00:23 Aragonese 03:17 Ladino 08:06 Galician

@michimacho73

3 жыл бұрын

There are more other videos where you can hear a more conserved ladino. Where the pronunciation is different to modern Spanish and with many old Words like in this example (read j as dj in french, z as in Portuguese, h is clearly pronounced): Non me acodro desde kwando en mi chiqués me ambezí el judezmo, má só me acodro que con mi babú me ambezí a meldar el solitreo y ansí después fue el empezijo de mis primeras letras a mi babú. Los hijicos de las mujeres en la quilá no sabían meldar como yo. Agora es como una hazinura de los judeyos que las criaturas no ablan ni se ambezan en djudezmo .....

@Braglemaster123

3 жыл бұрын

AOC is not Jewish at all. She’s 100% Puerto Rico 🇵🇷. Don’t believe her. No

@Braglemaster123

3 жыл бұрын

I’m 100% born Jewish. How are you Jewish ???? Please explain. Thank you

@Braglemaster123

3 жыл бұрын

If you have DNA from your father’s side, your not Jewish. No

@gaetano22

2 жыл бұрын

@@Braglemaster123 Sephardix Jewish descend directly from Mizrachim and people from Israel that settled in Sepharad, 4 people among 5 in Spain are descendants from Sephardic Jewish, either if your Jewish heritage comes from your mother side or father side we can have likely more canaanite blood than Ashkenazi people, without mentioning that 1/4 of Spain was settled by Phoenicians. When Jewish people were expelled from Spain they had the option of being burnt alive or convert to Catholicism to colonize New Spain kingdoms or...escape to Balkans, North Africa or Middle East. There are specific areas such as Nuevo León, Altos de Jalisco, Cotija and los Reyes de Salgado and Orizaba in Mexico or Antioquia in Colombia that were settled mostly by Sephardic and cripto-Jewish families

I speak ladino to Spanish speakers all the time and they never notice lol they just think I have a funny accent. I’m Turkish and Moroccan descent, born and raised Jewish lol

@s2sHoXXs2

3 жыл бұрын

very cool to know! thank you for sharing :)

@hammou1312

3 жыл бұрын

Do you live in Turkey?

@tvtalkwithavi

3 жыл бұрын

@@hammou1312 No, I live in New England, but I moved here from Israel

@pinkdoobie

3 жыл бұрын

Move back to Israel! Estudio Ladino agora i no tengo kon ken puedo echar lashon!

@tvtalkwithavi

3 жыл бұрын

@@pinkdoobie awww I want to eventually =}

I’m learning Ladino! The Cervantes Institute actually recognizes Ladino as an official dialect of Spanish. What’s cool about Ladino is that it preserves some features that began disappearing from other dialects of Spanish around the time of the Expulsion. For instance, Ladino speakers in the Balkans still pronounce the F at the beginning of fazer (hacer) and favlar (hablar). J is also pronounced as either ch or dj in Ladino instead of being the breathy sound it makes in Spanish. I recently saw a really cool newspaper article from New York City from 1903 or 1904. A ship arrived with Jewish passengers from Romania, and there were 3 families on board who spoke Ladino rather than Yiddish (the newspaper described it as “pure Castilian,” which it definitely is *not*). The immigration officials had to unexpectedly call for one of their Spanish translators, and the first one they found was a Sefaradi Jew whose family immigrated from Turkey.

@johnblossom944

2 жыл бұрын

Are you learning Ladino at the Cervantes Institute?

@johnblossom944

2 жыл бұрын

Also that story was really interesting as a Sefaradi Jew whose family is from Turkey & Yugoslavia

@chanaselka

Жыл бұрын

I'm a Sephardic jew from Turkish grandparents to who spoke ladi o.what do you wanna know?

@luckneh5330

Жыл бұрын

It is its own language ^^ not a dialect of spanish; hopefully they'll change that

@pinkdoobie

Жыл бұрын

@@luckneh5330 Not really. Ladino speakers consider it Spanish and it’s mutually intelligible with Castilian. And since politics and mutual intelligibility are really the only two standards for what differentiates a dialect from a language…

I'm actually from Galicia and I speak fluently Galician. Galicia it's just beautiful, not just because I'm from there but because it is. Love your channel, keep it up buddy!

@juanminon9467

3 жыл бұрын

Ola Candela ! Si é certo .A miña avoa era da Ría de Muros e Noia. Todos os veráns ía de vacacións a Muros. Cando era pequeno iamos en coche do sur de Alemaña onde vivo . Eran mais de 2,000 e algo de kilometros da distancia. Gústame a música galega e as paisaxes . Saúdos Juan

@calebgamer1720

3 жыл бұрын

Galician= Spanishsized Portuguese

@CanisLupus1987

3 жыл бұрын

Galaico-Português. A melhor família de línguas 😍

@CanisLupus1987

3 жыл бұрын

@@calebgamer1720 no. Actually Galician is close to Northern Portuguese and closer to Old Portuguese

@cande_1025

3 жыл бұрын

@@CanisLupus1987 homeee ❤️😌

It’s really nice to include Ladino. I myself am descended from Jewish Spaniards, like you, and I’m incredibly glad to see the inclusion of Ladino, as it’s mostly a dead language, despite some attempts to revive it.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Absolutely. I need to make a whole video about it with more research

@davidkasquare

3 жыл бұрын

Guys, listen to Yasmin Levy singing. Also, I have a Jewish friend called Noam Vazana who sings old Ladino songs from Morocco. 😊

@kyomademon453

3 жыл бұрын

Castillian ladino is still used in turkey

@cescfy4208

3 жыл бұрын

I am Catalan. I think we should taken Ladino as the reference language for Castilian. Jewish people maintain their culture and traditions against all odds and persecutions. Probably that language is much closer to 15th century Castilian than any other of its dialects.

@CanisLupus1987

3 жыл бұрын

Not In Israel. I know people who are fluent. Judaico Portuguese did disappear

Ladino is really just 15th century Castilian. The main difference is that Ladino is written in Hebrew. Some vocabulary may be from Hebrew but that would mostly be religious words. Otherwise, it really is a fossilized Spanish from 1492.

@seid3366

3 жыл бұрын

Cantar del Mio Cid: es ma child!

@johnblossom944

2 жыл бұрын

Ladino also has some influence from Italian as well, it depends where it was spoken (my family is from the former Ottoman Empire) and we have some words that are in Turkish when we speak the language

@luisteixeiraneves4211

2 жыл бұрын

E acontece que no século XV o castelhano era muito mais parecido do que é hoje com o português. Ainda pronunciavam o "j" e o "z" como nós os pronunciamos.

@williamwestbrook-rosales6508

Жыл бұрын

Yes and no what Ladino is really is called Spaineach (From Spain) originally yes was written in Hebrew script however after 1478 Ladino changed because the language and speakers were being systematically cut off of converting ladino into Castilian considering Castilian didn't emerge as the official dialect of Spain until 1500 or so and because of this Ladino is still to this day a medieval Spanish language that pre dates Castilian by 500 years remember ladino was being spoken in Greece, Turkey and Italy around the same time or prior to ladino in the Iberian peninsula and in modern day the language is spoken in 22 countries globally outside of Spain, Portugal and Latin America from Gibraltar(British Spain) Malta(British Sicily), Cyprus(British Greece), Britain (England/London), Italy(Ladin), Turkey(Istanbul), Greece(Solanikia), Armenia, Serbia, Bosnia, Slovakia, Russia, Israel/Palestine and then some

@philomelodia

Жыл бұрын

@@seid3366Cantar Del Mio Sid es del 1141.

I’ve noticed that all the different languages of Spain are all spoken with a Spanish accent which I find interesting.

@hyperion3145

3 жыл бұрын

Not all of them, but most are heavily influenced by Castillian due to the pressure the Madrid government has historically put on them

@joesatana

3 жыл бұрын

NOT AT ALL, not even Castilian is spoken by all the Spaniards with that accent

@kyomademon453

3 жыл бұрын

@@hyperion3145 castillian has not put a single bit of "pressure" in the accent of many region in spain, the accent you find Madrid is way too different than the one you'll find in andalucia, asturias, catalunya or galicia, theres a "standard new reporter accent" but that's common in any country

@LuckyBravo

3 жыл бұрын

True. I noticed it as well. It's as if they are Castillans trying to speak these languages to fit in after moving in. It's sad. Accent is an important part of a language.

@hboss30

3 жыл бұрын

Porque además hablan castellano como primera o segunda lengua por eso el acento español

Of all the Galician that I have heard, this one sounded very much like spanish, which made me think he wasn’t a native speaker, but rather a spainard who learned it later on. Normally it sounds nearly identical to brazilian portuguese and is often more understandable for brazilians than european portuguese is.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Hmm that is a good point. Do you know where I can find videos of native Galician speakers?

@dereknoble6796

3 жыл бұрын

@@ConvoSpeak just last month @econlinguist posted a video where he had @alaxonmario(hablante nativo de gallego) do a video and had portuguese speakers try to see if they could understand it. Even if you just search “falando galego” Im sure you would find plenty!

@manuelmiranda8142

3 жыл бұрын

@@ConvoSpeak kzread.info/dash/bejne/rJ-HqpifZd2ee5s.html

@bilbohob7179

3 жыл бұрын

If you understand him. He says that he learnt the language when he was an adult. He says galician is a second language for him

@bilbohob7179

3 жыл бұрын

@@ConvoSpeak kzread.info/dash/bejne/p51-mdSkfa_YZrQ.html

The Galician speaker has a rlly castellanized pronounciation and language (his mother tongue is castillian and not galician so it's normal, he speaks rlly well for someone like that, but that's not rlly representative of the habitual spoken language)

@David-mv8fo

3 жыл бұрын

@VFM #7634 No its not. Portuguese and Galician are actually different languages, there are a lot of differences, like in the pronunciation or intonation.

@WilliamPsyFi

3 жыл бұрын

@@David-mv8fo @VFM #7634 I guess you don't know what he's trying to say which I clearly understand, what he means is that the Galician sounds like a person that speaks Spanish trying to speak Portuguese what here in Brazil we call Portunhol 👍🏻

@brolin96

3 жыл бұрын

Imagine someone from Madrid saying that about Galicians accents while speaking Spanish. 😱

As a Catalan speaker I could understand 100% Aragonese as it is almost like Spanish and the few different words are actually the same in Catalan such as “mica”, which mean a little bit.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Fernando. Moltes gràcies! That is very interesting. How did you do with Galician

@fernandomallafre9833

3 жыл бұрын

convospeak I could understand everything too!

@jinengi

3 жыл бұрын

He didn't represent the Aragonese language properly :

@chakka13

3 жыл бұрын

"Mica" in the U.S. and Mexico means "Green Card". To my knowledge at least. Cool vid.

@aafiq2962

3 жыл бұрын

catalan is more sounds like french and Galician its sounds like Spanish Portuguese but Spanish Italian French Portuguese Galician Catalan its all Latin romance language

Soy brasileño. Para mí era más fácil entender el gallego que el portugués en Portugal. Después de varias (maravillosas) visitas a Portugal hoy los entiendo bien

@juanminon9467

3 жыл бұрын

Oi ,ola, hola Avelino. Si porque ustedes hablais más claro que la gente portuguesa, y no nos comeis letras por ejemplo al final de una palabra. Yo creo que pienso que el Portugués brasileño viene del antiguo galaico-portugues. Está más influenciado con el portugues del norte y el gallego. Tengo un canal de televisión de Brasil llamado Record Tv. Saudações do sul da Alemanha Juan

@Elplaceteno

2 жыл бұрын

Pois é amigo. Eu falo Português do Brasil, mas eu sou Cubano. O 'Portuga' me dá bronca pra entender a veses. Mesmo assim é mais pela pronuncia que pela gramática. O galego entendo mais, quase tudo, por causa da pronuncia que é Espanhola.

@rl_alterado6883

9 ай бұрын

A galícia costumava ser o norte de portugal Até que os espanhóis os tomaram, mas o idioma official da galicia é o próprio português.

@juandiegovalverde1982

8 ай бұрын

eso es porque el portugués de Portugal tiene una fonética muy diferente, en especial en Lisboa y más al sur y en Las Azores.

To me, Aragonese sounds like a mixture of Spanish and Catalan.

@Kongorlobo

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah. It also has a touch of Asturian for some reason.

@The1ByTheSea

3 жыл бұрын

Given that Aragon is next to Catalonia:it sounds like it has Catalan influences and entonations.

@aafiq2962

3 жыл бұрын

what i knew is from then until now is Latin Romance language is Spanish Italian French Portuguese Galician Catalan only

@unoreversecard4348

Ай бұрын

its between the 2 language families, western iberorromance (spanish, portuguese, asturleonese, galician) and occitan romance (occitan, catalan...)

As a Sefaradi Jew from a Turkish (from Istanbul) & European (Yugoslav, German/Austrian, Greek & Romanian) families I was raised with the language and when I heard “regular” Spanish for the first time I had a pretty similar reaction to yours when you heard Ladino just that I said something like “why are they speaking broken Ladino” (I was a kid) 😅😂

Mazal on finding out your Sephardi heritage! Ladino I’ve found can be harder to read rather than listen to for spanish speakers. But it’s mostly just 15th century spanish with a lot of loan words and it’s own phrases and sayings.

Es cierto que son muy pocas las diferencias entre el Ladino y el español moderno. Lo que pasa es que algunas consonantes son pronunciadas usando sus valores medievales. principal entre estas es la J y la G suave. Éstas consonantes comparten el mismo sonido que reciben en francés, portugués y catalán. En vez de ser aspirada como en el español moderno, se pronuncia exactamente como se pronuncia en estas otras lenguas. La S en medio de dos vocales es una sibilante vocalizada parecido a la Z en inglés. La Z se pronuncia igual. También algunas palabras que reciben una H al principio conservan la F original de latín. Esto se ven palabras como fazer (hacer) y fija (hija). La X también conserva su valor medieval que es el sonido exacto que se escucha en inglés con SH. Es decir, una sibilante palatalizada. Otra cosa que se observa es el reemplazo de M en ladino por N castellano Y palabras como muestra por decir nuestra y mozós para decir nosotros. Hay otras diferencias. Sin embargo, es tan parecido y tan familiar que cuando lo oímos en español, para nosotros, no registra como otra lengua. Estamos escuchando nuestro propio idioma nada más que otro variante.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Muchísimas gracias por todos estos datos. Te invitamos a suscribirte para que nos comentes más datos como estos.

Fellow Sephardic Jew here 🙋‍♂️ Ladino feels like a missing link between Portuguese and Spanish to me. Words such as “favlar” honestly just seem like a mash of the Portuguese “falar” and Spanish “hablar”. Some other words just sound like straight up Latin, like the word Dio (God), or like a Portuguese speaker pronouncing a Spanish word (the word “hijo” in Ladino is pronounced with a Portuguese-style J, not the Spanish sound at all). Another super interesting thing is that old texts can be written in the Hebrew alphabet. I can read Hebrew, so Ladino texts in the Hebrew script actually make me laugh a little - it’s so crazy to read this “Portuguese-flavoured Spanish” using the hebrew alphabet.

As a Brazilian Lusophone and I understand: 95% Aragonese 87% Ladino 99,8% Galego 95% Castillian

@ivokermartin3573

3 жыл бұрын

I'm the same, but Ladino seems easier than Aragonese, very simple to understand, even the "latin" terms said in the video sounds more Portuguese than Spanish (greeks-griegos-grecos-gregos)

@muammaralgaddaffi197

3 жыл бұрын

@@ivokermartin3573 Because portuguese and galician is same language

@dezmilcoisas

3 жыл бұрын

@@muammaralgaddaffi197 no, part of the same linguistic continuum, but different languages.

@muammaralgaddaffi197

3 жыл бұрын

@@dezmilcoisas Believe me, som galego. They are same languages. www.laopinioncoruna.es/coruna/2014/11/03/o-galego-o-portugues-son-24701740.html

@LUSO_

3 жыл бұрын

*O Harpy* I understand all also 🙂✌🏼 Even the PT-BR 😁😄🤗😋 Na zoeira mano✌🏼

I’m also descendent of Sephardic Jews who were expelled from Spain, then went to Portugal and then were kicked out to Brazil. Portugal allows us to get a Portuguese passport as historic debt reparation.

In more rural areas of Galicia the spoken galician is totally different to a point of being 99% identical to European Portuguese. The dude in your video likely speaks a "plastified" version of the language. There are some videos on youtube that you can check it out and compare.

@doctoralejandro1334

3 жыл бұрын

Not 99 but it's different, yeag

@CanisLupus1987

3 жыл бұрын

Still

@fwlenard

3 жыл бұрын

I was thinking that too. It would be interesting for him to analyze a native Galician speaker.

@levilima9925

3 жыл бұрын

WHERE ARE THOSE VIDEOS? I CANT FIND THEM AT ALL!

@FeelMetalMan

3 жыл бұрын

I rode the Camino de Santiago and met townsmen in deep Lugo with the thickest accent which makes galician much more complicated for a spaniard

I’m a Portuguese and I understood perfectly what the ladino guy was saying! 👌🏻🇵🇹

@reneperez2126

3 жыл бұрын

what about galician ? galician is the closest to portuguese

@johnhunt386

3 жыл бұрын

Hi Gonçalo. I hope you dont mind me pointing out something to you. In English, you should say simply, " I am Portuguese" and not " I am a Portuguese. I hear this mistake from people from Portugual all the time.

@reneperez2126

3 жыл бұрын

@@johnhunt386 ive heard/ read that the phrase i am /am a (nationality ) can be used interchangeably in english , with a slightly difference of meaning; obviously you have a better sense of the english language than i do

@johnhunt386

3 жыл бұрын

@@reneperez2126 You can say in English, I am American or an American so I guess that is possible. But for some reason it sounds weird or just incorrect to say I am a French, I am a Spanish. I am a Chinese, I am a Portuguese. That "a" can be followed by "citizen" and then it would sound perfectly fine. Its just that I have heard people from Portuguese who speak fluent English say and it sounds wrong and suprising that they would say it.

@reneperez2126

3 жыл бұрын

@@johnhunt386 definitbly sounds weird in spanish , i read that the a can be still put to use in english only cases when there is a need to express belonging to a certain group or nationality , maybe youve listened to stings song "englishman in NY ", he repeats im an englishman in NY like 100 times( i know is an edge case ) in the chorus but other than that it really sounds strange to use "i am a" when you mean youre from a given nation, i thought in english that phrase was interchangeable both in usage and meaning , thanks for clearing that out

Great video! I didn't know that Aragonese and Ladino were still alive.

There is also a dialect of Occitan called Aranese that is spoken in the Aran valley and is official in Catalunya.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Will add it to my list!!!

@bassmeisterD

3 жыл бұрын

Wow. I had never heard of that!

@brolin96

3 жыл бұрын

*Catalonia. That's how you spell it in English. Otherwise, I hope you use España instead of Spain or Deutschland instead of Germany.

@broccoli9308

3 жыл бұрын

​@@brolin96 Yeah sometimes I really hate exonyms. I mean I initially learned it as "Catalogne", then later as "Cataluña", then "Catalonia"… If I'm tired and the context is appropriate I default to the local name. I mean I reluctantly understand why I have to re-learn the way to say a "spruce" tree or other very specific vocab in x different languages. But toponyms? Proper nouns? I don't really see the point of each language having its own variant of remote place names. I also hate the fact that there are +10 different ways to say the name of the pope or other historical figures, it's stupid. We should just stick to the series of sound they used to refer to themselves.

Parece que ladino no es un idioma distinto sino un dialecto del español.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

A mi tambien me parece. Que opina la gente?

@markrossi5703

3 жыл бұрын

@@ConvoSpeak es espanol!

@danielamselli4980

3 жыл бұрын

Eso es parcialmente verdad. La gramática y la mayoría del vocabulario son españoles, aunque hay palabras y frases turcas, hebreas, árabes. También, la ortografía es muy diferente que la de español, como resultado de las influencias extranjeras como el imperio Otomano y los reinos árabes. Es una idioma muy bizarra, pero todavía comprensible.

@nautacomio1233

3 жыл бұрын

Es básicamente castellano antiguo, es decir el castellano que se hablaba en España cuando fueron expulsados, añadido a diferentes influencias de los idiomas de los lugares donde se asentaron.

@danielamselli4980

3 жыл бұрын

@@nautacomio1233 Si, estoy totalmente de acuerdo.

Why is this channel underrated its like the best language describing channel!

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Oh my god. that is very sweet Kristen! We hope to keep growing!

You are right. Ladino is Spanish the same way most Latin American Spanish is Spanish. It's descended from 15th century or earlier Spanish. The main difference is that it is a language spoken apart from the main languages in those places, which probably preserves a little more of the vocabulary, since it is preserved only within relatively small communities that are also usually at least bilingual with the more common languages in the area. Also, we can assume that the Spanish spoken in Latin America kept some kind of contact with Spain since, for awhile at least, much of it remained part of the Spanish Empire, whereas the Sephardic people who did not go to Latin America or Spanish-speaking countries probably mostly lost contact with Spain, which further aided in preserving older vocabulary.

Alguna vez has pensado en hablar más español en tú canal? Entiendo que es un canal para que los angloparlantes puedan aprender más de los acentos del español, pero me parecería bien que hablaras más español. Especialmente que eres bogotano y hablas rolo(mi acento preferido). Me encantaría que hicieras videos hablando y enseñándonos cómo hablar como un bogotano!

@juandiegovalverde1982

8 ай бұрын

de gustos y colores no hay nada escrito.

The deceased singer Eydie Gorme spoke Ladino.

@shampooing101

3 жыл бұрын

Her cousin was Neil Sadaka.

@caseyrogers573

3 жыл бұрын

Hank Azaria (from the simpsons, the birdcage, BrockMire) and his family are Ladino speakers.

@ricardoordonez5540

3 ай бұрын

Y gran bolerista, cantaba con Los Panchos.

Eu entendi as tres, mas hablo espanhol, português, galego. Ladino y aragonês no sabia que existo. Yet I found them easy to understand.

Sou português e vou comentar em português: entendi perfeitamente todas as palavras de todas as línguas aqui apresentadas!

@voltronsupremeFood

2 жыл бұрын

algumas palavras sao portugeusa. Falo agora e nao ahora. A parte que se fala é espanol é mais uma mistura de Portugues e espanol. Se vc falas as dois lingua vai enteder um 98% .

@johnny_ca

2 жыл бұрын

understood this and i’m spanish speaker

@heisenbones420

Жыл бұрын

Entiendo todo lo que dices cuando lo leo pero es más difícil entenderlo cuando lo escucho hablado

@josefernandez4807

Жыл бұрын

​@@voltronsupremeFood no o gallego é muito similar só portugueses De fato, é o portugues que desciende do gallego

@josefernandez4807

Жыл бұрын

O mais difícil de entender... é ao apresentador do vídeo (que fala em ingles)

Es increíble como Ladino y Gallego se entiendan perfecto, sobre todo el Ladino es prácticamente español

@manuelsastre5230

3 жыл бұрын

Muchos (me incluyo) lo consideran un dialecto del español

Muy interesante la variedad de español muy bien hecho aprendí much

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Gracias!

All these languages are very similar and that's beautiful, they are all dialects of Latin with influence of the preexistent languages of the peoples which inhabited each region of the Iberian peninsula prior to the arrival of the Romans.

@juandiegovalverde1982

8 ай бұрын

el español nació en Cantabria con influencia del euskera. Después al extenderse por Castilla recibió mucha influencia del árabe y el mozárabe.

Very interested since I'm part Galician and part Aragonese. Have heard Ladino spoken in person and in an Israeli movie. Seems is has not evolved as Spanish has. I could not follow Galician as a child but now I did! Rankings: Aragonese 3, Ladino 4, Galician 4. Really enjoyed your video, keep them coming!

@joseramonvieites8843

Жыл бұрын

Na idade media chamavanlhe galego simplesmente. Agora quer ser galelhano por mor dos malfalantes que tem como modelo o castelam.

I'm from Barcelona, my native language is Spanish. I understood everything In those 3 languages. And I had never realized that ladino was literally Spanish, I see no difference

This was a great video! I think I especially like Ladino, and Ladino songs are so lovely.. I wonder if all of these are dialects of Spanish, rather than distinct languages, though?

@avishaiedenburg1102

3 жыл бұрын

Max Weinreich, a Jewish linguist, had this to say on the topic of what constitutes a language vs. dialect: "a language is a dialect with an army and a fleet". Or in other words, it is political power that determines what's a language and what's a dialect. One of the reasons why Yiddish and Ladino are often regarded as distinct languages is that, at their later stages, these languages were spoken exclusively *outside* of their respective countries of origin, with German Jews adopting Hochdeutsch and Sephardi Jews living primarily in the Balkans and North Africa (as well as the Netherlands).

I just purchased a Ladino language book: Beginner's Ladino with Online Audio (Hippocrene Beginner's). I was able to understand almost everything. The written language is different but once you get used to it, it isn’t too difficult.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Sweet. I'll try to find it myself

@tiagodossantos1793

3 жыл бұрын

@@ConvoSpeak I bought it on Amazon.

Great video! Ladino is not a solidified ONE language. It is at its core Hebrew that’s been converted to Spanish with Aramaic. The ladino today varies on where you go to. Ladino spoken in Mexico could sound more like Spanish than Ladino in Morocco or Turkey. And even Turkish ladino has various dialects that has more Turkish loan words. :) hope this helps !

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

It helps a lot. Do you know where I could find videos of speakers of the different dialects of Ladino?

@johnblossom944

2 жыл бұрын

Also Ladino was spoken in different parts of Europe such as: Italy, Yugoslavia, Bulgaria, Romania, The Netherlands, Austria, Germany, Czech Republic and there was even a small community in Poland. Each of these groups had a different dialect with influences of the language that was spoken where they lived, It’s true there were/still are some differences in accents and dialects of spoken Ladino between different cities in Turkey.

I love this channel bro. Keep it up

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you!!!

Ladino started diverging from Spanish 500 years or so ago. But I think the way people speak it will depend on a lot of things - especially what country they live in, how immersed they are in Ladino, and how much contact they’ve had with standard Spanish. Unfortunately it’s dying out. I spoke with a Ladino speaker in Istanbul and understood most of what he said, but his language had many Turkish words in it, which is natural. Lots of the younger people didn’t grow up speaking Ladino since the population has shrunk there due to emigration to Istanbul. Many get interested and study standard Spanish. Of course the Jews of Thessaloníki were almost completely wiped out by the Germans in the 1940s, and only a fraction of that once major community survived and returned. So I would expect their Ladino to be more influenced by Greek today.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

That makes sense. I wonf r if there is an effort to keep the language alive

Soy de EE.UU. y claro, hablo inglés como mi lengua materna. Comencé a aprender el castellano a la edad de 32 años hace 25 años. Pude entender casi todo de los tres hablantes. ¡Gracias por el video!

Solo para aclarar, la mayoría de nosotros descendientes de judíos sefardíes que emigraron a las Américas durante la inquisición, nuestros antepasados no hablaban en ladino si no el castellano de la época. El se refiere específicamente al dialecto hablado por los judíos que arribaron al norte de África o tierras otomanas. Luego se fue incorporando elementos del árabe, del turco y otras influencias locales. Pero nuestros antepasados llegaron a las Américas hablando el castellano, o posiblemente otras lenguas como el catalán, valenciano, gallego etc de la época.

I think Galician jokes are more Latin American than Spanish. In Spain we have jokes for every region but those kind of jokes that you talk about we normally make about Lepe which is a small town in Andalucia. I can imagine that Latin Americans might have made more jokes about Galicians because among others, they're known for travelling a lot

I'm a native Portuguese speaker with a degree in French and Spanish. To me, the problem with those 3 languages is that they are all found within the boundaries of Spain and as such they are all influenced and tainted by Spanish (the dominant language). All their speakers also speak Spanish as their first language. Phonetically they just all sounded like continental Spanish to me. There were some parts of the Aragonés that I did not understand but perhaps it was due to the quality of the audio. Portuguese does not sound like that at all; neither the Brazilian version or the continental version, especially not the continental version. In Portuguese we have all the nasalized sounds which Galician does not have and overall Portuguese is quite a bit more distant from Spanish than Galician. With that being said, I also like Galician. After all, it's how Portuguese was born.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you for sharing your insight. You are right about Galician. Did you find other similarities between Galician and your first language?

@Alex-fv2qs

3 жыл бұрын

Ladino didn't have much contact with Spanish until fairly recently, perhaps with the exception of Haketía (the morrocan dialect of Ladino), as it developed independently in the eastern Mediterranean

As a brazilian i understand 98% Galician! Brazilian portuguese sounds is more close to Galician than European portuguese, this is so crazy haha!

Italian guy here. I think I got 99% of Gallego and Ladino. Pretty cool

@johnblossom944

2 жыл бұрын

Ladino has some influence from Italian in the spoken and written language

Comprendí más ladino que aragonés. Me encontré arangonés más difícil. De viajar a España muchas veces, siempre he entendido el gallego. El arangonés para mí fue el más difícil.

Hablo español de nacimiento pero también tengo un nivel avanzado de portugués. El que más entendí fue el Galician por mucho, después el ladino y de ultimo el aragonés.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Que interesante. Muchas gracias por tu opinión. No olvides suscribirte.

As a Brazilian,I agreed to you,Galician is a Portuguese with Spanish accent!

In Italy we have another language called "Ladino", but it's a language that evolve separately from romance language and it's more arcaic.

More romance or old language like Romansh ,Romania,Sardinian ,dalmatian ,proto indo european ,celtiberian,Gaulish how it mutual intelligibility to spanish check "ILoveLanguages!" chanel it look language library

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Absolutely. Will start checking them out!! and subscribe so you can watch the videos as they come out!

The Aragonese sample is kinda bad. It shows so much that he isn't native and that he was translating from Spanish in his head. Besides, he uses one of the created varieties (they aren't recognised, thanks god) that were created without following any linguistic criteria. It has some incorrect things and ignores many Aragonese words or expressions. I'd recommend other sources closer to the real language.

@davidprimo8236

3 жыл бұрын

Astí, que se note qui en sabe!✊

@guillemhidalgogomez6918

3 жыл бұрын

I agree.

@DiegoPVES

3 жыл бұрын

Hola bonico

@jinengi

3 жыл бұрын

@@DiegoPVES Oy! Hola queriu! Qué fas per aquí?? Cómo va tot? La tia Pepeta ya s'ha recuperau d'ixa malaldia des pulmons que teneva? Besez a toz 🥰

@DiegoPVES

3 жыл бұрын

@@jinengi La Pepeta planta bien fuerte, ya sale de planta i hue la tenim per casa dando mal 😉😉 Los chicos tamién perfectos, ai qui pillase estas edatz, eh? 🤭🤭🤭 I tú, bonico, que m'han contau que estás festejando con uno... Que pajaro! 🤭😘😘😘 Besetz!

Galician sounds the way it does because it was drastically forced to speak Castilian Spanish and it heavily changed the sound and accent of the language, the base of the language is Portuguese

@ricardoordonez5540

3 ай бұрын

I heard that Portuguese comes from Galician.

Those three are near 100 % mutually intelligible with Spanish. It may vary depending on the topic. You'll find more variety among spoken Spanish vernaculars. Try Cuban, Dominican, Puerto Rican, Andalusian or Chilean vernaculars. Aragonese, Ladino and Galician are piece of cake, no challenge.

Very fascinating! You asked the same questions I have: How can these be different LANGUAGES when Spanish from Spain and Cuba are just as different? I speak Mexican Spanish and I could understand all three of these far better than my friend from the Dominican Republic.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

It is indeed a good point. Sometimes language divisions are created for political or cultural reasons

@aafiq2962

3 жыл бұрын

some of people that Claimed that Mexican Spanish exactly same like Spanish from Spain

Even as a beginner I understood about 60% of the Ladino, ¡que guay! Viva España❤️ I can’t remember, but had you done Basque in this series yet?👀

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

I'll include Basque. I anticipate it is going to be hard. Muchas gracias amigo por todo tu apoyo!

@alvaro6587

3 жыл бұрын

Basque is impossible to understand to native spanish speakers, It is all what is left of the ancient pre-roman languages of Iberia

@jorgelotr3752

3 жыл бұрын

@@alvaro6587 to be more precise, from the north of the Iberian peninsula and south of France; the most it has been able to be traced back, it descends from a language called aquitanian, that went extinc somewhere around the early Middle Ages.

Ola dende Galicia Alive! Con respecto a los chistes sobre gallegos no son utilizados en España sino en zonas de América Latina: Argentina, Venezuela... Saudiños!

@galiciaalive

3 жыл бұрын

Con respecto al origen, éste podría ser debido a la enorme emigración que hubo desde Galicia a América Latina durante los siglos XIX y XX, donde en muchos casos eran personas con bajo nivel de estudios. Para que os hagáis una idea de la cantidad de emigrantes gallegos que se fueron, se pueden ver los Centros Gallegos dispersos por el continente: galiciaalive.com/es_ES/mapa-dos-centros-galegos-en-america-do-sur/

I think Galicia is seen differently bc they have more in common with Portugal than Spain. There was even a time when a soccer game Spain vs Portugal and most from Galicia supported Portugal.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Really? That's crazy. Thanks for sharing that insight. Any push for Galicia being more connected to Portugal?

@GringoCanoIngles

3 жыл бұрын

@@ConvoSpeak I think there are segments of the segments of the population of Galicia that would like to secede from Spain and re unite with Portugal. The feelings may be due to Spain making their language "illegal" at one time and forcing everyone to speak in spanish. Basically many did not like Spain forcing them to change their ways.

@CarlesPerez77

3 жыл бұрын

i can tell you that is not correct, most of galicians adore spain and also portugal, but if they had to choose....the 90% will choose spain...

@diogorodrigues747

3 жыл бұрын

@@CarlesPerez77 You're a troll...

@mikeold55

3 жыл бұрын

@@ConvoSpeak Yes, I am Galician and I would like to be part of Portugal, not Spain! because our culture is more similar to the Portuguese. The Galicians are not going to see how the Spanish kill the bulls and we do not dance flamenco either! : D

I am so glad I found your channel! I don’t know if you’ve seen The Beauty Queen of Jerusalem, but one of the main languages spoken in it is Ladino. Also, my first language is English but I speak Spanish and I agree about the rhythm of Galician. For me, that rhythm sounded the most like Spanish. And my mind is blown about Aragonese and the history behind it. I’m so excited to research it. 🤩

Holà. Soy frances y estoy aprendiendo el Euskara tambien. Vivan las lenguas de Espana !

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Que vivan!

Prácticamente se entienden todos. Ahora, menudo larpero el de Zaragoza, he oído hablar aragonés de gente del Pirineo y sonaban mucho más auténticos. Seguro que ese de Zaragoza lo aprendió para hacer el paripé independentista. Quería ser abertzale, pero nació en Calatayud.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Has escuchado el Gallego tambien de casualidad hablado por gente mas nativa?

@ithbem5372

3 жыл бұрын

@@ConvoSpeak Sí y se distingue bastante del gallego "académico" de escuela, la entonación del gallego es muy característica y los nuevos hablantes de las ciudades suelen emplear una entonación castellanizada mientras hablan gallego, el chaval del vídeo es un ejemplo de esto último. Conozco a gallegos cuya lengua materna es el gallego que al hablar presentan entonación y fonética gallega y se hace más difícil de entender para alguien castellano.

@Kongorlobo

3 жыл бұрын

Vi el video en su dia y si, lo has calado JAJAJAJ creo recordar que el tio ni siquiera es de familia aragonesa, pero bueno está bien reivindicar el idioma

@ithbem5372

3 жыл бұрын

@@Kongorlobo A mí me parece bien, sobretodo el aragonés que corre grave riesgo de desaparecer, pero la tontería indepe batasunera solo repele a gente interesada en aprender el idioma.

THey're all beautiful. I understood all of them almost equally,. Galician was definitely the more pleasant sounding one.

Ladino looks like Portuguese from Portugal. I understand it 100%

Catherine of Aragon had her father's title but she was herself born in Castile. Her mother was Isabella of Castile.

Sou brasileiro, pra mim o mais compreensível de todos também foi o Ladino. Talvez seja porque o falante de Ladino falou pausadamente.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

You have a point there about him. He was very clear

@samidato

3 жыл бұрын

I don't find galician similar to portuguese

@hermanot0rres

3 жыл бұрын

@@samidato Me neither. But people on KZread like to lie. 😂 I saw several Brazilians saying that they understand perfectly, they understand even better than Portuguese from Portugal. Lying people lol

@samidato

3 жыл бұрын

@@hermanot0rres Seguro, una cosa es comprender cómo se escribe, otra cosa como se habla

@diogorodrigues747

3 жыл бұрын

@@hermanot0rres Galicia is the closest to Portuguese and it's actually very understandable. His pronounciation was too castillianized: kzread.info/dash/bejne/rJ-HqpifZd2ee5s.html

Lindo video, se entienden los tres casi perfectamente, creo yo. Da la impresión que "Aragonese" se habla con sintaxis castellana, corríjanme si me equivoco. Ladino es una variedad dialectal antigua de la lengua castellana, no es una lengua en sí. El gallego se que es ... a miña avoa chapurreaba en galego :-)

@jinengi

3 жыл бұрын

En cuanto al aragonés, usa un modelo bastante regular, por no decir otras cosas. Es un mal ejemplo, bastante alejado de la lengua viva.

Galician and portugueses is both a variant of the same language: "galego-portuguesa" . The GREAT difference is that the "Galego" is talked/spoken with caastillian acent.

@luisteixeiraneves4211

2 жыл бұрын

Hoje! Por uns tantos. Mas o sotaque castelhano não lhe faz falta nenhuma. Há 40 anos, o primeiro galego que ouvi, não tinha nenhum sotaque castelhano.

7:41 Es un idioma separado porque tiene su propia escritura y ortografía, mas allá de que hay palabras que si suenan distintas a las que podríamos usar. Si los podemos entender, pero dudo que a la hora de leer un texto sea totalmente entendible para nosotros.

@anlingitalia

3 жыл бұрын

Y parece que el hablante de ladino conoce algo del español estándar. No todos hablan así. He visto vídeos de otros hablantes y a mí personalmente me cuesta entenderles aunque sea posible después de escuchar repetidas veces.

Cuando estudié en Alemania. Conocí a un turco que hablaba español .. entendía todo..era un judeo español fue mi gran amigo..!!!! .no olvidaré nunca a IZAAK ..

I think Ladin is old Spanish frozen in time 1492. I would give it a 5 like you .

I know a Galician friend sounds Almost like Portuguese except for b/V (similar to Northern Portuguese) and they pronounce ão as (on)

There’s a Mexican film, “Novia que te vea” in which both Mexican Spanish and Ladino (Judeo-Spanish) are spoken. Ladino-speakers emigrated from Turkey and Greece to Latin America - especially Argentina - around and just after World War I. The Ladino that was spoken in the former Ottoman Empire includes many words from Hebrew (there’s a dictionary of Hebraisms in Ladino), along with French, Italian, and Turkish vocabulary. I think that the Ladino speaker in the video was making a conscious effort to make himself understood to Spanish speakers. The phonology of Judeo-Spanish includes sounds that are absent or very rare in modern Spanish, such as “sh” and “dj.”

As an Italian Teacher of Spanish Language and literature I had no problem in understanding the three of them. I rank them 5.

Im Brazilian and I think I understood almost everything of Aragonese, I might have lost a few words. I understood 100% of Ladino and Galician.

@alexfsans

3 жыл бұрын

Você entendeu o galego porque é a mesma língua que falamos. A diferença é regional, apenas. E, claro, política.

@RafaelMarques-ul6pz

3 жыл бұрын

@@alexfsans viva o galego-portugues! Tenho maior vontade de conhecer a Galiza e falar com os galegos com.o meu sotaque brasileiro pra ver se me entendem e se eu entendo vocês também! Abraços lusófonos amigo galego!

@wallacesousuke1433

2 жыл бұрын

@@alexfsans não exatamente, "professor"

In Spain when we make jokes we don't mock galicians, we mock people from Lepe. "Gallego" in Argentina is used to refer to spaniards, and we are the target of their jokes. "Gallego" jokes would later spread throughout Latin America.

As for Ladino..it was written with Hebrew alphabet. I believe in Turkey Ladino is written in the Latin language, however the spelling is actually more phonetic than Spanish, for example instead of writing qué, the Ladino of Turkey spells this word ke.

Loved it. I would love to have seen Austurian-Leonese in this video. Do you already have a video of that?

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Not Asturian Leonese, but I will include it soon. What other languages do you recommend I post>

@TreyMichael

3 жыл бұрын

@@ConvoSpeak other minority languages in Spain such as Aranés, Fala or Llanito. If you could find a recording of the extinct Mozarabe that would cool too. Portunhol/Portuñol from Brazil/Uruguay. Spanish spoken in Africa (Equatorial Guinea and Western Sahara) would make for an interesting video as well.

Anybody has more info about ladino?

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Please share!

@danielamselli4980

3 жыл бұрын

It was spoken by Jews exiled from Spain in 1492 under the Alhambra Decree. In terms of the language, it’s essentially written and takes on Spanish grammar. The vocabulary takes a lot of loanwords from Turkish (as some Jews fled to Salonica and other parts of the Ottoman Empire), Hebrew (as they are Jewish), and other random words. Spelling is completely different to Spanish. The phonology is very different, but that doesn’t make it much less incomprehensible.

@dummlp

3 жыл бұрын

kzread.info/dash/bejne/hYl_2aOEY8TJgpc.html some traditional ballads in judeo espagnol and hebrew

@dummlp

3 жыл бұрын

It was spoken by the Jewish community in Thessaloniki, unfortunately like 98 per cent of them were murdered by the Germans in World War 2. There are some speakers of Ladino in Istanbul and Israel, but I'm not sure how many people actually grow up speaking Ladino these days. Probably no one :(

@dummlp

3 жыл бұрын

You can find plenty of Ladino music on KZread

Soy brasileño y entendí el 95% de lo que dijo este chico que habla gallego, también puedo entender a los hispanohablantes de la misma manera sin haber estudiado español.

Ladino is a mix of medieval Spanish as the base with Portuguese ( closer to Galician which is proto-portuguese ), Hebrew and the region that any Sephardic person settled in. Galician is very similar to Brazilian Portuguese.

L'aragonés (idioma aragonés u luenga aragonesa) ye un idioma romance, luenga propia d'Aragón, parlato por bellas 25.556 personas sobretot en as comarcas pirinencas y prepirinencas d'o norte d'Aragón. En as atras comarcas aragonesas a on que se charró l'idioma, hue o substrato y influencia de l'aragonés ye encara perceptible en o castellano que se i fabla, mas que mas en os aragonesismos lexicos.

Soy de España y para nada Galicia es la región con la que la gente hace bromas (las hay, como de Cataluña, País Vasco etc.), pero la región de la que se suele hacer más bromas aquí es el pueblo de Lepe (las típicas de "sabes porque en Lepe..."). Dónde si tienen un montón de chistes burlones de "gallegos" (para ellos, españoles) es en argentina. Lo digo porqué quizás esos chistes te llegaron de ahí, y si te llegaron de España te aseguro que la región "de hacer bromas" no es Galicia en absoluto, lo que es típico es que hay clichés de cada región (en Andalucía son vagos, en Galicia indecisos, en Cataluña tacaños, en el País Vasco rudos, en Murcia tontos(?) etc.) y de ahí que hay chistes, pero no se ceban todos en una región en concreto salvo el pueblo de Lepe que es con el que se hacen todos los de "Sabes porque en Lepe..." o "sabes porque los de Lepe..." También decir que casi nadie a día de hoy se ofende por estos chistes y la gente suele ironizar con los clichés de su propia región y hacer broma, aquí en Cataluña es muy normal oír cosas como "Que soy Catalán eh" cuando cometen actos supuestamente tacaños.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Gracias por compartir tus comentarios 😊

@qtkrtf474

3 жыл бұрын

@@ConvoSpeak Gracias a ti por responder! Muy buenos videos por cierto!

@Alex-fv2qs

3 жыл бұрын

Los chistes de gallegos son algo más de algunos países latinoamericanos, especialmente Argentina y Uruguay Durante la época de la inmigración europea a fines del s xix y comienzos del 20, hubo mucha inmigración de Galicia y se formó el estereotipo de que eran brutos o ignorantes. También muchos de estos chistes no son específicamente sobre gallegos ya porque tomamos "gallego" como una manera informal de referirnos a cualquier persona o cosa de España, por más que sea catalán, sevillano, madrileño, etc, así como "Tano" (apócope de Napolitano) paso a usarse para cualquier cosa relacionada a Italia

Me encanta tu video. Los puntajes fueron exactos a los tuyos. Muy interesante. Criado en Estados Unidos y Colombia. Gracias pir estos datos interesantes.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Gracias hermano

el idioma más parecido al español es el astur-leonés. El aragonés varía mucho de pueblo en pueblo, algunos dialectos pareciéndose más al castellano y otros más al catalán. No tiene una versión estándar. El asturiano sí tiene una versión estándar en Asturias, que es una de sus lenguas oficiales.

I forgot to comment (yes I also speak fluent English), that I undertood all 3 almost completely and would've given Aragones the lowest ranking as a 3. But I am biased, because I speak Portuguese, so for this reason Galician was the clearest one to me after Ladino. For me Aragonese sounds more foreign and kind of ancient.

As an Israeli jewish, I recognized here that he said "Kimat" which means "almost" in hebrew 5:57

I speak fluent Spanish, Portuguese, and of course English. To me, from what I heard on this video, Aragonese is basically Spanish, with some different words used locally, but also the word for speak is not hablar, but fablar. Sort of a Portuguese X Spanish hybrid word. I suspect there are more words like this, that a fluent speaker would use. I totally understand what I heard here. Galician has more "Portuguese" overtones to it. I can understand less than in Aragonese from what I heard here. I can distinguish the Portuguese grammar style and vocabulary and that helps. But the word for motherland (Tierra Madre) in Spanish is (Terra nai) in Galician. Nai being the uniquely Galician word, neither Portuguese (mãe) or Spanish (madre). Ladino, I understood everything taking into account words that I could easily identify as Latin or Portuguese. This form is probably close to the Castillian usage of the 15th century or (Old Spanish). I would like to study this language further. It is fascinating.

I'm a native English speaker fluent in Portuguese and even I could understand 90% of Ladino. Although if someone was speaking it to me I would have no idea it wasn't Spanish

My father's native language is Spanish (His parents could not get into America given the quota, so they went to Cuba instead), and there was a Turkish guy in the synagogue I grew up in, and they would speak in Spanish and Ladino.

As a Portuguese my thought is that most Galiian is so influenced by Castillian that it has become Portunhol. Words similar to Portuguese (and therefor still also to Spanish) pronounciation is really 100% Spanish and has got zero to do with Portuguese. That is this guy. Others can talk a a Galician that is closer in pronounciation to Portuguese btw but I see this rarely on youtube. It is not good or bad, languages simply evolve in their ways and diversify. I think it is actually a nice thing!

Is the Galician speaker Galician? Ir did he learn it... doesn't sound like other Galician I've heard

0:46 - that is Joanna of Castile, Catherine of Aragon's older sister.

The Greek dude speaking in ladino is basically how every Dominican/puerto rican speaks, but sounds closer to the Dominican side

Only in Latin America do they make Galician jokes. In Spain they make fun of the people of Lepe which is a town in Andalucía.

Didn’t know that very interesting Great channel

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you so much. For sure welcome to our community!

Cool video! Thanks for following up, man. Muy bien. Despite all the varieties of Romance similar to each other in Iberia, Spanish America is the exclusive domain of Castillian. Yeah, I think Aragonese is definitely a dialect of Spanish; Ladino is more of an accent, and Gallician the perfect mix between Portuguese and Castillian. Gracias por tus videos.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks for the tips Shane. Appreciate it!

@loboguardian2760

3 жыл бұрын

El aragonés es un idioma diferente al español o castellano, creeme, aunque parezca que entiendes algunas palabras, en una conversación no pillarías de qué se está hablando, se parece mucho al catalán, porque el aragonés viene del occitano gascón históricamente, es más parecido al aranés

@Kongorlobo

3 жыл бұрын

Aragonese is a different language, close to Catalan and Aranese and of course similar to Spanish.

Sí el aragonés y gallego son entendidos por todos los hispanohablantes, a parte de que estén muy aparentadas con el español sus hablantes en su gran mayoria también son hispanohablantes así que esas lenguas suenan exactamente igual que el español de españa, así que no hay ninguna dificultad de compresión como si nos pasa con nuestros vecinos portugueses, pese a que su lengua está muy hermanada cn la castellana, el djudeo español es el castellano que se hablaba en la edad moderna, con algúna que otra palabra añadida de otras lenguas así que al margen de alguna palabra puntual no hay ninguna dificultad de comprexión tampoco.

@jacoboarca8516

2 жыл бұрын

El español es una mezcla de todos los romances ibéricos por eso suenan tan parecidos entre ellos. Lo que era castellano es incluso un dialecto de lo hablado en la actual región de Galicia, Asturias y León con fuerte influencia del vascuence y del navarro-aragonés. Por eso se llama español.

@anshar2503

2 жыл бұрын

@@jacoboarca8516 No, tampoco es una mezcla de nada, simplemente es una variedad más del romance iberico, que fue evolucionando y desmarcandose más del resto de dialectos, y se llama español por la misma razón que el toscano se llama italiano, por ser la lengua mayoritaria del territorio, además de esa mania nacional de limitar un territorio con una sola yúnica lengua.

@jacoboarca8516

2 жыл бұрын

@@anshar2503 como gallego y hablante de gallego puedo decirte que lo que en ese vídeo se escucha tiene mucha más similitud con el gallego que con lo que estamos hablando ahora. Las evoluciones de las lenguas se dan por el contacto con otras, de ahí que la lengua que se impuso como común haya tenido tanta evolución y el gallego se haya quedado más próximo al latín. Y no, el español no es el caso del toscano, donde se impuso una lengua común ya evolucionada en el siglo XX. El castellano se impuso como común en su día debido a la necesidad de unidad lingüística en el siglo XIII y evolucionó debido a la aportación de todos los hablantes de español en ambos hemisferios. Rafael Lepesa te explicaría bastante mejor la historia de la lengua española, ya que él era lingüista y yo no.

also in Italy there is Ladino, but it is completly different languages from the spanish Ladino

Ladino is basically Old Spanish. For example : the J is pronounces as in Portuguese: mujer is pronounced muzher

Ladino is Old Spanish , and 600 years ago would have been indistinguishable from the Spanish spoken at that time , apart from a few Hebrew words. After the expulsion , over the centuries, Ladino has been influenced by the different countries and cultures where the Sephardic Jews migrated to.

Como falante nativo de português (Brasil), nem preciso dizer que entendi o galego completamente. A real surpresa aqui para mim foi o fato do ladino ser mais foneticamente similar ao português do que o castelhano atual o é, e também algumas semelhanças do aragonês com o galego/português, como os artigos "O" e "A" e suas contrações "d'o/d'a", assim como o "eix/aix" em várias palavras onde no espanhol seria "ej/aj", (ex.: bajo / baixo) - esta última característica também compartilhada com o catalão.

@ConvoSpeak

3 жыл бұрын

Muy interesante gracias por compartir. Hablas castellano?

@skuder491

3 жыл бұрын

@@ConvoSpeak Muy poco - cuando lo intento, siempre hablo con manierismos del portugués sin darme cuenta y termina siendo más 'portuñol' que castellano propiamente dicho! Hahah A propósito, ótimo vídeo!