"I see you found the mood" such a great line.

@senseishu937

2 ай бұрын

Cause it's from the book 😁

@deadwalking100

2 ай бұрын

@@senseishu937 Indeed👍😎 such a great line and one of many. I read the book about 40 years ago; and was impressed then and enjoyed various iterations of it since on film.

Considering this is an extremely difficult fictional martial art to translate vividly on-screen, I believe they did the best job possible.

@xyaeiounn

2 жыл бұрын

I've been doing martial arts since the 80s, I found the fight-scenes in this movie to be stressful to watch because the characters were introduced well, before being put in danger. Every second of the action meant something to the story. If the assignment was to show how people move, think and act after a life of training deadly techniques, then it was perfectly executed and merged perfectly into the drama of the story.

@robwalsh9843

2 жыл бұрын

It seems that Filipino and similar SE Asian martial arts would be logical real world analogue to the fighting styles of the Dune universe.

@AdrianMartinez-en1nb

2 жыл бұрын

What is the fictional martial arts of dune?

@robwalsh9843

2 жыл бұрын

@@AdrianMartinez-en1nb There are a few different styles. The Bene Gesserit practice a martial art called The Weirding Way, which Paul Ateides is trained in. The Fremen, Sardaukar and Ginnaz swordmasters all have their own fighting systems.

@StockyDude

Жыл бұрын

In another video, DV mentions that this seen used Balintawak Eskrima, a Filipino martial art.

Roger Yuan! HE'S that Atreides Captain! The one who says "Shields" before they step into Arrakis, the one next to Paul at the briefing, and one of the ones who holds a sword at Dr. Keines's neck when she's checking Duke Leto's still suit!

@foolslayer9416

2 жыл бұрын

He was also there when those dozen or so Atreides guards were holding off the Harkonen army. You can hear his voice.

@davecrupel2817

2 жыл бұрын

@@foolslayer9416 I was afraid of that. Didn't mention it in my comment, as I wanted to believe it wasn't him. :C

@foolslayer9416

2 жыл бұрын

@@davecrupel2817 It could've been someone else. Plus, in the novel many of the Atreides soldiers who survived and fled the attack rejoined Paul later on to train the Fremen.

@kwombok

Жыл бұрын

@@foolslayer9416 no... only one.

@Shady36

Жыл бұрын

He was also the guy who yelled "Atreides!" "Ha! Po!" During their last stand against the Harkkonen and subsequent massacre by the Sardukar.

I love and appreciate how the trainer used their real life experiences, like knowledge of sports to help teach.

I like the way they actually considered how shields that can only be penetrated by slow objects would change combat. polearms, meant for big brutal strikes, would be ineffective in this scenario. you need precision strikes, so a shorter blade is better. and there is a lot of grappling involved, it's not something you'd see much in the real world, but with shields slapping away a blade with your hand is a perfectly reasonable move. and they considered all that, and they figured out a fighting style for it. as a result, the combat scenes are great. you see it play out, and you think, if there really was this technology, then this way of fighting makes sense. it's this kind of consistency that makes a worldbuilding feel real

@squamish4244

Жыл бұрын

Herbert really wanted to show a true 'feudal future' in Dune, and coming up with the idea for shields was brilliant. A medieval swordfighting expert on YT (HEMA - historical European martial arts) discussed the film and said that if shields existed, knives would be far better than swords or any other melee combat weapon.

@luigilain5692

Жыл бұрын

@@squamish4244 you referring to shadiversity? I've seen that video

@squamish4244

Жыл бұрын

@@luigilain5692 Yes.

@woodrobin

Жыл бұрын

The personal shields are also the reason that martial arts make a comeback and become important in the Dune universe. "The slow blade penetrates the shield". Projectile weapons are utterly useless against personal shields, so everything from railguns to slings and arrows are off the table. Bludgeoning weapons and fists are also useless, because they rely on a level of transferred kinetic energy the shield won't allow to occur. A directed *energy* weapon, like a laser, will cause the shield to explosively discharge, possibly killing the shielded person (very likely if it's a powerful laser) but also very likely killing the person firing the weapon and converting the shielded person into a rather large bomb. Using an atomic weapon against a shield is an utter horror-show, as the interaction makes local physics do something similar to what intestines do after you eat at Taco Bell. So grappling, cutting blades, and poisons become the primary tools of close combat, and close combat becomes preferable to other forms (you can strafe from the air -- would you rather use lasers and risk blowing your own planes out of the air if they're shielded, or use guns and missiles and risk wasting them if they're shielded? The same applies to artillery.) Subterfuge and sabotage become the most effective siege weapons, and serious combat returns to face to face savage bloodletting channeled by the evolution of high technology.

@mariadelcarmengonzalez-rom6777

3 ай бұрын

​@@woodrobink

Roger Yuan…Roger was like a brother to me. He has really come a long, long, long way. From Shanghai Noon to Crouching Tiger 2, John Wick and Dune 2. Great choreographer - stunt man, and the reason why Tim McGraw looks the way he does.

Roger Yuan also had a nice supporting role in this film which was great. He was also great as a villain against Jackie Chan in Shanghai Noon.

@Metallica4Life92

2 жыл бұрын

I knew I recognised him from somewhere!

@Gunnar-Peterson

3 ай бұрын

He was great in Shanghai Noon and Paper Tigers

the fma technique used to it is "balintawak eskrima". love this technique but deadly. 🔥🇵🇭

@chenalindelossantos967

17 күн бұрын

i swear i heard Balintawak, i had to confirm in this comment section

I rarely watch a movie within 1-2 years of initial viewing, but with Dune I've already watched it three times. Same for Blade Runner 2049 & Sicario when they came out

@mauz791

Жыл бұрын

Classic Villeneuve

@wojtek1582

4 ай бұрын

Similar except Sicario (discovered it some time after release). I have also seen Dune 2 twice already :).

@thexlonewolf671

3 ай бұрын

Arrival is also fantastic. Highly recommend.

still wish they'd used the book quote for mood: "You fight when the necessity arises-no matter the mood! Mood's a thing for cattle or making love or playing the baliset. It's not for fighting.”

@azyjmexcuseokstop924

2 жыл бұрын

Pretty sure they do ?

@dennisduncan7561

2 жыл бұрын

@@azyjmexcuseokstop924 They left out the part about cattle and love making.

@DirByHasan

4 ай бұрын

Too wordy for a Denis Villeneuve script. He and Eric Roth retained the core lines and dialogues but pared it to his minimalist style. Non showy and flashy

@glacier68

4 ай бұрын

For all its flaws, at least Lynch retained it :)

@mollywoodshots6503

4 ай бұрын

That part about cattle isn't needed, it's not necessary. I appreciate they removed it because it would have been cringe to hear in a Villeneuve movie.

The fighting choreography in the movie is one of the best I have seen.

If no one else mentions it, I think Josh Brolin is perfect as Gurney Halleck. His age, his aggressive nature, his underhand style of humour reflects the Gurney of the novel. The fact he ran through this training scene in one shot at the age of 55 is a great reminder of the rigours of fighting and survival in the Imperium. I just wish he was more prominent in the throne room scene in Dune 2 where he catches the attention of the Emperor's Sardauker "Only the Atreides could command the loyalty of Gurney Halleck."

Watching this in theaters, i can fully identify if as kali with just few moves, im so happy they used this beautiful FMA style

The lighting of this scene is just soo beautiful!

One of the best movies ive seen since Nolans The Dark Knight.

One thing the shield does is turn your whole arm into something that can block. They tap and shove more than they would be able to with their bare hand.

You can definitely see the FMA choreography here. It's saturated with it. As well as the realistic applications. Well done Roger Yuan. 🙂

Seeing FMA featured in Dune is a dream come true...

1:19 isnt he the atreides soldier that feyd fought in part 2

@cindyschildgen536

3 ай бұрын

Yes

@spameranne

3 ай бұрын

came here to ask just that! nice to know!!

tbh didnt seem to matter till i clicked this video ive always remembered him for his great stunts that he dose that require lots of strength and planning

The best work I've ever seen on movie screen from boy to the man of his actions

This Training Room scene is so mesmerising and one of the most memorable moments in Part 1. Even after the fight became serious, it resembled a dance of sorts, between the master and the student.

Fantastic movie it was. I watched several times & I was not bored. Everyone was outstanding with their acting, the actions. Waiting for the second part desperately.

What a fantastic scene!!!

Behind-the-scene footages like this one are amazing. They show the human side of the entertainment industry.

I'll tell you one thing. Warner Bros. has created a better adaptation of Dune than the 1984 Universal Pictures version. All thanks to Legendary Entertainment for acquiring rights.

@miltontavares9506

2 жыл бұрын

And Denis Villeneuve s passion and dedication to the project.

@arunrajeev2634

2 жыл бұрын

I love Warner Bros.

@NightShadow720

2 жыл бұрын

@@arunrajeev2634 Same here.

@adrig6920

2 жыл бұрын

@@arunrajeev2634 not to dc

@SmartassX1

2 жыл бұрын

The original has a number of brilliant scenes too. "Bring in that floating fat man. ...The Baron!"

Such a great scene and very much love the fighting style of Dune!

I attended acting classes through Freehold Theatre in WA state. My favorite acting classes were the stage combat courses.

I think I saw Roger Yuan at the arriving scene in Arrakis where he said "Shield."

great scene love it both Josh & Timthoee did great

Give Roger Yuan all the awards! Immediately!

0:05 the BGM makes the beginning perfectly

Apparently, was supposed to be intercut with shots of Jessica training Paul in knife use. Hopefully we'll get to see that one day.

@michaelsnyder3871

2 жыл бұрын

What Jessica was training Paul in, was the Bene Gesserit form of close combat where the control of the body's functions can be used to increase the speed and training in situational awareness allows the combatant to "sense" the intentions of his opponent. This on top of Guerney's and Duncan's training made Paul the most deadly 15 year old in the Imperium.

@_Chipster

Жыл бұрын

Which is Villanuvue's version of the "weirding way" further emphasizing the Bene Gesserit training he's received.

Probably my favorite scene.

They did awesome. It looks and feels real.

Does anyone else admire the mentors shiny head? He could be a model

GREAT VIDEO

Fight choreography is making a dance look like a fight.

Love this videos♥️💖💙

Amazing job with the choreography and how they translated it beautifully to the screen. I do wonder why we don't see spears in the Dune universe though. I would assume spears would be way more effective...not that I'm complaining...this movie is legendary.

@winther2609

Жыл бұрын

because the slow blade pierces the shield, and a slow spear is just a stick to grab, while a shorter blade is more unpredictable

@TheNEOverse

3 ай бұрын

Tbf, you see some Atriedes soldiers fight Harkonnen invaders with spears in a phalanx. Its just too bad that the Sardukar then came along.

Пожалуйста не удаляйте Звёздного капитана!

the look of this scene is so "Bed Bath & Beyond" lol :)

Congratulations on winning the award!!

@freehandluke

2 жыл бұрын

@@dariussalepetru6770 nailed it

Пожалуйста не удаляйте Звёздного капитана

I really hope we get more one on one shield fights in part 2

@wallrider73

2 жыл бұрын

There's a scene in the book which introduces Feyd Rautha in a gladiator match on Giedi Prime. Roger Yuan's character, Lt Lanville is supposedly the captured Atreides soldier that Feyd fights so hopefully we'll see that.

Wow, that's so cool.

"Mood? Mood is a thing for love play and cattle not fighting!" Gurney Halleck

"DO YOU YIELD?!?!"

*"He shall know your ways as though born to them..."*

There is some longer fight scene that did not get filmed here. I want my four hour cut of Dune part 1.

So cool....

I wonder if anyone else noticed the importance of showing the elder breathing deeply while the younger wasn't. At the end of any training, if you're out of breath you'll need to do more exercises involving breathing. Go see this sequence again, you'll notice it now.

Fencing is a martial art. It's a matter of gaining time, which is achieved via space. Time is what matters. Space is only the means to gaining time.

@Wavemaninawe

2 жыл бұрын

Indeed. And kali (generally) is a type of fencing, among other things. But Villenueve is likely not a martial artist. So he probably wont think of the nuances in that field.

@StockyDude

Жыл бұрын

In another video, DV mentions that Yuan used the Filipino martial art Eskrima for this scene, specifically Balintawak Eskrima. Eskrima comes from the Spanish “escrima” - the word for fencing. The various Filipino Eskrima schools developed out of a mixture of the Filipino martial art Kali with Spanish fencing techniques.

@Wavemaninawe

Жыл бұрын

@@StockyDude The names of Arnis De Mano, Eskrima, and Kali, are umbrella terms though. With the name of any particular school having more to do with geography, than techniques/styles.

@StockyDude

Жыл бұрын

@@Wavemaninawe True. Balintawak is a place, and the Doce Pares school of Arnis popularized the art in Metro Manila.

The fight choreographer is also in Dune 2!

Love this movie♥️💖💙💚 Look for see second movie of Dune part two when is come out in theater again💖💖

Big fan of dude I love all the three main characters that I know

A kris knife is a khanjar. They should have modeled it so. Liet was cheney’s father not her aunt (fairly important to the story). Other than that I’m really loving this adaptation. Five thumbs and two stars way up.

I thought I recognised the fighting!

Oh yes, the sword fighting choreography is on par if not better to duel of fates

Be reasonable people, the captain is better than what was and is on KZread! No one has such an analysis of love, motivation, and presentation. Its level is higher than that of some cinematographers and directors

I hope we see a lot of sword fighting in part 2.

What a fantastic seen!

Будьте разумными людьми, Капитан это лучшее, что было и есть на Ютубе! Такого анализа и любви, и мотивации, и подачи нет ни у кого. Его уровень выше, чем у некоторых киниматографоф и режиссёров.!!!

>>>>>> #SO MUCH INCREÍBLE EXCELLENT WORK>>>>>>>>

진짜 넘 멋있어 😍

Wow

Be reasonable people, Captain, this is the best thing that was and is on KZread! No one has such an analysis of love, motivation, and submission. His level is higher than that of some cinematographers and directors.

imagine your weaponsmaster being thanos

I do want some serious prana bindu movies in part 2.

I doubt Josh clicked much along the way, hes pretty fit for his age.

Pfffff, epic

How come the shield let’s slow movement through? Wouldn’t just be better to block everything?

@MrSaphen

Жыл бұрын

some material get really hard if you shock it with kinetic energy but if you do it slowly it behaves like thick water. Maybe it's the same for thich technology?

@kennichdendenn

Жыл бұрын

Getting air through or touching any objections (even opening a door) would be impossible then.

@jodo2785

Жыл бұрын

@@kennichdendenn yeah the whole shield combat system is really dumb in the movie, everyone should have guns it worked a little better in the books, unless you spent 2 seconds thinking about it

roger yuan is in part 2

Ooooo and this is how he kills feyd!!!!!

Roger is a gorgeous man.

It's a long road from Goonies but you made it.

@TatteredToys

2 жыл бұрын

We need a goonies sequel, red dawn with aliens situation. Its our time. Our time up here. Middle management saves the town.

Свободу Звездному Капитану!

It's excellently done in this "duel" because they followed the rule that only a slow blade penetrates the shield, it's jus a shame when Duncan is hacking and slashing through Sardaukar later in the film they completely disregard it

@sathwikmatcha5511

Жыл бұрын

I think they don't use the shields in the desert because it makes the sandworms go in a frenzy

@aaron4820

4 ай бұрын

​@@sathwikmatcha5511oh so that's why they don't use it, in the second movie at some point someone was asked not to use the shield but they never explained why. I thought it was because they were out in the open and someone from far away could have lasered them (which apparently causes huge explosions)

How did Duncan Idaho wipe out so many guys who were shielded? In short order.

Why didn’t you experts use the weirding way of fighting in the film? That is the one concept that I really missed.

Будьте разумными людьми не удаляйте канал капитана канал капитана это лучшее что было есть на Ютюбе столько любви Харизма и других вещей его уровень выше чем в некоторых фильмах

😎👍

The stund double of Timothée have his perfect body type ! Can we meet him ^^ ?

Звездный капитан

Who does Gurney trust to zip up his shirt from behind?

I'm still not in the mood!

What I dont get on this movie is that we are so advanced far in the future but they still fight with swords?

@ANonymous-mo6xp

Жыл бұрын

The shields make bullets useless, and shooting lasguns at them cause feedback explosions at the shield and the gun.

@jodo2785

Жыл бұрын

@@ANonymous-mo6xp literally a bullet penetrates a shield in the movie and when entire cities can be destroyed in seconds with one warship . . . no one should be wasting time and manpower on ground troops with melee weapons

@cindyschildgen536

3 ай бұрын

😂

Timothée Chalamet looks like our chief accountant. A very attractive woman.

AYTИCTЫ, ХВАТИТ СПАМИТЬ ПОД РОЛИКАМИ УОРНЕРОВ, ВЫ ДЕЛАЕТЕ КАПИТАНУ ХУЖЕ, ВЕДЬ ОН ПРОСИЛ НЕ СПАМИТЬ ПОД ИХ РОЛИКАМИ

Пожалуйста оставьте в покое Кепа, разбираетесь с начала с тем говном который вы творите с другими звёздами потом лезьте к нам

They changed the original line. Mood is for cattle and love making!!

Sign no lies 3truth fair trade classic commerce no theft hook ai intelligence 911

Wow....is this cool or what???

the fighting was fine but the lines were the worst in the training scene

So many betas

Пожалуйста не удаляйте Звёздного капитана

Пожалуйста не удаляйте Звёздного капитана!

Thanos is consistent in his training, All his students go for the head.

Пожалуйста не удаляйте Звёздного капитана

Пожалуйста не удаляйте Звёздного капитана