Haviv Rettig Gur on legality of settlements

Times of Israel senior analyst Haviv Rettig Gur speaks about the legal aspects of West Bank settlements and annexation of Maale Adumim

Пікірлер: 30

  • @JonSamuelsen
    @JonSamuelsen3 ай бұрын

    This man is, sorry i stumbled across something that was actually yours, but I like it so much that not I will keep it for myself

  • @user-uz7dm6qn3y

    @user-uz7dm6qn3y

    2 ай бұрын

    Yes, exactly the Arab doctrine. They have 22 colonies and are eating away at tiny Israel.

  • @Stardust475

    @Stardust475

    Ай бұрын

    Actually under international law. Land gained by a defending country in a warcof defense is there's to retain. (Take a guess who started all these wars? Oh and the current one) And to make things worse for the Arabs they chose not to recognise Israels 1948 borders, they were armistice lines. They tried to give back West Bank to Jordan for peace and Gaza and Sinai to Egypt ( do you know about the three NOs) Egypt refused Gaza and Jordan refused WB. Proxy wars always has been, with the helping hand of KGB - Palestinian identity created to destabilise Israel. Anyway they don't want a state alongside Israel they keep refusing peace deals and what are they still chanting. This conflict is about relgion - the accursed dhimmis got sovereignty and Arab honour shame culture. They can't cope they got defeated so they have to purge the Shane by trying again. They were unaliving Jews for centuries there and they're proud of it. Samaritans were almost exterminated. Another Arab corrupt dictatorship is really needed by the world, a base for state sponsored terrorism aka Palestine!

  • @SaeclumSolvet

    @SaeclumSolvet

    9 күн бұрын

    @@user-uz7dm6qn3y Whataboutism and ignorance on full display.

  • @abupinhus
    @abupinhus12 күн бұрын

    Seize of land by defensive conquest is legal and common practice. Also there is no obligation to respect any ottomans property laws, because they are discriminatory to non-muslims. There for any land that not actively managed last 3 years should considered in full descretion of military control. Previous owners should prove not only deed, but also that purchase was made without discrimination to non-muslims. If they do, they made claim productuve value if the land before any development and cannot claim the land itself.

  • @Randy-lg1qo
    @Randy-lg1qo2 ай бұрын

    I wouldn’t mind a place in Hebron. How much for one of those houses with the Hebrew etchings in the stonework that the Arabs have?

  • @khaledb6580

    @khaledb6580

    2 ай бұрын

    canaanites wants to take israel back, prepare your luggage and your stonework

  • @scinatit
    @scinatit7 ай бұрын

    Daddy omg this man is exactly my type

  • @cleanwaternasenyiuganda8124
    @cleanwaternasenyiuganda81246 жыл бұрын

    C'mon startup nation! Make land records easy to find. Problems solved! ❤😇

  • @enriquegarcia2612
    @enriquegarcia26122 ай бұрын

    They have been declared illegal and therefore, those settlers are ruthless, cruel thieves.

  • @abupinhus

    @abupinhus

    12 күн бұрын

    I declare you supporter of illegal woke sect, therefore you are ruthless criminal supporting terrorists, so you are war criminal.

  • @fabriziodallolmo9840
    @fabriziodallolmo98403 ай бұрын

    Good faith being what is missing here .....

  • @user-uz7dm6qn3y

    @user-uz7dm6qn3y

    2 ай бұрын

    Best faith. Jews redeeming Jewish land from the Arab squatters.

  • @TillyOrifice

    @TillyOrifice

    2 ай бұрын

    @@user-uz7dm6qn3y Squatters being the people who have lived there for generations. "Redeeming Jewish land" being seizing somebody else's home because somebody you have no real connection with lived there thousands of years ago.

  • @Soul_sounds_888

    @Soul_sounds_888

    2 ай бұрын

    ⁠​⁠​⁠@@TillyOrifice no hate or contempt here, Just some questions and comments… 1 - if I did have a connection to the people who lived there thousands of years ago would that change your opinion? You say I don’t have a connection but I say that is simply not true. Those people are my ancestors who have preserved my identity and people until this very day. How can you say they have nothing to do with me? Just because I never met them doesn’t mean I have nothing to do with them. According to most definitions, one of the main qualifiers for a “nation” is a historical connection. 2 - the Ottoman Empire collapsing had nothing to do with zionists or Jews. We didn’t cause it, we couldn’t prevent it. After the ottomans fell, the English took over, still not the Jews. The British fled because 3 way tensions between them, the Jews, and Arabs were so intense that they felt it was no longer worth trying to manage. So there was essentially a power vacuum. Now the Arabs went to war with Israel in order for the Jews to not be in control of any Arab land. These are the Jews who had just been holocausted and suffered thousands of years of persecution since *the last time we were in Israel* (when our nation was conceived and solidified, and where we have been trying to get back to since we were originally kicked out). My question is like this. What were the Arabs fighting so hard for? Do you really believe living under Jewish rule is so terrible? Go ask the Arabs who are Israeli citizens if living under Zionism is bad for them. Ask them if they would rather live in Saudi Arabia, or Iran, or turkey, or any other Arab country. In my understanding the Jews would gladly have lived alongside Arabs peacefully so long as the Arabs were willing to comply with Israeli law and sovereignty which would mean full equal rights as citizens except in the areas that would render it a risk for Jewish survival. Again - if living under Israeli rule is soooo bad that it is better to fight til death then don’t be upset when death is granted. 3 - how is Palestinian nationalism or Islamism not explicitly racist and discriminatory? Look at other Arab and Muslim nations. Look at israel. Zionism and israel does not reject including members of all races, ethnicities, faiths, etc from living and enjoying our country. On the other hand, Palestinian nationalism doesn’t seem to be a voice advocating for the equal rights and freedom for all.

  • @benb6527

    @benb6527

    Ай бұрын

    @@TillyOrifice This is the "Holy Land" - the most contentious piece of land on the planet. You are correct that there have been people there for hundreds of years. How is it that, as a people, they were not displaced through any of the previous empire transitions? Because the people who survived either accepted constant persecution (Jews and Christians), completely hid their beliefs (Druze), moved constantly (Bedu) or had absolutely no identity of their own and jumped on any bandwagon that came along, teaching your children groupthink and fairy tales (Arabs / Muslims). They just believe whatever they're told to believe by their selfish, billionaire leaders (Idols).

  • @wazramzi6614

    @wazramzi6614

    Ай бұрын

    Genetic studies have shown that Palestinians are likely related to ancient Israelites. They most likely are partial descendants of ancient Israelites who became Christians then muslim over the last 2000 years. They are probably more related to Israelites than the average blonde/Red haired Askenazim or Sephardim.

  • @mieliav
    @mieliavАй бұрын

    how about we are all a bit more careful, since those settlements have always been an obstacle (present and future) to ever finding a path to any sort of peace. how about those settlers trying to follow rabbi hillel's explanation of what the torah means?!

  • @bodee591
    @bodee59110 күн бұрын

    Where they are backed by the government they don't mind because nobody will bar them since they are armed, what is illegal everywhere is encouraged in Israel,

  • @David99356
    @David99356Ай бұрын

    Wow, this did not age well. The bit about unilateral moves didn’t work too well in Gaza, did it? And the part about settlements is totally disingenuous. The overwhelming majority of settlements are on lands which were totally empty/barren before those were built. So this whole “worry” about the good faith business is basically nonexistent.

  • @spartacusche
    @spartacusche3 күн бұрын

    i was thinking he was a researcher that know history or law, he is such inhuman and liar

  • @spartacusche
    @spartacusche3 күн бұрын

    read the united nation report about the owner of the lands in 1947, 82% was for arabs non for jews

  • @practice4523
    @practice452326 күн бұрын

    Thieves

Келесі