One of the first times the western or English speaking media has addressed the catalytic murder case in Taiwan...

@Fai2012

4 жыл бұрын

Even that is too short of a summary. Taiwan played a role in this protest by not cooperating with the drafting of the extradition bill, while calling for justice to be brought to the family. Then when the murderer wanted to turn himself in to Taiwan after serving his sentence in Hong Kong, Taiwan also rejected. Of course, Taiwan president got pounded for that.

@irememberla6460

4 жыл бұрын

Fai2012 Yes for sure! It is a complicated scenario

@howard13243883

4 жыл бұрын

@@Fai2012 Stop spreading lies. Taiwan government were willing to provide the evidence to the Hong Kong government so that the murderer can be trialed in Hong Kong, but the Hong Kong government refused. There are also other suggestions to transfer the murderer to Taiwan such as case-by-case extradition bill approved not by the HK Cheif Executive, but by the Legco, or the HK gov could add a Sunset Clause into the extradition bill. All these suggestions were proposed by lawers or legislators, but Carrie Lam rejected all those suggestions and chose the most controversial one, which obviously because China wants to take more control on HK. Furthermore, Taiwan gov didn't reject to take the murderer. It's the murderer dicided to stay in Hong Kong after releasing from jail. Please check the facts first!

@Fai2012

4 жыл бұрын

@@howard13243883 Actual printed newspaper. I don't know where you got your facts from but if those are also your "truth" then the world is really is a dangerous place. You and I are both contributing to the discussion and revealing the gap, stay positive and non-personal if you can. Thanks.

@wanfeichim6307

4 жыл бұрын

The western media dont tell everything. Even this report is not objective.

this is what you call a real news reporting .. great Job

@Dignity100

4 жыл бұрын

yes

@SamYung0

4 жыл бұрын

al jazeera? real news? PLEASE! its like saying cow dung is real butter.

@amerolisla8950

2 жыл бұрын

Just do belEive that sanction resulted in Iran may . Resulted to wourld war 3 , this is some sort Advise and save people so we end now our advise, And give chance if they do think wisely ,

@anonymous1926ias

Жыл бұрын

Yeah but this also reality, this journalism of Al-Jazeera is limited only to non-Muslim countries...

Thank you for explaining the "why" and a little history behind the Hong Kong protest.

This is most simplest explanation I seen about HONG KONG .... thanks Al Jazeera

@heinzrichung

4 жыл бұрын

this al Jazeera is bullshit . only few people are for full independence from china

@TheTeKuZa

4 жыл бұрын

@Nguyen Khoi Learn Venezuela, election result is valid if you vote the right way

@TheTeKuZa

4 жыл бұрын

@Nguyen Khoi not entirely, but I did follow the news. So did in Venezuela. Btw Venezula has the same process as my country. My country was considered best denocratic election process in SE Asia while Venezuela in S America. Venezuela has majority too just like HK. But somehow because Venezuela was accused of intimidating oppositions then the west considered it invalid, while rioters in HK were clearly intimidating pro government voters during campaign was considered valid by the west, if you notice both HK and Venezuela election process were the same if not similar.

@simon6071

4 жыл бұрын

As much as I appreciate the video host's attempt to give an objective report about the Hong Kong protest, I found her report to be inadequate if not biased against the protesters due to ignorance as can be seen from the missing of crucial events which explain why the Hong Kong people are justified to hold massive protests against the Hong Kong police and communist China.

@simon6071

4 жыл бұрын

The crucial events that she failed to mention include: 1/ The Yeun Long Terrorist attack in which communists in Hong Kong hired pro-communist gangsters to attack Hong Kong people indiscriminately because the communists could not tolerate the massive peaceful protests against them. (NOTE: Please copy and paste titles for search of the videos. I'm unable to provide you the link because Google/KZread would stealth ban my comments with links) VIDEO: Mayhem in Hong Kong: Armed masked men brutally assault train passengers VIDEO: ‘My heroes’: Pro-Beijing lawmaker applauds Yuen Long men in white GOOGLE: 2019 Yuen Long attack - Wikipedia

Im thankful for them showing both sides and not all news sites have done this, not everyday you see a proper non-biased explanation into whats going on here

I like this journalist and series, good job Al Jazeera!

@wasifurrahman2764

4 жыл бұрын

Her name plz

@SelkentBus

4 жыл бұрын

@@wasifurrahman2764 atrevido!

Great Summary. I think this is the first doc on the HK protests that recognizes these protests are a result of many prior protests and that it's not just merely over the extradition bill. These protests run much deeper than just that bill, similar to how the American Revolution was over much more than just a tax on tea.

@teeteeang289

4 жыл бұрын

It is stirred up by sone foreigners and happened that those foolish student thinking they are smart followed blindly...They thought that is democracy which British had never gave them in those 150 years of ruling....

@garettreid8729

4 жыл бұрын

@@teeteeang289 Yes. I'm sure you and the CCP will show them true democracy

@teeteeang289

4 жыл бұрын

How can I give them democracy. ..its rubbish. I m just giving my opinion. .I live in Spore...and believe democracy has its limit...

@garettreid8729

4 жыл бұрын

@@teeteeang289 Spore? I'm assuming you mean SIngapore. Is that the cool way to say it? If I need to spell out the meaning of my comment for you then it's not worth it. If you can't see the difference between the gov't of mainland China and HK then you are lying to yourself; Even if you believe HK has a "fake democracy", it is a stark difference from the gov't that the CPP will give them. Freedom of speech, freedom of assembly, freedom of the press, freedom of religion........I could go on and on about the differences. That is what they are fighting about.

This is a REALLY good video!! No bias like most other media. Thank you for providing such accurate insights!

@brennencox516

4 жыл бұрын

Can you give me an example of evidence by other media outlets?

Please also include the 21 July Yuen long incident where the police deliberately arrived 39 minutes late after gangsters had a terrorist attack on the train. Attacked indiscriminately.

As Hong Konger , this video showed a clear pictures about the protest.

@jakelaw9768

4 жыл бұрын

What about Julian Assange and Edward Snowden??

@jakelaw9768

4 жыл бұрын

I don't understand why make such a big deal about China making laws for Hong Kong?? I mean Hong Kong is apart of China therefore if your bring Anti-China settlement makes you pro-separatist like Joshua Wong, Jimmy Lai, Marten Lee & etc?? To sum what the Interviewee said is all based on "feelings"?? I mean Britain did much worse things to Hong Kong like never allowing any freedom or democracy yet no so called international news covered that therefore I don't know why this video made it seem like Britain did!

@ori592

4 жыл бұрын

@@jakelaw9768 I want to know where do you live in, a country under democracy or tyranny? Cause if you are just living in the west enjoying your freedom and rights, you have no right to judge why people make such a big deal

@firewoodloki

4 жыл бұрын

Britain did much worse things to Hong Kong? Like what? Building public housing for us and one of the best transportation system on earth? Look at what happens to Uyghurs closely, and what happened to the Mainland students on Tiananmen Square 30 years ago, then tell me again if you truly think the Brits have ever done things worse than the government you worshipped. Remember, no other groups have ever matched the kill count by your beloved CCP government towards their people.

"without putting a real fight…‘’ hope there will be a peaceful transition rather than a fight...

@Crashed131963

4 жыл бұрын

Before the British pulled out they should have gave Hong Kong nuclear ICBM silos. No country with ICBMs ever gets invaded.

Very informative, unbias reporting! Keep up the good work!

Let's talk about the only person who died during 6 months of unrest. that person was a 70 old man caught in a brawl between citizens and was hit by a brick thrown by a RIOTER

this is what you call, real news reporting

@Dignity100

4 жыл бұрын

yes

@CrayCow

4 жыл бұрын

@Jana Catudan And yet they have the audacity to mention police brutality

@dawn8525

4 жыл бұрын

@Jana Catudan proof?

@dawn8525

4 жыл бұрын

@@CrayCow yeah police shooting at point blank, gang raping protesters and shooting pepper spray to children and passerbys are the most righteous, correct and best thing the police force did. You need to get things checked out Chinese CCP bot

Finally, a simplistic explanation.

May Allah give justice and ease to the people of Hong Kong 🤲🏼💔

One point to note here, The number of unknown body found/ strange suicide cases have skyrocketed between June and December. The official records are now around 2000 to 3000 cases. And many people reported missing after join protest or even peaceful assembly. If you have watched "Winter on Fire", you know what this means....

@2soulss

4 жыл бұрын

agree. n police brutality n violation of law all the time.

Has any of the protesters read the “HK extradition ordinance” ever? ONLY judged by the HK High Court to be guilty AND is sentenced over 5 years can perhaps be extradited to mainland China. The bill excludes 7 types of economical crimes and all of the political crimes. The Chinese government can use the bill ONLY AFTER the HK court makes the judgement.

3:15 missing the one in chinese

@bizneat3610

4 жыл бұрын

lol! I noticed too.

@wickedleeloopy2115

4 жыл бұрын

Can you translate...? Zero Country Two systems .lol

I needed this! Thank you AJ

Only 5 demands but not Independence..

@teeteeang289

4 жыл бұрын

If this protestors happened Spore..They were either a jail and 10 strokes of cane if they used arrow like Robin Hood or destroyed any public properties they will be met with police's guns..... So Hongkies called no democracy? I think those rioters have to be taught a lesson. .maybe, send them to gods. ..

@teeteeang289

4 жыл бұрын

Democracy has its limit...those rioters not protestors. .They are public nuisance. ..its difficult to understand HK police as well...on one hand approved public demonstration and the next they have to clean all those ''rubbish''....didn't they have more important issues to address etc... To many neighbouring countries this demonstrators are going too far., perhaps tge polices are encouraging them by given approvals. Look at others countries if such rioters and public vandalism happened what will happened to them. What a childish joke when they demand police of taking tougher action..but neglect their own attitude of vandalised public properties. .. It must be joke of this century.

@jefferyhan3694

4 жыл бұрын

stfu you probably ain't even Korean. Now go back to worshipping the superior Asian race.

Thank you for this explanation

This is what I call reporting news, no bulls*it, no bias just fact !! Great job!!

@Dignity100

4 жыл бұрын

Indeed

@brennencox516

4 жыл бұрын

Well， they missed some facts, but to err is human.

This series deserves more views...

Did u say that in the Sino-British Declaration the Chinese promised people of HK with universal Suffrage and total reform of the Legislative Council into a fully elected body? Not that people of HK asked for it; it is promised as an international treaty lodged in the UN, a promise that the Chinese resiled and refused to deliver! That’s where the frustration comes from. U can do better AlJazeera

Free Hong Kong 🇭🇰 sovereignty, prosperity, freedom❤️

6:13 She doesn't mention how long it took them to do that first action... Which is a major point.

this is a really good video regarding the topic thanks for making it!

Great video! Loved to know about it all!

thanks for being one of the more neutral and un-biased report out there on the HK situation

@Dignity100

4 жыл бұрын

Hear, hear!

@brennencox516

4 жыл бұрын

They glossed over quite a few things.

Finally, a simplistic explanation.thanks AJ.... make video on Afgha peace

UK didn't GIVE HK back. Margaret Thatcher met Deng XiaoPing and hoped to keep HK. She even threatened consequences, DXP just said HK will then be back on China's term, meaning PLA will fight British Army in HK, although it was not said directly. Please watch old videos on this meeting.

@crtordoes

4 жыл бұрын

IMHO Margaret Thatcher stumbled and fell on the steps after meeting Teng. Nervous breakdown 😱

@rcl998

4 жыл бұрын

Deng said Issue regarding the unification of the nation is not negociable

@imdba3685

4 жыл бұрын

The Brit also planted many bombs in Hong Kong before they were 'officially' out.

@IhateCCP

4 жыл бұрын

people keep getting this fact wrong. Hong Kong was invaded under military threat. Hong Kong is much older than People's Republic of China.

@fromfareast3070

4 жыл бұрын

@@imdba3685 they sold most of the lands to private businessman before leaving out. That's a Astounding Move!

Thanks al jazeera for taking this wonderful initiative to aware people about the issues ...👍

Great video!!

Hi team, I really love the content you present. It it very precise and to the point. My request --> Can you guys please do a piece on Crimea's annexation by Russia? Thanks!!

Very Liked the way they presented the video, Looks and feels like a Mission debriefing :D

thank you, Aljazeera. 3:13 it's "一国两制." Besides, "1 death and hundreds arrested" is not true actually. Since the breakout of protest, more than 2000 "suspected suicide" cases have been reported. There was no sign indicating their suicide will, however. It is widely believed that these protesters might have been secretly executed. Almost 6000 have been arrested, facing at least 10 years in prison... some of them were even transported to mainland China, which shall be a clear infringement against "One country Two systems." Taiwan supports HK.

thx for explaining

You guys are doing great job. Do cover trade wars, other protests around the globe, ukraine crisis, Palestine issue and Kashmir issue.

@omaralkayal7598

4 жыл бұрын

Sharjeel Ahmad It’s okay even if they didn’t regarding Palestine, thankfully they have already done tons of documentaries about Palestine both in Arabic and English

Very impressed with Al Jazeera English. This is such an effective news organization. I put it up with there with NPR with its unbiased and clear exposition. Thanks for the hard work!!!

Very informative in just a few minutes. Clears things up and summarizes plenty

Thanks for the concise and neutral break down of the situation.

yes, more international coverage plz.

This is best intiutive piece of a complex news. Hats off, keep up your good work.

very informative . thanks

More protests = Need more OT paid to the polices

My favorite reporter, you report in a way that, I never can't forget about what I heard.

It's the government who proposed the bill, not the lawmakers. And some lawmakers provided various alternatives to solve the issues without having to tie HK's judicial system to CCP China's, but the gov rejected.

This lady is best in story telling! I love it.

This is probably the best coverage of Hong Kong without bias language nor casting opinion as news.. very neutral and objective coverage. Great work !

perfect

Well done, thank you!

Mam your videos are very informative and to the point. Keep up the good work.

Thanks so much this media telling the truth in June 2019 Hong Kong protesters 👉 very clear and true all the news 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

@Dignity100

4 жыл бұрын

i agree

Don't forget someone was set on fire by protestors about someone was killed by a brick.

Write on Kashmir

Very nice and concise. Thanks Al Jazeera!

Can you guys make a video on India protests too becouse politics here are also too messy to understand

I like how you explain and break down facts making it easy to understand... keep it up

Thank you

There is a big thing missing from the explanation. That is the foreigner's involvement in making Hong Kong destabilized as bargaining power in US-China trade war.

appreciate the neutral reporting on HK. Thank you so much and keep it up. This is what news should be rather than taking sides

Good job! Non-biased reporting! Sadly Hong Kong will never be independent of China.

Thanks for sharing the real news!

Hong Kong has proven to the world that it is different from China.

@Crashed131963

4 жыл бұрын

The world is different from China thankfully. Hong Kong just wants to be like the rest of the world.

@tobyli52

4 жыл бұрын

HK is different in a worse way

Great show

Loved the piece.😍 but why you want me contact you with ideas via Twitter/FB ?? I don't like or use either....

Great video, thank you. I wish you had explained in more depth about how the "business ties with the mainland" of the "other sectors" makes the pro-China bloc bigger. That seems important, but it's still pretty fuzzy how that works.

@indigoyim963

4 жыл бұрын

As the legislators of the 'other sectors' often are businessmen and had ties with the mainland, which they get benefits from the CCP, the central government of the China, they have to vote in favor for the mainland government in various bills even if the bills are opposed by the general public of Hong Kong, as they don't have to fear that the HK citizens would vote them out in the next election.

@tomtam8789

4 жыл бұрын

There was a lot more background that could be covered, but this was a decent brief summary.

Great job, you mentioned the opium war and the murder case unlike media in us and uk.

@ter0874

4 жыл бұрын

What I wish is both sides be mentioned in Mainland China. In the US and UK atleast you'll be able to read both sides, unlike in China where Winnie the Pooh Bear is banned. Lol.

@vengefulspirit99

4 жыл бұрын

Too bad this isn't a two way street. Try releasing anything showing the hk side in China. See what happens to you

@ter0874

4 жыл бұрын

@@vengefulspirit99 in the US and UK you can read both sides of the story and yet this Chinese👆 complains.

@brennencox516

4 жыл бұрын

The murder case was reported on in US media. But it's not your job to know everything Pengfei Liu. 鹏飞六

@SomethingStrange910

4 жыл бұрын

@@ter0874 I live in the US and there is NO "both sides" when it comes to China. When the police shot the guy in his chest, all media showed the footage before and after the protestor tried to grab the police's gun, which is the standard code for the police to shoot in the US. Everything is acceptable as long as It's in the name of "Democracy". Pfff

Protests should be carried out peacefully, not violently.

Wow first time l understand what is really going on between China and Hong Kong

@sandra.gathmann

4 жыл бұрын

Our team is glad to hear it!

No, it's not about truth or stance, and there is no point fighting over this video or criticizing the content maker. She/They are just summarizing information from western mainstream media and internet sources. Just a part of that western mainstream.

Another excellent, concise news report by Al Jazeera and its fine reporter, Sandra Gallmann.

@sandra.gathmann

4 жыл бұрын

It's all thanks to our amazing team!

@teckhohng3870

4 жыл бұрын

She communicates well,too. Factual and not biased like the China news casters.

Fantastic reporting! Very balanced. Thank God we have the NSL now.

Separatist idea is definitely held by some of the people in Hong Kong but it has never got to the mainstream. However, it is heavily propagandised in China’s state media for the audience of mainland Chinese. Most of the people in HK still stick to the five demands without asking for independence. Your explanation will give people false impression that HK is fighting for independence. I can’t agree with you on that.

@vincentaw2418

4 жыл бұрын

Daisy like how police violence is heavily propagandised by foreign media for the foreign audience? Let's find a balance between that. I know what you're thinking. "Communist scum" "CCP troll" "Go back to China". It's not hard to understand

I need to understand the basics of the Syrian conflict..it's just too difficult to understand and it's super complex..we do need a video for that please...loving these..❤ -India

Good luck people of Hong Kong! With unity, even normal citizens can become stronger than the government!

@Asian-Outdoors

3 жыл бұрын

Silly Rabbit, Trix are for kids

Demonstration over a murderer. An evil student murderer.

@egukoucu

4 жыл бұрын

LT L you need to watch it again it seems

only one person died after many months of violence .. wow

@locacharliewong

4 жыл бұрын

She "couldnt see" the "being suicide" fellows.

@yopyop3241

4 жыл бұрын

Not sure what the numbers are now, but a little while ago it was 10 killed in France, one of which was by the police 14 killed in Chile, three of which were by the police In HK, there are two dead officially, neither committed by the police. But in HK there has also been a huge increase in the number of deaths that are classified as suicides, and the people of HK don't trust the HK police to have done proper investigations. The majority of HKers believe that the HK police have killed people and then engaged in cover ups. The level of distrust of the police among the people of HK is off the charts. The median HKer now rates their trust in the HK police at zero out of 100.

@teckhohng3870

4 жыл бұрын

One death but the economy is in danger. Recession has set in.

@adrianatgaming8640

4 жыл бұрын

@@yopyop3241 thanks to the advanced medical department, hk has not seen awful number of deaths.

@yopyop3241

4 жыл бұрын

​@@adrianatgaming8640 Not significantly more advanced than France. So the differentiator has to be due to a more peaceful and more controlled character on the part of the protesters.

The universal suffrage is written on Hong Kong basic law promised in 2007 Hong Konger can vote for their chief executive, Hong Konger simply want the government fulfil their promise

I do love this!!!!

NICE PRESENTATION

pretty sure more than 1 died. the scout rioter who leaped to his death thinking there was a platform and a civilian who got hit in the head with a brick thrown by the rioter, there may be one more other; not to mention the rioters burning a civilian completely head to toe for disagreeing with them, man is in coma

@yjasper8411

4 жыл бұрын

pretty sure police killed more than a dozen protesters, and fake it as suicide. plus the civilian who got hit in the head with bricks was killed by one of his ally, if u want to have the vid for ur reference, go take a look.

Do a video on the Rohingya Crisis in Bangladesh and the Genocide that had happened. There is an on-going hearing in International Court of Justice against Myanmar. Lawsuits have been filed against Nobel Peace Laureate Aung San Suu Kyi in Argentina by Human Rights group. She has become an international villain and now tarnishing her image even further by defending genocide herself in ICJ.

I think this is a good video althrough some deeper issues can not clearly deliver to the subscriber. 1. the protest were very peaceful at first. But the government was deliberately escalate the conflict. some violent events proposed by police (with clear video evidence) and triad (a.k.a chinese gansters) cooperate and target citizens ( e.g event on 21st July) More than hundreds of people were severely injuried. Some are disabled permanently.

@aldrichhai9638

4 жыл бұрын

Yes. I agree you said loads of bullshit because I see no point in you mind.

Excellent introduction

from the first one minute we understund that no foreign powers have cause the trubles and this is good! is clear chinas problem and we can nothing do! i just long was waiting such info and how the things have started and this go more back the extradition bill wich from this point i know and remember the problems in HK! but this event of facts have bring such results! who can even imagine!

Good job Al Jazeera. I like this kind of journalism.

It is like kurdstan in iraq....they want full autonomy.......that’s a global problem.

@magogo5905

4 жыл бұрын

By the way keep up....may be best political program.

Great job sis greetings in imphal manipur northeast india.

“one country, two systems ” it’s “一国两制”, not “国两制”。

@alantan9863

4 жыл бұрын

Short of '一'.

@celesteyeung8504

4 жыл бұрын

Does not really matter now, right? It is becoming one country one system anyway, maybe not now, but very soon if we don't stand up against the CCP.

@JY-ns3ug

4 жыл бұрын

@@celesteyeung8504 According to the agreement, one country one system will become true very soon. So why do you need to stand up against the CCP? To protect criminals from justice?

@celesteyeung8504

4 жыл бұрын

@@JY-ns3ug if we still haven't succeed in 2047, we are forced to accept that. But before 2047? Don't challenge the HKers.

@JY-ns3ug

4 жыл бұрын

@@celesteyeung8504 The agreement was made by British and Chinese, so if you're not satisfied with that, fight UK back, it's revenge time!

Please talk about Lebanon crises

Tis is hw protest starts. Good job....reporting truth facts. Well done....lady...

I don't know why but I always cry every time I see a news coverage about Hong Kong protests

@iamedyson

3 жыл бұрын

Why would you want to cry about Hong Kong protest when you're an American?

天 啊 是我第一回認真看完的英文視頻

No democracy under British rule. Governor ran HK with executive committee, which was made of British business leaders. Legislature under British rule were toothless. Sector legislature seats are also contested by both camps by elections. One country two systems also implies HK must be able rule its self. Riots in last 12 months has shown HK cannot rule its self. Hence, one country supercedes more than two systems. Independence of HK attacks one country hence will not be tolerated.

The nice things about this vid. Her Voice. She. ...wow.....smooth...:D

Now show us how they were all disappeared by the government

Thanks.Crisp, clear and short. If possible, please do an episode on What led to the ban on Maoist Fall out of US - China Trade

@brennencox516

4 жыл бұрын

ban on Maoist? What?

Not many people understand the extradition bill. Can you explain the in's and out's of the bill and determine whether it was actually fair or not.

@ansonauyeung4011

4 жыл бұрын

On paper it seems all appropriate and fine. But the last thing the protestors want to do is trust the cunning Communist government. A multitude of cases involving unlawful arrestment of HK residents have been reported, not to mention explicit human right violations perpetrated by the Chinese goverment for instance XinJiang concentration camps

@drno1467

4 жыл бұрын

@@ansonauyeung4011 can you stick with what is on the extradition bill that isn't fair. In you admission, you say it is a fair extradition bill but you don't elaborate on anything else that makes it unfair. Who were arrested and can you provide proof that it wasn't fair?

@ansonauyeung4011

4 жыл бұрын

@@drno1467 at first glance the bill doesnt involve politics, but on closer examination it is actually the first step towards political prosecution. Laws can be amended, especially in a parliament occupied by pro beijing legislators (not voted by HK resdients). This is the culmination of distrust and tension between Hkers and chinese government, which has been growing since 2014 umbrella incident. An example manifesting the evil deeds of communist party in HK will be the Causewaybay bookstore incident, in which the owner of a shop selling anti communist party books were arrested and detained in China. It really shows how dreadful the CCP really is

@ansonauyeung4011

4 жыл бұрын

@@drno1467 an easier example will be the sino-british joint declaration or the WTO matters. China is not trustworthy because it doesnt play by the rules. Chinese government did not stick to its promise and implement universal suffrage, as stated in the declaration. The WTO also demandes extensive opening up of the market yet China is still imposing rigid restrictions on foreign enterprises, goes to show Chinese government would not abide by rules

@drno1467

4 жыл бұрын

@@ansonauyeung4011 still not examples of why the extradition bill is an unfair bill. You are talking about something that hasn't happened that relates explicity to the bill. The Chinese book store owner was not extradited, but you are right, he was detained in China. I understand that, that isn't fair in anyway on the book store owner, but again, it has nothing to do with the extradition bill. The other examples are kinda irrelevant, as it has nothing to do with the extradition bill. Hk has an extradition bill with the US, but if we were to go on the example of distrust, we can easily say that the USA invaded Iraq, not for anything, other than oil, killing millions of people in the process. That is a massive human rights violation, so why do we have an extradition treaty with them? Doesn't make sense.