Buy me a coffe: www.buymeacoffee.com/dsaudio.review Instagram - instagram.com/digitalstereophony/ Facebook - facebook.com/DigitalStereophony/

@Amateur2k

Жыл бұрын

Instead of 1000 words, the best review is an AB test! Congrats, you got it.

Very close sound and response for lows and highs! I like the sound of the R2850db slightly more. Vocals and mids are more detailed and it just makes the overall sound nicer to my ears.

Yamaha definitely sounds closer to the source, but the Edifiers sound much more pleasant to my ears with deep bass and the nice gentle scoop. I'd take the Yammys for studio monitors and the Eddies for listening speakers. That's a tie.

@Gevoltful

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly as I wanted to say , and r2850 are for wider room , here recorded from the same distance :)

@alejolopezmarioabel887

Жыл бұрын

JBL Soundbar 5.1 vs edifer r2850db , cuál me recomiendas 😭

@jorgenavas6704

3 ай бұрын

Edifier r2850 o Edifier S1000mkii

@mokarramhossain7657

2 ай бұрын

Nicely explained

@sergiomunoz6825

24 күн бұрын

Yo tengo los Edifier y suenan super bien tanto en bajos como en medios y agudos 🤗👌

The difference in speakers these days is much more subtle than it was years ago, no speakers sound bad anymore, just slightly different. It’s like the difference between cream or custard on your apple pie, the apple pie is the important part, the sauce is just a matter of taste. Both are very tasty, just depends what mood you are in.

@streamsfromelectronicmusic5059

2 жыл бұрын

Well said mate. I had never heard it explained that way before. Yeah, just something about reading your message made me have that 'aha' moment... thanks. Have a great day!

@fractera

4 ай бұрын

This is only true if you're paying more than $200.

HS8 sound so close to the source. Great studio monitors. R2850DB add a bit of colour. Great general speakers.

`man on fire` really highlights the advantages of 3 way. relaxed and engaging

Instead of 1000 words, the best review is an AB test! Congrats, you got it.

СПАСИБО за долгожданное сравнение!

Edifier sounds punchy like HIFI speakers should. The Yamaha's are flat which is exactly what they're supposed to be as studio monitors. They're both good in the roles they were meant for. Obviously were I a content creator or wanted the most accurate representation of what I'm listening to I'd take the Yamaha's but for someone who isn't an enthusiast the Edifiers are perfectly fine. There's of course also a cost element. A single one of the Yamaha's costs more than a pair of the Edifiers.

@kckoh1102

Жыл бұрын

Agree

Edifier's 3-way makes all the difference. Plus it has more bass extension.

thanks for the comparison, more r2850DB vs (popular speakers) please

More instrument detail on the edifiers but the Yamaha’s 2-way setup is no joke

Not bad r2850.. worth for money.. thanks for this video..goodjob

Edifier would be good enough for my PC gaming and melodic metal songs.🤘

HS8 being 2way does perform as 3 way speakers. Very impressive.

Tengo los Edifier 2850 ,la mejor compra,lo que escuche aqui no tiene comparacion para mi gusto ,son muy muy buenos los 2850.

@HorizonMusic84

Жыл бұрын

Exacto , el Yamaha HS8 se escucha como si estuviera adentro de un tubo

@elpenquistalg

Жыл бұрын

Sonido enlatado dan los yamaha, los edifier mucho más claro el sonido

Edifier clearly sounds amazing but Yamaha for a 2-way setup is impressive

With the edifier you can def tell on those two crossover peaks. The sub bass is hollow compared to HS8. I’d say the technical performance is better on eddi but tuning and integration are better in HS8. Jazz con cajon is the song you can hear the greatest separation in tuning.

I have the 2850 for about a week now. It's a very engaging speaker thanks to it's midrange. It's an experience I never heard before despite my old Pioneers also being 3-way with 8 inch woofers. They are physically big but do sound absolutely huge. Downsides are they can be a little bright even with treble all the way down (to my taste, I do like warmth) and bass so strong it can draw attention to itself. Bass extention on paper is not super deep (No real output below 30 Hz) but they give the experience of being full range which is interesting. I wish the input light on the front could be dimmed without ducttape. Highly recommend if you have a room big enough and if a 2.0 setup is enough this is also the home theater speaker to get.

@dsavoy66

2 жыл бұрын

RustOnTime , could you please measure and tell me the width of the speaker? I suspect that on the Edifier Argentina website they have the width and depth data backwards. I want to know if they will fit in a desk. Thanks a lot

@RustOnTime

2 жыл бұрын

@@dsavoy66 I measure 25,7 cm wide and roughly 30 cm deep, with probably another 10 cm minimum for cables at the back

@dsavoy66

2 жыл бұрын

@@RustOnTime ,Thanks for measuring it! It is as I thought since it is seen in the images that it is deeper than wide, with your information I confirm that it fits in my desk with a 27' monitor and I can buy it. If I were guided by what Edifier informed me, they are approx. 10cm more and not everything would fit 👍

Should I get these or the Klipsch Fives for my vinyl set up?

Do you have a video on the presonus r80 v2? Vs Kali in8 v2?

They sound very similar but given the fact that you can put multiple sources into the edifier its hands down the winner. I wont do anything but opticle from my computer and the lack of that on the yamaha is a no go for me. Sound wise they are so similar I don't know which I prefer. I can hear a difference but I can't say which I like more.

how would the R2850db compare to the S3000pros?

Fingers crossed for HS8 vs the new Focal Alpha Evo 80

Frankly, in terms of sound quality, they're not too different and one can be happy with either. The R2850 seems to have slightly more sparkle at the cost of slightly less sub bass compared to the HS8, but overall, both deliver clear and pretty accurate sound. Both would need really good subs (i.e. clean and powerful output to at least just below 20Hz) with excellent lowpass filters to properly fill out the sub bass they lack. Both would do great with PEQ without very aggressive, potentially problematic settings.

*Please Edifier R2850DB vs Klipch R-51 which is better?*

what does everyone think of the R2850DB's used as TV speakers for movies etc ? with the t5 subwoofer ?...thx...cheers from Canada

Some songs sound better on R2850DB. HS8 is possibly better for monitoring because of mids. Any chance of doing ESI unik 8+ vs Yamaha HS8?

Which is better for subwoofers

Tras escuchar el video con auriculares circumaurales me parece que los yahama colorean los medios aportando más realce a esa franja y debido a eso mismo los bajos son más tenues que es casi lo que siempre pasa cuando se usan dos vías. con los agudos ahí están y se les nota. En cuanto a los Edifier suenan perfectos. Es como si los hubieran afinado, que parece que si, para que sean lo más cercano a lo grabado. No se lo saben..... pero tras mirar un poco por internet veo que tiene 3 amplificadores estéreo dentro. Uno para cada driver; uno para cada tweeter, otros para cada uno de los medios y otros para cada uno de los bajos. Vale cada € que cuesta. Y el precio es lo mejor. Saludos.

@vvilches1312

8 ай бұрын

Claramente, para escucha activa se sienten mejor los Edifier. Para grabación y edición, están los Yamaha con sonido más plano. Como dice el dicho, en cuestión de gustos no hay nada escrito y además, las experiencias son siempre subjetivas y personales. Saludos!

Hi, I love your videos, but is there any chance you could give your opinion also, even just in a small comment. It would really help, especially for those of us not too familiar with good quality audio.

Yamaha Hs8 of course, more detailed mids ,edifiers are a bit muddy in the mid.listening through my hs7 with a presonus sub.

Parabéns pelo vídeo. Deu para diferenciá-las bem na última faixa de música, onde as características de reverb ficaram bem mais presentes na Yamaha. A Edifier sumiu. Parecia dois ambientes diferentes. Se tivesse faixas musicais com orquestra, corais ou instrumentos que emitem uma espectro de frequências mais abrangentes, a diferença iria ser mais gritante entre as duas caixas. Nas outras faixas do vídeo, os resultados ficaram parecidos. A Yamaha, na maioria das vezes, mostrou mais sons do que a Edifier. A Edifier tem mais graves profundos e agudos (acima de 6,3k) e só. Mas as duas caixas são ótimas escolhas. Minha escolha ideal seria Yamaha por mostrar sons onde a Edifier não mostra. Mas a da Edifier é muito boa também.

Just got a set of R2850DB's for the price less than a single HS8. For me the this and the connectivity (optical & BT) of R2850DB's is a no-brainer deal. The Yamaha's sound pure, while Edifiers sound richer.

@hotdog9262

Жыл бұрын

can`t really find them, and especially not at that price. good buy

I love the Edifier.

2850 is better.

Edifier - hands down

The mids on the yamaha are incredible. They are on another league from the edifiers. Still, the edifiers cost like 1/4 of the yamaha so it's not really a fair comparison. I think the edifiers must sound amazing irl, but maybe the yamahas are better for professional use. I mean they are so simmilar to the source!

@PaulSebastianM

2 жыл бұрын

I beg to differ. The mids are clearer on the Edifier and muddier on the Yamaha. The lows are better on the Yamaha but unfortunately, they stand sort of alone compared to the Edifier because the mids help it put out a richer more encompassing sound. Overall I think the Yamaha's are too flat for my taste, made more for mixing and sound editing, while the Edifiers are what you would normally use to enjoy music.

@hanzen5174

2 жыл бұрын

@@PaulSebastianM "The mids are clearer on the Edifier and muddier on the Yamaha" had the opposite opinion until I read your post and listened to the `return to the wild` track. well spotted

@hanzen5174

2 жыл бұрын

the sound overall though is more detailed and `correct` in the hs8. have the 2750 and are happy with em, ended up plugging the ports for what was for me..less but better/tighter bass and an overall more balanced sound. cabinet improvements is next

Edifier R2850DB - 9.6 vs Yamaha HS8 - 9.8

EDFIRE 💥💥💥💥💥💥❤

Hs8+hs8s sounds so pure, so heavenly. The range, the resolution, unbeatable in it's price range. R2850db is also a great pair of speakers, I would say it's the most bang for the buck in 500cad$ range as well. Also I would recommend s2000mk3 for the best 700cad$ speaker and s3000pro for the best 1000cad$ speaker 😂

Edifier has deeper bass specially bassdrum, kick....Yamaha has brighter mid frequencies....i assume edifier is good for electronic music and pop music in general....and its almost 1/2 price

Would a dedicate dac like topping d10s improve s2850 sound quality? Im using it with my iphone through 3.5 to lightning btw

@back_to_life0

2 жыл бұрын

нет. Включил по оптике с телике и все, это их предел. Хотя если ты больной то можешь за штуку баксов купить цап и подключить от него) лучше должно быть конечно за оптику.

@-MarkWinston-

2 жыл бұрын

100%. Any 100 dollar DAC will greatly improve this speaker, especially in soundstaging and imaging. HUGE difference, you will start hearing sounds that are coming from outside the speaker. Try a good cheap dac like the SMSL Sanskrit MKII.

@krzysiekbs

2 жыл бұрын

Connect them to any digital signal - toslink/coax and they will play full of potential wtih losless sources! :)

@virtualoftheday

2 жыл бұрын

No, this device include A2D converter after analogue input, then digital signal goes to DSP and crossover. That's cheap converter in a cheap device, so better avoid it and use digital input

Еще нужно проверить, 2850 с сабом и какието коллонки с сабом, ведь при включении саба через саб аут 2850 режутся на низких, улучается низ до 70 герц , средина, колонки больше не упарываются в нижний бас который они ре способны выдать изза чего улучшается общий звук + именно саб начинает отвечать за нижний бас

@dmitriikolbeshkin3996

2 жыл бұрын

А если 2850 подключить по оптике (чтобы избежать двойного преобразования ЦАП-АЦП), не станет ли лучше? Что-то не нашёл в описании какой ЦАП использовали в этом видео.

@back_to_life0

2 жыл бұрын

@@dmitriikolbeshkin3996 на личные ощущения, что с оптики тв, что с реалтека 887 аналог, звук один и тот же.единственное по оптике громче

Very interesting. As an R2750DB owner, i was hoping the R2850DB would have extra oomph below 40Hz, but the graph does'nt reveal this. How do they compare in person? Does the bass adjuster bloat the 65Hz+ region up too high? Or does it nicley increase the 40Hz and below with out becoming too muddy?

@DSAUDIOreview

2 жыл бұрын

R850DB has more rounded and deeper bass response in person plus they sound smoother and more natural in the mid/high region. Tone controls work the same on both models

@finnba_h

2 жыл бұрын

@@DSAUDIOreview wow that's awesome to hear (pun intended). Thanks again for making this video. Hoping the r2850db's are available soon in Australia. Absolutely love the r2750db's. Price to performance is incredible.

@JoshyLats

2 жыл бұрын

@@DSAUDIOreview weird that the same mid and tweeter sounds smoother on r2850db, could it be because it is newer and not as worn in as the r2750db?

@DSAUDIOreview

2 жыл бұрын

@JoshyLats better resolved crossover points maybe? Both were quite fresh during recording with similar burn in times, as this is not the same R2750DB I had on the channel some time ago

@back_to_life0

2 жыл бұрын

@@JoshyLats у 2850 как бы сч динамик другой, ЖЕСТКИЙ! и с включение саба благодаря правильному фильту низких на колонках ,средние еще лучше стают!! 2750 вообще смысла не имеют... 2750 уже должны обновить давно!

Is there a way to extend the speaker cable r2850DB? How long is the one that it comes with?.. thanks for anybody's response!!!😉

@Sleepingsun40

7 ай бұрын

No for the first question. 4 meters long.

El Edifier suena mejor en todos los escenarios y cuesta la mitad . Este Yamaha está sobrevalorado .

I have a R2800. It seems to me that these E. have reached HS8 and even better in many points. Most importantly: if there is a difference in sound, then it is already within the taste range here. Yamahas are overrated.

Focal Alpha 65 EVO vs Edifier R2850DB

i totally dislike monitor sound even in context of music production. edifier sounds cool, yamaha sounds like something in mids need to be fixed in every mix

Is it wise to pair these speakers with a DAC?

@jorgenavas6704

3 ай бұрын

Ifi zen dac V2

i must say the 2800 and 2700 can go lower and give much more bass than these videos suggest. remember they are set flat. just spin the bass knob to your taste... same with treble

I have Adam audio T5V want Edifier but think hs8 now

HS8 looks better to me. Too bad it is not versatile in terms of connection

@back_to_life0

2 жыл бұрын

только вот ямаха стоит в 2 раза дороже и играть они будут лучше только тогда когда еще в пол цены ямах подключить источник., а не включать через переходник от реалтека

У меня стоят 2850Дб - качество отличное. Да и по видео слышно, эдики лучше звук.

Any chance of getting the Presonus R65 V2's against the usual suspects?

@DSAUDIOreview

2 жыл бұрын

I have my eyes on them but I do not know when I will be able to test them

@MonstaAU

2 жыл бұрын

@@DSAUDIOreview I have seen some complaints regarding a hole in response in the upper mids, yet others are singing their praises so your comparison would put that discussion to rest. Hopefully PreSonus will arrange a pair for you to test after the Eris E7 XT's did so well. Edit: also the Edifier MR4's - cheap and cheerful but not without some serious faults.

Edifire r2850db +

2850 tienen una salida para sub woofer

In the first track, Yamaha won, but in the next competition, they could not keep this victory.

Hi guys, I need help. I have visited several sound stores and asked about the Edififer R2850. I have been told that Edifier in general does not provide good sound and this has come to my attention because of the very good comments I have heard on this channel. In my country, Argentina, there is not a single store that has Edifier equipment, except for the official store which, unfortunately, does not have a showroom and they only sell their products online. In other words, I would have to buy it without having heard it. Could you help me decide? Do you think I should "risk" buying it? I have been told that Edifier is not hifi and provides sound far below any hifi stereo system. Is that true? Does this Edififer model worth it? Are there maybe some better options for the same price? Thank you and please excuse me for my bad English.

У ямах середина выпячивает, у эдиков нет, поэтому эдиф приятнее звучит.

скиньте ПОЖАЛУЙСТА Cсылку на второй трек man of fire

R2850DB Why is the left speaker on the right and the right speaker on the left?

@DSAUDIOreview

2 жыл бұрын

So you can ask about it 20 times

@XPEH

2 жыл бұрын

@@DSAUDIOreview This is not an answer. I asked a simple question.

@DSAUDIOreview

2 жыл бұрын

The answer is: because that is how I have set them up

Compare r2850 with something more expensive

HS8 has more detail.

Yamaha

почему упущена важная деталь, что ямахи играют адекватно только с 300-500баксовым цапом, на то они и мониторы, что им очень важен источник я бы даже сказал, что ЦАП это неотъемлемая деталь студийных мониторов.

Ямаха ✌️

edifier !!!

яхмаха лучше звучит и намного.

ascoltati con cuffie air pods max le ediefer gli danno la merda ❤️ Top Ediefer

First song the Yammi were better, then heavy rock sounded not so good on them

edifier e melhor

Yamaha overatted both sound harsh

Yamaha wins.

Jazz is better for Yamaha ?