JOIN OUR BODY LANGUAGE MASTERCLASS: behavior-panel.mykajabi.com/tbpmclive2022 PLEASE SUBSCRIBE: kzread.info MERCH STORE: thebehaviorpanel.myspreadshop.com/ FACEBOOK GROUP: facebook.com/groups/thebehaviorpanelists 🆂🅲🅾🆃🆃 🆁🅾🆄🆂🅴: Body Language Tactics - body-language-tactics.mykajabi.com/body-language-tactics-landing 🅲🅷🅰🆂🅴 🅷🆄🅶🅷🅴🆂: ChaseHughes.com 🅼🅰🆁🅺 🅱🅾🆆🅳🅴🅽: GET FREE TRAINING: TruthAndLies.ca 🅶🆁🅴🅶 🅷🅰🆁🆃🅻🅴🆈: Body Language Tactics body-language-tactics.mykajabi.com/body-language-tactics-landing

@lynngold1865

Жыл бұрын

Hi Guys!If u knew that Alec has had a 20 yr opioid addiction [like he did] would that explain the behaviors he did or more importantly he didnt do in his body language? I really am interested in your take on that fact!love everything i have learned from you.Gratefully, Lynn

@maybank5283

Жыл бұрын

Cannot wait to take this class. I live 1 hour away from Walterboro. Also he went to visit his mom house that night and states to the housekeeper remember I was at the house that night for 40 minutes the night of the murder. Smh he takes the cake and then some.

@aimeeysful

Жыл бұрын

Please do a video on Hilaria Baldwin! Her fake Spanish accent came back with the attention her husband is getting.

@HandleForElleJay

Жыл бұрын

Nooooooo-! How could you man?!! Come on Scott, bring back the hat! Please!! I beg of you … don’t mean to be rude ….. but here I am , giving it to you anyways! 😂 well , not THAT, I mean the comment I hope you take in the kindest of ways! The hat needs stay! You look 15 years YOUNGER without it - ano ! Yikes ! Feeling brave!😂 I was going to have a wee glass of wine or 9 with friends this evening, though the catch is - only sipping when you say “ seeing” . We are holding off for the weekend where we will be absolutely BlockBuster drunk! And I cannot wait! 😊 🍸🍹🍷🥂🍺 Have a fabulous weekend when it’s here folks! 🥂 👲🏻

@tland2u22

Жыл бұрын

It is a LIE that he had insurance on his domestic help… he helped the family with a lawsuit then kept the money.. it is disgusting when someone makes a living making these type videos yet gets critical facts WRONG!

His son's brain was blown out of his skull. I wouldn't be able to stop puking, let alone put together a chronological story for the police.

@peterkoutsis2780

Жыл бұрын

And then there are the prison calls. Which would definitely send you over the boat.

@BlackJack-sx1jw

Жыл бұрын

He may have worked out and rehearsed the story many times before he allegedly did the deed.

@phebeco7357

Жыл бұрын

I don’t know if I would have been puking but I would have been to distraught (and covered with blood

@kilimanjaro5292

Жыл бұрын

Most of us would either puke to death or in my case they would have to cart me away to Funnyfarm Sanitarium if I saw my loved ones head blown off! But what I find both horrific and sad is if Alex did do it, (which I believe he did), is to have the realization that Paul's looking down the barrel of a gun held by his own father. I mean not only shocking but the very deep, and terrible sadness the poor kid must've felt realizing that your father doesn't and prob. never has loved you. I wonder if any words were exchanged between Alex and Paul?

@FlowerChyld43

Жыл бұрын

@@peterkoutsis2780 Prison calls?

He never mentions being afraid of someone still being out there or he himself being targeted. He’s solely focused on making his story work. He’s beyond guilty.

@amycox2074

Жыл бұрын

Exactly…. But he was worried enough to leave the scene and go back to house for a gun after talking to 911. It doesn’t match any of his other behaviors or words. Just an excuse to have to touch a gun. And, am I the only one who could jot just leave my family laying there dead while waiting on the emergency crew? That doesn’t sit well with me either

@DonnaLena1

Жыл бұрын

@@amycox2074 Agree. The run back to the house is a fairly obvious attempt to cover up the GSR that would be on his hands. He may have grabbed clean clothes too. I’m leaning towards Alex washing the blood off at the kennels where I think a hose was running.

@janegardener1662

Жыл бұрын

@@DonnaLena1 The housekeeper testified that Alec called her to come clean up the house the next morning and make it "the way Maggie would like it". He knew that she would pick up the damp towel and the khaki pants and rinse out the shower, even though he didn't specifically ask her to do those things. When he was in jail, he kept asking to speak to her. He wanted to have a chance to coach her about what she saw.

@tdbdf

Жыл бұрын

Love your analysis. He is a story teller (Attorney)who manipulates people and the facts, which is what he’s doing here. The property is 1700 acres, but the scene is maybe 500 yards from road, as well as his home is visible from the road. The story with the housekeeper was that he sued his own insurance policy for the housekeeper’s sons after she passed after a fall at his house, but kept the 4.3 mil. He wasn’t estranged from his wife, she was just renovating their beach house 1 hour away. The mother’s house is 15-20 minutes by dark country roads and she has a nurse at night. When he returned to the house he would have seen the lights on at the kennel from the road, but there were none. The first responders describe using their headlights when they arrived. He actually called for both the son and wife to be there that night and as we all know he went to the kennel with the son and wife. He never says he looked for unusual activity on the road, it is desolate out there. What is the sniffing about? And what about pulling his shirt in that moment? You are so right there is no sad reminiscing, so odd. He explains the guy he hired took his daddy to the doctor and he wants us to know he had not fired him yet. “Probably an over reaction” going to get a gun when his wife and son had been killed? It’s a shoot property they have a tons of guns out there and now we know the bullets used are all stocked there. Dumping his chewing tobacco is interesting. The call log now reveals he called 911 on the way to the property, prior to arrival. What is that monster growl?

@fayebutler8640

Жыл бұрын

He has rocked through out the entire trial. I cried a bucket load of tears everyday for almost 3 months when my dog died. When my Dad died, and he was expected to die, I got so upset my entire top and bottom lip broke out in cold sores! He is guilty as can be!

I’m a Charleston native my aunt, uncle, and cousins are from walterboro. My deceased cousin actually had Paul at one of his bday parties when I was growing up. My aunt literally made a big deal about his daddy being a powerful lawyer in the town. This man is guilty and has been knowingly abusing power in this area for decades.

Scott is my kind of people. Has the best little one liners. All these guys get me laughing, they really work well together. They compliment each other!

@TheBehaviorPanel

Жыл бұрын

Thank you, April. 🙂

@kateashby3066

Жыл бұрын

Scott’s ridiculous humor is right up my alley! 😂

To see him switch from this emotionally distraught performance to being able to speak normally was chilling. There is nothing there.

It’s weird that 1- a call to his other son, Buster isn’t one of the first people he calls. And 2- wouldn’t you want to make sure your other son was safe?

@Celestes_Nest

Жыл бұрын

Especially if you think someone is targeting your family.

@maryburton-majure5350

Жыл бұрын

Ding ding ding!!! You don't call him bc he knows already. How does he know? Well...bc he did it!

@DonnaLena1

Жыл бұрын

@@maryburton-majure5350 Sorry, but Buster has a rock hard alibi. He was far from Moselle the night of the murders.

@CaseyRhyneXoXo

Жыл бұрын

I bet he paid a hitman or 2 to kill them. The murderer brought him a change of clothes. Or he did it himself, and he attempted to stage it like a murder/suicide in case law enforcement didn't buy his suggestion that it could be a coordinated ambush fueled by revenge by the family or friends of Mallory Beach.

@Leasagreen

Жыл бұрын

I think it is weird. But also buster may have done this himself. But I think more likely it was cousin Eddie. Of course being hired by Alex or buster.

When my best friend was murdered I was inconsolable for days, the loss was so deep x profound I had trouble speaking, thinking, breathing x even trying to execute basic functions. When l was informed l lost my legs from under me x lost consciousness. For years l often cried uncontrollably for days...NO1 reacts like that but a murderous deranged psychopath.

@anncorsaro224

Жыл бұрын

So sorry for your loss. I had to identify a friend after a motorcycle accident. That was in 1972 and it still leaves such an empty place in my heart when I think about it. This dude is a scum bag sociopath who thinks he’s got everything all sewed up.

@mariamassey5468

Жыл бұрын

@@anncorsaro224 Thank you 🙏 for your consolation x I am very sorry for your friend's departure also. That would have been incredibly arduous. When good people are taken from us unexpectedly, it's unbearably heartbreaking x soul-wrenching for one's that love ❤ them deeply.

This is my test; I’ve got three kids and a husband. I have been moved to tears on more than several occasions watching parents talk who have lost a child, it’s so deep and you can feel their pain. I listened to this (didn’t even watch) and I thought, why is it stirring no emotion in me?! Because that man did not lose his wife and CHILD in a tragic shooting. He definitely knew this was going to happen. I trust my own instincts. Of course a court of law should decide this haha! But that’s my two cents.

@cashmeremonroe7715

Жыл бұрын

What you have is a discerning spirit. It's a gift from God. Not all use it or believe it. I have it also. It Keeps us safer than most ♥️

@barbarafairbanks4578

Жыл бұрын

@Cashmere Monroe Call it what you will... It's empathy. Most neurotypicals, (e.g. non-psychopaths/non-sociopaths) have empathy to some degree or another. Some more, some less so, but 'normal' human emotions include healthy doses of empathy for others. Psychopaths & Sociopaths, OTOH cannot feel empathy for another - they have no 'theory of mind'.. cannot put themselves in anothers shoes. So, it makes perfect sense why so many of us have a problem feeling empathy for Alex. We feel empathy for people who are HURTING...especially losing a child - the worst kind of horrific, raw pain. That's because Alex, imo. has no empathy - he's not experiencing that raw pain and we can all sense it. Our instincts tell us the 'pain' he is faking is not authentic. Any emotion that might resemble 'empathy' for a sociopath/psychopath, is for themselves. I think that's how Alex is so good with the crocodile tears, maybe even conjuring up a few authentic tears, at times...when he feels empathy for himself & sorry state he's gotten himself into.

@andrewkorn3954

Жыл бұрын

That is worth way more than .2 cents !

@yogiine

Жыл бұрын

@@cashmeremonroe7715 im a psychic medium.. he did not do it It was a plot to take him down.

The police officer showed more legitimate human sadness than the father/husband/murderer did. It’s amazing.

@patscats2080

Жыл бұрын

That’s exactly it, the police officer reacted more disturbed over the horror of the situation than Alex did over his loved ones.

@Cherokee51774

Жыл бұрын

You haven't watched the trial. He was a mess when the pictures were shown. There's a lot of reasonable doubt that he did this. It's been a trial more about his finances. Less about the murders. There's been no connection.

@patsyjohnson3963

Жыл бұрын

@@Cherokee51774 Wrong. They have placed him at the scene, have his voice at the scene and finance's, cost of drug payoffs and wanting to keep his outstanding community name was probable cause for murders. $50.000 a week for drug habit might make a person do anything.

When an awful thing happened in my family, nowhere near as tragic as a death/murder, I couldn’t talk to anyone without crying. I know we all react differently but c’mon, he’s like talking about his grocery list….

"I could see his brains laying next to him so I tried to take his pulse."

They should have told him Maggie was still alive and they stabilized her, Alec would have pooped his pants.

@violetsrayreikishop2

11 ай бұрын

Why yall calling him Alec his name is Alex

The guys are right. The cop sitting next to Murdaugh is completely repulsed by him .

@TinaB111

Жыл бұрын

I saw people criticizing him but it was clear to me that he was absolutely disgusted by him but was playing it cool to prevent AM guard from going up.

@pad6080

Жыл бұрын

My thoughts exactly

Y’all nailed him in this video!! Especially after yesterdays admission of lying about being at the kennel minutes before they are murdered!!! Brilliant! Hope you do another analysis of him on the stand testifying in his trial. Thanks for all of these videos, so informative.

The cellphone comment 1:35 immediately did it for me. "I started to try to do something with it.., thinking maybe" Such a strange move.

@violetsrayreikishop2

11 ай бұрын

Right! I was like wow... Do what with it... Hmm

@maureenbrown6697

9 ай бұрын

He was thinking of taking it & tossing Paul's phone on the side of the road just like he did with Maggie's phone.

The detective in the front seat isn't buying a word of it. OMG, what a dastardly SOB. Love this body language analysis. Brilliant and spot on.

I love how Scott always talks about how he's gonna cut stuff out but he never does lol.

@pamelamac2879

Жыл бұрын

Their outtakes are the best!

Please do another evaluation of Murdaugh’s body language during his testimony 😊

@NYLor00

Жыл бұрын

Yes please. I feel conflicted watching him. Would love to hear your thoughts and insights

@gerrilagrange1290

Жыл бұрын

These Men Should create A Video for High School Children No Kidding Aside I am as Serious as falling in Love the first time! Our Lives Could be saved by following how these Men share there knowledge about psychopaths and people that constantly try to put one over on women men or children. I have watched these men for several years with their videos impressed oh absolutely! Just realize that these are very important issues that we have to learn in the times that we live for today thank you to you gentlemen who share all your information knowledge is inevitable for our lives and living ❤️

The big thing I notice in the first clip is how he explained away looking at his sons phone that slid out and what did he say he was doing something with it? He is setting up his excuse for having his fingers all over his son’s phone. Through the shock and horror this man is fiddling with his son’s phone.

Yay! The one I've been eagerly awaiting! Thank you, gentlemen!

@TracyLSingh-RN-JD

Жыл бұрын

Same here!!!

@anaydacaamano7550

Жыл бұрын

Same here!!!

@tammygarris2143

Жыл бұрын

You said it buddy! I am SO psyched for this one!

@rproffitt2918

Жыл бұрын

I’m thinking “Elic”’s going to be a hard one to read. No baseline? He’s a human Chameleon .

@emotionalsupportpaintbrush

Жыл бұрын

Me too! Although from what I’ve learned here at she BP I think we ALL could have figured this out it’s so obvious but it was nice to have all our suspicions confirmed

The body language on the guy asking the questions is stellar. He's leaning as far away from Murdaugh as he can manage without jumping out of the vehicle. 🤣

@christineoleary3862

Жыл бұрын

Yep. He looks very angry to me and can barely look at Murdaugh.

Mark! You are the reason I cut my hair and got highlights. Thanks for the inspiration. I love the new look, you are the bomb ❤ Kathryn B

My son's "tell" is that he clears his throat and says "umm" right after. He's done it since he was a child. I'm betting that Murdaugh's tells are so obvious that his colleagues are now looking back on every conversation they've had with him and wondering how they missed them all.

@ellemarr7234

Жыл бұрын

Oh that’s a really good point! 👏🏽

Not one time did he say to a police officer, “Guys please, find out who murdered my family!”!!!

@patscats2080

Жыл бұрын

Exactly! And wasn’t at all scared for himself or other members of the family. Everything he did and says tells me he’s responsible somehow. I still don’t know how he could have personally, but I think he had it done.

My husband was killed in a car accident. The second I heard he was gone I started screaming, I fell to the floor and screamed no for so long I was horse. I can only tell that story because it’s been 3 years ago now. This isn’t a person that has just lost his loved ones, this is a person that did that to them. It was only after I wore myself out that I went into a shocked catatonic state.

@avi7278

Жыл бұрын

I'm so sorry 😔

@nocturnepapillon

Жыл бұрын

You screamed but when I lost few close family members last year I didn't even cry or do anything, I don't remember much what was going on few days after, people have diffrent reactions

@maineexport13

Жыл бұрын

Sorry for your loss... that's unimaginable trauma to go through.

@patscats2080

Жыл бұрын

I’m so very very sorry you had to go thru that. My husband passed away ten years ago from a known and long illness so I didn’t expect to grieve a lot, I knew I’d be sad…but what I didn’t expect was the gut wrenching grieving I went through. There were times I felt like my insides were bursting open. We were married a long time and everything reminded me of him. Alex’s reactions he’s telling a story about what happened to people he didn’t know and had no connection with.

@Sami-nt2oc

Жыл бұрын

I’m really sorry to hear of your loss :( I completely agree with you!

No one in their right mind would be acting so calm after finding their family brutally massacred. The way his arms & hands are glued to his body are the giveaway for me that he is petrified of saying the wrong thing and looking guilty. Not one ounce of concern about finding this person who allegedly just came onto his property and committed 2 murders? Nah, anyone could see that somethin ain’t right here.

@Val-uy2me

Жыл бұрын

And if any of his BS was true, why isn't he worried about someone taking him out like his son and wife?! Doesn't seem concerned for his own safety or for Buster.

@hnnh1997

Жыл бұрын

@@Val-uy2me Exactly! Wouldn’t he also be concerned about the safety of his other son?!

Loved seeing Greg and Scott on Dr. Phil. I felt bad for the juror. He did seem very nervous and was definitely a man of few words. Bless him for his service in this case.

I was surprised that nobody mentioned how he said (start around 14:08 mark) after he tried to turn his son over and his phone fell out of his pocket that he "started to try to do something with it thinkin maybe but then". That seems like he caught himself mid sentence about to say something incriminating. Especially when you find out that Paul's phone had video of the 3 of them together right before the murders.

@FlyOverGirl

Жыл бұрын

my thoughts exactly... he messed around with both of their phones

@iTammy

Жыл бұрын

What would the Jury think when they found out homeboy lied (again) after they heard his voice on Pauls snap video and gets confirmed by 3 of 4 people on the witness stand! Oopsie! 🫣

@PS_testing321...

Жыл бұрын

If I found my child and spouse murdered, the last thing I would think about is what is on their phone. Because I wouldn't be able to think at all. I would just cling to them. And probably be full of blood and whatever, but I wouldn't think, I would only feel. Emptiness and heartbreak.

@justanothersmith6012

Жыл бұрын

He needed an explanation of why the phone was where it was on Paul and possibly having evidence of Alex’s fingerprints or DNA on it. He totally flubbed that explanation.

@HB.hobby.apiarist

Жыл бұрын

Oh... anyone who has been really watching/ invested in this, did NOT miss it.. just waiting for the prosecution to do a good job to link him to the murders

Chase- you nailed it when you point out what isn't AM talking about. When I first saw this video, I was wondering why he wasn't asking them if they could put protection on Buster, his only living son. I'd be asking, are we being targeted? What can you do to protect us? There is none of that because, in my opinion, he knows there is no additional, external threat!

My son was killed. I lay in bed for one week screaming his name. This guy did not do that. He held a conversation with the cop. Establishing an alibi. He took a shower. He changed his clothes. He called his brother. He killed them. Why or how ge could do it, I don’t know. But I screamed for a week. Just his name.

@ericasimonson8737

Жыл бұрын

I scream-cried every night for two years after my mom died. And that was cancer, not murder. You have my sympathies 💙

@Hayley-sl9lm

Жыл бұрын

Condolences 😔

@createone100

Жыл бұрын

So very sorry for the terrible loss if your son. 💕

@yogiine

Жыл бұрын

We are all different when in shock.

@createone100

Жыл бұрын

How absolutely traumatic for you and your family!! I am so deeply sorry. That pain must be like no other that a human being can experience. I hope you were and are, surrounded by light and love. I am not a religious person, but I know you will see your son again. Bless you on your healing journey. ❤️💖✨✨🙏🏻

Best thing about KZread right here. Greg, Chase, Mark and Scott each offer a unique take each and every episode. So educational. Thanks fellas!!

It’s so weird that he mentions Paul’s cellphone “I tried to do something with it, then put it down” - it seems like he is trying to cover his tracks for why he was fiddling with Paul’s phone. Also the check the pulse and “I tried to touch them as limited as possible” anyone innocent wouldn’t be worried about that.

@bonniesmith142

Жыл бұрын

"It just popped right out of his pocket" Yeah, right.

@astronautchick912

Жыл бұрын

I think he was going to use it to call 911, then thought…. I think that’s what he meant

@michelleknapp4064

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, the cellphone comment has me stumped as well. And if he had really checked them for a pulse, he would have had at least some blood on him SOMEWHERE.

I lost a brother in 2021. It was not entirely unexpected as he was in poor health and 16 years older than me, but he died in his sleep and we found him in his bed the next morning. He also had intellectual disabilities and I had been his caregiver for years and it was not easy. Finding him gone, I was a complete and utter mess, unable to stop crying or speak clearly without a hitch in my voice for hours. Now, I am not a weak woman and have been present for the passing of several family members in ill health and dealt with a great deal of stress and pressure on several fronts in my life. This man should have been practically catatonic at witnessing his beloved wife and son dead in the manner he 'found' them in. Way too calm and collected.

@siobhanmurphykiely8006

Жыл бұрын

I agree and no matter where you’re from his behaviour is so odd. Sorry for your loss.

@mortalclown3812

Жыл бұрын

His nonchalance Is almost terrifying. I'm very sorry for the loss of your brother. Can feel your love for him.

He's not distraught at all for a man who just found his wife and child brutally murdered.

This guy is a practiced liar. He lied convincingly to his friends, partners, family. He cannot, must not be believed.

Thank you, Scott, Chase, Mark and Greg for joining us today! It means so much, and i know you guys are crazy busy. This one was definitely one of the best! Have an awesome rest of your week 💚🙏🕊

@NicolaMaxwell

Жыл бұрын

Lots of love and light my friend 🙏💜💛💫xxxxx

@MayimHastings

Жыл бұрын

@@NicolaMaxwell Nicola! How are you? I've missed you! I'm sorry i didn't see your comment sooner! The last three months if I'm not seeing a doctor, then I'm recovering from seeing one lol! But that's why I've been absent so much. Has it been a crazy winter for you guys over there? Peace, love and light to you, too, Nicola! You are just the sweetest person 💖🙏🕊🤗

True confession: I'm completely obsessed with this case. I was so happy to see TBP finally do a synopsis, and as usual they nailed it. Thank you guys. Please do more on this case, please.

When Alex was being cross examined he answered all the crucial questions with hypotheticals. I may have, I would have, I could have..etc.

NO PARENT would EVER think to "barely touch the wrist" on their dead child. You would IMMEDIATELY try to hold them, if not try CPR. He's a terrible liar.

@_acb

Жыл бұрын

And tried “turning him with his belt loop”

@maried3717

Жыл бұрын

Exactly!

I lost my oldest son Jan, 22,, I still haven't stopped crying

@missrandom7145

Жыл бұрын

I'm so sorry for your loss.

@prentfaiyaz

Жыл бұрын

I'm sorry for your loss

@lidia2261

Жыл бұрын

Bobby, the pain does not go away. You learn to live with it over time. So sorry for your loss

@infamous_k

Жыл бұрын

So sorry for your loss.

@HM-sp4cr

Жыл бұрын

Very sorry to hear. I will say a prayer for your peace and for the repose of his soul.

Guy in the backseat is his friend/attorney. The woman LEO in the backseat testified her suspicions were raised when he mentioned going to see his mother with Alzheimer’s at night because Alzheimer’s patients are typically worse/more agitated at night, so she thought it was an odd time to go see her.

NEVER believe Scott when he says “I’m gonna take that out” 😂

What is even scarier, our Senator who is defending him is part of that inner circle.

Really wish you would run the video clip AS you are describing the details 🙌

The thing that I wish the prosecutor had made a point of is that Alex claimed that he couldn't recall what he talked about with Maggie when he was on the golf cart just before he "got out of there" and went back to the house. That would have been his last conversation with his wife. Any normal, innocent person would have recalled in detail the last conversation that they had with their loved one. Also, he claims that he checked Paul, tried to turn him over and then his phone fell out and he remembers picking it up and placing it on top of him. Again, any normal, innocent parent seeing their child like that wouldn't even register that a phone dropped out of the child's pocket--let alone be worried about picking it up.

@jaykay1053

Жыл бұрын

j L. I think he turned Paul over to retrieve Paul’s phone to “to do something with it”-words he blurted out to the officer. What would he have wanted to do with it? When he saw that the phone was already dead, he put it on the body, concocted the story, “I tried to turn him over”. 1. There is no need to turn over the body to check the pulse. 2. There is no need to check the pulse of a man whose brain is no longer inside his skull.

I have worked as a singer at funeral. So when everyone is crying because a young person or a child has died, I do not lose my cool. I sing without a trembling voice. But when my mother called me one morning and told me that my older brother had committed suicide, my legs gave out. I fell hard at the closet next to me and slided down to the floor. After talking to my mother in utter shock I tried to call a friend, but I could not talk. I was just wailing and snoring. My throat was in a emotional cramp. I could only say a word here and there. I don’t mean that you have to be hysterical. But your body will react if you are feeling sorrow and shock.

@betsykendrick8179

Жыл бұрын

I'm so sorry about your brother. Prayers to you and your family.

You should review the actual first interview from the first cop in the scene. First two things out of Alex's mouth: 1: I had a gun, it's leaning against my car (meaning I couldn't possibly have any other guns around here cuz I'm being upfront and telling you where I put my gun) 2: Immediately goes into the telling of his son's boat accident story (placing blame on some unknown people).

@krystalowens2061

Жыл бұрын

That's the gun he told the 911 operator he was going to go get .because he he didn't know who was still around.

@thegmom7812

Жыл бұрын

​@@krystalowens2061 he is trying to sell a story, guilty af

I can't watch this.. it makes me feel uncomfortable. Almost like second hand embarrassment for the police officer having to sit there and experience this horseshit.

Wow! In the last few minutes of this video Chase said he didn’t know much about this case but he wonders if maybe there is some kinds of stressful event that cause a psychotic break! Yeah! He just got confronted that day about his money fraud. You nailed it chase!

@careip

Жыл бұрын

Plus it was 3 days before Paul's court date.

@marcellepesek3038

Жыл бұрын

Crystal Janzen. No doubt there were huge stressors piling up, starting with the checks being discovered that he had withheld, then the son's boat calamity, his father's illness, his wife being willing to pay everybody back every cent, which is the last thing he wanted, to go back and start from scratch. And the housekeeper dying, without the sons seeing a cent of any promised money. But he'd been part of a powerful family, got involved in drugs for some 20 yrs. and was very stressful to be around. Even if people say he treated them like "family", there was always that sense of entitlement and feeling above the law, apparently. Even if you "snap" from stress, do you (allegedly) lure your wife & son back to the house and blow their brains out? He shakes because he's afraid of what will happen to HIM. It doesn't look like he sheds a single tear or has any grief for his family. As a lawyer, he knows how to act in front of the public, and some witnesses said he knew how to manipulate people. What a tragedy: to have so much given to you and destroying it all, with far- reaching ripples for so many others. May all those affected by this calamity be able to recover, and the victims rest in peace!

My daughter passed away one year ago and the Scott is so right. When I found out I went in to shock my whole body was shaking my head was shaking I was and still am devastated

@HappyOne3

Жыл бұрын

I am very sorry this happened and may you find strength.

@tori8380

Жыл бұрын

Condolences

@imaginempress3408

Жыл бұрын

I'm sorry for your loss. Thanks for your perspective.

@gailrod2096

Жыл бұрын

A.M. makes the oddest noise when clearing his throat, scary.

@philosopherwithin

Жыл бұрын

Oh Mary Mother god! Too much for a mama to bear.💟

His behavior made me think the interview was taking place days later, not immediately afterward

He is so obvious with his eyes checking to see the response of the person questioning him

Please, please, please do more on this guy! The body cam footage is out and his second interview 3 days after the murders is available. Living in South Carolina, this case has been a water cooler topic for over a year now.

@cynthiacameron7891

Жыл бұрын

You can always watch Perry Mason...

His behaviour in court is beyond creepy. He sits normally but the moment any mention is made of the bodies, he instantly starts to rock and fake crying. He turns it off and on as fast as Amber Heard. Makes my skin crawl.

@pamelamac2879

Жыл бұрын

I also noticed, despite having tissues on hand and usually in hand, when his nose is going to flow, he let’s that go so it drops noticeably in his lap, for effect IMO. 🙄

@lifesquandered

Жыл бұрын

@Pamela Mac Right! 😆 at the beginning, i think during opening statements, he did a bunch of fake crying and rocking, and he let a big glob of snot drop onto the table, then he looked up to see if everyone had seen it.

@laurie-jeannelister1029

Жыл бұрын

@@lifesquandered Yes he did!

@1notstressed

Жыл бұрын

I studied one of his hard stares during week one of this trial. You can see the whites of his eyes and he went without blinking for so long it freaked me out!

“..his cell phone popped out of his pocket, I started to try to do something with it, thinking maybe… but then I put it back down really quickly.” What on earth were you thinking (?) maybe (?) about his phone..? Now that the case has gone to trial, we know exactly what he was thinking, maybe, about Paul’s phone.

If you find your family shot you have to assume the shooter could still be around. He never showed fear that someone could still be there.

Those two poor police officers stuck in a car with a murderer and two snotty, snot spitting, snot swallowing, snot coughing, disgusting human beings. I admire their capability to sit next to a murderer with the bodies on the other side of the door, and not scream out, 'murderer!' and run in fear. It must be hell. I can't even imagine

@gsdogsmom

Жыл бұрын

😂😂😂😂😂

I'm intrigued by his lack of rage. Where is the anger, the need to find the killer of his precious child? The anger that his family has been murdered? The desire for justice?

@samueltalbot1456

Жыл бұрын

💯💯 -“what are you guys doing to find the killer??!!!”

I have watched this video before the trial, and after the trail. What the panel pick up on is spot on! 👌

😂😂😂❤ I love you guys so much!!! Smart and hilarious is a perfect combination for learning, in my opinion 😄 🤓

Please listen to his 911 call. Absolute silence while it's ringing and as soon as they answer its the full show!

@mjchiwara

Жыл бұрын

Exactly 💯🎯. AM didn't realise he was being recorded BEFORE the operator picked up ... he was completely silent. No distress, no heavy breathing, no crying UNTIL the operator is on the line & the drama begins.

Yeah...It took me about 7 years to be able to talk about bombing we survived without my body uncontrollably shaking when I try to explain how that went down. When something tragic happens you are in shock, shock and horror... And panic....Can barely talk, let alone being able to tell the story and go into details right after.

He's way too calm for any husband/father who just found his wife and son shot to death with brains splattered everywhere, etc. I'd be freaking out, throwing up sick to my stomach, shaking and crying that I wouldn't be able to speak. They'd have to take me by ambulance to the hospital to sedate me. I'd literally lose my mind.

@KClark-xe3wb

Жыл бұрын

I've been saying the same thing about what my reaction would be if I found family members after they were shot in the same manner as these victims. I'd literally lose my mind also.

@nancyferguson8295

Жыл бұрын

Me too

@BizzyGigi

Жыл бұрын

@Baubles and Dolls I agree that I would be hysterical and inconsolable if I were in that position. But furthermore I would want police out there IMMEDIATELY looking for who did this to my family? Get the criminal who did the killing. But I never heard AM say anything like that at all, ever. Maybe I missed it somewhere though.

All that coughing, hacking, sniffling really grossed me out.

@nevereverforever0010-uf9su

9 ай бұрын

its a pin point hes saying too much. ppl do this out of nervousness, suspision, and to try and not look guilty even tho they know they are. true tatics of psychopaths and narssasistm

His answer to the female detectives question as to when he texted his wife, “What time was WHAT?” The “what” was an arrogant, I’m a lawyer, Southern gentleman, and a Murdaugh, who are you to question me little lady? He recovered quickly because he remembered the male detective was there listening.

@rebeccaanderson5191

Жыл бұрын

I caught that.

@cynthiakarpamccarthy6598

Жыл бұрын

Yep.

@siyo99

Жыл бұрын

Notice how defensive he got or offended he got when on the emergency call concerning Maggie and Paul and the dispatcher asked if he lived in a mobile home or a house 🏠

@heidisymonds4382

Жыл бұрын

Yep, I completely agree, I heard distain on his reaction to the female officer too, the smallest thing but very telling

@vickifischer-rasmussen3850

Жыл бұрын

I’m not so sure about that. I was an RN for 45 years accustomed to thinking and acting under pressure and documenting events in chronological order. When I was 67 years old, I was assaulted by a 28 year old. The cops were a bit sus when they arrived at my home to be handed a typewritten statement of events in chronological order before I sought medical attention. Someone who is accustomed to thinking this way defaults to that. Murtaugh is a strategic thinker and a lawyer, so I would expect him to be thinking about who did it, what are the clues, not snivelling like a toddler or honking like a goose. I won’t express an opinion about guilt, but his behaviour had my antennae spinning. Sounds from witnesses as though people were walking all over the crime scene though. I would have expected a lawyer to be screaming at people to back off until CSI could process the scene.

Would you guys consider doing a second part to this? Now that we have more interrogation footage and the court case?

@carolynsnodgrass3752

Жыл бұрын

Please, please, please?!!! I have been hoping and watching for it!

I find it fascinating that the cop next to Alex doesn't want to look at Alex at all. He looks as if he doesn't believe Alex's statement and he's already on to Alex.

His phone fell out of his pocket? Your staring at your brutally murdered child and you notice his phone falling out of his pocket? I think that would be the last thing I would notice.

@TeddyLovesAxl

Жыл бұрын

Didn’t seem to notice his son’s brains falling out of his head! But he noticed the damn phone falling out of his pocket! Smdh! 😮

@nathalieslaney5131

Жыл бұрын

I suspect he did see the phone, that's why he brought it up... but I think he tried to check his son's phone... or perhaps try to use it to send someone a text from his (son's) phone to create a different time alibi? Its just odd how he talks about the phone but suddenly omits the end of the sentence because it probably is "then I tried to check it" and couldn't unlock it

I would be inconsolable. Screaming, running, falling down , pleading to God, an absolute hysterical wild woman! I could not answer questions when my son’s brain was blown out of his skull!!! This man is guilty beyond a shadow of a doubt.

The entire interview is bizarre. His son’s head got blown off & his wife was executed & he’s sitting there with a totally clean white shirt chewing gum. He’s a sociopath. The fact he thinks anyone believes his BS is scary. Pathological liar folks. I’ve been around enough of them to know

The "friend" in backseat is an attorney. It's been said he had an attorney with him every time they questioned him.

the most disturbing part of this is the guy snorting his own boogers and swallowing them every second

This has been one of my favorite episode! I loved it when Chase leaned forward and said, with a straight face, “ you don’t know about the Navy Seals and a high schooler who went after the Black Panthers….”! It was GREAT! I busted out laughing. I also dont know of any other episode that “within the first 18 seconds..” y’all called the man a liar. I mean, it took nearly the whole show for Casey Anthony to be called a liar. LOVED IT! Thanks guys!

@lozfranklin9501

Жыл бұрын

🤣🤣🤣🤣

@NicolaMaxwell

Жыл бұрын

😂😂😂 gold!

"Why are we sitting here... go find who did this NOW" would be the first words out of my mouth in that situation. That is... if I weren't the killer.

@JMay-

Жыл бұрын

@@bubbles8120 He wanted the buffer of lots of sympathetic bodies btw him and LE. It's weird that some cops knew he did it while SLED didn't lock off the entire property and really dig in. Those good ol boys don't recognize a bad ol boy amongst them.

When my son passed I remember I kept saying why? Why?! And he wasn’t even murdered! He doesn’t even wonder?

And, he says the 911 operator ‘was nice’. That was a red flag for me.

@silverforest4682

Жыл бұрын

He said he didn't touch them too much. Wouldnt you try to get a pulse or shake them?

@saraG100

Жыл бұрын

Me too. My narcissist ex would absolutely do that (See? I'm a good person. I recognize the little people. See what I did? Nothing to do w/the 911 operator. Just an interjection for an "atta boy" for him.

"His cell phone popped out of his pocket so I picked it up and started trying to do something with it, thinking maybe ... But then I put it down real quickly!" I wonder if he even knew Paul was recording. If so, he was thinking, how can I get rid of this evidence!!!

@thestepfordwife

Жыл бұрын

Yes! “….thinking maybe…I needed to check it for any recordings or photos and delete them” is what he was thinking! That is also why he tried getting into Maggie’s phone!

you guys should listen to the bodycam footage of the FIRST RESPONDER. 20min after calling 911 Alex and the first responder walk at the scene, the scene where his wife and son's bodies are still lying uncovered, the officer asks him a question and he starts talking all teary and then stops MID-SENTANCE voice completely changes to say "hey how ya doin" to a officer walking past, then goes back into emotional voice answering the original question.... WTF????

@joycesinclair9397

Жыл бұрын

I’d love to hear what the guys would say on that one.

"How was your relationship with Paul?" "As good as it COULD be" - he had given up on Paul. Done.

at 54 seconds in , immediately before the lady Deputy Sheriff says "I'm sorry," Alex looks directly at the camera right after breaks down crying, he is playing to the camera.

There would be no conversation or interview with me after finding my child and/or spouse murdered. They would have to wait until I came to in the hospital after screaming myself to near death. I cannot imagine the terror experienced by the wife and son as they saw the gun pointed at them.

@SniperLogic

Жыл бұрын

I just made an identical comment before I read yours. They’d have the crime solved by the time I was released from the mental ward and able to converse with them…..if I hadn’t suicided. That he can discuss anything at all while his family lies dead yards away is beyond my comprehension. I’d be strapped to a gurney & heavily sedated.

@gotlandia1588

Жыл бұрын

Agree! No interviews only needing the best sedation.

The murder happened June 7 and the police got paul and maggie's phone that same night, but didn't ask for Alex's phone until October, and guess what: he'd deleted the activity from that day. Also, if you want to see a real study in fear behavior, check out the testimony of Shelly, the caregiver for Alex's mom that night. She was so scared on the stand she cried, and sometimes could not even answer.

@shanny4306

Жыл бұрын

🇨🇦 Oh yes !, she had me crying with her ! What a kind spirited woman she is , I’d be lucky to have someone half as nice as her caring for me if I couldn’t function well anymore !

@forrestfey

Жыл бұрын

The police did not even secure the crime scene.

@NopeJustMe

Жыл бұрын

I felt so bad for Miss Shelly and Blanca.

@amandak3198

Жыл бұрын

Well it doesn't really matter if he deleted stuff, it can all be recovered anyway.

@NopeJustMe

Жыл бұрын

@@amandak3198 if you watch the trial you would see a lot of stuff was not retrieved.

You guys are dead-on. It is so useful to listen to the analysis and then watch the video-so enlightening.

All of you guys have been my A1's since my entry into the True Crime world with the Summer Wells case. I had no clue behavior/body language experts even existed. I also had no clue that such evil, soulless monsters existed, especially so very close to me. Yikes. Unsettling, to say the least. You're ALL stars, extraordinarily talented and, in my opinion, second to none! You guys are the best! Mark, I have to say, I belly laughed at you several times here. You all are individually sharp as tacks, but together are other worldly! 👌😍❤️

Before Alec left the house to go visit his mom, he says he called Maggie down at the kennels to let her know and there was no answer. Then he left, but didn't he have to drive right past the turn-off to the kennels on the way out? Why wouldn't he just pull over there to tell Maggie and Paul he was leaving and would be right back? It's the most normal thing you'd do if she hadn't picked up the phone and it was on his way exiting the property. Unless of course he killed them.

Did anyone catch on the police body cam video, when he's "crying " and someone he must recognize walks by in the dark background, Alex suddenly looks left and says, "How are you doing?" His mistake from "grieving " to "friendly" instantaneously was very obvious.

@andrewkorn3954

Жыл бұрын

I think that was a second officer who arrived to investigate a double murder he just committed . Ho Hum Im just a nice " Hey How Ya Doin " kind of double murderer . In Character - Out Of Character and then back again Poof just like that .

I don't even have to watch this video ..... the 911 call sealed the deal for me when the very first thing he said before anything else was his full name and address ..... WHO DOES THAT after they've just found their family brutally murdered??? Wouldn't the FIRST thing be HELP someone please get here my family has been SHOT!!??

The cop in the drivers seat isn't buying any of that.

Gosh I just adore Chase and the care he takes to make his other panel members feel comfortable and heard. He seems like a good guy

PLEASE TELL ME YOU GUYS ARE GOING TO DO A VIDEO ON ALEX TESTIFYING ON THE STAND TODAY 2/23/23!!!!

@dolphinbombshell7100

Жыл бұрын

That would definitely get a lot of attention. I know several people watching this case that I am sending to watch this video. They would love seeing that one as well.

@miriamart9712

Жыл бұрын

They did!!! 😁

42:01 Watching this after the trial and Greg nailed it with what the female cop was thinking. Cause that’s exactly what she testified!

When the police first showed up, he was crying, no tears, no snot, no crumbled face. I don't know about you all, when I'm crying my face is a mess. I would need tissue.

"I called 911 pretty much right away....and she was good" has to be the most bizarre thing ever said by someone who VERY RECENTLY had to call 911 because they found their wife and son murdered...and a strange time to rate the 911 operator. Wtf 😒😣

@Nope-s

Жыл бұрын

Now Mark is confirming what I was thinking lol. It's lunacy

Chase was right on about the call log because he deleted about 80 calls. Not realizing that the calls are registered with the carrier..

@salutsoleil3682

Жыл бұрын

Who doesn’t know the carrier has records? He’s a dumbass. Erasing the calls is further evidence of guilt.

Listen to this guy jail phone calls. He’s unbelievable. Tells you everything you need to know about his personality.

You guys are always so spot on, extremely professional and present.

I was an RN for 45 years. I've seen real grief from family members, even when the death was somewhat expected. I don't see that grief here. Or real shock, as when death is unexpected and sudden. Or fear, like my family's been slaughtered, are they still there and coming for me as well? It's not there.

@krystalsutherland8392

Жыл бұрын

I absolutely agree! I had been expecting my son's death for 11 months and I was vomiting, couldn't breathe, I couldn't even stand. I couldn't have even told you my name.

@melaniegaribaldi6724

Жыл бұрын

Toni, I was RN for 30+ years. I totally agree 👍

@tonibiava1047

Жыл бұрын

@@krystalsutherland8392 sorry for your loss.

@krystalsutherland8392

Жыл бұрын

@@tonibiava1047 Thank you. And thank you for the years of public service you gave. It takes a very special person to be a nurse.

@teresaholbrook7983

Жыл бұрын

Absolutely not. Also an RN!

Scott nailed it! He did change clothes and he has no evidence on him from being at the scene. I just ran across this video, sorry for the multiple comments. But reading people is something I have done since I was little. Ibwas an Officer for 10yrs and an EMT for 17yrs. This guys is Full of it! I live a few hours North from this and it just makes me mad how this whole scene etc were handled when its so apparent!

Scott you cracked me up with that Robert wagner comment ..lol that guy coughing like he's got Zika 😆😆😆😆