Nothing screams "Safe and secure platform" like "You're not allowed to take us to court if something goes terribly wrong"

@dakingofcubes

16 күн бұрын

agreed

@TakashiGolbach

16 күн бұрын

yyep.

@goofyahdemoman1134

16 күн бұрын

Most platforms have a forced arbitration policy.

@TakashiGolbach

16 күн бұрын

@@goofyahdemoman1134 'cause they dont wanna get sued and make themselves immune

@Will-en6zj

15 күн бұрын

@@goofyahdemoman1134And most platforms aren't safe and secure. Welcome to the 21st century

Roblox did this before, and a 10 year old took 10 million away. History is repeating itself.

@checkcats_short

16 күн бұрын

Yeah. But discord is worse because there’s a lot of disgusting stuff and in general a wasteland.

@1eris.

16 күн бұрын

roblox is litterary the same thing. ITS DISGUSTING. the tactics they do to get money from you are worst then discord using nitro and acessories to make you spent money really​@checkcats_short

@Boypogikami132

16 күн бұрын

@@frogtopg So is Roblox, your point?

@Morello.

16 күн бұрын

Yeah

@Nightleaky

16 күн бұрын

real.

Fun fact. The terms of service are like "house rules" if you break them you're expelled from the club, but have no legal weight or relevance. If you want to class action sue them the ToS have no legal weight or value. You can't sign away your rights. The companies want you to believe so but they can't take them from you.

@tsm688

11 күн бұрын

that used to be true. everything legally is slowly balancing the other way in the USA however. Recent precedent does not look good.

@magicball3201

11 күн бұрын

I would agree with you. Buuuuuuuuut, Discord has a cool 1 mil to slide the judge to create precedent that says actually their ToS is legally binding, and I don't have a counter argument to that beyond hope the courts aren't corrupt.

@Pequod-yv1iv

11 күн бұрын

@@magicball3201 That's why you don't sue them individually, you do a class action law suit. Apes strong together.

@geekzombie8795

11 күн бұрын

yes

@failegion7828

10 күн бұрын

@magicball3201 Nah too traceable. Judge sees more in a safer manner by going golfing with lawyers. Whom tend to have an interest to dunk on corps due to their fat wallets. Once class actions start up as well usually cheaper to just settle.

My work tried this. They said "Sign this document and we'll add $200 to your next paycheck." Everyone in my department signed it except me. I read it and it was basically signing away your rights to sue. I said "Nope, not going to happen." They told me I had to or I could be fired. I said "great" and I went to a lawyer. They stopped dead in their tracks and backtracked everything, and nobody got paid their $200 either. But... I unfortunately never got fired or got to take them to court. That was going to be fun.

@lev7509

5 күн бұрын

wow, they just pissed their pants instantly

@Keaton42

4 күн бұрын

"sign it now or get fired!!" "don't care" "w-WAIT yOU CaN'T DO ThAT!"

@romasissues

3 күн бұрын

"sign it" "i like my rights" "you wanna get fired bitch??" "I'll take you to court" "..okay i didn't expe- WAIT, W.. OKAY FINE NEVERMIND NEVERMIIND"

mm Discord's legal team must be just thrilled with a sudden flood of opt out emails

@schwingedeshaehers

16 күн бұрын

probably it is mostly automatic

@marekvojta9648

16 күн бұрын

and imagine if for some reason user who aren't from USA started sending those emails in masses too

@shadymedic

16 күн бұрын

Maybe they'll go and tell the developer team "Hey we don't have time to deal with all of this. Just add a button into the account settings that will automatize the opt-out process." And then, we'll just need to click a button instead of sending an e-mail.

@schwingedeshaehers

16 күн бұрын

@@shadymedic they will probably automatically parse the incoming mail, look if the id matches the mail, and then mark it in the account/database

@why1t

16 күн бұрын

hey name, fancy encountering you here :D

As an australian i'd love to sue discord on someone elses behalf

@megalodonsniperelite

16 күн бұрын

A great counter to US arbitration.

@NoxiusVI

16 күн бұрын

As a non US resident, I too would love to sue discord on someone elses behalf.

@shadowforge

16 күн бұрын

you didn't even bother watching the video did you?

@tonelemoan

16 күн бұрын

Karl Jobst is that you? :)

@officialhawkimport9824

16 күн бұрын

need more ppl like this

If they actually do something worth suing, they might end up doing what other large companies like Amazon have done, and quickly retract their arbitration clause. Basically, a lawfirm realized that you can automate 99% of the work required to submit arbitration claims for common issues, and flood companies with thousands of arbitration requests, completely crippling the entire arbitration system, and costing the companies millions in mandatory arbitration fees they promised to pay as part of the arbitration agreement. It's devious, and one of the best ways to fight back against what is a parallel and nonfunctional legal system in the US. When Amazon tried to find some excuse to get out of the arbitration clause they forced people to sign, the judge said "lol nope". I expect that if there's a real problem, it'll end up getting resolved one way or another. We've got a surprising amount of ways to fight back against illegal actions from companies.

@rashidisw

11 күн бұрын

I think Patreon doing the similar when they unilaterally terminate a comedian's account just because those within Patreon's Trust & Safety council did not like his jokes. Doing that however pissing off many of his patrons fans instead, one of them find out that they only need to pay nominal fee and Patreon are required to pay the rest of Arbitration filing fee. Many of his fans learn about it and follow suit. Patreon reaction after that was hilarious.

@TheNatos

11 күн бұрын

@@rashidisw fuck around and find out xD

@szadun

11 күн бұрын

The comedian was Owen Benjamin, and the whole saga is _hilarious_

@analogsamurai9576

10 күн бұрын

No online contract is genuinely binding when it comes down to it in court because it is just a puppet dancing on a screen, just because it forms the words arbitration or your xyz rights doesn't mean it has any legal value because it isn't technically real, even your signature on a document is not enforceable at the end of the day because it could not be your signature, all these "terms of use" are nonsense garbage

@basebutter

10 күн бұрын

In America, corporations are people. They have rights too, and they are more important than yours

Corpos have been doing this "you agree not to sue us" crap for decades. Courts throw this out in a breath. Contracts do not supersede law.

i dont understand how thats legally alowed TOS: "ur not allowed to sue me or get banned from discord" absurd

@2rx_bni

16 күн бұрын

Welcome to America.

@NitroDS

16 күн бұрын

@@2rx_bni pensive emoji

@Mempler

16 күн бұрын

In the EU, it isn't.

@echotheblackchrimson

16 күн бұрын

Because it isn't, much less legally enforceable. Companies try and sneak little blurbs like that in for the soul purpose into scaring people into not taking them to court.

@RenanMsV_YT

16 күн бұрын

Well its not, you can easily win in such case. But they write it there anyways just to scare.

I love sudden forced ToS changes that popup when you launch your auto-updating-with-no-way-to-disable software that force you to agree or close permanently. Really consumer friendly.

@wrathofainz

16 күн бұрын

Linux doesn't do automatic updates for Discord properly. So i'm just started using the webUI all the time.

@Warcrafter4

15 күн бұрын

Its also extremely illegal making it legally unenforceable. Aka its just there to scare people.

@SakaiHazaki

15 күн бұрын

You can disable auto updates for discord on both computer and android, not sure about apple.

@madladthad2403

15 күн бұрын

yeah im still on the old mobile ui(even as it starts to break down with not repair) since I refuse to update

@AceStrife

15 күн бұрын

@@SakaiHazaki Feel free to share how to disable them on Windows. I've tried multiple methods and every one has resulted in failure. Android is the only place I've been able to avoid updates for years. I'm surprised they still let the old clients login.

Pull a class action lawsuit against the judges that side with the company 97% of the time because that is literally an unbalanced legal system that has probably resulted in millions of dollars of unpaid damages to parties who are most definitely unfairly judged to not get the payouts they deserve.

Thank you for this, Seriously. I am a privacy, and rights advocate, and I use discord not because I want to; its where everyone I know is. I had no idea this was a thing, and I am glad I stumbled across your video. I've just sent my email to them, and BCC'd myself to 2 different emails, a copy of it.

@Kazuk0100

9 күн бұрын

did your discord account get banned?

I am not a US resident, cry Discord.

@capnryna

16 күн бұрын

Doesn't matter, it can eventually apply to you. Just keep yourself updated with the terms of service to see if it changed to apply to your country.

@WojtekPlay

16 күн бұрын

@@capnryna would make it illegal if that country doesnt allow it

@capnryna

16 күн бұрын

@@WojtekPlay Obviously, you'll have to look at your countries' take on arbitration

@steve_1507

16 күн бұрын

I still sent the email.

@ShimizuIzumi

16 күн бұрын

@@capnryna Yeah, for example, I live in a country where arbitration clauses are illegal (as far as I know), but I'm still going to send the email in case I move to the US sometime in my life while that is still in effect.

The issue here is most of these rules will get voided in court... You can technically put ANYTHING in fine lining for terms and conditions, though courts have the right to choose to not let them be admissible in court. So even if Discord says you agree to not file a class action lawsuit... you can still file a class action lawsuit. Discord does not override a court system. This is like someone killing someone and going "oh you can't take me to court because I said so"... no no no, you are the defendant. You do NOT get a right to choose how your legal proceedings go.

@DankGas-

16 күн бұрын

The defendant does get a right to choose how their legal proceedings go in a criminal trial but go off

@burnflamez534

16 күн бұрын

⁠@@DankGas-class action suits are civil suits different rulings but go off

@Unchainedful

16 күн бұрын

This is solely depends on the judge. The judge may state that the terms of service are illegal or the judge may agree to the terms of service. It’s 50/50. Mostly this is a civil matter, meaning this is not allowed to go to federal court or have a jury involved. You either settle out of court or allow the local judge make your decision.

@firedogman2280

16 күн бұрын

@@Unchainedfulthis would absolutely be a federal civil matter, civil courts in the US can do juries too.

@Tyler-nh6op

16 күн бұрын

@@DankGas- Please show me where in law does a defendant decide their legal proceedings. Defendants can FILE MOTIONS for different proceedings (such as jury trial, change of judge, etc etc), though they are not GRANTED their requests by right...

I like the employee specific clause of yeah you cant sue us for harassment, abuse, wrongful termination, discrimination or retaliation. Really makes you wonder

I was initially getting discouraged because it felt as if you were inflating an explanation for runtime, but you actually covered all the bases really well. You researched the topic really well and did an incredible job of presenting the information, before telling us what to do to fix it. This video is exceptionally well done and I appreciate it a lot. Thank you.

Luckily, we have the GDPR, in which the EU just says "Nope, I don't care if you're in the US only, you have EU data subjects so here's a fine of up to 4% of your gross global earnings"

@thecringeinspector5636

16 күн бұрын

This is why I love being a citizen of a European Union member state. Truly couldn't be more proud.

@witherschat

16 күн бұрын

That's why Discord has its ToS only apply to the US.

@Henoik

16 күн бұрын

@@witherschat Their ToS applies to me as an EU citizen as much as it does to you. If I harass someone on Discord, I am in breach of their ToS. However, this specific clause only applies to American residents because they wouldn't legally be able to uphold it in the rest of the world. Arbitration exists in the rest of the world, but it's usually a precursor to a lawsuit - you can't just waive your right to sue - it doesn't work that way elsewhere.

@witherschat

15 күн бұрын

@@Henoik That’s what I meant, thanks for wording it better than me.

@neonoir__

15 күн бұрын

average eu W

The biggest reason to hate forced arbitration: Tell ya what, we're gonna play a game where I pick the rules, the referee, who I pay to ref all of my games as long as I'm satisfied with how they do it, and there is no oversight or appeal, and it all happens behind closed doors with you agreeing you have to do whatever the ref says, including never tell people about the game after it's over.

@Xahnel

13 күн бұрын

You're allowed to not agree with the decision reached in arbitration and appeal that decision. Appeals are undertaken in actual court. They can't ban you from demanding the legal system's protection from their bad business practices.

@dieseldragon6756

13 күн бұрын

As a person with a disability which means having absolutely no social or negotiation skills, I wonder how companies would react to a _Forced arbitration_ being met with _Force of violence_ - Which in my case (And in light of the repeated failures of medical professionals to cure it despite many many requests) must be considered a reasonable correction for the complete inability to negotiate and communicate which such a disability causes? 🤔

@Xahnel

13 күн бұрын

@@dieseldragon6756 The fact that you can clearly articulate this would be 100% held against you.

@FlantisFroggu

12 күн бұрын

@@Xahnel the force of violence does not care

@Xahnel

12 күн бұрын

@@FlantisFroggu You go ahead and attempt applying said force. Go on, we're all waiting, it's boogaloo time.

I am fairly good at reading up on the discord terms and services but mostly when it comes to user violations as I mod for multiple servers, before this I had 0 clue as to what arbitration was or the fact that I agreed to it lol. Thanks once again for the insightful video!

stuff like this is why I never pay cash to any companies for anything online, I'd rather trust the pirates tbh. it all feels silly and useless, what with me somehow managing to convince each of my devices that I'm in a seperate country with zero use of vpn(no idea how I did that, mostly tech problems I purposefully avoided fixing), having each account seperate and generally unlinked for different groups of websites, randomly making burner accounts every time I visit a website with strange unique password fetishes, being blatantly honest with less personal information in a way that makes it seem like I'm making stuff up, which for example keeps real life friends from accidentally blowing my cover if they call me by my "nickname" ingame since I conveniently left out the part where it's my real name, or a part of it is anyways, probably, you don't know. ect. my favorite idea was giving scammers random pun names so I can keep track of where scammers are getting their info from, like some random old lady calls me and asks if I'm her grandson and I tell her "no, this is brian freiz(brain freeze)" and next thing I know all the scammers are calling me bre-an frezno, then I get a call from some chick asking if I'm Rian and I say "wrong number, this is don tramble(don't ramble)" and next thing I know I'm getting 12 calls a day asking for "Don". it really pays to be cautious. though I had to stop with the fake names when I realized that ANY response immediately marked you as an easy target, even just reading their text messages counted, and it was getting to the point where I had to mute my phone because it was just ringing every minute. another fun thing though, I've had a lot of "hackers" and "scammers" try to scare or startle me by knowing my location, but whatever the deal is with my devices, it tricks them too XD honestly you'd think knowing my phone number would be enough to let them know where I live, but I guess they just ignore that in favor of their fancy scary computer magic.

@Jack78467

5 күн бұрын

holy cheeseburgers how long is that

New legal tactic discovered: decentralized class action lawsuit “It’s not a class action lawsuit, I’m just representing all of these individuals in a series of definitely unrelated court cases using the exact same arguments, and I’ve charged each of them next to nothing for doing so.”

@blu8009

15 күн бұрын

It's an act of charity because they have gone through a bad situation :)

@degeneratebeats298

13 күн бұрын

They tried to pull a big brain with group arbitration to give consumers more power, but sadly companies have wised up to this and have simply added a "you can't do that: go fornicate yourself" clause to the arbitration agreement.

@absolstoryoffiction6615

12 күн бұрын

Illegal in America... Especially now a days as USA Judges around Contract Law are skeptical with TOS.

@fllthdcrb

11 күн бұрын

I doubt most lawyers would be willing to do something like that. But mandatory arbitration can and has backfired. Since the company pays most of the costs (which they do because otherwise, the plaintiff might be able to argue they are unable to afford the cost of arbitration, and thereby be able to sue in court after all), if enough people take them to arbitration, they end up spending a ton on the costs. For examples, see what happened with Uber and DoorDash a few years ago.

@PsychicAlchemy

11 күн бұрын

Instead of one big lawsuit they can have tens of thousands of little ones. :)

In France it's illegal if I remember correctly: you can not use a clause of attribution towards citizens. You can only against other companies.

@2rx_bni

16 күн бұрын

Great, but Discord is based in San Francisco this is very legal.

@comradewave5170

16 күн бұрын

​@@2rx_bniit's still illegal in the EU

@maikimaiki3456

16 күн бұрын

@@2rx_bni they cant since its based on where the person is from rather than where discord is based so if they somehow do that to somebody outside of the US they can be sued because of it

@Ugric

16 күн бұрын

Yeah but people from France and other countries can still sue discord

@redcrafter329

16 күн бұрын

TOS says: "‍IF YOU’RE A U.S. RESIDENT, YOU ALSO AGREE TO THE FOLLOWING MANDATORY ARBITRATION PROVISIONS" so if you don't live in the US, you are subject to different laws

Thanks for letting me know about this, gonna go post it everywhere I can

Literally never heard of you, or this, you now have a new sub. Bless you!

They should make it so if a company has a “you can’t sue me” clause in their TOS then the customer should be able to say “you can’t sue me either” lmao

@egarcia1360

16 күн бұрын

Tbf it's basically a "we can't sue each other" clause

@RocRider585

16 күн бұрын

I mean if you ready the TOS.. they can only arbitrate against you as well

@brianfeuerman1732

14 күн бұрын

That’s what it says pretty much. It’s just that you’d honestly have better chances of winning if discord attempts to sue you than if they try to “arbitrate” with you.

@degeneratebeats298

13 күн бұрын

i mean... you'd have to do something really harmful to discord's bottom line for them to want to sue you. The random discord user is probably not going to be able to do anything like that lol

@absolstoryoffiction6615

12 күн бұрын

@@degeneratebeats298 The funny thing about Discord... I have millions of throw away accounts. Which one should I use? I wonder. Oh... Their Contract doesn't apply to me. I simply never existed, that's all.

This isn't just Discord. This is all US tech companies right now.

@fredrick119

16 күн бұрын

is that 10 karma from rain world

@AshnSilvercorp

16 күн бұрын

@@fredrick119 I can dive into the void and there's no forced arbitration down there!

@Diddz

14 күн бұрын

eventually one of them will get too overzealous and do something as bad as blatent ID theft of their users and try to hide behind forced arbitration before arbitration gets outlawed

@MangaGamify

14 күн бұрын

@@Diddz Hmm kinda reminds me of "If everything is X, no one is", what I means if all comanies ToS has arbitration and "can't sue us" clause, court would just throw those out the window.

@AshnSilvercorp

14 күн бұрын

@@Diddz there's apparently some law in works in congress that would let you sue a company directly for privacy violations. I was unfortunately not tipped off on what name it was. And I'm certain the lobbying force against it is massive.

Holy smokes! Thank you so much for this video, and getting the word out there! I'm going to spread the word to all my discord homies!

Glad this came across my feed, thank you for spreading the info and keep those who will do something informed. Don't plan on suing discord, but... you never know.

US citizen here. thanks for posting a video regarding this. I take law classes and went over abuse of TOS and ironically still agree to BS like this. i just sent them the email and hopefully the honor the opt out. Put an end to EULA and abuse of TOS!

@godsmackvv11

12 күн бұрын

Did you use your Discord name or your government name for the email?

@rekunan

11 күн бұрын

@@godsmackvv11 either is fine as long as you get the userid and email correct, personally i did discord name

@ItsPlebble

10 күн бұрын

​@@rekunan I did everything correct and still got bounced

@ardynluciscaelum1010

10 күн бұрын

My nervous dummass wrote the message wrong. At the end of the message where it should say "Discord provisions requiring arbitration" But I wrote "Discord provisions arbitration" (without the word requiring smh)... Now I'm wondering if I should send a second email or leave that one as is smh...

@Dracossaint

10 күн бұрын

I sent mine when they very first changed the arbitration. I have not gotten the written confirmation yet and its been like a week i think?

i have sent a request to be opted out twice, both time were ignored and no reply, discord is going to end up with a massive lawsuit eventually im calling it

@TheNewYouTubeHandlesAreDumb

16 күн бұрын

You won't get a reply. There's no confirmation email, just have to send it.

@ZeFoxii

16 күн бұрын

They can not legally ignore it so if I were you I’d continue to send it and document wether they do it or not as you could be the reason they could get sued

@SupaGamersAlt

16 күн бұрын

3 letters for you: *B. C. C.* Start sending YOURSELF blind carbon copies so that you can document it in court if need be. You can sue the fucking shit out of them if they claim that you never requested an opt-out, since you have the proof that you sent in that request in the BLIND CARBON COPY that THEY cannot see.

@rnaodmsomething

16 күн бұрын

@@SupaGamersAlt YEAHHH, BCC. MAKE SURE TO BCC YOURSELF.

@SupaGamersAlt

16 күн бұрын

@@rnaodmsomething I'm not even joking. It's legitimately something that people use in WORK environments to save their own asses.

Thank you for making this, I definitely would not know to do this without your help.

Thanks for the heads up. Will definitely emailing them, and my other services too now that I think about it if I can

arbitrate is the big mouth guy from Halo

@AppleBiscuits

16 күн бұрын

wort wort wort

@10tative

16 күн бұрын

That’s arbiter

@rubysamurai

16 күн бұрын

Real

@isthisnametaken978

16 күн бұрын

Armpitter

@IVPixel

16 күн бұрын

i think his name was actually arsebiter

Can't wait for discord's legal team to piss themselves when they see the amount of arbitration opt-out requests that suddenly come flooding in over the next month or so thanks to this video.

@Styphoryte

16 күн бұрын

Fr, I bet they're already Rollin in. 😅 Mine barreled thru luckily just fine because the toast wouldn't even fit through the door unfortunately.

@RealDreadmania

16 күн бұрын

It's most likely automated

@rylandrc

16 күн бұрын

​@@RealDreadmaniadoesn't matter, it's still a statistic someone at discord will likely see and be keeping track of.

@Tamishvara

16 күн бұрын

I first got wind of this back in late April, sent my letter as soon as I read the TOS update and verified its legitimacy. Sent April 19th. Yeah, They're more than likely *flooded*

@ShockInazuma

15 күн бұрын

@@RealDreadmaniaAnd tell me, who keeps track of said automated process, thus overseeing what it does and obtains?

Thank you very much for including a template! Writing emails (especially formal ones) has always been hard for me

Hi, I am personally involved in class action lawsuit before. Few years back there was a case where the big banks in Australia was being sued for overcharging fees. Basically what happens is that a law firm will just start suing on your behalf, you can opt out but no reason to. Since there are often many plaintiff's payout isn't huge, I got like $550 or so. I think there are some underlying issues with discord that is waiting to blow up, that's why they changed the tos. Unlikely it will bankrupt discord but $500 is $500.

I have had 1 run-in with an arbitrator because a seller refused to properly refund me as I "damaged the product". Somehow, the arbitrator was unable to understand how a tripod could possibly get some very slight dust on the feet (it couldn't have been from simply having stood on the floor, it must have been outside according to him). My entire case hung in the balance of the overall intelligence of 1 person. Since then, when I see arbitration requirements, I go "NAH FAM".

@Lazy2332

16 күн бұрын

No they probably understood. They probably were ignorant instead as they are paid by the company to save them money & assume everyone is lying to them.

@Drazil100

14 күн бұрын

They probably weren't stupid. They probably knew exactly what they were doing and were trying to lose your case.

It's insane to have a clause that says "btw you can't sue me" like dude! It shouldn't be for you to decide, it's for the judge

@rydergolde3169

12 күн бұрын

technically this is exactly what waivers are, except waivers only cover so much, and one still can sue in cases of negligence (as far as I know, I'm not exactly studying law)

Thank you so much for this valuable information! I'm sharing the video with all my discord friends.

Recently, I just learned the definition of the word discord, and it is the most fitting name for the platform. discord noun lack of concord or harmony between persons or things:

This is a reflection of a larger issue in the American legal system. This forced arbitration clause is a part of so so many terms and conditions. AND it doesn't necessary hold up in court - people have created class action lawsuits DESPITE force arbitration being a part of terms and conditions! There is some good news - forced arbitration in terms of service isn't iron-clan law. USA has some legal precedent where agreeing to forced arbitrary in the terms and conditions isn't held up by the courts. There have been class action lawsuits that happen DESPITE this forced arbitration clause. And there are lawyers that make their legal fees separate (and covered) separately so it isn't taken out of awarded money.

@degeneratebeats298

13 күн бұрын

It depends on the court and the case, a lot of lawyers would probably tell you that you're screwed if you sign one of those. Also im not a lawyer so dont sue pls

@Thor.Jorgensen

12 күн бұрын

In the land of the free!

@nexor7809

11 күн бұрын

how nice im in europe and not america lul

@youtubehasbiggay

11 күн бұрын

@@nexor7809cope

@Lowlightt

10 күн бұрын

@@degeneratebeats298 You don't sign TOS's and EULA's. Which is why these things don't hold up in courts.

"Taking away the rights to sue them". I'm sure there's certain situations where this is automatically invalid, depending on the subject in court

@whimsicalchronicles8798

16 күн бұрын

no if you agreed to it on paper you legally binded yourself to their rules

@justinwyllie3359

16 күн бұрын

​@@whimsicalchronicles8798 No. No matter what you sign, you cannot sign away your rights and there are situations which can invalidate this.

@helpfulDeathgod

16 күн бұрын

Nnnnope! If you agreed to Arbitration, you waive your rights to sue! You have to go through Arbitration only.

@justinwyllie3359

16 күн бұрын

@@helpfulDeathgod In which cases is an arbitration agreement considered to be invalid? An arbitration agreement shall be invalid in the following circumstances: Disputes that arise in a field beyond the jurisdiction of the arbitration institution; The parties to the arbitration agreement do not have competence in accordance with the law; The parties to the arbitration agreement do not have civil capacity to act in accordance with the Civil Code; The form of the arbitration agreement is not in compliance with Article 16 of the 2010 Law on Commercial Arbitration; A party is deceived, intimidated, or coerced during the execution of the arbitration agreement and requests a declaration that such arbitration agreement is invalid; and The arbitration agreement violates prohibitions specified by the law.

@helterskelter416

16 күн бұрын

@@justinwyllie3359 that second to last bit, "A party is deceived...." , i'm assuming that "during the execution of the arbitration agreement". does this include the default opt-in being buried in a lengthy and technically dense terms of service? it doesn't say during the execution of the arbitration, but dueing the execution of the *arbitration agreement* which would be the signing or agreeing to the TOS, wouldn't it? that would make it invalid from the beginning. you could also argue that this was done in bad faith, since it's reasonable to assume that the average person isn't going to read the entire TOS for discord, or that they would understand the section dealing with disputes.

Commenting for algorithm reach, thank you for the straightforward explanation and template! Sharing this with friends to protect others.

Before this video, I did indeed know about this change and had already opted out.

As a Swedish student in law school, i am now certain that i can sue them for saving my messages and not deleting them after i delete my account. Edit: Woaaahhhh. Chill yall i'm 16. Yall would have to wait at least 4 years til i can file a lawsuit. And that alone can take a month or two.

@Dr.Arin.

16 күн бұрын

Count me in if you ever do.

@touma-san91

16 күн бұрын

You can but it would end up being a fight of who runs out of money first most likely so if Discord really doesn't delete those messages after deleting your account, it's better to contact DPA and hope they pick it up and forward it to the right bodies in EU that handle GDPR violations which this would be.

@Lasng

16 күн бұрын

@@touma-san91 Would much rather waste all my money and be on the news than that.

@oracle372

16 күн бұрын

I like having my messages saved…

@blu8009

15 күн бұрын

@@oracle372 I believe it's more that you should choose to have them saved after deleting your account rather than the saving in general but I'm not a legal student/lawyer so don't quote me on it

TOS doesn't overrule law. If they said you have to pay them a billion dollars in the TOS it doesn't mean you actually have to do it.

@uguraktas8018

14 күн бұрын

Forced arbitration is legal in US, you should research it

@el8779

14 күн бұрын

It’s mostly us because their law system sucks where the law has no value if it can be overwritten by a dumb tos.

@yusuf_kizilkaya

13 күн бұрын

if that was the case we would definitely have a lot of bs scam products having "user agrees to pay us 100 billion bazillion dollars" in their TOS by now

@Xahnel

13 күн бұрын

@@uguraktas8018 Forced arbitration is legal, but you can't have your right to redress taken away by a contract. Arbitration is just a step taken on the path to a lawsuit. A step that Discord has to pay for in full.

@rydergolde3169

12 күн бұрын

​@@Xahnel I'm far from knowledgeable in this kind of thing, so hypothetically what channels would one have to go through for this redress? (I'm not planning anything except for getting educated)

I thank you for this so many times since it reminded me that I forgot to do this for my alt, thanks very much mate :D love your vids and how they keep up on showing what horrors are under discords happy skin

I'm so glad this popped up in my feed! I'll spread the word. Thanks!

The fact that I can just hide this clause in a terms of service and for it to be fully allowed is surprising. I have never seen this before, and I'm probably ignorant to the countless other platforms that have this same clause.

@2rx_bni

16 күн бұрын

Are you new to the internet? Most of them.

@karmawsyd213

16 күн бұрын

Whether it's enforceable largely depends on where you live. There's a reason this clause only applies to people in the US.

@panzerfich

16 күн бұрын

​@@karmawsyd213 it wouldn't apply to german users for example, something such as the arbitration clause would be very blatantly infringing on your rights here and thus, despite it being a part of the ToS, it couldn't be upheld in any court. more likely than not discord would be fucking themselves over even more with such a clause over here. (take everything i say with a grain of salt, we only properly discussed digital ToS in a single lecture in uni and my memory is a little hazy, all i know is discord would be up shit's creek if they tried to pull a sketchy move like that here)

@karmawsyd213

16 күн бұрын

@@panzerfich mandatory arbitration clauses in TOS aren't allowed in the entirety of the EU which is why you don't see those targeted towards people in the EU. The reason they do it for people in the US is because it's perfectly legal there.

@panzerfich

16 күн бұрын

@@karmawsyd213 didn't know it was actually a EU law, thanks for clearing that up

Forced arbitration should be made illegal. The fact that these companies can do things that are borderline messed up just because of something your required to agree to upon signup is just messed up. I’m not targeting discord here, but look at many major apps that use forced arbitration, like Roblox as an example. Roblox has done a lot of messed up stuff but nobody can do anything about it because of their terms of service (I am aware about the 10 million dollar court case).

@Nebin20

16 күн бұрын

Yea, "You can only use this service if you never sue me" doesn't sound very enforceable in court.

@iflax7460

16 күн бұрын

I mean it is still a choice to use their service? We don't have a gun to our heads and are forced to use it.

@RealDreadmania

16 күн бұрын

Arbitration clauses are practically useless in court.

@EightPaleHorses

16 күн бұрын

@@iflax7460 "It's your choice to use their service" isn't going to work when monopolies crop up or there's otherwise a dependence on a certain service with no other reasonable options to continue your day to day activities or business.

@ZabivakaPirate69

14 күн бұрын

​@@iflax7460 You should learn about a concept called manufactured consent.

Thank you very much for sharing this information. I sent it to my server and opted out myself.

You're a lifesaver. Liked, subscribed, followed your instructions to the T, ASAP. Thank you so much!

Finally I understand why this is an issue, I feel like I've seen this dozens of times before now and the entirety of the explanation was "they force arbitration and that's bad."

Hey, with arbitration, In US law you can appeal by just suing the arbitrator. Specifically, the Federal Arbitration Act establishes that you can appeal arbitration decisions by petitioning a court.

@Calvin_Coolage

16 күн бұрын

Good luck paying for legal fees though.

@nickrogers3624

13 күн бұрын

@@Calvin_Coolageyou could always apply legal fees to the opposing party.

Huge thank you for this info sir! I recently just started using discord and was meet with a forced agreement to the ToS but also no way to really look at it (on the mobile app) and was sure I was signing my Rights away. I'm emailing right now to opt out of this nonsense (my cable/ISP just hit us with forced arbitration last month too) that every company is doing nowadays.

Thank you very much for clarifying both about the user ID number and how to find it!

Discord does train AI on your data. They have two patents for it. They acquired a subsidiary company called Sentropy, inc. It is literally an AI startup to combat hate speech on the internet.

@elliot_rat

16 күн бұрын

and i'm gonna guess 'hate speech' means 'someone calling their friend a poopyhead'

@RaceBandit

14 күн бұрын

How do we know they won't abuse the "hate speech" term?

@jejxkxk

14 күн бұрын

@@RaceBandit If you read the patents, it dynamically tags users based on all of their conversations. Not just hate. Anything you’re interested in, any messages in servers (and DMs aswell), any spaces or connections you have a presence in, any friends, it all contributes to your AI tags in their system. This isn’t just bad things either. It also tags people with good things if that’s what its judgement is. Point being, Discord has a way to categorise, track and profile every user according to their interests.

@chordalharmony

14 күн бұрын

@@jejxkxkso a social credit score computer. That won’t go poorly…

@morecarstuff

13 күн бұрын

combat hate speech = only speech i like will be whitelisted lol

Discord has a net worth of 14 billion, a 50 million dollar lawsuit would be less than half of one percent... that's not a good punishment, it just tells them they can afford to keep doing whatever it is they'd be sued for

@Chazzvc

13 күн бұрын

punish discord too much they just slap on a subscription fee on everyone and make us pay for it. No thanks, keep discord free to use.

I just saw this in time. Makes me really now want to take the time to read what I sign. 😅 Thank you. I have been spreading your video on Discord and Twitter. I just trying to get everyone I can before today ends. Everyone should have an option.

good content thank you. I was informed deeply about the issue that is relevant to a broad range of people. I will share this with my friends and family. Everyone should see this.

putting stuff like that in your TOS is just sketchy

@Fredomnom

16 күн бұрын

true + W comment

@xzProGamerOfficalzx

16 күн бұрын

fyi: this guy probably scammed people or bought a scammers account to get that checkmark, he has 1 video from 3 days ago with only 200 views yet has over 100,000 subs

@2rx_bni

16 күн бұрын

@@xzProGamerOfficalzx you sound actually deranged. That just happens sometimes.

@ivoxii

16 күн бұрын

@@xzProGamerOfficalzx so?

@user-bu5kf2tg7k

16 күн бұрын

@@xzProGamerOfficalzx i was wondering lmao

You can also choose to arbitrate even if you've opted out. All you're doing is giving yourself more options.

me forgetting and re-watching the day after its too late:

Thanks for posting this. I've been duped before by shady tactics which have subject me to unfair circumstances so I appreciate a warning in advance WITH incentive to act immediately. Really needs to be illegal to force arbitration since it's something that a person should willingly consent to.

mate, I was aware of forced arbitration from Loius Rossman's videos, but watched this one through. But I'm dropping a comment to say that it really just hit me how great your videos are. You explain things so concise, to the point, easy to digest (forgot to mention: entertainining). You may focus on discord but I feel like if you made videos like this on anything I'd watch haha. Keep it up man love your videos.

I literally NEVER saw any articles or anything I had no idea This man is doing the lords work

@wrathofainz

16 күн бұрын

Somebody has to. He's been sitting on his ass for _ages._

I don't know how this found it's way to my feed, but thank you for this video. Subscribed.

This man spent 4 minutes throwing around the word "abritation" and getting no where until finally explaining what it was

@iamexplosion

11 күн бұрын

Only 4?

@Beveyboygames

11 күн бұрын

the whole video was informational, if my adhd ass could sit there and watch it without noticing anything like that but you can't, you got a problem brutha

@KaceyKactus

11 күн бұрын

Could've just... Y'know... Not explained it

@ItachiUchiha-lu3hz

11 күн бұрын

@@Beveyboygames brother in christ, the dude could have spent 10 seconds at any point to explain what it was. L take

@jeffery9543

11 күн бұрын

@@BeveyboygamesDude you just admitted you were watching the video without even paying attention enough to have basic critical thoughts, specifically about the guy not giving proper context to what one of the most important words in this entire video means, at the start where it would've been the most important. Don't take the rest of us with ADHD down with you bruh

I can't believe discord used their TOS to make sure you have to do arbitrary code execution to sue them😒

@PixyEm

16 күн бұрын

*sigh* Time to start Super Mario World...

@KatTheOneAndOnly

16 күн бұрын

@@PixyEm you’re badass for getting that reference dude

@Rocky712_

16 күн бұрын

I thought that was a general reference to any kind of ACE speedrun, such as Ocarina of Time Any%.

@DMFF_YT

16 күн бұрын

Good ol ACE. I'm gonna run both SMW and OOT with ACE. No way they could stop that!

@ShowierData9978

16 күн бұрын

yeah, I thought it was general ACE, but in this case It would prolly be RCE

I feel like things like this could be easily argued in court as them hiding this agreement to arbitration under a lot of legal text as well as not providing clear ways to opt in or out, thus making the agreement void, but I'm not a lawyer and I don't know shit

@Xnoob545

16 күн бұрын

(this doesnt affect me specifically cuz i am in the EU, but it might affect others) IMHO I did **NOT** agree to Discord's TOS, and I'm betting that you didn't either. Sure, i clicked the checkbox that says that "I agree to the TOS", BUT 1. I have never actually read it in its entirely 2. I didn't actually sign it (ike with a signature) 3. I had no intent to actually agree with it. 4. I only clicked the check box so the app let me complete the account creation process, and for no other purpose.

@Asakedia

16 күн бұрын

​@@Xnoob545 digital signature nowadays is clicking the box where it says you read the ToS and accept them. That's the only way to use apps and their services, so you consent to whatever is written. Just because it's not a physical signature doesn't mean that it's invalid

@axld_eas

16 күн бұрын

​​@@Xnoob545 by clicking on that button you agreed to the entire terms and conditions.. i don't think it's really a problem for users outside the us

@terrycrews1584

16 күн бұрын

Unfortunately thats not how it works. It can be under 300 paragraphs of legal text, but at the end of the day the user is responsible for reading and understanding the entire thing. In the EU you are informed of every change to the ToS of a service. Some people call it "EULA roofying" where the user is mislead as much as possible and in practice forced to accept an extremely disadvantageous EULA/ToS just to get a product or a service.

@fireradfieritis8953

16 күн бұрын

@@terrycrews1584 Ah, good old Louis Rossman lingo. I recommend him as he covers a lot of topics involving costumer rights.

Hey, thanks for bringing this to my attention. Had no idea before this video. I've passed it on to my family.

Thank you for sharing this information and the template its very helpful.

Great, Discord's arbitration team, or whatever, is going to have a field day processing all the new "Opt-out* requests, lol. 😂 Great video, by the way!

I'm not a lawyer, but I doubt that a lot of forced arbitration is legally enforcable. Contracts aren't some magic "you've signed your soul away", if something is legally unjustifiable, that part of the contract is null and void.

@m4sterred853

16 күн бұрын

The real issue is the law enforcement loophole. Lawsuits are doubly costly for citizens, because they need to dedicate precious time to it and there are legal fees on top of that.

@yulfine1688

10 күн бұрын

they do have some legal enforceability but if it was something major like discord is found to be harboring a ton of CP or something well that falls flat very quickly, if its a major personal data leak of millions of users it might protect some people but ultimately they will lose if ithey're found to be at fault for the leak or something along the lines and if not well the government will step in and sue them anyways.. However whenever that happens its not like the consumers are getting any funds it all goes to lawyers..

Shared this with a friend. The template is very useful as are the directions in vid. I've seen the arbitration clause come up in so many ToS's. Just never looked closely enough to know how to opt out.

This an incredibly common practice believe it or not, as somebody who actually reads TOSs and Privacy Policies I have seen this clause tens of times. Luckily, it doesn't hold up to well when to do so would require a company to fight international cyber laws,

Moral of the story: our legal system sucks

@Zoie3x8

12 күн бұрын

actual moral of the story - our legal system is basically non-existent.

@screwgoogle4993

10 күн бұрын

ACTUAL MORAL OF THE STORY: Jews.

For what I understand The information needs to be very clear and visible to be legal, so the automatic opt in will not stay in front of a judge 🤣

Thank you for this and the timely heads up!

Never watched any of your videos. But, you earned a sub, and I want to learn more about anything. Thanks!

When i got asked to agree to the new terms mid April, i had a feeling forced arbitration would be in there and of course when i scrolled down it was. I would have warned more people at the time but i didnt know if people cared that much about it. i guess they only realized they cared when big youtubers talked about it. It would have been better if this video came out earlier, as this is a time sensitive issue. Maybe as a result of these videos people will look out for arbitration clauses in any new terms they come across, because this is super common now. At least discord had the slightest mercy to set up an email for opt outs; other companies make it so much less convenient

@Utrilus

12 күн бұрын

No way this is enforceable. I get the feeling if you went to a lawyer and asked to sue discord they'd say something akin to "they can't sign away your right to the law." in relation to the arbitration clauses. These things most of the time is to get people to not try in the first place, or guide them to do things in a way where they achieve nothing.

Do I get an email back confirming I've opted out or am I just gonna have to hope that they've done so?

@206Zelda

13 күн бұрын

Make sure you have proof that you sent it; that may be the bare minimum afforded. There's no way Discord's team will send back a statement acknowledging you're not falling for their games, because then they'd be made accountable if they DID try something with you. And if they ignored it or pretended you never sent it, you have the proof to say "not only have I got the proof, but I'll see you in court". Keep the receipt, scam the cheat.

@CrimsonBraveMaster

13 күн бұрын

@@206Zelda You right, you right

@Demolisher1433-ci2jx

13 күн бұрын

Do I have to go to court or anything if I opt out or do I send the email and thats it?

@CrimsonBraveMaster

13 күн бұрын

@@Demolisher1433-ci2jx Just send an email is what I'm guessing

@wildgurgs3614

13 күн бұрын

@@Demolisher1433-ci2jx Send it. I don't think they'd want to do anything negative to you bc then you could sue for retaliation Make sure to copy yourself on the email you send also so they know that you know they got it

thanks, I sent this video to my family group chat on discord, and then did it for both my discord accounts. Much apricated

I definitely am doing this just in case, doubt it'd ever come to it personally but better to be safe then sorry! Thanks for letting people know this dude 👍

This is some real weird and scummy nonsense. I refuse to give anyone this right, especially Discord. Thank you for telling us.😊

I was wondering when NTTS was gonna do a video on this. People have been talking about it everywhere, so I figured the Discord KZreadr would've been joined that party early 😛But it does make sense to take a bit so he can get all the information together to not only explain the main thing, but give plenty of context that most others did not. I might've eventually gone ahead and opted out myself after doing a bit of personal research. I just really wanted to hear it from someone who's reputation I know of like NTTS to hear that context, and you can bet I've opted out now.

I doubt I'll ever need to sue Discord, but even I did this when I saw what was going on. Thanks bro.

Always check to make sure you're not giving up info to some spambot, even if it comes from a source as such. This appears to check out and I appreciate No Text To Speech for sharing it.

Thank you for covering this.

Just writing to say you really did manage to make the video very entertaining. I'm in EU and it was both fun and educational (even when it only applies to US). You are doing an awesome job!

Thank you for making this known much more widely!

This reminds me. I read the TOS for epson printer drivers a while back and something similar was in there. Except rather than forced arbitration it was an in built waiver of your right to a class action lawsuit and another that essentially says you're forced to assist in defending the employees shareholders etc in court

I didn't even know about this nor have i thought about suing Discord. However, this'll be something to have in the back of my head lmfao

3:48 this example, while obviously not a 1 to 1 example of every situation, is honestly, for me, a very very good way of explaining what could happen!👍 and I mean that!

One small footnote: If you live in San Francisco County, CA you can still pursue them in small claims court according to their "Exceptions" section. There are also a handful of other exceptions concerning certain types of disputes like copyright, moral rights, and "unauthorized use of services" but that last one does leave a bit of an open question.

Isnt that kind of stuff being in the TOS about as substantial as trucks with a “stay 200 ft back we are not responsible for broken windows” signs

@LiaLia0407

16 күн бұрын

when the trucks are, in fact, very much responsible for their cargo, and that sign means jack shit legally

@xdragoonzero0

15 күн бұрын

​@@LiaLia0407That's what they're saying. There's constantly stuff like this on contracts, partly to cover their ass, partly to scare people.

Binah (비나, Bina) is the Patron Librarian of the Library's Floor of Philosophy, formerly the Sephirah of Lobotomy Corporation's Extraction Team, and a former Arbiter of the Head. She is met after promoting the Library to Star of the City and subsequently unlocking her floor.

@bezimieniabeznazwiska6763

16 күн бұрын

Project moon mentioned, sleeper agents activate.

@Glasyara

16 күн бұрын

come on man at least delete the "starcityicon"

@maitreyagpatel

13 күн бұрын

moon

KZread recommending this to me on may 16th is crazy

Thanks for the template, heard about it before and just used my username rather than the ID number.

Really glad I decide randomly watch this channel as I don’t watch the news so now I have opt out of this ridiculous term and service rule.

@skylerlightning4620

16 күн бұрын

Since I watch some newer episode I got this shown me.