I much enjoyed talking to you, thanks for making this work!

@Cherokie89

11 ай бұрын

Thanks so much for what you do.

@snowballeffect7812

11 ай бұрын

stick to physics

@andreasrumpf9012

11 ай бұрын

So ... have you ever figured out why men don't belong into women's sports? It's not that hard and doesn't require any Gobbeldygook either.

@AlexeyZakhlestin

11 ай бұрын

Thank you! It was a pleasure to see another side of you!

@psyclotronxx3083

11 ай бұрын

Sabine, I appreciate your approach to science communication. Starting with the premise that it's understandable for most people. (Detroit, Michigan)

I just can't believe that this kind of content that you both create it's free and available to everyone! Thank you very much for your hard and awesome work!!

@LettersAndNumbers300

Жыл бұрын

Shushh!!!

@cacogenicist

Жыл бұрын

Bot

Sabine is our shepherd, we lack nothing. She make us lie far from bad Science. She refreshes our souls, she guides us along the right paths. 😊 Well played, Joe! You completely represent us.

@johnhough4445

11 ай бұрын

Nobody is my shepherd ... as best I can I do my own research, my own analyses, and come to my own conclusions. (And sometimes my results concur with those of others, oh wow!)

@jeffreyholifield3847

11 ай бұрын

I walk through the valley of bad data.

I knew I was going to enjoy this. Sabine is a great content creator and author and I really enjoy her work... Just as much as I enjoy Joe's work just in different ways. Perfect combination that I just could not miss. Thanks Joe!

I never would have dreamed you two would get together, be here we are, in great awe and appreciation of the great work you do.

I love it how she isn’t afraid to have strong opinions that don’t necessarily align with popular trends.

Cool to see how two of the best science communicators around, have so many things in common while approaching things from very different backgrounds. That gives me hope for humanities future

I'm a huge fan of Sabine Hossenfelder and always enjoy hearing her insights. She's taught me to ponder the fundamental questions of physics in a more informed way. Moreover, she also brings deeply creative and original views on the human dimensions of our world. Such a beautiful mind!

I find it so cool when 2 of my favorite channels happen to meet… I must be on to you guys! 😂 Sabine is the real deal. Thanks for the treat.

May the two of you live long and prosper. Cheers.

Joe and Sabine . What a coup. Mop Dr. Sabine is an amazing woman. She is so smart. She is the #1 scientist whom I would like to meet and maybe play some music with. Both Joe and Sabine are engaging , and so much fun to watch .

2 people I watch every week. Saves time. Thanks.

The discovery of the night is Sabina’s songs. I’m now a fan!🎶🎤🎧

You're an honest to God scientist in our hearts Joe lol.

@Anuchan

Жыл бұрын

Maybe not scientist, but definitely a science communicator. The best teacher is not the person who is doing cutting edge research, but instead the person who struggled through it and understands what is commonly misunderstood.

"It is just an engineering problem." Very well. I'm starting the math. Joe, I've been subscribed to Sabine far longer than you. I understand (perhaps) half of what she says, but she has a wicked sense of humour. You made my day. Thank you.

Sabine is my favorite celebrity scientist. She actually understands the philosophy of science. Most scientists are very poor philosophers, and it gets them in a LOT of trouble. Especially once they start to talk outside the science and into the gobbeldygook.

So happy that this incredible woman lets us peek into her head and regularly.

Hi Joe. Sabine and yourself are far and beyond my favourite two KZread CC's. This was a lovely chill discussion. Thank you both for doing this and hope to maybe see some collaborations in the future???

The collab conversation I always wanted! Thanks Joe, Sabine, love both your channels.

what a wonderful talk, Sabine is a garanty for honesty and trustworthyness, couraged, soulful and pointed, thank you both

Love Sabine's channel. Great science news breakdown and I also appreciate her humor

@EarthCreature.

Жыл бұрын

You love her anti-Trans rhetoric too?

@teknophyle1

Жыл бұрын

@@EarthCreature. *shakes head* huh? how'd you get that from... nevermind. Is it possible she was just trying to highlight facts and you're virtue signaling? I consider myself a trans-ally. and sometimes we have to ask ourselves if science communicators are asking tough questions with the express purpose of advancing our understanding of a topic. I know its a very touchy topic for all sides right now but we have to avoid going all cancel culture or we risk becoming the problem rather than fixing one.

@sertaki

11 ай бұрын

She was showcasing debunked and old research and didn't really engage properly with the science available today, while also falling for some right-wing and TERF political talking points that intentionally twist the narrative. That video made doubt her as a scientist - if you completely fail to properly assess your data, it casts a bad shape on all of your work in the academic field. And she made some jokes in it that were extremely distasteful.

@thoughtfuloutsider

11 ай бұрын

​@sertaki I wondered. When she stepped out of her field of expertise. I trust her with maths, physics, space stuff but stepping into the complicated world of politics, gender & identity which maths isn't good for.

@sertaki

11 ай бұрын

@@thoughtfuloutsider I wonder how much of that was simply her failing to do proper research and how much was her using the platform to showcase her own political beliefs. Taking the nature of some of the jokes into account that she made in her video on transgender issues ... I fear it may be a deliberate choice. I would much rather have to doubt her academic process than find out that one of the top science communicators is a bigot, honestly. But seeing how she has not reviewed her video in any shape or form in reaction to being called out on the mistakes she made (and the falsehoods she pushed) , it leaves two options: 1. She is aware of the mistakes but does not want to admit to them (which would mean she is not a good scientist, rather choosing to keep wrong information out in the open than to admit to an error) 2. She is intentionally spreading misinformation because she is transphobic. Judging by the sheer size of her fanbase and how extremely bigoted the comment section under that video was, there is no way she is unaware of the criticism that was quickly levied against her by people like Rebecca Watson. She would have without doubt gotten thousands of emails by her fanbase alerting her to it. And I have not yet even looked at her newer video titled "Why is everyone suddenly neurodivergent?" ... I fear it's equally lacking in proper research and may be perpetuating talking points that pathologize neurodivergent people in outdated ways. I would not be surprised if there was a call for donations to "charities" like "Autism Speaks" in the video description. And it's extremely disappointing that I expect this now, since before her telling descent into anti-trans rhethoric, I would not have doubted her integrity. I very much hope I am wrong regarding her take on neurodivergency.

I freaking love her. I only recently found her channel and she's already my favorite professional scientist flavor of science explainer.

You guys are so right about the loneliness of deep understanding. In my click, there is nobody that remotely understands most physics subjects.

@petergleeson295

11 ай бұрын

Clique?

@hynesie11

11 ай бұрын

@@petergleeson295ironically KZread offers to translate to English. The result is click.

joe, Sabine is one of my fav’s as you she is so informative. Thank you buddy for showing us Sabine in a warm lay back interview.

Thank you for the awesome content and great videos!!

Love this talk. On mistakes, we make them. Do lose sleep over it.

My favorite physicist being interviewed by my favorite Science communicator!!!!🎉🎉🎉🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼

@EarthCreature.

Жыл бұрын

Your favorite? Because she's anti-trans?

@racingfortheson

Жыл бұрын

@@EarthCreature. what? I have no clue if she is anti-trans. She is a brilliant mathematician and physicist. She speaks truth to physicist who are lost in their own ideas and won’t except the truth of their failures (string theory, multiverse, etc..). Don’t presume to know why someone is a fan of someone or something. Even if she agrees or disagrees with beliefs I have or don’t, it doesn’t take away from her brilliant mind.

@Thomas-gk42

Жыл бұрын

​@@racingfortheson entirely correct

@Thomas-gk42

Жыл бұрын

​@@EarthCreature. nice, to see you guys not getting tired spreading your poison. Keep up your hateful work

Great interview!

I would absolutly watch videos about medicine from sabine!! And other topics she's interested in!! Without QUESTION!! PLEASE!! Do this! I can't wait for you to release the first one! :D

@cacogenicist

Жыл бұрын

_"I would absolutly watch videos about medicine from sabine!!_ Why? She's a physicist?

@alexwoodhead6471

Жыл бұрын

@@cacogenicist because I trust her to do her research and get it right. THAT ALONE is in extremely short supply nowadays

@pjaworek6793

Жыл бұрын

I love the way Sabine condenses a topic and delivers a balanced summary. She is never one-sided. She did the best job of communicating the trans issues (and non-issues about it) that I've seen. She strikes the right balance between being able to get a message across and having technical and objective content.

@cacogenicist

11 ай бұрын

@@alexwoodhead6471 - There are plenty of trustworthy people with actual academic backgrounds in biomedical sciences.

@Bestmann3n

11 ай бұрын

@@alexwoodhead6471 But you shouldn't trust her on medicine(or any topic except here niche in physics). That's the entire point. It's ridiculous to think that she can get complex subjects "right" by doing a few days of research. That kind of blind trust, just because, well you trust her, is exactly the problem with misinformation.

This was great! Danke Sabine und Joe.

Two of my favorite KZread-ers. Great discussion of many interesting and important subjects. Thanks to you both. 😊

Hi Joe - Yes Sabine is a great scientist and a great communicator as well. (I can't help referring to Richard Feynman when it comes to talking about communicators). But your stuff about "How Electricity Actually Works" was also pretty much top notch. So thnx Joe and Sabine for your great work 🤗

I love this introduction about 'gobbeldygook'. For even the simplest scientific papers, scientists try to sound 'scientific' by using their own jargon rather than describing stuff in words that non-scientists (like me) can understand. How refreshing it would be to read a medical paper about 'bruising' instead of 'ecchymosis'!

omg, omg, omg. Guys, I love both of your channels. No way you got her toghether in a video with you :D

I continue to learn a lot from the both of you. Many thanks.

Wow, two of my favorite KZreadrs! Thanks for this great collab Joe I look forward to any more content like this. 👍👍

Great stuff. Sabinews is of the best things in KZread!

Joe and Sabine in one video, does KZread life get any better?❤

👏👏👏👏👏👏 Thank you for this! Before I watch it 😊

Nice conversation. Sabine is great. 👍

Love this.

You are both funny and serious at the same time. A rare gift! Love both of your blogs.

Oh, ... great! Joe and Sabine Hossenfelder, ... unbelievable!

Great to see you two discussing these topics together (2 of my fave YT creators) and some really good questions from Joe. Thanks to you both! Not as many views as it should have, probably down to the YT algorithm - I'm subscribed to both Joe's and Sabine's other channels but I was shown this video for the first time just yesterday. Hope my view, the thumbs up and this comment helps this video to reach others.

A little humility goes a long way! You are awesome. The reason i watch You Tube

Joe scott and Sabine?!?!?! ON MY BIRTHDAY!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?! thank you :) Edit: Yes, it is the 25th of may :P

@klondike444

Жыл бұрын

Sabine.

@alexwoodhead6471

Жыл бұрын

@@klondike444 yeah, my bad!

You get to talk to the coolest people I know about! 😀 I'm so jelly! Great stuff. Thanks a lot.

Wow lots of interviews lately between my favourite YTers, thanks for this.

Two of my favourite creators in one place! Joy..

Thank you for the interview Joe. Sabrine is a very funny and interesting scientist. I try to watch all her videos, and I recommend everyone else to do it to.

I love her science news episodes!

Two of my Superstars. Joe and Sabine!

sabine is a rising star at a global level in the kingdom of theoretical physics and that bugs a few of her colleagues ;-)

Pure awesomeness!

Getting things wrong is part of the process of doing science. It's why we have a process of doing science. Trying to cover up and deny mistakes is wrong.

I love when this happens, I watch both of their channels.

and her channel is amasing and quite interesting and fun love her work

15:03 that's how I also felt about math! Glad to hear an actual expert say it.

love Sabine!!

Two of my favorite youtubers.

I'm so envious of Joe getting to have this conversation. I enjoy Sabine's take on pretty much everything, especially when she plays devil's advocate across from other physicists.

Would love to see you two do a second round to talk about how you both use humor and gags in your approaches to science communication - maybe get a little meta about the role of humor in general in discussing serious/complex issues? (Plus I'd love to hear Sabine talk about how her music vids fit into the rest of her amazing work - they're pretty awesome)

Keep it up, Joe! It's all good.

That was great. She's my favourite physicist.

WAAAT? BOTH OF YOU TOGETHER?! SO COOL TO SEE THANK YOU BOTH!

I actually have read some of Sabines books and followed her channel for a long time and I'm not in academia at all and just an enthusiast. I rely on Sabines input into some of the big questions hype because she is such a good skeptic, but I would bet the reason why so many people reach out to her for everything or questions about the theory of everything is most people don't know how specialized physics is. Just like in the trades there are people who specialize in just drywall, or just HVAC and even in the trade of HVAC there are commercial or refrigeration or geothermal etc. I must admit, when I think about physics and astrophysics and quantum mechanics I can get a bit science fiction phantasy and loose tract of what's been proven and what's the current base of understanding. The whole reason why I am such a fan and into this to begin with even though I'm just a tradesmen is because I grew up in the 80s just outside the Fermilab national accelerator in Batavia Illinois and my dad worked there for close to 30 years in facilities. I spent much time in and around that facility so I have always been quite familiar with theoretical physics and I was lucky enough to have listened to many talks given in the auditorium by Leo Lederman, on a side note, I have some interesting experiences with Leon and his wife..

Wow, a crossover from my two favorite youtubers🤗 This is going to be awesome 🤩

Two of my favourite KZreadrs. 🥰

I discovered she did music videos at 16:06 in THIS video! Wow! I checked it out in another tab. Music aside, the two of you are both great science communicators. I love watching both of you. Good interview.

Omg 2 of my favourite creators

I can't believe these two peeps are collaborating. Nice work.

Wow! You two! 👍👍

"mathematical philosophy" sounds so contradictory! Fascinating.

Yes, I enjoy her comments

So happy KZread recommended this video. Big fan of both of you. Thank you to you two🥹

wow, two of my most favourite science youtubers togerher in one video ! Great !

My grandson who is the youngest 20yrs old has this same syndrome. He is on a spectrum of very very smart.He is second year of college. His grades are very high. He is majored Political Science. He just got back from Iceland. He doing well on his own. His emotions are not regular but he is a lot better. We are proud 👏 of him.

Very nice talk. One thing to remember with the 'how long until X?' Technological inventions/progress isn't always linear(or a proper curve). The Romans had a steam engine device ~50 BCE. A cool toy but it seemed useless because they had slave labor to do the heavy lifting. AI/Machine learning will accelerate the progress of many industries, but without hindsight, you can't tell if ur going down the right path.

Awesome

That was actually a fun to watch chat there! But the most entertaining part was the awkwardness haha! More than anything this chat made me feel like Joe is super awkward but curious and dark yet kind in real life just about as much or more than in the videos. Thats nice. It feels reassuring to know that the science communicators of today have their integrity in the right place!

To quote the great Varvatos Vex: "Glorious!!!"

That part on "people sharing there theory of the univers but have no one to talk to."😅 Dang that hits home so hard.

Two of my favourite KZreadrs! What's not to like?

great food for thought duo. Sabine made me think of Veritasium in several comments. I forget his name but he delves into some mind boggling maths.

Can't believe the algorithm failed me this horribly. Two of my favorite people in one video and it doesn't pop up until 3 weeks later??

Just for some background on the topic of education in germany (where sabine is from afaik): I work as a dev for the german education ministry of one of the states and i can say the teaching plans (which basicly are set up by the ministry of each state to ensure all students learn the same thing up to a certain point) is getting adjusted very quickly. Just a couple of weeks ago i heard that some educational communicators and school advisors/maintainers talk about including A.I. Topics and how to deal/work with ChatGPT and other A.I. agents and tool. So should get included in the educational plans quite soon and even sooner in the pool of schools and classes which are chosen to act as early bird test classes. So yeah courses and lecture unit on how to deal with social media, fake news and the informational hazards are a quite a new thing of the last couple of years.

_This_ maths is a good representation of physics - if it wasn't we'd have invented/discovered a different one that was. Math-Anthropic Principle ; just put my Nobel prize in the mail.

Making occ mistakes and mis speaking makes you human! Thus i can listen to you because you dont think u know everything! Brian Cox spoke about ths as a scientist when you find you are wrong its good, you learned something. You both dont seem to do this because you think you are right but because you want to shaore what you have found. I love that and we learn together

I'm looking forward to Sabine's third book.

As a polymath, I have a theory of everything that only other polymaths can possibly understand. It involves becoming more like a human by mastering human sound through overtone singing, becoming familiar with all movement, understand the way the mind works, and becoming a polymath.

You should do an episode with Anton Petrov if possible. Him and Sabine are my go-to scientists on KZread. And he mentioned you in a recent video (about the LK-99 maybe?) so he definitely watches your channel. I've watched his videos daily for a while, but I'd love to see him actually talk about himself and to see you two have a conversation.

I have to say, ... I have a firefox extension and two different userscripts that go through and disable/remove annotations... I can see why you'd want that -- and if used for corrections: hey, let's do it. neat. But most often it's used to pop up annoying useless distractions and ads that make it impossible to pay attention to the video I'm trying to watch. I see a lot of in explicable "youtube thinks you'll like these videos" with creators pointing at nothing in particular and I just smirk and think, ... yeah, disabled. I'm so glad I did that. thought you should know.

I recall hearing that France does have nuclear material recycling capabilities.

Wow, what a score for Joe.

really nice conversation, slow paced but I think in other conversations on other podcasts there is not enough time for a participant to actually sort their thoughts out while speaking and have a tiny moment to reflect on his own words before the other party jumps in. For me it feels like a relaxed conversation .. but as a content creator it maybe actually be stressful to keep the talk artificially "dynamic" with a person who listens until the other person is fully done speaking or waits for an actual question to be asked. :D.

Oh yeah! After watching a lot of science communicators and delving deeper into textbooks and journals...man the difference is like a wide chasm! I sometimes feel like being lied to when watching a lot of youtubers explaining some physics. Often, they also make it sound as if a lot of theories and interpretations have been proven beyond any doubt. But yes, I also get it, the mathematics is often beyond someone who is not already at least doing graduate studies.

Sabine, Math works so well because we have been creating it to work with reality. Centuries of changes, corrections, modification and lots of addtions. So it's no wounder it works well. We through out all the bits that didn't. And still, there are lots of bits that don't work so well but we don't have a better way of doing it.

Interesting interview! Im particularly curious about how the misconceptions are overdone in the popular science media. There's such a redundant focus on click baity terms and inaccurate information. It's kinda disappointing. Love your channel! More scientists!

You complement each other very well.

same Kepler poster in my office ❤