knetz usually says that Winter and D.O. from exo have similar "texture" in their voices, both are called Yoo Youngjin's children who is the most popular vocal coach and producer in SM

@user-vs7pe6ez4i

2 жыл бұрын

that "growling" technique

@greentea4775

2 жыл бұрын

And Changmin from TVXQ too

@flady4967

2 жыл бұрын

Yes so you should react to D.O ft Yoo Youngjin tell me what is love as well as his Empathy album

@kwang-ya

2 жыл бұрын

Yes I'm a korean SM stan and we call Winter Yoo Youngnin's daughter and D.O. Yoo Youngjin's son. It's an inside joke

main dancer and main rapper could perfectly be lead vocals or even main vocals! they're all-rounders!

@r.uiyin19

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah

@lvehaerin

2 жыл бұрын

Ikr! Just SM artists things lol

@r.uiyin19

2 жыл бұрын

@@lvehaerin yeah, they drink a lot of sm water

@lvehaerin

2 жыл бұрын

@@r.uiyin19 lmao Wendy was right

@r.uiyin19

2 жыл бұрын

@@lvehaerin lol

Winter really has one of the most unique and the most beautiful vocals color.definitely favourite vocalist from all girl group that i have ever seen

@cherylblossom4301

2 жыл бұрын

Yesss, i really like her high note and growling technique 😍😍😍 , winter is my bias

kinda sad when aaron didn't say a thing about giselle voice i mean she's a rapper and she really did a great great job. her vocal is actually insane in this

@Lyf4rMusic

2 жыл бұрын

I believe Aaron mainly concentrates on interesting parts like Runs, Riffs or highnotes parts in Vocal parts. So, he may have felt it may be not as interesting to talk about since Giselle and Karina were given normal parts.

@roshankumarsingh4081

2 жыл бұрын

@@Lyf4rMusic then why he didn't talk about ningning's high notes?

@Lyf4rMusic

2 жыл бұрын

@@roshankumarsingh4081 Well, you have to ask him directly on that. But then again he did talk about the reonance of her high notes.

@4eversone480

2 жыл бұрын

@@roshankumarsingh4081 yes true I cant believe he didn't comment on Ningning's runs and highnote. I guess he's just too biased to Winter 🙁. He's the only reactor I've watched reacted to this mv that didn't mention how beautiful Giselle and Rina's voices are.

@lvehaerin

2 жыл бұрын

@@4eversone480 everything aside i just hope you don't hate Winter bcoz of someone who u think is biased towards her. Just saying :)

Aaron is definitely Winter bias, you should see her cover a bit of IU's Secret Garden in Knowing Brothers 😎

@mills00

2 жыл бұрын

Agree

I really love Winter's voice, it's so soft.

NO SHADE BUT SM ENT ARTISTS ARE JUST SO FREAKING TALENTED AND ALLROUNDER. I STAN

@cesartorres5582

2 жыл бұрын

That's no shade, Just a fact

@xxDxxism

2 жыл бұрын

It's a fact.

If you like to hear more of Winter's soothing voice, she sang IU's Secret Garden in Knowing Brothers. It's very beautiful. I keep coming back to it to listen to her voice. ☺ try to watch it too. PS: I changed the title. Hahaha thank you for the correction.

@ainamtalom5806

2 жыл бұрын

Same☺☺☺

@deph_ae

2 жыл бұрын

Yess... Me too

@naddd7308

2 жыл бұрын

I'm litteraly addicted to that cover version

@lovelyjanedizon8213

2 жыл бұрын

omg. yesss

@user-xu3fp6wp4h

2 жыл бұрын

Do you mean Secret Garden 😂

Ningning's voice it's so uniq. One of my favorite vocals from a girl group.

@brandonx543

2 жыл бұрын

Same here!

Aaron is really addicted to winter now.same😍😍i know he will love her so much i hope you can try to watch other video of her vocals.she’s surely has one of the best vocals in this gen

This song showcases their vocal colors, and I love that they're all different and surprisingly Karina and Giselle have fuller tones.

Winter voice so beautiful

love this song.. they did the original justice and made it their own

this is actually my favorite song from them 😊

@lvehaerin

2 жыл бұрын

Same

@Lewis5178

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, same here

@-ningning2340

2 жыл бұрын

Same (4)

Aaron, you should watch winter singing iu-secret garden on knowing brother!!!

@lvehaerin

2 жыл бұрын

UP

@aiirina650

2 жыл бұрын

Yes, please. Up

@sachan9907

2 жыл бұрын

YES PLEASE

@minch930

2 жыл бұрын

Up up

@naddd7308

2 жыл бұрын

Up!

This was really a genius move from sm to make the girls release forever as the second single, i liked that they weren't afraid of the result of it (just as we used from sm i guess), they are a rookie group normally the other companies give their rookie groups something catchy and like that, but not for sm they choose to first proof that all the four members can SING and they are following the other artists who came before them in this company in the "powerful vocals" thing. I just love this, the girls literally have such an amazing vocals as expected for sure, i really cant wait to hear morrre in the future

our middle child forever u will be loved no matter how many ppl hated u ❤

I like your honest way of explaining every single thing

Winter and D.O from EXO are definitely Yoo Youngjin's children KDHSKSHAKSK

He just focused on Winter's vocal. Four of them were so good in the song.

Actually i watch all people’s reaction and aaron is the only one who really appreciated winter vocals at the early part.

Finally 😭💗

@kwang-ya

2 жыл бұрын

wow you're here

Winter sing secret garden of IU in knowing brother.It’s very very good for me.

I'm waiting this for so long lol 😂😂😂 thanks Aaron

I mean you can dislike aespa but you can't deny their powerful vocals especially ningning she's so good and talented

@myab866

Жыл бұрын

Not only ning Giselle karina and winter ❄️ are talented asf too

If you want to hear more of aespa voice, you can watch their guide, there's a lot of clip of aespa singing cover on radio A Hopefully Helpful GUIDE TO AESPA by Lien Elleiro

@lvehaerin

2 жыл бұрын

UP

@_k_as__

2 жыл бұрын

Up!!

@minch930

2 жыл бұрын

Up

@4eversone480

2 жыл бұрын

Uppp

Girl group of SM has one remake song after song debute. Red velvet Be natural Aespa Forever

@tahajuddlover9427

2 жыл бұрын

Girls generation - girls generation

other members deserves recognition too

Winter Voice can be very soft if she sing ballad song and her voice can be so powerful if she go higher 😭 And I Love Karina Tone so much, she is my favoite vocal color in aespa, before being introduced as a member of aespa, i think she entered the vocal line because of the predebut video and i love her voice since 2019 😍 Giselle is in choir for 4 yeras before join in SM an become Main Rapper of aespa And NingNing no doubt, OUR MAIN VOCAL

I love this song and these girls so much💛 Also Winter became my bias after this lol

@K0ko53

2 жыл бұрын

I really love Winter too because of her voice and personality. And the fact Winter's bias in EXO is Baekhyun?? Damn i love her more when i heard that. I mean considering your pfp, i guess you must like Baekhyun too right? Because im happy when she said she likes Baekhyun because Baekhyun is my bias too lmao.

@lvehaerin

2 жыл бұрын

@@K0ko53 LMAO we're so same😂i guess bcoz Baekhyun is one of my ult biases in k-pop, i started liking Winter too eventually and she became my bias😂 Forgot to tell u that ur Aespa bias is my bias wrecker😉so we're actually kinda similar

Auron please react to anything about Taeyeon. Maybe, Stress and the live to it

thank you for reacting to aespa. im enjoying your reaction !

thank you for reacting to this song Aaron

Ningning voice so beautiful

Forever is my favorite ballad song. I just keep listening to it cuz I love soft vocals with techniques.

I love ningning voice the most

not sure why, but this song (their version, actually) really makes me want to cry. could be the vocals, could be Karina's face, not sure. it's been a year, almost, and I still feel it the same way I did the first time I listened to it

Youre really bias to winter. I hope you appreciate the other members too.

@bad_kmj2467

2 жыл бұрын

That’s not a problem lol.every reactors has their own bias.winter only has only few reactors who has her as their bias.why yall are barking about that

@joykim2699

2 жыл бұрын

@@bad_kmj2467 you're just replying to every commenter who's asking him to pay attention to Aespa as whole along with winter being his bias .. Are u too hurt because people are requesting him to pay attention to others? Isn't it a toxic solo stan behaviour????

@bad_kmj2467

2 жыл бұрын

@@joykim2699 what toxic lol.i just wanted to see some reactors really appreciate winter too.you need to see other reactors.they don’t talk about winter a lot.I’m just hoping people praised them equally but they don’t.that’s why i said i love it when aaron pay attention to winter so much because i wanted to feel how others people feel when their faves gets appreciated by the reactors.winter is not so popular among reactors.i feel hurt to when other reactors just don’t care about winter.i take dezzy as example he’s too biased to ningning and when ningning hits the highnote he’s appreciated her so much but when winter hits the highnote he just skipped it and doesn’t care about it.so you’re the toxic one here lol.of course all people will have their faves and aaron bias is winter so of course he will pay a lot of attention to her

@joykim2699

2 жыл бұрын

@@bad_kmj2467 if i was a toxic fan I'd talk bad about winter instead of talking back on you ... If u know u know how the popularity of aespa members among KZreadrs and fans and please idk about dezzy guy i only know aaron !!!

@bad_kmj2467

2 жыл бұрын

@@joykim2699 i know winter is so famous.what i mean is among reactors she’s not that popular.that’s why i love it when aaron appreciate winter so much.i want to see she’s get the appreciation too.and what i mean with dezzy is he’s also a reactor but she’s only pay attention to ningning only then why you don’t barking at him too lol

Indeed Taeyeon daughter Winter.Her voice really good. Actually they all sing so good tbh.

I always love Giselle's tone and thought she sings quite well. Apparently after watching and getting knowledge from aespa vocal analysis videos, many says her range and singing capability (so far) is still below Karina~ Though Ningning's gifted such unique voice and has strongest vocal (well she's the main vocalist) but I can rly see Winter's huge potential. She has this emerging vocal techniques and stylistic singing.

@taengoonim

2 жыл бұрын

I actually thought Winter's the main vocal or atleast they're at the same position.

@bad_kmj2467

2 жыл бұрын

@@taengoonim same.i think ningning is the main vocalist because she has more powerful vocals but winter has a better vocals color from my opinion both of them are like taeyeon-jessica

@ayeon5609

2 жыл бұрын

@@bad_kmj2467 You don't become main vocalist because you have better vocal color.

@bad_kmj2467

2 жыл бұрын

@@ayeon5609 I’ve never said that.I’m just saying that winter has a better vocals color but ningning definitely the best vocalist.

He's winter biased. 🤣✌️

if you like to hear more of Winter's soothing voice, she sang IU's Secret Garden in Knowing Brothers. It's very beautiful. I keep coming back to it to listen to her voice. ☺ try to watch it too.

I love Karina's tone so much! This was my first AESPA MV and am still shocked to find out she's a rapper, I mean she's got the best vocal color idk if u know what i mean She's also the main dancer, right? Wow she's really an ACE, all-rounder

Plz react to thier SYNK videos i really want you to see giselle's iconic rap which she wrote by herself

@naevis3801

2 жыл бұрын

Up!!!!

@seavenly466

2 жыл бұрын

uppp

@cityscapes5580

2 жыл бұрын

up

This Fav songs For every My's

You should watch aespa live singing compilation ☺

hey Aaron since ur(and my) bias is Winter you could watch some of her solo singing stuff- 1)Her cover of Chanyeol and Raiden's song 2)Her cover on knowing brothers 3)Synk teasers(of all)

@cityscapes5580

2 жыл бұрын

up

Karina and giselle are rapper but they doing so good

SM usually puts the same type of vocal trinity in groups - a very emotional voice, an R&B voice, and a very good harmonizing voice (usually at least 2 of these three are very skilled technical singers). it raises their versatility level since they can do different genres with the main of the main vocal for the song switching according to whose voice suits the genre better. I see that it's still true here, although even the rapper is a good singer from what I heard (can't say it's uncommon within SM groups either).

This is a Winter reaction and not aespa.

YAAAAASSSS!!!! 😍😍

SM flex their vocals in this song 😭

Aaron whipped by they maknae line in red velvet and now Aespa

forever is cover song which their producer(yoo young jin, ex singer) sang in 2000

love ur reaction so much:(

Aaron please react to 1theK "IDDP" Aespa. This video can make you know more about who aespa is.

All around girl group, for short aespa❤️

PLEASE REACT TO WINTER SINGING "SECRET GARDEN"

such a lovely song

you should check out Winter's cover of IU "Secret Garden"...

Am a simple girl I saw aespa I clicked

Please react to EXO - Sabor A Mi 🙏

HE SLEPT ON GISELLES VOICEE

Not being salty here but I'm hurt that he didn't appreciate other members vocal performance properly maybe after multiple listens he'll realise it!!

@bad_kmj2467

2 жыл бұрын

What can we do lol.I’m sure all reactors has their own faves and she’s really whipped with winter.plus not many people appreciate winter vocals in this era mostly other reactors also doesn’t care about winter vocals so why you need to be like this.I’m hurt too when other reactors doesn’t talks about winter great vocals you can watch others forever reactions literally almost all of them just skipped that early winter part and just focusing on other members

@joykim2699

2 жыл бұрын

@@bad_kmj2467 sorry but i have not seen many KZreadrs complimenting on vocals or the professional work done in the mvs or songs ... Very few people react on the technical work and aaron is one of them. So about people talking winter visuals also don't pay attention on Ning or giselles performance. I like how Aaron compliments and points out the interesting points it's just that he's not fully into aespa yet that he can fanboy all of them for example he's much more biased to Haechan in NCT because he never got to discover about other members a lot ... Same applies here ... And majority of them reactors are after visuals or trendy thing so they either talk about karina or winters visuals never appreciate Ningning or Giselle for what they've done ... Not only aespa it's the same for most of the group reactions ... It's okay to be like that and biased towards a member but on a bigger platform we subscribers take their opinions, reactions and also expect them to show interest on whole group or stuffs which we like so i was just stating my opinion I'm not asking u to agree or disagree ... I want ot4 appreciation

@bad_kmj2467

2 жыл бұрын

@@joykim2699 that’s why i said i want that ot4 appreciation too but other reactors doesn’t talks about winter lol.only aaron is the one who talks about winter so let’s us winter bias feels happy too cuz there’s a reactor who pay attention to winter.giselle,ningning and karina always gets appreciated by reactors but not winter.i just wanted to see people appreciate her too

@joykim2699

2 жыл бұрын

@@bad_kmj2467 I've never seen a KZreadr paying attention to giselle or ning ... I see most them focus on popular one's please !!!

@jgdeserg9176

2 жыл бұрын

I really dont like his reaction so weird sorry

this is what i've been waiting...

Aaron please react to winter singing live

FINALLY OHMYGOD

Aespa my bies Winter 🛐💗think reaction aespa i love you so much Always watch You im from Iraq

Ning ning is my favorite

Hey Aaron, I really love your reaction of aespa's video ♥️♥️♥️♥️ please react on there live stages they are 3 live stages of forever..please please i really want to watch your reaction...

It have a live performance of it on thier youtube account

Maybe just say reaction to Winter's vocie HAHAHA

"its really really resonance" Aaron really use resonance to describe and review the song from now

YEAY AESPA !!!

My fav song😝

All members are aces wbk!!

YOU CANT REALLY TELL WHO THE MAIN VOCAL IS!!! 🤧🤧🤧

FINALLY FOREVER!!

He definitely should listen to her IU’s cover she’ll for sure making him melt❤️

glad to see SM still highly values vocals to this day, they do this type of release for their other artists too - powerful main releases that may or may not totally showcase the vocals, and then special vocal releases.

Fainaly... Mds do céu... Nunca revirei tanto um canal pra achar esse react kkkk

@demitwice

2 жыл бұрын

gente... brasileiro aqui

@pablomix5256

2 жыл бұрын

@@demitwice ele tem o melhor canal de reacts 🥰

카리나는 신이야. 그냥 믿어~~! OMG = OMKarina = in Korea. now days~~*

I know he loves winter but he didn't even appreciated or replayed any Giselle's part This is so annoying Its literally Winselle era

Ningning always slays ♥💥💥💜😍😍❣😚😚😚😚🙈🙈❤❤❤❤

Because you love winter vocals so much.you need to watch her covers in knowing brothers the song is called secret garden and you can also watch her yours cover

My bias is Karina

Ningning in this MV look straight into your eyes and this is... amazing

Hi aaron, fyi karina said if aespa want to try various genre like to red velvet sunbaenim 😊

aespa my love

This song remind me of NCT U COMING HOME so much.... Can you do it next?

@beebeedeebu

2 жыл бұрын

NCTzen did so dirty to Coming Home please

@_mizahrezel_2387

2 жыл бұрын

@@beebeedeebu IKR.. like please raise your taste people

do you know that WINTER vocal coach is BOA and TAEYEON??

Thanks for this reaction!

Please react to NCT127 regular

Aespa is all main vocalist for me

React to taeyeon time lapse 💜💜💜💜💜

winter is your bias cause same

I want a reaction to EXO please😭😭😭😭

plz react to IDDP aespa in 1thek u will get to know the membr. more!!!

PLEASE REACT TO ENHYPEN'S FEVER MV.

Parece que solo estuvo pendiente a la voz de Winter 😄😐