EVM का हिसाब-किताब समझा, VVPat, गलत Exit Poll, Caste census पर क्या बता गए Rajeeva Karandikar? GITN

#LTChunav #ChunavYatra #LallantopChunav
Try American Pistachios - americanpistachios.in/
Buy Sensodent K now :www.sensodentk.com?YT&India+Today_KZread+Ads&+more
शुरू हो चुकी है लल्लनटॉप की चुनाव यात्रा. बताइए क्या है आपकी लोकसभा सीट का नाम और कवरेज की वजह? कौन से फैक्टर आपकी सीट को बनाते हैं ख़ास. सब्जेक्ट में 'मेरी सीट कवर करो' लिखकर भेज दीजिए मेल Chunav@Lallantop.com या लिंक पर क्लिक करें.
Link: forms.gle/uaRg378VkP9Jb88T8
Register here to be part of GITN Shoot- rb.gy/nbu7hi
In this episode of Guest in the Newsroom, we welcome Rajeeva Karandikar, Chairman of the National Statistical Commission. In 2018, the Election Commission formed a three-member committee to investigate complaints regarding Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs). Karandikar was a member of this committee, and its report formed the basis for the Supreme Court's dismissal of all petitions challenging the use of EVMs in April 2019.
In this interview, Karandikar discusses the history and operations of EVMs and Voter-Verified Paper Audit Trails (VVPATs). He also addresses the question of whether EVMs can be hacked, and the debate surrounding the use of paper ballots alongside EVMs. Additionally, Karandikar highlights the importance of data for a nation's development, and the role of exit polls and opinion polls.
Key Points:
-Rajeeva Karandikar was a member of the Election Commission's committee that investigated EVMs in 2018.
-The Supreme Court's 2019 dismissal of EVM-related petitions was based on the committee's report.
-Karandikar discusses the history, operations, and security of EVMs and VVPATs.
-He also addresses the debate surrounding the use of paper ballots alongside EVMs.
-The interview highlights the importance of data for development and the role of polls.
00:00:00 - 00:04:10 Precap
00:04:10 - 00:05:55 Intro
00:05:55 - 00:06:56 Rajeeva Karandikar’s personal opinion on EVM (Electronic Voting Machine)
00:06:56 - 00:09:46 Difference between Statistician and Mathematician
00:09:46 - 00:14:06 Pursuing Mathematics as a career
00:14:06 - 00:17:03 Functions of National Statistical Commission
00:17:03 - 00:30:37 Allegations on EVM,National Statistical Commission’s finding and remedy
00:30:37 - 00:32:09 Auditing Statistical basis of random sampling
00:32:09 - 00:42:49 The entire process of voting on EVM, function of VVPAT, hacking EVM
00:42:49 - 00:50:57 Suggestions for the betterment of EVM
00:50:57 - 00:54:37 Why developed countries are not using EVM for voting?\
00:54:37 - 00:56:41 The emotional argument on Ballot paper
00:56:41 - 00:59:40 The association of companies which manufacture EVM with the government
00:59:40 - 1:00:19 Do common people trust EVM?
1:00:19 - 1:05:17 The challenges of miscalculation between VVPAT and EVM
1:05:17 - 1:07:14 Can EVM buttons be manipulated?
1:07:14 - 1:21:09 The methodology of Exit Poll
1:21:09 - 1:26:28 The importance of data collection for nation building: political and policy decisions
1:26:28 - 1:28:22 Janta ke sawaal: Spreading awareness on the credibility of EVM
1:28:22 - 1:30:08 Lack of choice for voters
1:30:08 - 1:33:07 Discussing over voting ratio and Proportional representation
1:33:07 - 1:35:12 Do citizens also present their doubts over EVM to election commission through letters?
1:35:12 - 1:40:22 How the candidates symbols are placed on EVM?
1:40:22 - 1:43:03 Why America is not using EVM?
1:43:03 - 1:46:58 Use of mathematics in real life
1:46:58 - 1:48:32 Discussion over OTPs
1:48:32 - 1:50:57 Social media questions
1:50:57 - 1:51:23 Outro
खबरों को विस्तार से पढ़ने के लिए क्लिक करे यहां- www.thelallantop.com/
Instagram: / thelallantop
Facebook: / thelallantop
Twitter: / thelallantop
Produced By: Uday Bhatnagar
Edited By: Shakir Khan

Пікірлер: 476

  • @lokeshthakur7
    @lokeshthakur7Ай бұрын

    करंदीकर साहब आप इन औंधे घड़ों पर कितना भी पानी (ज्ञान) डाल दो सब व्यर्थ ही जाने वाला है । ये सारे लिब्राण्डु अपने थूथरोलॉजी से बाहर नही आ सकते

  • @shankarramharichavan7158

    @shankarramharichavan7158

    Ай бұрын

    Just find out who is first Librandu....jisane E-n pe sawal kiya tha.

  • @atullondhe5436
    @atullondhe5436Ай бұрын

    मैने कितने झगड़े देखे है मतगणना के समय, लगने वाले ठप्पे इधर उधर होने पर सभी दलों के लोग झगड़ते थे, मतगणना घंटो रुकी रहतीं थीं

  • @dineshnagwal2969

    @dineshnagwal2969

    Ай бұрын

    जब पूरे इलेक्शन होने में 2 महीने लगते है तो क्या दो दिन ओर नतीज़ों का इंतज़ार नही कर सकते है अगर इतनी तेजी से नतीजे देने की चिंता है तो पूरे देश मे एक दिन में चुनाव करवाये ओर दूसरे दिन नतीजे तब माने इलेक्शन कमीशन की क्षमता। ये बेवकूफ बना रहे है, जब आधी जनता को संदेह है तो उसे दूर करना चाहिए।

  • @p.a.asutkar

    @p.a.asutkar

    Ай бұрын

    ​@@dineshnagwal2969right 👍

  • @jitengol9852

    @jitengol9852

    Ай бұрын

    Ye sala vampanthi patrakar he jo aaapne aap ko Hindi pratkar kahalata he kyu ki haam Saab inki baatoo me aaajaye

  • @jitengol9852

    @jitengol9852

    Ай бұрын

    Salooo se baat hi nahi kar ni chahye😂😂😂😂

  • @vinayvijaydost
    @vinayvijaydostАй бұрын

    Bahut Sahi Jawab for France, America ne kyun band kar diya EVM..

  • @snehab8096

    @snehab8096

    Ай бұрын

    Aur America mein 2020 election mein kya hua sabko pata hai. Poora white house gher liya tha votes mein dhandli k liye

  • @harshkhandelwal6245

    @harshkhandelwal6245

    Ай бұрын

    You know nothing.

  • @AshokSingh-sq6hn

    @AshokSingh-sq6hn

    Ай бұрын

    Wo un deso se puchiye

  • @ankur7773

    @ankur7773

    Ай бұрын

    भारत ही नहीं भारत के बाहर भी दुनिया देख रही है कि बाबासाहेब अंबेडकर जी के संविधान की खुल्लम खुल्ला धज्जी उड़ रही है न्यायपालिका ने न्याय करना छोड़ दिया है

  • @subramanishankar1609

    @subramanishankar1609

    Ай бұрын

    Equally badiya jawab

  • @user-ee5ud6xx5g
    @user-ee5ud6xx5gАй бұрын

    Evm>>>>> ballet ppr

  • @girishkumar1565

    @girishkumar1565

    Ай бұрын

    Tu sala kyun Congress ka bhatha bitha raha hai, ab Congress aa rhi hei, agar EVM ban ho gai to Congress kese herferi karegi.

  • @vinayvijaydost
    @vinayvijaydostАй бұрын

    As a Citizen I have no Issue with EVM

  • @pardeeptandon

    @pardeeptandon

    Ай бұрын

    While I do have issues with it

  • @surendrabist5528

    @surendrabist5528

    Ай бұрын

    ​@@pardeeptandonGo to the hell!

  • @nShobhit

    @nShobhit

    Ай бұрын

    Because you don't know what it means to be a citizen of a country. You are a freeloader

  • @Global_putin

    @Global_putin

    Ай бұрын

    I don't believe evm

  • @Maharaja09

    @Maharaja09

    Ай бұрын

    Even I do have a issue with EVM

  • @chaksayantan
    @chaksayantanАй бұрын

    Goosebumps to see my professor invited to such show, coundn't be any better person for this discussion

  • @Fun_and_Knowledge_

    @Fun_and_Knowledge_

    Ай бұрын

    CMI or ISI ??

  • @ankur.mahajan
    @ankur.mahajanАй бұрын

    Was very disappointed by the unintelligent audience's questions asked by the Lallantop Staff. If this is the general comprehension capability of a newsroom, then it a very sad state of affairs.

  • @crackjack5272

    @crackjack5272

    Ай бұрын

    Yes, the guy in maroon tshirt countered that in today's date also booth can be captured... he aint understanding that in previous days within short time span (say 1 hour) thousands of ballet papers were stamped and put in the box which would get counted as valid vote against which on evm one can cast only 3 or 4 votes max per minute which would result in less than few hundreds votes in an hour. With EVMs, those who are capturing the booth also have to be savvy (knowledgeable) to cast a valid vote --which normally is not the case i.e. very difficult to find people who can act and threaten like goons and also operate machines like evms and computers.

  • @MOHITSINGH-pv7vw

    @MOHITSINGH-pv7vw

    Ай бұрын

    @@crackjack5272 aur aaj ke time possible nahi h booth capturing qunki sare parties ke observers rhte h evm voting ko dekhne ke liye

  • @divyanshudave3584

    @divyanshudave3584

    17 күн бұрын

    You should judge their intelligence by the kind of Clickbait they use for their daily news...

  • @abulfable
    @abulfableАй бұрын

    EVMs should be banned.

  • @AkashSingh-os4zl

    @AkashSingh-os4zl

    Ай бұрын

    Go Pagztan

  • @Vicky.7.

    @Vicky.7.

    Ай бұрын

    😂😂😂... Go to paxstan

  • @girishkumar1565

    @girishkumar1565

    Ай бұрын

    Tere jese fudu hi ye kahenge, ab supreme Court ke faikle ke baad bhi

  • @baidyanathdehury6939

    @baidyanathdehury6939

    Ай бұрын

    😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @anilgidwani2348

    @anilgidwani2348

    27 күн бұрын

    जाकर टायर का पंचर बना,तुम्हारा वही काम है मा#दों,अच्छे से घिसना ठीक है बेटा...😠

  • @SK-zc4rf
    @SK-zc4rfАй бұрын

    जब तक पार्टी, सत्ता पक्ष में रहती है या चुनी जाती है तब तक EVM पर पूर्ण भरोसा रहता है । और जैसे ही पार्टी विपक्ष में चुनी जाती या जब तक विपक्ष में रहती है तो EVM पर से भरोसा उठ जाता है। इसके के क्या कारण है????? Please reply this comment.

  • @kp37904

    @kp37904

    Ай бұрын

    ये मानसिक निर्बलता के लक्षण है भाई

  • @Fun_and_Knowledge_
    @Fun_and_Knowledge_Ай бұрын

    Rajiva Karandikar is one of the greatest living Indian Statisticians but not much of the asked about his life & his work

  • @MahenderKumar-yh5fm
    @MahenderKumar-yh5fmАй бұрын

    We want saurabh dwivedi sir interview with Ravish kumar sir in news room

  • @Shivamgupta-pc5gf

    @Shivamgupta-pc5gf

    Ай бұрын

    Ye to hona mushkil lag rha Saab

  • @Shivamgupta-pc5gf

    @Shivamgupta-pc5gf

    Ай бұрын

    Itni baski nhi India today group k.Godi media ban chuke h ye

  • @milupatadiya.7205
    @milupatadiya.7205Ай бұрын

    Thank you so much 😊

  • @shubhamozha6702
    @shubhamozha6702Ай бұрын

    Forget ballot paper but what is the issue with matching evm wil 100 percent VVPAT . Voter privacy dhong h niyat m khot hai 😊

  • @sonabhalke3486

    @sonabhalke3486

    Ай бұрын

    That is also manual then ??? And evm is issue then himachal , telangna , karnataka shouls also go in poll again

  • @devindersingh1603

    @devindersingh1603

    Ай бұрын

    There is no problem in matching but then the whole purpose of EVM will be nullified. Agar parchi milani hi hai to wo ballot paper hi ho gya. Time to same hi lagega

  • @navnathnagargoje7502
    @navnathnagargoje7502Ай бұрын

    Vote shown on vvpat does not cut in fraction of 7 second..confirm button neccessory to cut vote..

  • @lukmankhan2353
    @lukmankhan2353Ай бұрын

    Save democracy, save Indian constitution

  • @blogar01

    @blogar01

    Ай бұрын

    Tere naam se pta chal gya tha

  • @mohabbeali432
    @mohabbeali432Ай бұрын

    पार्टी चाहे कोई भी जीते लेकिन चुनाव वैलड पेपर से ही होना चाहिए,,

  • @sonabhalke3486

    @sonabhalke3486

    Ай бұрын

    Hmm so thar easy to booth capture

  • @rjdsolanki

    @rjdsolanki

    Ай бұрын

    Fir jo log aaj bhi sahi jagah stemp nahi laga sakte or uska vot fall hota hai uske vot ke adhikar ka kya?

  • @sb5224

    @sb5224

    Ай бұрын

    US, France.. etc mein Bahubali booth capturing karte hian kya? Nahi na, so they can do ballot paper. Indian mein booth capturing hoti thi jab ballot paper tha. Isliye EVM is needed.

  • @amitsethi11
    @amitsethi11Ай бұрын

    Great show , informative and a fact that you bring people from different field is great . Way to go

  • @manishagadgil1549
    @manishagadgil1549Ай бұрын

    Very logical arguments in favor of use of EVM's.Full favor of this system.

  • @dineshraodineshrao7997

    @dineshraodineshrao7997

    Ай бұрын

    Very logical. But we need technical knowledge of electronics for this discussion.

  • @arvindsingh24771
    @arvindsingh24771Ай бұрын

    It should be only by ballot paper

  • @DhirajSingh-sc5br

    @DhirajSingh-sc5br

    Ай бұрын

    Why are you using mobile phones, jao letter likho uncle

  • @republic980

    @republic980

    Ай бұрын

    Beta America ke uncle bhi mobile use karate hai lekin voting ballet paper se hi karate hai tumhe nahi pata hoga par uncle ko pata hai

  • @heeheeeeeeeee

    @heeheeeeeeeee

    29 күн бұрын

    ​@@republic980 American bewakoofi kare toh hum bhi bewakoofi kare

  • @vikasgoel5182
    @vikasgoel5182Ай бұрын

    The kind of questions the journalist asked are so childish. His understanding of the matter is also superficial. For example, he wasn't able to understand the kind of human error possible while counting VVPAT slips manually. Ignorantly, he said if no. of slips and votes on the EVM mismatch then counting should be nullified, try explaining this to a common man and party representative who is on the losing end. He didn't highlight the money and logistical issues if 50% or 100% VVPAT counting is implemented. He neither highlighted the shortcomings of the ballet system nor presented any convincing argument in favour of it. The tactile feel of paper as an argument is so sub-standard, then asking questions around it reflects 'stupidity' and 'lack of research'. Guys up your game when you invite guests of such high calibre.

  • @gauravtomar1679
    @gauravtomar1679Ай бұрын

    सब के अनुसार ब्रिटेन और अमेरिका तथा फ्रांस जैसे देश कम योग्यता और तकनीक रखते हैं किस कारण आज भी बैलट पेपर से इलेक्शन करते हैं😂😂😂😂😂। सर आप जल्दी ही बीजेपी ज्वाइन करे

  • @milupatadiya.7205
    @milupatadiya.7205Ай бұрын

    Thank you 😊

  • @user-yo8iv4pk5y
    @user-yo8iv4pk5yАй бұрын

    Only Rahul and Congress !!! No vote to Chanda chor, vote chor. !!! Ban EVM. !!!

  • @localtoglobal1917

    @localtoglobal1917

    Ай бұрын

    Chanda to congress ko bhi Mila hai.. fir bjp chor kaise.

  • @bullbhaidahorn477
    @bullbhaidahorn477Ай бұрын

    Excellent interview.👍🏼

  • @sureandarraikwar3629
    @sureandarraikwar3629Ай бұрын

    EVM, पर जबरदस्ती विश्वास या भरोसा थोपा नहीं जा सकता है। मतपत्र को बाहर किया जाना, जनता में अविश्वास को बल देता है।

  • @Youtubechnl1

    @Youtubechnl1

    Ай бұрын

    Many people don’t trust ballot paper system. What will you say to them then?

  • @AmitYadav-xy1vd

    @AmitYadav-xy1vd

    Ай бұрын

    क्यू झूठी बात का स्पोर्ट कर रहे Belet पेपर पर पुरे देश की पब्लिक भरोसा करते हैं

  • @headwayexport1102

    @headwayexport1102

    Ай бұрын

    Ballet paper se hota tha to boot hi capture kr leta tha

  • @atullondhe5436

    @atullondhe5436

    Ай бұрын

    बात सही है पर हमारे देश में मतपत्र पर लगे ठप्पो पर विवाद होता रहा है, साथ ही हजारों टन पेपर वेस्ट होगा , उदहारण मतपत्र १००% छपने होते है और मतदान 50%होता है , अगर 98 करोड़ की वोटिंग करना हो तो करोड़ों मतपेटी लगेगी, स्टोरेज बड़ी समस्या होगी, क्योंकि चुनाव अगर देश का हो तो कम से कम 6 माह लगेंगे,, प्रार्टिक्ल बड़ी समस्या है

  • @Dixitttt95

    @Dixitttt95

    Ай бұрын

    Bhai janta tu bus nhi hai hm bhi hai or hme bharosa hai EVM par ballot paper ka time bhi dekha hai jb poora booth loot lia jata tha gundo se ya farzi vote daale jate the to janta k liye kaam kroge nhi fir result aane p khoge EVM hack ho gya ye vaisa hi hai jaise teacher puchta tha kl school kyo nhi aaye to baccha khta tha sir fever aa gya tha appesement krte rho EVM aise hi hack hote rhega😂😂😂😂😂

  • @rameshkurada3456
    @rameshkurada3456Ай бұрын

    एक्जिट पोल का मतलब ही क्या है इस देश में। अरे भाई इन संस्थाओं के पास इतना पैसा है तो गरीबी खत्म करने में करिए ना गरीब लोगो का जीवन बेहतर करने में खर्चिए साहब दुआ मिलेगी। क्या मतलब है है यार चार पांच दिन पहले वो जीत रहा है यह हार रहा है रिजल्ट आने दीजिए ना सब साफ हो जाएंगा। क्या क्या काम कर रहे हो यार इस देश की प्रकृति को समझें बिना विकसित देशों की नकल कर रहे हो। बड़ा गुस्सा आता है यार ऐसी बेहूदीगी से। इतना खर्चा इस देश के गरीब लोगों के जीवनस्तर में सुधार के लिए लगाइए। उनके घर और बच्चों की शिक्षा पर खर्च करो ना भाई आपके पास इतना ज्यादा है तो।दुआ मिलेगी साहब इन लोगों की। क्यों माहौल खराब कर रहे हो देश का भाई रिजल्ट से चार आठ दिन पहले क्या मतलब है समझ से परे है भाई।

  • @shreensharma1871
    @shreensharma1871Ай бұрын

    इनसे आप ये पूछे की केरल में जब मशीन की चेकिंग हो रही थी तो सारा वोट केवल BJP को क्यों जा रहा था?

  • @gohananddaisy

    @gohananddaisy

    Ай бұрын

    Bhai that was during checking. Checking is done to correct things. So that in main election it should not happen.

  • @advocaterakeshkumarsharma7710
    @advocaterakeshkumarsharma7710Ай бұрын

    अगर वीवीपीएटी से गिनती में करने में लगभग दस दिन लग सकते हैं तो पारदर्शिता के लिए गिनती करानी जनहित व देशहित में आवश्यक है आखिर चुनाव पांच साल में एक बार ही होते हैं साथ ही ध्यान रखना चाहिए देश में लोकसभा चुनावों का समय लगभग दो महीने चलता है क्या दो महीने वोटिग होने में इतना समय दिया जा सकता है तो गिनती के लिए दस दिन लगना क्या उचित नहीं होगा।

  • @kumar268

    @kumar268

    Ай бұрын

    भाई साहब काउंटिंग की ड्यूटी आपके किसी परिचित ने किया हो तो पूछना 7 दिन लगातार ड्यूटी करना काउंटिंग में पेंसिल भी नही ले जा सकते ड्यूटी करने वाले और जब तक काउंटिंग खत्म नहीं होती बाहर नही आ सकते

  • @MOHDAKMALKHANOFFICIAL

    @MOHDAKMALKHANOFFICIAL

    Ай бұрын

    ❤️❤️👍👍

  • @pramodshah2491
    @pramodshah2491Ай бұрын

    बारकोड की चर्चा हुई है सुप्रीम कोर्ट में।इसे बताएं

  • @shilpapawar5452
    @shilpapawar5452Ай бұрын

    I am so proud of being part of this intelligent legacy of India 🇮🇳 👏 India aage badho world will follow you 🎉

  • @dineshnagwal2969
    @dineshnagwal2969Ай бұрын

    जब दो महीने में पूरे देश मे चुनाव होते है तब जल्दी नही होती है पर रिजल्ट कुछ घंटों में देने की चिंता है यदि इलेक्शन कमीशन पूरे देश मे एक साथ एक दिन चुनाव करवाये ओर दूसरे दिन रिजल्ट दे तब उसकी क्षमता को माने, अगर लोगो को संदेह है तो vvpt को जरूर गिनना चाहिए चाहे 2 दिन ओर क्यो ना लग जाये जिससे सरकार और इलेक्शन कमीशन की विश्वसनीयता बनी रहेगी।

  • @MOHDAKMALKHANOFFICIAL

    @MOHDAKMALKHANOFFICIAL

    Ай бұрын

    ❤️❤️👍👍

  • @MunendrasinghJadaun
    @MunendrasinghJadaunАй бұрын

    लेफ़्टिस्ट कितना नेगेटिव हो सकते हैं, ये आज मालूम चला.

  • @Anonymous19997
    @Anonymous19997Ай бұрын

    Thank you Lallantop for providing such a great exposure to intelligent minds.

  • @MA123mo
    @MA123moАй бұрын

    Thank u sir.

  • @dineshraodineshrao7997
    @dineshraodineshrao7997Ай бұрын

    The VVPAT slips are not for taking out but posting it in a box.

  • @vidheedesai7684
    @vidheedesai7684Ай бұрын

    💥May be New system .... हर पक्ष के लिये एक-एक, अलग -अलग, छोटे-छोटे मशीन होने चाहिये...... जिस पक्ष का बटन दबाये उसी मशीन मे वह वोट काउंट होना चाहिये... .

  • @aruntyagi3544
    @aruntyagi3544Ай бұрын

    ये तो अच्छी बात है की ये टेक्नोलॉजी हिंदुस्तान में भी हे।

  • @dharmikmehta5433
    @dharmikmehta5433Ай бұрын

    The studio audience is asking more sensible questions in this interview

  • @vikaskhot6941
    @vikaskhot6941Ай бұрын

    He answered all questions very logically.. but team had their own agenda .. they tried to hide their bias but not good like Saurabh 😂

  • @avinashrani3429
    @avinashrani3429Ай бұрын

    Wonderful!

  • @rockbottem1288
    @rockbottem1288Ай бұрын

    One of the best GITN, Very scientifically explained everything, though I liked anchor sahab's devil's advocate style and composer.... But I didn't thought such biased questions even after such good explanation,.... Mtlb wo nhi kr rhe to hm kyun kren, hm pahle yahin kyun kr rhe hain.... Really @lallantop

  • @sushilkumarvarshney7009
    @sushilkumarvarshney7009Ай бұрын

    Evm से छेड़छाड़ केवल मोदी ही कर सकता है देश में और कोई नहीं है इसका जानकारी रखने वाला कृपया एक बार यह भी बताओ कि यह कैसे संभव है

  • @AvirupDas-kt7lf
    @AvirupDas-kt7lfАй бұрын

    Professor Karandikar's arguments are definitely not unfounded, yet there are a few factors warranting consideration: 1. The statistical guarantee hinges on the premise of a truly random sample selection. However, there remains a concern regarding the possibility of EC-officials being swayed to draw a selective sample of untampered EVMs. 2. The integrity of the verification process itself raises doubts. The country has recently witnessed the Chandigarh mayoral election fiasco which underscores the potential for foul-play even during purportedly rigorous verification exercises. I agree that a 100% verification might seem impractical but recent events highlight the urgent need for alternatives. The Election Commission's apparent disregard for malpractices in recent week emphasises the necessity for a more robust and vigilant approach to ensure the integrity of the electoral process.

  • @DUSHYANTRAGDEVLOGS
    @DUSHYANTRAGDEVLOGSАй бұрын

    EVM सेटिंग हो गई हैं बीजेपी और सहयोगी पार्टी 366 सीट ला रही हैं

  • @davedhingra9697
    @davedhingra9697Ай бұрын

    As per sir, there is nothing wrong with EVM.. way more superior and way more safer. The non believers will always have problems.. let’s move forward

  • @realme12345.

    @realme12345.

    Ай бұрын

    Evm pe sawal uthane wale sabse pehle Modi ji hi the

  • @subhashbhosle8865
    @subhashbhosle8865Ай бұрын

    Best policy is that hand over vvpat slip to voter and posted it in box after his satisfaction. When recounting option arises, slips can be counted.

  • @prafulgupta2218

    @prafulgupta2218

    Ай бұрын

    What happens if some people do not post it in the box or mutilate it. During counting the discrepancy will arise between EVM count and VVPAT count and whoever is losing will cry foul.

  • @devindersingh1603

    @devindersingh1603

    Ай бұрын

    But for satisfaction you can see the VVPAT slip for 7 seconds when you vote. Uske baad kudh wo drop ho jaati hai box mai. Human interference kyu chahiye isme?

  • @subramanishankar1609

    @subramanishankar1609

    Ай бұрын

    That means you are doubting a hifher than 6sigma process. How unscientific. Have you ever sone election duty I wonder! One more box, which has all the ills of a paper ballot, you end up with more teouble! Logical thinking is essenrial, as also trust. Out of 96cr cotwr 95.99999 cr have no issues. We trust. Tgose who mistrust have an ulterior agenda

  • @viratmoradiya6792

    @viratmoradiya6792

    Ай бұрын

    It takes lots of time to count ballet paper and it is more chance not to get 100 percentage accuracy.

  • @megh280193

    @megh280193

    Ай бұрын

    So, you are only saying that in place of ink Stamp use printer. Can't be a more stupid argument.

  • @brrana6688
    @brrana6688Ай бұрын

    Sir, there is protest by more than 5lac people against Rupala in Rajkot Gujarat. But no media Coverage, why?

  • @ziaulhasan7164
    @ziaulhasan7164Ай бұрын

    Sir, 89 main congress ke time bharosa nhi tha but 2024 main Bjp hai toh aapko bharosa aa gya? VVPAT match krna kiyo pareshani hai... Sir,,, Aaapne point uthaya ki printer main dikkat ho gyi toh as an exuse not to match VVPAT but at the same time errors in the EVM is a reason for you to continue.

  • @dipanshugoel1
    @dipanshugoel1Ай бұрын

    Thanks lt

  • @user-di9jw9co9c
    @user-di9jw9co9cАй бұрын

    You ar rite sir

  • @Thought98
    @Thought98Ай бұрын

    बिकुल ठीक बोल रहे हैं ❤❤❤❤ इस बार मोदी सरकार बनाएगी तो सियोर है ईवीएम सेटिंग हुआ है 😢😢😢

  • @knowledge_forever
    @knowledge_foreverАй бұрын

    Paper ballot me itni dhandhli hoti thi. My uncle told me, he saw it first hand as a school teacher posted for election duties regularly.

  • @maniklalgupta9120
    @maniklalgupta9120Ай бұрын

    जब कानून यह कहता है हमें गुप्त मतदान का अधिकार है तो किस कानून के अंतर्गत ओपिनियन पोल किए जाते हैं? यदि ओपिनियन पोल कानून सम्मत है तो गुप्त मतदान के अधिकार से यह विरोधाभास क्यों? यदि ओपिनियन पोल कानून सम्मत नहीं है तो आमजनता से उनके मतदान के बारे पूंछने पर ओपिनियन पोल करने वाली एजेंसी पर कार्रवाई क्यों नहीं होती है?

  • @MOHDAKMALKHANOFFICIAL

    @MOHDAKMALKHANOFFICIAL

    Ай бұрын

    ❤️❤️👍👍

  • @rajujain1957
    @rajujain1957Ай бұрын

    People casting doubts on dark glass on VVPAT , what will be lost if transparent glass is reintroduced...😮😮

  • @lukmankhan2353
    @lukmankhan2353Ай бұрын

    Love from Assam, India, barpeta

  • @surjitkaur5951
    @surjitkaur5951Ай бұрын

    V good discussion vote must be counted

  • @TheHemant2007
    @TheHemant2007Ай бұрын

    बहोत अच्छा initiative I think we have asked him more on evm and political quetions Instead we could have utilize his knowledge of mathematics and policy making. That's what India youth needs to know.

  • @prabhanjankumar8852
    @prabhanjankumar8852Ай бұрын

    एक common आदमी बटन दबाया,,फिर उसे कुछ नही पता वोट,किसको गया,और उसी वोट की गिनती हुई या नही,,,,,, पर्ची वोटर के हाथ मे ये महाशय नही देना चाहते,,,,मुझे समझ मे नही आया कि इनके कौन से अंग में दर्द होने लगेगा अगर पर्ची वोटर के हाथ मे दे दी जाए,,,,,ये आदमी थेथर है,,, अगर इसमे हिम्मत है तो EVM VVPAT लेकर लाइव मीडिया के सामने मेरे से ठेथोरोलॉजी कर ले,,,,,,,,,,,ये सब वोट चोरी कर रहे है,,,ये देश और लोकतंत्र के खिलाफ है एक बार opposition की govt आ जाये इनको आप पब्लिक के सामने जलील होना पड़ेगा

  • @bahadursinghbisht9094

    @bahadursinghbisht9094

    Ай бұрын

    2014 तक तो विपक्षी दलों की सरकार थी,तब क्यों नहीं कराये बैलेट से चुनाव।

  • @user-ss5lg4iw7m
    @user-ss5lg4iw7mАй бұрын

    Excellent session. EVM all the way until something better is designed and agreed to by responsible bodies. Not going back to manual counting under ANY circumstances!!

  • @lokeshthakur7
    @lokeshthakur7Ай бұрын

    ये लिब्राण्डु पत्तलकार लोग कौन से स्कूल से पढ़ के आते हैं कि इनकी बुद्धि भ्रष्ट हो जाती है ।

  • @VermaRajinder
    @VermaRajinderАй бұрын

    Rajeeva Karandikar is a smart Activist !!! He needs to be more proactive !!! 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @pardeeptandon
    @pardeeptandonАй бұрын

    The voter list is uploaded by a cable. While uploading the list it can be programmed that to print APALE to VVPT But record Banna in control panel

  • @ankur.mahajan
    @ankur.mahajanАй бұрын

    @01:38:30 The names on EVM are in the serial order as per the Local Recognised Language or English as decided by the RO.

  • @pramodshah2491
    @pramodshah2491Ай бұрын

    Vvpat में keys होते हैं। उन्हें मैनुपुलेट किया जा सकता है। इस पर विस्तार से बहस अपेक्षित है।

  • @MDIRFAN-xo4ew

    @MDIRFAN-xo4ew

    Ай бұрын

    If missmatch.... Why mismatch... So Old system is Gold system

  • @art563
    @art563Ай бұрын

    जब तक केवीएम रहेगी तब तक हम वोट नहीं डालेंगे

  • @anoopmeena4070
    @anoopmeena4070Ай бұрын

    Evm पर कोई बहस करेगा और इसे एनरेलेबल बtaएगी, वो जेल जाएंगे

  • @dineshraodineshrao7997
    @dineshraodineshrao7997Ай бұрын

    "Pataapat ho raha hai.." . This guy has a great sense of humour.

  • @ajayverma4952
    @ajayverma4952Ай бұрын

    Nice Interview

  • @aslamislahi8826
    @aslamislahi8826Ай бұрын

    Chandigarh mein chori pakdi gayi kyonki yahan election ballot papers se hua tha.Yahi chunav aga EVM se hua hota to aaj Chandigarh ka mayor bjp ka hota.

  • @shankarramharichavan7158
    @shankarramharichavan7158Ай бұрын

    Hack is impossible but manipulation is 101% possible. Vvpat ka transparent glass is good suggestion.

  • @gajendrakumarvyas5643
    @gajendrakumarvyas5643Ай бұрын

    आम जनता का वर्तमान तरीके पर विश्वास है। ये कुछ पूर्वाग्रह रखने वाले बुद्धिजीवी भ्रम फैला रहें हैं।

  • @milupatadiya.7205
    @milupatadiya.7205Ай бұрын

    વાત સાચી છે ભાઈ સાહેબ

  • @rakeshkumarshrivastava3392
    @rakeshkumarshrivastava3392Ай бұрын

    सच को सामने मत लाइये क्योंकि इससे अराजकता फैल जायेगी इस आधार पर वीवीपेट पर्चियों की गिनती न करें, अजीब और संदेहास्पद है। इसके आधार पर तो कभी भी सच को सामने नहीं लाना चाहिए वाह क्या सोच है बीजेपी कब ज्वाइन कर रहे हैं

  • @goal493

    @goal493

    Ай бұрын

    Bjp kab join kar rahe ho? Sare k sare aarop hawa me hai Kabhi kahi par kisi ne galti pakdi hai.?

  • @bsnegi7410

    @bsnegi7410

    Ай бұрын

    लगता है जल्दी ही भाजपा जौयन कर सकते है।

  • @askdynamic

    @askdynamic

    Ай бұрын

    सच का सामना करने के लिए सही मंशा भी आवश्यकता है। जब आज के दिन में भी पर्याप्त सुरक्षा का इंतजाम होते हुए भी पश्चिम बंगाल में पंचायत चुनावों के दौरान बैलट बॉक्स पर खुलेआम लूट होता विडियो यूट्यूब पर आज उपलब्ध है। तो फिर वीवीपैट के सत प्रतिशत गणना के दौरान निश्चित ही मानवीय त्रुटियां का अनजाने में या जानबूझकर भी परिस्थितियों का निर्माण आसान है।

  • @MuhammedABDULRAZZAK

    @MuhammedABDULRAZZAK

    Ай бұрын

    20:36 21:23 21:33 22:06 22:08 😅😅

  • @nizampalace

    @nizampalace

    Ай бұрын

    tumhari akal pe taras aata hai. Professor ne pehle hi bataya ki Supreme Court ke order ke baad error rate 0.25% se kam ho jaati hai. Lekin arajakta Failane waalon ko samjhana bekar hai

  • @pramodshah2491
    @pramodshah2491Ай бұрын

    अनुबंध के मामले को परिष्कृत बनाया जा सकता है।कि जैसे जैसे सुधार करना जरूरी होगा,उन सभी को समायोजित करना होगा।यह बात अनुबंध का हिस्सा होने पर कोई इससे मुकर नहीं सकता।

  • @subramanishankar1609
    @subramanishankar1609Ай бұрын

    Did you get any receipt whwn you voted with ballot paper. How ridiculous!

  • @Bhaskar_karandikar
    @Bhaskar_karandikarАй бұрын

    For the EVM opposition, Britain is still ruled by the king, make me king of India then ask the same question. 😉

  • @lukmankhan2353
    @lukmankhan2353Ай бұрын

    Vote for education Vote for Manipur Vote for farmers Vote for women's Vote for youth Vote for laddakh

  • @uttam4159

    @uttam4159

    Ай бұрын

    Vote for sandeshkhali Vote for dictatorship in Bengal Vote for reservation politics..😂 Vote for anti sanatan.... Vote for anti national 😂

  • @ShivamKumar-kx2es

    @ShivamKumar-kx2es

    Ай бұрын

    Haan bhai abhi abhi vote kar ke aaya hu bjp ko 😊😊 They are doing good for farmers, market, business, education , youth, startup, infrastructure project

  • @uttam4159

    @uttam4159

    Ай бұрын

    @@ShivamKumar-kx2es👍

  • @user-fo6cn2kv7r

    @user-fo6cn2kv7r

    Ай бұрын

    Vote for population.. सारे रोग की एक दवाई जो भाजपा के पास है, वह जनसंख्या रोकने का कानून। घुसपैठ रोकने का कानून। इतना होते ही देश की सारी प्रॉब्लम महंगाई बेरोजगारी सॉल्व हो जाएगी। Agree हो???

  • @ravindran296

    @ravindran296

    28 күн бұрын

    Vote for 370 Vote for 35A Vote for 3 talaak Vote for halala Vote for CCA Vote for NRC हां ओर vote for pakistan ki jalane ke liye or मुगलों की नाजायज औलादों की जलाने के लिए

  • @suryap7141
    @suryap7141Ай бұрын

    लोकल इलेक्शन में मतगणना के टाइम पर मेरे यहां कई बार रीकाउन्टिंग के बाद रिजल्ट बदल चुके हैं। मतलब गिनने में कई बार गलती हो सकती है।

  • @MadanJangid-ft5oo
    @MadanJangid-ft5ooАй бұрын

    कई लोग होते हैं जो अकल तो गधे से कम होती है लेकिन अपने आप को दुनिया का सबसे ज्यादा इंटेलिजेंस समझते हैं

  • @KapilJoshi-uq1gr
    @KapilJoshi-uq1grАй бұрын

    asking question raised by prashant bhushan proves that you're so delhi centric

  • @dineshraodineshrao7997
    @dineshraodineshrao7997Ай бұрын

    "Define mismatch" ? What was it that the ECI told The Quint that in 373 LS seats, votes polled did not tally with the machine figures in 2019 ?

  • @saurabhsaxena184
    @saurabhsaxena184Ай бұрын

    Wat gem of knowledge❤

  • @atullondhe5436
    @atullondhe5436Ай бұрын

    Fantastic

  • @durgeshwarvarma1988
    @durgeshwarvarma1988Ай бұрын

    Vvpat connect to a machine where all parchi count automatically Not manually count.

  • @shashanksharma2008
    @shashanksharma2008Ай бұрын

    Algorithm should be open for transparency, you should also invite who are against this

  • @rjdsolanki
    @rjdsolankiАй бұрын

    Puri duniya ko UPI or EVM pe aana hi padega aaj nahi to kal

  • @bhuy797

    @bhuy797

    Ай бұрын

    Aakr band hogai America Europe mein. Evm is not proper never ever.

  • @ravindran296
    @ravindran29628 күн бұрын

    सोरभ जी ने लल्लनटाप पर ऐसे लिब्रांडु ट्रेनीज भर रखें है

  • @PradeepKumar-nk7vm
    @PradeepKumar-nk7vmАй бұрын

    Manual tarike se vote ginne Mein Ek limit tak ki hi Dandeli sakti hai lekin EVM se jo dhaandli Hogi uski Koi Seema Nahin Hai

  • @shamsulhudarizwi341
    @shamsulhudarizwi341Ай бұрын

    He considers ECI to be a divine body. If the EVM is a stand alone device, its source code needs to be disclosed to the public without any fear of the device being tampered with. The entire electoral process is for the voters, the main and the only stakeholder in that process, and, therefore, their opinion cannot be ignored by the ECI and the Court. A referendum may be resorted to if there is a doubt about the number of people who have lost faith in the process. Somebody who has certified the integrity of the machine, a scientist instead of a statistician, would have been a better person to be interviewed. The interviewer, too, seems to be unduly circumspect and ill-equipped to handle an issue based on science .

  • @First-yy5mx
    @First-yy5mxАй бұрын

    hath se vote daalne mein "assurity" milti hai..what kind of garbage being peddled..why use UPI, use the same credit card, oh why not use rupee, aana, paisa..what a regressive thought process.

  • @kachra5551
    @kachra5551Ай бұрын

    WHO will select the 4k EVMs that will be matched ?? Election Commission?

  • @2upload2utube
    @2upload2utubeАй бұрын

    America me ballet paper use nahin hota

  • @pvaish
    @pvaishАй бұрын

    For the first time, commenting here. And it is not about the interviewee or interviewer. Rest of the crowd is not just bereft of basic knowledge but seems so short of even basic understanding of either politics, or science or maths or technology. If this what goes for newsroom in India today, Bhagwan bachaye. Can we not get better quality people in journalism? Saurabh should really see the questions being asked by his team here. I am aghast.

  • @vinayvijaydost
    @vinayvijaydostАй бұрын

    Y Mr. Questioner not asked which country invented Super Computer?

  • @games4funtv820
    @games4funtv820Ай бұрын

    Why can't they print vote and also count manual at same time?

  • @kalusinghindargarh
    @kalusinghindargarhАй бұрын

    Masjid lagta hai ki EVM hack Nahin Hai Congress haik ho gai hai pappu Khan firoj Khan😅😂

  • @ankur7773

    @ankur7773

    Ай бұрын

    भारत ही नहीं भारत के बाहर भी दुनिया देख रही है कि बाबासाहेब अंबेडकर जी के संविधान की खुल्लम खुल्ला धज्जी उड़ रही है न्यायपालिका ने न्याय करना छोड़ दिया है

  • @ashokpradhan9094
    @ashokpradhan9094Ай бұрын

    the anchor forgot to ask why the glass in vvpat is dark and not transparent. This is the crux of the whole problem. Even the Supreme court is silent about it.

  • @dineshraodineshrao7997

    @dineshraodineshrao7997

    Ай бұрын

    The SC is also silent on re-election if microcontroller is tampered with. Only that the ECI will reimburse the candidate who requested the scrutiny and paid for it.

  • @chandramohan9220
    @chandramohan9220Ай бұрын

    हा हा हा जिस व्यक्ति को यह नहीं मालूम है कि एमएससी स्टैटिसटिक्स भी होती है वह आदमी साक्षात्कार ले रहा है ।

  • @madanlalsharma9062
    @madanlalsharma9062Ай бұрын

    Counting of VVPT slip should be wherever complaint is lodged and not wherever the EC wants. The VVPT machine can be re designed to segregate the slips symbole wise and push the slips into separately attached boxes. If so many boxes are a complication then two or three boxes of the main contestants should be designed.

  • @chandrikasaha6301
    @chandrikasaha6301Ай бұрын

    I like that Tulip engineer Madhav Deshpande's design solution which was told in Karan Thapar's interview. Why to choose Statistical uncertainty over Computational certainty. Turing had to choose Statistical probability over Mathematical certainty when he hacked the smuggled enigma machine. We don't have that situation. In one side Karandikar is batting for technological advance, on the other side he is arguing against feature enablement that makes the system impossible to manipulate.

Келесі