*What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Don't Forget:_ *Please join my mailing list to get FREE notes and resources from this show! click here: **briankeating.com/mailing_list.php*

@kavankachoria1699

3 жыл бұрын

garrett's laugh

@zenmeister451

3 жыл бұрын

Ah, er...that thing they said about that thing that relates to all those other things! Is he, to them, an "outsider"?

@stockinvestor1

3 жыл бұрын

your jokes. Lisi strict demand of Erics theory of everything. Bars set high. follow Eric up on that one! Can he or will be meet the demands of Lisi with his theory?

@RWin-fp5jn

3 жыл бұрын

Eric is the rare if not unique combination of being enough of an insider to assess the merits of current plethora of physical concepts and enough of an outsider to see that these are mathematical approximations at best and what is needed for physics is getting back to solid tangible geometric structures. Being a MIT grad he however should appreciate two key things: 1. increased complexity always points to erroneous (or incomplete) human assumptions. 2. The very word 'fundament' suggests that all derived theories must be more complex than the 'fundament' itself. Therefor: the fundament leading to ToE needs to be an extremely simply concept (preferably binary) which we have collectively overlooked for over 100 years now. It has to do with the physical linear structures (ST fieldlines) getting twisted by micro singularities (atoms) which fabric we then see as 'windings' or 'quanta of windings' of the same material that defined space at this ST location. Only in the wind up form we call this material 'energy' in stead of 'space' . Movement inside these spinor windings (inner atoms) is therefor perceived by our senses as going along 'quanta of energy' (think of electrons). Eric should look at the geometry of how Kerr singularities bend and spiral ST into spiraled EM windings. Thats what his Geometric Unity represents. The extension of the one (EM field) is the orthogonal contraction of the other (ST contraction a.k.a gravity). The physical setup of our continuum is BINARY or DUAL (and compensating as such) and not SINGULAR. Stop the complexity and face reality guys

@RWin-fp5jn

3 жыл бұрын

And as for 'spooky action at a distance'...It all depends on by what measure you define 'distance'. If you take the dual expression ENERGY as the 'grid' than there is no problem. Quantum Entanglement is then simply the consequence of 'locality' between two particles expressed in 'energy.' Particles that have the same spin energy in all three energy grid directions AND at the same 'mass' moment (having the same mass) are simply 'at the same' spot in the quantized energy grid and can thus influence each other 'instantly' time wise. What is so hard about energetic locality to grasp ?? Seriously, you guys should be smart enough to be able to think of physics in this dual continuum setup. The 'energy' as a particle property simultaneously means an orthogonal 'energy as the grid contraction' around it. Symmetry any one? Regardless which object or whatever change in motion since the 'big bang' the orthogonal continuum settings always keep the original zero equilibrium intact. That's all the symmetry you'll ever need....

What a time we live in. Over the last 5 years I have studied everything from economics to computer science to physics. When I started learning, I just wanted to know what it was like to know the same things as the worlds most brilliant minds. I still have years to go, but I have learned that the intuition for this stuff comes in small bite sizes over time. Subtle intuitions over time. I feel really blessed to live in world so rich with information. I don't think people realize how much we have found out about the nature of reality, and how fulfilling it is to attempt to comprehend it. Thanks for the content

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Very much appreciate your viewership

Brian as a participant physicist in the discussion rather than Brian adopting the tone of the moderator makes for a much more intriguing discussion.

I haven't got a fucking clue how to do these kinds of mathematics. I listen because it sounds like poetry.

@notreallysure1790

3 жыл бұрын

@Robert Hunt wait is that true? Im not familiar with complicated math and physics but he claims to “do math” in his spare time quite frequently

@Isaac_the_Seeker_of_Truth

3 жыл бұрын

@@notreallysure1790 No it's not true, Eric Weinstein has a PhD in mathematics, managed a hedgefund for a long while, and is well versed in differential geometry and topology, both of which are graduate to post doctoral topics in mathematics.

@Isaac_the_Seeker_of_Truth

3 жыл бұрын

@Robert Hunt I assume you haven't heard him discussing differential geometry with postdocs from MIT then? Edit: It might have been a California school, I don't remember specifically. It was one of many unrecorded conversations on his discord. But he was definitely a postdoc doing LQG, I think his name was Alan. Edit: The name was Tim, he went to Caltech and MIT, and used to do reseach at Simons Center.

@Isaac_the_Seeker_of_Truth

3 жыл бұрын

@Robert Hunt If you say so man 🤷‍♂️ just because someone doesn't publish doesn't mean they don't know what they're talking about. I never published my honors thesis in nanophotonics and plasmonics, but I know the subject matter pretty well. I'd say that if someone can propose and solve a problem in a given subject, which I've been there while he did live, then they're well versed in it.

@Isaac_the_Seeker_of_Truth

3 жыл бұрын

@Robert Hunt "Prove that for the bundle of all metrics over a manifold with a unique spin structure, the tangent bundle of that bundle has a god-given metric"

Would anyone be interested in companion videos to these sorts of podcasts that takes time to briefly explain concepts mentioned in the podcast like E8 and differentialble manifolds? The idea would be to assist in the translation of statements that are often said without meaning much conceptually to those who aren't familiar with the background physics and math required to parse out the statement.

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Great idea Kevin. If you guys make them I can help promote on the channel.

@simonmasters3295

3 жыл бұрын

Oh they're just three guys you know? ...they are joshing at top level. Not understanding is part of the pleasure

@tyfoodsforthought

3 жыл бұрын

I probably still won't understand (at this point in my physics journey), BUT sounds real cool 😁

@ReadingDave

3 жыл бұрын

I would be interested in these concepts.

@clivetaylor27

3 жыл бұрын

That would be a great service. As Feynman said - you have to teach it to understand it. I'm always intrigued by Sir Roger Penrose's diagrams and how they convey such sophisticated ideas. [Viz. Eric's cardboard roll and rubber band]

This was a fantastic conversation. I'd love to see Garrett explore Geometric Unity and how it may connect with his theories, and likewise Eric connecting Geometric Unity to aspects of Garrett's theories. A sort of Godel, Escher Bach exposition of theories, attempting to find the commonalities via analogues.

Congratulations Professor Keating! ^.^

Seeing Garett Lisi laughing is something I didn't know my life's been missing.

@coreyworthingtonii9230

3 жыл бұрын

Satisfying in a strange way

G. DAMN What Eric said at 2:10:00 Put a chill down my spine

@coreyworthingtonii9230

3 жыл бұрын

💯

@superkillr

3 жыл бұрын

I just barely caught this comment. I jumped in to this video and it was a string of scientist names and stuff I can't even begin to comprehend and I was gonna go somewhere else. That ending was really really good.

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Corey Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/mailing_list.php

@sammykays8873

3 жыл бұрын

Eric reminds me of Professor Irwin Corey.

Eric W. is clearly at another level of understanding of the universe and theoretical theory. He summorizes Garrett theory in 5 minutes better than Garrett can in my opinion. Eric is also open and courageous to abstract and pushing US to think beyond the known unlike Garrett and others.

Eric is stirring. He's a remarkable orator.

@Petrov3434

3 жыл бұрын

Deepak Chopra charlatan coming... - this is disgusting and irresponsible. You have lost credibility !!!

@dougg1075

3 жыл бұрын

@@Petrov3434 go away then

@Bluehoke98

3 жыл бұрын

For sure. If you like good speakers an obvious person you should look into if you don't know about them already is Terrence McKenna

@miyojewoltsnasonth2159

3 жыл бұрын

@Holy Squire I dunno, Eric might be stringing things along. :)

@miyojewoltsnasonth2159

3 жыл бұрын

@@Petrov3434 State your argument why you believe Eric is a charlatan.

There’s so much wisdom in this episode. I’m going to have to watch it a few more times. Thank you all for your courage, love, and diversity of thought.

Thanks Brian! Watched live and returning to it now for a second round of takeaways!

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Amazing. If you haven’t already, Please join my mailing list; just click here 👉 briankeating.com/mailing_list.php for exclusive 📝

@ronan8228

3 жыл бұрын

@@DrBrianKeating will do.

I wish Eric would run for President. I would have faith in humanity again if he was the President.

@raifthemad

3 жыл бұрын

If he ran, he would either get completely ignored by media, or if it looked like he had a chance, he would probably just die.

@williammoats8310

3 жыл бұрын

A desire for a "benevolent Big Brother" is tempting. However when one applies this desire to politics, our desperation emerges and metasticizes into a fatal (Trumpanoma).

@rhettburgess8753

3 жыл бұрын

@@raifthemad Agreed.

@PeterTheSAGAFan

2 жыл бұрын

Eric is way too smart, not willing to lie for a living and doesn’t hate enough people to win...

@DrBrianKeating

2 жыл бұрын

True

50:45 “the thing about, i don't think Garrett is actuality accurate; one of the really important things about what happened in the 1970’s, where we actually made progress but we pretend we didn't make progress is in the structure of mathematics, because we’re embarrassed where the progress happened; it happened around the mathematics of field theory, rather than in the specifics of the field theory that seemed to to describe our world. In fact, if Garret has a Lagrangian, which he does, and that Lagrangian is applied to the fields, which it is, Garrett will find that he will have something called a phase space, he will have a configuration space, he will have a phase space. The phase space will inherit a structure called the symplectic form. That symplectic form will become the curvature of a differential operator on something called a line bundle, and that line bundle is something like the XY plane where you can look at functions, and those functions will become the quantum states of a quantum field theory, so I think Garrett just said is not actually accurate.” nuff said?

@noxrubbish

3 жыл бұрын

Nuff said about what? He's describing geometric quantization, I think he actually summarized it quite beautifully, given that it's an extremely technical topic. To learn more, check out the nlab page: ncatlab.org/nlab/show/geometric+quantization

Would love a conversation in a more teaching/ academic discussion between peers style where equations were being visually put up for you and your guests to discuss the specifics of what you are talking about in a very nerdy in depth way. While not losing the fun conversational vibe that distinguishes this podcast from an actual college lecture 😀🤓

@soulsfang

3 жыл бұрын

While i love this idea, it comes with the problem that Eric sort of touched on at the start; the vast majority of the audience doesn't have the mathematical background to really begin to understand the depths of what they are discussing. I myself have only gone up to calc 2, and while I've attempted to learn more about higher level physics (Einstein field equations, schrodinger equation, couple other well known equations), I feel like I've barely scratched the surface of what they are dealing with, and I find it hard to imagine that someone with only a cursory understanding of basic algebra would get very much out of a single 2-3 hour conversation like what I think you are proposing. That being said, a weekly (or monthly) series that really goes in depth would be very fascinating. Just how far in depth is a tough cookie though. I love PBS Spacetime's format, though even that brilliant channel has trouble either oversimplifying the math, or going way over my head and losing me.

@simonmasters3295

3 жыл бұрын

I commend the Wolfram Physics Project because of its accessibility and the probability that effort would produce reward, and that it is fundamentally collaborative.

Weinstein/ Garrett 2024 The smart guy's turn..... let's make this happen

That eye movement from Garrett at about 53:03 was classic as he was registering what Eric was saying. Great episode all around.

This was an excellent conversation. Cant believe its only 10k views.

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation? Please join my mailing list to get FREE notes and resources from this show! click here: **briankeating.com/mailing_list.php*

Leave it to the surfer to recline in his Lafer chair for the livestream. Good stuff again, guys.

@ronan8228

3 жыл бұрын

You think it’s actually a lafer?

@kenhiett5266

3 жыл бұрын

@@ronan8228 Pretty positive. I own a couple. I guess it could be a knock off, but I highly doubt it.

I love Lee Smolin! Please get into the nitty gritty of his most personal and maddest thoughts on causality. Most interviewers do not do this and ask trite questions every time. You and Eric are doing an excellent job of igniting and armoring hidden millennials. Please keep on growing this last hope of a podcast with great potential into what the willing can and will absorb. -down the I5 from Glendale

"More time on the chalkboard, less time on the surfboard". Lol, Brian is surprisingly clever.

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

😀 thanks 🌊🏄‍♂️

Please, give us a review of the Norberts book. Interesting. Also, I wish to hear deeper reviews of TOEs, something along the line Eric talked about E8. It gives more perspective to hear about the few of the more rigor options in the field. 4h sessions are perfect. Good company for outdooring in the woods!

Eric I found you on Glenn Beck. We are more the same than different. I want Americans to love each other. You have inspired me to learn basic physics and math as it relates to music. Garret I am also an introvert. You are the coolest introvert. I looked up E 8. I don't really understand it but do understand that that is where you found beauty.

Albert Einstein started out as an “amateur “ physicist working outside of the established academic community. Thanks for hosting these guys who are both clearly approaching genius

You need to continue to give your two friends more time on your shows. I think this was a great show and Eric's comments are right on point especially about never being silenced so to speak as in not being afraid to call it like it is being straight forward and not disrespectful making the statement in true love.

Eric, that was a fabulous explanation of lisi’s theory.

I'l like to hear Garrett's thoughts on sacred geometry

I love Eric's ability to steel man Garrett's position, thoroughly but with concision. It was pretty clear to me that Garrett was in general agreement with his characterization. I think that is one of Eric's (and Bret's, too) great strengths; he is able to inhabit an idea (in physics or otherwise) and view it clearly and fairly, assessing both the strengths and weaknesses. Which is why I had asked elsewhere in another KZread comment for Eric's take on the Bohmian interpretation (pilot wave, if you prefer). The respect Eric shows for people with whom he vehemently intellectually disagrees, whose hard work he readily acknowledges, is commendable. Whether this unusual ability to fairly assess ideas (and to respect the people behind them, regardless of his view of the quality or utility of those ideas) is due to nature or nurture, or to what degree of each, might be a subject worth exploring. Zev's acuity, poise and maturity at a young age doesn't resolve this question for me. We need more Weinstein brothers in this world. I am not a physicist (just a BS in Mechanical Engineering) so most everything you all say is out of my mental reach; I'm not even really very competent in calculus anymore - use it or lose it. Despite my lack of intellectual sophistication, these discussions give me hope that there is still good stuff going on in physics. Thanks for taking the risk of talking to heretics, outcasts and pariahs, Dr. Keating. Much respect.

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks my friend. Stay tuned for more great guests like Michio Kaku

Kudos to Dr Brian for pulling an Eric and calling it like it is at 1hr:26min. I know he doesn't support the accusations but his clear commitment to a open and honest discussion even when it involves information we may distaste is worthy of praise and applause frankly in this day and age. When you treat people like adults, like they can handle the bad with the good, they tend to rise to the occasion. Cheers

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks Jory!

i literally could not possibly thank Dr. Keating more for what Dr. W said at 47:37, we are all unbelieveably grateful. your an amazing human being!!

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks very much !

Okay few questions: 1. . To Eric Weinstein, Garrett : As a graduate in Electrical engineering, part time physics enthusiast, what advice would you give for a newbie who is interested in exploring these concepts, I'm highly curious, but not sure if I would able to get upto speed to the current theories. How should I know, if it would better for me to ship some code in a tech company instead of trying to understand the universe? 2. To Brian Keating: Please bring my god to your podcast: Ed witten

This needs to be rehashed. Wolfram has said he's recently gotten some significant results, including computations that produce some of the sub-atomic particles this video said he hadn't yet found. Sabine just dropped a video "What's the Point of the Universe?" where she suggested that the universe could be "working toward an increase in complexity or computational power". That sounds suspiciously close to what Wolfram is doing, which means she might be warming to his idea at the very least, contrary to her "Do we need a theory of everything" video from 3 years ago. I still think Eric should consider going to work for Wolfram...he could then possibly contribute to that concept while having access to some young guns who could give his ideas some track-testing as well. And please have Neil Turok involved as well, and David Deutsch and Chiara Marletto for their constructor theory. I would love to see these people take two weeks or a month and just get together and play intellectual jazz with each other to see what kinds of wonderment could come out of it.

Having expressed pleasure in a comment on an earlier podcast when I heard Don Hoffman was going to be on, I'll double down now hearing that Nima A-H is going to be on. Though I'm sure, like with Eric, I won't understand a word Nima says, Hoffman, apparently, does as he frequently cites Nima in his other interviews. Look forward to that being explored more in depth.

Surprisingly accessible for such a meaty discussion. It's been a long time since I was able to find an popular update on Garrett's work.

@DrBrianKeating

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/mailing_list.php

The best part was when you guys briefly touched on the importance of our dwindling freedoms, the fall of common sense in general and how we must stand up to this authoritarianism movement now!!!

Eric IS one of the most interesting people.... Thanks for this conversation!

Blown away. Takeaway - how scientific minds can illuminate the truth and lay it out for moral application. Brilliant people all. I'm in. Your hosting was perfect letting the information flow with gentle nudging, exemplary. I'm in.

@clivetaylor27

3 жыл бұрын

Your hosting was perfect letting the information flow with gentle nudging, exemplary. I'm in.

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks VERY much Clive!

This was a fantastic conversation. I didn’t understand any of it, but I’m pretty sure it was great.

@deborahmeek6529

3 жыл бұрын

🤣

Eric, how can I get in touch with you, do you have a email for the public?

@phumgwatenagala6606

3 жыл бұрын

There is a discord, maybe that would work? Also check out his geometric unity website, there may be contact info there

What do I think? Well, I’m trying to figure out if I’m a chimpanzee or an orangutan in comparison to egg head central here. Lovin’ it.

Everything was my favourite. Thank you for a great talk!

Eric you are super funny. I really enjoyed when you said the younger generation should be seated as long as they weren't allowed to chant.

Brian Keating's book review right now...do we have time for it? worth the money + the time to understand and handshake with brian on his book? Please do tell. Thanks Internet.

Unbelievably fascinating...Brian's ability to get these high level intellects on to battle it out in good humour is remarkable.

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/mailing_list.php

@ubiktd4064

3 жыл бұрын

I didn't understand a lot of the physics to be honest even though I've read a lot of popular science books but I found it very entertaining..It's amazing how you can go to such depth on such a hard subject and still make it interesting..I used to watch Science Saturday on Bloggingheads TV every week with John Horgan..you should get him on your show he would be a perfect fit...thanks for the great videos.

Dont know maybe I missed something but what happened to the portal? Havent seen any new uploads..

Electricity and magnetism connects the micro to the macro. Everything is connected easily not complex.

@emilylowrance7930

3 жыл бұрын

are you familiar w/ the electric universe?

Breath taking, thank you for sharing your experiences, some overlap with my own and this helps to validate my research efforts.

Eric has echoed my fears about the social trend developing in the country. We no longer have a Democratic Party because the current administration is leaning more and more toward Fascism. Freedom of speech is the only true freedom that we have and when the mainstream media becomes a tool of the incumbent leadership it poses the gravest danger to that freedom. The prospect of being targeted by the government for reprogramming should be anathema to all Americans. I still hold faith that we have enough intelligent people like Eric who can turn back the dangerous direction we are going in without the need for revolutionary conflict. I focus on Eric here because of the comments he made but I also have the same faith in you Brian and all people of true intelligence. While intelligence doesn’t necessarily equate to altruism, anyone who is not a fool must know that the American populace will not submit to the kind of controls that the government is trying to impose on the exchange of ideas

Just found this channel last night. Can't wait to watch most of the videos. Love the names I've seen perusing the video list.

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Hope you will subscribe!

Well, maybe the community needs to differentiate what they call 'theories' and what they should call 'hypotheses', then there wouldn't be so much confusion in physics. I didn't hear any theories in this discussion.

Thumbs up and subbed! Thank you for the content!

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

_Thanks so much!_ *Stay tuned for more great guests!*

@ghostrecon3214

3 жыл бұрын

@@DrBrianKeating The more heterodox the better IMO 😁

This was an amazing discussion, Thank you Brian I play your shows for my teenager's during science chill Friday (home school, mon-thur more text book learning with hands on when possible, Friday is all mind) and they write a paper on what they could prove or disprove depending what they pick, just wanted to say we really do appreciate your time and effort to spread the words of science.

@DrBrianKeating

2 жыл бұрын

Fantastic! Love hearing that!!

@mitchellhayman381

Жыл бұрын

Great job Dad

This stream is still moving and powerful the fourth time through. There's nothing like it on You Tube.

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you, very much

Has anyone considered if there could be 2d geometric shapes working in the 3d matrix which would be responsible for the magnetic field and gravity field like a ring disk and respectively a square disk

Eric´s last words ! What a great postcast Brian ! EXCELLENT Executed,-

Great podcast Brian! You're among the best!

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks Christie!!! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation? Please join my mailing list to get FREE notes & resources from this show! Click 👉 briankeating.com/mailing_list.php *

Well you guys another amazing episode. Brian you have a real knack for facilitating these conversations. You push back with love and then allow each to speak their truth. What a wonderful way to connect the larger body of science minded mature individuals to honestly banter through complex ideas and push up into hints and dreams of stepping out of the matrix intact. This was fun watching discovery on several levels simultaneously. Eric is an interesting and awesome fellow...he has lateral intelligence galore. He is righteously and rightly furious at the wasteland physics has become because influence/mammon/power/status (IMPS) hungry academic mercenaries have ensconced themselves and perpetuated ancient tribal rituals that at one time distinguished early man from the other apes as they gradually learned to reason.

Coolest videos on the Internet! WHERE are those ten million viewers now!?? Can’t wait for Nima. Hopefully more viewers will come back and watch once it takes off.

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks Eugene. Stay tuned - Tuesday is must see video

@enterprisesoftwarearchitect

3 жыл бұрын

Carlo Rovelli? Cool!!!

Could you please add this episode to Spotify or Apple podcast?? For some reason I can’t find this episode there 🤷‍♂️☹️

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Yes coming soon. I am switching podcast hosts.

@dmitrypochkaev5922

3 жыл бұрын

@@DrBrianKeating thank you! Good luck with your channel, I’m glad I found you

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/mailing_list.php

Eric, you paraglide? Awesome! Let's go fly to Marshall :)

Hi there nice surprise, dont know nothing about Garrett, but I will stay tuning, brain storm. ....

What sort of support would physicist like in forms of work space, experiments and conversations that would advance the field?

I like Eric for his many enthusiasms, esp, music and human relations, and his generous spirit.

Eric, you mentioned Perimeter, but you overlooked Royal Institute which performs a similar service to the public.

Can anyone remind eric that he has his own podcast.

Great show gentlemen, great show.

Love this show, this was a great conversation with new branches.

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Tim Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/mailing_list.php

@coder8i

3 жыл бұрын

@@DrBrianKeating I think hearing the discussion about how they bootstrap the geometry / algebra to try and hit certain experimental criteria. Fun news ways to build mathematical structures. Inspired me to go learn some more geometric algebra.

Thank you Gentlemen!

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation? Please join my mailing list to get FREE notes and resources from this show! click here: **briankeating.com/mailing_list.php*

New to your podcast, Dr. Keating, and was surprised to find myself watching a truly fascinating exchange for the entire two-plus hours (though I could've skipped the bitcoin bit, in which I have no knowledge or interest). Anyway, on the subject of betting on experiments; I will bet an extensive guitar collection that should those wacky Europeans actually build a collider three times the size of the LHC, they will STILL find no hint of the shadow of SUSY. Though I'm an outsider, it does seem many of these adherents to String "Theory" (hypothesis which doesn't even pretend to be fundamental), SUSY and the "Multiverse" could benefit from the insight of a certain 14th-century philosopher named William of Ockham, and it's good to see you professionals

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Robert Thanks so much! * Please join my mailing list to get FREE notes and resources from this show! click here: briankeating.com/mailing_list.php*

@robertjackson9326

3 жыл бұрын

(got cut off, probably by random tunneling) are thinking deeply and seriously about the philosophical underpinnings of physics. (Okay, got that much off my chest.)

@robertjackson9326

3 жыл бұрын

Got a "404 not found" on your link...guess it's on an Apple platform. I'll try on my Google engines, as I really loved your presentation.

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Please try - join my mailing list; just click here 👉 briankeating.com/mailing_list.php 📝

Yes , Eric is a joy to me (and many) but please let others speak without interruption ...

Eric is one special dude!

I have great respect for those who are pursuing knowledge of our physical universe, past masters as well as current endeavors. I eagerly devour any source of information on the current state of the scientific arts and also the directions in which the numerous searches are tending. I do have a strange feeling that everyone is missing a key element that has been overlooked due to a bad assumption made by a previous theory that has been generally accepted as fact. No one is infallible and while past masters have given us some awesome tools to work with, they were also working from certain starting assumptions. If the old guys had the knowledge we currently have, their conclusions may have been somewhat different and possibly more accurate. Standing on the shoulders of giants will let you see farther but it also makes it hard to see your toes. My advice is: do not blindly trust anyone or anything be it physical laws or seemingly proven theories.

Really enjoyed this podcast.

Brian, I couldn't agree with Eric more. The list of guests you've had on your pod is ASTOUNDING and INSPIRED. By far the least controversial thing Eric has ever uttered. ;) BRAVO!

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks Jason. That means so much

@JasonAStillman

3 жыл бұрын

@@DrBrianKeating Fighters of the good fight. Again bravo!

I would pay to see a WWF style series of debates among intellectuals and thought leaders. Advertise it like the olympics of the minds and that show survivor. I would like it to be US focused. Have a pool of 100 people. Put it together. Man that would be cool. Also would be an awesome idea for Turning Point USA and similar groups with opposing views. In the ARENA!

So when do we get warp-drive?

This was both, fascinating and super emotional. Thanks for your work!

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks Rebel so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/mailing_list.php

Lie groups are interesting and i like the ideas here about that - i remain disappointed that the group of symmetries does not extend to the monster group

Looking forward to the audio book, Galileo dialogue

Eric is the best and funniest ... I love his energy and admire his courage & decency.

Spending time listening to these guys is the best investment you can do. Nothing bad about the others, but Eric Weinstein is out of this world/off the charts.

Fantastic. Listened in full. Subscribed. Thanks!

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Welcome to our Multiverse of minds!

VERY WELL SAID ERIC, IN COMPLIMENTING BRIAN!! (ABOUT 47 MINUTE IN!!)

@1:52:00 where Eric talks about Edward Teller - his memoirs are a a very interesting read - they are kind of like a Penrose triangle - up close in detail every argument he makes about why his did what he did in life makes total logical sense but when you step back, as a whole it looks completely insane.

At 45:00, realize that Eric is saying he is working on an explanation for the emergence of the CKM matrix in his theory. Whether he's just bullshitting, or it's true, that is up to you.

KZread has become an oasis of sanity for me, thanks to podcasts like this. The scary part is that KZread is controlled by people who promote insanity. This can all go away, overnight.

@14:00 Eric my dawg check mate you lite him up lol damn you're too raw! What a intellectual genius!

Both are great. I am not qualified enough to even understand what it is that they are doing but I hope one of them gets proven right.

I am reminded of a recent trip to Italy where I was listening to a couple of Italians speak in their native tongue. As a non-speaker I could appreciate that it was collegial, picking up on all of the social cues, but of course understood none of the actual words. The same is going on here. I would just like to know that since Eric has put up his own theory of everything as a mathematician and not as a physicist , and continuing with the foreign language analogy, perhaps might not be speaking perfect Italian, is there not something lost in translation? Secondly, to what end is Eric pursuing this, given its not his chosen field of study?

Please please please......continue..... These podcast of superhero minds. The dialog created here is inspiration for people's mind to be blown into thirst for knowledge. THANKYOU

I could listen to Eric rip all day.

This was great, thank you. Please do more of these.

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

I will Thanks Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/mailing_list.php

Man. I had always been skeptical of Eric but in the end he has won me over.

@amoff2009

3 жыл бұрын

What made you skeptical of him ? I’m only asking cause I’ve followed his discussions for a long time yet I hear people call him a charlatan and fake and that he doesn’t actually know what he’s talking about but the arguement are weak . I just want a different perspective not to argue

@knight3481

3 жыл бұрын

@@amoff2009 My skepticism just refers to his geometric unity structure for predicting SM+gravity. He does not have credibility in physics as he has PHD in Math and I have looked over his thesis on extension of Yang- Mills solution to higher dimension which involves some ideas directly applied to his Geometric unity theory and as so it is very much like Garrett theory of everything which seems to invoke a single idea to explain the whole SM+ Gravity which so far has not been done by too many brilliant physicists even though with an effort of over 50+ years. So, of course, one would be skeptic.

When are some new Garrett papers coming out?

New subscriber...Just wanted to say this was amazing, thank you.

@DrBrianKeating

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks Joe! So glad to have you aboard. Please join my mailing list; just click here 👉 briankeating.com/mailing_list.php 📝 to get exclusive notes etc !

Eric please let other people speak at all, and be still with your body and your face while they speak. That alone will wash away so much of the hate you get, you would never imagine.

How did you get from QM to politics :)

Brian this was an excellent chat, it's unreal that these guys are considered "outcasts" in the physics community. It's awesome to hear some differing/dissenting voices discussing my favorite subject. Keep going with these amazing chats, subbed for sure!

Wolfram and Weinstein need to collaborate !!!!!!! 100% !!!!!!