That's a no-brainer : One of the best bands nowadays, soooo full of new ideas and twists and turns. And Orr Didi, the bass player : most entertaining bass player EVER

Patty Gurdy is awesome. I love her cover of Over The Hills And Far Away.

@najrenchelf2751

Жыл бұрын

Wait what? :D

@shortstuff780

9 ай бұрын

​@@najrenchelf2751the 2nd singer artistic name is Patty Gurdy. She did a cover of Over the Hills and Far Away from nightwish a few years ago, it was brilliant

Most reactors I watch react to songs I already know. This song/band is the only one I recently discovered via a reactor. Wow, I can't believe I somehow missed this one. A perfect blend of Prog Metal, Symphonic Metal, and Folk Metal. This is definately a band destined to take the Metal world by storm. Can't wait for their new album to come out.

@najrenchelf2751

Жыл бұрын

The album that Concrete Cages sits on is out - Strangers by Scardust... it is a wild ride, have fun! :D

Noa has an amazing range!!! Please check out their song "Evolution of a Disney Princess..but she's metal"

@beldin2987

Жыл бұрын

+1 to this 👍👍🤘🏼🤘🏼

So beautiful this master piece is, I love scardust, I hope they come to Santiago of Chile so I can go to see them, I love you all scardust!!

The musicianship reminds me of the intricacy of Emerson, Lake and Palmer, Jethro Tull, Yes and King Crimson - This track turns me to mush every time I hear it!

Phenomenal performance. Everything went together perfectly.

In my top 3 song of the year 2022 👌 Scardust's amazing! Try Arrowhead 🤟

Just love this band, can't get enough of them! 🤘

I'm really enjoying seeing my favorite reactors discover Scardust. They are an amazing band, and this is just the tip of the iceberg. I recommend continuing your journey with Arrowhead, Gone, the Sands of Time suite, Over, Under (Over and Under address best listened to back-to-back). And just for fun, Evolution of the Disney Princess But She's Metal.

Great reaction - for more 'hurdy-gurdy' action, check out 'Cellar Darling' from Switzerland. Their tune 'Death' would be a good place to start.

@Ado_rpg

Жыл бұрын

Do you know any song from Cellar Darling, where Anna Murphy plays more hurdy-gurdy? In most videos I've seen so far, she is more singing than playing. Compare that to Patty Gurdys multi-layered-hurdy-gurdy-version of "The Longing", where all "instrument-sounds" are produced with her hurdy-gurdy. I have to admit, what I'd really like to see, would be a song of these two ladys together, maybe adding even more hurdy-gurdys. Something like a "real-hurdy-gurdy-only-folk-metal-song". :D

Orr Didi is the MAN ! he gives bass playing a new paradigm........mad props to Noa, the band, the Hellscore choir and the cinematographer for this crazy video........and Patty Gurdy is just fantastic.........

Soooo much going on in this song. Enjoyed.

I know this is 5 months old but I just had this pop up in my feed. Huge Patty Gurdy fan who was turned on to Scardust by this collaboration. The look on your face during the bass solo was a mirror to my own the first time I saw this.

What a great surprise from you to make a reaction video to my new favorite (symphonic) progressive metal band from Israel with stellar musicians and a vocal beast Noa Gruman, who: 1. makes her own stage outfits 2. writes the lyrics & co-composes the songs with her friend Orr Didi, who just recently replaced the original bassist of the band 3. has served her two year military service with the Israeli armed forces 4. conducts the Hellscore choir that has performed with bands like e.g. Therion, Ayreon & Amorphis 5. is a classically trained pianist & cellist, although she doesn't play these instruments with Scardust 6. has also been working with the Israeli opera as 1st soprano & also with Zubin Mehta 7. worked on her extreme vocals with Floor Jansen (Nightwish) for two years online and has over an octave wider range (i.e. 4,5 octaves) than Floor & e.g. Simone Simons (Epica), Tarja Turunen (ex Nightwish) & the late Whitney Houston. P.S. Noa also co-produced and edited this music video & the song is the opposite of Scardust - Huts (Official Music Video) kzread.info/dash/bejne/kXeqq9aPj6nWldo.html P.S.S. Noa's big sister was playing the violin on the right hand side of the male violinist & her younger sister was in the Hellscore choir wearing the only red dress.

@kennethdixson9561

Жыл бұрын

Hey my brother. Read both of my comments if they are still there. In November she refused to do Scardust with my 3 donations. What's changed? I think she's a bit phony especially after she refused. She keeps spelling stardust and saying it too. I had a lot of emails with her. Just fyi. Love and Respect always. ❤️🌹🤘

@tarmotyyri6733

Жыл бұрын

@@kennethdixson9561 Sorry to hear about that. Most reactors are here on KZread to make money, so they deliberately react to artists/bands they know will attract the mosr views, which is a big problem for new & even better artists/bands that are waiting to be discovered by the masses. This one of the main reasons I very seldomly pay any reactor for a reaction, the other reason being that most reactors bring nothing new/interesting things with their reaction videos. Respect ☮❤& safe🚛-ing.

@kennethdixson9561

Жыл бұрын

@Tarmo Tyyri we can disagree my friend. Not all are into the clicks. Some are in for the search. That's why I sponsor videos. I told her back then she should change her narrative. Oh well. Hope you're doing well. ❤️🌹🤘

@tarmotyyri6733

Жыл бұрын

@@kennethdixson9561 That's why I said "most", not all reactors. I'm fine & hope that you & your family are also.

Gotta love Prog metal

This is my soul lifting song these days! :D

I have fallen in love with this band. Badly! 🙂 How come I never heard of them before?

I was very late to the Noa Gruman/Scardust/Hellscore dance, but I’m all in and absolutely head over heels in love with them, and you have only scratched the surface of this deep & talented outfit! Everything they have done to date has been so well composed and performed and produced! It’s a shame (no, a crime!) they aren’t getting more publicity than they are, but I believe their time is coming(.) It’s coming in drips & pours, but the dam is cracking…… Now that you’ve ridden this first wave, your next dive should be “Sands of Time, Act V” or “Mist” or “Arrowhead” before jumping into the more progressive deep end! Thanks for the enthusiastic, warm, smart response/reaction!

Wow thanks for doing this one another different sound I like it sound kind of celtic and middle eastern undertones kind of if that makes since very strange but it worked somehow you always find the out of the way music and I love it as always your ride or die forever Eyyy Oooo

Interesting you mention how the hurdy-gurdy reminds you of bagpipes (I imagine that is because of the background drone notes). In Patty's collaboration with d'Artagnian (Farewell - kzread.info/dash/bejne/lZ-Hp9Cbj6yZiso.html) she plays alongside the bagpipes. Awesome song, short but full of energy and tight harmonies, and German lyrics...

Hello Rose! ❤

Hi Rosalie! You've just reacted to maybe the most interesting band at the moment for me at least. Like you said this music genre is not for everyone. But it is for me. I'm into prog and prog metal. And i'd call this band a fusion prog metal band. Based on their material so far. This song is probably kind of the middle of the hardness and complexity of their songs. And quite easy to the ears for someone who has not used to listen this kind of music. This group is extremely talented both in playing and composing complex songs without losing the feeling and melodies in songs. But the most impressive (for me, ex musician) is Noa. Her vocal ability and voice is something you just can't find everyday. This song just gives you a hint what kind of vocalist we are talking about here. Those band members are very lucky to have a vocalist like her in the band. There are few songs in their catalogue which shows Noa's incredible talent and range and versatility. I don't think there is any other singer out there at her level. In rock/pop music anyway. (Or any other...) But that's no wonder, her whole family is very talented. Her father and her sisters and brother are seen singing and playing with Scardust. Actually in this video there is her sister playing one of the violin. And her sister sings in the choir too. Musical family. Noa conducts the Choir, and i have to say it brings some very cool, not so often heard, element in prog music. It fits very well in their songs. And that bass player, Orr, not only a great musician, is responsible with Noa for these great tunes. This band has had quite many line-up changes so far, (original only the drummer and Noa), so it worries a little how they can keep all things together, but we'll hope for the best. You're reaction is just spot on, i'll concur everything you said. You have to react an other song from them, even if it's not your cup of tea 😁. But thanks for this great reaction and analysis!!! 😎

Thanks for the review. I'm wondering a little bit, why all these reviews about this song are published now - but better late than never. I agree with you, that Scardust deserves much more attention. They are announced as support band for Blind Guardian for their next tour (October 2023). Hopefully this will help. Well, Patty could of course also "use" more followers (which artist couldn't?), but she already has many more than Scardust (now 370k on her youtube-channel). I hope that we will see and hear more of the combination Scardust + Hellscore + Patty in the future.

When I first heard this I was smiling all the way through, and bonus, this band actually tackled Ghost Love Score, and only made a couple of really slight changes. I had actually picked that one to check her out, since Nightwish is hella tough, and oh yeah. Definitely, and how much fun is Orr, there? He seems like he's got a bit of the Sabaton guys' attitude, which I of course love :)

@rosalieelliottofficial

Жыл бұрын

Oh interesting!! Yes I think I see what you mean. So skilled!

I am following Patty Gurdy for Years now. The Hurdy Gurdy she is playing was specially made for her from ab Hurdy Gurdy Master Builder and costs around 22.000 US $.

Wow! Thanks for that! This was a special find, something I wasn’t expecting to find with you ❤️ This reminds me (minus the hurdy gurdy 😂) of progressive metal band Dream Theater. I think you’d like Home from their album Scenes From A Memory (an amazing album that tells a story like a rock opera), it tackles themes of reincarnation and forgiveness. Again, thanks for this Rosalie… appreciate you girl! ❤

Hey there from a fellow Elliott (yes, with two 'l's and two 't's)! 😀In this video there is a subliminal suggestion to the final scenes where Noa and Patty are exiting the VR of the video in the destructed environment, their eventual concrete cages. If you pause the video right about the line "The Earth is worn" and step frame by frame you will find two non-consecutive frames of Noa and Patty in the final environment in the same choreography as they are in the forest scene. I thought the distortion was a bit odd so I went searching frame by frame and discovered this. (On KZread, when paused the period and comma keys will move 1 frame forward and backwards, respectively. At least on US keymaps, I'm not sure about other countries' keyboard mappings.)

@Sembazuru

5 ай бұрын

@RosalieElliott On a more personal note, if you (like I) don't take yourself and last name too seriously, here is a humorous poem that I found on the Elliot clan website some time ago: The double L and single T Descent from Minto and Wolflee, The double T and single L Mark the old race in Stobs that dwell. The single L and single T The Eliots of St Germains be, But double T and double L, Who they are nobody can tell. Yeah... really fits my sense of humor. 🤣I hope you also enjoyed it.

The vocalist studied with Floor Jansen and it shows, she is amazing Great band, I will have to check out more for sure

@TTking9142

Жыл бұрын

I don't think her amazing vocals has anything to do with Floor. She's been amazing for ages. I think Noa wanted to find something to sing those Nightwish covers they did. But yes, absolutely great band. And Noa is incredible. And even better in their more complex songs.

@dac2007

Жыл бұрын

@@TTking9142 of course she has the talent but she studied when was young, must've learnt something

@TTking9142

Жыл бұрын

@@dac2007 Yeah, after singing her whole life, she started to study singing with pro teacher when she was 16. So she was trained and almost "pro" when she took online lessons with Floor at the age 22. That probably was mainly to modify and expand the singing style. And boost your self confidence.

Patty Gurdy, formerly a member of Germany based Pirate Folk Metal group Storm Seeker, received vocal coaching from Nightwish's very own Floor Jansen.

@Mischnikvideos

Жыл бұрын

Nope, that was Noa. Patty wrote to Noa to get gsang lessons from her. That doesn't seem to have happened, because she still sings the same way. Instead, they became friends.

Today is Israel's independence day!! I'm not sure if you knew that before posting, but I love it 💙

Yoohoo - one of my all time favourite music videos! Not only for the fact of the collaboration of Israeli artists with a German artist or the music itself. But if you ever saw someone having the time of his life performing in a music video it's got to be the bass player! This is so much fun to watch. Everyone of them, Scardust, Hellscore Choir and Patty Gurdy (btw: you might want to use the good old German word "Drehleier" to avoid tongue twisters in the future😉💛) is worth a more detailed look into their work. They all are oustanding in their own right seperately. Although I must admit that Patty, as good as she sounds in her videos and recordings, is a little less impressive when she sings live. There are quite some impressive and surprising collaborations of the same sort out there: (another) Noa, (Achinoam Nini) an Israeli artist as well, did a recording of her original song "Savior" in collaboration with Peter Maffay - very recommendable! And (again the other) Noa did a cover of "Imagine" from John Lennon together with Cheb Khalid, an Algerian artist who had an international hit single with "Aisha". That's the beauty of music - it is able to cross borders even when the "common man/woman" is either not able or does not want to do so. Eine Empfehlung ist auch eine kurze Doku über die Zusammenarbeit von Noa und Peter Maffay im Rahmen seines Projekts "Begegnungen": kzread.info/dash/bejne/h42BuJV6g8TaiKg.html

This was composed coming out of the lockdown so the phrase "concrete cages" could have a double meaning. The Steampunk VR twist at the end it telling. We have made our new home in VR perhaps. This is how we move along?

More Hurdy Gurdy: Celtic Pop: Patty Gurdy - "Run" Live @WGT2022 Prog Metal: CELLAR DARLING - Avalanche (OFFICIAL VIDEO) Symphonic Metal: LYRRE - North Star (OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO) More Scaredust: Scardust - Arrowhead (Official Music Video)

Who is the backing singer in the red dress, absolutely beautiful

@Sembazuru

5 ай бұрын

If you are talking about the woman in red in the chorus, I think that might be one of Noa's sister.

@2007Tarkus

5 ай бұрын

Ah that might be the reason she isnt putting a lot of effort in the singing but putting maximum effort in just looking fantastic@@Sembazuru

Reminiscent of Yes.

Noa is one of the best living female singers imho. The Whitney Houston of Metal.

Incredibly talented band. It is like watching Trans Siberian Orchestra or Nightwish. I will be listening and watching them a lot.

You like this and I think you will also like this: SUBWAY TO SALLY - Veitstanz (2014 Version) (Live) ft. Saltatio Mortis, Schandmaul, Feuerschwanz uvm

If you like the Hurdy Gurdy, then I can recommend Eluveitie, Faun. Saltatio Mortis.

Love the Hurdy Gurdy and it's use in Folk metal. Big fan of Patty's work and also Annie Hurdy Gurdy who is the new Hurdy Gurdy player for Eluveite. Some of my favorite folk metal bands that have Hurdy Gurdys are Eluveite , Cellar Darling, Saltatio Mortis, and Feuerschwanz. Recommend Eluveite's Inis Mona and Omnos to get more Hurdy Gurdy. The song that Hellscore is on with Arjen Lucassen is actually a Star One song, Lost Children of the Universe, inspired by the movie Interstellar. kzread.info/dash/bejne/aHV4uJmHiafMgdY.html.

Check out male version of never enough or immortal by boyce avenue. They have over 16.3 million subscribers on you tube. Best male voice out there.

You NEEEEEED to react to Bo Burnham, its not just a song, its several of them and maybe in chronological order, there's real depth in every piece and his whole career is amazing

Love your reactions! The slower reminds me of Celtic music, while the faster portion put me in mind of Middle Eastern music. Amazing! Question; I was sent this song on my feed labeled 'New song by The Warning' kzread.info/dash/bejne/Z6mtk8qSp8vNaNI.html There is something so familiar about parts of the song. I was wondering what your take on it is? You don't have to put it on your channel, I know that is time consuming, but does it sound familiar to you as well? Hope you'll let me know.👍🤘🤘

2:13: What??

Du solltest dir "Zeit" von Rammstein geben...

21:13 - You know a song was good when you've lost your ability to language! Brain? Broken. Spirit? Lifted. XD

This is so odd. You refused to do this band with my buy me a coffee saying they didn't have enough youtube presence for you. I have done other projects with other reactors. Kind of a false premise I guess. I'll listen this one time. Still think you're a bit phony.

@rosalieelliottofficial

Жыл бұрын

Hello Kenneth. I am sorry I was not able to do this one for you at the time. I thought it would not be a good fit due to the limited subscriber # of the band and low views. Since then my channel has grown significantly, allowing me more room to feature certain artists. Also, I believe the artist and their video views (perhaps it was way lower at the time) may have grown which is helpful on my end. Please remember we agreed on a different artist that I did then react to for you. I gave you various options and we came to a mutual agreement. I tried to find something that worked for you. I am sorry to hear you were not happy with the end results and hope you can enjoy that in a way you now got two videos of artists you enjoy (the one you paid for and now this one for free (for you). :)

If I Don't like this band does that mean I boycott them and then I'm gonna go to jail

Buymeacoffee logo New message from Rosalie Rosalie Hello Kenneth, hope this email finds you well. Saw your comment/reply and wanted to follow up. Would love to add some music from Israel (that has been on my to do list), but unfortunately only able to add artists that already have a significant following and after a quick check, I noticed Stardust doesn't yet. The reason why I need to be careful with which artists/channels I feature on mine is due to KZread algorithms. A channel can be heavily affected and viewed less, lose significant views and focus on YT and how the system works when doing so (learning from fellow reactors). Is there any other song/band you would be interested in me reviewing at this time? As my channel grows and m y foundation is steady, meaning I have a strong following and don't need to worry about YT taking me off the map, I may be able to add these other videos, but just currently have to be more careful. Regarding your coffee question, I am currently only able to take one request at a time, due to the time and effort it takes making a video. Everyone can make one suggestion, as long as it abides my channel policies, and can purchase how ever many coffees they like to support the channel. It is less a coffee per song, and rather a request for how ever many coffees you wish or are able to sponsor. Does that make sense? Pls let me know if you have any other questions. I am confident we will find the right song to add that you will greatly enjoy View message Notification Settings Help Center Buy Me a Coffee Buy Me a Coffee This is what you said to me in email after I bought you 3 coffee. This was Nov. This really is putting salt in my wounds in a way. This piece was still there in Nov when I told you I support 3 bands from 3 countries. My money, was not well spent I feel. This is why I unsubcribed in November and feel you are a bit phony. I'm glad in a way you did it, however so late to the party. Peace. Stay safe. God Speed. 🌹🤘

@rosalieelliottofficial

Жыл бұрын

Hello Kenneth. I am sorry I was not able to do this one for you at the time. I thought it would not be a good fit due to the limited subscriber # of the band and low views. Since then my channel has grown significantly, allowing me more room to feature certain artists. Also, I believe the artist and their video views (perhaps it was way lower at the time) may have grown which is helpful on my end. Please remember we agreed on a different artist that I did then react to for you. I gave you various options and we came to a mutual agreement. I tried to find something that worked for you. I am sorry to hear you were not happy with the end results and hope you can enjoy that in a way you now got two videos of artists you enjoy (the one you paid for and now this one for free (for you). :)

@kennethdixson9561

Жыл бұрын

@Rosalie Reacts At least you didn't ban my comments. I feel that you are not very authentic. If you remember, during our emails, after I disagreed with not doing Scardust, I told you many times if not Scardust then do my UK band. They had just below Liliacs followers. A strong presence. You ignored every time I brought them up. So I had no choice but to do a Liliacish one. That in my opinion didn't do a good job. Dialed it in sort of speak. I really couldn't enjoy your reaction. I said my piece. Only reason I saw this was I do general searches to the bands I support. I've blocked your content with the main page. Peace. God Speed. 🌹🤘

@rosalieelliottofficial

Жыл бұрын

@@kennethdixson9561 I'm sorry it didn't work out the way you hoped. We messaged back and forth multiple times and I tried to find something that would work for you and the channel. What we eventually agreed on is what I honored. Also pls note in the message you copied and pasted, I even mentioned that I may even be able to do it in the future as the channel grows, which has now happened (and it didn't cost you anything). Again, pls understand my explanation was also before the channel (and perhaps even video views) had grown to where it is now (meaning I had to be cautious (and still do) what I post. I honored your final request and am sorry to hear you were not content with the reaction. I respect your decision to block the page. I wish you blessings nonetheless.