Quake weapons sound design is wayyy better.

@illyay1337

Ай бұрын

Wish Trent Reznor ended up making the sounds after all. Would’ve been legendary. Though I do like a lot of the doom 3 sounds, especially the BFG 9000. The plasma gun and rocket launcher sound very beefy too.

I love how Quake 4 takes inspiration from Doom 3s plasma gun reloading sound

@doomwinterxglitchgamer

4 күн бұрын

same sound also used in brutal doom

Doom 3 handgun: It can hold up to 12 ammo each. Quake IV handgun: It does nothing but to have infinite ammo.

Good video. I prefer Quake 4 sound. It's just so clear.

Nothing beats Doom 3's legendary Plasma Gun

I always thought the doom marine could use a good pair of fingerless gloves

@bl4ke282

Жыл бұрын

Is there any mod?

Both games are amazing

Its a draw because two are better

@TheDoomMarine975

11 ай бұрын

Nuh uh

Doom 3 BFG/Dark matter gun: Has 28 ammo. Primary fire: Can kill cyberdemons and explode. Secondary fire: Can explode like a bomb & by firing in a charge. Quake IV dark matter gun/BFG: Has decreasingly 25 ammo. It contains nuclear darkness matter which cause them to explode into crusaders.

Doom 3 machinegun: Can hold up to 60 ammo and is in differently shape. It also has a scope beneath it. Quake IV machinegun: Can hold up to 40 ammo and is in differently shape. It also has a scope beneath it.

Doom 3 rocket launcher: Has 5 rockets of ammo and explodes in a tremor way after firing. Quake IV rocket launcher: Has increasingly 40 rockets of ammo and explodes normally after firing.

Doom 3 shotgun: Holds up to 8 ammo.(Same as Quake IV shotgun) Quake IV shotgun: Holds up to 8 ammo.(Same as Doom 3 shotgun)

Doom 3 vulcan: Can prematurely hold up to 60 ammo. Similar to machinegun. Quake IV nailgun: Fires nails and holds up to 50 ammo. Different to machinegun.

Doom 3 hand grenade: Can have 50 ammo. Also, it can throw down to take down demons. Quake IV grenade launcher: It has 8 ammo inside it. It can be used to take down monsters/Stroggs.

Doom 3 plasmagun/Hyperblaster: Has 50 ammo and does this to machinegun. Quake IV hyperblaster/plasmagun: Has 60 increased ammo and does this to machinegun too.

Doom 3 emphasizes more realism while quake 4 goes for an arcade feeling. Like gta 4 / 5 comparison.

@irrelevant9023

2 жыл бұрын

Doom 3 realistic... Yea right...

how did you make the camera look so far away you can see even the handles of the weapons? thanks for reply

@grunerd

2 жыл бұрын

increase fov. In console set g_fov way beyond 90

@davolthe1261

2 жыл бұрын

In Doom 3 BFG you need to first activate the console via steam or shortcut exe(there are plenty of guides on internet for that) while in original Doom 3 you don't have to, then open console and type: set g_fov "put number here", i personally use this setting: set g_fov 110 for Doom 3

Is this BFG doom 3? It has nerfed lightning and gun sounds.

Quake 4 is better than Doom 3

What view model fov and video fov do you use?

@beanieman3461

Жыл бұрын

Never mind I think I figured out the fov for Quake 4 he's using. Try g_fov 120

Plz doom 2 vs quake 2

@TheDoomMarine975

11 ай бұрын

That's kinda unfair, don't you think?

Quake 4 is better tho

0:00 6/10 not bad for a pistol 0:08 7/10 sounds pretty good 0:16 2/10 has to be the worst sounding shotgun 0:33 9/10 DAYUM 0:48 2/10 just underwhelming 0:58 7/10 I like it 1:09 6/10 not bad 1:20 5/10 I don't like it that much 1:34 5/10 eh. 1:39 6/10 pretty good 1:46 5/10 I don't like it. 1:56 7/10 nice 2:05 4/10 underwhelming 2:13 6/10 it's alright 2:22 8/10 Brutal doom BFG 👍 2:36 6/10 not bad

@-.MICHAEL.-

9 ай бұрын

Although the shotgun has a very quiet fire sound in Doom 3 (which gets better with EAX), it still has the best reloading sounds in the gaming industry. I've never heard such a juicy clang anywhere else.

@TheDoomMarine975

9 ай бұрын

@@-.MICHAEL.- nah, I still like the quake 4 shotgun better

@hoppinggnomethe4154

7 ай бұрын

Do you have any idea that Brutal Doom uses the sound effects from Doom 3? "Brutal Doom BFG" is fuckin' dumb.

@cryomnia9485

6 ай бұрын

You're fucking high

Could you at least turn off the background noises

More fov please 🤦‍♂

That FOV looks atrocious.

Both are similar but I prefer doom3, it has more identity, the graphic engine was made for it and you can really see that it suit perfectly with doom3 weapons and game style. Quake 4 is below its prequels and I am a quake fan also.

@verendale1789

3 жыл бұрын

Visually its a toss up, sound design wise quake guns tend to sound wayy better. Especially stuff like machinegun or shotgun or the hyperblaster. Doom 3 variants sound like weak pea shooters.

@mattonthemoon225

3 жыл бұрын

​@@verendale1789 Yes, it could be. But after all a game is not only sound or only graphics. It's a mixed of design, story and self-satisfaction. Personally I remember better Doom3 for its survival horror style (and its much different approach) than Quake4 while I still prefer Quake 2 overall :-)

@Maxxwell-07

2 жыл бұрын

@@mattonthemoon225 This is a sound comparison though. So your whole argument is invalid. The sounds of Quake 4 are literally better.

@mattonthemoon225

2 жыл бұрын

@@Maxxwell-07 I thought this video was a weapons overall comparison, not only limited to sounds. Ok...

@goulakh555

2 жыл бұрын

@@mattonthemoon225 I didn't undrestand your reasons for doom 3 weapons are better!!

Quake 4 is an imitation of Doom 3. Weapons are very similar. Doom 3 is better of course.

@dannyboi5887

Ай бұрын

"Imitation of Doom 3" Wtf does that even mean? It was made on the exact same engine, its development was supervised by ID and its gameplay is vastly different. How the fuck can it be an imitation? Also you're actually insane if you think Doom 3's weapons sound better than Q4's. Most of D3's weapons sound like peashooters while Q4's guns actually sound and feel like fucking GUNS.

@jameszack7158

Ай бұрын

@@dannyboi5887 weapons are same