It's my first time coming across this podcast and I must say it's very informative .

Scorpene stoppage after 6th is criminal, constriction should not have stopped and a further 12 could have been built

@manisherande4568

Ай бұрын

yeah .. did yoy pay your taxes???

@manojgoel3910

Ай бұрын

@@manisherande4568 much more then you can imagine

@manisherande4568

Ай бұрын

@manojgoel3910 yeah...how much df

@manisherande4568

Ай бұрын

@@manojgoel3910 how much??/.

@Olive_Chap

Ай бұрын

8 SSKs equipped with AIPs would be pain in ass for navy.. further fueled by the fact that we have only 6 SSKs of modern era

US also has a 900 Billion dollar defense budget against India's 72 Billion $ , but I fully agree with the sentiment that Shiv is expressing

@banajsahu546

Ай бұрын

Excuses. Do you know when the same US had GDP of 3 trillion they built 40 Nuclear Submarines in 7 years in 1960s . That's how Nations who have self respect act in a manner not like Cowardice slave India . Be ready to be Chinese Ghulam again . If Indian military really loved their motherland they would have taken over the political theatre and made the country extremely militarized and powerful nation. India is a country which has Cowardice population, absolutely useless politician, garbage bureaucrats and a shameless corrupt military.

@Myanmartiger921

Ай бұрын

yes economic growth is extremely important.

Excellent as always. Aircraft cariers are thought of as 'status symbols' and we all know as Indians our love for them. One would have thought that after the INS Vikrant and pakistani submarine Ghazi situation Navy would hv learn its lessons but seems like we are no yet there.

Enjoyed this edition a lot❤ ..... Please also discuss in detail about frigates and Destroyers also

Amazing show , so well put together. Can you do a show on signal intelligence and I have always wondered how the war room signal s work .. for example when we deploy our assets in a war zone .. how are they tracked ..

I love this series

Excellent explanation, we have lots of problem in self development of technically complicated machines , not able to copy it also...

Nuclear submarine Aisa hi hai jai se jis Nadi main mager maach rehte hai waha log Jane se derte hai. Shiv and Dev very good program about Navel Sub.marin.thanksC

A third aircraft carrier and more submarines are both absolute non-negotiables.

Excellent presentation and sharing of deep rooted information about SSNN and SSN. I am a big FAN of Shiv Aroor and never missed his program at 10 Pm. Recently I came across this podcast and since been glued to all his program. Keep it up. 🫡

Shiv please next episode on special forces..Also throw some light on Fujian and where r we on IAC2

@manisherande4568

Ай бұрын

Under powered IAC 2 with only 1 squadron will ready 2050.. given our pace and. Monies eat by army and babus....

SSBN can be used in conventional battles with regular missiles, not nuclear missiles.

This is in connection with an earlier podcast. Shiv, You mentioned in your podcast on ballistic missiles that we have thousands of them and the capability to manufacture more of them in large numbers of high quality with 99.9% strike rate accuracy etc. Well I just came across a thought process in the CSIS on National security that they would prefer acquisition of long range missiles SM 6, SM 3, as the set up is complex and expensive to build. Allies are preferred for such acquisition. Is there something to explore in this area?

Discuss on why we need to go for mrfa when we can make an air force version of tedbf.

Please also do another podcast on India's Main battle tank story or DRDO's AWACS/radar success.?

Firstly we need 10 to 12 dedicated submarine bases with outfitting, repair and arming facilities, also need shadow (tunnel) bases. Jai Hind.

Hello guys hey great show I am from Detroit Michigan USA but I saw your program and it's really interesting I can't turn it off but I just wanted to find out if your buddy there or your interview guy was a captain or an officer or chief petty officer or something I didn't hear that part.

It's very important for our strategic military might needs stronger bigger smarter Navy for our vast ocean with coastline from suyez canal to Malacca...its necessity for us ..then we needs indian Ocean to india Pacific for countable observable...

How did Shiv forget SSGNs?

@santoriniblue8413

Ай бұрын

I would say because they only exist in the US Navy, and are an afterthought of reconverting an SSBN that has been replaced by a newer class, and using them as a conventional missile transport truck. So, its like a boomer but with less bang; usually housing 4 conventional missiles (eg Tomahaws) in each ballistic tube. This is a concept also being explored in air power too.

@ShivAroor and @DevGoswami, for a country with a long coastline along the Indian peninsula as well as quite a few outlying islands including A&N, we seem to be lacking and definitely not talking about creating a serious tri-service 'Marine Expeditionary Force' capability with serious troop transportation, amphibious assault, landing and sustaining capabilities as part of the Peninsular theater. We will need this capability to protect the main coastline as well as the far flung islands. The A&N tri-service command seems to have some limited capabilities in that regard, but it will need backup and relief from a MEF from mainland, if it comes under pressure in any serious way as it is separated from the mainland logistically. Even compared to some south east asian nations, we seem to be lacking good well protected LSTs, LCUs and Amph Assault Vehicles, in numbers that match our coastline requirements, just as an example. Can you guys talk about that?

Small quibble with the notion that India has been Sea blind. The north of India is land locked, boxed in by the Vindhyas in the south. So, North Indians are Sea blind. South India has had a robust naval presence for a long time with maritime conquests in other land masses. Since independence, when India became one country, the center has had people from the North who have (justifiably) been wary of land invasions. Also adding to the equation, the British recruited Indians to an Army because they did not have their own in the subcontinent but were content to run their navy themselves. Now, as the southern states flex their economic muscle, the Navy will get a lot more attention.

Although nuclear weapons are usually associated with SSBNs (US, RU, CN, FR and UK); IL is suspected of being able launch them from their AIP-powered Dakar class, through purpose-built horizontal tubes. North Korea is adopting the formula the USSR used in its first models, fit up to three using the conning tower, as the missile is larger than the hull, propulsion is also diesel.

Instead of investing on subs....India should invest on UAV carriers....and UAV subs

Shiv is not entirely correct. SSN can also carry nuclear weapon. For example us navy SSN submarine carry tomahawk cruise missile which can carry nuclear warhead.

where is In Our Defence Podcast, S02, Ep 22?

Can you make an episode on India's lack of urgency regarding electronic warfare and surveillance capabilities? We have very few number of AWACS, whereas even Pakistan outnumbers us in this regard. With only 30 squadrons of fighter aircraft, more AWACS are desperately needed to see deep inside enemy territory and direct our limited air assets wherever needed. We need to remember how UK won the battle of Britain despite having a limited number of Spitfires and Hurricanes against formidable numbers of Luftwaffe assets. All because they had a good radar system that detected incoming German aircraft and were able to vector fighters accordingly.

@ffs_chirag

Ай бұрын

Netra mk1 will be ordered

only 27 year delay in p75i and v r yet to sign the deal.. MOD should b given bharat ratna for this outstanding achievement.

Our Coastline is 13K kms+.Don't forget the island territories.

India should have 12 nuclear submarines, 4 Slbm and 8 Ssn and 30 diesel submarines for complete protective authority over entire indian ocean but the speed the work is going it looks like it will take till 2040 atleast for the numbers to reach.

India is to develop nuclear operated submarines so as to maintain its strength in sea.

Will they remember to close the hatch before they dive? Brown water navy only

Isn't India getting French subs after France lost contract to Oz ? Also the stealthiest diseal sub is a Swedish origin & only Japan has the license to produce that type of engine , hopefully we either get it as well or develop our own. Agree in the point that we need many more naval vessels to be produced.

S4 is supposedly Aridhaman

Why not make annelid on the aircraft manufacturing capabilities of india both civial and military and can we have atleast an assembly line in india of Boeing or Airbus

Podcast request : A detailed episode on PM Modi's spontaneous visit to Pakistan. *The rationale behind the visit *Security challenges *Havings balls to land in Pakistan😅 *Assuming it was Pm`s firat term , was it naive of him to do something like this * The action plan if anything went wrong And any other pointers you can think of. Not much in extreme detail is supposedly available on the internet about this .

Then they also have SSGNs.

What Modi Ji is doing making our defense forces self-reliant. It means, we will have setbacks for a decade or two but in the long run, we will develop the technology that will help us not only secure our nation and it's strategic interests but also give leeway for future political leadership of the nation to formulate foreign and national security policies without having to worry about foreign pressure. Modi ji is doing the right thing and future generations in India will be thankful for it.

Nice work on the podcast ! Thanks You forgot to mention the UK Nuclear deterrence seems to be a joke at the moment…Didn’t their last 2 tests of their missile fail?

IND should have 30 minimum 10 ssbn 10 ssn 10 diesel electric. Jai Hind.

Question : China and India Naval engagement. India is unlikely to go to the south China Sea to engage with the Chinese Navy. About the Indian Ocean region, and engaging with China in our neighborhood. What are the real chances. Should China's submarine count matter to us? Why?

next episode??

He is talking about Navy and he forgot the name of the new navy chief. Ridiculous.

India has 15 subs with only 2 power vs china 70 subs with 10 nuclear subs😂

Why is there, what seems to be a commercial, a discussion on anti israel protests?

Even when it comes to power projection the Indian navy's aircraft carriers are a joke. They are not big enough to pose a threat to Pakistan, the country which we usually have to fight a war against. The navy actually hid the original vikrant in the Andaman islands during the 71 war because they were terrified that the Pakistani submarine which was hunting for it would find it and sink it, and that would be a humiliation for the navy as well as the country. And it was only after the Pakistani submarine was sunk did they remove the vikrant from it's hiding and use it's aircraft to bomb chittagong, which was totally unnecessary because the IAF had already achieved total air superiority over the E Pakistan airspace. And even today the Indian navy dare not use a aircraft carrier against Pakistan, because unless the IAF provides it with air cover the paf will attack that juicy target and sink it. So who else is the navy going to " project power " against? Sri Lanka. Maldives or Bangladesh? We are not the USA. Even the UK realized that they have committed a great blunder by ordering and building 2 aircraft carrier's, because they cannot afford them, but our navy insists on more aircraft carrier's and is not interested in submarines, especially SSNs because according to them they are not as sexy and glamorous as a aircraft carrier.

As per the host the huge maritime border of India appeared just after 2014 out of no where.

aircraft carrier and submarine saath mai nahi ho sakta to kyu nahi hum heli carrier bnate.. ..vo hamari najdiki area ko cover kar sakta hai

When I was interviewed for navy , i conveyed that india needs nuclear submarine with nuclear missiles!😂 If there was a beauty queen, she would added for peaceful purposes and for the sake of her mother and she would get selected!😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

36:29 is breaking point for me. Why this promotion inserted in such a good podcast. There is nothing Indian about it. Podcaster have very limited knowledge about submarine and weapon in it or against it. He is right only in one part that Indian navy (diesel operated) has very less submarine. He said 15 but it's only 8. War winning submarine are Diesal operated submarines. Any way I will never see this podcast in future due to 36:29 crap.

95% of India's imports and exports is via sea. Therefore India's naval strength is vital for India's defence and trade security. The Indian government's policy of ignoring its nave and in particular its submarine and naval aviation is incompetence and babuism to unbelievable degree.

I am a bit amused to hear this podcast. Figures being thrown around randomly - 45 boats - where has this number appeared from ? Perhaps a little research like remembering the Chief's name whom he met less than a month ago or the actual issues related to submarines, their design, construction, roles and capability would have helped. In trying to be cool and conversational, one should avoid becoming flippant.

Pakistan has AIP since 90's agosta B

👍👍👍🫡

shiv is always good with his english but his answers lack depth & his response is always same 'lackadaisical approach'.. bhai AF k jets ka pucho tab bhi ye hi... Navy ka pucho tab bhi ye hi.. army ka pucho fir same.. by deisgn SSKs are more stealthy under the water than SSNs as SSKs don't have dynamic part other than electric motor & propeller which is powered by batteries.. whereas in SSNs your nuclear reaction which power turbine to generate electricity or mechanical power has certain amount of sound signals.. but SSNs advantage is at certain depth it can cross ocean without noticed by patrol aircrafts.. which SSK can't as it had to snorkel to run diesel engine.. we didn't got 9 of SSKs from P75 because it was believed that DRDO's AIP would be ready when L&T would be fabricating 4th Kalvari class & additional 3 or 6 would ordered later.. 9 SSKs of P75I didn't happen because the amount of TOT (Know how this time not just fabrication that happened in case of P75) wasn't agreed by foreign vendors & also navy wanted Submarine which has operational AIP, Navy could figure out the operational logs of those & the real capability of AIP which is usually less then advertised.. also it's navy also to be blamed as they wanted AIP design only for this.. but in reality Japanese & korean sub with lithium battery are almost on par with AIP equipped sub of that era.. now most frightening condition of navy would be in 5 years when paki will have latest 8 SSKs from china equipped with AIP doing patrols in eastern as well as western boards & chinese SSNs lurking in middle & southern IOR.. ideally we should have dealt with french for SSNs to get atleast 12 of those but this government is more on making announcement & actually dealing with irregularities of lost decade of UPA toward our militaries laggards

Ref. war-footing acquisition of 36 Rafale; Bharat existing fab. capacity is capable of pumping out subs. - yards silent. GoI has the money and political will to buy some of the latest bling-blings now, if they wanted to - not done. Could it be because they're in no particular hurry ? 'V' coasts of Bharat is under layers of protection already, hence GoI approach to subs like a woman buying saree !?😊

Navy brass has become a joke 😂 Pakistani are getting Chinese subs and these chaps are just planning . SSBNs but nothing to defend them 😢

It looks like glorifying not a shameful situation 😂😂

India can not perform a strong offensive role without a massive help from our navy. 21st century wars around India will be fought in water. Reason chinese are investing so much in Indian ocean, gulf of oman, gulf of aden, bay of bengal and south china sea.

Khangress was so focused on secularism and appeasement of minorities, there was not much planning and investment in our defense preparedness for decades. All it did was buy things from Russia and take commissions out of it for parry funds or self-enrichment. Only after Modi became PM, we started planning for future defense requirements. The six decades after independence was a wasted opportunity, by Khangress.

75i exists because of AIP technology and French are bad at it.

I agree with Shiv,, khandvi is super pathetic

The knowledge was too much fragmented too much and the author redefines, updates it so much with his personal comments.... that the podcast becomes 😴.

Whats that random woke video inbetween. This is the second time i am seeing in this podcast series

SSNs are deadly Ninjas operating in utter secrecy. SSBNs are our Battle elephants, once they charge no one survives. That is a better explanation.

Amazing show , so well put together. Can you do a show on signal intelligence and I have always wondered how the war room signal s work .. for example when we deploy our assets in a war zone .. how are they tracked ..

Excellent as always. Aircraft cariers are thought of as 'status symbols' and we all know as Indians our love for them. One would have thought that after the INS Vikrant and pakistani submarine Ghazi situation Navy would hv learn its lessons but seems like we are no yet there.