I realized soon after posting this that I glossed over the very final step, the DeNoise step. I'll do another shorter video on that soon, as it can improve things that much more after you've processed the image in Siril. (This step occurs outside of Siril.)

After weeks of trying to get my head around siril and following youtube video tutorials and ending in failure, stumbled across your video and followed step by step and finally I got an end result. Thankyou so very much, I can let some hair grow back now.

@erewhon42

4 ай бұрын

I'm really glad it helped! And thank you for the kind feedback.

You can leave the satellite trail subs in there. they will not be visible on the stacked image most of the time. when I would delete all my 3-5 minute exposures with my "normal" telescope rig, therewon't be much left to work with.

@erewhon42

27 күн бұрын

That's true. It does average out. And yeah these days if you excluded satellite trails with longer exposures you'd have nothing left. :-/

Amazing video thank you! I’d love to see you process Pleiades ✨

@erewhon42

2 ай бұрын

Thank you. And nice suggestion! I'll have to see if I have enough data of the Pleiades. I think I did....

First of all, thank you for making such a clear and easy to follow tutorial. This has really improved my images with the Seestar! I am wondering if you’d do a video on editing globular/galactic clusters? Thanks!

@erewhon42

3 ай бұрын

Thanks, glad you found it helpful! And that's a great suggestion! I've been working on kind of a prequel video with a slightly simpler workflow. But now that some nice globular clusters are coming into view, that would make a good topic for the following Siril video. (Not to mention galaxies too.)

Great video! 🙂

@erewhon42

4 ай бұрын

Thanks! 😊. Really appreciate it!

Thank you, THANK YOU, for actually making a video and speaking in layman’s terms for someone like me who is just a hobbyist at best. (And also for injecting personality). If I watched one more video by some NASA PhD student nerd trying to explain Siril to me using words I don’t know or even care to learn, I was going to sell my Seestar

@erewhon42

Ай бұрын

Thank you for the kind words! I am glad you found it helpful. I do try to make sure I explain as much as I can without bogging things down. Glad you found it a good balance!

Thx so much, i've discovered another world

@erewhon42

4 ай бұрын

Thanks! Glad is was useful!

Hello there! Another Siril enthousiast I see! I cover it a lot on my channel too. What I tend to do with the plot view (after registration) is set the Y-axis to "background" to spot clouds or other irregularities in my data.That way I don't have to gloss over hundreds of images. I then draw a rectangle on the plot and right click it so I can then choose to exclude everything outside of the selection.

@erewhon42

4 ай бұрын

Hi there! Thanks for the tip. Every time I've gone through the frames on that tab, I've tried a few different things, including sorting by FWHM. I guess I decided since it was "only" a couple of hundred I'd just brute force it on the video. But it definitely gets tedious, and a bit painful with higher subframe counts. So thanks for the suggestion! I think I'll try that out today, as I have another batch I want to do with about 1000 frames! And I'm going to check out your channel so I can see what other things I might be missing in Siril.

@KopLamp

4 ай бұрын

@@erewhon42 I am also convinced that the images with a satellite streak in it (especially if you have so many subs) will not be worth to remove them. The sigma clipping algorithm will remove those 'faulty' pixels while the nebula data still gets used in the stack.

@erewhon42

4 ай бұрын

@@KopLamp I agree. And I should have probably made that clear. I didn't have the words to describe it (thanks for that! 😃). I did briefly think about that while I was doing it, but it was more of an example, and it was helpful that a satellite was near the beginning of the sequence vs the roof which was later.

loving this video saved the first picture im trying, just noticed a mistake(??) during background extraction you said to switch back to linear, but you actually go back to auto stretch. probably no diffrnce. just noticed.

@erewhon42

17 күн бұрын

You're right. I think I did notice that at one point long after the video went live, but I forgot about it. I try to avoid those kinds of errors, or I "correct" my words with text on screen, but sometimes things get through like that.

@erewhon42

17 күн бұрын

And glad the video helped you salvage something! I've definitely had to do that more than once! :)

Very clear tutorial. Something I don't get is the order of the photometric color calibration. Shouldn't it be after stretching to preserve the natural colors?.

@erewhon42

7 күн бұрын

Thanks. You make a good point. The docs for Siril say you need to do the photometric color calibration before stretching or the colors will be wrong. I'm guessing that if the image has, say, some kind of yellow cast to it, when you stretch it that yellow will get shifted relative to the other colors, so the photometric color calibration won't correct the colors correctly.

Thanks for the great video! I only seem to have a single FITS file on my Seestar after observing each object (one 12mb file per DSO). Will that still work with Siril, or do I need to change some setting on the device to get multiple files like you've demonstrated here?

@erewhon42

3 ай бұрын

You can definitely edit that FITS file in Siril. You don't need to do the stacking step, but you start after that. (Background extraction, star removal, etc.). Turning on the setting on the Seestar gives more flexibility, but only going forward. With the pre-stacked FITS files, you can also combine those. So if you had multiple days, you could combine them assuming they are overlapping enough. (The ones I've done have.) But again, you'd have more flexibility if you have the subframes. (For example when fixing the kinds of issues I showed in the video.)

@justinbaker6146

3 ай бұрын

Ok excellent, thanks so much!

@justinbaker6146

3 ай бұрын

I tried loading in the single 12mb FITS file but I'm not sure where to go next. Siril still seems to be expecting a sequence of files to do its work. Any guidance would be much appreciated! @@erewhon42

Would you exclude any high clouds? They havent blocked any of the stars registered just changed some of the screens to a slight lighter shade of green..

@erewhon42

4 ай бұрын

I guess it depends on how many frames there are. If there are a lot, I would. If there isn't much faint data there, I usually don't need to boost the brighter stars any more. I processed one recently where I ended up excluding a lot of frames.

At 14:22 you refer to denoise. Where in the video did you do that?

@erewhon42

4 ай бұрын

Unfortunately, I didn't. :-/ I used another piece of software, specifically Topaz Labs DeNoise AI. (Quite the mouthful!). It's really good, but it costs money. And looking at their website, it looks like they are pushing their more expensive photo product now if you want the denoising. For that and other reasons, I am working on a standalone video to go over denoising software. I'm going to go over a few of the options. I hope to get it out over next few days.

Hi, maybe dumb question here -- how do you download your subs from Seestar? The only option I see is to download each sub individually, which would take hours to tap through and do. Is there a better way? Can I plug it into my PC or something?

@erewhon42

4 ай бұрын

I plug it into my computer with a USB-C cable. If will show up as a drive, and then you just copy off the files. (I've only tested it on my Mac but I'm sure it works the same on Windows.). It doesn't take too long to copy.

@jwandel

4 ай бұрын

@@erewhon42 Yep, this worked. Thanks for the response, and super helpful video. Processed a 45min exposure of M42 with this and it looks phenomenal.

@erewhon42

4 ай бұрын

@@jwandel That's great!

dumb question but I'm new to this stuff. Where do I find all the individual images on the Seestar? My Seestar stacks them for me so I don't know how to find the individual pictures to process multiple sessions.

@erewhon42

3 ай бұрын

If you have that setting turned on in the app (Advanced Feature > Save each frame in enhancing), you can plug your telescope when it's on into a computer. I think the directory is MyWorks, then "M 42-sub" or something like that. (Where "M 42" is the name of whatever object you take a photo of.). In that directory you'll see all of the subframes. If you have multiple sessions, they will all accumulate in the same directory.

@cato451

3 ай бұрын

@@erewhon42 thank you sir!

@erewhon42

3 ай бұрын

@@cato451 You're welcome!

@johndaley9188

2 ай бұрын

SEESTAR is NOT broken. All you've done is make people angry. You know it's called post processing. If anyone wants to improve their captured image.... If you want to do a Siril tutoral, be proud and say what you are offering. Stop the bait and switch. Disappointed.

If I use the app on my iPad how do I get the files from my iPad to my iMac (I assume that my Seestar stores the photos in the iOS app PHOTOS)

@erewhon42

Ай бұрын

The app will save the on-telescope stacked jpeg to your Photos app. You can go into the My Album in the app, and pick the Seestar tab at the top to see everything on the telescope. They literally just came out with a new version of the Seestar app a few hours ago that lets you download multiple subframes at once. (Before you could only download one at a time.) Since I usually have dozens, or hundreds of subframes, I plug the Seestar directly into my laptop using a USB cable. (Since Wifi would tend to be a lot slower.)

Great Job!!!!! Is is the same for galaxies?

@erewhon42

2 ай бұрын

Yes, definitely! I've used the same technique on galaxies, both to fix bad sessions, but also to combine multiple days.

@Marcus_Aurelius_6

2 ай бұрын

@erewhon42 Thank you so much!

1:38 "the Seestar only takes light frames" This is not entirely correct, is it?

@erewhon42

3 ай бұрын

Well... are you talking about the stacked files? Or that it's using some kind of dark frame internally? I agree with both of those.

i want to beleave

@erewhon42

2 ай бұрын

Siril isn't magic, but it can help recover things that got mangled by the auto stacking in the Seestar.