Brilliant discussion sir. We need such simple, clear and honest opinions backed by facts rather than the meaningless blame game. I will share this with the hope more and more people see this debate.

Wonderful discussions. We need such elaborative explainations.

SALUTE TO DOCTOR ISHTIAQ AHMED.

This is a valuable and engaging conversation 👍

What a great Human being and Scholar He is. May God Give him long life

बेहतरीन प्रोग्राम सर जी मज़ा आया और बहुत ज्ञानवर्धक 🙏

Two nation theory was the British theory. Jinnah was persuaded by them to accept. Around 1930/31 Jinnah migrated to England. Lived and practiced there and had nothing to do with India. Then around 1935 he returned to India and plunged in to politics headlong. Perhaps lured by the British in to returning.

@iconoclastbhatti8159

3 жыл бұрын

Well its been good documented that several delegations of Muslim League went to see him in England.... they convinced him get back to India and to lead Muslim league

@mianzahor0

3 жыл бұрын

Two nation theory is the fact. Its present from the day human are created. Sir syed present it on political level and Jinnah worked on it.

@tahirqureshi8606

3 жыл бұрын

Punjabis killed Punjabis, Bengalis killed Bengalis and Sindhis killed Sindhis.......So in the Subcontinent religion is very significant...

@malikzubair8435

3 жыл бұрын

It's not india at that time it's called Hindustan*

@sameeralee8068

2 жыл бұрын

Jinnah was involved in politics Since 1904, he strongly believed in the Hindu muslim unity and he believed only by this unity people of India can be benefitted at very larger scale. Furthermore he was entitled as ambassador of Hindu muslim unity in 1916. But after 1920, Mahatma Gandhi's non co-operation movement, he gradually felt insecurity for muslims and 1930 he fully realized it that their is no future of muslims along with Hindu majority rule. He left india in 1930 because of non co-operation and diversity thinking of his own very league's people. But Jinnah has came through a very long political Struggle since he left England after completing his degree at Lincoln's Bar. Jinnah, the game changer♥😘

I think this is a intellectual debate with true knowledge of history where people without knowledge must not comment, just likes and dislikes would be good. For me if I have to comment on this I will have to spend some time to study this topic from different sources, compare and a analyse them, and then give my comments. Thankyou.

What do you think about how Jaun Elia said about Pakistan that "yeh sab Aligarh ke laundon ki sharaarat thi".

@ammirza8323

3 жыл бұрын

He didn't said it about Pakistan.He said this about partition.

@harisadu8998

3 жыл бұрын

@@ammirza8323 Partition and Pakistan are the same thing. How can there be Pakistan if there's no partition? The partition meant Pakistan. Secondly, if he's talking about partition and not Pakistan, then he clearly is saying that all of the blame is with people from Aligarh Muslim University and the Hindus had zero blame.

@shahidsohail4763

3 жыл бұрын

Jaun was not representative of common people as he was not elected in parliaments. Second I would appreciate if you say words on Khushwant Singh book in which he is praising Quaid e Azam.

@ritesharora4207

3 жыл бұрын

Right all movement started in UP and not in Punjab

Very critical analysis,pondering each phenomenons .

Right and Informative show🥰🥰.

Very knowledgeably discussing the reality of that time politics,

Very informative 👍

Very nice discussion

गुरुओं के जिस दर्जे की बात आप कर रहे हैं, वह भारतीय "समाज" में कभी था। अब वह दर्जा कुछ हद तक आपकी पीढ़ी में है। बाद वाली पीढ़ियों में ऐसा नहीं है। जो थोड़ा बहुत है वो दिखावे के लिए है। वरना कई महाविद्यालयों में पढ़ाने वाले शिक्षक महीनों बिना वेतन के उधार पर जीवन व्यतीत करने के लिए बाध्य हैं।

@dilipjoshi7346

3 жыл бұрын

वाह वाह क्या बात है । बिना कहे यह समझ में आ रहा है कि यहाँ बातें " सम्मान " की करते हैं और व्यवहार ?

Very Good Effort in bringing Ishtiyaq sb

Any one intrested in the subject can find the facts in British library london where every moves are been recorded by the British. Its just that they dont teach their bad image in the history books, just teach students about their glorious history as most of the countries do.

शानदार विडियो बनाया इतिहास से रूबरू हर भारतीय को होना चाहिए

Very good discussion

Punjabis killed Punjabis, Sindhis killed Sindhis and Bengalis killed Bengalis...So religion is stronger than culture and language in the Subcontinent...

@stormiwebster917

3 жыл бұрын

Muslim killed Muslim 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣....such a lame argument. Jahil kahi ka

@tahirqureshi8606

3 жыл бұрын

@@stormiwebster917 We are talking in context of 1947 dear...and your jahiliat and brought up is evident from your getting personal...

@stormiwebster917

3 жыл бұрын

@@tahirqureshi8606 so let me to drag you in another context that is 1971 civil war in bangladesh and culture will always overpower religion, your argument has zero credibility because there are more Muslims living out side the Pakistan.

@tahirqureshi8606

3 жыл бұрын

@@stormiwebster917 Dear...Two brothers can definitely have differences....But I really appreciate India for sacrificing thousands of its young men and billions of rupees in 1971 for the pure and selfless love for the Bangladeshi people although India was a poor country... The culture and language of both Bangladesh and Indian West Bengal is the same so they are strictly one Bengali nation, why don't they join into one grand Bangladesh...?...Would you please tell me about any big movements working for this...?

@stormiwebster917

3 жыл бұрын

@@tahirqureshi8606 and if religion is such a strong bondage then bengali Muslims of west Bengal should move to Bangladesh and Indian Muslims to pakistan. Why don't to ask Muslims ummah to erase all the borders between Iran and Kuwait, Qatar and Libya, Saudi and iran and lead towards one Muslim unit. My dear religion is a personal matter

I saw farst rail educated muslim saulte you sir.

@DeepakKumar-do5kg

3 жыл бұрын

@jason camel I am not

@rationalboy007

3 жыл бұрын

he's an Atheist

Very nice speaking

सर ! आप इस महत्वपूर्ण किताब का हिंदी अनुवाद करिए प्लीज़

Nice

आप सवाल ज़्यादा लंबे समय तक करते हैं और अपनी खुद की सोच ज़ाहिर करने में ज़्यादा समय लगाते हैं जिसकी वजह से आपके मेहमान अपनी बात कम कह पाते हैं ।

Hats off to prof ishtiyaque

Jinnahs ego lead to the partition but today it has gone in favour of India.

@rashidaquil5284

3 жыл бұрын

It’s favor of Pakistani Thanks God for Jinnah

@worldcitizen3519

3 жыл бұрын

@@rashidaquil5284 yes it's true it favoured Pakistan more because it has become a radical and bankrupt country after more than 70 years. This is Jinnah's gift to all Pakistani. This was given to you by Jinnah. You are right when you thank him. Bless Jinnah for Pakistan creation.

@kassimka123

3 жыл бұрын

Sharmila kaul. Plz . Just go through the book " India Wins Freedom " by Maulana Abul Kalam Azad and another book " Partition of India legend and Reality " by H.M Serwai, former Advocate General Maharashtra and get convinced who were the persons who are responsible for the partition of the British colonial sub continent before turning an accusing fingure against Mohammed Ali Jinnah and the All India Muslim League.

GOOD ANALYSIS. REGARDS

PARTITION. OF. INDIA. WAS. THE. WRONG IDEA.

@R.kandaswamy

3 жыл бұрын

In India The Partition is regretted , while in Pakistan, Partition is celebrated.

@atish3024

3 жыл бұрын

@@R.kandaswamy Fool you think 40% Muslim population would have allowed India to develop like it is now.

@R.kandaswamy

3 жыл бұрын

@@atish3024 This is not my view or opinion. It is an observation made by some intellectuals. I do believe Radical Zombies are drag on our resources and burden on our economy. What ever progress we have made is inspite of these impendiments. However I agree with the statement, particularly for people from Punjab and to some extent Bengal. The miseries of Partition difficult to forget and Scars of Genocide impossible to heal. Read " Freedom at Midnight " by Dominique Lapierre and Larry Collins. Indian Historians have distorted the history and played down brutality of Muslims.

Dr sab u r doing a great job,,,,,I salute U.Ali Raza Pasalvi

America , UK, Europe, Russia, China, Japan sab jante the ki agar India ajad hoke itna bada desh rahega to India sabse powerful desh ho jaega, in logo ne kashmir problem paida ki, taki yeh dno desh ladete rahe or hatiyar kharidte rahe, yeh desh jante aur unhone jinnah ko use kiya bharat ke batware ke liye,

Thanks and Namaste Dr Ishtiak Ahmed Saheb. Today understand so many things about India Pakistan and politcians role..... I am from India and want to learn his all three books so from where and how do i get it? kindly give me the link to how to get this the books?

salam , love & respect from new delhi

Two nation theory still exists.

@sandipjoshi1200

3 жыл бұрын

Even after Bangladesh? If two nations means one for Muslims and one for others, then all Muslim countries should be one country

@sandipjoshi1200

3 жыл бұрын

Gandhi wouldn't have been as big today if he was not killed early after partition

@akhlasscholar7054

3 жыл бұрын

@@sandipjoshi1200 but bangladesh is still a muslim country they did not merge with india

@sandipjoshi1200

3 жыл бұрын

@@akhlasscholar7054 why should they merge with India? We can live peacefuly and prosperous as neighbors

@akhlasscholar7054

3 жыл бұрын

@@sandipjoshi1200 they did not join india they belive in two nation theory

After watching his brilliant rational unbaised thinking I want to meet this intellectual

@ThePublicIndia

3 жыл бұрын

Prof Ishtiaq is based in Sweden

🕊GREETINGS 🕊

@secretknowledgebynas1356

3 жыл бұрын

Chut dede

@mayankindian3750

3 жыл бұрын

@@secretknowledgebynas1356 kya bakwas hai be tameez me baat kare 😊

Is Kitab ka Hindi anuvad aap hi kar dijiye

This book is available in hindi

🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

Please Is Book Ki Hindi Version Available ho To Pdf file Link

मनुष्यों की सबसे बड़ी विवशता है “विश्वास” मनुष्य “ विश्वास “ से रहित जीवन की कल्पना भी नहीं कर सकता। . माता की तो प्रमाणिकता है , पर मनुष्य का अपने पिता पर विश्वास करना , इसका सबसे बड़ा उदाहरण है । अपने पिता पर विश्वास करना और फिर परमपिता पर विश्वास करना । . मनुष्य का स्वयं के विश्वास को परखना ही उसे निरंतर गतिमान बनाता है । जो मनुष्य अपने विश्वास को परम स्तर परखता है , वह यथार्थ को पाता है । ये यात्रा ही मनुष्य की सफलता की परम यात्रा है । . गीता में ईश्वर कहते हैं मैं ही परमपिता हूँ। आप इस पर मनुष्य विश्वास करे या अविश्वास या चाहें तो परख कर देख ले। . अरविन्द जैन गीता सफ़ाई अभियान ।

Ego doesn't confine to simply 'I', in fact, clash of gaining intelectual property ever prevails . And for the sake of this prominence one puts great harm. The point at which reaction becomes against action necessary such sorrowful happening occurs! Etymologically hard to define caste and religion. Or sects and creed are on the following of respecting ancestors. Races are older than religions on earth. Moreover, conduct is contrary to instructions, Few may be exception. For them a real term should be framed in respect of what religion actually is ! Or not? Intelectual can not be friends. Had Nageli not been offered wrong flower Mendel, the father of Genetics, would have produced many more !

We ( myself Victoria Miroshnik and Dipak Basu) have analyzed this issue in our book, India as an organization, published by Palgrave-Macmillan. The thesis of Ayesha Jalal was wrong. Jinnah was recruited by the British in 1934 to create a new state where the British Army could stay to protect the Middle East from the Soviet Union and the sea route between the Suez Canal and Australia. NS Sarila, who was the ADC for the last three Vice-Roys of India, wrote that in his book. There are two others who were recruited by the British: Gandhi in 1915 and Ambedkar in 1930. British supported the Muslim League wholeheartedly from the beginning in 1906. In every riot, British police took the position to support the Muslims. That was obvious in August 1946 in Calcutta, then in Noakhali, and Chittagong in East Bengal. Pakistan was created by the British and Jinnah, Gandhi, Ambedkar were the British agents. Gandhi planned Pakistan in 1943. He sent his plan to Jinnah through Rajagopalachari, but Jinnah wanted a corridor through India which Gandhi could not agree with.

Ishtiaq Sahib- Where can we buy the book? I live in Pakistan

@stormiwebster917

3 жыл бұрын

Ye book pakistan mai bhi mil jayegi. Inki book ko pakistan mai bhi award mila h

Allah ka shukar hy Pakistan ban gya aj ma azad fizayion ma sans le ra hun

Muslim League was established in Dhaka in 1906 and Bengal is the first province where Muslim league Government was established and Prof Ishtiaq Ahmed forgot about it!

@tahirmalik478

Жыл бұрын

He is totally biased just twisting facts to present his fabricated narrative

Professor sahib is a great Punjabi historian.

Pakistan is a product of peculiar circumstances 1. Muslim League based in Bengal did not have an articulate leader 2. Mohammed Ali Jinnah felt side lined in Congress , wanted some following 3. Hence Jinnah who shared little value with Muslim League members became their transplanted leader 4. More importantly , British and the West wanted a country as a wedge between India and Russia . They also wanted control of that country. Huge money was exchanged to toe their agenda Pakistan was hence born out of unusual circumstances

Normal State cannot be an ideological State.. Pervaiz Hoodhbhoy.

there are many comments that seem to be from those who have the vision of a fantasy land of akhand bharat, a myriad of issues led to the final creation of Pakistan from those provinces which were majority Muslim, when one hears Indians talk they come over as though they gifted these lands to the Muslims, the Muslims of Pakistan are from these lands it's not as though they came from other nations. Jinnah was a savvy intelligent leader, who was sidelined by the British initially, but he got them to accept when the British needed manpower for the WW2 effort, as for British lackeys the biggest lackeys were the rss.

@babitayadav4806

3 жыл бұрын

There are as many believers of Akhand Bharat in Indian as there are of Ghazwa E Hind in Pakistan everyone in indian even muslims have an unfavourable opinion of Partition which led to the denigration of minorities in both side of the border especially pakistan and ethnic cleansing

You did not mentioned A,K, Fazlul Hoque , Hossain Shahid Sahroardy , and other Bengali Muslim Leaders , Jinnah join Muslim League in 1936 . When he can’t manage his position in National Congress .

Pakistan suits us Pakistani.

Waqt ne sabat kia k aj india sirf hindo ka hy kisi aur religion ka nahi hy aj yahi wajha thi k jannah sab ne 2 nation ki bat ki jis ki bat ab sikh b kr rhy hy aur dunya khe rhi hy yaha tak k hindo b jannah ki bat ko apnay amal se sach sabat kr rhy .

@hiiamkilly6212

3 жыл бұрын

Indeed its true 100 %.

Dr ishtiaq Ahmed after all your books, Pakistani establishment should reconcile with reality and focus on doing something for its people by diverting funds away from your armed forces

@Mohammadali-cs8gi

3 жыл бұрын

on what basis should Pakistan not build it's defence forces, it seems Indians have an issue with a militarily strong Pakistan. Pakistanis like other nations have a right to build a strong and comprehensive defence capability, just as India, China, Britain or France etc.

The way India is treating Muslims, we Pakistanis are happy, we got the seperate country, Thanks to Jinnah Sahib.

@lovepakistan4373

3 жыл бұрын

You are absolutely. Right yeh author pata nahi kiya bakwas karahah hai

Jinhna only believe on Subhas chandra Bose....not on Nehuru & Gandhi....

why to beat the drum now let us live like good neighbors . India and Pakistan must live like as countries and we must respect each other

गीता में ईश्वर करते हैं । पुरुष चार श्रेणी के होते हैं । ब्राह्मण ,क्षत्रिय,वैश्य और शूद्र । संसार के जितने भी पुरुष हैं, चाहे वो ईसाई ,मुसलमान ,हिंदू या किसी भी अन्य धर्म को मानने वाले हैं । वे इन चारों वर्णों के ही होते हैं । इस बात को समझना चाहिए । कम से कम हम भारतीयों को तो ये बात समझना ही चाहिए ।गीता में ईश्वर कहते हैं । मैं ईश्वर हूँ ।

mujhe ek bat samjh nai aati , kcuh insano ke badaulat, ek mulk ka batwara kaise ho jata hai,

@zohaibhasan3332

3 жыл бұрын

Mery khayal se us time circumstances e asy ban gy thy agar British weak na hota tu shyd two nations theory Zada prevail nae krti but end of the day it's a reality now Pakistan is separate country I admit that north Indians and Pakistanis have same DNAs and same culture

@unknown-mv5vi

3 жыл бұрын

@@zohaibhasan3332 history k hisab se angrezo ko 1900 se hi pta chl gya tha ki ab india m azadi ka resolution ane wala h or kuch hi sal hi Britishers ko jana pd skta tha isliye unne 1906 m ek communal act le k aye marley Minto sudhar jisse muslims ko seprate kiya gya . Wo y chahte the ki y log apas m lade or hm raj krte rhe ...or hua b aisa jb 1945 m unhe pta chl gya ki ab to bharat azad hi hokar rhega isliye unne muslim league ki bato ka support krk mulk k batware ki baat man li ...

@mkgupta6272

3 жыл бұрын

@@zohaibhasan3332 100% Right 👍👍

JINNAH WANTED TO BECOME THE PM OF UNITED INDIA, BUT NEHRU WANTED TO BE THE PM MAYBE OF TRUNCATED INDIA, NEHRU AND GANDHI ARE THE FATHERS OF PAKISTAN, WITHOUT THEIR SUPPORT PAKISTAN WOULD NOT HAVE SURVIVED EVEN ONE WEEK.

Hindustan mein sirf zat ka system tha mazhab ka nahi tha babar kay khilaf jang hindu aur muslim rajput akathay ho ker leray rana pertab singh kay sath muslim thay aur akbar kay sath hindu rajput thay aur foreign invaders kay khilaf rajput lertay rahay jis say hindustan kay Muslims mehfooz rehay yeh india kee taqseem to British aur america nay apnay mufad kay liay kee thee india aur pakistan kay 4 crore log jo apni bachion kee izat aur jan guwah bethay woh angez ko bura kehtay hein jo log kisi bat say mutasar nah houn woh nah to tareekh jannay kee koshash kertay hein aur nah hee kisi ko dukhi dekh ker dukh mehsoos kertay hein

Jinnah agreed to a federation whereby the centre would have power in matters of defence, foreign policy much akin to the US, Nehru agreed but when meeting journalists about the discussion Nehru said that anything is up for change after independence, this statement further cemented Jinnahs position for Pakistan, and thank God he had, seeing the plight of Muslims under the fascist hindutva Indian government merely makes my love for Jinnah and Pakistan increase, as he was right that Muslims would become second class citizens eventually.

क्या UAE जैसा भारत , पाकिस्तान और बांग्लादेश एक संघ नही बन सकता है ?

@dilipjoshi7346

3 жыл бұрын

आदरणीय यादव जी, आपने अपने प्रश्न में जिज्ञासा तो जाहिर कर दी है और इतिहास के सम्बन्धित हिस्से का विशेषज्ञ अवसर आने पर युक्तियुक्त जवाब देंगे, इस सोच के साथ इतिहास का अध्येता और अध्यापक ( अब सेवा निवृत्त) रहा हूँ, इसलिये स्वागत करता हूँ । लेकिन मुझे लगता है कि देश में आज राजनीतिक वातावरण " समग्रता " से न केवल दूर है बल्कि विरुद्ध ही है । " समग्रता " से मेरा आशय " निर्दोष बच्चों की प्रवृत्ति " जैसे आचरण से है । खैर, आज के हिन्दूवादी विचारों और आचरण पर ध्यान देंगे तो पता चलेगा कि वे अपनी पैठ बनाने के लिए गांधी को नमन् करते हैं और एक धड़े के द्वारा गाँधी के अस्तित्व को मिटाने के लिए अपने सिक्के के दो पहलू दिखा रहे हैं जिसमें एक है गाँधी को अपराधी तुल्य अपमानित और बदनाम करने की कोशिश , और दूसरी है गोडसे, सावरकर (+) आदि के नाम पर वैसे ही बनने की पहल । इसलिये आपके प्रश्न को ससम्मान कहीं सुरक्षित रखने की धारणा भी व्यक्त करने से इस शर्त के साथ पीछे हटता हूँ कि इसके लिए विश्वसनीय वातावरण बनाने की जिम्मेदार पूरी की जाय ।

@mkgupta6272

3 жыл бұрын

Nahi,No.

The Professor, has his own prejudices, we all have, but he is supposed to write history and he has miserably failed in that. In the first place, he does not give due credit to his subject. "Jinnah". He does not give due credit to the efforts made by Jinnah, to bring Muslims and Hindus together, for this reason, he did not join the Muslim league, but became a member of the Congress party. After all, he was called the ambassador of unity, not by Muslims but very prominent Congress leaders. Jinnah once said, "it is my ambition to become a Muslim Gokhale" on the other hand Gokhale himself said about Jinnah "he has a true staff in him and that freedom from all Secretary and prejudice which will make him the best ambassador of the Hindu - Muslim unity." Both these quotes are from a book "Jinnah Secular and Nationalist" published by Ajeet Jawed. Who happens to be a reader in political science at the University of New Delhi, India. Jinnah, like many other political leaders, was well aware, the design of the Imperial British government, to divide and rule. That is why, Jinnah opposed separate electoral roll for the Muslims. The question, one must ask, what compelled Jinnah to change course and if one were to go back one will discover, that Jinnah made every effort for the United country. All Parties National Convention in December 1928 Jinnah sent a telegram, saying that he and six other colleagues of the Muslim league would like to meet and discuss certain points with the Congress committee- these were the demands for settlement with the Congress. Mister Jawaharlal Nehru was president of the Congress. Most of the leaders were ainst this plan, but Mahatma Gandhi, prevailed upon them to invite Mr Jinnah and his party to Calcutta. Mister Jinnah place the demands before a special committee, but all were rejected Jinnah and Gandhi were the only two exceptions. Jinnah and the outgoing president of the Congress party had accepted the Cabinet Mission, but were scuttled by the incoming president of the Congress party, none other than, Mister Nehru himself. I would also like, your listeners and invite them to a book "Shameful Flight and called by Stanley Wolpert. On page 141. "Suhrawardy hoped to lead Bengal to independent dominion statehood, urging Governor Burrows and Mountbatten to help them create an undivided Bangla Dash..... Two weeks later, Mountbatten asked Jinnah what he thought of Suhrawardy's proposal to create a separate sovereign Bengal, expecting him to be shocked by his Muslim League lieutenant's treachery. Much to Mountbatten's surprise, Jinnah calmly replied, "I should be delighted. What is the use of Bengal without Calcutta they had much better remained united and independent; I am sure they would be on friendly terms with us." Maryville met with Nehru on May 27 and "I asked him how he viewed..... Independent Bengal. He reacted strongly and said there was no chance of the Hindus. There agreeing to put themselves under permanent Muslim domination.", Scratch that. In the late 1960's, Brian Walton, who was at the time, a member of Parliament for the Midlands told me, that he had once asked Prime Minister Attlee, what was his greatest achievement. The Prime Minister replied, the independence of India. To which Mr Walton, suggested, you mean India and Pakistan? The Prime Minister replied, the letter was a pity. People can make up their own mind

@prof.dr.4224

3 жыл бұрын

Jinnah was a member of the Muslim League as well, and he was first elected from Bombay as a candidate of the Muslim League.

@sameeralee8068

2 жыл бұрын

Jinnah of Pakistan! By stanely wolpert is very fine book for understanding Jinnah's struggle for uniting congress and muslim league at one platform and he has very neuterally interpreted Jinnah about changing his mind of siding away from congress and struggling for muslim cause.

Apko pakistan ke liye kam karna chahiye. Accha neighbour hona hamare liye bhi accha he. We asdure we never hury pakidtan

Is doctar ne khud accpet kia k ye koyi history janay wala nahi hy balkay aik science ka student hy to ye history ko just apni fazool ki soch k hisab se matlab nikal rahy hy per in k jhoth se jannah ki azmat kam nahi ho gi aesy kai bewaqoof aye ab un ka naam b nahi dunya me per jannah ki azmat ko ab puri dunya manti hy

Congress was using Muslims for Independence and posing as One single party of India. Jinnah tried his best to work with congress but HINDUS majority Congress never ever support him. 1937 election proved it. Congress was using MULLAHS to counter JINNAH. CONGRESS was playing very intelligently. but JINNAH outplayed it.

Jinnah had no vision

Who ever came with two nation theory but RSS and BJP proved them right .

Muslims considered themselves as separate but Sikhs joined with Hindus. Now you see what they did with Sikhs. Sikhs repent that they did not get a separate homeland and they are struggling for that today. Had muslims not got Pakistan they would be suffering in united India today. You can already see the muslims how they are living. Jinnah had many drawbacks maybe but he had more virtues and was of strong determination and how wonderful that he succeeded. So many intellectuals in India today are saying that Jinnah was right. Pakistan s bad luck has been the lack of leadership only. One great leader was Ayub Khan and the other we have today Imran Khan. Pakistan has a future. On the other hand we can see that India is doomed.

@alenuni9540

3 жыл бұрын

Continue to live in denial,good for our health.

India , pakistan, bangadesh ko ek ho jana chaye, jaise west germany or easy germany ho gaye, yeh ho sakta hai bas dil hona chaye, kaise hoga woh baith kar bat karke solution nikala ja sakta hai...

जिन्हा को उन्ही लोगों ने पैदा किया, जिन्होंने ने ग़ांधी को पैदा किया।

@AmarjeetSingh-vi8sq

3 жыл бұрын

Gandi koi mahatma nhi tha mahatma

@truthhurts2980

3 жыл бұрын

Aapke statement ka correction: Jinnah ko unhi logon ne paida kiya jinhone Savarkar ko paida kiya.

ThIs Ishtiaq Ahmed dude is from India or Pakistan? Looks indian to me 🙄

@shivanginirai5087

3 жыл бұрын

Pakistan

@KAASHIVIDEO

3 жыл бұрын

what makes difference

@unknown-mv5vi

3 жыл бұрын

Pakistani h ye gandu insan

@KAASHIVIDEO

3 жыл бұрын

@@unknown-mv5vi INDIAN appreciate him jinnah had logic but you people never understood Gandhi and you have gandu soch gandu thoughts

@unknown-mv5vi

3 жыл бұрын

@@KAASHIVIDEO mene ishtiyaq Ahmed sir ko gandu ni bola mne comment krne wale ko bola jo bol rha h ki ye indian h

Nehru n Gandhi should have favored Jinnah but their ego partitioned India

@SHIVAMYadav-pw5uz

3 жыл бұрын

They were living in la land.... They have not tried to understand the psyche Muslim elite of northern India and jinnah.....

@ritesharora4207

3 жыл бұрын

Did you even saw the interview?

CONGRESS was responsible of partition of INDIA. Congress never accepted Muslim Demands. JINNAH was very visionary , he started politics from Congress, he knew HINDUS very well, after decades of working in Congress and with HINDUS , he came to the point that HINDUS would never ever accept Muslims Demands, and he was so right that today we can see that what is going in India with muslims by MOODI BJP, and what HINDUS are doing in kashmir. JINNAH was 100% right ,.

@kulvindersinghvirk7521

2 жыл бұрын

Lolzzz visionary , fukin millions of peopled killed for shake this pakistan ,, more than 200 years have been chanting hindu muslim , can't get rid of this shit !

20:50 he saying k Jinnah Said Hindu Chaa jae gy totally non-sense. With due respect your analysis is totally wrong while Jinnah was right, Today we can see that he was right.

MR ISHTIAQ , for due respect. you missed very important points in your book . during that time Religion card was in full swing and CONGRESS was using that card very smartly , CONGRESS was playing in every field, POLITICS, RELIGION. BOYCOTT, Gurella WAR etc Hindus were every where and using sold out MULLAHS like AZAAD, Jamaait ulemae Islam, EHRAR ul Hind, Jammat e Islami etc . so there are so many parameters back there but you covered only one.

@alenuni9540

3 жыл бұрын

Jinnah was bootlicker of his colonial masters.He never confronted them.He never went to jail,unlike Congress leaders,who spent decades behind the bars.Pakistan was created by the western powers,Jinnah was their loyal puppet.

@unknown-mv5vi

3 жыл бұрын

Agr congress ki jagah bjp hoti us time to pakistan alag desh na hota ...or jin muslims ko azadi chahiye hoti modi ji unhe Saudi Arabia ya uae bhej dete 😝

Prof : ishtiaq Ahmed......chalo maan b liya jae quaid Azam galat tha...why he made separate county .....it was impossible in united bharat to side line Muslims..... Modi ji ne jinnah sahib KO sahi sabit kar he diya.... 25+crore Muslimz r side lined by Indian system.... Now they have only 3 options 1 all convert in sanatani 2 leave India 3 hang or burn till death... But we Pakistani pray for them for 4th option...

Mr ishtiaque Jinnah endorsed cabinet mission in which united india is guarented don't fool people congress oppose the plan so congress was to blame for India partition