I like how he answers the question "China will Completely Collapse in 17 Days!?!?" with "no" in 2 seconds 😄

@revcrussell

Жыл бұрын

Yeah screw those creators that drag things out for 10 minutes just for the watch time.

@Miranox2

Жыл бұрын

It's refreshing after all the sensationalist bs floating around.

@lu-vly

Жыл бұрын

Hence the ??? marks.

@danielguo1033

Жыл бұрын

Wow! Very impressive! Serpentza you knew China so well even history of communist! 9:30 what powerful speech! well said! it’s all true.👍👍

@lorddrac_dontaskmetodance

Жыл бұрын

If you're really interested in hearing why, I suggest watching the next 17 minutes and 25 seconds.

“The masses never revolt of their own accord, and they never revolt merely because they are oppressed. Indeed, so long as they are not permitted to have standards of comparison, they never even become aware that they are oppressed.” ― George Orwell, 1984

@cat-vv9xb

Жыл бұрын

Yeap, mainland Chinese are pretty spineless as they get, it's like expecting North Koreans or Russians to rebel, we all know that won't happen.

@steffenrumpel2784

Жыл бұрын

And even if they had some barebone impression of what freedom could look like, they won't necessarily revolt. Just look at Russia. ... When Russia started to invade the Ukraine and as soon as it turned out that Russia could not overrun the Ukrainian defence, I thought .... Just let a couple of thousand dead soldiers return home in cascets, then the Russian People will surely rid themselves of Putin .... Well, I was quite wrong.

@qdav5

Жыл бұрын

I've read 1984 several times, but I think I will read it again. It encourages the sort of self-awareness and self-reflection that is important always, but especially so in today's world of increasing tyranny and authoritarianism.

@Peter2k84

Жыл бұрын

Mmm, true But the Chinese people did have a taste of a better life for the past 2 decades or so. Food on the table, a roof over they're heads. A job that let's you get by, hope for the next generations to come. It's not like the north Koreans who never, even once, knew how a better life looks like.

@ChickenMcThiccken

Жыл бұрын

exactly. that is why in the republic of congo. you don't have tv shows that tell you can you grow up to be anything you want to be; and that life is happy and well.

It’s actually good to listen to a man that knows what China is about he lived there for 14 years that’s long enough to know what he’s talking about good on mate

@apocain

24 күн бұрын

Lived in China for 14 years and can't speak Chinese. What a talent

My wife said there is a saying that the flower that stands taller then the rest is the one that gets cut. And in my own experiences in China, the CCP watched what happened in the former Soviet Block and seemed to realize that they can keep the people fat dumb and happy through the market reforms that started in the 90's. I witnessed an evolution of people there becoming even more concerned about looking out for themselves.

@Shadowclaw25

Жыл бұрын

endurance is useless, if it gets to a point where u lose your humanity. Why be alive at that point ? Better to die then, walk into nature, look at the sky and stick that knife in your belly or let someone stick it in. Much better than to life in those conditions. Come back another time, even wild humans, lived far better lifes.

@user-tz7je5sz9j

11 ай бұрын

china is the most democratic country in the world. resources go to the weak majority ---> they explode to 1.4 billion people (90% are weak), while those who innovate, the small minority is shrinking ---> china is behind in technology and need to copy from the west.

A "90后" Chinese here. I am literally crying over this video Winston. It is unimaginable how much my grandparents and parents endured to provide for the family. My grandfather was an intellectual and used to teach in school. During cultural devolution, he was forced to work as a farmer and bricklayer in response to "知青下乡". He worked to death before I was born. My dream is to become a professor in the US and do everything I can to spread awareness as you do. What CCP fears the most is the truth. Stay awesome.

@jackieChannel.

Жыл бұрын

Good luck, sir. You’ll need it a lot. Keep your mouth shut for your own good and work towards this goal in silence. Who knows who could be hearing? I hope it goes well.

Жыл бұрын

The US does not need any more professor. It does need soldiers for there is a shortage.

@gameacc6079

Жыл бұрын

Xi jinping is ur god

@OFFONE

Жыл бұрын

If we want to destroy the ccp we need to simply bring back manufacturing to the US and stop getting out stuff built over there with slave labor.

@rishabmazumdar5635

Жыл бұрын

@@joynerwang1749 Why is it stupid?

Chinese people: "We the unwilling, lead by the unqualified, have survived the unbelievable for so long, with so little, still attempt the impossible, with nothing." Mad respect for your friend, Winston. Looking forward to hearing good news about him/her. 🌟

@ieronymos9265

Жыл бұрын

@Ruthanne Seven, just like you Westerners after the “covid” hysteria.

@Kekoa552

Жыл бұрын

I cry ever time china keeps pushing my people as a Hong konger I wish China will let us go I don’t want ccp I was freedom just like America I wish people can help

@ruthanneseven

Жыл бұрын

@@Kekoa552 I'm so sorry you are suffering. I wish you luck. You do not deserve the bad CCP. So Sorry. 😔🙏💔

@Kekoa552

Жыл бұрын

@@ruthanneseven life I was born unlucky I hope to be Born in happy homes “In a desperate situation. A fish stuck in a rut in the road will soon die if not moved. In need of immediate assistance.”

@rodiculous9464

Жыл бұрын

Lot of parallels to russia now esp with putin throwing away his last viable generation into some idiotic conflict

Yo, you are one of the very few KZreadrs that actually understand the real situation. Having lived in China for 13 year, I have been saying that all the time: CCP is not gonna collapse, because they have absolute control over everything, much more scary and stronger than Soviet Union...People keep giving hope on youtube for nothing. No hope about change at all.

@thenightwatchman1598

Жыл бұрын

doomer copypasta is doomer copypasta.

@Chadmeleon

Жыл бұрын

he doesn't understand jack. No collapse in sight westoid crybaby

@midgetydeath

Жыл бұрын

The CCP and China are not the same.

@Azad-qm2pm

Жыл бұрын

@@midgetydeath that is what you wish. they are unfortunately mostly same now ,and getting more same year by year. the huge brain washing machine is working 24hours a day over there

@aaaaaaaard9586

Жыл бұрын

​@@Azad-qm2pm You and Winston already got one thing wrong, chinese people did actually stand up and protest. You can't have an absolute control over educated, enlightened people because they're smarter than those stupid and corrupt CCP officials. History has shown time after time... you think you got an iron grip on the country, then the economy fails and people rise up. The CCP is no exception. Besides, since we're living in a chaotic system, what YOU believe also matters greatly. If everyone believes the CCP will fall, it WILL fall.

Hi, I only discovered you a few weeks ago, but I’ve watched several of your videos. I think this one is the best so far, as it explains how and why, a whole country can be so acquiescent. You do good work.

Winston's credibility rests on two things: 1) he's a subject matter expert (lived in China 10 years, speaks Mandarin fluently) and 2) he doesn't engage in race-baiting scare tactics and always insists his viewers distinguish between the people and the government there. His kind of educated, measured analysis helps educate westerners about China but also combats xenophobia. I really appreciate his voice.

@janboow

Жыл бұрын

His Mandarin is still at pre-school level🤣

@dereknicol3465

Жыл бұрын

@@janboow 50 center turn ur VPN off pinky.

@PeterPanQuails

Жыл бұрын

Winston's Chinese mandarin is definitely very proficient. I'm a Chinese myself and am amazed at his Chinese language skill.

@julsbuy1baubles

Жыл бұрын

Absolutely! Well said!!

@Aquascape_Dreaming

Жыл бұрын

@@janboow even if that were true (which is catagorically isn't), how is it even relevant? Perhaps you have nothing you can use to refute him so would deride his grasp on Mandarin in a pathetic attempt to create distraction from the truth. Why are all of you CCP apologists and agents so infantile and pathetic?

I love that Taiwan exists both as an irritant to the CCP and as a reminder to the Chinese of what could have been.

@tonysofla

Жыл бұрын

Taiwan are in decade long stagnation, people are bored and wages have not increased.

@erimart63

Жыл бұрын

Taiwan still smashes China on any given metric: per capita income, life expectancy, freedom of expression etc.

@PeetHobby

Жыл бұрын

Or what will be.

@MagSnapShots

Жыл бұрын

Yes, I do agree. So why can’t the West encourage China to unify with Taiwan under the democratic ROC constitution, as the condition for peaceful unification? The CCP could be open to it and it will be an impetus for CCP to reform…even if it takes decades, at least the trend is there. Why does the US insist on supporting the corrupt DPP regime that insist on Taiwan island independence ?

@EvilNeonETC

Жыл бұрын

@@tonysofla rather same ol same than fall into suffering and modern slavery

Was sad to hear you say China isn't going to change. Was hoping this would do it. But I'm overjoyed to hear your friend is alive and well, in a safe place. Looking forward to watching his news

I was in Shanghai for a month (scheduled to be there for two months) to learn Mandarin (I am fluent in Japanese). I asked my friend what she thought about Mao - and her face turned white and whispered YOU MUST NEVER SAY THAT HERE! and proceeded to say loudly so that everyone could hear her: Oh, he was a great man. He is the father of our country! In my Chinese language class - my second week - I told my teacher (who was really, really good) that someone had opened my backpack on the train and stolen my camera while everyone was watching. She looked sad, and went over to the window and closed the blind, and put her finger up to her lips to mean DON'T TALK - and wrote CCP on the blackboard and pointed at it, then erased it very quickly. Then she said: That's the reason why it was stolen. People steal to stay alive. It's the CCP that is to blame, not the Chinese people or their character. I saw Barrack Obama in Shanghai soon after taking office, talking to students and he was going on and on about American freedom and democracy. The students had completely blank looks on their faces. I realized they don't want freedom or democracy because freedom and democracy require personal responsibility, and they don't want that. Who wants to be responsible for their lives. They can throw garbage on the ground and not think twice about it - let the government take care of that. Housing? Let the government take care of that. They like not having to take responsibility for themselves. Communism helped unify the country during WWII - that had been colonized up to then by the French, the British and Americans, and invaded and raped by the Japanese, so it brought the country together as one country, so I'm sure they are happy about that - and with the CCP introducing capitalist methodology, things have improved, so people think things are fine just as they are. That's my interpretation. I left Shanghai after one month because it was dirty, noisy, people were thieves, and rude, and it was incredibly bad. I dropped my class and came back to clean, polite, and society is good. I was so glad to come back here. It's like night and day. I'm enjoying your videos Serpentza.

@funpau7549

10 ай бұрын

It’s so sad that Chinese always had a weak mind. They always go for the easy way out, even if it meant long term badness. That’s why they loss to a small country like Japan, with strong minds and determination, in WWII, even when China had way more people.

@zbz5505

10 ай бұрын

​@@funpau7549I'd say that's not entirely the case. They've thrown their emperors out every now and then in the past, idk what broke at what point though. The ccp has clearly outlived its purpose. Although, it might have to do with a certain square. The reason they lost in ww2 (and the entire century prior) was because of stagnation and overconfidence. Like, when Britain came for trade they told them in Latin no, because they were so full of themselves, they didn't care the Roman empire collapsed over a thousand years ago.

@stephenbartram7377

3 ай бұрын

​@@zbz5505they didn't collapse They morphed

@stephenbartram7377

3 ай бұрын

@dotten...barrysoetoro is his real name The other name is his ceyea/agent name

@darrenjohnson1299

28 күн бұрын

At least the thieves are doing one thing... taking personal responsibility for their lives.

I like how you immediately did the whole "Short answer? No. Now prepare for the long answer." with this video. Really caught my attention on the spot. Stay awesome my man

@drx1xym154

Жыл бұрын

yeah, though world economies will suffer - people will starve due to high food prices or simply a lack of food or get cold and stick due to a lack of fuel. Even germans are looking up the prices for firewood... the ESG/"Green Initiatives" are an odd form of a command economy and likely will result in mass suffering and a good bit of death.

@freeofmefree

Жыл бұрын

Short answer. NO Long answer. NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Finally, someone coming out with an option who understands also the cultural background and not only the economy. You just can't apply western market mentality to such a different from ours society.

@lip124

Жыл бұрын

I really hate that shit when people compare other western countries to china, its not even close to it especially when china is literally fake it till you make it. Is the china gonna collapse? yes but nobody knows when you literally can't put dates on when something is gonna collapse best to stay far away.

@MegaBanne

Жыл бұрын

There is nothing magical about the Chinese economy. Sure, it was slow to react to the largest bubble in history. But when that bubble popped no amount of propaganda can get people their money back. The revolution does not start with the people. It starts with the wealthy members of the party.

@TrickyNekro

Жыл бұрын

@@lip124 extremely many people don't understand that the markets are 90% masses phycology either. I'm not surprised, just a bit nuanced.

@es68951

Жыл бұрын

It’s not even just about ‘western market mentality’ or anything economic. It’s also about the assumptions that ‘human life is valued’ and ‘wrongdoers are punished’ and ‘rule of law exists’, and so on. These are things which are taken for granted in the rest of the world, so much so that they don’t even appear as factors in the calculus of these ‘experts’ trying to predict what will happen in China. Meanwhile, such things simply do not exist in the world of the CCP.

@daano465

Жыл бұрын

I dont know man, he acts as if when the government closes their eyes to the problem, the problem doesnt exist. This multi trillion housing bubble is still there, no way the government has the money to bail out that entire sector.

Love your channel! I watched all of those other videos and you always have the most thoughtful and informed opinions. Thanks!

I really respect how you do your videos. You're honest, you don't use scare tactics to dramatize your videos which totally would get you more views especially those who are very anti China. I was one of those people, but you made me realise I'm against the CCP, not the people. They're very manipulated and it's sad, but they don't know the truth.

@magoochito

Жыл бұрын

you were against the people at one point? glad to hear you changed your mind.

@craigdurso3005

Жыл бұрын

Serpentza changed the way I think about China , I realized I was starting from a too western way of thinking … there is a difference between the government and the people just like here

@TheWasher18

Жыл бұрын

It's like being upset at a child for being neglected and abused.

@starfrost276

Жыл бұрын

@@TheWasher18 It has been a long standing thing of mine that whenever I see someone acting poorly or disrespectfully, I restrain my anger and frustration because it isn't their fault. I hold those bad thoughts for their parents who failed to give them the knowledge and experiences they needed to grow into a prosperous and amiable being.

@JustLIkerapunzel

Жыл бұрын

Well like he said some do know the truth like all the ones who are didectly affected but there are various areas in which people are affected so one person wouldn't necessarily know about another area in which the CCP abuses its people and they are aware of how they can't really do anything about it. At the root of the problem China is basically a not quite as drastic version of north korea (and btw hugely responsible for North Korea to never get better)

As a Russian, I can note that if you decide one day to become an expert on Russia, you already have a fairly solid base for understanding the political processes in our country. Unfortunately.

@Spookshow1000

Жыл бұрын

Are you in Russia currently? Was wondering how the people are doing. I spent a few months in The USSR in 1988 and it was a real eye opener. When the wall fell i flew back to the states and always hoped US/Russian relations would of improved. Anyhow if you don't want to answer due to the government cracking down on dissenters I understand. Have a great day.

@naturelover7979

Жыл бұрын

Before communist Soviet Union. Now autocratic Russia. U have never been democratic.

Жыл бұрын

@@Spookshow1000 Russia will always have a bad relationship with the free world, for Russia is an empire, not a nation-state.

@qq5847

Жыл бұрын

@@naturelover7979 well, what can we do about that? If the Russian want democracy so bad, they have to get it with their own hands.

@Monsterpala

Жыл бұрын

Same here but I guess in Russia it is much worse.

Thanks for the great analysis, Serpentza. You are one of my six trusted sources for info on Mainland China. Pls keep up the good work.

I am so glad to see ads and over million subscribers in your channel. Your contents are helping those poor people who suffers under Chinese regime by exposing it and telling the truth without fear of consequences. you deserve the best and keep going ...you know the drill as always, Stay Awesome!

Finally someone with a common sense calling out these "China will collapse in x days" videos

@martintvrdik1655

Жыл бұрын

Most those videos talk about economy, not collapse of a country. And I do not think they are wrong at all. Was The Great Depression collapse in your book? Most peeople would say it was. And US saw decline of 10% GDP back then. China is looking at instantenous fall of 15% of GDP if real estate prices correct to US levels which is still tremendously overpriced and there could easily be spilled to other industries and sectors of economy making fall even worse. CCP will live through it and so will China. But it can most definitely be called economical collapse.

@brexitgreens

Жыл бұрын

Should make a colab on that with CGTN 😆.

I remember a story my Chinese mother once told me very long ago about when she grew up in the '50 and '60. She would be so hungry as a child and teenager that she just ate the only thing often left: raw peppers. This resulted that I came into this world with "hot food resistance level up +20".

@awjaaa

Жыл бұрын

Aww+Lol

@J_X999

Жыл бұрын

The sad reason why Chinese eat bats, is because the ones who didn't starved in the famine

@awjaaa

Жыл бұрын

@@sharedfuture5669 Boy, you've really fallen for the propaganda, haven't ya? Good luck in your dreams. We are living in reality, though.

@unduloid

Жыл бұрын

That's not how genetics works.

@awjaaa

Жыл бұрын

@@unduloid It's genetics, with Chinese characteristics. duh.

It's 5 days later...and I just ordered some Cool Outdoor Lights from...wait for it...CHINA!

In a world of sensationalised KZread videos, Serpentza is a breathe of rational fresh air.

The Chinese economy was recognized as a bubble *over a decade ago.* The people who said it was a bubble weren't wrong; we're seeing them being validated _now._ However, said bubble has lasted this long, over a decade. Why? Because of the CCP's control. They managed to keep up the facade and scheme all this time. I look forward to the day when the CCP falls, but let's not jump to conclusions just because it's the outcome we want.

@bighands69

Жыл бұрын

The CCP bubble lasting this long has nothing to do with the CCP control. China export market kept it going when the bubble was growing but it cannot maintain that bubble beyond a certain point and that is where you will see it go through a fast expansion phase. China will break down and split up and that is where the real danger is.

@drx1xym154

Жыл бұрын

Yes, though depending - the "collapse" could mean war and/or even war for Taiwan. It would seem they are playing the long game, though I suppose when they control so many aspects (command economy) - they also decides who dies, who goes homeless and dies, who goes hungry and dies and what kids turn in their own parents.

@Fight2Survive

Жыл бұрын

Why are you hoping for millions of people to suffer… China has very many positives and amazing people to work with and converse with.

@javierpatag3609

Жыл бұрын

@@drx1xym154 The war in Ukraine surprised everyone and I have no doubt even them. Taiwan is not Ukraine, and China is not Russia, but I've no doubt the war in Ukraine has shown the CCP that things can go badly for even those with perceived superior militaries- such as theirs. As such, I think they're just going to stick to just threatening Taiwan until the last of their days rather than actually going forward with it and potentially making things worse, as bad as things are. If the CCP ever decides to go after Taiwan, it will be out of desperation and madness. I don't know how much longer they can play the long game, though. With their demographic problem and their water problem, time is running out.

@javierpatag3609

Жыл бұрын

@@Fight2Survive I want the CCP to fall, not for the people of China to suffer. *DO NOT THINK THAT THE COMMUNIST PARTY OF CHINA = PEOPLE OF CHINA.* The CCP has ruled and oppressed and taken advantage of the Chinese people since Mao Zedong took over the country. They have let their own people suffer and die while they lived in luxury and power. The Chinese people are simply better off without the Chinese Communist Party.

Glad someone who understand the history of China can explain the context to those who are not Chinese. I keep telling my friends this who are not Chinese and they don’t believe me that the government would purposely let their own people die. They’ve never experience actual tyranny and lived too good a life in the Western world.

@TheSoonToBePurgedJackMeHoff55

Жыл бұрын

We aren't living "too good of a life" in the west, the Chinese are living a shit life. Its not our fault we have a functioning society...

@Immigrantlovesamerica

Жыл бұрын

Most Americans are completely delusional and detached from the reality of life outside of the US.

@user-oj8kd8we3t

Жыл бұрын

China has been a tyranny since ancient times, Tyranny, tyrant, and mob are the trinity of traditional Chinese culture. So there is no way!

@tinfoilhomer909

Жыл бұрын

Here in Australia it's a slow process but people are starting to wake up to the evils of our government. Here in Tasmania cloud seeding causes deadly floods, but it also offers "carbon credits". It's about profits, not people.

@Eedorian

Жыл бұрын

Worse thing is that many young people actually believe the West should follow China's example and become communist.

I love everything about you man. There are near billions of people in wait for their chance at life w/o the ccp. It’s terrifying how I feel about the American gov’t & society. When you look at China. “one of the top countries on earth” that’s people undergo this hell every waking second

@user-tz7je5sz9j

11 ай бұрын

china is the most democratic country in the world. resources go to the weak majority ---> they explode to 1.4 billion people (90% are weak), while those who innovate, the small minority is shrinking ---> china is behind in technology and need to copy from the west.

Thank you for your work, many of your videos are based on experience on the field/ counties (instead of intellectual speculation, as many other channels), that makes a huge difference.

My initial thought was "Aw jeez, not another of these 'collapse' videos". I came to mock but stayed to appreciate. Actually, at this stage, serpentza shouldn't have to make these points - most half-way knowledgeable people should have a better understanding of the Chinese situation by now - but apparently they don't. Keep on fighting the good fight, serpentza ! Thumbs up !

@TheDiner50

Жыл бұрын

For all intense and purpose there is going to be a collapse. But maybe going to hurt rest of the world more then CCP. And that is the *** part. Since people in China is expected to be screwed and CCP is going to be bad off but still in power. BUT ALL THE STUFF WE CONSUME IS GOING TO STOP COMMING TO OUR SHORES! Even a slight collapse for CCP is going to make the rest of the world faint in horror since there un edictal and wasteful way of life is not going to be as easy to live in for a month year? Wow. STOCKS GOING DOWN! Meanwhile people in china have a normal hell day..

@rwalker0130

Жыл бұрын

people are so willing to believe whatever is most sensational - unfortunately I live with one. I do believe the CCP will fall one day, just not anytime soon.

@yuka-youtube

Жыл бұрын

according to tim pool, civil war and ww3 are keep happening everyday for 3 years now...

@LeviathantheMighty

Жыл бұрын

No. I'm more than half way knowledgeable, and I didn't know this. You just insulted MOST people to put yourself up on a pedestal.

@mg1721

Жыл бұрын

>most half-way knowledgeable people should have a better understanding of the Chinese situation by now - but apparently they don't. well there is saying that half knowledge is dangerous

Update on the Casgains channel using my footage, they have reached out and now have put links to my channel in the description, we're all good now! Thank you to each and every one of you who support me by watching my videos, you're incredibly Awesome! Support Sasha and I on Patreon: www.patreon.com/serpentza Paypal: paypal.me/winstonsterzel

@HavingCoffieWithMrSatan

Жыл бұрын

They shadow band my REEEE

@fortunateson101

Жыл бұрын

You are 100% right Winston. Great news about your contact too.

@Fish-ub3wn

Жыл бұрын

13:40 Stay Awesome, modern hero...

@TheSusaneneely

Жыл бұрын

No Guns…no power. I was born there before Mao(1949). They do not care about the people!! Is the communist mindset,here?

@TheSusaneneely

Жыл бұрын

Just as in the rest of the world…the only power comes from GOD!!!

I saw this video title and immediately saw “posted 5d ago” haha oh boy

An informed, insightful and educated man. Very dangerous.

Thank you for the video Winston, i couldn’t believe people used your footage without even leaving a link.

"You can't use logic to explain China," something that was said to me by someone who escaped Mao's China. Now I realize the depth of what he said.

@inajosmood

Жыл бұрын

No, you can apply logic to China. Logic isn't one dimensional. With logic you can see what China is, how it's come to this point and some possible directions for how things will develop. The thing is, you can't apply dumb logic to China solely from an uninformed westerners perspective. Like serpentza says: China works and thinks different. But to anybody who studied a little bit of china or similar regimes, there's a whole range of educated guesses you can make.

@brianingram2068

Жыл бұрын

I agree, one can absolutely apply logic to China. But one needs to adopt a Chinese perspective and not Western assumptions. Then it makes absolute sense, even if we believe it's not-right. Reminds me of Winston's "China: The Way it Is" videos.

@crynesesoldier6983

Жыл бұрын

Commies do not use logic.

@natee9496

Жыл бұрын

"You can't use logic to explain China," Man these words have finally put into words my thoughts when people ask me about China.

@crynesesoldier6983

Жыл бұрын

@@natee9496 He is showing the world what the CCP does not want others to see.

The person I trust most talking about China and CCP is serpentza.

That's good, because this video was posted 5 days ago and I'm just watching it for the first time today.

5 days later, no complete collapse so far. 16:45 where I live

The fact those channels shadow ban your comments just for pointing out they used your footage even though you're not claiming copyright or flagging them, says a lot about their lack of integrity. That alone would make me mistrust their content!!!

@patrickmendoza3210

Жыл бұрын

I agree, I just went on their channel, and the said video, to bring it up, so the people who read comments are aware of the lack of integrity.

Thank you for this video. Your years living in China and your perspective as a foreigner provides invaluable insight. It's hard to find reliable commentary on China in the English speaking world.

"While America was landing a man on the Moon.. this kind of crap was going on in China." - serpentza 2022

@manoz6194

11 ай бұрын

Now this kind of crap is happening in America

@Drooh

10 ай бұрын

@@manoz6194America is definitely not starving due to withheld grain from the government

The first true recap on China I've heard. Big round of applause to this guy!

The exact same people The exact mindset The exact thinking The exact doing The exact policy The exact way The exact hostility The exact tyranny The exact control The exact pain There's no end..stay awesome

Glad you called out the other KZreadrs and fact checked all of these ridiculous claims from people that have no idea what they are talking about. That is messed up that they shadow banned you. Pisses me off.

Winston, as an ethnic Chinese born and raised overseas, I deeply thank you for all your work (as well as those by Laowhy86 and others) in spreading the truth about the nefarious nature of the CCP. Please do keep up the good work and not lose hope in this fight for better humanity and liberal democratic values.

@dawnnadir

Жыл бұрын

What ethnic of Chinese are you may I ask?

@pinnacleenrichments8387

Жыл бұрын

@@dawnnadir Born in Malaysia, raised in USA

@dawnnadir

Жыл бұрын

@@pinnacleenrichments8387 Cantonese or?

@pinnacleenrichments8387

Жыл бұрын

@@dawnnadirDoes it matter? Various Chinese ethics suffered under the CCP. The "despicable famine" and "hideous leap backward" killed tens of millions Chinese. What about yourself?

@pinnacleenrichments8387

Жыл бұрын

Chinese grew up outside of the 1949 China generally had been better off compared to the mainland Chinese. But the mainlanders are now getting arrogant, and saying how great the CCP is......

Absolutely correct. I admire your effort to report on this. Very good work.

When it comes to the truth about China, nobody knows the nuances better than you, Winston. It's much appreciated when you make a video explaining things like in this video. For info about China, all one has to do is subscribe and watch your channel. Thanks for the education you give to the "free" world about the depth of knowledge you have and freely share. Much appreciated. Thank you, sir!

@robbytherob

Жыл бұрын

China Insight is also another great channel. I just watch these two

@robertscheinost179

Жыл бұрын

@@robbytherob I have watched that channel but Winston Has the time in China and a diverse backround which offers a non USA and a USA perspective to understand the nuances that only he can, The BEST!

@robbytherob

Жыл бұрын

@@robertscheinost179 yep I am not disagreeing on that one. Not sure how to describe it but both channels are critical of China and do it in a professional way.

@TJshine1

Жыл бұрын

You have to fight for your rights in every circumstance. It is insane to me that people think that the US government just "allowed" freedom of speech and what not. As if it is not a right that is constantly under assault by those that do not think it is a good idea.

@makeergod4153

Жыл бұрын

.imchinese and what he made is nonsense 他所有视频都是断章取义胡说八道

I remember the video you and Matt biking through these ghost cities. That was a predictor several years ago. You guys also warned me about Covid several months ahead. You're both the real heroes of KZread.

@JatinderSingh-fs4ix

Жыл бұрын

It all began in China.

@nipmeetup2233

Жыл бұрын

In which video did he predict COVID?

@emmaswartz4549

Жыл бұрын

They had a video on Covid December of 2019, or January 2020. None of the major news station talked about it until it finally hit us around March. I didn't say they predicted Covid but they talked about doctor friends in China seeing a new respiratory disease and videos of people dropping in the streets. I saw it coming thanks to this video and wondered why our government didn't shut down the border earlier.

@JatinderSingh-fs4ix

Жыл бұрын

@@emmaswartz4549 They hid everything. China is a commie state and a dictatorship.

@JatinderSingh-fs4ix

Жыл бұрын

@@emmaswartz4549 They allowed international flights while banning domestic flights, did the CCP.

Sad that others steal your content-I’ve always enjoyed your travels around China on your motorcycle-being married there-thanx for the splash off cold water in the face about China collapsing💪👌😎

Serpentza your name and your work will be remembered in history. You're so correct than anything I have seen before. This is the best, thank you Serpentza.

My wife is Chinese, and whenever I express my support for (for example) the anti-government demonstrations in Hong Kong, she just says they are completely wasting their time. The expression she uses is ‘It’s the egg against the stone’.

@diegoseraph9225

Жыл бұрын

She is wrong…

@sticktwiddler9028

Жыл бұрын

@@diegoseraph9225 Explain.

@diegoseraph9225

Жыл бұрын

@@sticktwiddler9028 i have been living in Shanghai for over 20 years… Chinese wife as well. If it has been truth what she said even the revolution of Mao wouldn’t have been happened. They main instrument used by the Chinese domain class to control people has always been the immutability of the reality: you are slave and you ll be always a slave. Make people accept this and you even don’t need policemen or prisons. But, as I said, since Mao killed the last emperor then the CCP will be killed as well. The moment Chinese people understand who they are then they will get their freedom. It is not a fact, but what they believe. I don’t know if I explained well my thought.

@sticktwiddler9028

Жыл бұрын

@@diegoseraph9225 I hope you are right, but I’ll believe the. CCP is collapsing when I actually see it happen.

@diegoseraph9225

Жыл бұрын

@@sticktwiddler9028 it is not something going to happen tomorrow, but the CCP will collapse

This is why everyday HK people protested so hard while they could, even knowing the impossible odds against China and having no police or army or anything to fight for their freedoms with. They knew the inevitable outcome for HKers, and they were willing to be an example to show the world what the CCP really is.

@greattaiwan2899

Жыл бұрын

We don't want to end up like HK.

@JatinderSingh-fs4ix

Жыл бұрын

HK was great. CCP has totally ruined it.

@CallsignVega

Жыл бұрын

HK capitulated quite easy and quick.

@JatinderSingh-fs4ix

Жыл бұрын

@@CallsignVegaTaiwan does not want to end up like HK.

@greattaiwan2899

Жыл бұрын

@@CallsignVega HK was given to China by Britain and they ruined it.

This video made me remember why I started watching your channel a few years ago

Great video! Thank you! What you say is so true! It is so disappointing to see many of the western media analyze China as if it was a normal country. Most people have no understanding of what Chyna is really like. Thank you so much for educating people about the truth.

So proud of you man! Being South African myself I love to see your success on your channel!! Keep up the good work boet!!

This is one of the very best sources found anywhere on China, he had his 'skin in the game' for years - if I ever had a question regarding China - this is the first guy I would turn to.

@baikeiast5255

Жыл бұрын

Never believe a white guy from south africa looting everything there

@istvan9678

Жыл бұрын

China Uncensored is also very good with this, seems that both of the channels actually put an effort into understanding China

@codered4422

Жыл бұрын

How many others have you researched?

@bogermil4201

Жыл бұрын

@@codered4422 Many over the last 5 years or so - which sources do you recommend?

@codered4422

Жыл бұрын

@@bogermil4201 chinese vloggers, at least

thanks heaps always helpful Stay Awesome 😎

Great show. Thank you so much. Worked there a bit and your words ring true.

As one military analyst said: "Building numerous ships for your fleet is one thing, maintaining them is another."

@robertagren9360

Жыл бұрын

Keep building ships then.

Love your videos. I’m about to collapse in a few days. There’s too much drama. Serpent ZA you really changed my perspective on China. I hope you and your family are doing well.

@Hairy_Takoyaki

Жыл бұрын

In a few days? That's too vague. We need numbers! 17, 25, 47? Numbers!

@Anton.Baryshnikov

Жыл бұрын

What?

@xXAlmdudlerXx

Жыл бұрын

What do you mean with Im about to collapse? Need help?

@drx1xym154

Жыл бұрын

@@xXAlmdudlerXx -- maybe he simply means he will be more reflective? Introspective - hopefully not implosive (violent collapse).

@aspenenglish4976

Жыл бұрын

I mean me personally. Not any country. I’m facing some very difficult health challenges. Sorry if I misled you.

5 days later, saw this video, nope it didnt

Winston you are the best and you always give the best assessment of the situation in China.Stay awesome.

It’s refreshing to see someone being honest and making an informed commentary. Those other you tubers producing sensationalist videos are doing it for the views, which is rather disturbing to me.

@zidbits1528

Жыл бұрын

I don't think they're doing it for views, I think they really believe what they're saying. The believe it because if it happened here in the west, the governments WOULD collapse. They just don't understand how & why China is different from a western country. I personally both agree, and disagree with Winston. I believe China's *economy* can and will collapse. It's inevitable. How do I know this? Because there isn't an economy in all of human history that hasn't collapsed or had its bubble "popped". It's just a matter of when and how. Economies can't grow infinitely/forever, there are ups and downs, bubbles and collapses. China's in the biggest economic bubble the world has ever seen - this isn't my opinion but the opinion of every economist on the planet. It will eventually pop, it has to pop if they want to continue to grow. Winston says the PRC has total control and he's right - but China's economy doesn't exist in a bubble. It interacts with, and participates in the larger global economy. This is how China's economy collapses - other countries losing faith in the Yuan and foreigners losing faith in investing in China. The latter is already happening, companies are choosing to avoid having their stuff made there due to rampant IP theft. China also wants to get a robust middle class; to do that, they have to start paying decent wages. Once they do that, China will no longer be a cheap place to manufacture things and that alone will collapse their economy, completely ignoring all the real estate bubbles.

@jacob4920

Жыл бұрын

Why is it disturbing? You don't have to watch those videos. Nobody does. I don't, because I decided I have better things to do than worry about the downfall of countries thousands of miles from where I live. If it happens, great. If it doesn't, so what? What does that mean to ME? Nothing. And these other KZreadrs are clearly "click-baiting" with their predictions. That's an underhanded, but completely harmless, way of attracting gullible viewers, to increase their income on KZread's algorhythm. What's disturbing about that? Much worse happens in American society, every day, and yet we Americans just roll with it. Is any of this crap going to start a war? No. Only one thing is going to trigger a war with China: the Chinese invasion of the Island of Taiwan. THAT would be truly disturbing. What's happening on KZread: not so much. So let's just calm down here.

@CriticalThink

Жыл бұрын

@@jacob4920 I don't watch those videos either. You are correct that there are things in this world that are much more disturbing. Why is it disturbing? Because honesty doesn't come first. Although this click baiting activity seems harmless, I don't think it's a good thing to mislead people in any way.

Finally. I’ve been waiting for someone to make sense of all these videos which are suddenly appearing

Phenomenal video! You’ve definitely opened my eyes to the harsh reality.Especially now that they’re trying to make the yuan the reserve currency, and with BRICS association, they’ll do everything in their power to keep their economic issues contained and they will do whatever must be done to keep it that way.

Thanks for this. This is the first time I have heard a convincing assessment of the Chinese financial situation.

Thanks Winston, I hope your family and friends are well. Peace be with you.

Finally someone talking sense on this issue

On another note… when I see horrible videos of traffic accidents around the world… most anywhere… people come running to help… but often (not always) but when I see videos of terrible accidents in China… nobody comes near at all… 😕

Great video as always. Wow.

I love your content Serpentza. I love also the longer format stuff like you talking abt your brothers passing. I clicked originally because I found your China content interesting but the more vids I watch from you, the more I become interested in you yourself as the creator and your perspective and the way you are able to vocally go thru a field of mines

@serpentza

Жыл бұрын

Thanks mate!

I like that you called them out on their click bait & copyright infringement / use of your content. Thanks for the solid assessment, Winston.

It's hard to rise up when you are starved to the point of being unable to walk.

If Marvel characters were real Thanos and Mao Zedong would have been besties.🤦‍♀️ " When there is not enough to eat people starve to death. It is better to let half of the people die so that the other half can eat their fill." - Mao Zedong.

I've been seeing tons of videos popping up about the bad drought recently and found you. Loving the info and hands on videos!

@bighands69

Жыл бұрын

The reason many have been saying China will collapse is due to the fact China is about to go over an economic cliff. About one third of China economy is property based and that market is about to fall out and everybody can see it happening in slow motion.

@robertagren9360

Жыл бұрын

He can be a little one sided propaganda machine but he has knowledge about China. Mainly because there's nothing for a foreigner to find there. The people are born into the country and when someone says the word China it means an individual person in china. They worship butchers because they're allowed to worship them and the economy in China is fake so there's no wonder why the economy is unable to collapse when it's people who will suffer no matter how bad it gets. When it gets worse CCP gets more power since the military don't fight for their families. Instead CCP makes up stories which the people believe. They believe that USA is going to invade China and that CCP is saving them so there's no way a country who declared war on the rest of the world to abandon their savior. The likelyhood for the people in China to rise against CCP would be as if people in Great Britain decided to attack their own countrymen during ww2 and join the Germans.

Always appreciate you honesty. Fight the fascism!

Great work...thanks.

they are rising up right now even with tanks rolling out again.

These Serpentza videos are far more enlightening about China compared to what I hear from all those China "experts" that you see on the major news networks!

FINALLY! im glad someone is calling B.S. on these absolutely ridiculous click bait KZread videos I have seen. As much as I WISH it was going to happen, it just isn't.

Great work!

As someone who spent 18hrs in H.K. airport recently with only one small deli open for coffee, I understand that oppression

I love hearing honest, realistic opinions.

@Misael8924

Жыл бұрын

It takes people willing to die, and fight all the way to hell to distablize china. Unfortunately many have to die. Many get to a point of a degree, but almost make it in Belarus. They can't have their whole nation to crumble as well.

Saw the thumbnail from Serpentza and I went "Yes!". Then I clicked and, "NO!" Perfect.

Thanks for this, 👍.

I remember an old China hand for the US State Department commenting that China-watching is basically looking at the surface of the ocean. There are giant sea monsters battling underneath, but the only information you can get about them are the bubbles rising to the surface. I think the reason Mao was not held accountable for the Great Leap Forward or the Cultural Revolution was that he had gained too much face for winning the Civil War, kicking out the foreigners, giving land to the peasants, etc. It's a peculiarity of Chinese culture that when a leader has enough face, they can get away with far more egregious acts than the West would accept, and people will apologize and make excuses for them. If we look at historical precedent, I think the CPP is not at the end of its tether, but about halfway through. Throughout Chinese history, when a regime takes over, it starts out poor. The dynasty's leadership - often not Han themselves - has not learned to work with the Mandarins, the economy is wrecked from previous upheaval, and ordinary people sort of quietly wait and see whether the dynasty has staying power before they become productive. One move that a dynasty will make will be to open up to foreign trade. International demand for Chinese products has remained constant for the past two milennia - tea, silk, handicrafts, and all the cheap things they produce today. Although other civilizations learned to produce these things on their own, they could not match the Chinese in either price or quality. So the dynasty opens the country, foreign money flows in, foreign culture follows, and China becomes rich. However, alongside this comes the corrupting effect of extreme wealth, which eventually wears down the ability of the government to preserve order. It is at this inflection point that the government either collapses or, through a series of symbolic acts, closes itself off from the world. Usually these involve moving the capital, executing a few high-profile officials, propping up the founders of the dynasty, expelling/murdering foreigners, and often getting rid of foreign cultural influences. Think of how the Tang dynasty conducted pogroms against their urban Muslim populations after the An Lushan rebellion, or how Zheng He's treasure fleet was allowed to rot, and records of his voyages were forgotten about. Of course, we can see all this happening with the CCP. People tolerated the Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution because the CCP was still in the wait-and-see period. To a Westerner, giving a Communist like Mao credit for China's economic boom makes no sense, but in the Chinese perspective wealth flowed into the country *because* the CCP survived the wait-and-see period. Whether or not it adhered to its Marxist ideology is irrelevant. It is important to emphasize that this is not just me, the gwailou armchair Sinologist, with my own opinions. Xi Jinping himself is obsessed with the idea of dynastic collapse, as was Mao. The CCP's historical symbolism is obvious, deliberate, and easily recognizeable by any Chinese who is aware of their history, as most educated Chinese are. So, will the CCP collapse in the next five years? Chinese culture represses resentment until it suddenly explodes everywhere. However, the CCP is loudly signaling that it is at their inflection point and is dealing with it - Mao's cult of personality has been revived, foreigners are being expelled, English-language education is restricted, and a few top officials and billionaires are harassed, imprisoned, or disappeared. I think there is a good chance that people will accept this and get on with their lives. The thing about freedom is that, unlike what we Americans are taught, most people don't care about it. Freedom matters to the top 5% of hyper-productive and thoughtful people, people who would today just leave China. Ordinary people are happy to just guo rizi. Until they aren't.

well, i agree with you. i had a strange suspicion about sudden surge of contents that ccp will collapse in X days videos.

My heart breaks for the everyday Chinese people. I remember seeing Tiananmen Square when it happened. It really drove home how trapped they are. 💔 I'm terrified for the people of Hong Kong. There was a time I didn't realize how much stuff on Amazon comes directly from there and helps prop up the CCP. I appreciate you guys showing us that and trying to get the truth out without going to either extremist side.

@lhopee

Жыл бұрын

Not just Amazon, eBay n lots of other websites sales products from China. Lost of middle class n wealthy Americans are still living in lala land though. China is good a bagging for money Fr US n if can’t they will start stealing. It is the US fault for giving China the power to threaten us.

@exodusprparadoara6536

Жыл бұрын

谢谢，但是我们大部分人不需要你的同情

@crynesesoldier6983

Жыл бұрын

It is better to fight and die than live like a coward. Hope the Chinese realize this some day.

@Pancakegr8

Жыл бұрын

@@crynesesoldier6983 It’s nearly impossible when you have this pesky biological aversion to being tortured or killed.

@crynesesoldier6983

Жыл бұрын

@@Pancakegr8 That is correct. But there are billions of them.

Awesome analysis!

You are exactly right

Hey man they nailed your china show video for copyright FYI You guys are awesome Thank you for all of your hard work

Dude, your China content is so insightful. Thank you for your hard work and for sharing your knowledge on a country that most of us in the west get very legitimate info on. As someone who was born in Russia, I can't help but see some striking similarities between how both of these world powers suppress their people.

@cecillec2331

Жыл бұрын

Because the same people controlling Russia control China. They also pretty much control the rest of the world, including America. This simple fact goes "whoosh!" over the sheep's head. Why was Alexander Solzhenitsyn destroyed? What did he reveal? Who was really behind the Bolsheviks? Why do you think the CIA is all over the world infiltrating governments? Who created the CIA? When Philippine President Duterte spoke live on TV with a lopsided face (from an obvious stroke), he said, "If anything happens to me, the CIA did it", my heart ached. I wondered how many other people understood exactly what he was trying to convey. If you study history and politics as doled out by our programming institutions, you don't really know the truth. The 1980s educational reform had sinister implications. It resulted into 80% of American high school graduates being functional illiterates, and what there is left to learn are all orchestrated to mesh well and assist the agenda of the globalists. I cannot post any links here because free speech is now a felony (legislation sponsored by the same people).

Thank you for this insight no matter how disheartening. I truly love your perspective.

Well, that was clarifying, interesting, horrifying, and sad. Thank you for the history lesson. All this reminds me of the book, 1984, (Room 101), etc.

Thank you for your insightful and important commentary on China and its effect on the global economy. It is refreshing to hear truth that I can apply in my daily life from an obvious expert on the subject.

I don't think I've ever felt so depressed over a video in my life. To say that the CCP can survive such an economic downfall, uprisings back in 1989, famine, be so mismanaged and corrupt, and it be 100% truthful it's like the CCP has won in some way and short of extinction or a very bloody war is robust enough to endure pretty much everything else. The Chinese people outnumber the members of the government 100's if not 1000's to one. I just feel so helpless.

@isunlloaoll

Жыл бұрын

@中国历史 No, you support the CCP. I don't, and my large Chinese family members don't.

@titob.yotokojr.9337

Жыл бұрын

Yes, the Chinese people are poor saps and doormats of the CCP.

@JGldmn333

Жыл бұрын

Your math is off. The Chinese outnumber the ruling class probably 1 million to 1. What does that have to do with anything? It is the Chinese police and army...security forces too that you would be dealing with. THAT number is in the millions. The only hope: that the Peking upper echelon leadership gets nuked in a war with the USA over Taiwan.

@thegreatepic

Жыл бұрын

@中国历史 You support someone who put their burden on you and take all your food in return for their kindness for letting you carry their burden and make your families and friends in becoming their slave. How much have your government brainwashing you?

@theuncalledfor

Жыл бұрын

@中国历史 And I'm sure they'll allow you to keep breathing for a few more days now that you said this.

Thanks for the informative & enlightening video. ✔

Why American rich ppl invest more in China, let their kids learn Chinese??

Please, don't skip Serpentza's ads. 😊 No skipping ads for Sterzel.

Fantastic insight as always. Thank You, stay awesome.

Thanks for spreading the truth. It's so true!

Great job!