Hey guys, abandoning the follow up video on trying this modifier with flash. I can't give more information on why at the moment, but since all my subs are intelligent, I'm sure you can connect the dots.

@JohanTalk

3 жыл бұрын

Was this not made for a flash unit?

@cagf2013

3 жыл бұрын

I can't connect the dots at all. Some people in the comments are saying it DOES work with certain flashes.

@Lucy-dk5cz

3 жыл бұрын

Chris Fatseas same lol. Maybe I am unintelligent?

@robhallphoto

3 жыл бұрын

At the time of writing this I was told a flash-specific adapter was in development that would be more efficient, and fit all flashes. Given it's been 10 months, I'm unsure if we'll ever see it. The SA-17 adapter "fits" all current strobe models like 400 pro and 200 pro, but not 1200 pro / 600 pro, however it's horribly inefficient and not fully featured since the flash tube distance is not the same as a cob light source. So it works, just not well.

@brotherted9212

2 жыл бұрын

@@robhallphoto This seems like such a trivial fix -- wouldn't a conical bowens mount extension tube be all that's needed for compatibility with the AD600 -- or even just an elongated version of the existing design?

I did tried it on AD400 pro, its work super great 👍

@vernonfowler7880

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you bro

@saadalhamady578

3 жыл бұрын

@@vernonfowler7880 You are welcome

@mortezakhobzi3651

2 жыл бұрын

Hi there, does it need the Bowens mount adaptor? Or does the projector attaches itself to ad 400 and ad300 series considering they are Godox specific mounts? Any loss of power on the ad 400?

@jerromimuckle139

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you I was looking for this comment lol

Looking forward to you testing this with the AD200!

Good looking beard! Thanks for sharing!!

Following for the flash test... It would be cool if you can review the new godox ML60 wish is already on my wishlist 😬

I like the look of this , the whole set up .. thanks for sharing & ys be good to see if it works well attached to the godox strobes

Would be interested to know how the intensity changes compared to, say, a standard reflector

Will it work with bare bulb non-LED lights like ones that use tungsten/halogen?

Thanks so much for this, Robert. Quick question: What size are the gobos? Are they interchangeable with the very-useful Roscoe 66mm gobos, for example?

I just received mine today. What I didn't find anywhere is the rubber O ring on the projector to SA 17 mount. IS it there to reduce play or vibrations? IT doesn't fit under the lock tab. The brightness is as expected: weak even on my FV200. With the flash function there will be a 2 stop increase in theory. The iris works well but does have little bumps in the circle projected. Perhaps I'll get the 150 lens for a better circle output. It doesn't get very hot, which is good.

godox sk or ms have a bowen mount,is it possibel to use it for flash and not led?

How much light do you lose with the projection attachment on?

Hey just a question please wich one will fit Godox ad600bm?

Hi Robert, can we use this SA-P snoot adapter with godox DP600III ?

Do you loose any light output with this adapter? I have a wellmaking one and I loose around 9 stops of light output

Will that Bowens adaptor work on the Good SZ150 rgb light?

Tell me, is the Godox SA-17 Adapter with SA-P projection head suitable for the Amaran 100d?

This Projection mount can be mountein on Godox Ul 150?

Can this be used with flash strobe like godox ad300 pro?

Mine arrived this morning. I've confirmed it works in the S2 bracket with the AD200 with the H200R and the AD300Pro. The Ad300Pro works really well as the modeling light is nice and bright and allows easy focusing. I'm pretty sure it will work OK with the A1 and the AD400Pro in the S2 bracket. If the Ad400pro won't fit than putting the Profoto adapter on it and using a Profoto to Bowens adapter on the S-17 will work (it's how I use the Aputure 2X Fresnel). I think unscrewing the ring inside at the rear would probably let more strobes use it. Wgist the S30 may not be useful for the sort of photography you do I think it is very useful for product photographers who have good control of the ambient and need very fine control of the light placement.

@saadalhamady578

3 жыл бұрын

No need for S2 Bracket with AD400pro just mount it

@TheCn19

2 жыл бұрын

how about ms300 ? does it fit?

@elboogie2324

Жыл бұрын

​@@TheCn19 that's my question. I have the MS300v

Looking forward to the flash .G

How can you project a colored Gobo but then light the model correctly

is this compatible with an aputure 300X ?

What’s the link to the led light I can’t find it

Would come in handy with a Full RGB Bowensmount Light!

does it fits on the ad600bm?

How about the power lost? Is it decent?

Funciona también con el ad600?

I have a question.I got the kit but the scrims don't fit because there is no space between the projection snoot adapter and the a tall projector. Did anyone find a way to sort this because I do need to use the scrims but don't want to get the original Godox S30 light. Is there a chance that my SA-17 projection attachment is defective or it simply doesn't support the scrims? Any idea if the bracket in 17 can be replaced by a 3d printed one in order to allow space for the scrims to fit between the SA-P projection attachment and the adapter? I haven't found any information on the web yet.

@raynaudier8622

2 жыл бұрын

Bobby Genev, the scrims fit at the front of the S30/S60.

Is the modeling light of the godox ad400 pro powerful enough to see a good preview with the Godox SA-17?

@robhallphoto

3 жыл бұрын

I don’t think there’s a yes or no answer because it largely depends on the distance you use it and how dark of an environment you are in. I know even in my dark studio, when I had it 12 feet away, I put the VL300 LED on it to dial everything in and then swapped to the 400 pro.

Anybody got any info on what the light loss in this modifier is? I’ve found similar ones need at least 600w to be used effectively

@NeilSnapePhotography

2 жыл бұрын

I will find out soon. I ordered mine, with a 85mm lens. I have both a FV150 and FV 200. Since I know there is a huge loss with non focalised light source ( why the S30 and S60 are far more efficient) at least I have the flash function with the FV series giving 4X the light or 2 stops.

Help! How do I mount the SA-11 gels?? I thought I had in the right place but it melted.

@jaegerschtulmann

3 жыл бұрын

the godox gels are garbage, get some from rosco. They are high-temperature resistant, produce better color saturation and do not cut the light as much! (just a bit expensive, but you know the saying: you get what you pay)

Looking forward to Ad400Pro/600Pro tests! ;)

@CiprianKis

3 жыл бұрын

doesn't work with the AD600Pro, found out today.. the hard way

Rob did you ever try this out with the ad200 or other flashes? Thanks

@robhallphoto

3 жыл бұрын

I’ve used it on the 400 pro. And I tried it on the 600/1200 pro but it won’t fit on those.

Light is leaking what should I do ?

DOESN'T WORK with the AD600 Pro, the Bulb won't fit in the adapter

I've had a gobo before (not this specific model) and the problem was the beam angle was too narrow for practical use (or depending how you look at it, my studio space was far too small to make it useful). Found the things like the Aputure fresnel much more useful in practise

@robhallphoto

3 жыл бұрын

This thing with the wide angle lens was able to fill up my entire 9 foot background from a relatively short distance.

@Willymaze

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah, worth a try with the 60mm lens

@jimlafferty

3 жыл бұрын

Robert Hall Photography Couldn’t get the wide angle lens to mount to save my life. Even had a rep at Adorama in NYC try. It just wouldn’t wedge in. Would love it. Guess I’ll try one from a different maker - mine was branded CLAR.

Hi, thank you for this video! is it have an option to change lens (of canon ef amount) ?

@robhallphoto

2 жыл бұрын

no.

Yes I'm really curious about how they will work on the flash heads, specifically the AD600pro heads that I'm using. Also can you measure the gobos as to what diameter they are, the most common size is 86mm and Rosco and several others have much "better" patterns then the ones you showed here. Dedo and Rosco are the ones that I am familiar with and the also make 66mm, and I just checked and they also do a 37,5mm that I was not aware of. But my question is really. How big are the Godox gobos and if they are to the same sizes that Rosco does??

@kojpetersson

3 жыл бұрын

Ive googled this and as far as I can see the Godox gobo is 66mm so the Roscos should fit so I'm answering my own question. BUT I would still love if anyone could pop this on a AD600pro and see if it fits.

@philipfowler9044

3 жыл бұрын

@@kojpetersson That's a standard GOBO size. Size M I believe

@kojpetersson

3 жыл бұрын

@@philipfowler9044 yes that's right, 86 and 66mm are the most common sizes and then there is 37,5mm but I'm not sure what kind of projectors use that size, possibly theatre lights.

@jimlafferty

3 жыл бұрын

It doesn’t work on the 600Pro, even with modifying by removing the rear internal ring.

@kojpetersson

3 жыл бұрын

@@jimlafferty Thank you for the heads up, its to bad I don't like the answer ;-) I would love to be able to use this on the ad600pro, my other option would be with the ad200pro that I am also using but with a Bowens s1. I wonder if anyone has tried it. But then you run into using it with the modelling light of the fresnel head that might be very strange light projection or using it with a bara bulb but without the modelling light.

This Sa-17 worked with ad400 and ad600 flash ?

@robhallphoto

3 жыл бұрын

addressed in video and pinned comment.

That’s great Rob! Can’t wait for the AD400 test. The entire contraption looks a little unstable and flimsy, no? Why the poor tolerance ?

@robhallphoto

3 жыл бұрын

I would prefer a top latch that had more "authority" when connecting to the SA-P, but it's the same design as the S30. While I don't think it's going anywhere, it does have some wiggle to it where it connects. As for why...I didn't make it lol.

@ZzdeathangelzZ

3 жыл бұрын

consider the aputure spotlight if you want something more secure

@mortezakhobzi3651

2 жыл бұрын

@@ZzdeathangelzZ that light is stupidly heavy. Seems like a canon ready to fire

Did you test it with the Godox strobes?

@saadalhamady578

3 жыл бұрын

I did used it on AD400 pro and still using it, its work great, I made a great and dramatic shoot using it 😁

AD600B fit in yes !!!!

Great video and info man! Would this projection kit work with a Godox ml60?

@caliber420

2 жыл бұрын

Follow on this… i found the ml60 (60w) i put on the s2 to sa-17 is a weaker light output vs the original s30 (30w). Any tips on this would be helpful!

@mortezakhobzi3651

2 жыл бұрын

@@caliber420 it is weaker because your ligjt is not fresenel head like the 30,so you need a more powerful light be it continuous or fladh strobe

can you make your own Gobos? you've said it's quite hot, so cardboard or plastic wouldn't be suitable? only metal?

@robhallphoto

3 жыл бұрын

If you have access to the resources, sure. But yeah I wouldn't do cardboard or wood.

@CreativePathFilms

3 жыл бұрын

Rosco has a custom gobo service where they will create steel gobos for you in various sizes. I believe this uses the M size, but double check beforehand if you decide to order one :)

pls make a review with flash test

Does this works with Ad 600 pro and SK 400 II

@hiphopopotomus

3 жыл бұрын

Ad600 pro bulb is to big for the aluminum housing in the bowens mount. So no, unfortunately. Ad600 down will fit. Although I'd caution running Ad400 bulbs with this mount for prolonged periods of time as the aluminum casing literally wraps right around the bulb and gets really quite hot.

@hiphopopotomus

3 жыл бұрын

Sorry typo. Meant ad400 pro and down should fit*

Will it work with godox s60w?

@NeilSnapePhotography

2 жыл бұрын

Yes no problem.

This works on AD600 pro? 📸

@robhallphoto

3 жыл бұрын

no. Does not fit bulb.

Still not enough selection of cookies yet. It's easier to make your own cookies out of paper and mount them to the barn doors. Maybe in a year or 2 if they come out with a better selection it would be worth it.

Does NOT work with the SL series. :*(

@NeilSnapePhotography

2 жыл бұрын

Why not? It does on mine unless I'm not remembering correctly.

@think2mucheh

2 жыл бұрын

it works with my sl60

Hey mate. Thing sure is that it doesn't fit on a Ad600 Pro. Tried it myself on my gear and... The bulb is too large 😂😂

i order a couple to test with ad300pro

@vanitystudios832

3 жыл бұрын

How did it work out?

Light is leaking outside of spot light