Some of these comments are hilariously ironic. Criticizing him for something you are doing. He never said she wasn't doing it, couldn't do it, or any of that. What he is saying in the beginning is correct. He points out her talent and that editing the audio in that way wasn't necessary and took away from the live feel of the performance and her talent to begin with. You don't put someone in the same sentence as Phil Collins and Don Henley and it be a negative critique. He quite literally says, "I'm not saying she is lip singing". So before you criticize someone for not knowing what they are talking about or to do research how about actually finishing the video first, number one, and two, understand what he is actually saying. Practice what you preach kids.

Paulina is that good. There are only a few drummer/singer including Phil Collins, Don Henley, Karen Carpenters but Paulina in my opinion is on a level above. And she has been at this level since she is 13-14 years old. Hard to believe but if you have been following The Warning as long as some of us Warning Army you will know that there is nothing "fake" or "artificial" about these girls. They are the best band I've heard in years.

My calm suggestion to you is to watch an interview that Fil from Wings of Pegasus did with THE WARNING! He explained it first, then they answered every question about the back track (which, as he put it, not every good band knows how to use), the click usage, and whatever more you might be "upset", "angry", disappointed about. All that wasted emotion! For what! This band of sisters aren't hiding anything, aren't misrepresenting anything, they're just being themselves! You might watch some of the other reactors that give them kudos on their "advanced" stage setups, concert and/or in their "cave" setting! Chill!

5,800 feet is the difference between the first and second video. First video is in Monterrey, Mexico at an elevation of 1,500 feet which is where they live. It was also recorded almost a year later. The second video is at 7,300 feet above sea level, the altitud of Mexico City where that second video was shot at. Pau still kills her vocals and drumming 90 minutes into this performance at this altitude. How? She practices singing while exercising. That plus her being an alien. 😜

I am with you 100%. This is a world class LIVE band. I prefer their live performances to the studio albums, as the studio has yet to capture how dynamic they are.

Be careful. They have some pretty passionate fans. I'm one of them. I would have picked the video I liked and reacted to it. It's not like they are covering up their inability to play or sing. Paulina is one of the best drummer/singers I've seen in a long time.

I'll bet most of the negative comments were written during the first 10 minutes of this video and not after watching the whole thing...

Despite of you having a point, they do it to improve the performance, i had the chance to see them live at Argentina, there is not post production, mixing or whatever, they use a backup track adding some guitar, piano o second voices... keep in mind that when they perform those concert The Warning didnt have a record label, they do it by themself (and Rudy) by pateron.

It's a backing track. Simple as that. I understand what you're saying and I agree with it. But in this situation, she's singing along with a backing track.

Are you kidding me? The Warning, opening for Rush? 🤯 i think I would have sobbed. They would have learned so much from them, too. As far as im concerned, they are Rush 2.0 for the modern era. They are coming up very similar to how Rush did and are controlling their own art and destiny. I hope they are aware this was done to their product and have stopped it because I'm pretty sure it's not how they want to be represented.

I was skeptical, but after hearing your whole argument? hell yeah man, they didn't need to mess with how good they sound live at all! Specially, if you go an listen to other live performaces, official and unofficial, they sound WAY BETTER live. At the very least that's the case with all of their earlier stuff. Studio has kind of stepped up a bit with their new releases buuut I still feel like they have yet to catch their raw energy, how dynamic, aggressive and emotional they can be is not quite captured on their records. So yeah, 100% with you on this. Edit: oh, the extra voice track at the bridge part is no one singing, it's a sample in spanish of a speech. It's part of the song.

Damn dude, you are right. Had not noticed this before. But it still doesn't take away the fact that Paulina does an exceptional job singing while playing. I would refer you to their Lunario CDMX videos. Pau sings several songs and there is no post-production editing.

I also like the Lunario video as well (2nd video). Thanks for the honest reaction and insights. The Warning is a great band and I'm looking forward to your next reaction to this band. New subscriber here. 🤘😎

I was a hard rock drummer in my 20s. One of our guitar players sang lead in the first half of the set. Then I sang the 2nd half of our set while playing drums. And we played Boston, Foreigner, Def Leppard, and R.E.O. Speedwagon, just to name a few. So, I'm living proof that it can be done. And I've seen others do it as well.

New point of view different from any other reaction videos I have watched before. I didn't notice the editing things to this performance. Thank you. Love these girls' talent as well.

Subscribed because of your honesty and showing respect to the band at the same time. At

Amazing! You explained it in a way that your not bashing the group, but bashing the mixing and editing. You're right! Everyone listening can hear and see what you are explaining. I agree with you, they are an AMAZING BAND that doesn't need anything extra. And you can hear the authentic, organic sound in their other concerts and live recordings. Very good video! Thank you for your explanations. I still LOVE THE WARNING!

Great.insight never notice it before, 97% react to the 2nd video at Lunario Mexico City🤟 Hope to see then live in 2021🙏🙏🙏😁

Edited: after reviewing the official video from TW site (that is the full concert) and compared with the fan uploaded version of just this song I say they are the same. I am quite sure the audio is the live version but it is mixed out to sound similar to the album version. The Warning had full control of their QOTMS album... and they also had full say themselves on the concert video... they did not have a record label at that time. Only funds from Kickstarter and Patreon. They have never been anything else than true to their craft... well,. the Dust to Dust from Foro Didi is their own recording, they released it themselves... same with the album but as you know they are using backtracks even live but I agree that it sound more polished vs the Lunario version... maybe over-produced audio but I’m quite sure it is audio uptake from the concert...

Haha, was going to have at a go at you at the start , walked away , came back watched through , glad I did , also its your channel , so stay true to yourself, its why i subscribed in the first place.