Lets calculate how long ymir would take to make these titans. (I used "." to indicate decimal numbers, and "," to indicate the power of thousend for reading) Decide the titans volume, decide the volume of her bucket... Then assume that each bucket takes additional walking, and sculpting. Even just one collossal would take a monumental amount of time. For the sake of simplicity imma assume that the volume of the collossal titan is about 33% of a cylinder. 60m(the feet are burried for stabillity) By 12.5m, and the 33%= 2454.37 cubic meters. (radius^2*pi*height) *1000 cuz each m3 holds 1000l 2,454,370 litres per titan. Then the bucket. I assume its a simple 10l bucket. Thats 245,437 walks per collossal. Even if she took one minute per bucket (which is definitely wayyyy to fast) it would take 170.5 DAYS PER TITAN DEAR GOD. then multiply that by 573,084 for all the titans in the wall... 267,610 years... she spent at least over 267 millennia mentally doing that task..... You can easely modify the awnser if you think that a minute per bucket is too slow (double the time if you think it fits better, or multiply by 5, i dont mind), or if you think that the titans are 50m tall (*5/6) I know my method was very very crude, but i hope it shows the immense amount of labour that Ymir had to endure for only one command.

@eloquit9489

2 жыл бұрын

AMAZING!! Thanks for the huge amount of work you put into it 🔥🔥

@greentitan0262

2 жыл бұрын

@@eloquit9489 I was curious so i crunched the numbers.

@TCS-vy7us

2 жыл бұрын

You deserve all the likes possible💀✨

@bfFAN221

2 жыл бұрын

Pog 😳 But now the real question is: how much does one minute of in-Converging Paths time last in the real world (or better off, one day), seeing as what we know from Zeke conveying to Eren that time moves faster within the Paths (or in this case, time in reality moves slower compared to it). Now that'd be a doozie 0_o

@saiki244

2 жыл бұрын

@@bfFAN221 it's like trillion yrs

If it was 573,084 Beast Titans instead, Levi could've finished off The Rumbling singlehandedly

@jesusdubz5285

2 жыл бұрын

Straight FACTS

@gamanzhiydanil

2 жыл бұрын

Let's say Levi has energy to kill 100 beast Titans a day(very bold estimation), it would take him around 15 years to kill all of them. I assume he needs to rest too, and I wonder how many blades it would take🤔

@moxielovesu

2 жыл бұрын

@@gamanzhiydanil nah man Levi only needs 1 blade

@TheGreatBigBo11

2 жыл бұрын

@@gamanzhiydanil he only sleeps like 3-4 hrs per day so

@regotub

2 жыл бұрын

It's gonna be easy since they are pure titans

That was a very Relaxing way of analyzing the Apocalypse

@wowhowbizarre8176

2 жыл бұрын

We prefer to call it the cleansing

@atharvapagnis2564

2 жыл бұрын

🤣

@epicstudio7185

2 жыл бұрын

Chill beats for studying

@s1mpl3x95

2 жыл бұрын

@@epicstudio7185 lmao

@agentkirifuda_shank7071

2 жыл бұрын

xD

the wall titans are actually 60 meters tall, just like the colossal titan shifter. the walls are only 50 meters high, because 10 meters of the wall titans are in the ground, so nobody can dig under the walls

@mr_nobody8587

2 жыл бұрын

I wanted to comment this too i remember a story about this in an episode

@user-re3nr9fd6f

2 жыл бұрын

No the wall titans are 50 meter tall. You can see here at 1:23 how their feet are not underground. And in the anime scene, you can see the same thing none of their feet are underground when the walls are un hardened.

@yourpetugly5035

2 жыл бұрын

@@user-re3nr9fd6f They mentioned in a Chapter that a guy once tried to dig beneath the walls but couldn't get under it which means they are deep in the ground. Even though it is not shown in the anime, i am concerend it is true.

@Liquicatslowedmusic

2 жыл бұрын

so based on the comments, are they grounded 10m or not?

@user-re3nr9fd6f

2 жыл бұрын

@@Liquicatslowedmusic It’s highly debatable. But I guess yes they are 60m

One thing which you missed out on. The walls are actually 60+ metres tall, its just that 10+ of those metres are underground. I saw that in a little inbetween paragraph that is between episodes in season 1, it described someone trying to cross the wall, digging underneath them but the walls continuing even 10 metres down.

@gandalf_1738

2 жыл бұрын

I rememeber walls were 50 metres and colossal titans were 60 metres. Thats because colossal titan was able to look up to walls.

@biglongpopsicle1033

2 жыл бұрын

Well now I guess the colossal Titan shifter not special since I though that all wall Titan are 50 metre tall because they want to the colossal shifter look a bit more special or original but I guess not.

@notyourdad9548

2 жыл бұрын

@@biglongpopsicle1033 no the special thing about the shifter is they are not pure and they can also go BOOM.

@biglongpopsicle1033

2 жыл бұрын

@@notyourdad9548 true and some shifters have abilities like harden and and can turn back into humans

@Kalenz1234

2 жыл бұрын

@@biglongpopsicle1033 Only the armored titan has hardening. Shifters can gain the abilities of other titans by consuming the spinal fluid of another shifter.

Love it when anime kinda inspires people to mathematically calculate certain numbers. Great video!

@eloquit9489

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks

@omnom1577

2 жыл бұрын

Death note lol

Yeah but it might as well be millions because I was only able to count 40 before I got stepped on.

@SenyaD

2 жыл бұрын

🤣🤣🤣

@psprealms2705

2 жыл бұрын

Me: Please don’t step on me! The Colossal Titan: *I missed the part where that’s my problem*

@Kaiii85

2 жыл бұрын

Underrated LOL

@epicstudio7185

2 жыл бұрын

RIP

@epicstudio7185

2 жыл бұрын

How are typing bro???

I'm wondering how long did it take Ymir to build all these titans

@Arosh.

2 жыл бұрын

Thousands of years. But in real world. It happened in an instant. Almost. It took couple of seconds to transform you know.

@divingstag

2 жыл бұрын

@@Arosh. Thousands of years to build 600 000 titans would mean building about one 50 meter colossal titan by day, considering the mass of sand and water you would need to carry for the sheer volume of these titans I'd say it would be more like tens of millions of years

@nicholasleclerc1583

2 жыл бұрын

Even just 1 month per titan is therefore *30 thousand fucking years*

@TheGamesMaster6

2 жыл бұрын

In an Instant or In a thousand years. It depends on how you look at it

@greentitan0262

2 жыл бұрын

Lets do this: (I used "." to indicate decimal numbers, and "," to indicate the power of thousend for reading) Decide the titans volume, decide the volume of her bucket... Then assume that each bucket takes additional walking, and sculpting. Even just one collossal would take a monumental amount of time. Forthe sake of simplicity imma assume that the volume of the collossal titan is about 33% of a cylinder. 60m(the feet are burried for stabillity) By 12.5m, and the 33%= 2454.37 cubic meters. 2,454,370 litres per titan. Then the bucket. I assume its a simple 10l bucket. Thats 245,437 walks per collossal. Even if she took one minute per bucket (which is definitely wayyyy to fast) it would take 170.5 DAYS PER TITAN DEAR GOD. then multiply that by 573,084 for all the titans in the wall... 267,610 years... she spent at least over 267 millennia mentally doing that task.... I know my method was very very crude, but i hope it shows the immense amount of labour that Ymir had to endure for only one command.

I always doubted how so few titans (as it looked in the series, maybe 200 titans for wall SINA) could possibly do anything to an entire planet. 500.000 50m tall gods of destruction on the other hand... the world is gonna be dust in a year.

@lanttu10

2 жыл бұрын

@@kubajadrzak1123 Well I think it would be better to say it wouldn't be world ending but I think it still qualifies as a problem. Sure there are weapons that could kill the titans but they are still limited in number and there are other problems too. For example let's say we want to nuke them all. Sure humanity has enough nukes to kill them all but depending on where the rumbling originates most of the nuclear arsenal might not be in range and even if it was the amount of nukes needed to kill them all would have serious and long lasting effects on our environment. And when it comes to killing the titans with other weapons they are also limited in number and even more limited in their range of operations. Not to mention the fact that there are less than 20 million active soldiers in the whole world. That's less than 40 men against a single titan. Not to mention the fact that the number of weapons that are actually capable of targeting the nape of a titan is not that big. Considering it's a moving target the size of a human in the height of 50m and you are either required to be able to fly (only way to get behind them) or blast through the neck. So in essence it might be possible to kill the titans but they would most likely destroy multiple countries if not a whole continent before finally being stopped.

@Coolguy98765432q457

2 жыл бұрын

@@lanttu10 the US Air Force can deploy nuclear weapons anywhere in the world in the span of a just a couple of hours, and a single B52 can carry enough nukes to wipe out all the Titans. The nukes would probably do more damage than the Titans do.

@lanttu10

2 жыл бұрын

@@Coolguy98765432q457 unless the titans were in a group and not a line you would need thousands of nukes to kill all of the titans and there is absolutely no way that they fit on a single plane. The line of titans would be about 7000 km long and there is no way that even the strongest nukes would kill them on more than a few kilometer radius not to mention that most of the nuclear weapons today are not as big as the strongest ones. But yes it's true that the nukes would do more damage than the titans but only if they are killed fast and even then I would still count that as the titans "merit" because we were forced to use nukes to kill them.

@lanttu10

2 жыл бұрын

Also I think that most people today are vastly overestimating the capabilities of nuclear weapons. Most of their effect comes from two factors which are the radiation and the capability to destroy concentrated population centers. They aren't used in wars because they simply aren't effective against military units spread across a large area and are better utilized as threats to large civilian populations which no one wants to start. A much more effective way to deal with the titans would be either non nuclear bombs and missiles or artillery fire.

@Ptr96

2 жыл бұрын

The Nagasaki arch, a wooden beam construction, survived an almost dead center hit from a nuclear bomb. I actually highly doubt anything else than an almost direct hit from a nuclear bomb would do anything but topple and singe a 50m mass of meat with regenerative powers. + Make them highly irradiated, desecrating the ground they tread upon even further...

okay, so your vid motivated me to expand the math here ! First of all, the titans are 60 m tall not 50, so if we redo the calculus, it brings us : 6974300.4 meters of total circumference of the three walls divided by the ratio shoulder/height (25.8% of 60m) 15.48m = 450 537 titans, plus the same approximation for the districts and you get 462 713 collossal titans in tolal ! So, okay, it's not millions of titans, but i will show you that it is still widely enough to trample all the ennemis and to keep moving forward ! the average speed of someone walking for a globally standard height of 1.75m is around 4.8 to 6 km/h so we will say it's 5 km/h. If we multiply the speed by the gain in height, it will be: 5km/h x 60m/1.75m = 171,42857km/h But we can argue that they walk slowly, so we can approximate that marching speed to 3km/h for a human: 3km/h x 60m/1.75m = 102.85714 km/h So it's still the speed of an auto going full speed on the road (depending on the laws of your country obviously). Next is the lenght of it and now i must warn you we will start to dive in big SPOILERS !!!!!! If we take all the titans shoulder to shoulder and they start trampling in 1 line, that line would be : 6974322,4m + 188495.4m (the ones that were on the districts) = 7162817.8 meters long so 7163 kilometers ! (just check on google maps to realize the insanity of the scale) But you can argue that when eren start the rumbling on the first city, they look like a wall of numerous titans and that's true ! so there is not a line but we should'nt assume he does that same disposition everywhere. When he is in front of fort Salta, we can see that it looks roughly like a checkerboard of 10 titans, if we were to assume that's the same disposition everywhere (wich is surely not the case but we will see it on the less horrible perspective) then it gives us : 462713 titans / 10 x (15,48m x 2) = 1432559 m or 1433 kilometers wich is roughly the same distance between Miami and Washington ! Now you can imagine that the less worst scenario is a wall of titans stretching in 1 line from Miami to Washington advancing at 103 km/h to the west coast. Now for the worst scenario : (yeay) After Eren has landed his troops and they went further in the continent, they could stretch to a line of 1 in areas non populated (Eren doesn't need to fuck the nature, unless they continue the cycle of hatred, then he will keep moving forward until all trees are destroyed) and walk in group of checkerboard of 10 in strategic zones (towns and military areas), so given the density of population on the real world, i will do an approximation that 85% of titans are stretched and 15% are attacking the strategic points. So that gives us a line of : 85% of 7162817,8m = 6088395,13 meters so 6 thousand kilometers long ! with this lenght, he can land his titans all across Africa's east coast, India and arabian countries and start the rumbling ! Now for the final math, we'll see if the timing of Eren arriving at Fort Salta is realistic : First of all, we need to know that even though the map of Aot looks like ours, it isn't bcs if you compare Eldia to real life Madagascar, the walls cannot fit inside.... But neverthless, if you were to start walking from south of South Africa and walk until Bordj Badji Moktar (Very roughlythe place where Fort Salta is if it were the real world, you can check it in chapter 132) you would need to travel 8400 kilometers and depending on the speed it would take : 8400km / 103 km/h = 81,5 hours so roughly 3 days and half or 8400km / 171 km/h = 49 hours so 2 days So yeah, the timing makes sense (honestly i don't remember how much time passed in the manga but i think that it's the result) Feel free to comment if you have another suggestion, pov or to correct a mistake i would have done Thx !

@tallerstond8105

2 жыл бұрын

Legendary comment

@fusososososo3507

2 жыл бұрын

Didn't even read your entire comment but I'll give a like because of the nice spoiler warning

@redsolozach1151

2 жыл бұрын

Now that’s a colossal comment

@maric28studios

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you for putting a reference of "Miami to Washington", to really show how big that is, which basically means all Eren has to do to rumble America would be to walk across America twice.

@supercool_saiyan5670

2 жыл бұрын

how do we calculate how fast the titans can swim

So I assume since the full founder can take away titan powers it can also grant them. So imagine this. Everyone moves in, makes houses, all that. Then around 500k people in total are mind controlled to stand in 3 circles (+districts) around everyone else. Suddenly, all those blank faced people explode in a gigantic lightning storm visible over the entire world and just as quickly the walls are there. That's gotta be quite the cruelty to basically strip away the thought of 500k in an instant

@Cripplified

2 жыл бұрын

The founding titan likely has the ability to create the wall titans out of nothing.

The two really messed up things when you think about it: 1. All those wall titans are Eldians. So there's almost as many Titans in the walls as the Eldians behind them. 2. The first King of the Walls turned over 500,000 Eldians into Colossal Titans. How? Did he just... line them up one by one and inject them with Titan fluid?

@nuclear37

2 жыл бұрын

I'm assuming he used the power of the Founding Titan to turn them all into colossal titans, and then walls.

@d00mrunn3r6

2 жыл бұрын

spoilers : The founding titan can control all of the eldians sooo he can just will it into existence like how eren talked to every eldian in the paths and in the final battle he turn everyone like connie jean to titans without needing to inject them with spinal fluid

@infinitethunder6184

2 жыл бұрын

Spoilers I used to think this was the case, but I'm beginning to doubt it. Remember, at the start of chapter 139, all titans were taken away from the world. People that had turned into pure titans, such as Connie's mum, turned back to human. The wall titans, however, turned to smoke and left no humans behind. It's weird, but I think that means they were never originally human. Since the founding titan did this, I'm sure it's possible that they were just conjured from nothing

@oneandonly8746

2 жыл бұрын

Founding Titan power His Titan is insane

@user-re3nr9fd6f

2 жыл бұрын

No he created then out of nothing. It would make no sense for him to inject 500,000 + Eldians with spinal fluid when he has the ability to create titans with his founder ability. Those are titans created out of nothing.

500,000+ Colossal Titans could definitely F things up on a global scale…

@MuhammadHamza-fi1lb

2 жыл бұрын

Not current world nukes will vaporize them

@tellinggojira1188

2 жыл бұрын

what are the wall titans going to do about the entire worlds nuclear arsenal containing gigatons of tnt

@moneratan2750

Жыл бұрын

1000 tanks would deal with 500k in just under half an hour. No need of nukes.

In the manga its specifically mentions that there are tens of millions of colossal titans buried within the wall. The issue with using the drawings for scale is that Isayama like many manga artists tends to exaggerate or minimize proportions for dramatic/artistic effect. This however makes using them as a frame of reference quite unreliable.

@easylivinglife6284

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, and the other thing is we know titans dont follow the normal human proportions. Ive always thought colossal titans are more skinny and long than wide.

@GezzarTV

2 жыл бұрын

that number was used as a threat so I imagine it was always meant to be exaggerated

@arinavog9962

2 жыл бұрын

But I hope there are atleast 1 million Colosis cuzz 500k is disappointed.

@moneratan2750

Жыл бұрын

​@@arinavog9962 have you ever seen 1000 people irl? 500,000 is a lot. Especially if it's 60m behemoths.

@arinavog9962

Жыл бұрын

@@moneratan2750 yeah maybe you are right . I was just how is it enough to distroy humanity but then I thought Jist one Colosal titan destroyed 10k people in shinganshina and also in leberio more then 30k people imagine what 585k will do.

No bullshit. No wasted time. Answers exactly what the title asks. A perfect video

Can you calculate next how much time does it take for Ymir to build one titan, especially collosal titans? How much time did she really spent inside the path if she spent all time building titans?

@eloquit9489

2 жыл бұрын

I also had the same idea, and I'm currently working on it! Stay tuned

@greentitan0262

2 жыл бұрын

lel i already did

@blankswiftiegaming8998

2 жыл бұрын

Just have to know the amount of time needed to make 1 titan.... That time x no of titans = Total time taken ymir to make all those titans

@greentitan0262

2 жыл бұрын

@@blankswiftiegaming8998 267 thoused years assuming she has a 10 litre bucket, taking 1minute per bucket, and thus intern 170 days per titan without sleep

@alantonix213

2 жыл бұрын

By Green Titan02 3 days ago Lets calculate how long ymir would take to make these titans. (I used "." to indicate decimal numbers, and "," to indicate the power of thousend for reading) Decide the titans volume, decide the volume of her bucket... Then assume that each bucket takes additional walking, and sculpting. Even just one collossal would take a monumental amount of time. For the sake of simplicity imma assume that the volume of the collossal titan is about 33% of a cylinder. 60m(the feet are burried for stabillity) By 12.5m, and the 33%= 2454.37 cubic meters. (radius^2*pi*height) *1000 cuz each m3 holds 1000l 2,454,370 litres per titan. Then the bucket. I assume its a simple 10l bucket. Thats 245,437 walks per collossal. Even if she took one minute per bucket (which is definitely wayyyy to fast) it would take 170.5 DAYS PER TITAN DEAR GOD. then multiply that by 573,084 for all the titans in the wall... 267,610 years... she spent at least over 267 millennia mentally doing that task..... You can easely modify the awnser if you think that a minute per bucket is too slow (double the time if you think it fits better, or multiply by 5, i dont mind), or if you think that the titans are 50m tall (*5/6) I know my method was very very crude, but i hope it shows the immense amount of labour that Ymir had to endure for only one command.

It's strange to think how far this anime/manga has gone since our discovery ALL the way back: "The walls are titans!"

@shepherdstar14

2 жыл бұрын

I know I used to subscribe to the theory that the titan world was an experiment by people watching from another planet and that the “warriors” were from a tribe or something outside the walls who stole the titan serum or something. Boy was I wayyy off.

@kshitizsrivastava9429

2 жыл бұрын

@@shepherdstar14 I also imagined that.. But the pathogen we saw... It looks like alien creature.. I think AOT will become Scienee fiction if it get a sequel and we all know it will not get any more seasons😢..

actually each district walls has 58(and that times 12 is 696), i did it by simply counting from where district wall meets the main wall to the gate section at the outer most part in which each section of the walls in general is a colossal titan, so by adding all 3 of the main wall titans(588,000) to the district ones you get:588,696.

i LOVE this approach on AOT. Man you rock!! 📈

I am just gonna pretend its 10 million which sounds a lot cooler

@Kalenz1234

2 жыл бұрын

The walls aren't perfectly round. It's probably a lot more than the calculation in this vid says.

@moneratan2750

Жыл бұрын

​@@Kalenz1234slightly more, not a lot more. Probably not more than a million.

@Kalenz1234

Жыл бұрын

@@moneratan2750 You underestimate how much length can be increased just by adding curves. Just look at land-ocean borders. The closer you zoom in the longer it becomes. It gets especially ridiculous in Norway's case.

one episode discloses data of the miner which attempted to dig under the wall.. this leads me to believe that the shown height of the wall isnt the overall height (possibly the titans being buried at the knees or something)

@thegamingengine4537

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah they are 60 m like the colossal but 50 m above ground because their feet are buried

@theamorphousflatsch2699

2 жыл бұрын

The titans are buried into the ground for about 10 meters for stability

@daimajin266

2 жыл бұрын

@@thegamingengine4537 They are 50m, its confirmed bruh

@nu_kercat1

2 жыл бұрын

@@daimajin266 its 60m, check the wiki

@teagoodstuff734

2 жыл бұрын

thats true colossal in the walls are 60 meters tall

According to the lore, there are 585.000 wall titans + eren, so it's 585.001 titans

@AnimA-pc2rg

2 жыл бұрын

Use comma (,) not full stops (.)

@NagantHunt

2 жыл бұрын

@@AnimA-pc2rg some countries use periods for numbers

@bobfredkinsei553

2 жыл бұрын

comma is weird

@SordidusFellatio

Ай бұрын

@@NagantHunt period is for decimal, you either use it or you dont. Like in this case, 585000

@NagantHunt

Ай бұрын

@@SordidusFellatio Did you mention the wrong person? It's obvious I already know that.

Earned a sub. Good content!

Thank you for this, I was really counting them titans but always got confused.

Only one problem Although it was close as you said, each walk Titan is 60m tall as it was specified that the titans were buried 10m in the ground

Can someone calculate how long it would take these titans to cover 80% of the world if they walked in a uniform line should to shoulder?

@michaelbible3124

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, if anyone does this lmk

@niklasneumann2595

2 жыл бұрын

Why just 80%?

@undies891

2 жыл бұрын

@@niklasneumann2595 spoilers :)

@supercool_saiyan5670

2 жыл бұрын

I would also like to know how many times they would have to circle the earth because Imagine one line of titans isnt enough to cover one whole strip of earth but idk thats why Im asking

@fg009letyrds8

2 жыл бұрын

@@niklasneumann2595 Eren planned to kill 80% of world population so that Paradis can get to arm themselves so once the humans gets to recover their numbers while remembering how Eldians massacred 80% of humans in the world, Paradis will be ready for war (which as we seen later they still lost) :3

U deserve a sub

@eloquit9489

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks 😭

Nice Technical analysis :)

Can u do a video to calculate the time for the rumbling to crush the entire surface of the earth ? We have some details to explore during the chapter 129 (or 128) when Hansi said colossal titans walk at a speed of horse, and she calculated herself that it'll take 4 days. Thanks

I would say that estimate number would be lower since colossal titans have unproportionate bodies for example their arms being longer and legs aswell so they would fit differently in the walls

This was satisfyingly smart. Extremely good.

Wow thats alot of titans and thats a really good way to literally end the world!.but good thing u made this vid cause this helped me to figerout this question and now look a vid just helped my life but thanks and great video:)

"Chicken china" "Shigan shina" "Shigan china"

It actually more than this cause these calculations are assuming that the walls are perfect circles but there are many curves and turns. Also the colossal titans are 60 meters. The wall is 50 meters but there is 10 meters underground

Could you do an area comparison of all those titans? Like, comparatively, how large of an area would all those titans encompass compared to other countries?

Comment for people that were asking how did the titans manage to trample almost everything. First of all, aot's map hasn't been showed. There's theories that Paradis island is Madagascar but it isn't confirmed. Therefor we can't really calculate it 100% accurately. But let's say there's around 550,000 titans and their shoulder's length is 15m (15m because i've seen different comparsions and they all say shoulder's length is 1/4th of titan's height). If they all lined up perfectly, they would cover 8250km (let's make it around 8000km just in case there's less titans) Africa, which is the biggest continent, is 7400km from west to east (best distance) and 8000km from north to south (best distance). If they lined perfectly, they would be able to trample Africa in one run. However, there's a problem. Titans weren't perfectly lined, as we saw that they formed multiple rows. If AOT's map is based on our map and titans lined up perfectly, they could trample everything. But since titans didn't line up perfectly and they managed to trample almost everything, then AOT's map has to be smaller. I hope this gives you the idea of how big rumbling really is. Thanks for spending some minutes of your life with my comment and have a nice day!

@kappipappi2985

2 жыл бұрын

pretty sure the area of the walls is bigger than madagascar

@epicstudio7185

2 жыл бұрын

Perhaps it was shown and the continents are different than ours

@thepaintingbanjo8894

2 жыл бұрын

IF that world map shown in the basement chapters are anything to go by, AOT's is basically Earth but flip north to south. Problem here though is that Paradis is obviously way bigger than Madagascar; the 480 km radius of the outer wall would easily stretch out into the Indian Ocean and Mozambique Channel. The world literally needs to be twice the size of our Earth to accommodate any of this. Also someone on reddit did the math what the rumbling would look like if the titans were always in formation as the manga shown. Basically it would line up on the East Coast US from NYC to Charleston, SC. (or NYC to Virginia Beach if the AOT Earth is twice as big)

@AndrewLee-hp6zz

2 жыл бұрын

Alright, but how are they gonna just walk through the ocean trenches?

@kedrednael

2 жыл бұрын

​@@AndrewLee-hp6zz One foot in front of the other. Otherwise, swim.

As impressive as this may sound, all those titans would still need a whole lot of time to trample over 80% of humanity, Africa alone (AoT has inverted africa, is it even the same surface area?) is over 30m km2, and that still leaves other continents.

@mislavkukina2026

2 жыл бұрын

the thing is that it was never stated how long it actually took Eren to squish 80% of population, but it didnt really matter coz at the time they didnt have the weaponary or technology to deal with it so they were doomed either way. If something like that happened today their speed would matter because we actually have the means to end it before big damage is done.

@lanttu10

2 жыл бұрын

@@kubajadrzak1123 That just isn't true though. The most powerful nuclear weapon in the current US arsenal would be capable of killing the titans in a a radius of about 2.5 km and all the titans side by side would make a row 7000 km that means you would need 2800 of those nukes to kill all the titans and considering there are only 3750 active nuclear warheads in the world and the average nuke is vastly weaker than the strongest ones you would need to take out most of the other nuclear weapons too (the total number of warheads is a bit below 14000) you might have enough but it would still do huge environmental damage and wouldn't be an easy process by any means.

@lanttu10

2 жыл бұрын

The line of titans would be about 7000km wide which is more than Africa is in any direction (Africa is a bit less than 6000km in a Nort to South direction) which means you only really have to calculate how long it would take for a single titan to walk across africa. If we say they walk about 30 km/h (which I think is still too slow because of how huge they are) it would only take 200 hours or 8.3 days to cross the continent, which in my opinion is not long in the grand scheme of things.

@thebulletdragon2876

2 жыл бұрын

@@lanttu10 they move faster than a galloping horse according to the manga

@lanttu10

2 жыл бұрын

@@thebulletdragon2876 okay that's at least 50km/h then so 120h or 5 days

But after the fight with the female titan in the first season, we've seen that wall Titans are also facing backwards. That is, the walls are probably 2 titans thick. So multiplying your current estimation with 2, we get a million titan.

@anguta216

2 жыл бұрын

I got that in my head Canon as well even if we saw only one after the walls broke

@fg009letyrds8

2 жыл бұрын

Even if you make it 2 million its still to few to kill most of the world's population within few weeks like it did in the series. Calculations were already done and with their speed and 2 million C titans lined up walking in a SINGLE row it won't be even able to get too far from the Paradis Island within a few weeks, and is certain the titans aren't walking in a single row and they're not faster than 1920s information travel technology and Airplanes.

@Cripplified

2 жыл бұрын

@@fg009letyrds8 We do not know the size or exact layout of the mass land structures of the planet the story takes place on.

thats the best tts ive ever heard

That's...alot of titans. I'd figured it be in the thousands but nope. Thanks for the knowledge!

632,770 Titans

Pov: Marly mathematicians trying to calculate that over the sea

@sourcesymbiosismetamorphis2228

2 жыл бұрын

Lmao bro

What TTS did you use on this video brother?

Nice!!, these days I was wondering just that, they say millions of titans, didn't seem to me it was that many

The impressive thing is that if the wall titans were to stand shoulder-to-shoulder, they would make up a line spanning over 7000 km (4350 miles), which equals the distance between London and Mumbai in India!

Real question: was Ymir in Survival or Creative mode in the paths?

@t.o.w.a1978

2 жыл бұрын

Survival Mode, I think she had to build some sort of stairways and keep grabbing sands too, noone in creative mode would do that to build something.

The text in the half episode break said there are millions of colossal titans but still cool you took the time to calculate mathematically evrything

i love that you make several errors in the first 51 seconds, like seriously enough to void the entire video

Were this far into the show and people still think the titans are 50 meters?

@3takoyakis

2 жыл бұрын

I thought wall Titans are different than colossal but no The king buried their feet 10 metres into the ground as foundation (even though it didn't have finger, but ig hardening is really flexible to use) There's a story about miner try to dig down the wall

@skippi99r32

2 жыл бұрын

@@3takoyakis exactly my point, the story about the miner digging his whole life to go under the wall but it just ends up being more wall, and people still think the wall titans are 50 meters even though that story was from like season 1 or 2 or something

@Dany2100.

2 жыл бұрын

it seems like not many people read the story of the miner :(

@Dany2100.

2 жыл бұрын

it seems like not many people read the story of the miner :(

Good job finding the estimated count.

Something to keep in mind though with actual depictions of the walls they were not perfectly straight. They dipped and curved and the districts in comparison to the main walls were very small.

I Love how every Titan have a different Art style

thats where you need maths in life, kids

How long has Ymir been in the Paths, from her perspective? I estimated around the lifespan of a red dwarf star. Or at least longer than the current age of the observable universe.

@eloquit9489

2 жыл бұрын

I'm making a video on the same topic, so stay tuned 🤗

@Gojo_the_honored_rat

2 жыл бұрын

63.072 billion years

@user-re3nr9fd6f

2 жыл бұрын

@@Gojo_the_honored_rat why

@Gojo_the_honored_rat

2 жыл бұрын

@@user-re3nr9fd6f what do you mean why I had to do the calculations the guy wanted an answer

@user-re3nr9fd6f

2 жыл бұрын

@@Gojo_the_honored_rat No I mean what why is it that number and what are the steps of your calc? How did you do it?

2:26 I think that number is enough to flatten marley along with hizuru

@Gunplabro

2 жыл бұрын

Eren Flattened 80% of the human race in the Manga.

Guy took guesstimates to another level

Wow, they did a pretty bad job representing the walls then, cuz multiple times during the anime while standing on a wall they can see the other quite clearly, and if you know what 100km are being able to do that is just stupid.

Is that your actual voice or is it a voice software? It's very pleasant to the ear.

@yvick7770

2 жыл бұрын

That would be a god tier voice software

@randomannoyance

2 жыл бұрын

@@yvick7770 he said that it is under the gothkasa video

Nice

"Hey look, its the rumbling! lets count each and every titan before we die"

The real question is Yuomir waited for 2000 years in real life. so the 2000 years are equal to how many years in the other dimension?

@youcantusemypfpornameinarg4962

2 жыл бұрын

There is no clear info, but Eren and Zeke wandered in Grisha's memories for years, while in real time only like a millisecond passed

@user-re3nr9fd6f

2 жыл бұрын

Billions probably

@DECENTcrew

2 жыл бұрын

Or maybe its the other way around it could be fast and slow depending on how ymir comprehends it. Because its kind of silly to think she sat there doing nothing except making a titan once every billion years...

@Gunplabro

2 жыл бұрын

The paths do not run on our perception of time. They are eternal. Time does not flow there. What would take someone 200k years to do in paths happens instantly in paths

I got a similar number by my own estimates: 465,561 The main difference was our assumptions in the lenght of the Wall Titans from shoulder to shoulder. Titans aren't always porportionate to humans, so I went by the original size shart comparing a human to all known titans at the time, including the Colossal Titan. In said chart, Bertholt's Titan is illustrated as having a shoulder length of 20 meters, hence why my number is smaller than yours. The disctricts I just eyeballed at the time, counting the wall segments each as a colossal, giving about 58 each, or 696 in tital. Granted, I never felt happy with that number as it would make a district wall only around 1.2 km in length.

Next vid do a 3d model of this number walking and compare them to other objects or fields like football stadiums

If they all walked in a single line, it's basically a 6800km long eraser going through the globe

Did Hajime calculated this

@AlexFarrus

2 жыл бұрын

It doesn't even matter, in the show we will be able to see the titan in a massive view,only the ratio can be calculated

@infect6521

2 жыл бұрын

i dont think so but i dont think its necessary, it was already said there are millions of titans in the walls

Another thing that should be mentioned is that erens founding titan actually can fit shiganshina inside. Im pretty sure it was meant as a metaphor as how eren wanted nothing bad to happen to his family

Oh thank goodness, it's only HALF a million 60 meter tall unstoppable death machines. Cool.

You also have to consider the parts of the walls that are broken by titans in previous seasons

I appreciate the calculation. Also, everything that was said in the manga including the "tens of millions collosal titans" are canon. After all it's just plain fiction, and they can say whatever they want.

@taz8951

2 жыл бұрын

I (RESPECTFULLY!) disagree. The characters inferring there are millions of titans is just an assumption from the CHARACTERS-- not a direct fact from the mouth of the creator

@professorhaaland6210

2 жыл бұрын

Just like how many Clones that serve during the Clone Wars. The debate have been going on for decades and no one how many clones are there that was made. Just like the number of wall titans and the exact number is debatable.

@moneratan2750

Жыл бұрын

That was used as a threat. Don't take everything literally

Can you calculate how fast these wall titans had to move to kill 80% of the world assuming the AoT world population is similar, if not the same as irl?

@tganims9804

2 жыл бұрын

this is what i wanna know

@mislavkukina2026

2 жыл бұрын

If we're looking the rumbling by itself it was moving pretty slowly, I reckon it would take years for them to actually do it (if we're looking aot world as ours), but compared to allied forces that tried to stop them they seem to move pretty damn fast since by the time allies came to the continent by boat the whole rumbling already passed the ocean and Marley was crushed. So their speed doesnt make much sense in the story.

@eternaleffect2499

2 жыл бұрын

@@mislavkukina2026 its definitely not slow its same speed as a car coz of their huge size it can be hard to realize their speed of 1 step. But it would take a human 335 days to walk around earth so i would safely assume it shouldn't take wall titans more than a few months to cover whole earth.

@mislavkukina2026

2 жыл бұрын

@@eternaleffect2499 saying something is the same speed as a car doesnt narrow it down in the slightest. Avg car can drive 5 and 180 km/h so what exactly do you mean by "same speed as a car"?

@FoxytheHumanFoxyDarkFox

2 жыл бұрын

It took around 4/5 days in the manga

What kind of text to speech app do you use?

wildly accurate

Now I'm stuck wondering why when the walls were breached the few times they were that Reiner and Bertolt didn't yeet any colossal titans or expose them. Edit: I don't think any of you read the reply I made, someone already mentioned it was the gate he broke and not the wall

@CNMashin

2 жыл бұрын

They aimed for the gates, and not the walls themselves

@SmeargleRocks

2 жыл бұрын

@@CNMashin I forgot about that

@Gunplabro

2 жыл бұрын

They kicked the doors in. No titans there.

@stevewalker1376

2 жыл бұрын

@@Gunplabro I never knew that till now. I always was confused about that.

@Gunplabro

2 жыл бұрын

@@stevewalker1376 the walls titans were never a mystery to the Marlayan Military. The warriors likely would have been briefed.

573K Titans are involved in the rumbling... And an AC-130 can hold around 1500 rounds of the 155mm howitzer. That means if only a single fleet of AC-130 is sent to dispatch the Rumbling, it will just take around 574 sorties to clear the rumbling out, excluding Eren.

@Kalenz1234

2 жыл бұрын

Collosal titans tanked battleship artillery with no problem. Nuff said.

@skybattler2624

2 жыл бұрын

@@Kalenz1234 actually, no. Especially given HOW they tanked them. Some Collossals are actually taken out by the ship artillery. But remember, these ships are at a period where Dreadnought are just recently built, with no fire control radars, gyroscopic stabilizers, and the like. Some of the ships there aren't even the most modern for the time, and still inaccurate. Also, ship artillery fire slowly. Besides, the Collosals flipped them from underneath the waves. It will also be commented later, but Air Power is the only way to stop the rumbling, but your bombs must be accurate or large enough. The Marleyan airship attack failed because none of their bombs hit any titan (as airship bombs are notoriously inaccurate even in real life), but if the same scenario happened with a B-17 like aircraft or any modern day jet, the results will be different.

Now, I'm inspired to do my math homework :)

LOVE THE MATH

It was clearly stated that the walls are made of 10 million colosal titans in episode 64 declaration of war

@kait3n10

2 жыл бұрын

True but that could well be propaganda by Marley

@haloborn6785

2 жыл бұрын

Tybur clearly stated that it's a lie that there were millions of titans within the walls and it was used as a way to deter enemies from invading paradis island

@ErenNeager69

2 жыл бұрын

@@haloborn6785 bruh he never said it was a lie he said that the king took 10+ million colossal Titans to paradis island

@arinavog9962

2 жыл бұрын

@@ErenNeager69 I think the map they have shown is wrong I guess because first thing at that time there were not smart tools to measure Area plus in walls almost every book evey statment is brainwash .

Bro you might have to recalculate because the walls are 50m tall above the ground and 10m below the ground. It was mentioned when they were interrogating pastor nick that someone tried to dig below the wall and found out that the walls are there below ground level too.

Makes sense. But either way it doesn’t matter everyone outside gonna die lol

Great video, one problem i have is with the width of the colossals. they aren’t proportional to normal humans not by a long shot.

I also calculated this, long time ago, but with a different values; the titans measures are: 49/7 (if you want to do it as a human body it is about 1/7 width and length) So, with that values the number is 996,000 (without the cities) After I was watching your video, I tried to calculated the cities, but with about 6/6, it adding 26,441 more titans. So, in the end we got 1,022,441 titans...

The petruvian man has normal human proportions whereas the titans clearly do not, so it seems your calculation of 12.5 meters wide is probably not accurate...

That alot titan for sure, 1 collosal titan already done so much damage imagine half millions of those.....the earth shaking.

Willy Tybur in his speech said that the walls were made by tens of millions of colossal Titans . When i was watching his speech it said that or my subtitle was wrong

HOLY moly i did not expect 500 thousand colossal titans, hange killing 3 colossal titans wasnt even worth it at this point also yes spoilers

@ObtainThePain

2 жыл бұрын

Probably even more than 500k since he assumed the districts were semicircles

@gg_sam7847

2 жыл бұрын

They were the ones whose path was directly where the others were and they managed to escape just as the building was getting trampled, by the looks of it at least one of the dead Colossals tripped up at least one living one. Either way, it was very close

@tganims9804

2 жыл бұрын

What was the point of that edit?

@mightycake3373

2 жыл бұрын

@@tganims9804 i forgot to put spoilers

@tganims9804

2 жыл бұрын

@@mightycake3373 But you put the spoiler before the spoiler warning so that was pointless 💀

I think it would actually be less. Since the radius of Paradis would actually be a lot smaller since they live in Madagascar. The walls being a lot smaller would also explain how people could travel from wall to wall so quickly

This is what they try to teach you in school

This guy is really good in math

I didn't expect this math-ish explanation!!

Man. TTS is really getting good these days

Nice one! Next question is: We've seen how Merleyan navy was vaporised by temperature of rumbling steam. Human bones turns into ashes in approximately 600° C. What temperature might have all of rumbling and how or if would it affect global warming? 🤔

if the width is 12.5 and the total amount is 573000, the total length if put by side by side would be 7162kms. for reference, continent of africa from top to bottom is 7400km long. despite the fact that they arent lined in one line and theres like multiple lines of them, it still makes sense that such a power could destroy the whole world.

1:57 shiggin'chinna XD

But in the today's episode there was that screen that say random information , so it said what's rumpling? And it explained it and it said that there's a millions of titans that are going to kill everyone on the earth except that island so....

@derongeorgie2749

2 жыл бұрын

True, i came back here to say that

Ty

I think the collosal titans are a little bit wider proportionally than titans. If you do straight up pixel measurement it’s about 1/3 height. When I calculated it I got around 500,000 titans so it seems that there’s about that many

This also means that they would have had to get 573084 subjects of Ymir and inject spinal fluid of the colossal titan into them, Thats a lot of people to be turned into a titan. Though it was done by the founding titan so that prob made it easier to do but that’s still an immense amount of people to turn into a mindless titan

@moneratan2750

Жыл бұрын

Ymir can make titans out of thin air now apparently.

somewhere in the manga it was stated that there are actually about 500.000 titans in the walls. COULD also be from a wiki, i dont quite remember anymore. anyways, very close!

The fact that I calculated the number of Colossus Titan yesterday make me laugh😂😂😂

The next question is how long does the collosal titan have to walk on the entire earth to kill every single fucking one of us.