71 year old BTS Army here. This song is based on a quote from the late great choreographer Martha Graham. "A dancer dies twice - once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful." It is about an artist eventually losing their passion and/or the difficult forced retirement of a career dancer. Thank you for your reaction!! 💜

You didn't watch the end had you played it out you would have seen that the Shadow is defeated and fall down to nothing. The song is about their real fear of losing their passion for their art eg Song writing, composing, producing, rapping, Singing, Dancing even just going up on stage. This was their real fear at one point due to being exhausted physically and mentally. However they overcame it as they were able to take a couple of weeks off. The 'Shadow' is part of Jungian Psychology along with 'Persona and Ego' Shadow being the part of the mind where we hid are darkest and thoughts, feelings fears from other that plague us. The 'Shadow' (their fears) were conquered thankfully and they continued to go from strength to strength.

@Maraaha55

28 күн бұрын

Yes: I too was going to point out that with Every BTS MV you MUST watch to the end, because there is always something more. In addition I do sometimes wonder whether those reactors who fail to watch through to the end are entirely sincere in their practices of reacting to BTS. Jury is out here with this gentleman, who seems OK, but I truly encourage him to watch the whole complete offering from BTS, because BTS always fill every moment with meaning...

@alicesworld1

25 күн бұрын

Excellent explanation Eileen! 💜

@Mark-vj7zd

18 күн бұрын

Hmmmm. The shadow isn’t defeated, it’s accepted as an inevitable part of their humanity. Jung writes about the reconciliation between Persona and Shadow through the Ego. It’s an important distinction and something they’ve been returning to ever since B,S &T. Without the shadow there is no creativity, only the mask.

With "Black Swan," BTS divulge their most harrowing shadow yet, one that any person who lives for making art faces: losing the passion for creating. "A dancer dies twice - once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful." Martha Graham. This quote is at the root of the sentiments inlaid in "Black Swan." Much like a dancer feels purposeless when they can no longer express themselves through dance, BTS contends that the day that music no longer fills them with the same passionate fire as before, or even if there came a day when they stopped creating music - what they feel is their life's purpose - it would feel like death. RM sings, "If this can no longer resonate / No longer make my heart vibrate / Then this may be how I die my first death." Once again, BTS affirm that despite their countless record-breaking accolades, the wealth they've amassed, and their ever-increasing fame, they are artists. What means most to them is the art - music, visuals, dances - that they create. 💜

Yes BTS is a group of 7 SUPERSTARS 🫶💜

so glad you are enjoying the journey. They touch so many peoples lives in so many ways in addition to their music. They honestly are 7 of the most humble, generous, kind individuals behind all this amazing talent.

Thanks for reacting BTS. I hope you can react BTS - ON Manifesto Come Prima and BTS - Blood Sweat and Tears..

There live performances are even better. Check out Magic Shop live with English subtitles 💜

They're amazing artists and genuinely good people. Thanks for reacting to BTS. 💜

You are so right about their music videos being mini movies. I can see you’ve reacted to On Kinetic Manifesto film. BTS have a ton of great videos with my all time faves, PURELY FROM A FILM MAKING POINT OF VIEW, being Daechwita, Haegeum and Love Wins All - the first 2 are solo Suga (he goes by August D as a soloist) and the last is actually another Korean artist IU - but BTS V acts in the MV so I’m including it in my list. There’s no loss to you, IU is a beautiful singer.

Thank you for reacting on BTS😊. Looking forward to your next reaction❤

So glad you enjoyed this, it happens to be my favorite from BTS 💜🖤🫰they really are incredible, diverse artists.

Love the song and your reactions

You respect, appreciate and compliment BTS -I subscribe 🙏🏼💜 Thank you for reacting to our gorgeous guys 💜💜💜

Iconic jungkook 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🥰

I like all comments

Black Swan ilustra a morte como uma etapa da vida, como o fim de um ciclo. Como se algo que se tornou ruim, morresse, para que o que ficou de bom pudesse renascer de forma mais brilhante e intensa. "My heart no longer accelerates when I hear the music play, It's trying to stop, it's like time has stopped, oh This would be my first death, which I was always afraid of.” Podemos então deduzir que o primeiro medo de um músico seria perder o amor genuíno pela música. Ou no caso descobrir que sua imagem é mais consumida do que a arte que ele tanto se esforça para criar. Essa seria a primeira morte, e os sete juntos, seriam o cisne. Nesse ponto também relacionamos à busca da perfeição, à crítica à indústria que exige o público, aos charts, aos estereótipos, à fetichização, etc. A escolha do teatro, do palco é o local de trabalho do artista, onde suas personas se manifestam. O BTS traz os conceitos da Psicologia de Carl Jung, mostrando que no palco o artista transita entre Persona e Sombra (observem as sombras no MV que mostram movimentos diferentes dos artistas). Persona se define por ser não aquilo que se é realmente, mas a quilo que se acha que é e o que as pessoas acham que se é . É uma combinação das expectativas do sujeito consigo mesmo com as expectativas da sociedade quanto ele próprio. E Sombra é o oposto, o que se tenta esconder, o que está oculto e muitas vezes é o que se projeta no outro . Os espelhos surgem oara mostrar uma busca pelo íntimo, a busca pelo que há no interno, a busca pelo outro que habita nele próprio, busca para o autoconhecimento, é preciso mergulhar e abraçar suas sombras, usá-las a seu favor. Nesse trecho a seguir: "Deeper Yes, I think I'm going deeper I keep losing focus No, let me go Let my own feet guide me I will dive into myself In my deepest interior”...aqui o BTS nos mostra que é necessário ficar vulnerável, estar disposto a mergulhar para acessar e trabalhar em seu autoconhecimento. No MV podemos ver o uso de espartilho de couro em Jimin e Jungkook, um objeto muito utilizado no imaginário da fetichização. Seria aqui mais uma vez uma crítica à indústria musical que coloca artistas para assumirem um Eu ideal que foge do Eu Real? Podemos notar também a transição das roupas brancas para as pretas, visto no momento icônico em que surgem asas negras em Jimin. Vemos o movimento no qual seu peito - onde o coração justamente está - se abriu, realizando um cambré. Fazendo uma alusão ao filme com Natalie Portman, ela fez os giros com essas asas, e é quando ela se deixa ser tomada pela sombra. Podemos dizer que aqui o artista aceita sua sombra, ou seja, já conhece a si mesmo em sua totalidade. Sabemos que com o BTS nada é por acaso. Lancem aqui suas ideias. Adoraria conhecê-las. Sou Patrícia Carneiro, tenho 45 anos, sou army e sou psicóloga.🇧🇷💜

JIMIN IS the Black Swan I think the thumbnail with wings is Jimin , that's all thank you

Glad to see you appreciating BTS. They are an endless source of inspiration and joy. Jimin dances so beautifully in this.

If you like this, and are interested in a song that looks starkly at the ways we lie to ourselves before snapping out of it, maybe check out the video for Fake Love. It's considered a BTS ultimate classic and is an iconic song with choreo that newer groups study for the sake of passionate performance.

estoy muy feliz de reaccionar tus videos soy una army , un saludo desde ecuador

Saludos desde nicaragua gracias por su reacción

I am enjoying your reactions but please pause at the end as just when you think the video is over, it's not. Many BTS songs have deep meanings & sadly, you missed the end of this one. Some of their videos also connect to each other, so please always pause at the end, & always have subtitles turned on. Thank you.

Jimin es genial y único voz angelical y un gran bailarín