP AND HILLARY CLINTON *COOOUUUGHHHHHHHH*, sorry, I have an allergy.

@dodopoopinpoop

7 жыл бұрын

***** lolz exactly.

@Kevin-fr2zx

7 жыл бұрын

dodopoopinpoop ye

@ThatGenericPyro

7 жыл бұрын

"So this is how liberty dies... With thunderous applause..."

@duckdude4130

7 жыл бұрын

dodopoopinpoop seriously, jar jar is basically the reason everything happened.

Who else went \(0.0)/ ?!?!? when the guns didn't shoot lasers?

The "wipe his memory" thing never really bothered me. It's been shown Protocol droids get their mind wiped frequently. The first thing Owen told Luke to do was to wipe 3PO's memory, because he was still attached to a previous master.

So...HelloGReedo does double duty as a Stormtrooper and a Sailor? Nice. Thanks for the videos Shipmate

@HelloGreedo

8 жыл бұрын

+mgsgamer Was in from 2007 to 2011 :)

@mgsgamer

8 жыл бұрын

HelloGreedo nice. Where were you stationed? Thanks for your service

@jamesm1928

8 жыл бұрын

Thank you for your service HelloGreedo!!!!!!!!!!

@JonaszKeronOfficial

8 жыл бұрын

+The Great Reviewer ...

@jabawakee99

8 жыл бұрын

+HelloGreedo hooyah!

"With all due respect...This is dumb as Fuck" Gets me everytime hahahahah

"With all due respect... This is dumb as fuck."

@N05L31

9 жыл бұрын

hbk showstopper what?! I'm quoting the video, big whoop

@solmoore143

9 жыл бұрын

hbk showstopper You are.

Haha, the 'To Catch a Predator' parody was great 😂

@AroAceGamer

7 жыл бұрын

I actually I find it some what disturbing since it actually, though albiet unintentionally, equates prequel fans to sexual predators. It's called unfortunate implications.

@adonizi

7 жыл бұрын

+TheFluttershyFan Youre reading way too much into it.

@lennyfais5040

7 жыл бұрын

TheFluttershyFan Chris Handsome....

But the lil green laser sword

@Alex-ji6ob

7 жыл бұрын

LITTLE GREEN LASER SWORD I T T L E G R E E N L A S E R S W O R D

What the hell doesn't lead to the Dark Side?

I honestly feel that revenge of the Sith is actually pretty good

@harshbutt

9 жыл бұрын

Venom Joe lol.

@jonathanpartin9833

9 жыл бұрын

Venom Joe I do too!

Black suit and brown shoes? really?

@HelloGreedo

8 жыл бұрын

+Stoica Alin Blue suit.

@janerogerson5207

8 жыл бұрын

+HelloGreedo lol

@DEU9002

8 жыл бұрын

+Creeperninja176 but yodas green laser sword

I have a challenge for you. Criticize the original trilogy

@kyleADezisToysAGames

8 жыл бұрын

+Bobby Lee you can but compared to the prequels, they are not that big.

@1ajgtwm

8 жыл бұрын

+kyle estes Not that big? INCEST is bigger than any issue in the prequels. I need someone to explain that shit to me. When Luke find out about his sister was bigger reveal to me than Vader telling look that he is his father lol

@KylePhantomK94

8 жыл бұрын

+Bobby Lee I can write an essay about this shit, lets begin, bring on the fanboy rage... I rewatched the original trilogy just last night, and i have to say, is why the fuck didn't the rebels just beam the plans to the base on Yavin, when the the imperials attacked the tantive IV? it shouldn't take that long, let alone how could rebels that have ONE fucking base have the ability to destroy let alone capture the plans from a high tech powerful empire that we see thats even more powerful in empire strikes back, to its most powerful weapon plans... The fact the empire just sat on their asses saying "oh their not gonna find a weakness to our ultimate power in the universe" instead of thinking of ways "oh they have our plans, don't we have a backup somewhere? lets see where we fucked up so we can protect our weakness or implement and fix it so they don't destroy what clearly is the worst weakness in cinema/story telling history" Now lets cross out the prequels, I enjoyed them, i loved them, they had great ideas, and there is effort in them, but they aren't perfect movies, not even the originals, if you ask me the the only thing that is perfect that is in the star wars universe that is Kotor, Kotor is hands down better than the 6 movies.. Bioware knows how to make a good story in the star wars universe.. Yes even Kotor 2 (with restored content mod) is better than the the movies too.. But as a i was saying, in the prequels and in comics and the Clone Wars its stated that Tatooine is a source of pain for Anakin thats why i guess you cant say he didn't go down and take the plans himself personally and he had a team instead do it for him, but lets cross out the prequels, WHY THE FUCK DIDN'T VADER GO DOWN AND GET THE PLANS HIMSELF!? Look at the force unleashed expansion dark side alternate universe, starkiller went and got shit done by himself. I call it bullshit and laziness if you ask me. Let alone why is Vader taking orders from Tarkin? DUMB! I'm sorry thats sooo dumb.. I can go on and on.. But this is just a starter list.

@bobbylee1557

8 жыл бұрын

Kyle Phantom Also from as acting standpoint, it was a little flat. I mean of course it's better than anakin's acting in episode 2 but still, the acting is very one dimensional in the OT. At least with anakin you can see the inner struggle, with luke he might as well be jesus (for the most part). Having said this the OT acting is obviously better but people still shouldn't deem it infallible.

@KylePhantomK94

8 жыл бұрын

Bobby Lee I don't really care much about acting, i've seen series, primarily machinima and anime series, that have terrible acting, but i just don't care man, i care more about the action the plot and the characters...

This entire video is absolutely amazing. There are so many great quotes and great points made. As a Star Wars fan, discovering your channel was one of best things I could've done. Been subscribed for probably a year and a halfish.

Why are your blasters shooting bullets?

@At_Amsterdam

9 жыл бұрын

Probably copyright issues?

@NobleManager

9 жыл бұрын

But suddenly at 3:47 they do work correctly :v

@drhaxx7425

9 жыл бұрын

fenixman2 because todays kids dont want to see boring red streams anymore. thats why lucas will soon replace all blasters with mashine guns in the SUPER MEGA ULTRA ALPHA OMEGA edition of the original trilogy

@ian-op5fv

9 жыл бұрын

Dr Haxx nope, thats way to violent, blasters bolts in the next version of the original trilogy will be nerf darts that make a squeaky-toy noise on impact. you see; it's all about making the films more family-friendly.

@drhaxx7425

9 жыл бұрын

savage1493 and darth vaders dialog will be replaced with MLP quotes. To make it more appeling for female viewers

Had to pause and give a like for the Samuel L. Jackson rant.

That's the problem, you said you loved revenge of the sith. Believe me, the prequels are not as good as the original trilogy, but that's the problem, we compare these movies to the originals. We say all minor characters in these prequels are forgettable and shouldn't be praised, like general grievous or jango feat. But at the same time you have boba fett who is equally forgettable. Now I love all starwars characters but let's be real here, you can't say a silent bounty hunter that gets eaten by a sand vagina is better then some robot with 4 arms, they're equally minor, they don't need to be there. So let's not fight over characters and just watch the movies as they are. Star Wars.

@VaderTheWhite

8 жыл бұрын

+Frank Woods But Boba in Empire and Jedi was always treated as a background character. He was never built up. The fanbase is the one who latched on to him in a way Lucas never anticipated (he said that if he had known, he wouldn't have killed him in Jedi). With Grievous, he was stated to be a dangerous adversary, yet Obi-Wan took out two of his four hands like they were nothing. That's the difference.

@thevesp00

8 жыл бұрын

If you forget the originals and review the prequels they become 10x WORSE

@mariano1196

8 жыл бұрын

+Vader the White supposedly Grevious had some circuits fucked up since the end of the CN cartoon (which ends right at the beggining of ep. 3) Windu managed to damage him. So he wasn't in his prime However point aside I still hate how easily he got beaten

@Solo_Traveling

8 жыл бұрын

+Frank Woods Don't try to argue with Star Wars "fans" that don't like half of the Star Wars movies. I think it's rather useless. It's become trendy to say that the prequels sucked, so many people will just go by it. I remember when 'Revenge of the Sith' came out and everybody was saying how amazing it was. It got really good reviews back then. And then, a few years later, it turns out everybody hates these movies. Call me weird but it doesn't make any sense to me.

@Stonemask5

8 жыл бұрын

+LadyDors maybe that was the hype dying down?

Leia is adopted. Her remembering her mother has to do with her foster one..

@emile5921

8 жыл бұрын

Ross McCarthy I remember the line. But did she ever find out that she was not her real mother? I don't think we know that.. Do we? I am asking.. I really don't know :P

@mikkelfosbl

8 жыл бұрын

+Emile else he woulndt have said "real mother"

@emile5921

8 жыл бұрын

mikkel fosbøl But again, I don't think Leia knew she was adopted at that point.. That's how I always perceived it..

@omar1s1

8 жыл бұрын

+Emile When someone says to you "your real mother" It makes you say "wait, what?" Get your head out of your ass.

@omar1s1

8 жыл бұрын

***** You are too dense for words.

Revenge of the Sith is an amazing movie, you take it too seriously bro, you can do an equally lame analysis about episodes 4,5 and 6, but no, you saw them when you were a little kid and loved them, so when you watch them now you don't see how stupid they are too, these are movies primarily for kids, any kid who watched the prequels absolutely loved them, chill a bit bro and enjoy.

@DavisWOW

9 жыл бұрын

Lorenzo Rey Camejo I watched the prequels as a kid and still find them very bad. Those movies are just simply bad, shitty story with shitty characters and dialogues. Just because the title has the words Star Wars, that dosent mean you have to love a bad movie.

@lorenzoreyguitar

9 жыл бұрын

DavisWOW u didn't like them as a kid? Or did you like them and then heard all the internet backlash and changed your opinion about them ? I bet is the 2nd

@DavisWOW

9 жыл бұрын

Lorenzo Rey Camejo Well as kid I liked them especially ep 1. I found ep 2 kinda boring and lame even as a kid. But now after 16 years, with a lot of experience watching real good movies, and reading really good books, and stories I found them laughable. And I dont need others to form an opinion.

@lorenzoreyguitar

9 жыл бұрын

DavisWOW but if you are going to judge the prequel trilogy on that criteria, you should judge the original trilogy by the same standards, people hating on the prequels treat the OG trilogy like its this holy grail, when they are pretty bad too, a lot of stupid shit, you people hate on jar jar Bink's but don't hate on those annoying dumb huggy bears on return of the Jedi, or those stupid AT walker vehicles which are the most silly and unpractical vehicles you can think of, dialogues are pretty bad too, hate on anakins acting when Luke's isn't remarkable either, the dude never did much after star wars and its certainly not an amazing performance, I understand what you are saying about how growing up you've watched real movies and real.books but dude this is stuff for kids, if you go watch big heroes or frozen with that mindset you're gonna be disappointed on all the silly dialogues and stupid shit for kids, all star wars movies are movies for kids! You shouldnt judge them on different criteria ! When you watch toy story as an adult you still enjoy it because you know what's all about...

@VoltageFilms

9 жыл бұрын

Lorenzo Rey Camejo Except that the originals are good. He's not taking it too seriously he's analyzing it. People have done it for the originals and it turns out that the movies are actually amazing. The original trilogy has a fantastic story. The story still holds up today. Why else would people hate the prequels? For some reason when people say they hate them people like you just say it's because they're a fanboy. But no it's because they see that the prequels aren't as good. It's simple as that. They don't like the prequels because they aren't as good. Usually the people that like the prequels are younger and haven't realized yet that they aren't as good as the original masterpieces. That's just what I think though.

I like the prequels because i find the characters of obi wan, palpatine and Anakin interesting. I like the score. I like hope it showed that destroying the Jedi was balancing the force and how they were kinda bad

@jasminapejovski3753

8 жыл бұрын

The characters obi wan and palpatine were really interesting but I really wish the dialogue was better. The score really was amazing though and these movies aren't really that bad but for me it's just really hard not cringing at half of the things in these movies especially compared to the originals but that's just my opinion

@TechnologicallyTechnical

8 жыл бұрын

+British Nerd But how can you not see that calling the Jedi bad is a COMPLETE slap to the face to the entire franchise??? Are we supposed to hate Obi-Wan and Luke now because they're Jedi's? I thought we were supposed to root for them, but nope. Prequels say otherwise. Prequels say that they're bad. See what I mean?!

@britishnerd3919

8 жыл бұрын

Technologically Technical I always saw them as good people but working for an order that had too many contradictions and bad Jedi. During Prohibition there were several the police force was corrupt, but there were good, hard working police who were trying to do the right thing and that is how I see the Jedi in this film. Just because Obi-Wan and Luke are Jedi doesn't make them bad because they are the good fighting for the little person, but the Jedi Order had become too concerned with self-preservation. The Jedi needed a new breathe of life and that is what Luke was, making him even more of a hero for the Galaxy Far, Far Away.

@britishnerd3919

8 жыл бұрын

Blahblahblah14898 yeah, the clone wars sped it up, but I think that the cracks were already there

@TechnologicallyTechnical

8 жыл бұрын

Blahblahblah14898 But it kind of ruins Star Wars. It was always meant to be a nice, simple story of good vs. evil. Jedi are good, sith are bad. Sweet, simple, to the point, just like the originals were intended to be. Then the prequels went and confused all of that.

Honestly, criticisms of the prequels range from valid to pretentious nitpicking. Compared to several other movies that were released around the same time, they used a great deal of practical effects too. It's this kind of mentality that really divides the fanbase and its really not very fun to partake in when everyone is trying to justify their tastes and say why X movie is bad or what X movie did better than Y movie. But according to whom is your taste good or bad? The supreme chancellor of the internet? The only objective thing about any of the movies is that people who've seen them have an opinion on them. Its been over 10 years since this trilogy as finished, yet here we are, almost 2016, and people still won't get over it. And yes, I've seen the Plinkett reviews. They're very funny and great points are brought up, but do I seriously have to hate everything I read a negative review of?

@colonelcoover

8 жыл бұрын

+KAZ People hate the prequels because they actually suck I know shocking.

@KazuyaMithra

8 жыл бұрын

colonel coover​​ Then people are way too emotionally attatched to star wars to let such trivial things bother them. I know, shocking.

@colonelcoover

8 жыл бұрын

KAZ I don't give a shit about star wars but I hate the prequels the most.

@KazuyaMithra

8 жыл бұрын

colonel coover​ Hate is a pretty strong word for something you don't care about.

@adamp3223

8 жыл бұрын

+KAZ Could you give an example of the "pretentious nitpicking" you've observed in prequel criticisms? Also, art is subjective. In fact, almost all of human experience is subjective, so please don't insert objectivity into places it doesn't belong in. Thirdly, it's been over ten years, and the prequel trilogy hasn't gone away. If someone built a statue next to your house that just appalled you and made you shudder in disgust every time you walked by it, when would it stop offending you? Lastly, no, you don't have to hate everything yo read a negative review of. You can if you want to, but you don't need it, and it's bad for you. Form your own opinions. If your opinion is honestly that the prequels were good, that's fine! Just understand that other people have formed opinions as well. Some of us have loved Star Wars almost our entire lives. It's the world we escape into in our spare time. It might seem trivial to you, but we love it. It's not trivial to us.

This video is great, love finding older videos like this

You know....out of all people who don't like prequals, Greedos opinions seems most rational to me. It's not just blind fanboys complaining about minor things, but actually somne major plotholes and problems. Even though I loved Revenge of the Sith as a kid, I have to agree with him at everything, maybe except Yoda's lightsaber, that didn't bothered me that much. I would probably didn't considered prequals to be part of my cannon too, but than I watched The Clone Wars series, new and old one. Both are amazing and they make me forget about those bad movies.

@leoaguilar8684

9 жыл бұрын

Mr. Plinklett goes in to full detail why he hates the prequels

@Thane3999

9 жыл бұрын

Leo Aguilar But what he pin points are stupid things, most of the time. And sometimes misunderstands some things. If we did Red Letter Media review of Episode IV, V, VI liked this, the would be nothing left.

@SteveJonesGamingGWO

9 жыл бұрын

Leo Aguilar and that's cool for him,red letter media's reasoning is valid but I do find some of it fanboy bitching for the sake of fanboy bitching especially when you recongize that some of the faults (especially with elements of script) are in the original trilogy

@richis404

9 жыл бұрын

Thane3999 Confused Matthew pointed out most plot holes in his reviews

@samiamtheman7379

9 жыл бұрын

Steve Jones Gaming Something that Red Letter Media and the Nostalgia Critic both agree on is Anakin's portrayal isn't Hayden Christensen's fault.

Well the Prequels used more Practical effects than the Original Trilogy, funny sometimes when they think the movies are about almost entirely on a green screen.

@killvader1001

4 жыл бұрын

lol what? the OT is all practical effects and the PT used some practical effects so no they didn't have more than the OT. what a dumb comment. movies with lots of CGI don't have more practical effects than movies with no CGI

@ultrabrian8151

4 жыл бұрын

Starkill345 let me show you. kzread.info/dash/bejne/dqqkr7iioq_ZiZM.html

@mariogomez2386

4 жыл бұрын

Starkill345 Well the OT movies have blue screen, he can tell you that he’s not joking.

@wookiecookies9929

4 жыл бұрын

Starkill345 Dumb you say?, hmm. Everything seems to be CGI in the prequels, but I watched some videos and they seems to tell me that they used practical effects as well as the CGI, & pretty much more practical effects than the Original Trilogy.

@wonderfulwookiee6443

3 жыл бұрын

@@mariogomez2386 yes, they had blue screen, but not CGI. They composited read sets, models, and matte paintings onto the film

Episode 3... it's bad, but it's at least more watchable than EP1 and EP2....

@mxj67x3

8 жыл бұрын

Agreed

@gazebo3496

8 жыл бұрын

It's the watchable prequel yea

@CrunkKrow

8 жыл бұрын

+Shadowff61337 Episode 3 was amazing. Fuck the hate Trend bangwagon

@mxj67x3

8 жыл бұрын

CrunkKrow how was it amazing Suprise me

@CrunkKrow

8 жыл бұрын

Diego Vasquez All the lightsaber battles,The emotion it caught of the downfall of the Republican was dramatic depressing and spot on.Truly the Darkest of the entire Star Wars Series.Hayden Christiansons look and facial expressions in the movie were very well played to say the least.The environments were varied and very well done.My only complaints is some of the written dialogue and directing fell short but out of all the 3 prequels it was the ONLY prequel that was actually SHOWING us what was happening instead of just talking about everything constantly like 1 and 2. It actually had a lot of action and story.1 and 2 were pretty bad in my opinion but not 3.

When people watched the Original trilogy did they think Yoda never fought anyone before? He was a Jedi Knight, man.

@ajfanotreally2523

2 жыл бұрын

Yea idk how someone would be mad at yoda fighting. Perfect example of sometimes people just wanna go against the grain just cuz

@Connor17199

11 ай бұрын

​@@ajfanotreally2523I think it's just because of how ridiculous it looks. You can have him fight without him having a seizure

@AwesomeMooseSmile

7 ай бұрын

Because Yoda represents the real nature of the force. It's not a superpower you use to fight and be super OP, because Yoda, the strongest force user in the OT, isn't a strong character, he isn't an imposing figure, he's just a little gremlin, because the force is beyond the physical, it's a luminous source of energy larger than life and beyond the simple material world we know, which is why there are so many incredible life lessons to be gained from his teachings beyond just the applications of the force, themes of learning from failure and how important it is, doing instead of trying so the possibility of failure isn't in your head, focusing on where you currently are instead of fixating on the future so you can be more productive with achieving said desired future, these are all incredible lessons that don't just apply to learning the force, but to all of us, and that's why yoda is the perfect representation of the jedi and the force, not because he's the most powerful jedi. He even says himself "a Jedi uses the force for knowledge and defense, NEVER for attack". But sure, Yoda has foughten before, I'm not against the idea of that, but the big issue was HOW they did it. You want to make this big fight between Yoda and Palpatine, these incredible masters of the force, that's alright, great even, but the problem is they treated these two as just another jedi and sith by being these flashy lightsaber deulists, when a much better option would be to make them fight exclusively with the force. They're both incredibly powerful old wizards, and like I said, Yoda (and Palpatine to an extent) is beyond the physical limitations of his body, so having an all out force battle would not only fit and understand the characters infinitely more, but it would also be a completely unique fight that would be so much more climactic, grand, and memorable. Making it so Yoda is just this aggressive backflipping swordfighter who spouts goofy cliche dialogue not only misses the point of the character, but it's also creatively bankrupt, and THAT'S what people have an issue with.

@AgentZ46

7 ай бұрын

@@AwesomeMooseSmile Hit me with an essay over a comment I made 2 years ago.

@AwesomeMooseSmile

7 ай бұрын

@@AgentZ46 I didn't check :(

Prequel thoughts: 1) I wish the story had been different, that Anakin had been older and that his fall to the dark side amounted to more than teen angst. 2) I wish the films were better written, leaner and about 90% less goofy. 3) I wish George Lucas, 20 years older than he was when he decided to delegate the workload for Empire Strikes Back, had not attempted to write and direct these films all by himself. Both aspects suffer badly as a result. 4) I hate all the CGI. As a child, I used to daydream about fighting alongside the rebels on the blockade runner, storming the death star corridors with Han, Luke and Leia, escaping up the millennium falcon ramp, etc etc. The sets looked part of a real universe I could touch and my imagination bought into it in a big way. Same with the ships and the puppets. For whatever reason, my eyes recoil at all the CGI and I don't feel part of the universe of the prequels in that same magical way. 5) The prequels did improve from film to film for me: I thought Episode I was too childish; I at least enjoyed some aspects of Episode II more; Episode III was better again - though points 1-4 still stand.

@mvos858

4 жыл бұрын

Agreed

@Dino23968

3 жыл бұрын

“I may have gone too far in a few places.”-Lucas

The thing I liked about the prequels was that it introduced use to new worlds, like Mustafar, Coruscant (More thoroughly), Felucia, Kamino, etc. New species, and new characters like Qui-Gon (who is personally my favorite of the prequels), Mace Windu, Jango Jett, and many others. The factions such as the Republic and Seperatists (CIS) were also pretty interesting also. And maybe this is just me, but the Clones are one, if not, the most beloved things to come out of the prequels.

@ffabiang

4 жыл бұрын

All of this is what the sequel trilogy has gotten wrong.

The Samuel L Jackson thing isn't really fair since this movie came out at a time when he wasn't in everything. He wasn't nearly the scale of an actor, in terms of fame he was today

@Jes.117

8 жыл бұрын

true

@simplythebest2k

8 жыл бұрын

Is not valid critic is a prejudice just because it is part of the prequels. Say what you will about any prequel but if we go by the TFA rule of apology. Revenge of the sith is by far a better movie than TFA and some times even the original. Specially for what it brings to starwars.

@w-james9277

7 жыл бұрын

TFA is miles better than ROTS. It actually puts character and story over spectacle. ROTS is a bad movie imo. The characters are dull, the story is a mess, the CGI already looks dated, Anakin's turn to the dark side felt completely forced, the dialogue is horrible, its terribly shot and the directing is awful. Just because it has some flashy action and a good John Williams score doesn't make it good.

@simplythebest2k

7 жыл бұрын

W-James hahah TFA was the worst movie on the series. It destroys common sense and fantasy.

@w-james9277

7 жыл бұрын

John christopher TFA is a fantastic film and brought the franchise back to life. It great had acting, characters who are relatable with tons of personality, a fun and engaging plot, action which is well directed and always keeps our characters in the foreground, a great John Williams score, good humour, a great use of film techniques including sound, lighting, camera angles, mise en scene etc…A villain which is greatly developed and complex, great, timeless effects (minus some CGI), great atmosphere, great world building, great and interesting character motivations and character interactions, great pacing, letting the action be part of the story and tell it for us, great emotional drama and it was brilliantly edited. ROTS is a empty, meaningless spectacle with flat, clumsy writing. None of the characters talk like real people, and their mouths are full of nothing but unsubtle, in-your-face efforts to express simplistic emotions or pointless exposition about war and politics that means little and goes nowhere. Anakin Skywalker comes across as a naive idiot who swallows every single obvious lie that Palpatine feeds to him. Nowhere do you see the grim cynicism of Vader emerging. He's simply duped into agreeing with Palpatine's paper-thin suggestions that the Jedi are trying to take over the Republic and are a force for ill rather than good. Ewan McGregor is obviously phoning it in as Obi-Wan, and he could scarcely come across as more uninterested in the motions of CGI action and exposition-laden dialogue that he goes through, although that's completely understandable. Ian McDiarmid completely hams it up as Palpatine, but again a large amount of this is due to the flawed dialogue. Palpatine goes from being a reasonably believable manipulator, to being someone completely, obviously evil in this who makes no attempt whatsoever to disguise his malevolence from those around him, making his subjugation of Anakin very difficult to believe and dependent on Anakin being a complete moron. What this film needed to do, I would argue, is not make Anakin into such an overtly furious character who is drawn to the Dark Side through what largely amounts to anxiety, but rather to realise him as an embittered, power-hungry cynic who sees service to Palpatine as a vehicle for his own ambition. This only emerges as a single piece of throwaway dialogue in the film when he suggests to Padmé, as he does to Luke, that the Emperor may be overthrown. The transformation is unsatisfying and at no point do we see Anakin metamorphose from a fundamentally good Jedi and friend of Obi-Wan to becoming the character we see in Star Wars of 1977. In the original trilogy, you get the sense that the only reason Vader and the Emperor haven't killed each other already is that they're simply using each other. And when a new alternative comes into the picture (Luke) they're quite happy to kill each other. Revenge of the Sith is an entirely fake-looking assault on the senses from the opening battle above Coruscant to the final duel on Mustafar. The film is so visually noisy, full of overly crisp-looking computer generated ships, environs, soldiers and creatures that it looks more like a sequence of mid-2000s video game cutscenes strung together than a film. The action, which primarily involves incoherent laser blasting battles and shots of Jedi bashing away endlessly at each other's lightsabers, is so excessive and fake that it is not remotely exciting or suspenseful; rather it is boring and weightless with no sense of reality. I believe that the action should serve the story. George Lucas obviously believes that the story should only serve the action. In the original trilogy, every laser blast, every swing of a lightsaber had weight to it. . The character of General Grievous is the WORST secondary antagonist in film history. He had no motivations and he looked terrible. He obviously exists only to sell toys, as the "cool cyborg with four lightsabers". Not only does Obi-Wan spend ages chasing him on a big lizard that goes "whoop whoop" but there's simply nothing to him as a villain. He's just some guy with a Russian accent who then dies. As has been stated countless times before, Darth Maul should obviously have been the secondary antagonist for all three films, or failing that Dooku. Instead of the class of Christopher Lee, in this film we get a CGI cyborg who only exists as a crude foreshadowing of Vader with his robotic limbs and raspy cough. Otherwise he serves no purpose beyond getting Obi-Wan away from Anakin for a bit. Furthermore, think about how stupid his role in the opening sequence is. If you consider the situation, with the captured Chancellor on board, you have all three leaders of the Separatist movement in the heart of battle where they're incredibly vulnerable rather than coordinating things behind the lines: you have Grievous, the military leader, Dooku, the political leader, and Sidious, the true leader behind the scenes, all in the one place. If anything goes wrong, the entire plan goes up in smoke immediately. Palpatine didnt need to fight anyone with a lightsaber. Note that in Return of the Jedi he refers to Luke's lightsaber as "your Jedi weapon" as if such things mean little to him. Within the context of the Originals, it's perfectly easy to explain that the reason Vader wields a lightsaber is because he's a former Jedi and not because all Force users, light or dark, wield such weapons. Palpatine also doesn't need to get his face all messed up. Couldn't it have just been explained as old age and the wear and tear of the corruptive Dark Side? As has been said elsewhere, Order 66 makes the Jedi, who previously have been shown in the Prequels as amazingly resilient, look hopelessly incompetent. Beyond the straightforward massacre at the Temple, there's no sense of what Obi-Wan describes in Star Wars as Vader helping the Empire hunting down and destroying the Jedi knights. By piloting Anakin's ship, is R2-D2 somewhat complicit in his crimes? I shouldn't have to even dignify this with a response because of what an utterly absurd proposition it is to argue that Revenge is better than the original trilogy and the force awakens. By any standard, the Original Trilogy and The Force Awakens are better films. The acting is better. See the confrontation between Luke, Vader and the Emperor on the second Death Star for an example of character drama done extremely well, by Hollywood sci fi action standards. The action is better: the lightsaber duel and the Battle of Endor are both composed in a way that is coherent, rather than just a nonsensical mess. The Original trilogy and Force Awakens also succeeds by actually having actual plots. Revenge of the Sith doesn't. In Revenge of the Sith a bunch of shit just happens in order to get the pieces in place for the Original Trilogy. Return of the Jedi for example ends on a meaningful note with the image of Anakin's redemption, unlike the utterly meaningless shot of the unambitious Uncle Owen posing like Luke at the end of Revenge of the Sith, even though Owen is completely unimportant (it could have at least been Obi-Wan.) The effects are also better in the Original Trilogy and The Force Awakens. Observe the creature feature of Jabba's palace for enjoyable, practical effects, compared to the mind-rotting CGI of Revenge at every turn, especially Obi-Wan's lizard thing and the inhabitants of that planet. Obi-Wan in Revenge (these characters no longer develop in any significant way except for Obi-Wan realising, in the context of the Prequels, what an abysmal failure he's been as Anakin's master) I can't really think of anything from it that I like except maybe that it's cool to see Vader and hear James Earl Jones again, even if the dialogue he has to deliver is eye-rollingly awful. Revenge of the Sith is a hollow, empty piece of bombast with no drama or interest. It's crap.

I honestly don't care what people think of this movie, I love it!

@SycoSight

7 жыл бұрын

Yoshifan1219 you're entitled to an opinion. Even if it's a bad one that everyone will judge you for.

@blue5standingby684

7 жыл бұрын

I don't mind Revenge Of The Sith even though I far prefer Return Of The Jedi I won't judge you for your opinion. To each his own.

@tylerskiss

7 жыл бұрын

I'll say this- for what Episodes I and II set up, RotS was as good as one could hope for. Minor gripes aside, it was a solid Greek Tragedy in Space. Yes, there are so many things they could have done better, but most of those things were already set up by the first 2 films. I feel, if somebody handed you Eps I & II and said "this is what we got so far, we need you to declutter this mess and stick the landing as best you can", then RotS would be something you could hand in proudly.

@alejandrokaplan7243

4 жыл бұрын

This comment feels like An actual quote of a fan

@Yoshifan1219

4 жыл бұрын

Alejandro Kaplan lol that’s to be expected from someone who was 15 years old

I'm sorry but I will still call Episode 3 arguably my favourite movie (Either that or Episode 6) Maybe its not so much the movie itself but what it represents. For me it represents the ending of the good days of the Republic and the Jedi. I consider the good days Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008 series) not the earlier prequels. Episode 3 is simply the dawn of a new era. I did agree however Yoda should have stayed more of a monk than a warrior. Nonetheless, I will still always love the prequels (AND ORIGINALS TOO) with all my heart. I'm no less a fan. Keep making good videos Greedo!

@harshbutt

9 жыл бұрын

jasonvideos5 lol.

@MK-oz2lf

9 жыл бұрын

harshbutt I know right? lol #oyvey

@jonathanpartin9833

9 жыл бұрын

The Electrocist Why so harsh! This movie's awesome and you know it!

@SonGara

9 жыл бұрын

"All Jedi had was a bunch of fuckin' muppets!"-Dante lol

@jonathanpartin9833

9 жыл бұрын

Its much better than the previous two. Dont care what anyone says

actually, revenge of the sith is probably my 2nd or 3rd favourite star wars movie. if you can tolerate the dialogue its not that bad

@jk844100

9 жыл бұрын

So basically if you ignore 60% of the movie it's "not that bad"?

@The9garr

9 жыл бұрын

oops

@The9garr

9 жыл бұрын

jk844100 more like 40% although in your defence, i havnt watched any of the star wars movies in a year or 2. im saving them for some marathons ill do before episode 7

@jk844100

9 жыл бұрын

Mr Kitten no, they said if you tolerate the dialog it's not that bad. So I'm just saying that if you "tolerate" (ignore pretty much) what makes up at least half this movie it's "not that bad". This movie is made up of only 2 things: mindless action and mindless dialog.

@The9garr

9 жыл бұрын

jk844100 tolerate, not exactly ignore

"..swinging his litlle green laser sword." That sounded so weird

I like how you killed General Grievous

@deez1883

3 жыл бұрын

*no*

Taking the piss out of the effects and greenscreen while greenscreening yourself... Oh the irony :')

@leoaguilar8684

9 жыл бұрын

It's that EVERYTHING was green screen

@jasonli3404

9 жыл бұрын

Except HG is one lone youtuber and the team behind the prequels was huge. Your comparison makes no sense.

@bwcmakro

9 жыл бұрын

Sam Cooper they did it because they could. He does it out of necessity.

@turnburn26

9 жыл бұрын

Sam Cooper At least he doesn't fill it to the brim with background sky traffic and pod-racers.

@ASCG5000

9 жыл бұрын

...Because HG has the budget of a few dollars while LA had millions of dollars...

"Binks shot first" (?) I hate myself for this comment

@WillPattenden

9 жыл бұрын

ComanderScar That's good because Hello Greedo didn't

I think you're way too hard on the prequels.

@henryambrose8607

7 жыл бұрын

Vasily Petrolev Agreed. They do have lots of awfulness about them, but ROTS is definitely not a bad movie.

@foxybingo1112

7 жыл бұрын

Henry Ambrose yes it is

@impulse5674

6 жыл бұрын

This video was meant to be a lot more funny than serious I think

I like the Prequels but love the original trilogy!

@Ommialfonzou

6 жыл бұрын

The Zhark wow 👏 real Original 5 year old

@TooCooFoYou

6 жыл бұрын

Prototype Blasters, maybe?

@fleetmastermichael

6 жыл бұрын

Lol I prefer the prequels my self

Greedo, been subscribed since the first changes video (blows my mind that that was 3 years ago, and you've still been putting out some of the best content on this site. Keep it up, man, and thank you.

I disagree w/ you about Sam Jackson in Kingsmen, but he was definitely wrong for Star Wars. Also he erased 3PO's mind, but not R2. And how come Obi Wan didn't recognize R2 when he saw him in A New Hope?

@jimmothyjohnson

9 жыл бұрын

The Dashboard He probably just saw him as another astromich droid. Kenobi probably doesn't remember him, but might have if he lived a bit longer...

@dialecticalmonist3405

9 жыл бұрын

The Dashboard "And how come Obi Wan didn't recognize R2 when he saw him in A New Hope?" Because it was stylistically designed to be that way.

@thedashboard9562

9 жыл бұрын

Jimmothy Johnson I don't buy that. He's been around that droid for years. His padawan and friend took it w/ him nearly everywhere. There's no way he forgets R2-D2.

@danck941

9 жыл бұрын

Jimmothy Johnson He never said he did not recognize R2. He said he did not remember owning any droids. He never owned R2; if anyone ever owned R2 it would be Anakin. Kenobi wasen't lying since he never really owned R2. He was simply answering the queston Luke asked him. If Luke had asked him if he recognized R2 he probily would have said yes.

@jimmothyjohnson

9 жыл бұрын

Daniel Knighton Ahh. That makes sense.

Lol I actually liked it when Yoda says "Not if anything to say about it, I HAVE!!"

you should make a series of to catch a prequel lover.

@Caitykorn

8 жыл бұрын

I actually enjoy episode 3 Episode 2 was terrible And episode 1 is watchable Overall 6/10 to the whole trilogy

@joaquin9190

8 жыл бұрын

To Catch A Prequel Lover Episode 1 Jar Jar Episode 2 Padamè? Episode 3 Jango Fett? Idk I'm just listing random characters.

11:16 when you were asking how Leia remembers her mother. She was talking about her adoptive mother not Padme. Of course she wouldn't know who Padme is she died when Leia was still a newborn baby.

@TheTendermen

7 жыл бұрын

"Do you remember your mother, your REAL mother" Luke was asking about Leia's REAL mother, obviously he was not asking about her Adoptive mother

@rangogamer1386

7 жыл бұрын

Liam Fosdike Bro her adoptive mother. Senator Bail Organa's wife is the only mother Leia has ever knew growing up of course she was talking about her adoptive mother, she probably didn't even know about Padme

@TheTendermen

7 жыл бұрын

RangoGamer Then why didn't she respond the fact that Luke said REAL mother signifying that she was adopted. In fact according to the visual biography in StarWars.com, it was common knowledge she was adopted. www.starwars.com/databank/princess-leia-organa-biography-gallery

@username45739

7 жыл бұрын

yawn

@mvos858

4 жыл бұрын

@@rangogamer1386 she knew she was adopted

I like revenge of the sith but knot the over satcheration of light sabers

@luxy9530

7 жыл бұрын

Not really

@treverp4938

7 жыл бұрын

scifi super hero nerd 231 Pritchard I don't mind it. Doesn't make me get bored of light saber fights or make them lose there coolness .

" 'I want to be a master' this shit is blasphemy" 😂😂😂

I love that your one those youtubers that hide their faces and gives you a certain unique aspect.

Shit on this movie as much as you want but this is still my favourite Star Wars movie of all the time

I have an idea for the C3P0 problem. So C3P0 was built by Anakin. He was close to both Anakin and Padme. We also have proven that the droids have emotion just like the humans do. Throughout the movies including this one, show C3P0 get closer and closer to them. Wasn't he there when Anakin hurts Padme? If he wasn't put him there and have him speak out to Anakin. Have him try to defuse his master and long time friend. Then when Anakin still lashes out, he feels hurt and betrayed. Don't have his memory being wiped be a convenient sentence spewed last second. Have it be a conscious choice on C3P0's part. Make the pain from the whole incident to much for him, so he asks R2 to wipe his memory, so that he doesn't have to remember all of that. You could also use this to add a new layer to their friendship. Or, you know, not have Anakin build C3P0 in the first place.

The opening of this video is cathartic for me. Afterward when the music starts blasting and you get all suited up no matter how lethargic I'm feeling I am motivated to go do something. This video really fuels me up to battle it out with all the trolls who want to hate on TFA or Rogue One (even though they have not even seen the film yet).

"Would ya like that, smart ass?" Hahhahahaha. I freakin' love your vids man.

I love how close it was to "to catch a predator". I was dying so hard throughout it all. You are amazing Greedo, well done.

The one thing I will say (because I get that the special effects is way too much) but the purpose and message of the Prequels is that the Jedi are basically neutered, cold, self righteous jackasses. Also yeah there’s a lot of lightsabers in the Prequels because this is the era where there were a shit ton of Jedi and that was the Jedi’s weapon of choice

Dude your jar jar impression had me roaring. Spot on.

HelloGreedo, where'd you get your helmet? I need me one of those.

Plot twist Hello greedo went as Han Solo and his friend went as greedo therefore we've finally seen Hellogreedos face.

I LIKED Revenge of the Sith

@TheKaiTetley

8 жыл бұрын

Yeah, a lot of people do. Many fans consider it the best in the series.

@ChrisPTenders

8 жыл бұрын

I think George didn't have that many ideas for Episodes I and II, but Episode III was his baby... his pride and joy. When I watch it, I can't help but think he poured every ounce of his soul into perfecting it.

@mikeythethrashmetalhead7102

8 жыл бұрын

So did I. I just came back from watching all the prequels back to back and well, now I know how dark that movie really is. I agree with what +Chriss Merritt said about how he didn't really have a lot of ideas for Episodes I and II, but had a lot of ideas for III. That movie is a masterpiece in my opinion.

@TheKaiTetley

8 жыл бұрын

+Mikey the crazy band lover Is that Dimebag Darrel in your profile picture? If so, that is awesome. Would have loved to have seen them live.

@mikeythethrashmetalhead7102

8 жыл бұрын

TheKaiTetley Yep. Dime and Slash.

My friend yelled “Holy fuck!” when Anakin pulled out his lightsaber on the younglings, it got the theater cheering

HelloGreedo, prior to discovery of the Despecialized Editions from Harmy, what was your preferred way to watch the trilogy? Blu-ray, despite the special edition changes? VHS? Laserdisc?

more prequel bashing....whatever

@oopiumosmo1062

8 жыл бұрын

at least its funny

@colonelcoover

8 жыл бұрын

+Julian Morgan People hate the prequels because they actually suck I know shocking.

@janerogerson5207

8 жыл бұрын

+Casper jasper yup!

@Dukeybookey

8 жыл бұрын

There kid movies yourll all a bunch of fucking dumbass the prequels ARE KID FILMS IM GETTING SICK OF YOU OLD FUCKS BASHING ON IT EVERYONE 26 and younger likes it beside you old fuck bags SHUT UP ALLREADY

@oopiumosmo1062

8 жыл бұрын

+Zhake Rape wtf? do you consider anakin touching padme creepily in that one part a rape?

God, talk about old nostalgic original trilogy elitist fanboys, hellogreedo I enjoy alot of your videos, we both love star wars but do you like anything other in the star wars universe BESIDES the original trilogy? Is anything in the star wars universe considered "true star wars material" outside the original trilogy to you? I realize that your views on the prequals are just your opinions but stop stating them as if it's part of some "true star wars fan handbook". Do you realize how many star wars fans became fans cause of the prequals? I'd rather have a whole generation of star wars fans who love all 6 movies opposed to half of the stars wars saga.

@conradojavier

9 жыл бұрын

Justin Overton It's only Canon when They spend their money on Practical effects.

Where do you get your prop stuff?

where did they get those blasters they have at the beginning?

Before I start, I LOVE the original trilogy more than anything. I hate the Phantom Menace and I fall asleep to Attack of the Clones. Episode III though was a good movie. If you focus too much on how bad this movie is compared to the originals, you won't enjoy it for what it is. It's not a bad movie. It's nowhere near as good as the originals but you make it sound like its the worst thing to happen since Phantom Menace. Another thing I don't get is that everyone complains about using CG and green screen over special effects. Look at Avatar, 90% of it was CG. What happened to it? Oh right it made $2 billion and unlike Episode 1, it had no previous material to hold it up. Plus it was a great movie. CG doesn't make a bad movie, the director does. George did whatever he wanted with no one telling him what was wrong and not. That worked in the original trilogy. He had no big named company to answer to and he made 3 of the best films in history. He then got a big head, and thought he could do whatever he wanted and get away with it. George is a good story teller. Look at the basic plot of the prequels, it's actually pretty good and they had the amazing actors to make what could have been one of the best movies ever made. But George had no one to answer to and he made the prequels. Remember, Episodes 5 and 6 were written by George but were directed by two different directors and they gave us the two best Star Wars movies. It's actually a shame that the directors aren't given the credit they deserve. and passed away with most fans forgetting about them. Now imagine if Steven Spielberg or James Cameron directed the prequels, then they would be amazing, but George was the writer, producer, and director and had no one to answer to but himself. For this next film, they have a whole team of people who are dedicated Star Wars fans working on Episode 7. Who knows if this will be good or not but it looks promising. The last thing to point out is that we shouldn't ignore the prequels. It's been 10 years since Episode III came out and and there's no way to get rid of them. It's time to recognize their existence and move on. It's getting old how every Star Wars fan is dissing on the prequels instead of making videos on how great the originals were. Bashing the prequels doesn't make them go away.

@DavisWOW

9 жыл бұрын

Zombotron5678 I agree on the CGI. CGI dosent ruin movies, if its done right, like in the LOTR. However too much CGI can take away the action, and look too clean, and out of the place (like in the Hobbit 3). So movies have to find the balance bethween cgi and practical effects. My biggest issue with epsiode 3 is the way that Anakin turned to the dark side. I mean fighting for the loved is a beautiful aim, but IMO it is just too overused in movies, almost every movie is about that. So the way he actually turned is just too unsatisfying to me, I expected a way better story with actual hard decisions, and a depth to the characters. I mean Anakin just turned, and after that he goes and murders everyone he knew and grown up with, even the children. WTF? And Sidious says he cant revive Padme if she dies, cause its only been done by one sith before. BUT Padme gives birth in like the NEXT DAY! So why didnt Anakin realise that he cant save Padme? BTW how could've Padme died during childbirth in a technological wonderland, in a hospital under the supervision of future doctors? And then, Padme dies without any actual reason. And the prequels made the Jedi look like an assembly for idiots. They should have realised that Sidious is a sith (Windu even say they were LOOKING for a sith!), and like Greedo said, they should have sent more Jedi to get down Grievous (and Maul in ep 1, just imagine 50 jedi in front of him at the palace, they could have easelly capture him alive, and solve everything in ep 1). So a lot of things dosent make any sense in ep3. And for me the fact that the Senate just accepts, that Sidious made the 1000 generations old democracy to dicature is just too stupid. I mean it was the end days of the war, there was no reason to a dictature anymore. So even tho ep 3 is way better than the first 2, it still has very bad story (with a lot of plotholes, and contradictions to the originals) and the characters are still uninteressting, boring and badly written (the dialogues are very bad too).

@thatonestormtrooper2760

9 жыл бұрын

Dont get me started on avatar I hated that movie HATED it I never understood the hype.

@MK-oz2lf

9 жыл бұрын

Zombotron5678 After AVATAR made its $$$$ people practically moved on and forgot about it right away. It didn't have "staying power" that other franchises have achieved for pop culture. The real AVATAR movie came out in 1992 actually. Back then we called it, "FERN GULLY: THE LAST RAINFOREST". Cheesey but charming non the less. RIP Robin Williams.

@Zombotron5678

9 жыл бұрын

Alright so, DavisWOW, I can see how that would be a problem for Episode III. I mean no one suddenly turns evil and slaughters hundreds of Jedi, including friends and children. Padmé dying during childbirth because she lost the will to live isn't exactly the best way either. If I were to do it Id take a darker turn by having Padme have kids and either killing herself or die at the Emperor's hands. With Palpatine being a Sith, would you expect ot? Ok we all did but they didn't. For example, unless you're into conspiracies, you probably would be shocked if say Obama turned out to be a Nazi or had ties to Terrorist organizations. Everyone trusted him, although with caution as the war began to end. The Jedi didn't have the resources to send 50 Jedi onto Grievous. Geonosis saw the massacre of 100+ Jedi, and hundreds more were killed during the war. And most of what remained of the Jedi were either spread thin across the galaxy continuing the fight or stayed at the temple cause many Jedi did not want to fight or were protecting the temple. And then Obi-Wan was a leading, lifetime member of the Jedi Council and one of the best fighters the Jedi Order had plus he had experience fighting with Grievous, being one of the few Jedi that survived one of his attacks, let alone dozens of them. And while Grievous was a great fighter, he was a coward. He would run and hide if too many Jedi attacked him at once. And even if he didn't, if you've seen the Star Wars: Clone Wars mini series, 7 Jedi attacked him and he killed 4 of them, nearly killed two of them, and Ki-Adi-Mundi almost died fighting him. And there was also the droid army and Magna Guards, which were specially trained to hunt and kill Jedi. The Senate issue you bring up, I agree. They tried covering up by saying that they were corrupt but not a single one of them realized that they were following a power-hungry Sith Lord? Not very convincing. The movie had a bunch of flaws but as a fan of the X-Men Franchise, I'm use to continuity errors and plot-holes. The characters were uninteresting, besides Yoda, Obi-Wan, Grievous, and Sidious, but that's because of George Lucas. I mean Samuel L Jackson was boring in that movie. The same guy that plays Nick Furry and was on Snakes on a Plane, Jurassic Park, and many more films that he rocked in, was the most boring character in the film. That one stormtrooper, that's understandable. Not everyone likes the same movies. I actually have a friend who hated Star Wars even though everyone she's friends with are Star Wars nuts (like me). So that's alright. The Electrocist, that's because Avatar's Sequels were way too delayed to make much hype, say Empire Strikes Back never came out, I doubt Star Wars would be where it is today because that movie added Yoda and most importantly, I Am Your Father, one of the most memorable and shocking quotes in movie history. Fern Gully: The Last Rainforest, is that really what Avatar is based off of? I'll have to check out that movie sometime.

@DavisWOW

9 жыл бұрын

Zombotron5678 I agree with you . IMHO ep3 should've benn split into two episodes: into ep 2 and e3. And AOTC should'been ep 1 (TPM has almost nothing to do with the story, only very small parts, I the story would be even better imho without midiclorians, or the prophecy) Or maybe SW prequels would've been better in a series like Game of Thrones. Well at least in my opinion ep3 feels too rushed, Anakin suddenly turns, the jedi suddenly gets destroyed, the Senate suddenly turns a 1000 generations old democracy to dicatorship. It tried to tell a story what needed at least 2 movies (the first part could've ended with Anakin's turn) And I remember watching the clone wars mini-series back in 2003-4 and Grievous was a fckin badass there. But in ep 3 they made him like a standup comedy guy. IMHO Grievous would've been enough as a villain during the whole 3 movies under Palpatine. IMO the fact that there were 2 sith lords (Maul and Dooku) comming out of nowhere, and died like they were absolutely unimportant is just simply bad. Siths should've been unique, and not on every fckin corner. And I love X-men series too since first class. DoFP was a great movie IMO, and we dont care about the plot-inconviences, because they are good movies. But the SW prequels arent good movies (IMO ofc) so the plotholes just make them far worse.

Man your George. Lucas voice is amazing

"Do you have to be in every fucking movie?" - Loved that one

what is the soundtrack that starts at 6:52 ???

Well. Episode 3 was my favourite and I have seen all the star wars movies.

This is fucking brilliant, love it when you do Lucas from 10.25 perfect.

Where did you get your stormtrooper helmets?

Where did you get that dl-44?

Uh,are you gonna kill my dad? He showed me revenge of the sith the first time when I was 8.😥

9:19 Its pretty standard IRL actually. The dumbest people get the most powerful positions.

@n0nsticknick

9 жыл бұрын

BUT THAT'S NOT WHAT I WANTED TO SEE SO ITS DUMB AND MAKES NO SENSE. That seems to have been his mindset while making this video.

@TheSpacecraftX

9 жыл бұрын

Nick Bruce I hate it too but I'm just making the observation that it''s not far off from real life. Unfortunately. It's just out of place in a world where there are so many apparently wise people to guide the world.

@SomeHarbourBastard

9 жыл бұрын

Nick Bruce Remember. There was an American Senator recently, who thought that North America shared a border with Africa!

@NemosHusbandswife

9 жыл бұрын

+Roger Rabbit And some think Climate change is fake... *sigh*

one of my favorite videos of all time

I get so nostalgic for these old videos

6:07 I knew Ep. 3 had something redeeming about it!

Dear lord that "Blaster" fight was simultaneously the most badass and hilarious thing I've ever seen....

Why do the Star Wars guns make normal guns sounds? Are laser sounds copyrighted?

8:12, but dont you appreciate that this is the purpose of anakin and Yodas interaction here, to highlight the failings of the jedi order and enrich the story of anakins fall and the destruction/renewal of the order? This aspect of the prequels is crucial and personally is one of the most intriguing to me, even if it's not what you wanted to see.

"Your father wanted you to have this when you were older, but your uncle wouldn't allow it." "He feared you'd follow old Obi-Wan on some damn fool-idealistic crusade like your father did." This backstory gave SO MUCH potential for a REAL prequel storyline between Owen and Anakin! It's so easy to envisage Owen being the grounded sibling, bailing Anakin out of a major ordeal and then arguing with Anakin about continuing down that road. Later after further burdening Owen with his son AND THEN wanting his son to have his lightsaber, Owen forbids it fearing it would just corrupt Luke in the same way. There could've been several PASSIONATE arguments between the two, providing such rich character development it would've made people actually CARE about the tragedies that would later transpire. Empire is a perfect example of that. Han and Leia's arguments really endeared them to us, so by the time Han is tortured and lowered into Carbonite, we really feel Leia's pain. THAT'S Star Wars.

Excellent video and excellent analysis, as usual. I agree with you so much.

Hey Hello Greedo, do you like Ewan Megregor performance as obi wan, I know some lines Lucas gave him were bad, but mostly he was great, what do you think, I'm curious

Despite being mainly a joke he puts up so many good points about the prequels This video definitely aged well with people suddenly thinking George Lucas is a mastermind and the prequels are suddenly a work of art

@dymoure

3 жыл бұрын

Couldn’t agree more. People glorify the entire prequel era way too much now just because they’re funny to make fun of.

@hermos3602

3 жыл бұрын

We didn't suddenly praise the Prequels. We always have, it's just that the small minority that hated them were louder.

@hermos3602

3 жыл бұрын

@@dymoure People gave loved those films since TPM came out back in 1999. I don't know why you people seem to ignore that.

@jackbruno953

3 жыл бұрын

@@hermos3602 Nobody liked the phantom menace what are you on about, people only liked it when it first came out because of hype but months after the film came out that’s when critics and fans starting panning the film. The prequels are all very flawed films with revenge of the sith being exception, even then I think it’s overrated. The Clone wars is what saved the prequels and glued it together. The story that prequels have is good but the execution was horrible. The sequel are the opposite, with the story not being so good but a better execution, despite its high budget and great acting it’s gonna be harder to fix those films

@420K

2 жыл бұрын

George Lucas IS a mastermind, and the prequels are indeed a work of art :)

Oh look, an OT purist I hope you enjoyed the sequels, you deserved it

@videogamesworld01

2 жыл бұрын

he did enjoy tlj

@tristanskywalker1998

Жыл бұрын

We found the bitter nerd.

@Connor17199

11 ай бұрын

He did

I love the effort he puts into these videos hahaha!

2:30 can someone please tell me where he got the helmet in the middle

That moment when you think General Grievous is one of the coolest characters...

I like "Revenge of the Sith" But.....yeah. Yoda using a Lightsaber is still dumb as fuck and so Anti-Yoda

@hermos3602

3 жыл бұрын

How so?

i wanted to ask you if you are going to try to be an extra in any of the coming star wars movies?

Episode three is my favorite of the prequels but this video is absolutely hilarious, Keep it up!

Something awesome we got from the prequels. MEMES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

@SpeedyBlur2000

Жыл бұрын

NOOOOOOOOO!!!

When it comes to Jar Jar, not even stormtroopers miss.

why are the guns making real bullet noises instead of the normal blaster sound?

what the song that plays after he kills jar jar in think that song would be a good ringtone gone?

I really do consider episode 3 my favorite star wars out of all 6 movies

@harshbutt

9 жыл бұрын

Buddy System lol.

I love his George Lucas skits lol.

Dude, this is great

in Grand Rapids, MI that night (the premier) the midnight showing was, of course, sold out... But the Twelve-0-one AM showing still had seats available. Everyone was so focused on being the first ones. They had waited three days in line. I walked right up to the window and bought my ticket for the Twelve-o-one AM showing 20 minutes before the show, and saw it one minute after they did...

General Grievous was such a disappointing character. I remember thinking he was going to be the new Darth Maul kind of character for Revenge of the Sith based on how fantastic he was in the 2003 Clone Wars series, but then in the film they made him this complete coward who runs away from everything. And they continued that trend in the 2008 Clone Wars series unfortunately.