I'm crying with you, professor. So emotional, tears inducing voice and instrumentals. I have never felt the music so hard in my 40 year life, like with BM, especially Monochrome

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Glad it's not just me :)

@RenegadeSamurai

8 ай бұрын

Su touches your heart directly with her voice...YOu don't need to understand it, you just feel it...

Professor Hartley, the biggest researcher and critic of Babymetal - as a phenomenon - in the world. We need your analysis always so sensitive and enlightening. I guess this new album represents the transition, the rite process to the adult world, definitely. It is a delicate moment, sensitive and profound, existentially. May they achieve success and happiness in this hard passage. May they never forget his childhood origins and that enchanted all the fans, who understood that it was not just another band, but the real representation of the existence of those girls, today young women. Babymetal is a human and cultural experience through Art.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

That's kind of you. Thank you for your comment and support!

@youngKarl007

Жыл бұрын

Hello, I want to say it’s nice for me to hear someone else expressing appreciation for the depth and mystery that is Babymetal … there’s so much I have to say about this and someday I will write it all down… one thing: no one can really know babymetal without understanding everything they create has its roots in the deep timeless culture of Japan, though I guess you could also say they go beyond it… into the unknown future. I have no friends who are babymetal fans , so the only way to express even a little of my interest is to write people like yourself. 🦊🦊🦊

Awesome analysis… thank you

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

My pleasure! Thanks.

It's a beautiful song...

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yep

疫病、戦争、自然災害、この狂った世界で、私は今夜もこの澄み切った声を抱きしめて眠りに就くことでしょう。

@jakemuller8626

Жыл бұрын

☔☀️🌈

@kitkat6407

Жыл бұрын

@@jakemuller8626 😭🤘💙

@salesiocaritas8400

Жыл бұрын

”モノクロームララバイ” でおやすみしましょう...zzzzz.....🌈♨^_^🍅

@kitkat6407

Жыл бұрын

@@salesiocaritas8400 😪💤

@salesiocaritas8400

Жыл бұрын

@@kitkat6407 異世界からの声...「笑って、Kit Katº」🦊⛩

As person from Russia that images hurts me so much that I cannot hear this song without instant tears. I can't think about this song without connection to the current context and it... yes, hurts so much...

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

I'm sure. Best wishes.

@markpahate7019

Жыл бұрын

Stay strong 🙏

@carlosandleon

5 ай бұрын

did you leave yet?

@mr_ozio

5 ай бұрын

@@carlosandleon yes. hope I can go back someday.

Very good reaction. At the end of the film, it turned into color, which was very shocking...

I saw the flowers in the images as well. Instantly thought of a lotus 🪷 flower.

Beautiful.

Excellent as always, thank you. I think you said everything that needed saying and the comments below covered anything else I may have thought to add about how this song makes me feel.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks!

@davidornberg

Жыл бұрын

@@AndrewHartley Thank You Andrew. You know. Babymetal is Special Guests to Sabaton's European tour. I am going to see them in Stockholm and I am hyped. About the video. I instantly got the reference to Hiroshima and the tree that survived the A-Bomb and still lives. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hibakujumoku

Nice reaction. With all that's happened in the world in the last few years. This song hits it right on the head. The blending of the Norse mythology with the real-world atomic bomb dropping is brilliant song writing. But when you add in the images they used for a so-called lyric video. Stunning. This should be called a story video. While all of this could be taken in many ways. That is a Babymetal hallmark to their lyrics. Folk can relate to the lyrics individually. Fighting depression during covid lockdowns is a real thing. For many it feels like the world was monochrome and might still feel that way. A surrealness to the world. I've seen many post on how Babymetal have gotten people through some very tuff times in their lives. Babymetal delivers on yet another strong positive message song. No matter how bad things are now. You can survive and We can build a better life. Which is part of the Ragnarök myth. There are survivors who build a better world. Babymetal for me as well dig into their roots here. That opening is reminiscent of Babymetal death. But also, Lyrically Catch me if You Can. A song about a version of hide and seek. At the end of hide and seek. The tagger would call out in a sing tone to anyone still hiding that it was safe to come out. That feels like that's what Moa is singing. Lockdowns are over it's safe to come out and see us in concert. Ok I just want it to be safe to see them in concert. I'm sure I'm not alone in that thought. And the idea of seeing them in concert does bring a smile to my face. Babymetal brings us a song of hope through tragedy. Babymetals back and the color returns to the world. They're still the happiest place in metal.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Great comment. Thank you!

@RODRIEUROMANIAKO

Жыл бұрын

YES !!

Thank you so much for your beautiful reaction and analysis. Typical you! （さすがです！）Too many profound observations for me to respond to, so just one = your description of Su's "Pure" voice being not just of hope but conviction hit my heart. Yes, that has always been at the core of BABYMETAL! Every time I hear this song, I am smiling with tears in my eyes.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thank you too!

@lencooke944

Жыл бұрын

@@AndrewHartley Just an update Professor, after seeing you and a couple of others suggest Monochrome may be referencing "Grave of the Fireflies" I found a subtitled version and watched it. I have to say that I don't know if I have ever had such complex emotions about a movie. On one hand it is one of the most heartwarming stories I have ever seen. On the other hand, it is so gut-wrenchingly traumatic that I almost feel emotionally violated. The only movie that I can think of that even comes close to the emotions I felt watching Grave of the Fireflies, was the opening 10 minutes or so of "Saving Private Ryan". It's been over a month since I watched the movie, and I still tear up when I think about it. It's amazing what a couple of cartoon characters can do to you. However, after seeing the movie, I have to agree that there may be references to this movie in the video for Monochrome. I can see what you suggest from the film in the Monochrome video. However, something that I haven't seen anyone comment on, is that those meteors/bullets/bombs/whatever that the girl under the umbrella is sheltering from, it may also be a reference to the carpet bombing of Kobe and, to a much lesser extent, Tokyo with the incendiary devices that led to large fires that destroyed large sections of the cities. Anyway, I just thought I would share my experience with Grave of the Fireflies. Keep the good stuff coming.

私は、ベビーメタルがこの世界と現実に真摯に向き合う姿勢が好きです 🦊☔🌈

@htusda1

Жыл бұрын

賛同します。昔から BABYMETAL は単に希望を抱くのみでなく、’積極的に前進しよう！’ の強い意思を感じられこれが全世界の人に感動を与えてきた。（さすが AJ の分析はいつもすごい） BABYMETAL 自身も ① アイドルだけの世界からの脱却 ② Yui-metal 引退 ③ 藤岡さんの他界 ④ 白熱ライブの敵であるコロナ を克服してきた実績があり、単に口で言っているのでは無い事もあって尊敬の念が深まります。

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

これは素晴らしい指摘だ。全く同感です。

@seregamolodets5286

Жыл бұрын

☔🌈🍅

@salesiocaritas8400

Жыл бұрын

@@htusda1 全てに深く頷けます。全くその通りだと思います。

6:59 i had the exact same reaction

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks!

Su METAL の歌声は琴線に触れる。 私の中でもベストな楽曲の１つです。 『モノクロームの花火なら、僕らは虹色で包もう世界を、笑顔で』 Su METAL が歌うから説得力があるし、BABYMETAL だからこそポジティブなメッセージになる。 見事な考察を有難う御座います🦊👍🦊

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

コメントありがとうございます。とても感謝しています。

Thank you for doing this again ! At first I thought Hiroshima and maybe Suzuka is the girl with the umbrella, but maybe it's Sasaki Sadako ? You might want to look at this SG-diary entry as well (translated by onji-Kobe) 🌸Diary 2010🌸 SG students' diary 20100806 Suzuka SG students' diary 20100806 Suzuka Title: Hiroshima We go to school on August 6 every year, although it's during summer holidays. It's the day of Hiroshima Peace Memorial Ceremony. At 8:15am, we observe a moment of silence. At night, we have Toro Nagashi Ceremony. Now I can enjoy singing, I can laugh, because of the 'Peace'. This year, I've turned the 1st grader in middle school. Sasaki Sadako-san, the girl of the origami-cranes about whom we've learned at the class of peace-education in elementary school, passed away at the same age with me. She only lived for 12 years. She must have wanted to live longer. She must have wanted to do more and more things. I listened to 'inori' of Kumiko-san, and that made me think of Sadako-san again. With gratitude for being alive, with thankfulness for being able to do what I really love -- singing!, I'll do my best in the coming event. Ｓｕｚｕｋａ 【August 6 is the day the atomic bomb was dropped on Hiroshima in 1945. "Toro Nagashi" is a ceremony where people hold a memorial service for the spirits of the deceased by floating paper lanterns and other offerings in a river. Wiki about Sasaki Sadako. 'INORI' is a song which sings about Sadako and her origami-cranes (There is a legend that anyone who folds one thousand origami-cranes will be granted a wish). Footage. Lyrics in Eng】

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, I'd seen this, but thanks for posting it here. Appreciate it.

Perfect Reaction !! Thank you!

素晴らしい👏 コメントですネ👏 貴方はBABYMETALです❗ Ｗｅ are BABYMETAL 🦊

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

ありがとうございます。本当に感謝しています

SUMETALの無垢な歌声に打たれました… まるで数年前に戻ったかのようです… 歌詞の内容とも相まって、寂寥感を感じます まさにBABYMETALにしかできない表現だと思います 今回も教授の分析を興味深く拝聴いたしました ありがとうございます

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

同感です。そして、ありがとうございます 日本のBabyMetalファンからのコメントにはいつも感謝しています。

@salesiocaritas8400

Жыл бұрын

SUMETALが「僕らは oh oh...」と、私達に呼びかけていで胸が熱くなります・・。

Great content again Professor, you never disappoint. I agree that Monochrome is top tier Babymetal, I just cannot wait to see what they do with this song live. As you have pointed out this song oozes melody, both in instrumentals and vocals. It now sits firmly in my top five favorite Babymetal songs. I would like to pick up on just one thing: I haven't seen this talked about in other reactions, but I can't believe that no one I have watched has mentioned how much Su's voice (when she goes into the almost crying, frustrated kind of scream at about 3:17 in your video), sounds like Delores O'Riordan from the Cranberries in their song 'Zombie'. For me, this links the present situation in the Ukraine to the Irish Troubles and to Hiroshima and Nagasaki (this is a long bow, I know). Monochrome appears to carry a war theme. However, I also feel that later in the song there is an environmental aspect when the planet depicted has its atmosphere is destroyed and cartoon Su (can tell by the ponytail) only has her umbrella as protection against the forces outside, be they meteoric or objects more nefarious. There seems to be so many messages in Monochrome that I see something new every time I watch the video. I can't believe that I still get emotional watching this song, even though I know what is coming. The song is so good.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yes, I agree with the war/environment dual theme and the way that the lyric stays broad enough to include broader (or more personal) instances of hope/conviction in the face of hardship. I like the Cranberries comparison too. Totally different vocal style, of course, but I know what you mean about the way both songs carry the intensity of the content. Thanks, as ever, for your support.

@timrose3960

Жыл бұрын

Yes the message in "Zombie" has that provocative Irish fighting spirit feel to it imo. Monochrome was done in the polite Japanese way imo. As a Westerner, I won't let it's meaning make me feel uncomfortable because that's not Suzuka Nakamoto's intent. I am not just a fan but an ally of Su chan' s pure heart. Her age doesn't matter because her generation is correct. The world has some soul searching to do before it's too late and Su metal couldn't have been more gentle and positive in her approach. BM can teach us all something. I am ready so "let's go!" :)

Man I always love your analysis, but with the actual first time reaction included, this video is absolute gold! Well done :) 🤘🦊🤘

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks! I nearly didn't do it, because I knew I wouldn't be jumping around and shrieking like most reactors. Too much the Lancashire lad, I suppose. :)

@react-o-mat

Жыл бұрын

@@AndrewHartley I think there's plenty of genuine 'reaction' and emotion to see here! Would love to see you do this for their next songs too!

I have often been told that I have the emotional capacity of a brick, BUT I have listened to this a few dozen times now and I still tear up every time I hear this. What else is waiting for us with the other new songs? I can't wait. Great reaction and analysis Prof Hartley.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Right there with you.

🍅💀🍅 🤘🏼🦊🤘🏼 " Just smile "

@salesiocaritas8400

Жыл бұрын

🦊☔🌈🍅^_^

@htusda1

4 ай бұрын

Yes..... but I am crying.

Great reaction and analysis as always. Great stuff AJ! 🤘🦊🔥

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Appreciate it!!

Is a great song and whatever is the meaning behind will still be a great track with a beautiful message.... _"Just smile"_ Thanks for sharing this Andrew.🦊🤘🌈

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks!

Possibly my favorite BABYMETAL reaction of yours. Arigatou! 🦊🤘 #notacult #justsmile

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thank you!

excellent content Professor Andrew-Metal, as always your BABYMETAL insight is wonderful. I see that you had a few emotional moments, as do several kitsunes that feel BABYMETAL's music, myself included.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

I deny it! Stoic throughout, that's me ;)

@Marty-Metal

Жыл бұрын

@@AndrewHartley ha ha, you can't hide it,, neither can I, lol

As always love your very informative reaction and breakdown . The high note Su hits with the last " We Will " gets me every single time . Su's vocals just make you feel ❤️ I can not wait to see Su , Moa and the Kamis perform it live and see Su putting her full emotions into the performance 😁🤘🦊🤘

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks! Yes, I really hope we see this live.

@johnschultz7765

Жыл бұрын

I found that drop and a Cappella phrase quite jarring the first few times through the song. And I didn't like it. Understanding the phrase better, thanks to Professor Hartley's comment in his video, it now fits with the song for me. I now hear it as both an inclusive iron-willed statement of intent as well as an exhortation and encouragement to follow suite breaking through the song. 🤘🦊

@martinmetal7481

Жыл бұрын

@John Schultz it just brought a lump to my throat as it had become more powerful every time she said it Full of positivity . At least it felt that way to me . 😁🤘🦊🤘

@htusda1

Жыл бұрын

@@johnschultz7765 Similar as in the case of "Distortion", it's grown on me and the Wow-wow-wow-woh has to be there.

I say this time and time again, but I think it bears repeating - the quality of this comment section compared to that which is oftentimes found elsewhere on the internet is yet another indicator proving that you've been doing something very valuable through your video explorations (and other endeavors in life, of course). Your work inspires people to think about our entertainment in a more thoughtful manner, and I think that's quite fitting as BABYMETAL continues to grow, and start to have even more insightful things to say. Thus far, Monochrome definitely feels like one of their most "personal" songs, and I'm all here for it. I enjoyed the "little kids being metal cheerleaders" era very much for what it was, but I'm so looking forward to seeing what they do next!

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

I'll take that, man, thanks, though I can't take credit for other people's excellent contributions. I'm just glad this is a place for real thought and dialogue which goes beyond saying how cute they are. Your contributions are especially valued. Thanks.

Hiroshima, Hibakujumoku Trees, and Endless Rain Most probably already know what the song BABYMETAL - Monochrome tells, which is a story about a glimmer of hope from the citizens of Hiroshima after the Atomic Bomb that devastated the city which is also the birthplace of Suzuka Nakamoto And the Hibakujumoku Tree became a Symbol of Hope after it was the only tree that survived the Atomic Bomb Attack The name of the title of the song Monochrome also reflects the situation of Hiroshima which became pitch black and the rain of nuclear contamination that continued to fall. #BABYMETAL #HIROSHIMA

@davidgreen449

Жыл бұрын

I think it’s only you and I that truly understand this The Professor for all of his views and thoughts doesn’t realise where Suzuka is from.

@jankafka7330

11 ай бұрын

@@davidgreen449 "The Professor for all of his views and thoughts doesn’t realise where Suzuka is from." He is so ignorant of the fact that he prominently mentioned it in the video.

@7cIII

10 ай бұрын

I am impressed that he was so close to the message just by guessing.

Masuji Ibuse's novel "Kuroi Ame" compares the ash fall of an atomic bomb to black rain. Su-metal is from Hiroshima and received peace education from an early age. The black umbrella in this video clearly represents the fear of nuclear weapons.

Thank you, AJ. Always enjoy your discussions of BM music. Cheers, man!

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for listening

Listened to BM for about 6K hours now. and I wasn't actually hyped at all about the new album. It'll be there when it is, and that's all. But. I almost accidentally clicked on this (no offence meant, AH; I'm a big fan) and within about 4 minutes I'm blubbing like a child. This is Babymetal, back and bold. I'm not sure if I'll even finish watching this vid, or just wait until the album comes out. But it is SO beautiful to know that they are still out there and there is still hope of further ONEness. I miss Yui with all my heart, and always will; she was certainly the cutest thing this world has ever seen. But at least we still have this legacy, and hopefully future.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Right? Great stuff.

Hadn’t noticed the similarity to Death, but yeah… so looking forward to the album. For me, the umbrellas remind me of pictures of D-Day parachutes.

Excellent commentary and analysis that has added to my internal picture and understanding of the song. On first listen I found myself simply in awe of the tonal quality of Su-'s vocals in the opening verse. I heard this somewhat in Divine Attack, but here there is an ease to her singing I have not heard from her before. Not the driving, cutting clarity of young belting Suzuka. This is not the "sing as loud as I want/can" of the Su-chan Flet's angel. Nor the intense-she has a death-glare-power of Su-metal. I have not heard this style of vocal in a top-tier artist since Karen Carpenter. (soprano vs contralto notwithstanding.) I have fallen in love with her voice all over again. Great song.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yes. The Carpenter connection is really interesting. I'd love to hear Su sing that kind of song sometime, with really simple instrumental support, so we hear that vocal clarity even more. Thanks for the comment.

Thank you for your reaction. I enjoy all your analysis of BABYMETAL and your love for them. This is a very emotional song for me and every replay makes the tears pool in my eyes. Su and Moa are masters of emotion projection and I don't think Koba could have chosen anyone better. There are many related interpretations to this song at many levels from obvious to subtle, past to present and public to personal. (And it hits me personally about my previous depression) I think this makes Monochrome a very, very beautiful and meaningful song of epic level. The intro always reminded me of something familiar but I could not place it until you mentioned for reminiscent of BABYMETAL Death. That hits it perfectly!! Thank you again! 🤘🦊🤘

@htusda1

Жыл бұрын

> I could not place it until you mentioned for reminiscent of BABYMETAL Death => Yes, same with me. Only AJ could come up with his many inferences from so many angles!

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thank's both. Much appreciated :)

You make me cry.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

I hope that's a good thing ;)

Yeahh!! 🤘🦊🤘 Beautiful reaction man.. thank you🖤

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks!

Always delivering such a profound analysis of each BM song…amazing

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks!

Sugoi 🤘😎🤙

That was sooo... good! Thank you. This grittiness initially upset me. But under this carpet you feel - without effort - the positivity of this song. 🤘 🎸 🤘

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thank you!

I have nothing more to say. Great thanks AJ-san.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Glad you liked it! Thanks.

The previous BABYMETAL was something to watch in a way. The new BABYMETAL is a full-fledged METAL band when you listen to them, but when you watch them, I'm waiting for next year's concert in anticipation of an experience that will establish them as BABYMETAL 😁. Think! And feel! That is the one and only new BABYMETAL😊.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

I hope we get to see this live.

Had been looking at quite a few reactions to "Monochrome" after hearing it on a reaction channel, when I came across yours. Would like to express my appreciation for the analytical and emotional content - the combination of the two is so interesting, inspiring and, above all, informative. I've probably been someone who arrives at connections with songs typically via their emotional impact, but your analysis has vastly added to my appreciation of the thematic content of this song. I first heard of Babymetal around 2014, and hoovered up everything I could pretty much straight up, as I found them a fascinating 'concoction': viscerally interesting and musically fascinating, but also a little challenging, as they were vastly different from any music blend I'd previously experienced, and I had a niggling concern about it being a performative marketing exercise in combination with a vague feeling of exploitation in a 'work for hire' sense. But as time, and their careers, progressed I felt less concerned about that aspect, as their longevity stretched and the girl's own personalities found their way to the surface. I feel their progression and maturation as performers has been interestingly notable: it has changed the nature of their music in an evolving way, and has enhanced their credentials greatly. The first substantial step in this evolution was ,for me, the song "Karate", and now "Monochrome" is to me another quantum leap for the group. Their best song ever? - feels like it to me, until the next leap arrives, if the future allows it. Anyway, thanks for the reaction - look forward to more new content, and working my way through your back catalogue. Cheers.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for this thoughtful and supportive response. In truth, I'm always conflicted as to whether to keep making these videos and it can sometimes feel like I'm just talking to myself, but responses like your keep me going. Thanks for taking the time to comment. I hope you find some of my older material interesting. Cheers.

I love all the speculation on the meaning of this song, in other words yet another great Babymetal song. I have given it plenty of thought, and there are good arguments for most theories. I think that is maybe because the song fits a lot of different things, for example as an exercise I considered if this song was about depression and mental health issues and sure enough the lyrics and symbolism fit perfectly as well as the overall message of persisting and fighting to a better future, so perhaps the song is just that, the same message as in so many other Babymetal songs.

@jakemuller8626

Жыл бұрын

Exactly, like KobaMetal tweeted recently: "Never ending story ☔☀️🌈"

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, as I said to someone else, part of what they do well is build generality out of specifics so that the audience is invited to apply their own sense of meaning.

As always, professor, thanks a lot for sharing your insights and in this case also emotions. My own interpretation is on a far more personal level. Dieing dreams , old age, crumbling relationships, but if you find a significant other you can dream with, than the colour can come back. But then, I got to know Monochrome via The First Take long before I really watched the visuals, and I understand now where this "nuclear" interpretation comes from. I am also aware that my take on the song might say more about me than about the song. Again, thank you for your time.

Pure Bliss

Always great to see these breaksdowns, AJ. You always find details and connections that the rest of us miss. My two bits is that they are drawing a parallel between the destruction and rebirth of Hiroshima, and Ragnarok in which there is also rebirth after the destruction of the main gods. I think that the underlying theme is rebirth or creation out of destruction that pain and grief have to be suffered through to find hope on the other side.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Makes sense to me. Thanks!

Such an amazing reaction and talk through of your feelings Andrew. Its great to see that Su's voice can still affect people like she does to me...haunting, melodic, hopeful and simply beautiful. The first 2 tracks from the new album have been so good and it fills me with joy to think we are so close to more BabyMetal songs. I had read that there was talk of this track being around Hiroshima, but your explanation makes a lot of sense. Thank you again for the reaction. Stay safe. Ray

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks! Glad it made sense for you.

Powerful, emotive, thought provoking, with a myriad of possible interpretations yes classic Babymetal The opening vocals pure tinged with a sadness, almost a lament for something lost, the umbrellas are interesting 🤔 l thought of Matsuji Ibuse's novel Black rain. Which l read as a teenager, and at that age it was all too vivid but l don't feel it's ment as any direct reference to Hiroshima as such, but a more general comment on nuclear warfare. The Norse mythology is a nice touch and give the whole thing as you say a very Tolkienish feel, especially the emphasis on the tree or nature. As you say the Bokura where the music drops out is especially emphasized. We're all in this together and perhaps it's only when we collectively make a change that beauty or colour to the world can return. I also get a sense of their being beauty even in a monochrome world, that in such times beauty can still be found. So their is also a ring of hope though out the whole track. Each individual can draw varying pictures so brilliantly done.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yes, I haven't read the novel but from what I've heard it sounds like it could be one of the influences on the song. Thanks for the comment.

I also agree with you.

another amazing job! Please, never stop doing these :)

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Glad you like them!

There's a post on the BABYMETAL subreddit with a lot of info

I have probably listened to Monochrome 200 times since it came out last week. As much as I love Babymetal... as much as I listen to Babymetal... there has never been a Babymetal song that has completely grabbed me like this one. Is is the best Babymetal song ever? I think the mere fact that I can't dismiss that possibility shows how strong a song it is. I think there are some Babymetal fans who are looking for the "craziness" that was the old Babymetal without recognizing the "craziness" that is the new Babymetal. I keep thinking in my head... if this is a Pop song... why is there a 45 second instrumental to begin the track. If this is Metal, why isn't there a guitar solo in the middle. There are three verses... and each one has a different musical bed. There are three choruses that are all subtly different. There are strategic places where they drop the music so that only the voices can be heard. Moa is so important with the backing Woo-Oh-Oh's that bring a lightness to the song which is so heavy in meaning. And... only at the end does Su join her. They have found a way to meld everything so it doesn't sound completely foreign anymore... yet it is. I find that absolutely fascinating. I could talk just about the structure of the song for paragraphs and paragraphs (and I might at some point). It is a stunning piece of art. And, in terms of Babymetal's future... I see this being just as important of a song as Megitsune (which took them out of Sakura Gakuin and into their own). I came into Babymetal relatively late and maybe because I came in with Distortion, I don't have the same mental baggage of being there from the beginning. Or, maybe it's just that I don't want any band that I like to not continue to evolve. Evolution is what we should all be striving for (in my opinion). And, Monochrome is exactly the type of song I hoped they would make. I'm glad they did.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Right there with you. I hesitated to say just how strong I thought the song was in relation to the rest of their catalog on a single listen, but the more I listen to it, the more I think it's a serious contender for best song, which is amazing of itself. Thanks for the comment!

@matasuki

Жыл бұрын

I'm right there with you. This might be their best song ever.

@matasuki

Жыл бұрын

My evolution was seeing them waaaaaaaayyyy back when they were a unique idol group on I think it Kimmel late night show in America. Back then they weren't much of a metal group, more of a gimmick. Then they added Kami Band and doing tours like a proper band. And their music started to actually become less pop and more metal and substantial. I came back to them a few years ago so I totally get it. You've found them at a great time.

LMAOO the clickbaity thumbnail hahaha. I don't know who is editing your videos, but for sure is doing an incredible job. Extremely entertaining to watch on top of being informative!

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

I'll pass that along, thanks! My editor is Ru-Metal.

Loved this thoughtful reaction - there's been way too much kneejerk "this is too poppy and slow" and people getting bent out of shape that we aren't just getting Doki Doki Morning or Gimmie Chocolate all over again in a lot of the reactions I've seen.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, I think this a far more mature song. I love those early songs, of course, but I think we're beyond that era now, and that's not a bad thing. Bands have to evolve,

Love your reaction and this is my favorite babymetal song for sure.. Amaaaazing

Was waiting for your reaction. And not disappointed at all. Also liked the fact that you immersed yourself into the music first, rather than dissecting. Sometimes, it's good to do what Su said - don't think, just feel.

Thank you professor for your wonderful response. The surviving tree that is said to symbolize the atomic bombing of Hiroshima is the "Aogiri". "Aogiri" means Chinese parasol tree in English. Umbrellas imply many things.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for that. I remembered the Hiroshima tress after I made the recording but didn't know the name or its umbrella meaning. That's really helpful. Thank you.

Let it out, let it all out

I'm glad somebody else "gets it". Your response mirrored my own upon my first watching. Thank you! The intent from the band was a "concept album" where Babymetal visits different worlds, in this case, a dying Sun on a planet with the promise of rebirth. There are other concepts that you've mentioned of course as well, which makes all this work accessible to everyone like true art.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Cheers. Always good to know other folks are on the same wave length.

🖤🖤🖤

I love to see that I'm not the only one picking out connections to previous BabyMetal songs in this: BabyMetal Death and Road of Resistance as you mentioned, of course. I also hear beats that remind me of From Dusk To Dawn (verse), The One (chorus), Catch Me If You Can (intro), Kagerou (the alt-rock base) and especially Karate (the overall composition), among others. I wonder if you've seen that too, and whether that might show a potential shift from taking genres and styles of other metal bands as they did for their first 3 albums and changing that to take their own stuff and start mashing them together to create their own unique sound that pushes through another boundary, and what that might mean for them moving forward. From my perspective, that is exciting. I really want to see where that could take them.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yes, that final vocal melody is very One-ish. And yes, that would be an interesting concept approach. Thanks!

Such thoughtful commentary and reaction is much appreciated. Babymetal is deep and multilayered..so many levels!. This is one reason i have been drawn to them since day one. So thank you professor. You have a new subscriber. 🦊🦊🦊🤟

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Appreciate that, Michael. Cheers!

"When you hear Su-metal sing..." Yep 😭

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Right? :)

私はあなたに救われました。 BABYMETALのファンを続けることができます。

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

それは面白いですね :) あなたがまだBABYMETALのファンでいてくれることを嬉しく思います。

Regarding "Hotaru no Haka" ("Grave of the Fireflies"): This is the most devastating piece of cinematography I've ever seen! If you remotely have this thing called empathy it completely destroys you. I have watched this movie twice in the past (with around ten years between the sightings) and I swear I will never ever watch it again! I have to admit that I got a little bit (maybe more) traumatized by it. This said: Everyone should watch this movie once in their lifetime!

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Agreed.

This is the one Nice review Kagerou/brand new day vibe

I have heard that Su-Metal has written the song Divine attack. Su-Metal is actually from Hiroshima, so I think she actually also wrote this song. I think you are right this song is about the bombing.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, I haven't seen her name attached to credits for this one, though it was for Shingeki. Maybe we'll find out later. Thanks!

Watching your Reaction to the New BM in this Track. and listening to your view of the imagery, and my mind went straight to Hiroshima. an average citizen is going threw their daily routine and Bang. Monochrome. desolation, disaster. but by the end. the Color returns. Albeit a raged vision of how the day started, but the Color is back. Hope survived. and will prevail.

Wonderful analysis! To me this song is very hopeful and energising, i love that you pointed to that inspiring, ensuring last chorus that's like a call-to-action: WE WILL illuminate this monochrome world with colourful light. There is a progression, a narrative, in the (last lines of) the choruses: First one 'What colour can we imagine the night sky?' comes from a place of uncertainty, what can we do against this darkness? The second one, 'we will imagine the night sky in rainbow colours': we found an inner spark of hope, we can already envision a brighter future. Then the last one, accentuated by the music dropping during the 'bokura wa': 'we will illuminate the word in rainbow colours' is turning that inner spark outwards, actively changing the world together. The power of imagination!

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Good points. Thanks for the comment.

Both the two new songs there is something different in the way they have layered Su's vocals. Previously they always seemed to be fighting over the music. Here she is clearly standing on top and above. Clear, strong, powerful AND mature (the girlish tones now gone). This is a woman at the very top of her vocal skills.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Agreed. Thanks!

The copium on that "Please" at 4:22 haha I was waiting for this reaction. Thanks!

@Slytherkins

Жыл бұрын

I've been wondering since they announced the album title if it means they are going to officially name a third member. Crossing my fingers.

@pspatino

Жыл бұрын

@@Slytherkins at this point, i kinda doubt there will be a permanent 3rd. They may bring back, but i think koba will be set on the duo format plus "unnamed" 3rd

この曲大好きなので、リアクション動画出してくれて嬉しいです😊

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

ありがとうございます！気に入っていただけてうれしいです。

We have been waiting for you. Thank you for your always implied reviews. I believe that Babymetal was forced to change course markedly by the plague and war immediately after the release of their third album. I guess that's why it's The Other One, and I'm sorry to think that they had a true fourth album on their hands. I'm sure there were many bright and fun songs on that album. But I also think this reaction is what rock music is all about. It is really sad and painful. The many falling umbrellas look like the incendiary rain from "Grave of the Fireflies," and when Ragnarok is brought up, the subject seems to be universalized to include the bombing of Dresden. So, for me, the fact that Su is a third generation A-bomb survivor overlaps with Kurt Vonnegut, Jr, whom I respect. But I don't think Su intends to show it off too much. More than that, this song sounded like they were worried about the Russian fans who came to the Moscow concert three years ago. BABYMETAL values their fans more than anything else.

@kitkat6407

Жыл бұрын

That's right！

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Interesting. Yes, I think part of what they are so good at is expanding beyond specific references so that listeners can find their own points of resonance.

@tanamach

Жыл бұрын

Thank you so much

@davidmakinster8521

Жыл бұрын

I also thought of Grave of the Fireflies, when the silhouette of the girl and umbrella amid a rain of sparks appeared. I was just about to ask, "Is it just me, or..." when I saw your comment. How appropriate that Suzuka was born and raised in Hiroshima.

@tanamach

Жыл бұрын

@@davidmakinster8521 Grave of the Fireflies" takes place in Kobe, right? It is now a fashionable city one rank above Osaka. The Great Tokyo Air Raid, for example, rained incendiary bombs comparable to the bombing of Dresden, but the tragedy is not so much used for peace movements or politically. The Japanese people can't say too strongly about it, partly because they were encouraged by the mass media before the war, but also because they had played a leading role in instigating the military to go to war since the time of the Sino-Japanese War. That is why Godzilla, exposed to the hydrogen bomb, attacked Japan, not the United States. None of the Japanese are asking Godzilla to attack the U.S., which tested the H-bomb. My mother came back to Tokyo from Manchuria, which was a colony, and found that her house had been burned down and everything was gone. It's a complicated story. I'm not sure if this song is part of the album concept, but I'm still trying to figure out the meaning of the archangel in Divine Attack. Can't wait to hear the whole album.

"The longing, the yearning, for something better." Happy to see I wasn't the only one who was emotionally affected by this song. As always, GREAT analysis and first reaction. Edited: One additional note about the color pallette, I think the monochrome palette is supposed to represent soot and ash aftermath. That's indicative of the sudden splash of color on the tree of hope for a better tomorrow.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for the support and comment!

Amazing reaction/discussion... again. Thanks! Just wanted to point out that the flower looks quite a lot like a Nelumbo nucifera, best known as lotus flower. It is a sacred flower in Hinduism and Buddhism, where represents the path to spiritual awakening and enlightenment. Although I still prefer "Divine Attach" musically, "Monochrome" got me from the lyrics perspective. And that's amazing! Until next time!

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks!

Yeah I got similar conclusions and images myself, even the Grave of the Fireflies feeling, but I think I never mentioned it because thinking about that movie brings me back PTSD xD I had never thought on the umbrellas as an image of protection, to me those clips with them falling are a metaphore of the area bombings. There is a short image at the first part of the video with a set of lines grow like a mushroom cloud, but if you look slowly it's really making the form of the metal bars in an umbrella. I think it is making a relationship between the two things. But then it does not fit very well with the girl wearing it for protecting her from the rain later. Other stuff that I noticed in the video... -The relation between the firework and the fire flower, that for someone who does not have a notion of japanese might not make the relation on the play on words. The hanabi made a symbol of destruction but also of rebirth. -The stylistic choice, that reminds of a 40s video, with a lot grain and black and white color. I think it is made with the whole intent of bringing you to that era of conflict. -How it revisits common themes in the BABYMETAL history. How it is playing with the light and the rainbow as a spectre of the light being the same. We travel from the dusk til the dawn through the long night, never stranding from our road of resistance. We see the rainbow spectrum coming after the rain, reaching a brand new day. -If we check the distortion music video we see fight against giants in this destroyed city landscape, it might be also reminiscent of the ragnarok. -I am not sure of what happens in the end. I think the girl approaches the tree, the fire blossom then grows inside her, and she rises as a new sun, who then makes the stars (The One?) bright stronger and together they bring back the light. I am not sure if it is exactly what is happening at the end, but maybe. Su sacrificing her life to become the sun and bring light to the world through her singing is another very recurrent theme in the BABYMETAL legendarium. What happens here at the end, if it is what I think it is, it is very well explained in the two kamishibais that played before BABYMETAL DEATH and THE ONE at Legend S. --- I also never expected them to go this way. I thought the big Amuse suit guys would make them go for a more mainstream approach, a product for this people that collect Moa gifs like if she was one more of the girls in KPop bands. But they have gone to the total opposite and made a product with big depthness and emotion, made for a weird person like me. For that I am very grateful. And Su, how good she is. That part before the first chorus when the first firework rises to the sky rips your chest.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Good points. Thanks!

I hope one day I will hear this anti-war song on stage in Ukraine. I was impressed by the singing ability of Su-metal Charm without tricks😢 arigatou🙋

I love this song and the video really adds something to it. I love the parts on both new songs when Su sings softly. Was interesting to hear your thoughts on the umbrellas because that was the main thing that I couldn't up with much of an explanation for when trying to understand what was going on. Regarding the part with the flower. I've seen some people saying they think it might be a lotus and the explanation for that makes sense but my own idea is that it's an Oleander. Oleander is the official flower of the city of Hiroshima, having been the first to bloom following the atomic bombing of the city in 1945. I could be wrong but it fits with the theme and in my opinion it matches the appearance of the flower in the video more closely than a Lotus. I hope the backing vocal for this song is sung live at the concerts and they don't decide to use a backing track for it. I suppose it depends on how intensely Moa is having to dance during and also if a similar sounding can be done live and outside of the studio.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks. And yes, would love to see/hear this live,

The tree - Hibakujumoku (Japanese: 被爆樹木; also called survivor tree or A-bombed tree in English) is a Japanese term for a tree that survived the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1945

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yes. One Japanese fan said he doesn't see that tree in this image because it has a particular and distinctive shape, but I defer to those who know better on this.

Thank you sir. We saw babymetal live in kuala Lumpur and the song was just epic

@AndrewHartley

11 ай бұрын

Awesome. I look forward to seeing it in Atlanta.

Great video as always. Thanks. This song may be the most extreme contrast of heavy (music) and light (vocals) in any BM song yet. And, yes, Suzuka's singing has no irony or sneer, and I would add no kitsch either. She uses very little vibrato and few slides or runs. No unearned sentiment, just tone, amplitude and real emotion.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Couldn't agree more. Thanks!

I've known babymetal from the beginning, but never really listened to them. The occasional video on youtube two or three times a year but that's it. Then I heard the first take version of monochrome and I was blown away. I've listened to the piano version so many times I lost count. Now I am hearing the full orchestral version the first time. I'm sure I'm going to love it.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Hope you like it!

What is an atomic bomb if not a monochrome firework and what is a nuclear attack if not Ragnarök? Also: the survivors used umbrellas to shield themselves from fallout and there were some trees that survived which became kind of mythical in a very real way. Beautiful song. I'm very excited for the direction of this album.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Agreed.

Ah, I was waiting for your analysis of this song - great as always and as close to a "normal" reaction video as we'll ever get I suppose. ;-) I really like "Monochrome" and it has to be one of the best and most intricate lyric videos ever done (at least of those I've seen). It seems to me that the album will be a lot darker and more cohesive than their earlier stuff. Which on the one hand is great and will make for an awesome album which may get more people interested in BABYMETAL who may disgarded them as gimmicky before. But on the other hand it may make them more like a conventional metal/rock band which would be a bit sad (for me). What drew me in to the BM world was the original juxtaposition of the cute and the dark/heavy and the playfulness and musical ecclecticism, etc. So when they get rid of the kawaii and fun part I may have a harder time to be as fascinated as I was before. The Metal Galaxy album wasn't really my cup of tea and I was afraid that they would go on in that direction - but it seems that The Other One will be an unusual album for BM. Not as "weird" and crazy as before. Btw there are japanese bands who perfectly manage to combine kawaii with seriousness and maturity (and the band members being in their 20's or even 30's) so it's not mandatory to drop this part of their style just because Su & Moa are in their mid 20's now. But it seems that's what they are going for, at least with TOO. But that being said, I'm still very happy that the first two songs turned out to be very very good which gives me hopes that the album will be some kind of a banger. 🙂 "Monochrome" isn't a song that I will listen to on repeat but it will fit perfectly on the album and I will enjoy it in that flow, I can feel that.

@CHRISCONTEPSS

Жыл бұрын

I see your point. I have had similar thoughts. . . .As you said there may be other bands still trying to follow old formulas into adulthood and that is fine if it works for them. However when I think about it from Koba, Su and Moa's perspectives, I realized. . . Yah, but they ARE NOT other bands. *Side note: Metal Galaxy not Kawai and fun enough for you?? BMC (Su gang signs and tiny Japanese bad asses), Oh Maginai (folk dancing like life depends on it :) . . Night Night Burn (Tiko Tiko Ting), and Pa Pa Ya! OK. Its your opinion and fine, but PPY it is a metal song about summer and FRUIT SALAD . . lol. . .. So I guess I respectfully disagree they had lost much of that part of their charm on that record. .or perhaps I misunderstood you. I will admit it took more listens than their early stuff .but I like that it felt same but different. . . just my opinion. I am the guy that orders something different every time I go to the same restaurant.🤘🦊🤘 Imagine being Suzuka in your mid to late 20's and constantly traveling around the world still singing Doki Doki morning and Gimmie Chocolate every night as the core of your work. Fine for others but there is no way these intelligent, lovely and worldly young women would want to continue to do that when they have always led the path others are following. They seem very self aware and know how awkward and potentially sad that could get. They must continue to evolve and continue to forge their own road as they move forward (regardless of the "weather" or not everybody likes it). I think I read that kinda thing in some translated song lyrics once or twice. . lol Kitsunes up! 🤘🦊🤘

@hedobannord1184

Жыл бұрын

@@CHRISCONTEPSS Yeah DDM and GC are definitely songs that won't work when you're an adult. 🙂 But the sound of songs like Headbanger and Megitsune would still be okay (if you change the lyrics/aesthetics a bit) nowadays. Pa Pa Ya was one of the few songs on MG that worked for me. NNB is not my thing, although it's kinda funny, for sure. Same for Oh Majinai (which I can't stand at all tbh). I think what's missing is Yui - not just her as a person but generally speaking a third band member so they can vocally bounce of each other as on the first 2 albums. This kind of back and forth is one of the (many) elements that made BM's music special for me. Nevertheless I'm looking forward to the new album and expect that it will be more to my liking than MG. 🙂 EDIT: Just to be clear: there are a couple of songs on MG that I like (PPY, BMC, SSS, Distortion, Kagerou, Shine and Arkadia).

@CHRISCONTEPSS

Жыл бұрын

Yup. Yui's departure sure did change things. My biggest gripe is masking the Kami's. . . I guess I was moreso worried they would not be able to create more of what they were doing and do it any better than they already have. . . So I am open and greatful for a new direction. . . And for sure I can't imagine they would not do Megitsune or idz. . . Etc Those can be timeless👍gotta run to work Nice chatting with you 😁 kitsunes up!

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for the conversation, all. I'll leave you to it :)

The beginning Guitars remind me of Early Rise

Yes they're back, and so are you! Thanks to your video it's helped me better appreciate Monochrome for its worth as I'd initially thought it would be one of the rare occasions of a BM song where I didn't quite get it the first few times but would eventually grow to love eventually. So... will you be attending Makuhari Messe? 😊

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks! But no, alas, I can't get to Japan till summer so seeing them next year seems unlikely, but we'll see...

Bokurawa will now replace Imananji as my go-to Babymetal chant! Well outside of Nametara Ikanzeyo )))

@htusda1

Жыл бұрын

Intersting point. I am split on the entire audience shouting "Bokuraha" since I really feel the passion in Su's voice that I would not want to have it drowned out. Maybe the audience singing along with "Oh-oh-oh" as someone suggested would be better. When they performed Megitsune in front of a "ONLY GIRLS ALLOWED CONCERT", shouts of "SORE" totally drowned out BM, which was hilarious.

Great reaction and review Professor. In my opinion this song convey sadness and hope beautifully just like in NRNR. And good call for umbrella and Grave of the Fireflies there. IIRC Fireflies and Totoro was released as double feature in Japan. ✌️

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks!

Thanks for the emotional and thoughtful reaction. I confess I took a while to appreciate this one. The production on the two singles so far has confused me: I am so used to being able to hear hints - even in studio tracks - of what a live performance might sound like. With these new songs I've not really been able to get that feeling beyond a vague sense that live is, indeed, the context in which they will really shine. I also see the iris and pupil of an eye in that ambiguous form in the sky that seems to be tree, umbrella, nuke mushroom and flower simultaneously. The drop where just Su's voice remains is devastating. I'd also like to see/hear a third performer but so long as we manage to keep Su and Moa I'll be happy. I'd also like to see more visibility and open acknowledgement for the Kami Band. I don't know any fan who doesn't have a wish list for the return.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Interesting points. Thanks. And yes, I'd love to hear this live.

Do you see a mushroom cloud in the silhouette of the girl with the umbrella at the end of song?

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

I looked for a mushroom cloud specifically, but didn't spot it. Will look again.

@daguitarman808

Жыл бұрын

@@AndrewHartley it's at 3:30 on the vid....the outline of the girl with umbrella looks like a mushroom cloud to me 🤘😎🤙

Monochrome was the word observers used to describe the color (or lack of) during the first A- bomb test. Suzuka Nakamoto's message isn't subtle, it's the Japanese way. Su chan' s generation doesn't want nuclear weapons used on populated cities ever again. They are right! And as a Westerner, I am on Su-metal's side. Her internal beauty shouldn't make anyone uncomfortable. Having a connection with her on something this important to her shouldn't be missed.

@rakuonmusic

Жыл бұрын

Thank you for the comment. Not everybody knows the atomic bomb was a "Monochrome" blast that exploded at 600 m above Hiroshima. Together with the through interpretation described by Andrew, may I also say that the reference to war and bombing in general might be extended to other air raids on Japanese cities during WW II. The visuals reminded me of what happended to Tokyo, "3 napalms per square metre" falling like rain on the people living there...

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for that clarification, Much appreciated.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yes, Grave of the Fireflies is about the fire bombing of Kobe, if I remember rightly. The overall meaning expands from the inspirational specifics.

@ozsctgeo2679

Жыл бұрын

@@rakuonmusic When I first saw the umbrella I was thinking of the atomic bomb floating down with a parachute. Using the parachute slowed the descent which allowed more time for the bomber to clear the area before the blast, and for the delicate trigger mechanism to activate at at the correct height. In this age of nuclear missiles and bombers directly dropping bombs on targets, most people don't know that the atomic bombs used parachutes over Hiroshima and Nagasaki. When I was a kid in the 1960s I read quite a few account from survivors watching the parachute floating towards the ground and wondering what it was about. Some of these were quite poetic and created an emotional experience, since for many inhabitants it was the last thing they ever saw.

@timrose3960

Жыл бұрын

@@ozsctgeo2679 yes some people are trying to say the song has many meanings but in my mind it is crystal clear. I know Su chan was disappointed that Tokyo (now where she lives) doesn't mention the anniversary in the local news or call for a moment of silence. I understand there may (don't know) be some collective shame in what happened to those two cities but it hurts me to think about what it must be like to hide one's true feelings about such personal tragic events. It reminds me of Megitsune. The National "I'm okay" mask isn't necessary anymore because this isn't the 50s. I'm looking forward to Babymetal inspiring us all to rethink our stone age mentality. I've got thick skin so I can take it! :)

Another level of meaning rooted in the personal. Su is from Hiroshima and had survivor grandparents. Growing up before moving to Tokyo she would know the stories of neighbours and the memorials, including the main survivor tree in the centre. I read that there were 190 trees in the Greater Hiroshima area; now reduced to 170. Unlike on Divine Attack Su is not credited as a lyricist on this one

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Thanks!

@keithsowerby8179

Жыл бұрын

@@AndrewHartley I impetuously mentioned all of that before you covered it yourself. I realised the connection about half way through my first watch of the video. What I still don’t understand is how they are going to connect the different worlds represented in each song

personally I think the song/video had more to do with the destruction of the environment then war, which can be seen with image of the world then outer shield disappears, showing the depletion of the Ozone, also the rain (as acid rain), the umbrella (for me) is the band aid solutions people come up with, no one wants to address the real problems cause well money and greed, which can also apply to the title itself Monochrome (single color) or my interpretation single mindset

@allegorical

Жыл бұрын

The rain is the fallout after a nuclear strike that comes in the form of black rain. The umbrella is classic symbolism for it as it was used to give some protection from the poison as it fell in Japan. You can hear that hard hitting instrumental 'explosion' when the first drop of water hits the puddle and followed by smoke rising off the splashes.

@htusda1

Жыл бұрын

Please check 1:05 of the original video. The shape of the cloud and the distorted sound of the base drum sends a strong message.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, I think both meanings are related and in play, but there's enough nuance and generality in the way the lyrics work that audiences are invited to hear their own related meanings.

@jeffwotherspoon3867

Жыл бұрын

@@AndrewHartley exactly everyone interrupts it in their own way, the message is never the same for all people

as a soon to be concept album, I wonder what are your thoughts about the correlation to singeki (which I heard they've changed it from cavalry) here I am wanting to dig deeper thanks to you professor 😜

@allegorical

Жыл бұрын

Each song is to represent an alternate world. We may see a larger pattern when the entire album is released.

@AndriMutit

Жыл бұрын

@@allegorical I don't know about that alternate world things, I just follow what professor said at shingek reviewi that related to the word kamikaze so maybe its just straight obvious historical representation themed

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, I think I'll have to wait and hear more to see precisely how the concept album idea works (if it does). Right now, I'm just focusing (happily) on the individual songs :)

One reading of this song I like is it's a "goodbye" to Yui. A fond and tender one, at that.

Another reactor immediately recognized the flower blooming as a Lotus which makes sense .The Lotus has significance in both Japanese and Buddhist culture associated with purity, transformation, renewal and enlightenment.

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yes!

@paulos9900

Жыл бұрын

This makes sense but I came to the conclusion that it was an Oleander. Oleander is the official flower of the city of Hiroshima, having been the first to bloom following the atomic bombing of the city in 1945. After looking at pictures of both flower types I still think it is more reminiscent of an Oleander.

Thanks for the reaction. There are a few things that stood out to me. First was the drop after the introduction, to a very minimalist instrumentation, as if Su is saying :you need to pay attention'. And then Su's phrasing in the verse, clipping each word, and thd the breathiness and space between the words, I don't think I've heard Su do that before. Such sadness. The use of silence in this song for emotional impact is amazing. I personally think Su sounds much more mature, she is making more mauture and nuanced choices in her singing. Like the English lines, where she clips the preopositions; her English is better than that, and Su has better English than that, and her diction in songs is impeccable. So to have poor diction is a choice, like the phrasing in the first verse, is coming from a more mature singer. I think the child like quality is because we are used to her singing in her chest voice or belting, here she is in a more pop mix. Also for the opening guitars which reminded you of Babymetal Death; the lick in Babymetal Death always sounded to me like a lick in Jesus Christ around the Herod scene,

@AndrewHartley

Жыл бұрын

Yes, the silence is huge. I like your take on Su's voice too.. Thanks!

The verses have a nursery rhyme feel to them at points. Or is that just me?